Editorial With Sujit Nair | Centre Stops ₹7000 Cr Ration Funds To State For Not Putting PM’s Photo
The Central government has reportedly withheld Rs 7,000 crore funds designated for the West Bengal government under the National Food Security Act (NFSA). The reason cited for this action is the alleged failure of the state government to comply with ""branding standards,"" which encompass the display of the logo and a photograph of the Prime Minister. Senior officials within the West Bengal government provided this information.
HW News’ Managing Editor Mr. Sujit Nair discusses how such decisions affect the lowest common denominator and how the poor suffers due to such political confrontations.
#westbengal #nfsa #ration #food #commonman #poor #bjp #narendramodi #mamtabanerjee #bjp #tmc #pmawas #mgnrega #centre #state #centrestaterelations #primeminister #HWNews
To get the latest news updates at your fingertips, download the HW News Shorts app: onelink.to/85hk86
To Join KZread Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotion.com/hwenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
Пікірлер: 390
Rightly said common man suffering
Very disturbing. Thank you for bringing this up in your editorial. Would like to look for the WB govt’s protests and for any public debates on this issue.
Every word of this is true! Having said that, how and when is it going to change....?????
I appreciate you from the bottom of my heart for a bold and blend views you share dear Sujit❤
With Nirmala Sitaraman as Finance minister u can expect worse .😜🤪
Display of photograph on any govt schemes in India is a disease. In Western counteries no pne does that. Only communist and dictatorial countries does that. How come India a democratic waste so much money printing the photos of politicians?
If centre doesn't deliver ration to west Bengal. Then it failed as a government. When a government fails at food safety then the government is dead in spirit.
Sujithji Great editorial as always Its damning that our money is considered personal property of these parties. How dare they. Disgusting. Our poor bring denied there due. Your passion is awesome.
Atleast you have taken up this subject. Appreciate. Thanks.
Why are the people of India keeping quiet this is tooo much for the people of India
I completely agree with you
Simply outrageous How far can one man's ego be allowed to trample people's basic necessities ?? Shocking and inhuman state of affairs ... Vishwa Guru, indeed.😢😮
@raveetr8730
4 ай бұрын
Do proper analysis and research. Then decide. Nair is only provoking
When religion and power gets into the leaders hearts. The country runs into chaos.
@raveetr8730
4 ай бұрын
How....where is cha......loose???.
@joymascarenhas3491
4 ай бұрын
@@raveetr8730BLIND Bhakt!
@zarinekmehta781
3 ай бұрын
Your opinion......
We select a government to manage the country and accordingly we provide the government the funds and country's resources to do so. What happens when the manager, i.e. the government, takes over our funds and resources and start treating these as their own? What happens when the owners, i.e. the people, have been ingrained with the belief that their manager, i.e. the government, is their 'maibaap'? That whenever the government does something that benefits the people, it is a favour being done to them? What happens when the appointed manager not only has no qualms in misusing his position but has a king-sized ego and believes that it is his right to do so?
BJP and RSS can do what they want and NO one can question them. No use of questioning them as they have the support of the majority, media and institutions.
@aryaman05
4 ай бұрын
Follow procedure and the common people get their ration. What's so difficult about that ? How long is this state gonna stay lawless ? Are these folks a bunch of culture-less, law-less barbarians ? Is this why it is still so utterly corrupt and incompetent ?
@kirankoti6316
4 ай бұрын
Yes we will support them..thanks for understanding
@raveetr8730
4 ай бұрын
If thy do corruption. Thy will also go home. Karnataka is example
@vkaaa1
3 ай бұрын
complete nonsense. Lets go To SOUTH INDIA. no state wont put MODI photos in ration distribution. Use commonsense before posting
@rajanbabu3448
3 ай бұрын
No no no , no public support, they just Rape EVM ..... MR. Vajpayee a towering personality could not get or reach beyond 42 MP's in his second innings, how could this murderer , rowdy , could ????... All that he do is Rape of EVM .....!!!!
As usual you have hit the correct point sir. Common man always suffers, no matter what
Very good point raised and also the fact that even educated people are politically uneducated.
If this is the reason for stopping ration money to West Bengal, I demand as a Tax prayer fromTamil Nadu logo of government of Tamilnadu Kerala Karnataka Telangana and Maharashtra and the chief ministers photos should be placed in nook and corner of UP Bihar etc. and also the same should be placed in the central secretariat buildings and in the parliament.
Thank you Sujit Sir for a great and relevant editorial 🙏🌻
Wonderful analysis. Real eye opener. Hope Modi Bakths will understand.
@Jesssco
4 ай бұрын
Bhakts are Brainwashed by kinduism fantasies.
