I'm a sikh & like many others I don't want Khalistan & No one ever used this word in my family as far as I remember , I first read about this issue in a newspaper!! & yes I respect All religions !! No hate for anyone except this dirty politicians!! Most of the sikhs want Justice , public apology for the genocide & not Khalistan!! 💯

@raminderify

4 жыл бұрын

you are right , Sikhs and especially sant bhrindwale never asked for Khalistan. All Sikhs asked for was gurbani recitation from golden temple to be broadcast on radio and a train to be named golden temple express and most important less of central govt interference in states. Now that really put scare in central govt so they are the ones who started screaming OH LOOK SIKHS WANT INDEPENDENCE. The name Khalistan was invented by congress govt,, Sikhs were surprised to find that they were supposed to be part of Khalistan. Ask shatrugan Sinha the actor who was told reason he was not invited to patna university celebrations was that the central govt in delhi decides who is to be invited.. MICROMANAGENENT. Now off course lot of water has flowed under the bridge with all the killings of hundred of thousends of innocent sikh youth so it will never be the same. that hindu sikh brotherhood is done thanks to the brahmin central govt. The brahmin has always had a fear complex which makes him fear the dalit the buddhist the muslim the Christian the sikh etc and he ways fond of quoting Chanakya to prove how smart he is and yet he was enslaved thruout history and his women carried away but he never stopped insting look how smart I am.And yet thruout history this brahmin sucked up to the one who conquered him and took his women.Sad part is that this brahmin convinced followers of guru ravidass to let the brahmin install idols in their temples and eventually convinced them that they are hindus but be ware LOW CASTE HINDUS. Look at reality any you will realise that this brahmin is really the minority in India and yet how he has convinced the rest of indian humanity that they are hindus too,,,, but low caste hindus so he can fuck with your women but you low caste hindus cannot mess around with his women

@harri089

4 жыл бұрын

No u not a sikh......dear

@simiedulay

4 жыл бұрын

@@harri089 theek aa ji Tahi mein ik bnde na ladai kiti Jo sant ji bare glt gll krda c....Mere ghrr sare path krde aa prr koi na asi keda sikh aa asi ta madrasi aa😂....Sikh sikha di respect ni krde hora nu ki kahiye !! J thonu pta na hove ta dssda Khalistan congress ne shuru kita c ....prr tuc ta boht saiyane o thonu koi ki samjave!! Jede NRI bolde aa Khalistan Zindabad ohna ne kde ona v ni j bngea!! Chhdo prr tuc ta sbh jande o...Nahi aa asi sikh tuc hi o bss!!🙏🙏🏻

@simiedulay

4 жыл бұрын

@@raminderify *Sant Bhindravale ....sorry for correction but u wrote it wrong. No disrespect 🙏🏻

@harri089

4 жыл бұрын

@@simiedulay ਬੀਬੀ ਜੀ ਮੇਰੀ ਗਲ ਤੁਹਾਨੂੰ ਬੁਰੀ ਲਗੀ ਅਤੇ ਲਗਨੀ ਵੀ ਚਾਹੀਦੀ ਹੈ। ਗਲ ਹੀ ਮੈ ਏਹੋ ਜੀ ਕੀਤੀ ਹੈ ਪਰ ਕੋਈ ਨਾ ਏਹੋ ਗਲਾਂ ਕਰਨ ਵਲੇ ਮੇਰੇ ਵਾਗੂ ਬੜੇ ਆ।ਤੁਸੀ ਕਿਅਾ ਖਲਿਸਥਾਨ ਕੋਗ੍ਰੈਸ ਦੀ ਦੇਣ ਆ ਪਰ ਆ ਵੀ ਗਲ ਸੰਤ ਜੀ ਨੇ ਆਖੀ ਸੀ ਕੀ ਜੇ ਦੇਣ ਗੇ ਆਸੀ 47 ਵਲੇ ਗਲਤੀ ਨਹੀ ਕਰਨੀ। ਹੁਣ ਮੇਰੀ ਗਲ ਸੁਣੋ ਕਦੀ ਕਿਰਾਏ ਦੇ ਮਕਾਨ ਚ ਰਹੇ ਹੋ। ਜਾਂ ਕੋਈ ਅਨਾਥ ਬਚੇ ਨੂ ਮਿਲੇ ਹੋ ਗਲੀ ਚ ਭੀਖ ਮਗਦਿਯਾਂ। ਜਾਂ ਫਿਰ ਉਸ ਔਰਤ ਨੂ ਜਿਸ ਦੇ ਮਾਂ ਪਿਉ ਮਰ ਗਿਅਾ ਹੋਵੇ ਅਤੇ ਜੋ ਆਪਣੇ ਪਤਿ ਤੌ ਹਮੇਸ਼ਾ ਕੁਟ ਖਾਦੀ ਹੋਵੇ। ਜਾਂ ਫਿਰ ਏਕ ਬਚਾ ਅਪਨੀ ਸੋਤੇਲੀ ਮਾਂ ਕੋਲ ਪਲਦਾ ਹੋਵੇ। ਜਾਂ ਫਿਰ ਕਿਸੀ NRI ਬੰਦੇ ਨੂ ਜੋ ਵਿਦੇਸ਼ ਚੋਂ ਵਾਪਿਸ ਨਹੀ ਆ ਸਕਦਾ ਕਦੀ ਵੀ ਤੇ ਉਸ ਦੀ ਮਾ ਤੜਪ ਤੜਪ ਕੇ ਮਰ ਗਿ ਹੋਵੇ ਯਾਦ ਚ। ਜਾਂ ਫਿਰ ਹੁਣ ਹੀ ਵੇਖ ਲੋ lockdown ਚ ਸਾਰੇ ਮਜ਼ਦੂਰ ਦਿਹਾੜਿ ਦਾਰ ਆਪਣੇ ਘਰ ਕਿਉ ਪਰਤ ਰਹੇ ਸੀ ਓਹ ਕਿਉ ਨਹੀ ਰੁਕੇ ਜੋ 10 10 20 20 ਸਾਲ ਤੌ ਆਪਣੇ ਘਰ ਨਹੀ ਮੁੜੇ ........ਪਰ ਆਜ ਮੂੜ ਗਏ। ਜੇ ਆ ਸਬ ਗਲਾਂ ਦਾ ਸਾਰਥਕ ਅਰਥ ਤੁਹਾਨੂੰ ਪਤਾ ਲਗ ਜਾਵੇ ਤਾਂ ਮੇਰੀ ਗਲ ਪੁਰੀ ਸਮਜੋ।

An excellent interviewer. No shouting, no below the belt questions. A rare species found in India now a days.

@tajinder9308

Жыл бұрын

Sant ji

@avinashghadge1683

Жыл бұрын

Well said

@abhayoka2768

Жыл бұрын

😊😊😅😊

@abhishekkumar-yu7fh

Ай бұрын

Very TRUE sir ji

I think he is real sikh who cleansed golden temple from terrorists . In Future Sikhs will be proud of him unlike the some fanatics who preach hatred and play with emotions of people following faith . He is real follower of Sikhism.

@armanveergrewal9664

Жыл бұрын

That day there will be no Sikh on this planet ……he is seen as enemy and we will make him for what he has done ,,,,,,,haq haq agah guru gobind Singh …..shah_e-shehanshah guru gobind Singh…….

@shivanshsharma3536

Жыл бұрын

@@armanveergrewal9664 Kaat denge kar ke dikha .. Bhule me na baithiye..

@armanveergrewal9664

Жыл бұрын

@@shivanshsharma3536 baba bille shah ne kaha tha “na kru ab ki na kru batt tab ki, agar na hote Guru Gobind Singh to sunnat hoti sabki “ hamara kuch nhi jayega indra Gandhi ,genral vedya,makkan . Aur harkissan ka Hassar jo hua tha dekh lena phir baat krna

@thebittertruth3514

Жыл бұрын

@@armanveergrewal9664 Read Shiva Bavani. 'Bhushan Bhanat Bhagyo Kashipati Vishvanath, Aur Kaun ginti me bhui geet bhav ki, Kashi karbla hoti, Mathura Madina hoti, Shivaji na hote to sunnat hoti sab ki. It was written by Poet Bhushan for our saviour ' Chhatrapati SHIVA JI MAHARAJ' .

@shivanshsharma3536

Жыл бұрын

@@armanveergrewal9664 who said that I am against Sikhism? Or tu ye bhi yaad kar ki agar rajput apne ladke na dete to Sikh panth paida hi na hua hota.. Ghanchakkar...Or ab gaye time jab maarte the tum..Aaj maarke dikhao na kutta banake chhoda tab kahio

It was how an interview should be conducted. Difficult questions asked but no shouting , no mud slinging .

@banisingh8169

4 жыл бұрын

Difficult questions 😂 really ? He should have asked why infants were bursted against walls and cracked open , now that’s what a difficult question is. Get your level of difficulty adjusted based on reality and not government propagated narratives.

@yogawithanish

4 жыл бұрын

@@banisingh8169 as if u saw those busted heads . Cmon

@banisingh8169

4 жыл бұрын

Anish Sharma I knew it very well that you won’t believe me as for you it’s just another incident. There are interviews of mothers of such children 👶 who survived against the odds.

@yogawithanish

4 жыл бұрын

@@banisingh8169 ok.

@satvindermudan5006

3 жыл бұрын

Which was the difficult question ?

I have known Gen Brar when he was a Brigadier in the late seventies. At the time of this operation I was posted at Jallandhar. He is a thorough gentleman and a professional soldier. Inspite of his personal feelings at the time of the operation, he kept them aside and carried out the assigned operation with success notwithstanding the terms of reference imposed. It needs a lot of character and discipline to execute to a task like this. He is a true soldier for whom duty is above everything else. This task is a lot tougher than fighting an enemy equipped with all available weaponry.

@akikullie

5 жыл бұрын

colrajdhan it would have taken more guts to go against the orders!!!! His job is to protect the civilians not kill them!

