Siding with Knight Shin at the end of the Brotherhood of Steel questline that was added in Fallout 76's Steel Reign DLC. Here's a video over what happens if you side with Paladin Rahmani in the end - kzread.info/dash/bejne/X6yj27CMn7q5l7w.html

@stagger9660

2 жыл бұрын

A bit late to the party aren't ya.

Vadez: "I can't believe Rahmani is dead!" Vault Dweller: *Flirt*

@user-hb2lj2my9t

8 ай бұрын

That’s why I wanna play fallout 76 again, my dad got rid of the Xbox because he didn’t wanna pay five dollars to keep the membership going

@teste-yh5df

2 ай бұрын

@@user-hb2lj2my9t u can play on pc u know right

Shin is the living embodiment of "He's out of line, but he's right." meme.

I sided with Rahmani, I agreed with her throughout most of the DLCs... but Shin had a point right at the end, so it was a tough call.

@mehtarelingolien

2 жыл бұрын

Same. I was totally team Rahmani, up until the end. Funny thing, it was the Wright scientist that pissed me off the most and helped me agree with Shin. I did let her live. I really liked her.

@overboss9599

2 жыл бұрын

sided with Rahmani in the first half, Shin earned my respect when he threw himself on a bomb to save one of his troops, and that wright clown really grinded my gears. ended up sticking with rahmani because her crusade aligns closest with Maxson's original purpose for the brotherhood while shin would simply repeat the isolationist failures of most other chapters. still it was a tough call and the decision didn't sit with me 100%, which is a great feeling to have in a situation like this, really felt immersed in the story, hope fallout 5 manages to do the same whenever it comes out.

@Elnegro..

2 жыл бұрын

It's the exact opposite for me. I agreed with shin on most things, he stuck to the brother hood code. At the end however paladin made a good point, I spent 30 mins thinking it over then decided to side with shin because one good choice doesn't override paladins constant stupidity.

@Elnegro..

2 жыл бұрын

@@overboss9599 If that's your reasoning then you should have sided with Shin. I do agree that paladin had a good decision at the end that fit with the brother hoods mission, I don't however see how that overrides the fact she's constantly going against the brother hoods mission.

@overboss9599

2 жыл бұрын

@@Elnegro.. i disagree with the assertion she's going against the brotherhoods mission to be honest. the brotherhood's mission is threefold at this point, Collect Technology, the stated intention to use said technology to help the people of the wastes (At some point) and the elimination of the threat of things like the Scorched. with the collecting technical data mission the Vault 76ers undertake the new Appalachian brotherhood is achieving the first one even in these early days, (even if the current initiate heavy nature of the chapter precludes much in the way of sending patrols and expeditions to obtain them otherwise) her stance on the second is more practical and true to form than "Horde everything and blow the bunker sky-high if a wastelander so much as breaths near the keyboard" and the Daily ops and various outposts scattered across the wasteland are present in both endings, speaking to the commitment of both sides to the last goal. honestly while her little stunt with the transmitter and refusal to communicate with the elders back home are failures of her personal mission, the overarching goals of the brotherhood are better served with her than with Shin. plus, I let shin live, so the elders are getting that report they wanted one way or another.

The scientists being completely unapologetic was what made me side with Shin.

@teste-yh5df

2 ай бұрын

they were brainwashed since childhood, and they intentions were indeed good, but the means was obviously horrible, with proper education and a new vision of world that could be corrected.

Rahmani is like "Thank you for supporting my totally not seditious takeover of our Chapter. For your loyalty and support I will...banish you under the lieu of promotion so I can run my little private army in peace."

@totalygamingtemplar

2 ай бұрын

shin is like "thanks for helping me set in stone that we wont help anyone and make the wastland worse for everyone but us"

@joshuagonzalez5959

2 ай бұрын

@@totalygamingtemplar letting the doctors that started a zombie outbreak live isn't helping anyone

@randomizer6553

2 ай бұрын

Zombie outbreak?​@@joshuagonzalez5959

@khandkersabahatrizvee8417

Ай бұрын

@@totalygamingtemplar slight correction "worse for everyone including us". By the end of it the brotherhood members are basically lobotomized toaster worshipers. And yes that is in lore by the end of it titus actually had missions collecting toasters. this is why i dont even hear maxon and danse out in fo4 i just wipe them on arrival.

