Erik here! You’re welcome to disagree with my analysis that Paul is *using* Chani and that his affection for her isn’t sincere. I derive my take from Paul’s early exchange with Jessica, when they have first arrived to Sietch Tabr and they’re eating separate from the others. Paul whispers about the need to disrupt spice production to get the emperor’s attention. This, along with his telepathic exchange with Alia in the womb (his opening words in the movie), led me to believe that Villeneuve wants us to think that Paul views the Fremen as a means to an end, and that he feels this way from the beginning of Part Two. Yes, it’s clear that he begins to feel affection for Chani. But that affection peaks when she reveals her name as Desert Spring and ties herself to Paul’s “prophetic” purpose. I also believe this is part of the reason Timothee Chalamet was cast, and that the movie doesn’t include any significant internal time jumps showing Paul’s aging and Alia’s birth. Chalamet’s greatest asset as an actor are his skill at playing believably and empathetically lovetorn youths (Call Me By Your Name, Little Women) while bringing the charisma of a theater kid cast in his first starring role who learns how to project his big-boy voice to the back row. Villeneuve wanted to show us a kid who understands the political advantage of an alliance with a group, calculating his immersion into that group, start to genuinely feel chemistry with a woman in that group, but most importantly, that chemistry is the product of a political agenda that was stated by the character at the outset of the film in two scenes. I understand Chani had a different role in Herbert’s text. But I believe Villeneuve uses her character to better deliver the themes that Herbert felt some readers missed: that Paul’s relationship with the Fremen - all of the Fremen - amounts to a betrayal… even if he believes he’s doing the right thing. We end the film with Chani’s anger to deliver that point. Again, feel free to disagree with this analysis, but it’s grounded in evidence of Villeneuve’s choices.

@joshpartridge760

2 ай бұрын

the way I see it why then would he sabotage himself by telling Stilgar that Jessica trained to endure the water of life and that it was a staged prophesy - or did he see the future and know that this would make Stilgar believe more

@Jessica-xc6vn

2 ай бұрын

Your take on Paul's motives and psychology really flattens him into a one dimensional evil character which is not what the author or director had in mind.

@QueendomCome621

2 ай бұрын

​@Jessica-xc6vn I agree. His take is definitely off here. The relationship is definitely much more nuanced.

@blackmetaldevil2

2 ай бұрын

I’d say his engagement to Irulan is the means to an end. He ONLY loves Chani. That never changes in the books and I don’t see it changing in future sequels. You were off on this one.

@bensonbenson8729

2 ай бұрын

I do not think you read the books more than once. At that it was probably a trace read to say you have.

Anya Taylor Joy went through extreme diet and method acting to play a fetus in Dune: Part Two. Oscar-worthy tbh

@mystuff6045

Ай бұрын

LMAO

@reviveithomeimprovement2495

Ай бұрын

Soda just sprayed out of my face. Thank you

@gox123

Ай бұрын

Hilarious

@queenseabee8113

Ай бұрын

Wow...just wow. LoL!

@dong7598

Ай бұрын

🫡

I disagree that Paul was using Chani. To keep going on the road he is on he marries Irulan. That doesn't mean he doesn't love Chani.

@Ontir

2 ай бұрын

Paul ONLY loves Chani. Irulan is a means to an end.

@mikethejedi1982

2 ай бұрын

Thank you. I came here looking for this.

@gregmeli951

2 ай бұрын

@@Ontir This was my understanding as well

@jessicareichard2500

2 ай бұрын

Agreed. In both Dune and Messiah Paul only ever makes love with (has children with) Chani. Marrying Princess Irulan is to gain power and become the next Emperor.

@broderickfoster2107

2 ай бұрын

@@jessicareichard2500isn’t there a quote in the book where it’s like “we may be concubines but history will remember us as wives?”

It is so refreshing to see a director as talented as Denis Villeneuve be provided with the budget to bring us the Dune Franchise!

@liamn.7664

2 ай бұрын

yeah fr that just shows the studio really cares about these films

@madtitan0825

2 ай бұрын

@@liamn.7664WB who also shelved movies for tax write off? Lol

@ryanmoorehead2945

2 ай бұрын

He had that budget for blade runner almost a decade ago, yet no one went to support it. They've had faith in him, but does the general audience?

@happytrailsgaming

2 ай бұрын

@@ryanmoorehead2945theaters are full for this movie since release in my area so yeah. Blade runner is known by those that like good movies

@brandocalrissian3294

2 ай бұрын

He ruined it. The ending was terrible and he changed stilgar and chani to be completely different than their book counterparts.

Paul wasn’t using Chani…. And it wasn’t all acting, he had struggle, that’s why he restrained himself from going south…. Did we watch the same movie? 😅

@kungfumatts

2 ай бұрын

My thoughts exactly. 😆

@joasbenjamin6804

2 ай бұрын

Exactly 😂

@forfun6273

2 ай бұрын

Right. It’s like he didn’t watch it but was told what happened in it and a lot was lost in translation.

