JYP is strict because he wants them to be great. Yeji didn't cry because he yelled at her, she cried because she was disappointed in herself. She also wants to improve. She said it with her own mouth so don't assume otherwise.

@MrFakNo

11 ай бұрын

No, they are crying because how bad the song is, and they have to keep carrying on because of that.

@saraxx948

11 ай бұрын

@@MrFakNo read the last sentence of the comment again

@Music-vr7sz

11 ай бұрын

@@MrFakNo weird since the song is amazing. grow up.

@MrFakNo

11 ай бұрын

@@Music-vr7sz Not one JYP song has been amazing. FACT.

@Thispotatolikekpop

11 ай бұрын

​@@MrFakNothat's your opinion

Now I guess I understand what seungmin meant when he said he had traumatic memorise from the vocal recording room

@aeqsage

11 ай бұрын

Link of video where he said that?

@johnvaque9464

11 ай бұрын

@@aeqsage fr

I don’t get why people are getting so worked up about this. He’s literally a producer. It’s his job to get the best possible version for a song that’s going to be there forever. He’s not even being that strict here, it could be so much worse. He is known for being a perfectionist in the studio when it comes to the songs he writes and producers, but look at how accomplished his catalogue is.

@retricallltann6243

11 ай бұрын

It’s because of his people have a burning hatred for jyp even when he no longer leads the entire company since years ago alr all these people see is it’s jyp he doesn’t care abt the girl feeling

@Arcessitor

11 ай бұрын

@@nk2012 Have you ever met a producer, or had a boss of any kind? He's super-polite in what he's saying, and they're also not animatronics, there's no reason not to be emotive when saying it.

I think this is more of a grey area. He has a sound that he wants. And he needs them to do it. He doesn't want (for his sake and their sake) to release a track that is weak. He wants them to shine. But also there's plenty of reasons why Yeji might have been crying. She might have been disappointed in her ability, or she could have been frustrated. Haven't you ever done something, and not done it perfect and gotten so frustrated that you wanted to cry? Not because of someone yelling at you, but because of not being able to do it how you want it done? But also on JYP, he should realize that he won't get the desired result just by hammering at it over and over again. If after a while they don't get it, go take a break, eat something, let it sit. And then try again once you're less frustrated.

@Arst38

11 ай бұрын

It's not that he's being hard on them really. He's doing his job and they're doing their job. It's his role as a PD to get the sound right and their job to give him the sound he's asking for. It's not an easy job. It's not just have a good voice and go up there and read some lines. There's delivery, emphasis, pronunciation...a lot goes into it and it takes work and effort and emotions happen.

@Bunnybunny5656

11 ай бұрын

This is his job. I’m sure with all his years he knows how to do it better then you. There’s a reason all his groups are so successful

@Arst38

11 ай бұрын

@@Bunnybunny5656 he most definitely does. I never claimed to know his job better than him? Chill

@aceldeath1871

11 ай бұрын

highly agree with you

@krom5720

11 ай бұрын

Agree. I see lack of ability to deliver what he wants from them.

A boss enforcing a certain quality from his employees, what a monster! /s What did you people expect from their recordings? A happy encounter with everyone laughing and agreeing 100% with eachother? Wake up, this is a business with a hell lot of competition. Idols are professional artists and this kind of pressure is part of their job. JYP is the boss and he MUST be strict because he knows how good they are and he is not gonna release a studio version if the final product is not the best.

@coconut_roll5200

11 ай бұрын

Those were my thoughts too. Although we don't see the whole process, I assume they did cut out certain parts, but even with that in mind, there were no yelling, no cussing, nothing. Yes, he is strict, but he needs to be strict to bring out the best in them. Even with Yeji or Lia not meeting his expectations, he didn't flip out - sure, he was disappointed, but not agressive! When he went inside the recording room, I didn't hear any bad intention in that "Yeji-ah". Sure, he is strict, but he NEEDS to be strict, and tbh I expected far worse from the head of one of the biggest kpop companies.

@cxli318

11 ай бұрын

Agreed

@jessica33313

11 ай бұрын

You can tell they are also strict on themselves they don’t need a boss breathing down their necks like this. They clearly needed a breather. I wanted to cry with them!