Man you are one of my favorite streamers and one of the first i ever really subscribed to and i just want to say i miss you making fallout 76 content. Also i hope your family is doing well and i hope to see some more fallout 76 camp build videos or anything 76 lore related in the future you are really good at explaining things.

this was great! just finished the other day and it was interesting to see the other outcomes.

Finally someone did this I haven’t finished it because wasn’t sure what all the outcomes are thanks for posting this

I get Rahmani and her outlook on things, but it's premature. This Brotherhood chapter only just arrived and barely has their foot in the door. They lost half their team crossing the US, they are in no position to help anyone. They need to continue to build up their own forces and establish basic rapport with the major factions, or they are going to end up like Taggerty's squad. Then, and only then, should they be expending ANY forces to help anyone. Rahmani's problem is that she wanted everything her way, immediately. Damn the consequences. From the sounds of things, she has always been that way. That is the core of her personality. It's why the California chapter approved her expedition anyway. Shin's problem is that he has trouble forgiving himself. Apparently he didn't always have a stick up his a**, both Rahmani and him made a bad call, and he holds himself to blame. That can be treated with time. At the end of the Story, This Shin is already very different from the Shin we first meet. That's good, that's progress. And his ideals make sense. To a degree. But with our player character and lead scribe Valdez there at his side, the Brotherhood could be a very effective force that not only helps its neighbors, but is also able to help itself.

@klubstompers

2 жыл бұрын

Helping out people in your area, will net you resources, allies, and information, which is necessary in building rapport, numbers, and security. The more you aid the local populous, the better your perceived, and the easier it is for you to grow. Help a group out, and people within that group are more likely to join in your cause, share local knowledge with you, and trade necessary goods. Hiding in your bunker as the world falls apart around you, only makes your job harder, and your enemies stronger.

Well done Rifle. I sided with Rahmani since I am a retired Army National Guard officer as she was and I am always looking to help out the people. Shin reminded me of some of the officers I served with over 27+ years who went by the book to the letter and sometimes got people killed in combat, real people so I was glad to see him go. Hope all is well with you my friend. Take care and God bless.

@Mason-zp8yb

2 жыл бұрын

Ironic since Rahmani is a failure of a soldier and disobeyed orders and got people killed.

@marcolopez5769

2 жыл бұрын

@@Mason-zp8yb I think it was the right way because taking Palidin Rahmani will mean a better and Elder Maxson is dead and a new elder is here and doesn't give a dam about helping people which Rahmani cares about other people

@fallout0624

2 жыл бұрын

@@marcolopez5769 Shin does care but he's also looking at it from a much different perspective, they only have a total 3 officer and a bunch of rookies at best

@Ryotbh

Жыл бұрын

She cut off reinforcements for her own personal power trip. I fail to see how that assists anyone. Given the previous Brotherhood chapter in Appalachia was slaughtered when they were separated it hardly bodes well. Imagine, within a wartime situation, your commanding officer ordering your channels of communication be cut off with command because they didn't agree with commands decisions. Now imagine that you are aware that this shuts off your provisions, assistance, and battlefield knowledge.

@dovahkiin3526

Жыл бұрын

Rahmani got many of her own forces killed

I chose Rahmani bc my character is evil, and I perceived her as incompetent. Being a prequel, this choice logically leads to the east coast Brotherhood’s arbiter pathos and the misguided spread of FEV we see in later games.

@mostlyjovial6177

2 жыл бұрын

Dude... thats next level. I applaud you.

@remanscimitar

2 жыл бұрын

*slowly claps as a Noddy*

@CommanderM117

2 жыл бұрын

same as an Enclave supporter every mission i did for them was to weaken them in the long run.

@mgf555

Жыл бұрын

Rahmani is soo incompetent, she's more like a politician than a soldier ... so I sided with Shin

@tacidian7573

9 ай бұрын

Siding with Rahmani to weaken the Brotherhood is just hilarious.

So happy you’re doing fo76 stuff again. Love your videos

If Rahmani really wanted to deviate from and subvert the Brotherhood’s mission then she should have left the BoS and started her own organization. But then she wouldn’t have had access to Brotherhood personnel, gear and most importantly name and clout that comes with being a part of the BoS. She turned her back on the BoS principles but didn’t have the heart to turn in her Power Armor, renounce her rank and give up all the other perks of being a Paladin.

