Ernst: Grand Caprice, Der Erlkönig Comparison
Heinrich Wilhelm Ernst's Grand Caprice on Schubert's Der Erlkönig, Op. 26 "Le roi des aulnes", considered as one of the most difficult violin pieces ever composed
0:00 Ning Feng
0:41 Kerson Leong
1:27 Vilde Frang
2:07 Shannon Lee
2:58 Kristof Barati
3:39 Irène Duval
4:26 Hilary Hahn
Пікірлер: 18
We need much more of this kind of video!! I'm waiting for the comparison of shostakovich vc cadenza and some ysaye sonatas
Having listened to all of these on high quality headphones, Hahn's performance is clearly the best, which is especially incredible seeing as the video used for comparison isn't even the best available. The others all have their own issues, whether it be shrieking, twangy or crunchy playing at points, or just having inconsistent rhythm, they're comparatively unpleasant to listen to. Played well, the piece isn't supposed to sound hard and I feel like Hahn is the only one that accomplishes this.
I just want to add that I am also hoping for more of these comparison videos! They're super interesting!
kerson leong is so good
@OopsSpaghetti69420
20 күн бұрын
its kinda scary
Hilary Hahn
Just the recording quality but hilary crushed that holy shit
love these so much
Sibelius pls
Kristof Barati 🔝🔝🔝
This is cool
Bruh Hilary’s is so clean and connected compared to the others, and that’s on a bad recording as well.
this is no comparison... hahn is the only one that is able to meld it all properly.
@IndoPersian1969
2 ай бұрын
agreed. the others may be good, but Hahn is the master.
WHERE IS MY NING FENG LOVE HE IS THE ONLY ONE WHO CAN DO IT RIGHT
Leong, Barati and Feng
@violintegral
4 ай бұрын
+Hahn
For me I prefer Kerson Leong.