What people have to understand is how brilliant these guys were. They had no internet, few if any textbooks. They had to reason things from first principles, so much original. Just stunning

@andraskovacs517

4 жыл бұрын

They _wrote_ the textbooks & had them published; they published papers in mathematical journals, of which they had several; and some of them maintained extensive connections through personal letters.

@ernst9100

2 жыл бұрын

@@andraskovacs517 Thinkers existed in centuries gone by....they invented whole new concepts to explain reality of the times

@boukharroubamediane119

2 жыл бұрын

and above all, they did not have an electronic calculator! everything was done manually !! 😳 wow!!

@chandradeepraut9306

2 жыл бұрын

This is what I think ,we could also have been smart if we had no tv (in my childhood upto 6th) as I spent my childhood in watching tv and no critical thinking of sciences ,so I end up just learning what others had done but I started in 10th class inventing techniques to solve maths but it was too late

@boukharroubamediane119

2 жыл бұрын

Chandradeep Raut 👍

For a long time 0 didn't exist, and some people who stupidly claimed that nothing existed had their heads bobbed. Now imagine imaginary numbers. That was like claiming the earth wasn't flat.

@MarkNewmanEducation

9 ай бұрын

It was Descartes that called them "imaginary numbers". An unfortunate name. Perhaps he might have done better to call them lateral numbers or something that intimidated the idea of their working in more than one dimension. That might have made them easier to understand.

@purplrshadowyay

4 ай бұрын

​@@MarkNewmanEducation A good name could have been surreal numbers (S) or just the other name it has, complex numbers (C)

It is over 20 years since I studied the maths of Euler but this is by far the best explanation I have ever seen. I wish I had seen this video back then. Students of today have it a lot easily than years ago, when you were expected to just get it!

@MarkNewmanEducation

2 жыл бұрын

This is why I made the video. I was also just expected to know it and it frustrated me that I didn't. This video is part of a whole series on the Fourier Transform which I made for the same reason: howthefouriertransformworks.com/

@AmikaofMan

7 ай бұрын

@@MarkNewmanEducation Thank you for the link and the video here for Eulers. Definitely makes more sense this way than the way my physics teacher tried to explain to us back in the day.

To me what is beautiful is that you have a number with infinite and random digits that is related to exponencial growth/decay, then you raise it to the power of a number that we find impossible to solve and so we call it imaginary, and to another number with infinite and random digits that is related to circles and it's geometry, and then you add a single unit, probably the most basic number that we know, to all of this only to get what we call "nothing"

Now I am waiting for Euler's Supremacy and Euler's Ultimatum...

@MarkNewmanEducation

6 жыл бұрын

+Niespotykanie Spokojny Rowerzysta haha... Apparently, I might have been wrong in stating that it was Euler who gave e the name Euler's number. It seems to be that the name was coined later although exactly when and by who, I don't know. Euler probably used the symbol e simply to denote "exponent".

@us-Bahn

6 жыл бұрын

They are coming! But they wouldn’t be if Euler had never been Bourne.

@petrophilip2279

6 жыл бұрын

LOL, Good one Ian McCutcheon

@ruffifuffler8711

5 жыл бұрын

Happy you didn't move stuff across the = symbol without a triple deep incisive prayer.

@georgesealy4706

5 жыл бұрын

Excellent!

It is not just beautiful "in mathematical terms," it is just BEAUTIFUL. Period.

@MarkNewmanEducation

5 жыл бұрын

Very true.

A lot of people seem to think that math is boring, but for me personally, studying mathematics has been like discovering a hidden cave full of beautiful treasures.

@likeitornot6821

3 жыл бұрын

Likewise

@MarkNewmanEducation

3 жыл бұрын

I think that the problem is the way that maths is taught, and that it is treated as a totally abstract concept with no relation to the real world when in fact it describes the real world with precise beauty.

@jaredhouston4223

2 жыл бұрын

@@MarkNewmanEducation You hit the nail on the head

You should also highlight how euler's identity is nicely shown with multiplication of complex numbers as vectors around a circle plot on the imaginary plane. And how to maintain symmetrical values working out the power spectrum density in FFT.

@MarkNewmanEducation

Жыл бұрын

Thanks for the idea. Will look into it.

I have seen and used the constant "e" in the study of calculus, complex numbers, infinite series, natural logarithms etc, but no one explained what the number is. This is the simplest explanation I have seen. It takes a special kind of a skill to correctly explain a complex concept in simple terms. Thanks Mark Newman.

@NoferTrunions

5 жыл бұрын

Explanation by example or picture are the best.

@NoferTrunions

5 жыл бұрын

@@oldlonecoder5843 Unfortunately, mathematicians are the worst at explaining from example or pictures - they do their explaining by showing how to manipulate equations. Physicists on the other hand are the opposite - they use sketches and examples regularly. A meaningful humorous comment on mathematicians is that once they prove a solution exists, they lose interest and move on to the next problem...

