I LOVE the Dune universe and its a great pleasure to bring you all another look at daily life on Arrakis! I'll be making the art available for download on Patreon so check it out to get some amazing illustrations from Beverly Johnson and support the channel: www.patreon.com/InvictaHistory

@orionstark

2 ай бұрын

If you loved Dune, then you would not make this crap. This is hack work made for shilling.

@TripleNpple

2 ай бұрын

Seriously don't see your videos anymore on my feed :( I think you tube is down playing you. I hate youtube 😒

Honestly, fictional or historical, how someone grows up in a society is super interesting and fundamental to understanding their culture.

@InvictaHistory

2 ай бұрын

Same, the "Growing Up" series is one of my favorites

@MatthewTheWanderer

2 ай бұрын

@@InvictaHistory This and anything showing what the lives of regular people were like!

Bless the maker and his water Bless the coming and going of him May his passage cleanse the world May he keep the world for his people

No phones in sight. Just people living in the moment. And inhaling spices.

@RezaQin

2 ай бұрын

*worm sperm lol

The Dune Encyclopedia really was something else. It's a shame we'll likely never see a reprint of it in Brian Herbert's lifetime, if ever.

Fremen vs Sardaukar AKA Space Arabs vs Space Mongolians

@Princeps7289

2 ай бұрын

I always saw the Sardaukar and the Emperor as either Persian or Ottoman.

@dziban303

2 ай бұрын

yeah s/he's referring to the mongolian throat singing in the film ​@@Princeps7289

@jacavanheesch4593

2 ай бұрын

@@Princeps7289 in them movies they troat sing that why the guy above thinks of them as mongolians

@jays2551

2 ай бұрын

I always thought of the sardaukar as space spartans, since the rite of passage for becoming a sardaukar warrior is an increasingly intense series of trials in the wilderness. and they're thrown into that wilderness as children, alone and defenseless, also similar to the rite of passage for a male from sparta

@HolyNorthAmericanEmpire

2 ай бұрын

@@jays2551 I am aware that the Sardaukar are inspired by many warrior cultures throughout history. They are brought up like spartans, they fight like Samurai, they are faithful like knights and loyal like the Immortals, royal elite guards like the Praetorians. However in the movies they also are depicted to throat sing like Mongolians. Which were also once a great Empire with renowned warriors. I think in one of the novels Genghis Khan is actually accidentally thought to be a Sardaukar by one of the characters, could be wrong though. The Sardaukar (and Fremen) are essentially the culmination of every great warrior culture in our history.

Invicta's Growing Up series *and* sci-fi worldbuilding rooted in real life cultures? You have my undivided attention

@coreystockdale6287

2 ай бұрын

Funny traveling man is here guys

As a woman, Fremen menstruation sounds fascinating. Instead of monthly periods, the women might have 6 or less periods per year. Without sounding too gross, the periods might be little dried clots like beef jerky bits mostly devoid of water.

What an awesome video; world building and exploration is endlessly fascinating. Proud to be a sponsor of this one!

* Whispers as Invicta drops video * Lisan al Gaib....*clicks with much reverence *

You should do a battle animation for Paul’s utter capitulation of the emperors army. Seems people don’t understand how Paul used combined arms tactics, and his prescience in detecting the incoming storm to neutralize the air superiority of the emperors force. It was literally the perfect storm, and people think the sardukar were just nerfed..

@yaujj65

2 ай бұрын

I mean I saw the movie and I can see the Emperor army is woefully unprepared. It doesn't matter if you are very skilled, tactics is the deciding factor in battle. Logistics is for wars but that a story for another day.

@pinchevulpes

2 ай бұрын

@@yaujj65 the army wasn’t unprepared they just didn’t have enough time to deploy in proper formation and first FIND where Maud’ib was. Maud’ib came and ambushed the emperor using the cover of the storm. I think this mirrors the attitude in the emperor from the former duke leto that he would have time from the moment he arrived to deal with an attack, both were given neither.

@yaujj65

2 ай бұрын

@@pinchevulpes I mean that what I mean by unprepared. Because they are in the middle of mobilising. A storm hit them and a group of worms strike at the army before combat ensues.

@pinchevulpes

2 ай бұрын

@@yaujj65 a storm Paul knew would be there at that exact moment and planned his entire ambush around, that’s the advantage of prescience, it doesn’t matter how prepared or unprepared you are. The Mahdi can see whenever you’ll be, when, and with whom. An unassailable advantage indeed.

