DRUMEO 30 - Day FREE Trial ► www.drumeo.com/andrewrooney/ OG Video | kzread.info/dash/bejne/eoF2tMyoY5bJhag.html SUBSCRIBE! ► kzread.info DONATE | REQUEST a Reaction via PAYPAL ► www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?cmd=_s-xclick&hosted_button_id=WNN4VP75DG53J | or hit me at andrewrooneydrums.com/youtube-reaction-requests/ SUPPORT | BLOCKED VIDEOS | Join My Community and hit the PATREON ► www.patreon.com/AndrewRooneyDrums SWEETWATER Latest Drum and Percussion Deals ► imp.i114863.net/EaqZz2

@TheDondoran

4 ай бұрын

Hey Andrew, KZread here, it looks like the link to the OG video goes to Chad Smith playing 30 Seconds to Mars.

My favourite thing about this Drumeo video isn't the performance (although the drumming is unbelievable!) or the song (even though it's way better than I expected), it's Mike Portnoy's personality. I've never listened to Dream Theater so I've never come across Mike Portnoy before, but he's great! Love the new studio too!

@Cmoore718

4 ай бұрын

His personality really shows in his drumming, and really made Dream Theater what they are. Not taking anything away from Mike Mangini (who replaced Portnoy for a few years), but he's the man

@powerups5434

4 ай бұрын

The Dark Eternal Night

@69CamaroSS

4 ай бұрын

Que up the Images and Words album and hold on to your seat…..then the Awake album!

@RyTrapp0

4 ай бұрын

I'm a lil bit of a drum nerd(maybe a 'nerd-lite'? Have to put too much time into being a full time race car nerd, one man can only do so much nerding) so that's how I know about Portnoy, though Dream Theater has never been my style. An all-timer band for sure, talent, writing, & performing abilities off the charts, just not my style of prog metal(blusey Mastodon-like and darker Mudvayne-type stuff are more my style; I'd still go see DT live though for sure). But I would listen to the shit outta a Mike Portnoy podcast! It looks like he's been a guest on a number of different ones, but dude would totally have a market for his own show for sure lol.

@theodoreknuyver7075

4 ай бұрын

They’re a band of musical geniuses who are incredibly true to the craft and grounded as people. It’s a deep dive into their catalog of fantastic music.

Mike is a musical genius. The double kick with the triplets was all his idea. It's amazing how these top level guys can reinvent songs and still keep to the original idea. Thanks for sharing.

What i find absolutely fascinating about Mike Portnoy is how he is abe to play so busy parts, playing so much without annoying or disturbing the song, but doing right the opposite, He is as far from any look-what-i-can-do drummer as you can be and that while he´s doing all Mike Portnoy does.

@kcrang

3 ай бұрын

He's definitely a stadium drummer. He is so good at making the song sound huge with the way he plays the drum

calm, relaxed, having fun, just a walk in the park for Mike. the funny thing is that, even tuned down, his drumming is 200% more complex than the original

Now they need to give the drummer of Nickelbag a Dream Theater song. It's only fair! 😂

@matijagrguric6490

4 ай бұрын

Daniel Adair is actually good. He has a second band Martone. Jazz fusion, prog rock/metal

@AndrewRooneyDrums

4 ай бұрын

That’d be great. Daniel is a complete bad a**

@ludwigvanbeethoven2490

Ай бұрын

@@matijagrguric6490playing simple things doesnt mean suck, the harder part is to push your ego to serve the song

Mike has been my favorite musician for many years - but not only because of his drumming. He is just such an interesting person. Back in the old DT days, he would document everything on video and this gave us fans a look into the personalities of the band members. His love and knowledge of other bands is also something I admire

@69CamaroSS

4 ай бұрын

Ahhh the good ole YTSEJAM days!! I was there from the beginning, read and commented on the msg boards daily for years, got ALL of the fan club Christmas CDs (and about a dozen bootlegs), met them numerous times and even got Mike’s permission to video one of his Guitar Center drum clinics in Atlanta using a HD camera on a tripod with 2 of it’s 3 legs TOUCHING the drum riser….and gladly sent him a copy at his request!

@adampletcher1153

3 ай бұрын

I loved him when he filled in for avenged 7 fold and also dream theater

The best part of the series with him is him playing Dance of Eternity for the first time in 14 years and nailing it like he’s been practicing it for years.

the half time chorus with the double bass was killer ... simple but so effective

Mike Portnoy’s drumming has always had an “Acoustic” sound to me. In Dream Theater his drumming always grabbed me.