@parmachine470

2 жыл бұрын

e is also involved in some of the most beautiful comprehensible markings on a chalkboard.

@Chad-qk1ig

2 жыл бұрын

@@NoferTrunions depends what kind of mathematicians you're talking about. Historically mathematicians heavily utilised geometry.

Sometimes I wonder if the internet made us numb.. Back in the day you were kind of 'forced' to think. Just look at this absolute beauty.

I don't believe Euler named the number after his own name. From what I know Euler was a very modest man, he instead named the number e because it was the next available letter that was not already taken. Listen to the podcast of 'In Our Times' discussing this number.

8:10 "The brilliant thing about mathematicians is that . . . when they are on their way to some wonderful mathematical discovery, they don't let a little thing like "Numbers NOT EXISTING" stop them." Is it safe to say HERO ?

This is the best mathematica axplanation I've found so far on KZread for anything.

That sure as hell is beautiful--especially because, as a student, I didn't understand why this formula was so special. Great video.

@MarkNewmanEducation

6 ай бұрын

I'll let you into a secret. As a student I didn't understand it either. I just had to accept it. It wasn't until years later when I had to work with it that I found out what the link was when I had to research it for my work. Glad you enjoyed the video.

This gentleman Mark is a very good teacher he is a master.

@MarkNewmanEducation

2 жыл бұрын

You're most kind.

This is the best explation about Euler's identity! Thanks.

I don't say this to every explainer or professor or technologist but I think it's suits you well. "You are real intelligent"

Euler was so obsessed with complex numbers, he based his identity off them

You done something to me in 8 minutes which many people could not do. Thank you

It also links exponents, zero, addition, equality, the identity element under multiplication, and when expanded, trigonometry, division, factorials, and infinite series.

@DejiAdegbite

10 ай бұрын

And also indirectly, logarithm.

My first ever comment in 10+ years of watching KZread. Mark, you nailed it! This video has me feeling ecstatic. You have shown me the connection between sin, cos, i, e, and π as presented in Euler's famous identity. This reveals the deep foundation that underlies all of classical math and ties everything together. Now I have seen the light! Thank you so much.

@MarkNewmanEducation

2 жыл бұрын

Amazing. So happy to have helped and thank you for making my video the first video you commented on in a long time. Any suggestions for future videos you would like to see would be gratefully received.

I just want to say, there's so much efforts in making this video and I appreciate it. From animations to sound effects to historical facts and figures .. this is so much works.

I have watched over a dozen videos on Euler"s identity, and this is the most clear and straightforward.

I think this is the finest maths video I've seen on KZread - and I have sought out many. Well done!

I saw various equations named Euler's method or formula, I was so confused about what Euler's formula is. This is the best video I found to clear up my confusion. Thank you very much!

This video really made me understand how beautiful Euler's identity is

So beautiful that the simple identity e^(pi*i)+1=0 can link together the most important mathematical concepts (0, 1, i, e, pi) using the most fundamental mathematical operations (equality, addition, multiplication, exponentiation)!

@BRORIGIN

Жыл бұрын

Equality is not an operation

The true heroes are living in the world of youtube.

I watched this video awhile back and did not comment. It occurred to me that this presentation helped me to connect a couple of dots which enhanced my understanding. I actually had to spend a bit of time to find this video again but I felt the need to say thank you for your time and for the explanation.

@MarkNewmanEducation

6 жыл бұрын

+Benny Morgan my pleasure. Really happy to have helped you.

Brilliant, simple, elegant. The video is a piece of art.

What an excellent explanation of one of the most used fundamentals in the real world. You did a far greater job in under 15 minutes than my lecturers did over hours of classroom time. Well done.

Mark Newman -- wow! Sorry I missed the release of this video almost 4 years go. Beautiful! This is a stunning exposition of an often spoke wonder I had never grasped. Your explanation left me gobsmacked twice. Holy cats man -- great! I will share this unfolding to help my students understand - and point them to this video. Can't wait for more! Extremely well done.

I agree that the Euler's identity is beautiful but so was this vid. Hard work went into this!

@MarkNewmanEducation

6 жыл бұрын

+screenflicker1 thank you. I really enjoyed every moment of it.

you have no idea how much i loved this video... beautifully explained...

Euler's number isn't just beautiful. It literally describes reality to perfection.

@ucctgg

4 жыл бұрын

What is reality?

This is beautiful. I've never seen it explained so clearly

this is the best explanation I've seen so far :)))

@MarkNewmanEducation

7 жыл бұрын

That's very kind of you to say so.