@randy2152

2 жыл бұрын

You must have started playing since FO4

@brookehuffman2248

2 жыл бұрын

if you played fall out 3 you'd know that the east (aka west virgina) and west chapters of the brotherhood of steel have diff mind sets on how it should be ran. if knight shin took charge there wouldnt be diff mind sets because knight shin was by the book just like the west. soo in the universe it had to be paladin, makes more sense for knight shin to go back to cali because it tells us how the west knew about the east spltting off and doing their own thing

@CommanderM117

2 жыл бұрын

she actually had the right ideal sadly she was brotherhood through and through and it the Only reason i sided with her to destroy the brotherhood from the Inside. Veronica was the same the brotherhood would die if they did not adapt and the west coast is all but wiped out down to their code killed off by the NCR. Lyons Brotherhood was the right direction however Arthur Maxon destroyed that dream. God Bless the Enclave and Death to the Brotherhood

@kirkbrownell1556

Жыл бұрын

@@brookehuffman2248 sounds like you dont know your lore homie.

@pRiMeEmIrP911

8 ай бұрын

@@randy2152well considering this game takes place earlier than any other game , their lore is meaningless as of now

I’m at this choice right now on Xbox and your video was extremely helpful! Thanks mate on helping me make a tough decision :)

I like the awkward silence and all staring at you pause.

Shin, was right in the end tho. It had to stop.

Thank you so much for showing both sides of this. I've been too sick to play 76, so your video's have enlightened me to the stories going on. Thanks! ~Prayers for your daughter and family, much love~

Thanks for sharing, its good to see you uploading again

I choose knight Shin because what they did reminded me of the Japanese scientist in ww2 that never got punish because they gave they’re research on hundreds of human test subjects to the allies.

@overboss9599

2 жыл бұрын

eh, for the most part they seemed more like capable scientists who just got caught up in something unfortunate when Blackburn decided to go all Doctor Frankenstein. I don't blame Farah or Jain, But I would love nothing more than to drag Wright kicking and screaming to my Vault shelter and subject the psychotic "Insert derogatory" to the worst and most painful experiments i can think of, all to "Better humanity" of course.

@brookehuffman2248

2 жыл бұрын

if you wanna stick more to the fall out universe, i feel choosing thee paladin over the knight is right. because if you read up on lore and played the other games you'd know the east and west chapter separted into their own factions. if knight shin would have took charge than he would have evenally got in contact with the west chapter, its also stated that the two chapters had diff ideas on how the brotherhood should be ran. if knight shin acctually took over than the east chapter would have the same mind set as the west

@szyszus4683

Жыл бұрын

@@brookehuffman2248 What you said is not right. East Coast Chapter is not the same as Appalachian one. No matter who becomes the leader, Lyons will still be sent out, and he will become elder anyway. Shin also has different mindset than Western BoS. He cares about their ideology, but isn't isolationist. He is in fact more open than previous Appalachian Brotherhood. There are many hopefuls and initiates, and he has no problems with it. In short, the choice in Appalachia does not change the East Coast BoS. Shin actually reminds me of Arthur, elder of East BoS in Fallout 4.

@D3V1LDR1V3R

Жыл бұрын

Unit 731

@Akiraspin

Жыл бұрын

@@overboss9599 The Ellie chick literally says she doesn't feel bad for the hundreds of people experimented on. And Doctor Jain says he fully intends to continue FEV experimentation. So no, they did not get "caught up" in it. They willingly and knowingly used human experimentation.

I play a lot with my brother, we never choose same endings to see as much lore and options together. 🤘

@Elnegro..

2 жыл бұрын

Gaaaay

@elgwninja

2 жыл бұрын

@@Elnegro.. that would be incest

The final nail in the coffin with my schtick with Rahmani was when she just stood there as I was fighting for my life against the sheepsquach impostor and did nothing to help me. Also her sympathy for the scientists playing god with the FEV makes me side with Knight Shin even more.

@nickschaffer3766

11 ай бұрын

😂😂 my son is 9 an told me dad she didn't even fire a shot 😂😂

There is a reason why one of the scientist drop Cultist Dagger. Was on Rahmani team just until the end.

@LolSho0orTs

Жыл бұрын

Can you explain more what is the reason?