@kentonsmith4214

2 ай бұрын

Chani ….. sounded like Jonny in the cinema I saw it at 😂

@madamgigi

2 ай бұрын

​@@kentonsmith4214 I thought the same

Paul really does love Chani. It's Irulan he is using. Usul isn't a surname, it's his 'secret' name. Maud'dib is his public name.

@elisebrown5157

2 ай бұрын

I was hoping Jessica would have the final line, telling Chani that "history will call us wives."

@gavinmcconnell1219

2 ай бұрын

@@elisebrown5157 Isn't Jessica called his concubine consistently throughout the future books?

@jadetrentrichards255

2 ай бұрын

that would be suuper weird to have his mother called a concubine.@@gavinmcconnell1219

@mikaylarose8198

Ай бұрын

@@gavinmcconnell1219she was Leto’s “concubine.”

@phil4986

Ай бұрын

THIS And Irulan will find out in the third Dune. Chani comes back into the picture. Probably only to be killed by Irulan right in front of Paul.

idk why you acted like Paul was only manipulating the whole time, there was clearly conflict there and a transition over time with the final turning point where he drank the water of life and got the visions of a single path

@T-Roy-G

2 ай бұрын

Agreed

@DatBoiChris420

2 ай бұрын

Because he didnt actually watch the movie lmfao someone else watched it. Wrote the script for this video

@Anxyte

2 ай бұрын

Fr i thought i watched a whole different movie lmaoo

@emkas36

2 ай бұрын

Yup. Whoever watched the movie clearly hasn’t read the books and didn’t thoroughly research their ideas- first time I’m disappointed in NR, which considering the number of their videos it not too shabby tho

@Hashbandocoot

2 ай бұрын

Even after the water of life Paul professed his love for chani…I don’t think Paul was using anyone, it just seems that way when he realizes his revenge also aligns with the path.

IMAX gave us Earthquake experience when they used Sandworms to attack the capital

@ThePaddyandtheFag

2 ай бұрын

I was in a dooby atmos showing, and literally the whole theater shook. In the reclining seat? Felt amazing

@drisshansfreetime453

2 ай бұрын

For real!!!! ❤

@jessicareichard2500

2 ай бұрын

I couldn't tell if my heart was beating or the seat was shaking for that scene.

@Yupstate845

2 ай бұрын

Fr fr fr😊

@LifeLeftAjar

2 ай бұрын

We went to see it on Dolby and we experienced the same and it was so satisfying!

Everyone who agrees that Paul was NOT manipulating the Fremen the whole time and NOT lying about everything. 👇

@myawilkes7560

2 ай бұрын

Agree.

@dan816ful

Ай бұрын

The movie kinda shows him manipulating them. But I never got that from the book

@MrThibault6969

Ай бұрын

@@dan816fulI dont agree. I feel like he goes straight to the point and do what he has to do because now he sees everything and knows that there's only one way for them to live\win. I dont take it as manipulation, more like I dont care what you think, I'm doing what I have to do for the good of the people. I also think he truly love Chani and it broke his hart to marry the emperor's daughter but still does it for the greater good. However, I didnt read the books ...yet. Ordering them tonight haha

@cityoftrees9953

Ай бұрын

@@MrThibault6969Paul also never wanted to go to the south knowing what would happen. So how did he take advantage of the freemen

@o.z.3154

Ай бұрын

Well he knew what he was doing. This is why he yelled at his mother saying what the bene gessurit did was “NOT HOPE” its religious deception. Although i do think he has their best interest in mind

Okay but the way Feyd and Paul stab each other alluded to the way Gurney caught Paul in their training session (Dune 1). That was slick.

it's a bit inaccurate to say that Paul was just using Chani from the start. I think its pretty clear he did love her, even after taking the water of life and realizing what needed to be done

@bobmarley1686

Ай бұрын

Did the Story tell that? No.

@NeillY0

Ай бұрын

@@bobmarley1686lol the story didn’t say otherwise either.

@Shadoukuron

18 күн бұрын

@@bobmarley1686 bruh, they gonna have kids and shit

Dune Pt. 2 had many chilling scenes, but the one where Paul addresses the people in the war council in the south tops them all IMHO. It was a "oh dang, this is how ascend to power works" moment.

@dashcamvids

Ай бұрын

I agree, i loved the scene and way Timothee performed.

@vergelvelasquez

Ай бұрын

gave me chills to the spine

@960456

Ай бұрын

Agreed. I loved how Dune 2 leaned into the fact that Paul is not a good person for the Fremen, in the end.

I saw this movie yesterday, and while I haven't read the books in about 25 years, I was impressed that the film was able to achieve close to a level of nuance, and convey the manipulation that was present in the novels. Dune: Part 2 is spectacular visually, incredibly well-acted, and the score has majesty to it. I adore it. Highly recommend.

@Ttyumbra

2 ай бұрын

So how many books are left for the films to adapt for dune?

@KonohasYeIlowFlash

2 ай бұрын

@@TtyumbraI think Denis will only do the second book-there are five more books. There’s a lot of room in the Dune universe to do several mini-series. I’m looking forward to the Bene Gesserit series coming to Max later this year.