@wt3522

3 жыл бұрын

Brar is a traitor to the Sikh Sangat

@kartikcoolchamp

3 жыл бұрын

Yaaa brar should do do everything.... Where as the person who fortified golden temple is a sant. Hypocrisy dekho

@vicksidhu616

2 жыл бұрын

so nobody at all finds it strange that the Indian army decided to attack the Golden Temple on the anniversary of the martyrdom of Guru Arjan Dev Ji, the guru who completed the construction of the golden temple, making it one of the most visited times of the year. please don't be naive and give into silly propaganda...the question is asked at 36:45 in this video and the "general" has no answers. pathetic. I would say he's more of a puppet that got used by those in power.

@kakarotdb490

2 жыл бұрын

@@akikullie civilians don't fortify a temple. They were bloody militants not civilians

I think making comments on this video is just a stupidity, we already had one partition in 1947 and millions were killed. Another one will cause more than that not only Sikhs but Hindu Brothers and Sisters. Please stop criticizing each other religions and start thinking how to encourage good and healthy relations. US has all races and they all live together with love, why can't we..??

@mailajaykumar

9 жыл бұрын

Dalbir Singh gr8 comment

@djay2030

7 жыл бұрын

Dalbir Singh we need sensible people like you no religion is bigger than human life because god bless us with it as his first gift.

@anilsharma1509

7 жыл бұрын

Dalbir Singh i fully agree with you

@apusingh1967

6 жыл бұрын

I agree @dalbir ,, is not easy

@mukesh43ford

6 жыл бұрын

Dalbir Singh haameshaa punjaaab da lahooo jydaaa duliyaa chahay 47 tay84 raaab meraay punjaab nu hasdaa wasda rehaan daay baahut khoon ditaaa es zaamee nu

I have read his book so was aware of the tactical aspect of the Operations, Gen Brar is a Soldier, his words come out as a Soldier asked to finish a task. Sometimes they are asked to clean the dirt created by the political class. It's easy for us to comment now but those were dark times.

Thanks for the interview. I grew up 250 meters from golden temple and lived through that time .I was 8 year old and remember all events crystal clear. I clearly remember in our street that shared wall with Goldent temple complex people rushing into their homes when Army started cordoning off the premises. I can say there was NO looting by Army at that time . Thank you for you service General Brar.

@eakamjotsingh9151

Жыл бұрын

The sikh library burned down and many Guru Granth Sahibs were stolen, burnt, Disrespected and you have the audacity to say no looting was done

@INDIANATHEIST526

Жыл бұрын

​@@eakamjotsingh9151 propaganda.if army motive was to destroy golden temple,its a matter of day than whole building would dissapeared

@Coronavirustheinevitable

Жыл бұрын

​@@INDIANATHEIST526 if Sikh want then Ram mandir will be destroyed in 1 hour 😅😅

@INDIANATHEIST526

Жыл бұрын

@@Coronavirustheinevitable and what will happen to sikhs?

@Coronavirustheinevitable

Жыл бұрын

@@INDIANATHEIST526 like Indira we will kill modi and Amit Shah and lot of Hindus💪💪💪💪

Being a sikh it pains me wat happned at Darbar Sahib. But demanding Khalistan in itself was wrong in many ways. to start of with asking for a landlocked state b/w india nd pakistan was gonna be a diaster. We wud hav been like Afganistan. Secondly letting go Punjab wud mean letting go Kashmir. India wud never let that happen.

@harjyotsoni4019

8 жыл бұрын

bro may be u are unaware of the fact that none of the follower of Bhindrawale has ever asked for khalistan it is a rumor which was spread by the government of that time.

@ManmohanSingh-vp7zj

8 жыл бұрын

Pawan Singh, I totally agree with you. That operation still pains me, but I am totally against Khalistan. Whole of India is my Khalistan.

@ManmohanSingh-vp7zj

8 жыл бұрын

My brother very few Sikhs know that one of the Panj Piyara was from Bidar in Karnataka.One was from UP. Sikh Gurus were strengthening the core values of Indian society, culture and religion. They were for whole of India as a their own motherland. They were only against the so called Karma Kand, un-touchability and religious fraud done to the society.

@miknateeees

8 жыл бұрын

And you are saying that Sikhism has achieved that goal???? Think again. I agree with you our Gurus had clear vision but I do not think majority of Sikhs follow the teachings. They all pretend.

@ps9747

8 жыл бұрын

agreed

1.Why haven't you asked about burning the Sikh reference library? 2. The operation was over on 8th June but the pilgrims were allowed to visit Darbar sahib on 28th June what is going on for next 20 days after the completion of operation?

@ArvindKumar-xm3tl

3 жыл бұрын

Do you really think if such operation happens the pilgrims would be allowed the next day ?

@bhaskardabhi

3 жыл бұрын

Lol 1) he already said sikh soldiers were there. They never saw such thing 2) as you are pakistani your army dont follow procedures and like school noobs but india army is professional. Such kind of things go under investigation and other procedures. That’s difference between you and us

@RahulSingh-hg4ee

3 жыл бұрын

@@ArvindKumar-xm3tl They used the whole 20 days to steal priceless things

@daudmasih1557

2 жыл бұрын

Use common sense if you guys have any…you will get your answers of stupid questions

@SomeoneOfficialReal

3 ай бұрын

​​@@RahulSingh-hg4eeAnswer his Question First When Army Operation Happened who allow Pilgrims to go inside ? When Akshardham Temple Operation Happened did Government allow Pilgrims to go when Operation Happened against Terrorists ? Does it make any Sense ?

It was Pakistan's interference & weapons across the border & political masters or power seekers of punjab who waged morcha against central govt & the reluctance of the then prime Minister to fulfill those demands then state terrorism.Also injustice to a very Capable General Shubeg Singh who was a man to be reckoned with 'Liberation of Bangla Desh '.Another factor was youth unrest which all lead to political crisis turned into religious fold .It could have been averted.

@dsb8307

3 жыл бұрын

WOw. Excatly and very precisely you concluded the facts. Your are very right.

@leisureclub_

3 жыл бұрын

Pakistan's interference ??? How the hell you people come up with these type of logics... Borders are heavily guarded.. By saying that Pakistan sent weapons from borders.. are you admitting that Indian Army is doing nothing at border??? Do you know about Weapons?? It was totally due to indian RSS Establishment which will never accept you as Equal citizens ... They don't even call u Sikhs in their constitution...

@gsingh9441

3 жыл бұрын

Gober kho paji tohade dimag lyi shi aa

@deepakarya7051

3 жыл бұрын

@@gsingh9441 is that the reason of your Sharma mind ?

@arminius6506

3 жыл бұрын

Of course we Pakistanis also killed thousands of innocent Sikhs in Delhi with the support of Indian government..... Kuj sharm kr le besharma

A very well done interview on an extremely sensitive subject.

An excellent narration by Gen KS Brar, a brave man and an honest man.

@jaskarnsingh7322

9 жыл бұрын

Bilkul tuhadi taran

@gurpreetsingh-hd9yr

9 жыл бұрын

I think your mother or sister is best choice

@K_S536

9 жыл бұрын

+mallik sharma On Respect GOI: "Troops were particularly instructed not to wear any leather items in holy places and to treat all apprehended person with dignity and consideration." White Paper on the Punjab Agitation 1984 Reality: "On Saturday, medical workers in Amritsar said soldiers had threatened to shoot them if they gave food or water to Sikh pilgrims wounded in the attack and lying in the hospital." Christian Science Monitor, 8 June 1984

@K_S536

9 жыл бұрын

+mallik sharma On Women & Children GOI: “No women or children were killed in the action by troops" White Paper on the Punjab Agitation 1984 Reality: “… a team of doctors… examined 400 corpses, including 100 women and 15 to 20 children, all under five and including a two-month-old baby.” Associated Press, 13th June 1984

@K_S536

9 жыл бұрын

hacker hacker Shiv/Parvathi/ Ganesh each day pray to Sant's feet to have his kind of courage. They could have little Balls in Ball-less kaum

Sikhs got played by Pakistani ISI and unfortunately some of them are still being played by Pakistani Army. They took away Kartarpur once they got the investment back and Propoganda did not run as per their expectation. Pakistan Army wants to take a revenge of Bangladesh creation by using Sikhs. This is very sad😔

@ikkat.9472

3 жыл бұрын

Tere kk kya tu raam krna khalistan nahi chaiye kisi ko bhi parr asse kanjro ke nark main jagah chahiye jo bhagwan jarur denge

A true Sikh will always thank this man for saving Sikhs from being called Gaddars. Extremist Sikhs hail Bhindrawala as a hero...but forget that it was he who took weapons to harmandir sahib , hold the devotees as captive , killed thousands of innocents people. But they will not held him responsible , Beware of such Deshdrohis... This was the man who cleansed the temple of terrorists. For Patriot Sikhs he is the HERO , A true Sikh , who fought for his Country. For Traitors , the Terrorist Bhindrawala will remain a hero... a Talibani styled illiterate ,who wanted to split nation. SALUTE SIR!!

@bloo6199

Жыл бұрын

Take Singh out of your name

@amritsarcrockeryking

Жыл бұрын

Pehle full knowledge lo. Phir baat kro.

@amritsarcrockeryking

Жыл бұрын

Even kisi bhi court mein sant ji ke khilaaf koi compalint nai phunchi aaj tak . Supreme court ne bhi ye bol di that he is not guilty. But hamein woh toh janana hi nai.

@amritsarcrockeryking

Жыл бұрын

If aisa hi thaa ke central gov. Then Delhi trilokpuri mein woh sab kyu hua.

@anshuman1693

Ай бұрын

​@@amritsarcrockerykingSupreme Court ne kab bola ye? Jhoot kyu bol raha hai bhai?

I have read the book by the General Brar. And I have no doubts about his sincerity, loyalty and upholding his duty towards his country. Being Sikh, he along with 2 sikh battalions did what he was supposed or duty-bound to do for the safety of his nation. Don't forget Lt Gen RS Dayal also was the Sikh involved in this operation. Kudos and salute to Gen Brar. for doing his duty to the best of his abilities.