Nfsa logo is justified.. PM photo.. its just shameful display of hunger of publicity
First of all, the people of the country should understand that what they get from the govts are not alms from the PM/CM. They are getting them because it is their right. Modi has no right to withhold the amounts due to state govts becoz they are ruled by opposition parties, or they don't display his pix wherever he wants. Autocracy and fascism are creeping into the polity ever since Modi came to power. The earlier the citizens realise it, the better for them.
@d.dcosta8771
4 ай бұрын
Yes very true. This govt thinks that our money is their personal property. Eg PM CARES fund😢 We don't live in medevial times of zamindars n their types.. who commanded the subjects. WE ARE NOT YOUR SUBJECTS. Mr. PM n CM. WE got a disgusting megalomaniac person who is unfortunately our pm. Sorry to say this.... But it's the reality.
@srinivasrao369
4 ай бұрын
Yes true
@zarinekmehta781
3 ай бұрын
That's spot on...... But how many are listening ??😮😢
@rahulkarmakar5183
3 ай бұрын
😂
@sabyasaci
3 ай бұрын
Look how is speaking ???the product of appeasement...
I am eating because of my prime minister. So I am shitting indirectly because of my prime minister. Therefore the drawing of a man in front of men's toilet in the public toilet may be replaced with the photo of my prime minister. Otherwise the swachh Bharat department may issue a circular to lock the public toilet facilities across the country.
@jalajabhaskar6490
4 ай бұрын
😂😂
@monkeybaath2325
4 ай бұрын
🤣🤣🤣.... but please don’t shit too much... more than 3 times a day will attract 28% GST 🐵🐵🐵🤡🤡🤡
@orlandofigueredo3823
4 ай бұрын
Perfectly true n correct if pics of PM is paramount! Every power outage n shutdown in water supply also should bear PM snap apologising to de affected public !😮
@ammu8291
3 ай бұрын
😂😂
@mohandasnv6395
3 ай бұрын
Tamiliyans prefer Railway tracks.
Whatever you said in this video very much true I hope our people will decide our country's future in upcoming election wisely.
Gujarat is the new Pakistan.
@ashrafnm2448
4 ай бұрын
Gujrat is looting indian people.
I am from Tamilnadu Here no ration shop exhibits P M photo in front of ration shops. Here ration shop gives bill in the shops name. You know TN is best state in distribution of ration for many many years
@rajnair1357
4 ай бұрын
This is a misguiding program. It's opposition sponsered 😅
@SJ-tm6iq
4 ай бұрын
@@rajnair1357oh you great andhbakht.
@ramakumarnambiar7010
4 ай бұрын
@@SJ-tm6iqy? You don’t like facts?! Or you simply accept what that twit and a ‘public official’ stated?!!
@sudarsanbabu2900
4 ай бұрын
@@rajnair1357oh opposition put in Indian Express in newspaper,
@doddipatlaaparna7961
3 ай бұрын
వీడి భాద ఏంటి అసలు?
Thanks for your daring and hearty news on this subject which no one can express or say dare to report.Please go on with this.Continue in good confidence. Be blessed❤
From the heart Sujit, as always.
😂😂😂 As a nation, We are increasingly becoming a joke
It’s a pure psycopathic action from the centre and it’s leadership.
West Bengal is one of those unfortunate states that gets far less than what it gives to the central government aka Dilli Durbar. Same was also happening between Islamabad and East Bengal prior to 1971. Islamabad was literally robbing East Bengal which led to the bloody civil war and birth of Bangladesh. Withholding money due to the people of a state means robbing their money.
@11arkitkanrar85
4 ай бұрын
stop fooling joker ..............i m from west bengal and i didn get my 5 months ration .....where did it go?
@agonnoga6100
4 ай бұрын
@11arkitkanrar85 moron from BJP IT cell didn't you watch this video? If central government stops your ration then how will you get it?
@raveetr8730
4 ай бұрын
Always unfortunate. Not now.
@agonnoga6100
3 ай бұрын
@sydmohe now bhakts are even hiding behind Muslim names?
@banibasak7363
3 ай бұрын
@agonnoga6100 but in that case your intention (of separate nation)behind your comment will not full fill. As a resident of WB ,we are really unfortunate that we have this kind of corrupt govt.Here jyotipriyo mallick expelled from his ministry because of scams in distribution of ration.and as a tax payer also I'm happy that I can contribute for my country (betterment of other state), because we Bengalis are not narrow minded like you who have only thought of their own
Totally agree with you 👍Till now is the operative word!
Dho Gujarti poori desh par bhari
Can't imagine this is happening in India we are living in.