The people asked... here it is!

@senna1994

2 күн бұрын

Thank you. I don’t mind the original song but Mike made that song excellent and your review helped explain what makes it, and him, great. I just loved this

@annebokma4637

Күн бұрын

Thinking of what I am going to ask now 😂

Mike is so humble I will just hire him just because of that trait never mind that he’s a goddamn drum genius

@AndrewRooneyDrums

Ай бұрын

seems like a hoot

You know it's damn good when you see other musicians give it a stank face. 🤘🤘

@AndrewRooneyDrums

18 күн бұрын

Yes Sir!

What a drummer! Since 1995, when i listen Dream theater for the First Time, he changed my vision on what a drummer Is and must be.. he's creativity, his touch, and everything's about his drumming Is awesome!

Excellent human being. I have to admit I love Portnoy's version myself. It was not pulled bac, but it also wasn't overkill by any means. 💯💪🤘✌️🫶🔥

I'm sure you have heard or seen it by now but they (Mike & Drumeo) did another little song you might know called PNEUMA by Tool. Not a blind listen but VERY worth watching, Mike spent 5.5hrs listening & watching the Drum Cam of Danny and still was challenged. He sure had no problem praising Danny for what he writes & plays.❤

Mike Portnoy is just pure awesome.

@AndrewRooneyDrums

4 ай бұрын

What a riot! And KILLER player

For me it was a way more interesting drum-part and made the song better and more entertaining.

Portnoy’s self-effacing humor aside, I thought his version kicked ass. I’d rather listen to that part than the original. Also, if anybody from Drumeo/etc is reading: please do a “Basseo” site!

He played his greatest hits. His go to stuff. All the stuff we know and love.

mike made the drums sound like they should have enough said ive heard this song like a 1000 times since it came out best drums ive ever heard

Mike is THE dt drummer and he's an amazing musician. So happy he's back. Such a down to earth and fun guy.

I already saw this video but I'm glad to see that you enjoyed it too. Mike Portnoy is so good.

Portnoy did 3-4 videos with Drumeo. Playing Pull Me Under, and an hour long discussion and playthrough of 4-5 Dream Theater songs and a Winery Dogs song. As well as an Avenged Sevenfold intro. Well worth a watch on all of them

That advice about relaxing the jaw is so important. Everybody who was treated for TMD knows exactly what you are talking about Andrew

@RyTrapp0

4 ай бұрын

I wonder if this relates to wearing a mouth piece in sports. There's been different mouth pieces that are supposed to "increase strength/explosion a couple percent", "less susceptible to getting KO'd", and this and that, but as far as I'm aware none of these have ever legitimately tested to show a consistent, meaningful improvement. But, anecdotally, you'll hear a lot of athletes say that they feel like they can perform better - maybe some subconscious 'comfort' of sorts as a result of a little tension release.

Wow wow wow…. The musicality in that was insane.

@AndrewRooneyDrums

3 ай бұрын

RIGHT!?

Different drummers have different ideas. Sometimes the simplest drumming can have a bigger impact.obviously Mike is a great drummer!

@AndrewRooneyDrums

3 ай бұрын

Oh for sure. There’s a reason hit songs have simple drum parts…

Portnoy is such a fantastic musician, not just a drummer. He just always somehow creates the most tasteful parts to complement the music. I can’t understate how insanely overjoyed I was when I heard he was back in DT. And he’s going to use his best sounding drum kit for the new album. I have the highest hopes and wishes.

@AndrewRooneyDrums

3 ай бұрын

Brilliant drummer and great guy

@nicholasvinen

13 күн бұрын

Now that Rush have retired they are #1. Like Geddy, Alex and Neil there is something special when John Petrucci, John Myung, Mike Portnoy and James LaBrie work together. Despite some friction over the years they just mesh so well. I love Mangino too but I also can't wait to hear what these guys do next now that they're back together.

16:32 The idea of Nickelback firing Mike is like Metallica turning down Les Claypool to replace Cliff Burton 😂 Mike's a riot!

When are we getting a first listen drum playthrough by yourself? Would love to see your process, and how you approach/attack a song :)

The new set-up is perfect, just hang some blinds on the back wall and I'll feel right at home.

That's what you get from a legit master's master pro genius. Show's how totally pedestrian everyone else is.