@ayoubmounadi2142

6 жыл бұрын

Sacred Sanctuary i share the same opinion with you 😃

@wickrenner488

6 жыл бұрын

Yes, a very good explanation. I finally understand Euler's Identity, huge revelation, thanks.

@sophialopez8024

5 жыл бұрын

Maybe that's because you limit yourself to 'religious' sources..

@michaelzhu6952

5 жыл бұрын

Agree!

So in simple terms, the value of the function of e raised to ix at pi rads is -1. That's mind blowing

This makes WAY more sense than some of the other videos I’ve seen on this. Thank you.

Thank you Mark! I am Enlightened and Delighted. It's great to find you!!

Euler was perhaps the most productive mathematician of all time. The number e is named in his honour. It is to Euler that we owe much of our basic understanding of infinite series and complex analysis. But Euler had a weird flaw -- his proofs always fell well short of the standard laid down by Cauchy, Riemann and Weierstrass, and often were wrong even by the relaxed standards of the 18th century. But no result ever published by Euler was ever shown subsequently to be wrong. Everything he claimed to be a theorem in fact was, even though his proofs were never rigorous and were often downright wrong. Euler was perhaps the most spectacular example of history of mathematical intuition. Euler derived his eponymous identity using the infinite series for e^x, and his proof was largely correct.

you can consider e^ix to be (e^i)^x. then imagine e^I , (e^i)^2 , (e^i)^3 ... as a special case of a spiral on the complex plane that stays on the unit circle and advances 1 radian (57 degrees) each time similar to (1+i)^1 which is 2^.5 long and pointing at 45degrees. then (1+i)^2 = 2 units long at 90degrees = 2i which is 2*( cos(90)+I sin(90)) and (1+i)^3 is (2^.5)^3 long at 135degrees etc.

Offc 🌸 it's beautiful the two fundamental constants e and π comes in a equation along with an imaginary number

Aside the brilliant minds behind the formula, your presentation is also "beautiful" and very structured. No wonder, it is almost 2 in the morning and am wide awake!

I think this is the only guy that ever clearly explained Euler's identity on youtube that I could actually understand. wow.

@7rgrov198

4 жыл бұрын

@@jacksmetana7932 then what did he spend 14 minutes doing?

This is the best video on the euilers identity

The most simplified illustration. Amazing! Beautiful!👏

Another beautiful aspect to that representation in particular. It involves precisely one each of addition, multiplication, and exponentiation, while also being set equal to 0, as is the custom when solving for roots.

"They don't let a little thing like numbers not existing stop them" This is why math is amazing, the limit is how far you are willing to push it!

@MarkNewmanEducation

2 жыл бұрын

Very true!

Beautiful explanation i have never seen such a nice presentation skills . God bless

@MarkNewmanEducation

6 жыл бұрын

+Unique Family thank you

AMMAZING!!👍👍 !! this is how a story is told and a lesson is learnt 👌

Clever and clear explanation of the formula makes this video a good one :)

brilliant, thank you Sir... i was "taught" this badly over 30 years ago... i get it perfectly now...

This is the best explanation of this that i have seen

This is basically a mix of all we learn in highschool but in one single calculation, absolutely madness bro

You rocked man.....we need teachers like you ...... Lots of love from Pakistan ❤

@anymaths

4 жыл бұрын

watch my maths videos.

Most beautifully presented!!!

man, this is the easiest video to understand above all videos. thank you!!!

@MarkNewmanEducation

Жыл бұрын

Amazing. Glad it helped. Check out my channel for more videos like this.

What a beautiful explanation it is!

A very nice,clear and comprehensive video. Thanks for the preparation and share👏👏👏

The most beautiful formula in Mathematics explained in the most beautiful way in this video. Thank You!

@esuchil

5 жыл бұрын

Other than having that ugly ass Pi in it, and needing to subtract 1 for no reason, it's pretty meh.

@MarkNewmanEducation

5 жыл бұрын

You're welcome.

@MarkNewmanEducation

5 жыл бұрын

...but PI is SO useful. It crops up everywhere!! I use it a lot in electronics and filter design.

This is Excellent! Very well explained and illustrated! ❤ 😊

Truly BRILLIANT expositon!! The introductory theory & linkages to the Trigonometric Series were so cleverly explained, that I think even an average Math student would find the topic both fascinating & understandable. I also noted the emphasis on demonstrative exposition with the aids of Graphs, etc. Please keep up the great work & tutorials....a new subscriber!

My mind is totally blown right now!!!!! Great job Mark!!

There is a great feeling when you understand a new math concept - I finally understand e and its relation to sin/cos after this video. Excellent work please keep it up !

