What are some of the other weapon-based martial arts not mentioned in this video?

@lightningjadejavier

2 ай бұрын

too much sht

@ShakenWolf11485

Ай бұрын

u missed urumi weapon from india and sri lanka

@onesound4474

Ай бұрын

Kalari payattu

Canne de combat was taken from African Slaves who competed in stick fighting competitions with their native African stick fighting arts liek Kalinda. There is a paint showing French and British blacks doing this art

@krystofcisar469

Ай бұрын

Bullshit... You cant steal stick fighing - nobody has copyright to it bcs every second kid does it :D

You put the Australian flag instead of the New Zealand one for Mau Rakau.

@PlainlyPutHQ

2 ай бұрын

My bad. Both of those flags are very similar. Lol.

The HEMA explanation felt pretty off. Daggers and especially pole weapons tend to be on the more niche side of what we do. It's not a remotely centralized thing, so HEMA is going to look pretty different in different areas, but the most common weapons are definitely two handed longsword, saber, rapier, and sword and buckler. Sport and competition is also a significant aspect, as while plenty of people don't go to tournaments, they're a regular thing for a lot of us. There's definitely a sliding scale of people who are more interested in the historical side vs competition, but a lot appreciate both aspects. Part of the function of tournaments is to take people from different clubs, that potentially practice different styles of the same weapon or just interpret their own style differently, and seeing what aspects from the old manuals actually work.

What about Jogo do Pau, the Portuguese stick fencing like martial art?

nice

Entertaining AND comical 😅!

Kalaripayattu from india KERALA

Wold of fighting style techniques used weapons skills

I will argue that effective gun fighting is a martial art. If we are going to include swords, staffs, sickles, and scythes, nunchucks (originally used as a wheat flail), then we can include firearms and effective use as a martial art.

@amirferdhany3177

9 күн бұрын

Yep,it takes skill to draw a gun and fire accurately at a target in a short span of time.

Keep going make more informative video on martial arts

@PlainlyPutHQ

2 ай бұрын

Thank you, I will

HEMA should be here. Also the type of fencing you described, now Olympic fencing, originated in Spain in the 15-16th century.

You didn’t mention North or South American war arts either. 19th century saber and pistol, tomahawk, rifle, knife, etc

@eagels3131

2 ай бұрын

he is talking about actual traditional weapon based martial art what you described is very irrelevant except for the native indians weapons

@ericfierro1693

2 ай бұрын

@@eagels3131 weapons are weapons. Whether it’s a polish saber or a Glock.

@eagels3131

Ай бұрын

@@ericfierro1693 I understand your point but the video is "weapon based MARTIAL ARTS"

@ericfierro1693

Ай бұрын

@@eagels3131 the art is used and thought to get in a combat scenario. That’s what Marines and the Army do to teach their soldiers how to fight and kill. That’s what it means to be Martial. To be like Mars, the god if war. Martial arts are martial arts. The weapons may be different but the principles are the same. It’s human on human violence.

@eagels3131

Ай бұрын

@@ericfierro1693 I agree

What about jianshu, daoshu, kwunshu, and quiangshu in Wushu Taolu?

Video #4 of asking for the jacket video #coatclip

Your research is incomplete in regards to ninjutsu. Look up Toshitsugu Takamatsu.

i'm sorry but you displayed an image of nihon kobudo practitionners while speaking about okinawan kobudo...

Just bo or staff, bo means staff

Always thought it was funny that systems that used "everyday" tools, don't continue to add current examples. Sure, honor the traditional but keep the system's theory in practice as well. What's in the current home, office, etc. that could used when needed.

@19Pyrus70

Ай бұрын

Just what we need: (Pencil/pen/stylus)jitsu -- attacks with writing implements Tool Fu -- attacks with tools Bucketdo -- attacks with (filled or unfilled) buckets, cans & containers of various sizes Cuisine Coupe -- attacks made with cooking implements Street Fencing -- attacks with stolen items😃

Fencing wasn't originated in Germany

@Jonahch2v9

2 ай бұрын

The first written theories and practices came from there. As far as the first guy who tried to teach another, you'll never know that.

@InvictusSolDeus

2 ай бұрын

@@Jonahch2v9 No, what existed up to that point was swordmanship, and it was practiced throughout Europe, not just in Germany. But Fencing, as we conceive it today, dates back to the 15th century, and it is considered that the first manual that codified rules and techniques was writen in Spain by Diego de Valera in 1471. Even the swords used in fencing are derived from the Spanish ropera sword.

@Jonahch2v9

2 ай бұрын

@@InvictusSolDeus "The oldest surviving treatise on western fencing is the Royal Armouries Ms. I.33, also known as the Tower manuscript, written c. 1300 in present-day Germany" (Fencing comes from the German fechten) Your info. is correct for the foil (small sword) weapon. Fencing like most sports evolved. The Italian and French schools still hold differences, both use the foil, but their grips and style vary. So, of course they both claim to be the correct version, while neither is the same as what came out of the Spanish school. Spanish grip is thicker, French is thin and slightly curved, Italian is straight with a inner cross guard and then came a modern "pistol" grip and I believe a newer one also exists. So, it's always changing.

@InvictusSolDeus

2 ай бұрын

@@Jonahch2v9 If we are strict with the definition of word "fencing", it existed since the first swords were invented. It doesnt matter if in english the word "fencing" has German origin (in other languajes it hasn't), but swords already exist since ancient Egypt. But the modern fencing, as the video shows, originated from Spanish's swordmanship, not German. They are very different on each other.

@Jonahch2v9

2 ай бұрын

@@InvictusSolDeus The Bible mentions swords even earlier than ancient Egypt and it doesn't act like they are anything new, when they are first mentioned. I get your point (pardon the pun) but the problem with defining "modern" fencing is where do you draw the line. The German manuscripts show the footwork and techniques already in use. The Saber competitions began long before the epee, which came long before the foil. The Italian school claims to be the origin of the sport, since they were the first to use the three weapons and only those three. Spain claims to have contributed one sword, but the rules and techniques already existed and continually changed, even after becoming an Olympic sport. The foil competitor uses many of the epee techniques which came first (claimed by France).

HEMA MENTIONED ⚔⚔⚔⚔⚔⚔⚔⚔⚔⚔⚔⚔⚔ WTF IS FOOTWORK 🤺🤺🤺🤺🤺🤺🤺🤺

0 mention of wushu its kinda sad :(

Was this narrated by an AI? The English is mostly good, but the mispronunciation of the occasional word is jarring.

@PlainlyPutHQ

2 ай бұрын

Yes it is.I try to pick humanly sounding voice as possible. I will watch out for the pronunciations in the future videos. Thanks for your feedback.

It's funny how kung-fu is the one oldest if forms or combat with weapons and China I'd not on this list 🧐🤔💊🥃💯🃏🤨

@jacobharris954

2 ай бұрын

Because there isn't a separate art of weapon skill training,it is part of all arts

@100spoked6

2 ай бұрын

@jacobharris954 each chamber is a style and they are broken down

Many misinformations about most of the japanise arts