@yaujj65

2 ай бұрын

@@pinchevulpes Of course prescience plays a huge role in the battle, no doubt about it.

Hey, it would be really cool if you made a video on the Harkonnen army and what growing up on Geidi Prime was like.

Gorgeous video! Thanks for putting out more Dune material 😃

The spice must flow!

What happens if you add Spice to like...food?

@InvictaHistory

2 ай бұрын

Apparently its a pretty regular part of the Fremen diet, at least in trace amounts. I believe it will add some flavor and pass on traits such as extended life and the blue eyes.

@dziban303

2 ай бұрын

@bagel3703 the books say it tastes like cinnamon and allspice

@AlexandruSD

2 ай бұрын

I would be curious how you add food to spice. There are no animals to hunt, and I haven't seen a single greenhouse on the entire planet.

@stalfithrildi5366

2 ай бұрын

Oi mate, you can't add spice to food its 'ighly illegal

Really enjoying these Dune videos you've been doing. Hopefully there are other fictional worlds you plan to dive into

Excellent Video! Like the rest of this collection!!

@jeffreykwan9330

2 ай бұрын

Addam Reshii A-Zanta!

Long live the fighters!!!

@jeffreykwan9330

2 ай бұрын

Addam Reshii A-Zanta!

Now I'm convinced to read Dune.

Cool concept!

Couldn't click play fast enough! Love your content

Harsh climate breeds a hard people

I would LOVE the score to this video! The music is fantastic!

Love it!

Bless the Maker and His water. Bless the coming and going of Him. May His passage cleanse the world. May He keep the world for His people.

As a Dutchmen I have to say that the presence of spice is *very* attractive.

I gotta say, I actually like the book sponsorship I actually listened/got intrigued by it, instead of ignorig it like the usual sponsors

@rowanalexandriabennett

2 ай бұрын

Thanks so much! I really hope you give my book a shot.

I love the Dune series! Read the books many times! Thanks. I don’t find many Dune fans these days! Wish Peter Jackson was a huge Dune fan!

Wow. Your Dune videos are amazing. 👍#dunefan

Love it! Will we be getting a Fallout lore video too? :)

5:41 akrep is scorpion in Turkish, just wiktionary'd it and yes, it comes to Turkish from Arabic aqrab

AS IT WAS WRITTEN!

Waaaitttt let me get some coffee

Make a playlist please

Have you guys ever read the Red Rising series? If your into Dune you'll probably love it as it definitely takes a ton of inspiration from Dune. It also has a LOT of historical references to ancient Rome/Greece as the inspiration for ruling society with smaller culture groups being based off other historical groups like the Vikings, so it's filled to the brim with fun historical Easter eggs for the reader to catch as many of the events are definitely based on old fantastical tales.

Lisan al Gaib!

Give us a part 2 to the true size of the tyranid swarm

Hey invicta make shorts. I think you tube change something and your vids aren't getting to all your subscribers. That notification button makes a huge difference now and most of us need to update our preferences to your channel. Btw great video

Is this video based on official lore?

@InvictaHistory

2 ай бұрын

Parts are pulled from mentions in the official book, other come from supplemental material like the Dune Encyclopedia or the RPG handbook

You guys should make a units of history about the United States secret service I feel like a lot of people just think of them as guys in suites

Time to move to the arabian desert and join a nomadic Bedouin tribe.

I can answer what life is like. It’s thirsty

@rimacalid6557

2 ай бұрын

Maybe the hakonen world planet is more suitable then

To be honest the idea of the author of a society which members kill each other so frequently just to proove that they are full "adult" was at least a little bit bonkers. I mean a duel is a intern affair which more weakens the tribe than it makes him stronger. Well, the victory of the Fremen over the Empire of their galaxy was maybe a little bit less stupid than the role of the Ewoks in defeating the Galactic Empire in the SW-Galaxy, but only a little... And both are strange people to choose as allies.

@yaujj65

2 ай бұрын

About the Ewoks, they did help in the battle but never the decisive factor. It gave the Rebels space to fight back.

I don't know about the lore because I don't watch Dune well thanks for the video anyway

If every male has to kill another male to marry, and might kill multiple other males, and if males have the extremely dangerous sandworm riding rite of passage and are also the warriors... you'd expect a ratio of like 3+ women per man. But I feel like we don't quite see that? it looks more like 1.5:1 or something closer to that.