I just watched a video of Portnoy talking about/breaking down Alex Van Halen drum parts. It is absolutely incredible to watch him play this stuff. You should check it out!

Dream Theater have never been my thing but I've always liked Portnoy for how clear it is that underneath all the prog shenanigans, he's still completely dialed in with rock and pop drumming. Nobody in the prog world has catchier, more musical and accessible parts.

My favorite comment from this whole video from Portnoy was "This is why they're rich and famous and I'm just a fuckin Prog guy" XD

These Drumeo vids are super entertaining and are a great insight into the minds of all types of drummers and how they compose their parts...Mike looks like he's playing this in his sleep😂😂 You can see he's really holding back from over playing...Word on the street is Drumeo might be bringing MARIO DUPLANTIER up to the studios which would EPIC 😎🤘🧐✌️

i knew that you're gonna laugh at 'premature evacuation'! was so sure bout that, and there it was! :D

The flowing locks add to his supernatural capabilities (sorry Andrew). A god among drummers. Also, in response, his hitting was actually pretty light compared to normal. And not tense at all, he was enjoying the experiment. Fun guy to watch.

Basically, they trolled him, but now Daniel is in serious troubles 🤣🤣🤣

Dig Mike. Dig the new digs. The FPS (whatever) of your orange light in the background does however poke at my non-existing epilepsy.. if that makes any sense.

Those Tama drums sounded GREAT!

Andy, per usual, I love your videos mate! The best part of this reaction is seeing your reaction to one of the greatest drumming forces of nature on this planet! If you watch his “Liquid Drum Theater” instructional video, you get the same brash, honest, no pretense, experience! The dude is just real! And we love those kind of people, don’t we? No decorum, just this is what I do, Take it or leave it, and if you like it, then I have done some good in the world because Mike Portnoy, is Mike Portnoy, and he ain’t changing for anyone! You saw How excited the “Drumeo” guys were to have him in studio. A master, a drumming force of nature, an amazing lyricist, an amazing musician, an amazing person. One in a trillion! I love you Andy! You are like Mike, A force of nature! Keep The vids coming brother!

@AndrewRooneyDrums

Ай бұрын

Yeah I love his style! Thank you!

@chrishuard12

Ай бұрын

@@AndrewRooneyDrums Love you bro! Want to visit New Zealand some day. You’ll be the first Kiwi I look up! Check out Matt Thompson the drummer for King Diamond! Mikkey Dee was the original drummer, another drumming force of nature to check out . I’ll send you a link. Please make a reaction video. Check out Matt Thompson live at the Fillmore in San Francisco. Look up “Welcome Home” Matt Thompson drum cam! It’s bad ass! Holla! Love ya mate!

@chrishuard12

Ай бұрын

@@AndrewRooneyDrums Here is Mikkey Dee. He plays with the Scorpions now but he dude is amazing! Huge inspiration for Me! kzread.info/dash/bejne/ooWcqtyfYK6yiqw.htmlsi=qUOXE0OAOAC_Xr2f

@chrishuard12

Ай бұрын

@@AndrewRooneyDrums I sent a couple of links. King Diamonds music is dark and b Heavy, but the musicianship is top notch! I MEAN TOO NOTCH!

People often comment when I play at church about my mouth being open…. I tell them it would sound bad if it was closed and if you want to know if I’m comfortable with a song look at my mouth 😂

Most people don’t realize Daniel Adair is a prog drummer as well. Look up one of his drum solos. He also has a side project. That is prog.

@Hadgerz

4 ай бұрын

You can tell Adair knows what he's doing. No flam timing issues between that snare and bass. The old 'slow is smooth and smooth is fast' mantra never fails.

@Johnsantos_of_asguard

4 ай бұрын

@@Hadgerz Daniel is actually beast of a drummer. And sings a lot of the back up lines as well. Very underrated

I love it 🤘 he wanted double bass in that song so freaking bad 😂😂😂

Great to see Mike so chill and having fun. His version was busier but probably still dialed back for him. Love the new studio. Props to your decorator!

The nest example of being absolutely overqualified for a task 😊

You know you are a listening to a world class drummer when Nickleback almost sounds good.

mike is a super funny dude, love his enthusiasm and his skills.

A nice follow up to this video would be to check out one of Daniel Adair's solos. He's got beastly chops that are never expressed in any of Nickelback's songs

@StefanP742

4 ай бұрын

Begged drumeo to try and get Daniel on! They said he is always welcome... so I hope it happens some day, he's so underrated!