Paul doesn't hear Chani say place the thumper lower. It shows he remembers his training from Chani and Stilgar

@Dudemon-1

2 ай бұрын

Yeah, but that viewing point was great for Paul to walk a few meters away, catch a worm, plow through several large dunes for a few minutes before getting up in time to pass the spectators. I guess the Shai-Hulud was doing laps, confused by the thumper in its gullet!

@nailinthefashion

23 күн бұрын

@@Dudemon-1imagine he just does donuts and gives Chani a good yeehaw lmao

@tuz2tuz229

18 күн бұрын

This video has multiple inaccuracies, a little disappointing cause they are pretty blatant too

He was not using Chani. He only decided to go along with the prophecy once he realized it was the only way to save them. Chani is his true love.

@whiterosemotors9026

Ай бұрын

I feel like this is blatantly obvious. But, I haven't read the books so idk

Dune: Part Two was my most anticipated film for the past three years and it didn’t disappoint. Denis managed to exceed all of my expectations. Not only is Part Two my favorite film of the year but now of all time surpassing The Wizard of Oz (1939) which was my favorite film of all time for over a decade and a half. Long live cinema!

@24JesseD

2 ай бұрын

It may have cracked my top 10. Hans Zimmer never disappoints. Cinematography at A+ levels again as well.

@forfun6273

2 ай бұрын

I try to wait before I judge a film. I like it to hold up. Like I thought avengers endgame was amazing the first time I saw it. But now it’s ok but I wouldn’t say it’s one of the best movies. This movie is definitely really good. I think after watching it a few times you get a better perspective. But yeah this is one of the best movies I’ve watched. But we’ll see how it holds up. I don’t see it falling off like endgame though.

@pttthhh

2 ай бұрын

@@forfun6273 I don't think it can fall off like Endgame. Endgame was good and engaging, even fun, but we got to see what happened to everyone. That's what was so good about it. But it wasn't the best..

@forfun6273

2 ай бұрын

@@pttthhh yeah I agree.

@randyschwaggins

11 күн бұрын

The Marvels was a much better film

I think the move that Paul uses to stab na-Baron was a nod to Gurney's lesson from Part 1 as well, a little detail I liked.

@spidavenom4

2 ай бұрын

Yuuuup. I got that right away

@hkalisvaart

2 ай бұрын

It's a damn the character that kills the Baron and has a whole character arc because of it isn't even born yet in the movie, what do we do now, moment.

@BeGo127

2 ай бұрын

Yess!!! That scene reminded me of that!

@maxwinterburn1513

2 ай бұрын

Yep, defo got that

The bombing wasn't on the spice plant but on the "shield wall" mountains that surround Arrakeen. So that Stilgar could attack with the worms.

@Virakotxa

Ай бұрын

So many omissions in the world-building, making no mention about the prohibition of using nukes about troops, laser-shield explosions, and the code of the Great Convention... No wonder people are confused.

@OutHereOnTheFlats

Ай бұрын

correct

Paul’s salute to Feyd-Rautha was a call back to when he took Jamis’ life. Jamis said it to him before they fought.

@bendicion2010

2 ай бұрын

Yes and no, that is just a common saying among the Fremen before a duel

@objectdefiance4027

2 ай бұрын

He was also Honouring Duncan Idaho.

@tedczarnecki7351

2 ай бұрын

I remember the "apparently" winning move from his training with Gurney in Dune 1

@makeyourmark00

Ай бұрын

It's actually emblematic of who Paul (Muad'Dib) has become. A leader of and from two worlds. The raising of the blade to the shoulder and then forehead is a House Atreides pre-battle gesture, whereas the motto "May thy knife/blade chip and shatter" is Fremen.

@Sylla402

25 күн бұрын

That's just Paul being a Fremen, it's their way.

The book actually says “Once men turned their thinking over to machines in the hope that this would set them free. But that only permitted other men with machines to enslave them.” So it's implied that the Butlerian Jihad wasn't just against thinking machines but against men using thinking machines to enslave others.

@bbartky

2 ай бұрын

Thank you! The book is very clear that it’s not a war of machines against humans but a war between humans. That’s why I only consider the books by Frank Herbert to be canon. It makes me so mad that Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson made it like the Terminator movies.

@Ontir

2 ай бұрын

The Titans who were men merged with thinking machines.

@demistic1248

2 ай бұрын

Actually, according the book, "Dune: The Butlerian Jihad" it was a war against both Thinking Machine AND Humans who had merged with machines.

@bbartky

2 ай бұрын

@@demistic1248 Yes, that’s in book by Brian Herbert and Kevin Anderson, which to me is nothing more than fanfic. And it completely contradicts what Frank Herbert wrote in _Dune_ .