@buddies6389

11 ай бұрын

@@jessica33313itzy should just disband then if they can’t handle criticism

@baekchikenhyun

11 ай бұрын

true but if the girls were struggling that much to bring out the best of their vocals, he could have given them a break or give them some water to drink

Watching ‘Bet On Me’s documentary really had me in tears, witnessing how hard ITZY worked and poured their hearts into this comeback. Their dedication and relentless efforts make me incredibly proud of them. I’m really in this itzy shit forever. ITZY, I’ll always be with you. 🖤

he wasn’t even mean this is just what a coach does lol yeji is probably crying out of frustration for not getting it yet, not sadness

@user-xp5yf4xv8g

11 ай бұрын

Exactly I would cry out of frustration to

What a striking difference between this and watching Chan and Changbin's vocal direction when Stray Kids are recording. They praise highly and seem so proud when someone does well, and gently direct the Kids when they aren't sounding quite how Chan or Changbin envisioned. Their remarks are specific and helpful. They always look like they're a team.

@seiji909

11 ай бұрын

That's because JYP was never involved with Stray Kids that much. Stray Kids are their own thing, they do basically everything when it comes to their career. Itzy does not. JYP is their boss, he's there to help them improve. He's strict because he wants to become even better.

@j3t617

11 ай бұрын

@@seiji909YP is still technically their boss as the CCO, but yeah I get what you mean

@seiji909

11 ай бұрын

@@j3t617 Yeah, I meant Stray Kids are their own bosses basically

@j3t617

11 ай бұрын

@@seiji909 that’s not how it works though… they’re self produced but they still are employees of the company. The only group that are their own bosses are 2PM cause they have Director status

@seiji909

11 ай бұрын

@@j3t617 I think you missed my point. " Stray Kids are their own thing, they do basically everything when it comes to their career." JYP is obviously their boss, they're under his company, but he's barely associated with them. Stray Kids make their own music, everything is by 3RACHA or other members. They choreographed plenty of songs too. The only things JYP really does for them is give them a place to work + their contract, but besides that, he really doesn't have that many things relating to them...

ITZY didn't have good vocal techniques and JYP helped them raise their ability in singing. You guys are overwhelmed to criticize him. JYP is a producer, and Bet on Me is his song. He’s right to require them to complete his product in a perfect way. If you watch the video again, you will see that Lia and Yeji had bad techniques in singing.

@retricallltann6243

11 ай бұрын

And the video said the recording was delayed as well meaning they were on a tight schedule alr people like to forget that the industry in general is alr harsh and a producer being very strict is nothing new and just because it’s jyp doesn’t mean we have to bash him for doing his job as a producer and wanting the best for his grp

@ilikebeingsmart

10 ай бұрын

Isn’t that partially on JYP Entertainment if they have in-house vocal instructors and their singers have bad technique? Genuine question.

@retricallltann6243

10 ай бұрын

@@ilikebeingsmart depends itzy I guess Never really had vocal lessons mich because their songs were mostly performance based also it’s like vocal coaches can teach the techniques but it’s also still up to the artist to fully utilise those techniques in the right way just generally speaking

JYP worked with ITZY during Dalla Dalla, the song that made them became one of the best rookie groups in the history during their debut year. I am sure they knew how strict he is. They were just angry at themselves since they had high expectations. The song is out and most people like it as a b-side track, apart from the trolls and some anti who are wasting their lives hating on a girl group 😂

If yall are offended by this, you would be traumatized by what Simon from XG was telling his girls during vocal training

@johnvaque9464

11 ай бұрын

ong this aint nothing i feel for the girls but there lowkey grown women they shouldnt even really be crying or shedding tears hes not even yelling

I am not a jyp fan, but he has experience, he is a producer from a long time, twice, got7, skz, these groups had gone through him, whatever it is, he is working on itzy, to make them more strong, we should support them, because last year was hectical for them, and they are fading away from kpop, and this is true, we need the energy back for them, and support their concept and cb.

Can people not hate on him. It’s like a father correcting his child and wanting the best for you. There’s no way they won’t feel emotional cause they want to make him proud. And we all know this is how JYP is. He didn’t shout on them he just want the best for them and I’m sure the girls agree. There’s no need to hate anyone

I can guarantee you that every single k-pop group have had experiences like this in the studio. It's just that JYP and ITZY chose to share it. The 'recording behind' videos that most groups share are only a fraction of the real recording process. Recording vocals professionally can be really tricky, especially when the producer has such a clear vision in mind and they're on a time limit. ITZY are professionals and have been in this business for over 5 years, they know how to handle criticism. I imagine they feel frustrated when they feel they aren't achieving their best. JYP has been in the industry for decades and knows when to push for better vocals. It's not that unusual to see stuff like this in a booth.