@MichaelRainey

2 ай бұрын

It doesn't have to be another Fremen. They can take the water off some soft offworlder.

@owlfrog

2 ай бұрын

@@MichaelRainey That's a good point. I am not a Dune expert, but my impression is that they have relatively little contact with offworlders. But maybe they don't, and we should think they are killing Harkonnen workers regularly? Seems like there would be more vicious reprisals if so, though...

@MichaelRainey

2 ай бұрын

At least in the books the Fremen didn't seem too hung up on polygamy either. Paul "married" Jamis's widow before he was with Chani or Irulan.

Lisan al Gayiiiiiiib!!!

Warhammer 40k cadian shock troops or catachan jungle fighters

At least you can ride giant worms for fun

can you do a growing up a zack snyder character next?

13:04 So is there like 2 men for every woman in Fremen society?

Growing up Fremen: "And then came the witch and the false Messiah Atreides".

@PatrickOMulligan

2 ай бұрын

Heresy!

@ezio4546

2 ай бұрын

Silence!

@jeffreykwan9330

2 ай бұрын

Blasphemy!

Also, sand. Alot of sand. In all places. Sand.

@MichaelRainey

2 ай бұрын

It's rough and it's coarse and it gets everywhere.

Loving the dune lore but it seems counter productive to kill other warriors just to marry lol

Is this fiction or non- fiction?

@RexoryByzaboo

2 ай бұрын

Fiction.

algo comment

you didn’t mention their islamic traditions such as fasting and so on. still interesting to see this in a video like this!

@toxion_8

2 ай бұрын

They aren't exactly Muslim. They're ZenSunni. A form of IslamoBuddhism.

@muslimresponse103

2 ай бұрын

@@toxion_8 well he could explain all those specifics. its obviously an important part of growing up.

@georgecristiancripcia4819

2 ай бұрын

​@@muslimresponse103 He did so in other videos on this subject.

@InvictaHistory

2 ай бұрын

​@muslimresponse103 we worked in those details in the earlier "Origins of the Fremen" episode but I'm with you that we could have repeated some of it. Ultimately though we will stitch all these parts together into a History of the Fremen super-cur

@muslimresponse103

2 ай бұрын

@@InvictaHistory thank you for replying! i can’t wait to see the full length video. I’m not a fan of these shorter videos that come once in a blue moon because i have already forgot the previous videos on Dune that you made. i have the same issue with other channels cutting up videos. i would rather watch a 3 hour video on a subject than many short videos on the same subject over a period of months.

He took a lot of Islamic practices

I would have expected to hear that the Fremen kill all babies who are mentally or physical disabled, considering them at a waste of food and water. I mean given the brutally of the Fremen and that it is expected that children did participate from so young age, I can not imagine that they have any patience or mercy with anyone who can do their part... However I was never realy convinced with this Fremen-hype as the super-duper-badass🙄. I can accept that they beat the Sardaukar in survival skills (of course only in the desert) - but in combat? Na, I am not convinced. After all they still have to WORK/grow food/repairing etc., while the Sardaukar are fulltime soldiers. It is this (i. m. o. a little bit silly or at least naive or short-sighted) idea that the "noble savage" always beat the professional soldiers. This cliche is so overused, I am a little bit sick of it.😉

@13darkjems

2 ай бұрын

Some of my favorite characters are disabled people in really tough "kill disabled babies" societies. It adds to the stakes. Makes for good stories. I feel like a story about a disabled fremin kid would be cool.

Blue, within blue yes.... no whites in them...

Did you used to produce good content? I don't remember. :)

This is a waste of your time and energy. I do not care to learn about fictional people based on someone's fantasies about space Berbers.

@AIartificalIntellige

2 ай бұрын

C R Y

@13darkjems

2 ай бұрын

No art that someone, even the maker, enjoys is waisted. Also, you sound rude.

@orionstark

2 ай бұрын

@@13darkjems this is not art. This is a documentary about fictional people living in an imaginary world.

@13darkjems

2 ай бұрын

@@orionstark that's... that's art my guy. "something that is created with imagination and skill and that is beautiful or that expresses important ideas or feelings."

@orionstark

2 ай бұрын

@@13darkjems documentaries are the opposite of art. If you are making art, you are not conveying facts. I do not want facts about made up things on my history documentary channel and you are a bully. I am entitled to my opinion and you are entitled to go duck yourself.