Shahbeg singh was the hero of bangladesh war. He was commanding the mukti bahni. This is what the system does to you.Its injustices turn a patriot into a blood thirsty militant. What a crying shame !!

@ishavdeepsingh6379

4 жыл бұрын

@MOHUN PUDUKODU RAGHUPATHY what was the corruption case ? Sale of a truck of army cheaply? Later that was also withdrawn. What a shame

@pineapple9644

4 жыл бұрын

yes but it is your nation when you loose patience you burn what you have earned in life even hindu loyal officers get charged with corruption charges. i salute shahbeg singh but i dont respect his decisions

@pineapple9644

4 жыл бұрын

to change the system you hv to do it diplomatically

@Luvlyfvlogs

4 жыл бұрын

General subegh singh was wrongly accused with corruption coz at some point he denied some orders from indira gandi and court marsheld him even without trial which he won case after many years .it was big time injustice with sikhs everywhere that's y this all started.

@khalistanzindabad2279

4 жыл бұрын

Mayur Panghaal saleyo thodi bahart lai koi ladey ta true patriot of same persons dies for their own religion then terrorist saleyo sharam karo kush moot peeni kaum

Huge props to the interviewer as he was so cool, calm and collected through out the interview. A thorough Gentlemen 🙏👏👏👏

@harpreetkaur5022

3 жыл бұрын

Gentlemen my foot thu thu

@harshita7658

3 жыл бұрын

@@harpreetkaur5022 He is talking about Sikh gentleman not about KS brar.... Interviewer is indeed a gentleman 👍👍👍

Mr. K S Brar is man of great caliber. He had done his duty with level of highest standards keeping the importance of holy place. We salute to the great leading officer. You had put you and your family life in a risk for the rest of the life.

This is how an interview should be. Two learned people talking calmly and not trying to put words in each other's mouth

@gd5762

3 жыл бұрын

Brar was a snake but his salary controlled his morals and actions

@adityaganjoomech

3 жыл бұрын

@@gd5762 I dont think so. Indian Army does what the government elected by people of India tells her to do. Army cannot refuse the commands of a democratically elected government

@731-akashdeepsyan8

3 жыл бұрын

Aditya Ganjoo use your brain first

@adityaganjoomech

3 жыл бұрын

@@731-akashdeepsyan8 what part of my statement do you find brainless? Now dont state the whole statement. That would make ni sense

@utdpb

3 жыл бұрын

@@adityaganjoomech every indian democratically elected government is a sheep. India have majorities and minorties.the sheep knows which majority they need to butter. and when did sheeps started advicing lions to kill other lions? only lions of circus can do that.

What a soldier, my deepest respects to you General, I wish we could teach our kids about you and would have more even 10% of what you are. What a wonderful religion Shri Guru Gobind Singh Ji made, you have not an iota of doubt as to what was right and what was wrong for you. You chose the most difficult path but the right path, how easy would it have been for you to have refused to do it, the Army would have definitely found many. I don’t know what history we monkeys will write your name in and as what but definitely you will find the highest place in heaven for doing your Dharma of a Soldier so beautifully. 😊🙏🙏

@manoharpanesar1497

3 жыл бұрын

So true

@harkarannirman4281

3 жыл бұрын

He is a gadaar a traitor for sikh religion and community you are hindu go study your religion we will see ours

@manoharpanesar1497

3 жыл бұрын

@@harkarannirman4281 not easy to do ones duty. What do you have to say about persons bringing arms into Harmandir Sahib in the first place. How can this be justified. How can taking pilgrims hostage in the temple be justified.

@harkarannirman4281

3 жыл бұрын

@@manoharpanesar1497 you know without arms or weapons sikh religion is nothing our 10th guru says if you dont have hair and weapon you are not real sikh second thing they weren’t in temple they were in parikramas and akal takht why did army shootes golden temple? Come on man first get to know about history properly

@harkarannirman4281

3 жыл бұрын

@@manoharpanesar1497 sant bhindrawale was arrested in 1982 you know that ? If they need to arrest him so badly why didn’t they keep him in jail that time ? Sant bhindrawale was only in akal takht why were 54 other guruduwaras ruinded ? He wasn’t there in delhi November 1984 ? He wasn’t there in 1955 when golden temple was attacked that time too

Lt. Gen. KS Brar in this interview has made it so crystal clear for those who judge him blindly to open their doors of knowledge and broaden their perspective of the Operation Blue Star. Thankful to this platform for providing a piece of concrete and unfiltered information.

@vicksidhu616

2 жыл бұрын

so nobody at all finds it strange that the Indian army decided to attack the Golden Temple on the anniversary of the martyrdom of Guru Arjan Dev Ji, the guru who completed the construction of the golden temple, making it one of the most visited times of the year. please don't be naive and give into silly propaganda...the question is asked at 36:45 in this video and the "general" has no answers. pathetic.

Mr. Brar is the Royal and brave son of India, we salute u sir. Jai hind.

Bharat Mata has such a great sons who are ready to sacrifice their lives. Jai Hind 🌹 Gen Brar son of India. 🌹❤️

comments dekh ke aisa lgta h divide and rule aj bi utna hi successful h ..

@71samrath

3 жыл бұрын

Sadly true

@wt3522

3 жыл бұрын

Good

@HarpreetSingh-jh8vr

3 жыл бұрын

just wait and watch Bharat maata Randi hone wali hai,

@wt3522

3 жыл бұрын

@@HarpreetSingh-jh8vr Inshaa’Allah

I believe him when he says that operation BlueStar was not his choice and wished it should never have happened. I would not blame him for that. Political responsibility lied with the Govt and country's leadership.

@nsawaan

10 жыл бұрын

***** what abt militants inside GT. ?

@mail2gopala

10 жыл бұрын

@saivanguru5327

10 жыл бұрын

***** He is Indian solder.

@rozbey2504

7 жыл бұрын

The Richard Nixon administration in the US had initiated a "covert action plan" in collusion with General Yahya Khan's government in Pakistan in 1971 to encourage a separatist movement in Punjab, This plan envisaged the encouragement of a separatist movement among the Sikhs for an independent state to be called Khalistan. In 1971, one saw the beginning of a joint covert operation by the US intelligence community and Pakistan's Inter Services Intelligence to create difficulties for India in Punjab. The then Pakistani military ruler Yahya Khan invited Jagjit Singh Chauhan to Pakistan, "lionised" him as a leader of Sikhs and handed over some Sikh holy relics kept in Pakistan, which Chauhan took to the UK to win a following in the Sikh diaspora. "With American and Pakistani encouragement, the activities of Chauhan continued till 1977.

@guruword8378

7 жыл бұрын

yes he could have said no but he didnt and yes it was leadership fault

This interview should be broadcasted on national and international media so that people can know the reality

@jojames6621

Жыл бұрын

but how you know he's speaking truth?

@HARRY-xz1hf

Жыл бұрын

@@jojames6621 well you can't put him on lie detector now can you. If his words match with the events then what he said could very well be true.

@jojames6621

Жыл бұрын

@@HARRY-xz1hf he said in one interview he never went to the golden temple as a kid while growing up. In another interview three years later he said I dd go to golden temple while growing up. Which one is it?? He clearly is lying.

@jetpark3743

Жыл бұрын

@@jojames6621 what truth do you want?

@InderjitSingh-ug4bq

Жыл бұрын

@@jetpark3743they killed innocent people and he is thinking he was capable reality they chose him because his last name singh he was not Sikh he doesn’t believe any religious

My first favourite North Indian Punjabi/ Hindi and English channel. It was a shock to see it going closed.

Since at that time no one dares to go near the periphery of golden temple .How he made announcements.

@sudeshnugyal2369

4 жыл бұрын

They are made by loud halers dufer

@davindergillgill4490

4 жыл бұрын

Es da koi mahapaap kita se peshle janm da dushman se ke brar sikh koum da koi gal nai karne bharni o wahe guru jane

... true soldier who did his duty n can be inspiration for all of us...Wish everyone one of us keep country before our religions....

@jkcivilservices4599

5 жыл бұрын

Keeping country before ur religion makes ur religion on 2ns preiorty so if u r a Muslim then u must have to change ur mentality... Plz

@xelsysadm

5 жыл бұрын

@@jkcivilservices4599 religion is to cater people ....god is because of people than otherwise

@jkcivilservices4599

5 жыл бұрын

@@xelsysadm ALLAHA is not bcz of people but we people are bcz of ALLAHA... still i don't know ur religion so dont know about ur god...

@jkcivilservices4599

5 жыл бұрын

@@shibayanbiswas4058 kyu bai ghay ka moot peenai walai... Such sun kai jalee kya...

@avinashkoli5021

4 жыл бұрын

@@jkcivilservices4599 religion is to lead a meaningful and guided life not to behead people and killing them...

Loved the interview. General Brar is an extremely honourable and clear minded soldier. The interviewer also did a good job by asking questions that bust the untrue stories floating around the net. Hope this interview brings some clarity of the events and closure to fellow countrymen

At 23:00, interviewer asks “ was any effort made to reach out to the people inside to leave peacefully?” Gen Brar fumbles for a few seconds and responds: we asked the Intelligence to do so and they told that their efforts didn’t work out.” In other words, we have no clear record of those efforts. If we put it in perspective to Gen Sinha’s interview in the same series where he refers to answers from the Defence Minister, “it’s all politics”, we can extract a more judicious understanding of what was going on in the country at that time under the pretext of maintaining law and order. More than a decade ago, I had interviewed a senior officer from Intelligence posted in Punjab during this time and his words still resonate with me, “terrorism was created”. Whatever happened was deplorable; the merciless killings and a state of lawlessness for decades to come. Even today, Punjab has lacks a sophisticated educational infrastructure (IITs & IIMs) and youth is being pushed to unemployment and drugs. Regardless of whichever religion, community or state is impacted, our country should not be a playground for politicians. Period.