Remember in Queendom 2 when Monika of Prowdmon made the Loona members and Eunji of Brave Girls cry after the dance practice? Look at the outcome. They ended up winning with that amazing performance in the end. Pressure can burst a pipe, but pressure also makes diamonds.

Hes so kind compared to others

@johnvaque9464

11 ай бұрын

lowkey

@BornInsane0

10 ай бұрын

Like who?

Wowwwww y’all (the netizens) are so hypocritical lollll. You know why??? The reason is y’all will be the first ones to point out how badly the singers are singing, yet you can’t take it when they are going through tough teachings in order to improve?!?! JYP sees potential in them that’s why he’s making them go further. Y’all should be glad that he is actually putting effort

I love itzy, but they are undeveloped vocally. And JYP doesnt seem to insult them or yell at them, he seens to try to help them to be better. I feel like the reasons for girls crying wasnt bc of his behavior, but rather them realizing they have to do better and bc of PRESSURE theyre under.

Tbh the frustration yeji felt in her ability to sing is literally me when im solving a math problem, poor girls though. But ig its cause jyp really wants to get them to push it to perfection which is bad and good at the same time

I'm a fan of Itzy but some netizens are just over the top being dramatic. JYP literally wrote the song himself and his job as a Producer is to create music he envisioned. There are way worse producers who cuss their artists. He simply wants a good result. He didn't even yell at them, he just looked disappointed that's all. Believe me, recording sessions aren't all rainbows and sunshine all the time. He wrote this song for them and he wants to produce good music showcasing their vocal abilities even if it means pushing their limits.

Just because a video showed this doesn't mean these don't happen in other idols or other company's vocal rooms, this is something idols have to go through to become strong and to work more hard.

Isn’t this normal? If he doesn’t provide feedback how the hell would they improve?

recording a song with jyp is like doing your math homework with your dad 💀

Am I the only one who agrees and sides with JYP?

@tjekker4274

11 ай бұрын

Youre not

@akbarwali

11 ай бұрын

Jyp not wrong

@mchaberry6140

11 ай бұрын

He's literally a producer ofc theres criticism

yall needa stop blaming JYP at some point and realize that not all recording sessions with different groups are the same and that's OKAY. As far as I know, there are no producers/ main writers in Itzy, so they were not really directing the song like Soyeon does for idle and Changbin/Bangchan for SKZ. I think ITZY might also want to have more creative freedom, but this wasn't that song. However, you know they are all trying hard for the best outcome because of their tears and struggles, and for god sake, yes JYP was being a it strict but that doesn't mean he's a bad producer 🙄🙄

This is the reason why ITZY shouldn't do vocal-heavy songs because they're more of a performer/dance group than a vocally-skilled one... i can tell that their vocals "not being good enough" for the netizens are really lowering their confidence? so PLEASE JYPE don't give them songs that are so vocally focused to these girlies

Y'all are too sensitive lmao. Jyp was doing nothing bad. How y'all think people improve? He needs to make them improve. Of course he have to be strict

I understand that teachers sometimes are strict, but sometimes they take it too far :( ❤❤❤

Jyp did not a single thing wrong

jt jst tht he wants to help them cuz he seen them that u gzys called itzy bad vocal it u guys fault

@thegameksk

11 ай бұрын

Bc the songs he picks are bad for their vocals. He's a moron.

jyp wants it perfect but they are just humans

why couldnt he just give them a break or give them some water to drink? it helps

@salma31000

11 ай бұрын

exactly .. break rather than pushing them when he see's they don't got energy

I know he is doing for good but I lose it everytime JYP sings 😭

@nasrul23neymar11

11 ай бұрын

Haha, he make a song in female keys not in his keys. Thats why when he sing all of 50 song he produce that rank 1 in chart in a concert, people make fun of him and make a meme out of him. He produce a song according to that person or group vocal not according to his vocal. All of his song are in his vocal range and sound very good. People thought he cant sing since he debut when he already old and cannot reach some keys nowadays.

its legit his job, u can feel bad for them but dont slam the guy doing his job, (as a yeji stan)

I don’t like JYP but he was definitely not in the wrong here 💀 It’s his job to give them criticism to help them sing it right and they were just frustrated cause they couldn’t get it right

Jyp is not wrong it happens when i learn dance i get criticism when i go to school and do something not the way its supposed to ( that doesn't happen with me ) i get criticism constructive criticism those tears are feeling bad that how we are not able to do a certain thing it's alright it happens

people call itzy's vocals bad, he's probably just trying to help.