@gecko-v

Жыл бұрын

@@LolSho0orTs She never shows remorse of the kidnapping, and why would a scientist have a cultist dagger? I mean, if she had some other weapon, okay... I would feel a bit different. In my eyes, she was brainwashed by the cult and then influenced the rest of the scientist doing all kind of atrocities.

@johnpenguinthe3rd13

Жыл бұрын

@@LolSho0orTs In Fallout 76, there is a cult in the game called the Cult of the Mothman. They are spread out in various locations (one of the most notable locations in their large Church which is within the forest area a few "miles" away from Lewis and Sons Farming Supply that's in west Appalachia). Long story short: they are FREAKING CRAZY!! Nellie (the young scientist) has a cultist dagger on her (the same exact cultists daggers the Cult of the Mothman members have) and she uses that to attack the player if they decide to kill the scientists. It was explained by one of the other scientists (the older female, Dr. Farha) that she originally met Nellie when Nellie broke into her place (sometime POST-war) and started scavenging for items, but then Nellie had a great interest in Farha's science notes (which led to Farha "adopting" Nellie and teaching her about science and Nellie eventually becoming a scientist under Farha and Blackburn). So... Where did Nellie originally come from? Due to the type of dagger she has, she definitely originated from the cult. However, she most likely met Farha at a young age and fell in love with the science stuff she had read and wanted to learn how to be a scientist, so she picked being with Farha (Nellie also mentions how no one liked her before meeting Farha, so very high chance that Nellie's behavior was so abrasive that even the other Mothman cultists were getting fed up with her. Granted, Mothman cultists tend to have very hostile personalities to begin with). However, cult members, even disloyal ones that break away from a cult at a young age, are still going to hold on to VERY bad habits. Mothman cultists do NOT hold human life in very high regard. Hell, the player has a higher chance is being able to negotiate with Blood Eagle gang members than they do with Cultists in the game (I don't think it's possible to negotiate with the cult members, they just instantly attack when they see the player. Blood Eagles can at least be talked to during rare occasions and a FEW times peaceful agreements can be made with them. Blood Eagle leader Tally Lang in Vault 96 being a prime example). So... Due to Nellie's upbringing, this would explain why she did NOT give a damn about all the people that were killed off during those experiments and she had such a warped view on the entire thing. Because of her cult of the Mothman type morals (A.K.A: she doesn't give a damn if people die during one of her experiments. Hell, she most likely ENJOYS it if someone dies or mutates from her experiments), there is a high chance that if the player decides to spare her and brings her back to Fort Atlas, she is going to do something horrible when someone isn't looking in order to carry out some crazy experiment she has in mind (EX: she might release FEV in some weird way on some Brotherhood member without them knowing so she can see what happens as part of her experiment). VERY hard to trust someone like that.

Paladin Rahmani betrayed the Brotherhood when she destroyed the transmitter back at the Enclave base. I sided with Knight Shin because he was right all along, these scientists killed thousands in the name of science and their actions needed to be punished for.

@tazii0966

Жыл бұрын

Science requires sacrifices

My lazy self finally got to this part in Fallout 76 after this procrastinating and I had to be like wait a minute I'm going to look it up on KZread rifle definitely did this thanks bro your video was perfect

My first character sided with Shin, this is just like what happened at Mariposa; FEV tested on civilians.

Oh my God I didn't even know that's how you got the hellcat power armor great video thanks for making it

While I agreed with Paladin in a majority of her actions, I could NOT be made to spare the scientists. When I found out that they were the root cause of Huntersville and that they were replicating the sane experiment that failed utterly? I felt thst there was no possible way for a end thst would win me over other than killing them all. Shin may be the stereotype of BoS I despise... but I was made to see why they guard technology. All those deaths and for nothing.

I went with Shin as well, but I didn't kill Rahmani--great vid, Rifle. Thanks!

@asianartist1

2 жыл бұрын

yeah, scribe valdez still talks about her, saying she wonders how Rahmani is doing

@davidhytha9828

2 жыл бұрын

same

@Elnegro..

2 жыл бұрын

So she could make a faction to directly oppose the brother hood, and create confusion and mutiny in the order?!?! You also let her leave with advanced technology! I hear by strip you of all brother hood title's, you are to be excommunicated and exiled!