@demistic1248

2 ай бұрын

@@bbartky The books were written based on Frank Herbert's own notes. Considering these were the same duo that ended up completing the Dune saga for Frank Herbert after his passing, I believe they have enough in sight to be considered a bit more reliable than standard fanfic. 🤷‍♂

I've had such a great day with my son, we were watching Dune part 1 here at home while having a nice dinner, the went to the city to watch part 2 on the cinema, 5+ hours of awesomeness. We both agreed that part 1 was 9 stars and part 2 10 stars. Part 2 was probably the best film I've seen since the The Lord of the Rings, and just as good. Something hard to admit for a massive Tolkien fan. Also, there's been a temperature above 10 Celsius today, at the second day of spring, after a really hard winter here in Norway, that made it feel like summer compared to how it has been. 🙂

@kishenkoolskills90

2 ай бұрын

I have never seen Lord of the Rings but enjoyed Dune Part 1 and 2

@froggerus2

21 күн бұрын

@@kishenkoolskills90 Lucky bastard... I'd give anything to be able to see LotR again for the first time :P Go for it!

I got Dune Spice fever... And the only cure for it is more Dune Spice! 😂😂😂

@YourXLNerd

Ай бұрын

i'm like any other fremen, i put my still suit on one nostril at a time

@gojo8082

Ай бұрын

Cow bell!!!

@alexanderbarrera9140

22 күн бұрын

Joe dirt joe dirt!!!!

That scene where Paul rides the worm for the first time was amazing with the Prime Rumble Seats. This was an epic movie. I want to see it again.

@method341

2 ай бұрын

Me too. I can't stop thinking about it. I watched it in 70mm but I want to go see it again at IMAX.

I think your take on how Paul’s manipulating the whole time is all wrong. He’s genuinely concerned with the visions he’s seeing of billions dying. And holy warriors worshipping at the shrine of his father’s skull. He doesn’t want all this death attached to him. For most of the movie he’s avoiding going south because that path may bring death to billions.

@tedczarnecki7351

2 ай бұрын

As much as I liked the film, including the nuance, I still felt Paul's move from reluctant messiah to confident one was under explained. I am sure all will be revealed in Dune 3

@carolyns3720

2 ай бұрын

@@tedczarnecki7351it was explained by him taking the Water of Life

@BullGator-kd6ge

2 ай бұрын

@@tedczarnecki7351 His change in attitude came from him not predicting the Harkonen attack on Sietch Tabr despite his previous ones being accurate. He took the Water of Life so that he’d have a better understanding of the future.

@justjuniorjaw

Ай бұрын

​@@tedczarnecki7351Under explained? We spent the first half talking about how he's hesistant and in search for answers hear that he can see everything from drinking the water of life. He went and did it, and all his actions changed due to it. The water of life made him see clearly, and his actions speaks louder than any monologue he could've done after the setup of the 1st half.

@fallacyinc2215

Ай бұрын

@@tedczarnecki7351I agree that the movie didn’t do enough to explain the change. In the book it’s made clear that when Paul, the first male ever to survive the drinking of the water of life, the thing the bene gesserit had been trying to make possible for 10000 years of selective breeding, effectively became omniscient. Access to all of his male and female ancestral memories, as well as “prescience”, future sight, combined with “mentat” training to act as a human calculator. He’s literally all knowing. That’s why his personality changes. He can see the past and all futures, and has to try to forcibly bring about the one that has the least bloodshed in the end

Such a weird take/ interpretation of the movie imo. I think it was pretty clear Paul was not using Chani from the beginning. It seemed apparent that he desperately did not want to be the Lisan Al Gaib but only after drinking the Water of Life that he embraced it.

I don't think Paul put the ring away to hide his nobility. Wearing a ring is not good if you are a warrior because it can get snagged on something. It also would not be smart to wear a shiny object when you are trying to be camouflaged. My thinking is he was having a moment of reflection and wearing the seal to remember his father and then put it away when he needed to go back to his mission.

@itsjustme8947

Ай бұрын

As a certified Dune-nerd, allow me to explain the ring. He put the ring away in the beginning because in order to survive, he had to become Fremen first. He put the ring back on and claimed his Emperor-given fief of Arrakis as its rightful duke for two reasons: 1) To proclaim his authority as leader of a Great House in order to give his claim for the throne legitimacy and (most importantly) 2) By naming himself as Duke of Arrakis, and uniting the tribes under his banner, he no longer had to challenge Stilgar for leadership of Sietch Tabr. Paul: "Is there anyone here who thinks they can best me in single combat? Shall I weaken the tribe by cutting off my right hand?" The answer: "It is the way". Paul's reply? "Ways change."

This was modern day Empire Strikes Back, a great movie that ends on a WTF cliffhanger, can’t wait til we get to see Messiah.

@chickpease

2 ай бұрын

The book influenced Lucas. Star Wars is derivative, not the other way around.

@briengakaplan-b1550

2 ай бұрын

@@chickpease Dune influenced a LOT of sci-fi worlds, that’s very obvious watching some of the same tropes that come up.

@dik56

Ай бұрын

@@chickpease yes but empire strikes back is way more popular. its a fair comparison

If you think he was just using Chani and the Fremen, then you really weren’t paying attention.