It is his job to do whatever but can't put so much pressure

Soyeon is strict but it gives a different vibe....i guess his just strict in his own way

@dujsjssjjsjsj107

11 ай бұрын

Um maybe because he is their boss

@nichie3897

11 ай бұрын

@@dujsjssjjsjsj107 But not every boss will do it this way...

@retricallltann6243

11 ай бұрын

That’s because soyeon makes their song knowing the members capabilities in mind but she can be just as strict when it comes to recording still she doesn’t actively joke around with her members when Shuhua needed help hitting her note after many tries she personally went in to give advice as well jyp is doing the same here just much stricter because he knows itzy can do better and he sees their potential he wants itzy’s comeback to do well as much as anyone does

@nichie3897

11 ай бұрын

@@retricallltann6243 That's what I think aswell.....

This is exactly why itzy always has those straining songs. I truly dislike those high screeches he makes yeji do. It doesn’t sound right.

If you have to push them for the sound you want maybe that sound just isn’t for them … I mean half of their songs are out of their vocal range. I’m not the producer but just a thought. 🤷🏽‍♀️ So idk maybe he should try making these songs sound good…see how easy it is 💀💀

@eurika297

11 ай бұрын

@@bonbonbonfire Say that to Simon lol Ever heard of sport coaches being a good coach despite not being a player? Being a producer is a different job, it's not the same as singing.

@diannaa.62

11 ай бұрын

@@eurika297Simon cowell? Oh my lord haven’t heard his name in ages lol

@nasrul23neymar11

11 ай бұрын

@@bonbonbonfire he is a very good singer. With his own money as a singer producer, he build jyp ent and now have $250m dollar net worth. He always committed in music. Most producer couldnt even sing yet they know what they want from their client. Jyp produce a song ICY for itzy it was such a hit with 12 wins, he know their capabilities, and he believe they can do it. Listen to all his song and u will know how good he is. He's now 52 years old and people forget how good he is back then. He still sing and dance recently in his latest song live as well.

If JYP think itzy didn't have strength so why they didn't sing for itzy

yeji: "I choose me" -SLAYED jaywhypee: I Choiose me

This is what you get when you hype objectively poor quality kpop groups/music. People push for tiktok dance legends, but companies will take that as a sign to scout visually pretty idols that will no longer be properly trained for anything vocally related. In the end this only harms the idols themselves and it destroys their confidence when it comes to real idol skills. Anyone can be a dancer, but not everyone can be an artist. This is coming from someone who wishes the best for ITZY and similarly vocally struggling groups. The true blame ultimately lies with the kpop audience and it's current lack of responsibility to hype objectively sound music/groups. This is not anything ITZY or other similar groups should be blamed for. I will say that JYP as a company should take accountability for this and re-train them if this happens on a regular basis. Help the girls. Yelling at them won't work.

@CDOG14515

11 ай бұрын

*this*

@Anjan_-

11 ай бұрын

Preach

He was being nice.

I love these comments that im seeing

I understand if he's strict, but this was a little bit too much.

@snowyhsoo

11 ай бұрын

for real

Jyp is strict

We are in the era of the snowflakes and participation trophy hunters 😂😂😂😂😂

watching the documentary right after watching NewJean's behind the scenes recording of Super Shy.. was a very big difference.

tbh it wasn’t that bad but okay💀

It's stupid. Do they want Itzy to release garbage songs and flop or hit songs?

The title seems to be trying to make JYP the villain... 😬

I don't think Jyp is in the wrong

why are ppl mad that he wanted it to sound a certain way like its supposed to sound that way?

Jyp is doing the right thing...this is kpop.....when they perform live this track is going to be the backing vocal. This is the most important thing the group is doing. If this isnt right then everything is screwed. The people mad dont understand the business.

News flash: His name is on the building. Itzy is more upset with themselves than with him. It’s their job to sing and sell the song.

As a person who doesn't understang singing i can't honestly tell the difference everytime i watch videos about recording songs, artist repeat a single line a lot of times but it always sound almost the same, also with all the editing they will do on the song, i wonder, is all this stress really necessary?

girll this time he isnt wrong fr

@johnvaque9464

11 ай бұрын

frfr

its itzy not nmixx of course he had to

If he's making a song for a JYP artists he makes them keep recording until it's perfect. Once you leave his company like 2AM and 2PM, he doesn't care, they were surprised that recording ended very quickly because all JYP artists had to go through his methods. Even YG's G-Dragon and iKON's B.I do use the same method with their members to get the most perfect recording so the fans can enjoy the song.