@davidhytha9828

2 жыл бұрын

@@Elnegro.. Someone was not paying attention during the quest.

@Elnegro..

2 жыл бұрын

@@davidhytha9828 She said she's leaving to help Appalachia, naturally people who loved her will be confused and inspire to join her cause, as for technology she literally left in power armor holding a High tech weapon that shouldn't be left in cvillian hands.

Great video. Always wondered what would happen if I'd sided with Knight Shin.

Personally, while Shin is an ass, he is right. All three of them still wanted to work with the FEV, something that has shown time and time again that it only creates more destruction than the good it can bring. They needed to be dealt with properly. Inevitably keeping them around would eventually cause it to come full circle. So it had to stop. Something tells me Ramani was cannon though, seeing as there is an ungodly number of supermutants around the east coast... and it would definitely explain where they came from if you saved the idiot scholars who thought the best hope for humanity was continuing to expose people to the worst substance in Fallout...

@CommanderM117

2 жыл бұрын

as and Enclave supporter i agree killing scientist best option. however screwing over the Brotherhood by letting the scientist live is the Best Option for the Enclave Victory.

This was my ending, despite siding with Rahmani most of the quest line... but after what I saw in that vault, I knew I couldn't let them get away with it, much less to "Try again" to make humanity better on their terms. I hard aligned with Shin over this, and sided against Rahmani for the first time. I DID let her leave though. I didn't see any reason to gun down the paladin. But those scientists sure got their redemption alright... at the end of my chainsaw. Better than they deserved.

I love the end point it brings a good debate too which side should have been picked but in the end the only good pick is the one you believe in

Gonna be real here. Knight Shin is right, but his methods are... jerkass. Dr. Farha is the only sane scientist in the group who legitimately regrets her actions. Doctor Jain is a very smart-stupid person who sooner or later will go back to researching FEV. Nellie Wright is freaking evil and should be immediately put down for the safety of everyone. Put simply only 1/3 is worth saving. Also, due to most of us having joined MODUS in the game by now he's justified in not trusting us due to us being Enclave. In fact, I think he might try and kill us during some of these missions if we just came out and told him that. So yeah... he's got a point. It's just that... at the same time I would rather we just cap the two bad scientists and imprison the last one for R&D stuff. Then, maybe, an option to reveal Enclave bio materials to get both Shin and Rahmani on the same page.

@articueilacoryphaeusdux5941

2 жыл бұрын

Nah, his methods are completly justified. You have to realise that this is a wasteland and they are a military force...Even Martial Law is still going on...But even in modern day if you kill someone and you simply say "Yes I did, but I see my error" you will still be executed or get life sentence...especially if its a literal mass murder like they did...

Two of the scientist wanted to continue the research one of them still believed that what they where doing was not wrong and given the chance she do it again plus she use to be a cultist.

Im just gonna give the vid a like since i dont want any spoilers

thanks for this, i just couldn't bring myself to join shin but i did wonder how it would work out.

Thank you -- I choose Rahmani and wondered what happened if I had chose Shin instead.

Interesting , Thank you

Damn mannnn, wish I searched for this BEFORE I just finished the quest about an hour ago

Just finished Over and Out last night, and I wanted more insight on the outcomes of the decisions, so thank you! Also, thanks again for the C.A.M.P. Locations video as well! I was able to place both of my CAMP’s at 2 of the locations in that video and I absolutely love them!

There's a computer there and although I'm only learning the language that I play FO76 with (German), I think one of the options was "Let the virus loose" or something. I wonder what happens if one chooses that. I only checked out the research data and personal logs there. I also wonder where Rahmani went. What group "fits her ideals"? Responders? Or... the Enclave? I let her live, so I wonder where will I see her in the future and other players will see what there instead of her...

if I remember, if you brought Dodge to the Brotherhood before this, he had dialogue too in regards to your decision

Night Shin is like Elder Maxson, though he is a lot more reasonable

@Beans_130

2 жыл бұрын

Fax

@averageforzaplayer1048

2 жыл бұрын

@@Beans_130 with or without the machine?

@bender3219

2 жыл бұрын

@@averageforzaplayer1048 lmao

@Tester-sh1mn

2 жыл бұрын

“Reasonable”

@MrMadre

2 жыл бұрын

No, he's not more reasonable, he is probably about the same. Why do people think maxson is such a dick?