Austin butler in this movie, is who Christian Bale’s Gorr the God Butcher was supposed to be in Thor: love and Thunder

@samuelmarchyyy63marchand75

Ай бұрын

Exactly my thoughts

@jacestringham7022

Ай бұрын

That movie was a terrible waste of talent

@allieeh9845

14 күн бұрын

Yup. He may have been my favorite performance.

@Ryker150

9 күн бұрын

Many people finds Austin’s acting pretentious

@Tobywojuola

8 күн бұрын

@@Ryker150 isn't that what acting is all about? Pretending?

It’s been 10 hours since I’ve seen this film, and I’m still awe struck 👏

For me, Villeneuve’s Dune interpretation marks the highest achievement in sci-fi cinema history. We are very lucky to live in a time where we can watch this in the theatre.

@Idrcatall

Ай бұрын

That’s facts, not just you

@aprilratliff8202

Ай бұрын

Agreed!! I got to watch it in huge screen theater with the rumbling seats and everything, it was incredible! I really hope this is one of those films that makes it back to theaters for special screenings every so often. Everyone should get to experience it like that!

@SageO6PathzGON

17 күн бұрын

i mean... i kinda agree. like i just watched it on my laptop unfortunately... but even still that was probably the best sci fi movie ive ever seen... as somone who loves star wars but still isnt my fave ip (marvel forever) that was without question better than any star wars movie ive ever seen

This film is an absolute masterpiece.

the water of life wasn't just about pain.... it opened them up to all of their ancestors living memories....

Paul wasnt using Chani. Denis even said he was excited to make a romance in this movie

Saw it last night and it is STUNNING. I didn't get to see it in IMAX yet as I want to crowds to die down to see it in my IMAX but DAMN!!!

@EagleEye-MJG

2 ай бұрын

I HONESTLY believe the demand for this movie in IMAX will NEVER "die down", until it leaves the theater.

@Zarik15

2 ай бұрын

I saw it last night but not in IMAX, still amazing, but I definitely need to see it in IMAX. Half of the friends I went with didn’t want to pay for IMAX and I came to terms with that, but while watching I definitely saw scenes that were totally meant to IMAX, so I think I’ll go again on Monday for that IMAX experience lol.

@kishenkoolskills90

2 ай бұрын

I went in IMAX and feel I need to watch it many times, Were not getting a 3rd movie anytime soon so it will go down as a modern classic

@Dudemon-1

2 ай бұрын

Stunning in IMAX. The changes made hurt the movie in several ways but helped in others.

@OutHereOnTheFlats

Ай бұрын

Must see in IMAX. The soundtrack with shake you

23:22 I digress, he’s not a monster although it may seem like it. Since he’s got prescience, he’s got to do the things that need to be done. Yes billions may die, but in the long term (thousands of years after) humans would actually flourish if he did this, & if he didn’t extinction might be possible. And I just would like to add that before he drank the h2o of life he wasn’t trying to manipulate anyone. He was just surviving, and wanted to get revenge on the harkonnens. But after he drank it he knew he’s got no other way than to manipulate. That’s why he puts the ring back on. Just a take on it!

@LittleMonkey425

Ай бұрын

Exactly! It. Seems nobody got it, he knew he needed to to be able to win, he needed to manipulate not only for his sake, but for the freeman and also the legacy of his father and house.

My biggest issue is how in the 1st they said the other houses look up to HouseAtreides but even after finding out about the emperors betrayal etc the other houses still didn’t back Paul’s ascension as emperor.

@eilebig

Ай бұрын

Great point

@jordykanange6689

Ай бұрын

Its because they are all greedy and want a chance for control themselves

@wutzittouya3765

Ай бұрын

I thought that too, but I’m guessing they didn’t take to him nuking their source of spice very well. It’s basically space travel fuel among other things.

@caf82007

Ай бұрын

They had to take Paul down when they found out about him leading the attacks on spice production

@Neil-qg9cw

Ай бұрын

​@@wutzittouya3765Paul doesn't nuke the spice. He nukes the mountain beside Arrakeen to let Stilgar attack with sandworms. The mountain was a natural barrier protecting the city.

Yeah no. Your characterization of Paul as manipulative is completely wrong here. Throughout the movie he is getting visions of the holy war and it is getting more and more inevitable. You said yourself; Paul is a tragic hero. He is cursed to see that the only way he can survive leads to billions dead. By the time he has taken the Water of Life, he quite literally is acting out the script required for him to remain alive. Irulan says in this movie that the Maud'Dib can't even be killed - because he will just be martyred and this is an important element that comes to play in Dune Messiah. Paul is locked in to this future he sees, and nothing he can do will stop it. The rest in the series of books is all about how this ability to see the future is what would inevitably be humanity's downfall.

I don't believe Eric's actually read the books. He misinterpreted a good handful of things about the plot. (They use atomics to detonate the shield wall giving them access to Arakeen for example)

@tuz2tuz229

18 күн бұрын

He probably has writers for these videos I don't think he does this all himself. That said I agree multiple things were interpreted wrong that were pretty big plot points in the books.