Bang on! More power to you!
Yes wake up India and ...Question injustice. Sir..thank you for pointing this out.
You are absolutely right for power politicians use common man's innocence
People in WB should raise their voice / protest
Your best show dude. Well done.
Thankyou Mr. Suit.for your courageous comment on depriving the masses of daily food because of a publicity mania of a logo. Where to.have our leaders come! Keep educating us on these matters. H.DLima
Yes its true, your coverage is always good and honest, what ration, what's great about it, can it cover all my daily expenses, as a senior citizen I get Rs 2000 from the government does this cover my months expenses, is only giving ration enough. Look at the cost of living for a common man who has no food, jobs and money, originally I used to pay Rs 540 to travel in an a/c compartment from Goa to Mumbai, today I am forced to pay Rs 1,540, can I afford such expensive travel? Today travelling by 2nd Class reserved compartment is a nightmare and just next to impossible, the compartment is so cramped that any movement in the compartment is just impossible, because as a senior citizen, children or women we just cannot go to the toilet, no TC comes to the compartment to check the ticket, people drink, quarrel and abuse and what nonsense is happening in our wonderful railways. We do not want a Vande Bharat train, it's meant for the rich. Why does a common man to pay gst to the state as well as Central Government, why is petrol cost so high because of which cost living has gone up so high the only the common man and poor man is suffering because he either has no job or a poor salary. Why do I have to pay Gst on a cup of Tea l have in a Hotel, why is the cost of a gas cylinder so which a poor man cannot, so is it worth having free rice only. What are we seeing happen in our country today nothing but burning of churches, murdering the innocent, raping our women, allowing criminals like Brijbushan Singh who humiliated our gold winning wrestlers to shamelessly roam freely in our country, what about the 11 convicts who released prematurely for the heinous crime they committed on bilkisBano, murdered her 3 year daughter and murdered her 14 relatives, Why [is Ram Rahim given parole once again? People of India just think about this. Open your eyes, look for truths, we all need respect to live a decent life and quality life . Just think about it. Darryl Goa
@sudarsanbabu2900
4 ай бұрын
But the people are brainwashed by bjp supported medias.
God Bless You eternally for the great job you are doing in a Courages and fearless manner. It is written Those who exault themselves shall be brought low and those who humble themselves shall be exaulted. We believe in this promise we thank You and wait on You and know that you are God.
Really worth following you... Great and fact filled naration which must be translated and reach to every Indian...
Would like to thank Mr. Sujit Nair of HW News Channel for this excellent information as being told by him in this above video. All this while, I used to think that only people who received or have any amount of money that is over and above the Taxpayble limit only pay taxes. I suppose many persons like me would certainly not be aware that all the people of India including a Beggar , know that all of us pay taxes. By saying that whnever we purchase any item such as Biscuits, or whatever items, we also pay the GST and other taxes. And that these taxes are made use by the ruling Govt to improve the country by using this money to construct roads, build bridges, introduce new trains etc etc. So Mr Sujit Nair, if he is saying all this information with Authenticity, then he should be highly applauded.I also wish to add that the statement made about using some important Leader's photograph on Ration Cards or Receipts was very good information.
@SATISH_KUMAR-Bhuj
3 ай бұрын
There is not a single person in our country who doesn't pay taxes, however the poorest class get more benefits than what they pay, which is justified too.
Excellent Editorial, Greatful to you Sir
Thanks Mr Nair, for reminding people the common factors that often we forget the democracy, ' of the people, for the people and by the people' , we all must stand strongly against the notorious autocratic attitude.
With such misplaced priorities, one wonders how the rank of 107 out of 121 countries in the 2022 Global Hunger Index could be blamed on some incorrect calculating methodology! Why doesn't this state just put up the required signs alongside similar ones (or maybe even bigger) of its local leader?
Shocking revelation
Very well presented Sir
If this is ramrajya then I hate it the most
West Bengal common man is a Bharatiya citizen
Excellent Sir. Thank you.
Rightly said...
Mr. Sujit you need to make this in a language that our domestic help and drivers , rickshaw drivers can understand.. they are the ones who need to know the facts .
You are doing wonderful job Mr. Sujit sir.
This is a matter where the Supreme Court should step in as they have done with returning the Bilkis Bano rapists to jail. But while the SC take suo moto cognizance of such blatant misuse of power by the Central Government headed by the despot Modi?
Great analysis..! Very true..! We must change this system..
It's pathetic that no opposition parties even raise a concern about it. They all r proud about country's GDP while half of population denied their deserving rice, sugar, flour and other essentials to keep their stomach half-full. 😢
@philomenasequeira6083
4 ай бұрын
The Congress party under the Gandhi Parivar is to blame for India not having a proper opposition.