@imajm123

Жыл бұрын

Do you really think it would have helped to send a message of peace to terrorist that had fortified the harimadir sahib? We all knew terrorist have been living in Akal takht for years yet no outrage was expressed by Sikh people or leader that they r wrong. I wonder all those that blame Brar or Army ever felt bothered by disrespect by terrorist using mandir for their political gains

@japharirk

Жыл бұрын

@@imajm123 were you sitting there inside the temple too? Why govt banned international media and human rights organizations to cover the attack? Till today, there is no record in home ministry documents or Punjab govt documents against Bhindranwale. Why ???

This is the reason why I want to join Indian Army. Think about it, a person, a sikh person who knows that this operation will bring him criticism from his own community. But still he does his duty. Isn't he a true sikh by his nature. Militants on the other hand, bringing guns and putting themselves above Akal Takht. And we support the militants. If congress did something wrong, how is Lt. Gen Brar responsible for that? Think people. Don't follow someone bindly, bcz 1000 others are following him. Sati was followed by Indians from 1000s of years till the day William Bentick intervened and naturally faced criticism. And now is Sati right???? Think and judge. Dont judge and then think....

@ujjainimukherjee2267

5 жыл бұрын

Wonderfully described, i am a hindu but still i felt so bad about the operation blue star and all its repercussions. I still feel things could have handled differently. So many innocent lives were lost due to it.

@ApSinghGaming

5 жыл бұрын

Wrong thinking... humanity comes before all duties... God gave intellect to humans not to kill other humans and not to follow any idiots orders before self judgement.

@singhgammer5280

5 жыл бұрын

So u can destroy holy shrines

@akikullie

5 жыл бұрын

I’m not even going to dignify this idiots ideology with a comment.

A soldier caught by the Karma,In Mahabharta the armies of Lord Krishna faught against Pandava and the lord himself who was against the Kauravas. This entire episode was unfortunate and more efforts should have been made to avert it.

@kulbhushanraimadan1707

3 жыл бұрын

Rightly said.

@raunaksinha4439

3 жыл бұрын

indira gandhi responsible for all that mess

@bpawar2556

3 жыл бұрын

HINDU name behind this.

@anant14

3 жыл бұрын

@@raunaksinha4439 , It is a very complex problem (Hindu-Sikh relationship + Punjab peace and stability). Let us also kid ourselves that issue is resolved..... At least now let us keep the peace and not generate fresh conflict......

@wt3522

3 жыл бұрын

@@anant14 Khalistan Bane Ga

Communication very sharp and to the point. Gentlemen

What a great interview.... D anchor is so retrained .... Love and respect for Gen Brar .... Probably d best anchor that i have seen...,

I had some sympathy for Khalistanis,, because I thought Blue star was wrong but now I m against bloody Khalistanis after listen Brar

@simonjeetsingh1211

6 жыл бұрын

David Wood he had lied in interview

@simonjeetsingh1211

6 жыл бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/c2eIuJOcktvRj5c.html see this video many like it on KZread

@kaler4637

6 жыл бұрын

David wood listen to gen rk sinha fare and square

@MsSandhu9

5 жыл бұрын

I am a Sikh who grew up during Punjab insurgency. The reason behind Blue Star was not bad. There were terrorists hiding inside the holy place, who had fortified it with latest deadly weapons, and they would kill hundreds of innocent civilians and then go hide in Golden Temple, capitalizing on the fact that the armed police was not allowed to enter to fight them (some hypocrite Sikhs criticize the army for entering with weapons but not the terrorists themselves who had ALREADY desecrated the holy place). So, an operation was definitely needed. But the operation was executed poorly, either due to confusion, misinformation or paranoia and many wrong decisions were taken. One big wrong decision was the day chosen for execution. But it's easy to say it now that they were wrong decisions. At that time, they probably did what they thought was best based on whatever information they had. Anyway, looking back now, a siege-operation would have been better in this case, blocking all food supplies, even though it would taken many more days. But then again, the army was worried that they would be attacked by hordes of outraged Sikhs from Punjab's villages and not only put army's own lives in danger but also the operation would effectively fail.

@MsSandhu9

5 жыл бұрын

@@simonjeetsingh1211 I am a Sikh who grew up during Punjab insurgency. General Brar is not lying at all. He is being totally honest. You have to keep in mind that he is telling about the situation AS THEY PERCEIVED IT at that time. Army cannot know the situation a 100% accurately. Sometimes they take decisions based on intelligent speculation. So some of the decisions can be based on wrong information/speculation. It's easy to criticize wrong decisions later when situation becomes more clear. But the fact is that the army has to act based on whatever information they have at that time.

It's really really sad, feeling to cry, I wish it had never had happened this has created hate between Hindus n Sikhs the blood brothers. For Hindus Sikhism is as sacred as for Sikhs lakhs of Hindus visit sacred golden temple. Hindus and Sikhs are still living happily together but somwhere there is a crack. There is no fault of Hindus it was all about politics. I wish somehow it was avoided Really really sad.

@jannat674

5 жыл бұрын

Exactly

@amank.7052

4 жыл бұрын

The Indian government will not allow any minority to live peacefully. That is what history has shown several over several times. It's about time the people of India realized what the agenda of the government is. When you choose a PM who doesn't even have a grade 10 education, how do you expect him to run a country? Oh wait, it's not the PM or the government that runs the country, its the RSS. An organization which idolizes Hitler and the Neo Nazi Nation. Do you know what that means for minorities? Ask Dr. Ambedkar. He knew everything but your government did not listen to him.

@RaviSharma-jq1bi

4 жыл бұрын

Aman K. You are a pakistani

@mksharma1464

4 жыл бұрын

@@amank.7052 What are ur sources for declaring education of PM? He has completed MA from polity by distance learning, election affidavit has proof, politics is game of statesmanship not education , jo kam napoleon nai kiye wo newton nahi kar sakta, Modi has overthrown khalifate of kashmir, resurrected hinduism in ayodhya, made the temples on land of arabs, UAE and saudi Arabia, rural electrification, ayushmaan scheme

@amank.7052

4 жыл бұрын

@@RaviSharma-jq1bi Really? Wow, can you please tell me what a Pakistani is?

Whenever this tragic massacre of 1984 is remembered, the wounds of the mind are refreshed and even today, 38 years later, it is very sad to admit that our holy place of worship had been bombed by the army of 'our own' country and turned into rubble. This incident filled the mind with a sense of alienation which is still alive But aftee 38 years ,going through introspection one can conclude that blaming only KS Brar is not perhaps justified because he is being blamed for it only by those who are either naive or those who were themselves guilty but to divert attention from them, all the blame was laid on K .S. Brar who was actually bound to do his duty as a soldier. Indira Gandhi, her kitchen cabinet, some fanatical Hindus and Sikhs, the Akali leadership - mainly Parkash Singh, Badal, Gurchan Singh Tohra, Balwant Singh Ramuwalia,Surjit Singh Barnala,Balwant Singh etc etc were responsible for this massacre. They are prime accused. Bhindrawala,who was once a religious leader, fell prey to these cunning foxes and could not understand the dirty politics of these shrewd foxes. This tragic incident wounded the psyche of the Sikh community and sense of alienation prevailed forever.

@imajm123

Жыл бұрын

You made good points but u are discounting the fact that Bhindranwala n his armed men should not have used n fortified the Golden temple. Soldier KS Brar did his duty n still became black listed in Sikh history n not to mention a marked man for rest of his life.

@P.Babrah58

Жыл бұрын

@@imajm123 -- You're right to great extent. Bhinderawala shouldn't have used Golden Temple as his den. That monster was created by Congress to counter Akali Dal in Punjab as Indra Gandhi wanted to win 1985 elections at every cost. But Bhinderawala proved like a gene out of bottle. When he was gathering ammunition and arsenal in Darbar Sahib,why didn't any security agencies prevent him. Why and how ammunition was allowed to carry to Darbar Sahib by hiding in trucks. Where was the Police,CRPF and BSF ? Actually Indra Gandhi wanted to teach lesson to Akali Dal but eventually she did it with the Sikhs. Perhaps it was the first time in the history of mankind when army of any country invaded the shrine of it's own citizens,own community, no matter who was at fault. Bhinderawala could be very easily expelled from shrine ....exactly likewise it was done 2 years later thru Operation Black Thunder when few terrorists were forced to exit by raising their hands. Similar approach could be adopted as in case of Bhinderawala. Unfortunately, Indra Gandhi had to pay the price by losing her life. Consequently 25000 Sikhs were massacred in India....many of them burnt alive by putting burning tyres into their necks. A special kind of explosive chemical was made available to killers to burn alive the Sikhs. It was ironical that Rajiv Gandhi said immediately after he took over as Prime Minister of India that... Some earth shudders when a big tree falls. "जब कोई बड़ा पेड़ गिरता है तो थोड़ी बहुत धरती हिलती ही है"। 38 years have gone by but these bitter words still haunts me...haunts Sikhs. This whole act of Barbarism emotionally and mentally alienated the Sikhs forever. PS: Read the book-- AMRITSAR:LAST BATTLE OF MRS.INDRA GANDHI--- written by Mark Tully- former correspondent of BBC and Satish Jacob jointly. May be pdf is available.

@9434530481

Жыл бұрын

Bhindrawale was not only a saint he was a saint turned later turned terrorist.... their was no option left bt to carry out this operation...salute and kudos to general brar and indian army

Good interview and bringing the reality. My country first and my faith comes after. We are proud of Gen Brar and clarified many things hope people let him live his civilian life like anybody else.

@sandhujatt3886

3 жыл бұрын

Country 😂 rapistan 😂😂

@lucifermorningstar7723

3 жыл бұрын

Now i have no hope in this country. They distroyed our punjab completely . Firstly pakistan then haryana and himachal lastly our culture . They never done justice with punjab and sikhs.

@anshuman1693

2 жыл бұрын

@@sandhujatt3886 Pakistan ja chootiye

@vicksidhu616

2 жыл бұрын

so nobody at all finds it strange that the Indian army decided to attack the Golden Temple on the anniversary of the martyrdom of Guru Arjan Dev Ji, the guru who completed the construction of the golden temple, making it one of the most visited times of the year. please don't be naive and give into silly propaganda...the question is asked at 36:45 in this video and the "general" has no answers. pathetic.