I'm doing this right now had to check what happens b4 I choose

Thank you so much for this. I sided with Ramani and really wanted to know what would happen if I chose Shin, without having to choose him in game! I didn’t kill him though. He just left hinting he’d be back (with the boys probably😯) I wish there had been an option to incarcerate the scientists and no option to kill either Ramani or Shin because we worked with both of them. Killing either shows a lack of humanity. I don’t think my/our character is like that. Really good to see, thanks again.

@robertreed2824

2 жыл бұрын

Um... i agree with everything you have said.. but you should probably remember our characters (at least mine) has literally launched nukes because the Enclave told them too, idk about you but i think that shows a lack of humanity

@Jules-77

2 жыл бұрын

@@robertreed2824 good point Robert. I think the whole Shin/Ramani thing mirrors real life really well. It’s rarely black and white it’s mostly grey but sometimes we just have to go with what feels right at the time even if it’s not perfect.

@ceu160193

2 жыл бұрын

@@robertreed2824 Enclave told us to launch nukes, but left it at our discretion, where they should be launched. So it's not lack of humanity, but test of it - would you use it for good to kill Scorchbeasts, or for bad?

Thank you

I chose Shin because he is so cool

Just came across your channel after like 4-5 years of forgetting about it tbh. Use to watch your destiny 1 videos back in the back. You ever consider getting back into the destiny universe?

I was with the paladin all the way up to the end, after discussing with the scientists. I sided with the knight

How are you reloading??! Thats incredible you can go back and choices can be explored!

I just did this yesterday and rahmani went through the laser grid and u couldn't get her loot

How did you get that modded gun i only thought that was possible on fallout 4?

I don't know how your still playing this game gl

I felt like like chosing Rahmani and the Appalachian brotherhood would lead to the creation of the Later Outcasts in fallout 76

I chose shin somewhat by accident. I didn't actually know it was such a significant decision. But i was NOT ok with giving those three villains access to the brotherhood resources. So i killed them. Then Ramani said she was leaving and i was gutted. But then i realised that she never really fit the brotherhood anyway and starting something new was best for both. Ultimately i was happy

I misclicked and sided with Rahmani. Now I'm a traitor to the brotherhood, I've lost Knight Shin and I've doomed my brothers and sisters to being outcasted from our order. (Do you think I could get anywhere by contacting Bethesda support and trying to get my quest outcome changed?)

Ad victoriam, team Shin

So personally with my background being a National Guardsman, I almost want to side with Paladin Romani, but I always side with Knight Shin, since his vision of the Brotherhood has always been what I align with. I also just don’t like the way Romani speaks to people, I’ve always seen her as a bit of manipulator to get what she wants. While Knight Shin has nearly always been direct, barring his trauma with what happened to the settlers (which is understandable imo)

It will be interesting to see what, if anything, happens farther down the line. I sided with Rahmani though I would have liked to kill the one scientist (the one who saw absolutely no problem with what they did). Having Shin at the helm instead of Rahmani should defiantly have a different impact on Appalachia.

i choose side of rahmani ,but im curious what if i choose shin? thanks ☺️☺️

I want to experience all this for my self so I'm wondering if there's a special weapon or items from either side? But don't want to hear any type of spoilers.

How do you get 999 ammo for fixer?

That's why you have to have 2 characters guys I got 1 sided with Rahmani and the other one, well you guessed it...

I am considering making a second character and siding with shin, and siding with raiders

Do you still get the hellcat armor if you side with rahmani

Daniel Shin is 💥💥🤯🤯

I'm sorry, I love the Lyons Brotherhood... but removing the elders from the command list. Unacceptable

Does this mean you can’t go back to the brotherhood

How did you make your character like that?

just beat it and picked knight shin

With only one "real" character, thanks for showing me what the option I didn't take was. (watches video) I regret nothing.

So if you do this you get the hellcat power armor

Went you do missions with them Shin help you and he sacrifice to. She no even drop his gun to help you. She is not a true Brother. Her morals, decisions and leadership were just to get more power. Shin is a true Brother.

I thought we had to follow shin due to the chains that bind us furthermore when Rahmani wanted to further research FEV that was a big NO once Pandora’s box is open it’s open we put the world at more risk which will be more sinister than nuclear bombs rahmani is negligent, at least shin has resolution is in his identity with his brotherhood rahmani is splintering into another faction

Wait, how u have all the infinite ammo and all of that?