I didn't see him do anything inappropriate. At least in these clips he's just treating them like they're professionals doing a job. They're not children, so he isn't (and shouldn't be) coddling them, but he's not yelling at them either. I don't see a problem here.

Aaah is jyp the producer for all itzy only or nmixx too?

@cryforme8656

11 ай бұрын

Yes.

Man all he had to do was let them have a ten minute break and drink some water. I know he’s strict but atleast let them have a break.

Honestly jyp was very strict with them for me i think lia and yeji did really good !

Meanwhile Simon give hard time to XG during vocal evaluation nobody bats an eye 👀, on the side note, not to be harsh but itzy is just vocally weak group, they are just a strong dancer and performer, and that song message is quite powerful so i don't blame jyp for that, he just want to put out the best sound for them

people are only being angry because its jyp take a look at gidle behind the scenes recording it isnt all sunshines and rainbows just beause soyeon is directing and producing she is still strict with the members when it come to recording and using a certain voice to convey certain lyrics sorry but this just how producing works and it will harsher esp on grps who underdeveloped vocally producers just want the idol to do their best in the studio recording of the song and its their job to do so

Well singing better doesn’t come like that, maybe he should try give them proper vocal lessons that way they can healthily produce good sounds

the fact that he seemed so nice after watching a2k makes me so surprised to see this

@cryforme8656

11 ай бұрын

Most participants in A2K had better voices than ITZY. That's why ITZY needs to be trained strictly to succeed.

@buddies6389

11 ай бұрын

⁠@@bonbonbonfirewdym messed up?

@buddies6389

11 ай бұрын

i’m pretty sure he is nice. he’s being strict for a reason.

@baekchikenhyun

11 ай бұрын

this is what i was thinking in my mind, you took the words right out of my mouth

@j3t617

11 ай бұрын

You realize that judging people that have little to no training vs idols that are 4 years into their career are totally different right? Look at Gordon Ramsey. He’s very strict on Hells Kitchen cause those are professionals. He’s much nicer on Master Chef cause those are amateurs

I know he wants them to do well, but this is a little to much, atleast let them have a break and continue later when they feel more confident

I don't think they were crying because of him. Have you all ever been so irritated when something doesn't go right after so many tries. They were probably crying because they were annoyed.

man im glad that skz are self producers. they are so chill with the kids

Nothing wrong here. Move on

yeji and lia sings so much better than jyp

What did he say to Yeji💔 Imagine what happens when there are no cameras around💔 Some fans make me believe that since ITZY is in Division 2 that JYP himself doesn’t really have a hand in their management, but doesn’t this bury that narrative that 👀 I hope these girls stay together after their 3 years are up and sign under a different company💔

@retricallltann6243

11 ай бұрын

jyp has a hand in what they brong out as artost not how they are managed he is a producer ffs and he isnt being as strict as some other producers you think if the members themselves were producers they wouldnt be strict if the recording member is unable to deliver the expected result needed for studio recording just look at gidle and skz they are strict even on their own members when it comes to recording and maybe take a look at xg recording bts and see how strict their prod is compared to jyp

He's a genius but he's also a bully

@idkonce4295

11 ай бұрын

How is he a bully 💀

JYp should learn fron seoyon in gidle.

@cup1d1ss0dumb.

11 ай бұрын

Soyeon* no offense! True tho

@nasrul23neymar11

11 ай бұрын

Are u fr? Jype have more than 50 song rank 1 in chart that he produce. 4 song are Song of the year and many of them got perfect all kill. He even produce a song for american R&b singer cassie and Will smith as well. He's an oldie of course his style of teaching are different. Even in school old teacher are stricter than young teacher. Soyeon are with her members meanwhile Jype is a founder of the company with 250m dollar net worth to 1 of his artist.

He can’t sing anyway idk there’s not another vocal coach there to direct

@hunnilola

11 ай бұрын

He’s literally a singer

@shooterforumji4891

10 ай бұрын

@@hunnilola he may be a singer but it does not sound good

Awww its okay the song is not catchy anyways no matter how good they sing it

He's a moronm pushes them this hard only to makes a terrible choice with their lead single. They should leave.

@guadalupemontoya1819

11 ай бұрын

🫢

Yeji 🤮🤢🤮🤢🤮🤢🤮🤢🤮

@eurika297

11 ай бұрын

You must be miserable in real life. I don't like cursing others but you deserved the worst treatment in real life for being a prick online.

He is doing too much , they sound great

😅 this happens with all groups. You have to strive for the best product. JYP only wants what’s best for the girls 🥹