@hamidakarm5363

2 жыл бұрын

On 03/06 at 7am soldiers had carried out an emergency across punjab. All telephone lines throughout Punjab are disconnected. The soldiers started the attack and fired. !! On 05/06/1984 heavy weapons and tanks started to be used because they failed to get inside even though it had been 2 days since the attack. !!!

I feel we are all too small to judge the operation blue star. It is the darkest chapter in the Sikh History. Either one can be in favor of the operation or one can oppose it. I am the one who oppose it for my own reasons. I just wish this never happened. :(

@MsSandhu9

5 жыл бұрын

For it to not have happened, it was important that Bhindrawala and his men should not have used it as a convenient hiding place. His men would kill innocents and then go take refuge in Golden Temple. Bhindrawala and his men were misusing and exploiting Sikh sentiments to achieve their own selfish, fundamentalist and hateful goals. Their modus operandi and thinking was not much different from the Taliban! I am a Sikh myself but I call them the Sikh-Taliban. It's hypocritical for some Sikhs to object to the entry of the armed forces into the holy premises, while being okay with (or at least tolerant of) armed-terrorists residing inside. It's not the army that desecrated the holy place. Bhindrawala and his men ALREADY did that when they would hide there with their AK-47s after killing innocents, many of who were dragged out from buses and killed just because they were Hindus.

@amritpalsingh3293

5 жыл бұрын

@@MsSandhu9 Fully Agree

@maanewalia

4 жыл бұрын

Ms Sandhu Can you please explain more about the selfish, fundamentalist and hateful goals of Sant Bhindranwale??? FYI carrying a weapon is must for a Amritdhari Sikh. No FIR had been registered against Sant Bhindranwale till date as disclosed by an RTI in 2018, so on what basis you are putting this hateful thing against him or you are just another government tool???

@timwatson6603

4 жыл бұрын

@@MsSandhu9 what are you on about he was a saint soldier

@MsSandhu9

4 жыл бұрын

​@@maanewalia A few points 1) A government tool? I grew up in Punjab (during the Punjab insurgency FYI) but have been living in the US since many years. I have absolutely nothing to do with Indian government, who I criticize on many aspects, especially on the point that they did not bring the perpetrators of 1984 anti-Sikh pogrom to justice. This will FOREVER be a kala daag on Indian government. 2) Carrying a kirpan is a must for Amritdhari Sikh, not mass-killing machine guns & AK 47s. This aspect of Sikhi is recognized & respected by even the Indian government, which is the ONLY government in the entire world which allows Sikhs to carry kirpans in certain high security restricted places where NO OTHER weapon is allowed by anyone else. The only exception is made for Amritdhari Sikhs. 3) I do not agree with the way Indira Gandhi's administration carried out Operation Blue Star. I think instead of an all-out attack by the army, they should have adopted the strategy of "siege and wait" (surround the premises, cut off their food supply etc, then enter in a few days after they are already weakened). That would have minimized the casualties. Indira Gandhi acted in her typical undemocratic, dictatorial & rash way in dealing with terrorists hiding in Harmandir Sahib. But to say, that nothing should have been done is not only idiotic but INHUMAN to the nth degree. You expected that Bhindrawala should have been allowed to carry on his terror campaign just because he was doing it in the garb of religion? So, Indira's mistake was not that she took action but rather she took action in the wrong way. 4) As per the original Khalsa panth, the kirpan is NEVER to be used on unarmed, innocent common people. Guru Gobind Singh fought against tyrannical Mughals and their ARMED FORCES who were forcefully converting Hindus/Sikhs to Islam but never targeted common Muslims. Bhindrawala ordered killings of innocent men & women from the sacred premises, many times just because they opposed his violent ideology & methods. Many times even total innocents were killed during terror attacks (I still remember how innocent Hindu travelers were pulled out from Punjab roadways buses and brutally killed just because they were Hindus). Bhindrawala and his men acted more like mafia dons rather than true believers of an ideology. 5) You can deny all you want. But I grew up during those times and have seen things with my own eyes. That is primarily the reason why the Khalistani cause lost all its support among Sikh population which ACTUALLY lives in Punjab (Sikhs living abroad do not know the ground realities). The Sikhs in Punjab had already tasted what Khalistan would look like - the most appropriate term would be "Sikh Talibanistan".

Once he was exercising parachute jumps with his soldiers ... His parachute didn't open and he landed on my uncle's parachute in mid air ... Both survived astonishingly .... If he died during training ... He might have not done Operation Blue star, but, some another General could have done this ... History might continue to happen even if he died along side my uncle in training ...

@pineapple9644

4 жыл бұрын

@@amank.7052 he is not responsible you are the problem bro

@amank.7052

4 жыл бұрын

@@pineapple9644 sure thanks

@moreovernostalgia214

4 жыл бұрын

SHUBHAM yes we are the problem, that’s whey they tried to wipe us physically,historically ,psychologically 👍.i feel pity on your statement. If you don’t know that fact and circumstances under what the event occurred.

@moreovernostalgia214

3 жыл бұрын

@@jaidadwal9762 lol brother sikhs were always religious fanatics (not like muslims and The people who shout hindutva) that’s how we survived when there were costs on our heads and it was state terrorism back then, we never wanted devision of country , nor in 47.

@rajuchacha132

3 жыл бұрын

@@moreovernostalgia214 ..brother I just can't understand why the militants choose ha rmandir sahab while they can choose any other place ....its really sad they choose a holy place ..didn't they know army will attack

I cannot stand to listen to this interview. Seeing his face and remembering the images from videos shown by bbc is very hurting. Our Golden Temple and Akaal Takht was badly demolished. Innocent Sikhs inside Gurdwaras brutally killed. I can remember the image of the large tank demolishing walls of building. This massacre will always be in my mind and never forgotten. One day, Waheguru will give us justice.

@prashanthrao8649

3 жыл бұрын

Were you there at that time when operation blue star took place ?

@sharankaur798

3 жыл бұрын

You don't have to be there to be sympathetic. All the news especially BBC channel showing live footage from that time from the Golden temple and tanks passing from side of Akaal Takht . This black and white footage was shown on this channel in 2014. Due to the 30th anniversary on the attack on ' The Golden Temple' .

@shankergoyal707

3 жыл бұрын

@@sharankaur798 u should read a book name Last battle of Indira Gandhi by Mark Tully bbc editor and report during 1984...and clear your fact...if u watched complete interview then u should know why army used tank... But mainu lgda blue star operation hon toh rok sakde c...kyunki intelligence nu khabar kafi pehlan aah rahi c dudh dhol vich Ak47 harmandir saheeb ja rahiyan ne.....but at that they did not take any action.

@nirmalsingh6364

3 жыл бұрын

If a group of heavily armed people occupy a religious temple, the government has to act.

@Mayank_7766

3 жыл бұрын

Theek hai , te jo ena asla 47, rocket launcher RPG aa sab dhrm de na te terrorism chlda pya holy shrine vich oh theek si,

They were both right at their own places, it is the policians and politics which lead to all of this

@RahulSharma-bq8bk

2 жыл бұрын

Right....Gen Subeg Singh g ko..bina mtlb dismiss

@DM-ui1oy

Жыл бұрын

Bhindranwale was a filthy terrorist

@lovepreet301

Жыл бұрын

@@DM-ui1oy can't blame you, you have been fed what exactly the whole india has been fed, you probably aren't smart enough to research and dig out the reality

@DM-ui1oy

Жыл бұрын

Bhindranwale was a illiterate hoodlum, terrorist. Khalistani terrorists killed 20.000 Sikhs in the years 1987 to 1992

@lovepreet301

Жыл бұрын

@@DM-ui1oy no need to debate with a person who knows nothing about history and believe only rumors

I like the interviewer; he's professional and gentle.

@kshitijvengurlekar4412

6 жыл бұрын

MsUa125 True. I completely agree with. Respect for the interviewer

@NeelamSharma-vl1il

6 жыл бұрын

Yes he was good but sometime he was repeating question unnecessary in such a way that he wanted to show Mr. Brar guilty and responsible....for a example when he was arising question about killing people with their hands tied behind but Mr. Brar never wrote anything like this in his book & he repeated nothing like this happened....also Punjabi captions running under interview were not translated 100% according the interview....one caption said he was not very religious because he didn't get chance to be religious but MR. Brar said he was religious and believed in God but he was not practising religion all day long.... I am glad we have people like Brar in this world who see things as they are not dipped in the religion.

@kuljitsidhu3751

6 жыл бұрын

MsUa125 yes me to

mr Harry saini, this operation blue star is not home affair of sikhs because We punjabis in general and Hindus in particular were affected by day to day deeds of bhindrawala. you don't know that about 50000 innocent lives both of sikhs and hindus were lost in Punjab because of him.we lost our relatives who were sitting in their shops in taran taran and many other known people ,perhaps u were not born at that time.Regarding your views about chhatrapati Shivaji. U call him rat or lion it is upto U but he is the contemporary of Guru gobind singh.He killed Afzal khan of bijapur, he killed the son of shaista khan the mama of auranzeb,and made shaista khan run from marathaland with 5 lakh army. he fought 250 battles in his short life and won all.raja jai singh persuaded him to meet aurangjeb but aurangjeb imprisoned him in Agra. But who can imprison the maratha lion. With the wisdom and deeds he went free and revenged appropriately by winning all forts again.even after shivaji,The Maratha empire ruled indirectly almost whole of india.Can U fairly call such a person rat. Pl read about him and u will be enlightenede. so try to widen you horizon and try to appreciate an indian hero. don't follow the language of muslims to call him rat. Let us be proud of being indian.a good is good and a bad is bad. god bless u .

@dukezango

5 жыл бұрын

Mr sharma ur love ones are killed by congress propaganda their black cats

@dukezango

5 жыл бұрын

Chatrapati shivaji is not holding northern india it was us giving our bloods for hindusim who are betrayers

Don't blame the Armymen who were carrying out orders . Armymen put their life on line to get things done . Things which a normal civilian/bureaucrats cannot do.