I usually like watching your videos on analyzing movies but I think you should read the books when you have time. Paul is not using the Fremen OR Chani. He uses Princess Irulan (pronounced eeh-roo-LAHN) for power and influence Keep up the good work 👍

Well you didn't really mentioned the changes from the book except the fact that Alia was not born in this story, I think it would be a great idea for another video since there are so many

@demistic1248

2 ай бұрын

I agree, since there were MANY changes.

@kadosaszollosi8945

2 ай бұрын

@@demistic1248 After a second watch, the movie get's so much better. I tried to not focus on the things they changed. I thought that it's a great movie after the first watch but now I think it's even better. They didn't bother to bring in Alia in a weird cgi way and so they changed the story which I kinda like now. I also like how Chani is different from the books, I think they made a solid background in this movie to back those changes. So overall even I am a big fan of the books, I am satisfied with this movie but it needs at least a second watch and a few days to think it all through.

Gurney's training session with Paul in the first film and the lessons taught there foreshadow how Paul's fight with Feyd ends.

This review is from someone taking notes throughout the movie. There’s quite a few misinterpretations, guess that happens when half your attention is in your book rather than the screen.

@donniedarko6699

2 ай бұрын

i disagree, there are is only one factually false take that i see in this review but other than that i loved it. summons up the event pretty good with extra informations and backstory. really better than reading people theorizing in twitter

@Xherbal0sprey

Ай бұрын

@@donniedarko6699this is a false take itself

@elliottwitt5369

Ай бұрын

100%

@jayel1471

Ай бұрын

He's getting very arrogant as of late.

@thatonerotom8999

Ай бұрын

@@jayel1471Either that or lazy.

Just seen it today. The scene with the harkonnens floating up to the top of the rock outcrop was incredible. One of my favourite shots

Paul won the end battle the same way Gurney won their practice bout in the first film. Dagger to the rib.

1. Paul does not hear Chani say lower 2. Paul does not target the spice store in the end, its the mountains that were protecting the city from the storm. This wears off the shield of the emperor's ship

Are we just ignoring the fact that NR is literally just showing the full film from a camrip or something here?? Some of these screenshots are not in trailers lol

@seabassmoor

Ай бұрын

Cry

I really hope Denis Villeneuve gets to direct RENDEZVOUS WITH RAMA

@bobconstructeur

2 ай бұрын

He will, he will

@aliastana7103

Ай бұрын

and i am looking for Star wars the old one. it should be incredible

"Those who read the books know his sister is the hero of the story." WTF no...

@akiraaoiichigo

2 ай бұрын

I think even the ones who just watched the movie understood that.The introduction to the embryo immersed in water of life itself was evident

@annalis7990

2 ай бұрын

Leto II is

@scottdenman8980

2 ай бұрын

yep....Its Siona Atreides and Duncan Idaho.....

@Space_Ache

Ай бұрын

Yeah I have no idea wtf he is talking about. He got a few things wrong in this video and that is one of them. Ideology clouding reality.

@sethsmith6042

Ай бұрын

"Abomination"...

I think Paul genuinely loved Chani and didn’t want to drink the water but knew if he wanted to ascend he HAD to

Yeah. Paul wasn't using Chani and also saw how the Water of Life would change him. The sudden change came because he drank the water.

The floating soldiers look good (and not goofy) because their movements are similar to real-world astronauts on the moon with lesser gravity. Because we have all seen this image of astronauts jumping on the moon, this harks back to that memory.

One Paul to rule them all, one Paul to find them, One Paul to bring them all, and in the darkness bind them...

@sweepyourspeech8350

2 ай бұрын

The prince that was promised for sure

@iamtheicycle

2 ай бұрын

Here come to Tolkien fans lol

@hildaenjoyer8862

26 күн бұрын

@@sweepyourspeech8350 The Paul that was promised*

IF you pay attention to the talk between paul and his unborn sister in the start of the film you realize pauls intentions are set and he always planned to rule and forsaw it, he says dad i found my way as well and says that he believes in revenge all before starting his journey with the fremen.

The shai-halud (sandworm) that Chani summons at the end of Dune Pt. 2 looks the same size as the "grandfather worm" that Paul called for his first ride.

@demistic1248

2 ай бұрын

The worm Paul summoned was huge, but not unprecedented, at least in the book.

@akiraaoiichigo

2 ай бұрын

I don't think so,it was small in size tho

@shahidal-mubin6569

22 күн бұрын

No it was smaller.

i agree with your interpretation that Paul becoming a monster and serving as the anti-hero by the end is exactly what Denis was trying to portray. This is made more evident i think by the name of the track that zimmer composed for the ending scene. it uses the same melody as paul and Chani's romance theme, but the track is called "Kiss the ring" showing how their love has been perverted to serve Paul's interests for power and revenge. beautifully subtle and tragic writing here.