@MarkNewmanEducation

7 жыл бұрын

I SO know what you mean. For years this stuff was incomprehensible to me. Then I got this project at work (I'm an electronics engineer) which was all to do with complex impedences and all things "imaginary" that I HAD to understand in order to get the job done and finally, after much research, I got that Eureka moment that I am so happy to have helped you arrive at as well, where everything just fell into place. Then I really wanted to make sure I understood it properly and the best way to do that is to try and teach it. I am now busy working on more stuff as we speak which I shall be putting into an online video course about the Fourier Transform. I have published my research notes for the course at: www.themobilestudio.net/the-fourier-transform-part-1. I'm posting progress reports on the course on a Facebook page facebook.com/TheFourierTransform/ which includes snippets from some of the videos that will be in the course. I'm just putting the finishing touches to the video on "phase" and will post an extract from it on the facebook page (and probably here on my channel too) during the next week or so, so please stay tuned. Thanks so much for your comment.

@Bobby-fj8mk

5 жыл бұрын

@@MarkNewmanEducation - good post - i might be imaginary but it gives you real results when you play with complex numbers & impedance's in electronics. It's all to to do with time - relating one voltage to another by a phase difference. When you do Fourier analysis you don't only get the amplitudes of the various harmonics you get the phase differences coming out of the equations. It's about time domain & frequency domain. We couldn't calculate anything much with using i. It is very powerful mathematics.

@pwnmeisterage

5 жыл бұрын

EEs describe phase impedance as _Z=x+jy_ ... I guess easier (visually relates to Euler's identity) when graphing with polar coordinates but why isn't _i_ good enough?

It all makes so much more sense now. Thanks :D

omg i've been looking for a video that explains what all these terms mean for so long. thank you for your elegant teaching!

WOW. Just discovered you through this video. You are a fantastic teacher of mathematical concepts. Thank you.

Beautifully explained, thank you.

The best explanation of Eulers identity.

Excellent presentation and analysis!

Superb clarity. Thanks Professor.

Wow! Simple explanation, need more videos of same kind .

The formula IS a wonderful solution. The 4 concepts are combined all together and zero is appearing. That is Amazing, that is elegant, that is math.

Excellent explanations and presentation!

I've got so interested. I want so many videos and knowings about mathematics like this

Yes, they are beautiful, and you explain them beatiful.

Wow!!! Divinely beautiful explanation...thank you so much

The beauty of the formula is that it says so much in so little space and in a simple and elegant way. That's what good literature or well written instructions ought to be. Say it simply.

totally understood this - thank you so so much for your clear explanation.

Good Presentation Mark

One of the best videos on youtube

This is really amazing!! Sir, I would like to thank you for rekindling and making the beauty of intuition work so well. I chose mathematics in my high school years because I was interested in it but just being told to cram formulae and pressurized to just score good grades deteriorated my interest but videos like these is what will keep me going so thank you.

this explanation much better than other videos that try to explain euler's identity by rotations

This is the best explanation I ever had except that one explanation when I was in 4th standard.

e^(i*pi) means you have rotated the complex number 0+i to 180 degrees. Because in polar form it is written as cos(pi) + isin(pi) and it is -1 :)

Wow! I just understood so much I never got before. Thank you mate! Well done

Splendidly and beautifully explained

This is one of the coolest math videos I’ve ever seen, thank you

@MarkNewmanEducation

2 жыл бұрын

Wow, thanks! It's part of an online course which I am producing on the Fourier Transform. You can access the whole course at howthefouriertransformworks.com/. So far the course is made up of a mixture of video lectures and blog posts. I am currently working on turning the remaining blog posts into videos. I've just released Video 7 - From Fourier Series to Fourier Transform Part 1 to my Patreons patreon.com/MarkNewman and I am hard at work on video 8

This equation is actually very beautiful.

Hey, I just want to let you know that I liked the cute visuals and the explanations, they really made it easy to understand how truly wonderful that identity is! I also liked how your tone of voice wasn't too demeaning but in a gentle explanatory way conveying the ideas and concepts :)

@MarkNewmanEducation

2 жыл бұрын

Awesome, thank you!

It so profound and amazing. It has been long I encountered all these signs in maths, like sine and cosine, + - ÷ but right now I got understand how all those signs came into existence, with help of your explanations here. Thanks

Explained beautifully !!

This is one of the best videos ever

Beautifully explained.

Wonderful presentation !!

Beautiful! Inexpressibly and inexhaustible beautiful! Astoundingly and undeniably wondrous! Didn't understand a single, solitary syllable he said but I want to. Time to get back to learning math

Great Video. You might as well add that this is the only equation that connects all the important mathematical constants - e, pi, i, unity (1) and zero.

An absolutely wonderful wonderful "experience". Like a time-capsule back to math classes when everything was proved. All that is missing is the smell of chalk dust! Thank You Mark.

This was the most beautiful explanation of the most beautiful identity.