@sukhjindergill4345

3 жыл бұрын

Armed forces are slaves from brain and mind obeying any order by political system

@satvindermudan5006

3 жыл бұрын

It is the job of a professional soldier to carry out the instructions of his commanders, in this case the Indian government. If his conscience does not allow him to comply then the only honourable action would be to take off his uniform. He cannot be held accountable for the political decision. His accountability rests with the strategy, method, execution, quality and outcomes of the military action. I cannot glean from the interview whether the General himself (rtd) thinks that he did a good job or not. The metric for this needs to be high as india at that time had a large army and access to advice and support from friendly countries. So not a fledgling banana republic with a few guns that might or might not work. For example, The story about the lights on the tanks fusing is just laughable and i am reminded of the axiom -poor planning leads to piss poor performance. His excuse seems to be that he didn’t have enough time. I did not think that was a worthy excuse for a general to make and this alone reduces his credibility as a professional. I cannot believe that they don’t have contingencies in place for such an event. The interviewer should have pressed harder on how the operation was viewed post hoc within the Indian army and by experts from other military forces. At that time I believe the British and the Israelis were helping on this and it would be very interesting to see what their counterinsurgency units thought of it and of the General.

@user-gw9yd1sj7p

3 жыл бұрын

@@karans1269 army vaale pagal nhi hote vo to sirf govt ka order follow krte Hain Jai Hind 🇮🇳♥️💪 Indian army ♥️

@tarsem344

3 жыл бұрын

@@satvindermudan5006 If you were a soldier who who was given a command by your government that led to the oppression or death of your own family or innocents, I'm willing to bet you would grow a clear conscience in a heart beat. You may very well be correct in stating that it is the soldier's duty to carry out the command of their respective authority, it is essentially the job they signed up for. But I would not be so willing to diminish a soldier's reputation and being to a meer pawn and cog in the machine. They are still human, still able to make decisions for themselves in what is clearly right and wrong. In the case of 1984, brar and those soldiers had every chance to give indra the proverbial middle finger and deny her goal in this ethnic cleansing of Sikh history and its people. Wether or not he performed his duties "efficiently" as a general is really missing the mark and strays away from the truly devestating impact his actions had on the lives of thousands of innocents.

@satvindermudan5006

3 жыл бұрын

@@tarsem344 what i might do or not in that position is not the subject of the discussion and nor should it be in an open forum such as this and so you should not be taking bets on what i might do or indeed anyone else in this forum. But, to address your points. 1 it is the legal duty of a soldier to carry out the instructions of his superiors and this is an unalterable principle on which chain of command in the armed forces functions. Nor should we seek to subvert this. Imagine an army where each individual member can decide whether to comply with a lawful order or not. An army is not a democratic institution where we take a vote on actions and the majority carry the day. 2 In a system of government (anything other than a military dictatorship) it is the obligation of the armed forces to carry out the instructions of the civilian government. India is a representative democracy and the government of the day was fairly and appropriately elected by democratic process etc and so there is no reason to suppose that the government was somehow improper. Nor, is there any reason to suppose that the instructions from the government, as outlined by the General, are anything but lawful instructions. Therefore, the army must comply. 3 To suggest that the individual army member should deliberately disobey the government and carry out some other actions of their own making (whist wearing the uniform) and thus challenging the civilian command is also know as a subversion or a coup. I would think and hope that you don't think that is a good idea. 4 There is no reason to suppose that members of the armed forces are not intelligent enough to be anything more than cogs in a machine and one would certainly hope that a 3-star general would be well above being a cog in the machine. I think this is a very important point, that he is not a mere cog in the machine but a highly decorated soldier with skills, a great deal of training, experience and on whom a huge amount of money has been spent. Furthermore, I would like to make it quite clear that i did not state or even imply such a notion. On the contrary, i make it apparent that any signed-up member of the armed forces and even more so the upper echelons of the institution, faced with a moral dilemma where the task in hand conflicts with his beliefs should be free and without reprisal to do the honorable thing and that is to resign his post or command, what you cannot do as a public service professional (of any profession) is pick and choose which jobs you want to do and which not. It may well be that, if he had felt conflicted, Brar may have thought of this. Indeed, such an action tantamount to offering up ones head for ones beliefs would be in the truest tradition of a sikh and relatable to the modern world. I would like to think we have come beyond the days where we think it is a good idea to set oneself on fire to make a point. Indeed, this would have been a good question to ask, the thoughts of the man upon being given the instructions rather than what the interviewer gives us which is a mere iteration of the chronology of events. I don't speak for him but maybe he did have these thoughts and no doubt knew that were he to resign or recuse himself from the order he would be replaced in an instant and by whom we don't know. All this would have been good interview material. accomplished his mission without a single death, what would his epitaph be then.

An Army Officer. 1. He is to execute the order from top. 2. He did the job to cleanse the evils from that sacred Place 3. Those criticising him is not understanding what would have the situation in North India if Khalistan had created Absolute Riots, mass Murder just like 1947 Partition, which Pakistan wanted to happen. 4. Though some Hardened Sikhs believe otherwise, Most Sikhs in india understand that they are part and parcel of a large country 5. The Canadian & British Sikhs are the orchestrators under the Behest of Pakistan & British funding trying to keep Separtist Movement.

I request all the sikhs never to allow politics to happen in Golden temple.. This is a temple of peace and a unique one.. We all need that temple to remain as a symbol of peace...We all respect our Guru Gobinbsinghji...

@teeman3440

5 жыл бұрын

the righteous will always stand with you

@JaspreetSinghArtist

5 жыл бұрын

lol you don't understand anything about Sikhi . Darbar sahib is for spirituality but Akal Takath is for politics . attack was done by Indian state because they wanted to kill Sikh school of thought . it was done before by mugals too . who ever come into power they tried to attack on Darbar sahib and Akal takath because its represent independence of Sikhs .

@Barwal7

4 жыл бұрын

@@JaspreetSinghArtist Can you cite a credible source, literary or otherwise, which can shed light on : "they wanted to kill Sikh school of thought?" And most importantly, who is "they"? "Independence of Sikhs" is a dangerous term to use because nobody in the entire history tried to destroy Punjab other than Mughals and British (include their Indian stooges also). I'm from Kangra and the great raja Sansar Chand of Kangra sought help of Maharaja Ranjit singh ji to drive away mullahs, which he accepted gladly (with terms of course). But there are tales of the bonhomie and mutual respect they both enjoyed. Sikh school of thought draws it basics from Sanatan Vedic knowledge, Ek Omkaar Satnaam (Om is the real truth), Seva (serve Ishwar which resides in all of life), don't fall in to unnecessary rituals, no need for mutipuja, importance of Guru to achieve spiritualism,etc. I'm of the opinion that Gurunanak Dev Ji was so much pained by the loss of dharmic values in people that he had to ask them to revisit true dharma. In Babur Baani, he vividly describes the loss of values among people, misrule of kings, ignoring the needy and increasing lust for materialistic things. That is why he says, Babur invasion was act of Rabb, it was inevitable. Karam bore the fruit. I listen to Gurbaani a lot on morning radio and find it more meaningful than Jai MataDi type bhajans, simply because it mentions the true Bharat right from Shri Raam. So when I hear Sikhs mention with a thump of chest that they are not Hindu, it is both funny and extremly sad at the same time. There is no doubt in my mind that majority of what happenned in 84 is completely hidden from general people. But when JSB started distancing himself from this soil and its cultural values of which Sikh is a part, I presume that the Communist separatism had gotten to him. 2/3rd of Punjab went to Pakistan, then why not start Khalistan from there? (-istan word itself makes it clear the involvement of Pakistani ISI). Attacking Harmandar Sahib Ji is a crime but then isn't destroying its sanctity by amassaing war stores inside the shrine a crime too?

@sumitsingh7835

4 жыл бұрын

@@JaspreetSinghArtist Hijacking Akal Takht by those who were carrying grenades , AK 47 and not to meantion they didn't let the Pilgrims out of the temple . And you have the nerve to call them sikhs and Bhinderanwala a Saint ??

@maanewalia

4 жыл бұрын

Sumit Singh Sant Bhindranwale was a Saint and Indra Gandhi was a bitch and I meant it. You know people like you will go all out to show your support for Che Guevara or revolutionaries from other countries and talk big things but are nowhere to be seen when a Saint Soldier took things in his own hands against your beloved government. What do you know about Sant Bhindranwale??? Get a life and stay away from things you don’t know much about!!!

dear kanwar sandhu ji please try to find jasbir singh raina and other soldiers who participated in the operation and interview them

Gen. Brar is a patriot par excellence, just as he was a star army commander and was picked to lead operation Bluestar

Best questions that will always have it ground to prove politics and army action illicit that the action taken could be done before or after 5 Jan. Why such a crowded and religious day was chosen, When govt was already planning from last 6 months. It was not about just Sant ji, it was way to send a message to whole religion and show them down. But legacy was maintained by blessings of Guru Sahib Ji. And no govt in future can think of such act again ever. The consequences of it were far more than imagined.

@wink8916

2 жыл бұрын

Sant ji🤣🤣🤣... Sala Gunda Indra da tatta

@rishavgautam7286

2 жыл бұрын

A militant who seized akal takht which no one has entered or lived not even the Guru's ri8 upon the Guru granth sahib and reinforcing with ammunition and weapons is a saint for you.

@Life-ld9ko

Жыл бұрын

This is the decline in sikhi! When you call a terrorist and an imposter a saint!! Pathetic!

army did their duty.......also sant bhindranwale was right at his place....punjab deserves anandpur sahib resolution ...it was all politics...sant ji was used by the filthy akalis and congress also...and alot of innocent blood was shed

Well General Brar has no answer that why timing of the operation was not delayed ? If they have plan to restrict their casualties then why it was planned for pilgrims. ..so this puts a huge question mark on Government motive. ?

@johnyrayz

5 жыл бұрын

He already said the Bhindranwala's goons won't let people come out... They were held as an insurance policy of millitants...