I like this quote that my friend said after reading dune messiah “Paul is a victim of fate”

1) I thought the 2 nukes were just making an opening in the rock for the sand worms to enter the perimeter and not destroying a spice plant 2) I would like to know how the Freemen know how to pilot the emperors ships and what they planned to do with them 3) I had the distinct impression Paul was just playing a part and fulfilling the role in his visions by going south. He wanted to stay in the north so he could stay with Chani.

Lady Jessica became reverend mother because she defeated Stilgar and that would lead to a conflict, because the one who defeats a naib usually takes their place.

26:57 Naw, Dune just made all of Star Wars look like Bambi.

@kishenkoolskills90

2 ай бұрын

Dune is like our Generation 1977 Star Wars

@pttthhh

2 ай бұрын

That's what I've been telling a few friends that have no clue and haven't even seen the first one yet. Even The Expanse ruined Star Wars for me.. But Dune makes SW look like Sesame Street..

This is tha best story based movie I’ve seen in awhile. It showed what movies could be even tho I don’t think we will get movies that live up to this one again it’s in its own realm

The Amrita in Avatar: Way of Water is also a reference to the Water of Life in Dune 🤯 Extracting a liquid through the mouth of a planet's largest beast in water

I understood the battle differently from how you described it. As I understood it, they don't blow up a nearby spice field, but instead the mountain range that protects the city from the incoming sandstorm. The emperor is adviced to leave the planet and wait out the storm in orbit, but the baron interjects (and I'm paraphrasing): "The mountains will protect us from the worst of it." So the Fremen blow a hole and use this created mountain pass to attack the Sardukaar with their sandworms from an unexpected angle, followed by a huge deadly sandstorm that kills even more while also protecting the worms from Harkkonen aircraft. Showing that Paul has truly mastered Dunes Desert Power, combined with his own Atrades, Bene Gesserit and Harkkonen Power. It is a fantastic culmination of all of Pauls story pieces coming together, building up all the way to the duel against Feyd. A duel between two destined messiah. This shit is so dope, you guys. XD

I agree with Denis about dialogue in movies. Especially in the first blade runner. Theres very little dialogue but it doesn't detract from the story whatsoever

Saw the movie on Wednesday when it came out in France and I found the translation for Chani's name interesting because instead of translating spring to mean a source of water they translated it to mean the season of the year (printemps du désert). I was thinking about that after coming home and wondering if it was a mistake or not. I don't think it is, but translating it to mean a source of water would make more sense.

@msjadhav5192

2 ай бұрын

Book is English, so translation is not really accurate... thank for pointing

@froggerus2

21 күн бұрын

Hmm, I didn't notice until you mentioned this. In Polish version it was also the season of year version, just as in French. Interesting.

Baron Harkonnen to Paul Atreides.. "Paul... I am your father!"

This must have been rushed. You got a lot wrong.

@jakepolacek6209

2 ай бұрын

Was thinking the same

@boat1280

2 ай бұрын

It’s obvious they’re not book readers and are just hopping on

@crushculture783

2 ай бұрын

​@@boat1280funny thing is, I haven't read the books (yet), but even I can tell they got a lot wrong about the film 😅

@simonb7711

2 ай бұрын

I wanted creepy Alia

@rubixd9v2

Ай бұрын

I got half way through and had to stop listening. So many mistakes. I also disagreed with the pre-water-of-life Paul manipulating the Fremen but, admittedly, that's mostly just opinion.

good work I enjoy this video very much. so I more excited to see dune part two. how's crazy is that fight scene between Paul vs feya that is so awesome

This movie has made me constantly think about it and I want to live in that universe so bad 😂 Denis is a genius I swear

I reckon the Atreides gladiator scene was one of the best in this movie. The colors, the suspense, the actual fight and the ending.........phenomenal.

So impressed with the visuals of this film. Every scene was breathtaking. Not just the cinematography, but also the creativity of it. Never seen a shot like the Womp scene before and it was so unique.

I really hope part 2 makes so much money that WB fastracks part 3, cuz Denis said he wanted to do other stuff first, which could be a while.

That's not how it ended in the book between Paul and Chani. It's the only part I didn't like.

@sunilpermaul7876

2 ай бұрын

Same. I didn't mind other differences, but that one wasn't right.

@NoraGermain

2 ай бұрын

Can u recap the difference for us plz

@objectdefiance4027

2 ай бұрын

@@NoraGermain Chani stuck by His side. and Jessica tells H3r history will remember H3r as W!fe.

@lucijarebrovic8058

2 ай бұрын

it’s so that we get the idea that not everyone is on his side and to give the idea of a prophet a counterbalance

@AnymMusic

2 ай бұрын

@@objectdefiance4027 I feel like Denis will come back to that later as it did seem solely done for cliff hanger purposes

Paul isn’t using Channi, he’s using the princess.

LOL i love your random outburst about caucasian palettes xD

PART 3 LETS GO

@qcrew2938

2 ай бұрын

the first book is complete I doubt they'll be another one for a long time...... If there is it better be Dennis again

@arutzuki2491

2 ай бұрын

​@@qcrew2938part 3 is confirmed as the last movie by Villeneuve, isn't it?