@kirankoti6316
4 ай бұрын
Half a population denied their deserving rice?😂😂😂
@thepeacefulwarrior2879
4 ай бұрын
@@philomenasequeira6083 don't expect a strong opposition when you haven't voted for one.
So ridiculous !!
Well said sir 👌
Brilliant episode.
Superb.
Sir you are 100 p.c correct. I just don't know why many people are crazy about Modiji.Why do they need to put PMs photos.
Bravo Sujit Nair! Keep up the spirited exposures of hypocrisy!
The day every citizen of our country understands that the money spent by the governments if public money, our money, we will start to become prosperous…..
How much tax payers money are spent after Ayodhya ? It is BJP party's programme and not nation's programme.
We will die shouting and making points to people bt untill these andh bhakti of people not wake up.. nothing going to change sir.. its not peoples govt. Bt people under monarch..
You surely have a point, but again democracy is a self-modifying paradigm, if the people/party in power are really that bad then they will be removed from power by the people. Have faith in the people of India.
Pathetic state of affairs.
❤Great ❤
Sir simply great presentation of facts hope the litterate understand their ignorance 😢
Wah Modaniji Wah, Ache din?!!! Modaniji deserves Oscar 👏
West Bengal Govt, accepts foodgrains from Union Govt and publicizes it as if it's from Govt of West Bengal!! Hats off to such sculdgery of WB govt!!
So painful . What a funny decision
It shows the dignity levels of those who deny ration for the people of the same country
Gautama BUDDHA said: The SUN ☀️ The MOON 🌙 and THE TRUTH cannot remain Hidden for ever ‼️ INQUILAB ZINDABAD 🎉
To bengal goverment, just put the banner in 1 inch x 2 inch somewhere in the corner to avoid penalty, which is also illegal in this case.
Modi government should order immediate inquiry into the allegations.Why Bengal government approchs media and noi go to the court?
Good video. Some honest feedback. When you produce a video based on a news article please make sure you share the article in the description. It will make the video more credible and the original author will also get some publicity which they deserve. Please
A time isn't so far when Smriti's photo will also be compulsory for all the shops and business organizations.
We should file case in supreme court against people who are imposing stupid conditions for taking ration. And basic needs. Can it be possible? Is PIL possible for this?
Very convincing
We see the PMs photos on all Petrol Pumps and now we have to see him on all Ration Shops also.
People should know where the ration is coming from, centre or the state.
The public is sleeping. They buy the stories of politicians. They buy personalities of politicians. They have forgotten that the politicians are paid servants. Kalyuga
I'm waiting for your last point Mr.Sujith! It happened in SRILANKA very recently!
No Photo No Food No EVM NO Election No Godi No News Say No to Democracy
Saddest reality of today's India where one party wants to become supreme leader without being answerable to the nation or the institutions.
A video that lays bare how brutal politics does not even spare the poorest of the poor.
Toronto
West Bengal has got tones of photographs of CM on streets here .
Lets flip the narrative: Just because Mamata has to apply the logo and the PM’s face she is causing the poor amd the needy to go hungry?? Is your ego so Important Mamata Begum??
It is high time that West Bengal goes its own separate way....as an INDEPENDENT COUNTRY.
Sir God bless you and your family members with team members.sir i will keep Modi ji and Shah ji photos please release we will put Modi ji photos on all shops.like gandhiji photos
PM will even take credit for ensuring people of WB are made to starve for not putting his photo. HW should come up with a video and show how much of taxpayers money is spent on such publicity.
Utter shame
By the way whose money is this😡..n u said it sujit saab
Correct.. Every Indian Pays Taxes.. The Credit goes to all Indians... There is nothing given Free 😀 Sad Very Sad System...
Why the photo is not provided ..wb should follow other state if maitaung the records upto date
Camr back to HW editiorial news after a year of not watching . Liked HW initally around 2-3 yrs ago then left disapointed adter seeing one sided narrative. No change seen in the editorial epiaode even now. Still only one sided view being shown. Sincere suggestion - Please guve a balanced view / view from both sides. HW and Print started at same time. But difference in subscriber is 10 times more in The Print. Because they give both sides of the story. One thing i liked and still do is the way you talk and present the editorial.(liked your editorial on the issue and the courage you showed in changing your stand )Hope to see some changes in future byy bringing in balanced view. Surely the govt has done some good things in last 10 years. And surely the opposition has made few mistkaes in the same rime frame. Please show both . All the best. P.S i hooe you dont delete this but take ir as aconstructive suggestuon.