@teamgreenindia9512

3 жыл бұрын

as though u know. Dont comment if u dont know the person, subject or event as a direct witness.

@bharatmakhija9963

2 жыл бұрын

There cannot be justification for a religious place be held as a fortress.

@jsbedi60

2 жыл бұрын

Deliberately done at that time because there was a sinister agenda against the Sikhs. Indira was an evil woman ................... an icon and a symbol of pure raw unadulterated EVIL

The fact is Jarnail singh Bhindaranwale did start as saint but didn't end as a saint.

@Rakhjiv

3 жыл бұрын

Saint soldier, I’d say

@og4558

3 жыл бұрын

He ended as a sant soldier

@sandhujatt3886

3 жыл бұрын

He ended as saint soldier and also reveal true face of hinduism

NO mention at all of the burning of the Sikh Reference Library and the treatment of pilgrims in hostels east of the complex

Wonderful interview. He made his point clear and he proved he stands for the country over and above his religion. See how shikh are now . We have them everywhere, Manmohan, harbajan, Beshan bedi etc etc. Has this operation hasn't happed , we would have lost our friendly community and our own brothers for ever.

One of the best interview... Respect for both...

Fair enough Indian army was clearing golden temple from ‘ terrorist’ but why thousand of innocent Sikhs were killed in Delhi Riots!

@SACHIN-ys3vl

3 жыл бұрын

Congress pogram

@shubhamrawat530

3 жыл бұрын

@@SACHIN-ys3vl thousands of Hindus were also killed in Punjab before that by KHALISHTANI.. just googl it... I am not justfing DELHI 84. but taali kv ek hath se nhi bajti...

What is your contribution dear Sandhu other than spreading hatred and doing one sided postmortem of events.

What does it mean of 'being Indian' ? Ask Gen Brar and ask that brave Sikh Jawan who stood up first when the General addressed all the troop and gave them the option to honorably walk away from the operation. If an Indian man or a woman is ready to pick up arms to defend the integrity of India; it does not matter that person is a Hindu, a Sikh, a Muslim, a Christian, a Jain, or a Budhist. That person is a true Indian!!!

@K_S536

8 жыл бұрын

+G BRONCO India is amazing- is that why you see ENDLESS ENDLESS ENDLESS lines of Indians FLOCKING and BEGGING at foreign embassies to leave India ?

@K_S536

8 жыл бұрын

+Satpreet Brar Integrity of India, is nothing more a ruse to keep Brahmin hold on a geographical piece of area. India is basically a Brahman theocracy masquerading a a secular democracy.

@K_S536

8 жыл бұрын

+G BRONCO Have you read the vedas carefully. Please read they speak about a Fair skinned Aryan coming and he is fierce with the native settlers of India.

@gbronco820

8 жыл бұрын

+Karan Gill - puttar, WHAT "Fair skinned Aryan coming" has to do anything with India's integrity? Also, we are a nation of a billion plus people and our human resource is getting higher paying jobs in UK, US and so on. UNLIKE Syrians, we aren't refugees crossing the European border illegally. UNLIKE fanatic Sikhs, we aren't seeking political asylum in Aussie/UK/US and so on. We are a well educated work force who are seeking legal way to immigrate to more prosperous countries without having any attitude (unlike Moslem refugees demanding 'Sharia law' in EU countries. The way Moslems in EU are producing babies; they are going to take over Europe in no time). We come to US, we become part of the society, and we never demand Sharia law. We contribute to developed economies of the west, legally. Ok pumpkin?!?

@K_S536

8 жыл бұрын

G BRONCO Your parents did not teach you how to speak to OTHERS. Poor Upbringing. You can take pride in a land created by LYING, CHEATING and CUNNIGNESS- as honor does not come to all. Have you ever lived in the west, find out how much lies are on H1B resumes ? You will even find out, how Narayan Murthy Infosys has a Red Mark on US State Dept. How Indians regularly cheat in the wall street, US. 3-7 were caught in Insider fraud in NYC. Regularly Indian doctors are caught defrauding US healthcare. Not paying taxes. You think Hindu are not sneaking ILLEGALLY into US/Canada/west. You are so so Uniformed. Someday find out a US immigration officer, you will find out the Truth. Not to mention using ENDLESS LIES/CHEATING to Enter the countries at the first place. Legally we also have a Mass Murderer elected as PM. We are proud :) :)

you are brave gen. brar you removed massaa ragan from the darbar sahib. and you fought for the country. even the Sikhs were afraid to go to darbar sahib. that modern massa ragan was full of communal hatred. and by fortifying darbar sahib. he showed how he uses the sacred religious place. in Sikhism there is no place for hatred. and the only massage of love and humanity should be out from the harmandir sahib. you and the govt. saved the sacred place from the killers of humanity. waheguru bless you.

@shutupstupid100

10 жыл бұрын

Lady atleast pronounce the name properly, its massa ranggard. Stop believing all the bs that youre being fed and go do some research and open your eyes.

@harrysaini7805

10 жыл бұрын

You are wolf in sheep skin

@bravepunjabi5368

9 жыл бұрын

Well said sister!!

@gggursimar

9 жыл бұрын

STFU

@rahuldevale7485

6 жыл бұрын

You are the first sikh i came across who said such beautiful thing, where as majority of Sikhs are supporting the idea of bhindrawale!!

Nice interview sir, thank you. Aclosure is very much needed. He did what he had to do as a soldier.

so what about 1984 sikh genocides? why world second biggest army was not able to stop the mascaras of Sikhs on Delhi streets, from kids to 100 years old sikhs . ?? what is the excuses for that ?

Unity in diversity..ideal diversity is incomplete without Sikhism..labelling Sikhism with militancy is disgraceful..

@9495tj

3 жыл бұрын

I agree.. Sikhism is a great faith and is integral for our unity in diversity. Among the followers of almost every religion, there exists a fringe element of people who wish to use violence to achieve their goals. And we must condemn them and make our governments bring them to justice no matter what their faith is. In this case, Bhindranwaala was the fringe element and the good Sikhs were fighting against him. He was such an evil person, he chose to put a lot of people and one of India's holiest of places in harms way. I don't see anyone else except him to blame for this incident. I personally think Sikhism has nothing to do with militancy. And like I said, we must condemn the fringe and violent people of any faith.

@jaskiratsingh1970

3 жыл бұрын

@@9495tj lol who are the good Sikhs against Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawala? Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindrawala is revered as the Great Sikh Martyr of the 20th century. He was the 14th chief of Damdami Taksal founded by Guru Gobind Singh and whose 1st chief was Baba Deep Singh. These armies and govt will come and go but whenever atrocities will occur, we'll retaliate. Nothing new for us. Thanks.

@navroz1135

3 жыл бұрын

@@jaskiratsingh1970 why bhinderwaleji demand khalistan And killed 5000 hindu in Punjab

bhindrawale must have surrendered to avoid such massacre of innocent people

@CylindricNetwork

8 жыл бұрын

Um there was no one stopping them to arrest Sant Ji

@himmatshergill4621

8 жыл бұрын

khalsa will never surrender and sant ji fought very bravely

@aatishkumar8920

8 жыл бұрын

sikhs are hindus only

@kunalarora9489

8 жыл бұрын

live and let live................gasti dea tera attwadi sant darda maara bahar nahi si aanda harmandir sahib to......us ghusse di maa di lan uthe jaa ke diti military ne.............congress da kutta si tera sant jehra murke aapne hi malik nu vaddan laga te bund te golian kha ke narakan nu rawana kar ditta gya

@gagangill3078

8 жыл бұрын

what was the last time a sikh surrender

It was an event that shouldn't have happened but then the integrity of the nation is supreme. Buddhism, Hinduism, Sikhism, Jainism etc are there because Bharat is . In any other country , we won't be remotely allowed such freedom as we have here .

@HarmandeepSingh-mv8xd

3 жыл бұрын

Majority community is supreme here in India , they're just hiding behind the so called nationalism. No equality

@abhijittripathi1385

3 жыл бұрын

@@HarmandeepSingh-mv8xd deal with it fucker

@jagmeetsingh1875

2 жыл бұрын

@@abhijittripathi1385 did Taj hotel got shelled by 20 rounds of tanks? Thou it was cleared that everyone inside is dead except militants ?

@jagmeetsingh1875

2 жыл бұрын

@@HA-rn2iu continue attacking with AR and semi ar . Just asking for shelled 20 rounds of tanks

@jagmeetsingh1875

2 жыл бұрын

@@HA-rn2iu consider if the precious and memorable weopons of our sikh warrior got destroyed like Guru Hargobind Sahib ji Maharaj , Baba Budha ji , baba Fateh singh ji , baba Deep Singh Ji and many mores by one of the rounds , what about that ? Can you restore them ? If by any chance they would have been destroyed , then it'll be more chaotic situation Between army , government and Sikhs. Akal takht was restored , but weopons won't and this is called suppression not bravery , lmg against tank . Atleast have a fair fight with your own people . Police could not take risk in 26/11 regarding the casualties , they need to be dead asap. And in Amritsarthere was power cut of water and electricity from 1 June , how could have the news spread ? People sent back from literally 10km from the site even the news reporters

A very incisive interview. Channel did touch some controversial issues but did not drag on, when response was not forthcoming. The clarity and conviction of Gen Brar is amazing after so many years. His frequent responses like 'I am not aware of ..' are not unexpected considering the complex nature of operation.

When brar have to cover his excesses his answer ....I cud not recall

@teamgreenindia9512

3 жыл бұрын

what do you expect? Torn between his duty towards country, against his people. Dont judge..

KANWAR sandhu himself is a spokesperson of khalistan & ISI

@MadeinPanjab1699

3 жыл бұрын

Bss Kro Koi Hadd hoti hai Thappe Lgaane ki Bewkoof Kyuu Hr Kisi Ko Badnam krne ki Gandi IT Cell jesi Harkat krte rehte ho Bina kisi Sachayi aur True Proof k

@navdeepsingh2862

3 жыл бұрын

Ok so you are justifying killing of innocent people and giving him title of desh baghat wah(kps Brar)

@navdeepsingh2862

3 жыл бұрын

@Indian which innocent people he kill name them idiot

My appreciation for the interviewer. He was very tough, piercing and pointed queries but very dignified. Both Sikhs with swelling emotions did an excellent job.