Russel should become like sam the new ally. An atom shop ally from the brotherhood. Since sam is a settler. We will prob get a raider next season lol. Russel should be the BOS ally with solomon. Agree disagree?

hahahahahaah Gets stabbed "im hit." In such a normal tone

Shin uptight and one order away from the dark side, thanks. I'll take him out

I regretted destroying the transmitter

How did you have unlimited ammo like that?

What kind of gun was he using?

BoS always had eternal conflicts about prioritising Technology and Humanity. West Chapter were more for hoarding tech than saving humanity, they would take from humanity regardless of the circumstances. The east ended up helping humanity for couple decades after events of fallout 3, because their goals aligned and shared a common enemy. Up until fallout 4 where they became too isolationist, attacked none humans whether they were hostile or not. And killed or just stole tech from those who said no to them, which were your average human settler. They lost their humanity and compassion as a faction eventually. Shin's choice would be what the brotherhood west chapter would expect their soldiers to do in that situation, interrogate, take what knowledge they can, take out those who would be a threat to the brotherhood and in this case because the scientists created the mutants they are too dangerous to be kept alive and it's not something BoS would want in their new world order. And yeah, experimenting and kidnaping settlers is f***ed up. Both choices in the end would not be bad as long you let Shin or Romani leave to go wherever, depending on your choice, but that is my opinion about it. I wouldn't execute people, as a person in real life I don't agree with the death penalty. Full, natural life imprisonment in a highly secured prison would be just for this sort of crime. If I side with Shin, I will not be killing the scientists.

does picking one or the other effect rewards/vendor stuff like how who u choose to raid the vault w settlers or raiders does?

@kombat4790

2 жыл бұрын

No

Those drops aren’t randomized. I got those exact drops aswell.

Even if I think Paladin Rahmani had her heart in the right place, I wasn't gonna stand for her going full-Nuremberg Trials on the scientists. I told her to hit the road.

I personally killed shin. Feels more canon since the Appalachian BoS is never heard from again

Sided with the brother hood of steel and killed rhamani I shouldn’t have let her destroy that transmitter !

Rahmani was unhinged through this story man, shin all the way

wait you can take shins side i tried to kill the lab people first then i spun a coin bc i was annoyed they wouldn’t let me kill them so i chose to let them live n it gave me the opportunity to kill shin so i chose to bc i wanted to kill something.

@youdragmyballs6093

2 жыл бұрын

if i could choose kill her i wouldn’t chooses too but i took shin guess shouldn’t play fallout 76 after an long day

I get that the scientists were evil but in the end the brotherhood feeds off of great technology so I sided with rahmani and kept the scientists to help the brotherhood

I side with knight shin because he sides with the border hood and she Bork the radio so the rest of the border hood well not be called

I sided with Rahmani, and I'm glad I did. Instead of learning anything, Shin just pounded that stick up his butt even further.

I sided with Rahmani. She reminded me of the Lyons chapter of the BOS (who I think is the better chapter than Maxons.)

The middle scientist was the only one I felt sorry for. The other two showed no remorse.

I sided with shin just because I think “brotherhood is better”

7:17 pm

To this point I mosly agreed with Shin but the last issue was too much for me, so I sided with Rahmani. I recret it so much since I noticed my heart breaking when Shin walked away 😭 Stupid stubborn cutie butt

Too bad you didn't flirt with Shin afterwards. His facial expressions and stuttering are the highlight of the quest for me 😂

I'll be honest: First time I did this to unlock the achievement for completing the quest, I just couldn't bring myself to kill Blackburn's co-workers and took Rahmani's side. My paternal grandfather served in the U.S. Army after the Korean Armistice was signed, and despite all of Shin's boasting when it came to securing the Hellstorms during the Steel Dawn quests, my bleeding heart is always to sparing the lives of NPCs, no matter if it is Fallout 76, Skyrim, or MGS 4 with the Beauty and the Beast Unit. Shin let his own guilt and hatred blind him to the truth, and in the end, I had no choice but to let him return home to New California and pray Elder Maxson gets him to see reason behind Rahmani's decisions instead of having the successor to Taggerdy's Brotherhood be dishonorably discharged for treason.