@kishenkoolskills90

2 ай бұрын

WB will make spin off for HBO Max, but Dune 3 will be the final part of the Trilogy

If you want to experience Earth in a somewhat Infrared Spectrum like in Dune 2, go outside an urban environment to the countryside with no artificial street lighting around; do so during a 1/4 moon as a half moon or greater reflects too much of Sol’s light spectrum. The environment you see will be revealed in Black, White and shades of gray.

The best movie I’ve seen with a standing ovation since 1. The Dark Knight 2. Avengers Endgame 3. Dune Part 2 Mount Rushmore of great entertainment movies 🔥🔥🔥🍿🍿🍿🍿🍿🍿🍿🍿🍿

15:03 Paul doesn’t listen, he has learned

Thanks for the rundown. My Son & I saw this 4 times at the theatre. The 1st Dune did the world building. The 2nd started off like a 100 meter dash and never looked back. Stilgar made me laugh constantly. So many fantastic portrayals, by a stellar ensemble. This movie definitely moved into my top 5 and I can not wait to see the finale!

It was so amazing on IMAX! I heard it was more intense on 4D.

@better__beauty

2 ай бұрын

It was intense and honestly kind of distracting lmao

What an unbelievable movie

One detail that was clever in the opening moment with the Harkonnen troops being killed is you hear one of them say "No shields." This is because if any of them have their shields on and are hit with a lasgun, the effect would be so devastating that it would wipe out the entire squad. The movie never really touches on the fact that shields and lasers don't mix, but having small details like that really help build more of the world - and also are nice little things for fans to catch.

From a visual standpoint there are some really nice choices that are homages to previous interpretations of Dune, The Geiger esc architecture of the Harkonen. Who got his start in Hollywood on Jodorosky’s Dune

Best movie I’ve seen in a long time

Alia of the Knife is the Hero? Abomination.

2:20, It's actually book accurate that Paul's story is told from the perspective of other characters. In the book, each chapter starts with a quote from a future book referencing the events of the chapter. This gives the impression that the events are all recreated or second hand recollections of what happens.

He paid a price for that barrel roll. That’s why they teach you not to spam the spin kicks in karate and TKD. Bad ass knife fight though.

Been waiting for this video! Saw this movie at early screening last week and going again tonight 😅

Villeneuve is top tier. We are fortunate to have such a bold director in Hollywood today.

With the bene geserit test he puts his hand in a box and accesses his mother’s heritage and background. By opening the atomics vault by putting his hand in another box he’s accessing the power of his father’s line.

ha ha, get to watch this asap 😎 watched it earlier this morning, and it’s probably gonna be the best blockbuster this year.

I came for the recap I stayed for the Brittish Bake Off rant

This movie was WONDERFUL. I'm going back to see it again on Sunday evening.

I have already seen it twice and I will see it more as soon as possible

I find it tragic that Lynch did not have the budget nor the facilities Villeneuve had.

I watched the first dune before going to the movies to see the second part. Wheeeew. I’m not even a big dune fan and I can say I was blown away by how good it was. Most the time I fall asleep at a movie. But I was awake and engaged the entire time watching this

Dune 1 was a work of art, but this takes it to another level...wow!!!

Has anyone writing this actually READ Dune?! Yes, Paul is a tragic hero, but dear gods... Chani was the only one Paul loved, and his truest companion, one who he went out of his way to preserve in Dune Messiah. She never felt betrayed by him, she always encouraged his quest for vengeance and ascention, offering to step aside as his lover on a number of occasions. Frankly, Chani was his most fervent believer, despite being the only one he truly allowed to see the real him. Yes, Paul knowingly manipulated the Fremen's beliefs, but the greatest tragedy about Paul was that he eventually began to believe his own mythos, until something happened that he hadn't foreseen and THAT was when he took the water of life, to improve his abilities. As for Feyde's evening with the Countess, that wasn't a Gom Jabar test, the book literally lays it out as a last ditch attempt by the Bene Geserit to save that bloodline. They changed key points from the book to the movie that just make no sense. The first movie did a great job of transitioning the book to the screen, and this movie duology COULD have easily rivaled that, but... making Chani's relationship with Paul strained and basically turning Paul into an evil mastermind, when in reality he was a desperate marionette struggling against the roles the Bene Geserit, and more specifically his mother, forced on his is far too much of a change. I'll give this a few more watch throughs once it comes out for home viewing, but as of right now, I'm ready to consign this version to the bin beside the 1985 version, despite how much I liked the visuals and how well cast it was, the key plot points were just too changed, especially if they intend for a faithful rendition of Dune Messiah and Children of Dune, sadly, if they do follow through with this movies changes into those, then they will be a far cry from the haunted, self loathing Paul supported by his adoring Chani that is shown in the books.

TIMMY GAVE ME A HEART ATTACK WITH THAT "SILENCE" 😭 Probably the greatest sequel + book adaption oat- i have alot of favourite scenes but its hard to top the council in the south scene,that scene was fuckin insane but Feyd's introduction is close