In Army duty is duty. Bhendra wala was terorist and swhweg singh trater of army

It’s a man who simply follow orders from up in the chain and have no idea/or say in consequence. And yet so proud and ignorant. Plus, god damn it , this was not act of bravery for Indian army , sir!

@robindersinghpannu8289

3 жыл бұрын

True said bravery show karni ya tay China border tay show Karan. Few hundred rag tag militiamen vs Indian army with tanks not a fair fight.

@AmanKumar-ym6ir

Жыл бұрын

Just following orders like that many naive followers of Bhinderwale

Good interview

Well I don’t understand why people still say that Mr Brar is lying. Please share proofs if any

@kanganajokerranaut667

3 жыл бұрын

There's no proof they asked the civilians with kids, toddlers or infants to vacate.. they on purpose killed those babies.. There's no enmity between hindus and Sikhs, nothing even in the religion or culture so obviously someone created it and that whitch wanted to benefit from it.. I wish she would have lived and faced karma

@EatPrayLove25

3 жыл бұрын

@@kanganajokerranaut667 exactly my point if you read Sikh history too Bhindrawale has become nuisance for alkalis too. There were stories of infighting within the premises. The rumours of Army killing are spread to just to create disturbance

@kanganajokerranaut667

3 жыл бұрын

@@EatPrayLove25 I don't care about Bhindrawala.. Infact I detest him because his policies led to killing of innocents but lets not give a clean chit to these trigger happy assholes.. they're no soldiers and Indira witch Gandhi was no Iron Lady.. Anyone who cannot ensure the safety of civilians is no leader to me..

@EatPrayLove25

3 жыл бұрын

@@kanganajokerranaut667 trigger happy ? it’s a very harsh statement. There were Sikh soldiers in that team. You should read; if they were trigger happy, the people who would have stood up first would have been the ones in that attack

@EatPrayLove25

3 жыл бұрын

Are you a Punjabi ?

Gen Barar a true soldier of mother India I don't think the present day government would have dared to carry out such an operation

Gen.Brar just did his duty as a true soldier. He followed the instructions of the Government. So why is he the fall guy and not people like Bhindranwale?

Very good interview; with honest questions and answers.

@wolfking3875

2 жыл бұрын

Ask the gen brar, has he ever lived in Punjab after the Sikh genocide? Never because he knows all of the Sikh people would never forgive him after what has he done and govt. Used a sikh face against Sikhs purposely. Gen. Brar Attacked on golden temple the prime holy place of sikhs. If you listen this interview again, gen. Brar said that Sant ji were demanding khalistan which Sant ji never did so what was the other reason? they had to attack on golden temple? Reason was indra's ego. She destroyed akal takhat, killed so manny innocents. She was the root cause of blue star. Listen to Sant ji speech's on KZread, they treated all races equally. Absolutely No hate for no one🙏

You can live in harmony, so long as you dont start the trouble. Agree ? So dont start trouble.

Interviewer had started the interview with a clouded mind. A composed and honest response from Brar, hopefully clears all that from his mind as well from many many peoples' minds. Brar is a true religious man without following any religion. Blindly following rituals is not religion but the principal of the religion is to be followed.

13:00-13:30- I almost had tears in my eyes. Kudos to whoever that brace Sikh soldier was.

@apoorvchauhan6258

Жыл бұрын

He was Captain Raina He was awarded Asoka Chakra

Calm, composed,patience and cool although he is sikh........a true journalist Hatts off to him.

Very peniterative interview great puts things in perspective nicely

What about the act of bravery by sant jarnail Singh bhindrawala

And this is no "Fair" interview... Its colored bunch of questions asked by an already prejudiced Sandhu...

I have just been to the golden temple for a wedding of my friend ..and I want to say it again and again that I felt safe among these big people wearing swords than living in a so called safe world of corporate in Mumbai and Bangalore .Punjab is one of the best examples in the history of the known world when one talks about the bravery resilience courage and humanity. Lots of love to the Sikhs all over the world. You are the best. Love from a Maharashtrian.

@malebhaskar

Жыл бұрын

I feel safe in whole India🙏🙏

You both played very well.

Lt. Gen. Brar is an army man and he followed the orders like a true soldier. So asking questions such as "why" , "if-then-else", or "But" to Mr. Brar makes no sense. The moment Bindranwale and his men entered the holy place with guns and ammunitions', they lost all their credibility (doesn't matter saint or not). Yes, it would have been better if this incident could have been avoided but we all can learn from the past and avoid mistakes in the future instead of harboring "revenge".

Raj Bina Nahin Dharam Chale Hain, Dharam Bina Sab Dalle Malle Hain

@ASTeer1699

3 жыл бұрын

ik hal te hun reh gai ik gal azadi 🙏🚩

gen barar is a man of courage. he had the reqd guts to stand for the correct .. a true khalsa in deed

@sheru-xw5bc

8 жыл бұрын

+Gaurav Moudgil WELL SAD!!!

@hbsingh1085

8 жыл бұрын

Totally. Killing thousands of innocents is an amazing act of bravery.

Noida channels should learn from this interviewer, how to do an interview. Ask tough questions and wait for answers. No interruption no shouting. No hysterics.

Very nice interview done by Kanwar sandhu and so magnificently answered by brar sir what I feel is brar sir have done is part of his duty but thing went to much out of hand ,gov should have tried to do something else to bring out terrorists I don't know whom to blame for sikhism downfall thanks

@gauravtyagi7346

Жыл бұрын

Agree

Thanks for doing this thankless job you will be always remembered as unsung hero who cleared mess created by others and prevented religious madness which you could see what can do to countries in middle east.

khalistan can only be made if Sikhs take nankana sahib from pakistan

@miknateeees

8 жыл бұрын

+vjfive00 Genius...

@maanchudvaalojinnechudvaan4968

8 жыл бұрын

+vjfive00 Why Telangana had been separated?? Because it was demanded by you lovable Hindus?? Bhindravaaale never demanded Khalistan He asked for Basic rights of Human being and Anandpur Sahib Resolutions. You are a ignorance stupid moran person with no knowledge of background what was being asked and what VOTE bank Congress did in Punjab,.

@samakshrai5241

6 жыл бұрын

@ harman singh .....sikhism aint native to bihar ...there are many gurudwaras in maharashtra does it mean you will take that too

@RDPOINTOFVIEW

6 жыл бұрын

Harman Singh we will take shit out of ur ass. And make u eat that.

@hk5789

5 жыл бұрын

@Harman Singh Guru Nanak ji won't be proud of you! Get back on right track before it's too late.

Sir, you are a true soldier who did his duty.We all proud of you.

@sahajkamboj3632

4 жыл бұрын

He is traitor of sikh kaum ...........

@timwatson6603

4 жыл бұрын

He was a butcher

@robin2630

3 жыл бұрын

@@sahajkamboj3632 And u r coward..He is a brave Soldier

General brar is a bloody lawyer, why he and his officers could not meet sant jarnail Singh bhindranwale and why they should not read about the facts of anandpur resolution, there are so many efforts to avoid operation bluestar. General brar and all other military officers are totally responsible for this operation. They already know that even a single singh can't surrender. He is totally lying, there are only and only political reasons for doing operation bluestar. General brar accept a big rank in the army and other offers to kill sikhs in golden temple, there is no fir against sant jarnail Singh bhindranwale, why they choose guru arjan dev g shaheedi day , why general brar fight and argue with amritsar dc who told about the bad consequences of operation, at that time sant jarnail Singh bhindranwala was right person who stands for right of punjab in way of anandpur resolution and took weapons for their self defence, why gurbachan nirankari would release on killing of thirteen sikhs in 1978

Hats Off To U Brar Sir U Are The True Hero Of Our Nation Salute To U And Rotten Tomatoes To The Anchor Who is questioning ur honesty and duty and justifying the terrorists

@ikkat.9472

3 жыл бұрын

Jesde photo layi ohh pp fan aa dantan da terrorist apde baap nu bole jaddo proof hi ni hoya kadda terrorist

@onerycool

3 жыл бұрын

Pandit ji I am sure your Chodi ji bhakt.

India salutes her Sikh soldiers. There has been a few avoidable incidents in our history, which was fermented by mad fanatics from both religions. It is our need to learn from the past, and avoid it for the future. Indians first we are and then to whatever religion we practice.

@plaintruth7503

7 жыл бұрын

RK Ramachandran

@wissamsalman6415

7 жыл бұрын

Well-said!

@rajeever

6 жыл бұрын

Falcon crest was your ancestors Hindus??

@MrMehrana

6 жыл бұрын

Jai Kuma teri india/bharat mata bohat chudne wali hai Papa Pakistan se.

@adityasinghaswal4923

6 жыл бұрын

MrMehrana Don't bring Pakistan here, your country is irrelevant.Not saying India is the greatest or anything like that.

His calm personality is impressing .his way of talking also

I wish Operation Blue star would have not happen. When I say so, my wish is similar to Lt Gen Barr’s wish, had some wisdom prevailed over Bhinderwala or even his followers, and at first they should have nor resorted to violence and if at all, then at least refrained themselves from using the sacred place like Golden Temple or any other temple. Sikh religion is unique, I do not find any other religion with such wisdom and sacrifice in the teachings. I am a Hindu and if I may say for my other friends, we all find solace in any Gurudwara and appreciate gurudwara are managed. We are deeply sorry if you are hurt. We love all Sikhs and it is disturbing to notice that our brothers are disturbed. We cannot imagine India without Sikhs. I would have definitely endorsed Lt Gen Brar had he done this operation the same way at any of the Hindu Shrines. We need character and resolve of our leadership as that of Lt Gen Brar

@harpreetkaur-lb3dl

3 жыл бұрын

How could you be so diplomatic. We love Sikhs but what happened was correct. Ridiculous