Andy, I feel ya on the music collection. I have 700 or so albums. Mostly late 80’s to 2010ish. Like most people, I think, my album acquisition happened from around age 10 to 30ish.

Fucking A! I’d watch a podcast of him religiously he’s such a cool guy

I love how Mike's first take is basically ready for print on the track, lol. Incredible and agree on his musicianship! On the topic of the double bass on the chorus, I would say that my preference would be to have the stripped back single bass drum on the first or 2nd iteration of the chorus and then save the double bass or even half time feel for the 3rd iteration or towards the end. That way you get something different as the song progresses. I would also say that my mind works similar in terms of understanding the charting so that I can play ideas that fit with the music and the structure. Great vid as always Andrew!

In 2005 Dream Theater recorded a DVD playing Pink Floyd Dak Side of the Monn. You can see Mike Portnoy playing perfectly at a very slow tempo for him. You can check it out here on KZread

Yes! First thought I had while watching was hoping we'd get a Rooney Reaction, thx for delivering sir!!

Thank you so very much for doing a reaction to this one, Andrew! Mike Portnoy is and always has been my favourite drummer of all time. Such a phenomenal talent, and just such a dude as well! I’ve watched this performance of his numerous times now, but the first time I saw it, my very first thought was your reaction to it! Just awesome, man! You were smiling just as much as myself😊👍🏽

Great video mate

I really hope, over time, you do the rest of these Drumeo videos. I think they are fascinating, and you definitely make them more interesting. Great stuff.

Mike did a tribute to Alex Van Halen with Drumeo you should check that out…incredible

@AndrewRooneyDrums

4 ай бұрын

I will

Hahaha, OMG!! Love this fills!! This guy is incredible!!!

Awesome tip with the relaxation of the mouth. My wife notices when I am feeling and just enjoying what I am playing, and I tend to have a big smile. Mike Portnoy is my #3 favorite drummer of all time. The first time I heard "Pull me under " I was hooked on listening to his drumming.

Great drummer, great guy!

YOU NEED TO DO THE 1 hour video from Drumeo with II from Sleep Token. He does his first video interview EVER and does a multitude of song play throughs. Please Andrew, you must do this!! YOU WILL LOVE THAT VIDEO, and have a new admiration for II and Sleep Token based on drums & structures of his playing

@AndrewRooneyDrums

4 ай бұрын

I'll get there!

one of your best reactions. funny as hell. you are right he should do a radio show or something

Very cool video. Im certainly not a Nickleback fan but this song isnt so bad imo. Its a good song to break out once in a while at a party lol.

@AndrewRooneyDrums

4 ай бұрын

Yeah I dig it

Diggin the new studio. Lighting and angle!

Andrew , I was one if many im sure,askifor you to react to this , as ever your knowledge and thoughts are so valuable, I'm know drummer, but I found watching Mike s7ch an inspiration..

Hi Andrew Mike portnoy is a absolutel genius. Awesome reaction.

Awesome video, love what Drumeo has been doing with this idea, it's pretty genius! Love this series! Really appreciate just hearing MUSICIANS play and talk about other music that they aren't typically associated with, gotta love the LACK of gatekeeping and snobbery from the majority of the musicians out there, it's such a contrast to trying to talk music with fans("fans"). Shout out to YT and such giving the Andrew Rooneys of the world a platform too for that matter. Mike Portnoy filling in on drums in Nickelback would've been pretty damn awesome, I would've actually checked that out LOL. Gotta love those crossovers, like Joey Jordison filling in for Lars in Metallica. BTW, for every video they do where the drummer doesn't just jump right into it - we always have to acknowledge Chad Smith just being an animal and shredding 30StM while barely having heard it lol. I'm not saying he's "better" than anyone else, or that that's the "better" way to do it... but damn it's impressive!

@AndrewRooneyDrums

4 ай бұрын

Yeah I'm loving this series of vids :)

Oh i luv Mike ❤🥁

Goosebumps when that chorus comes in with the epic fill and the triplet double bass. Let’s go!

Mike is the man!!!

awesome tip

Portnoy is amazing,overplays for a simple band like Nickleback But I’m sure he was just having fun,nothing wrong with that!

There's a reason he said it would be so fun to play with them !!! It would be so relaxed for him and just chill !!!!

Spartan...so squeeky clean, the room is also very sprightly too!!!!!

Man, this was one the coolest videos ever! That tense and hard hitter, less than half of an actual drummer you described, is me. The messaged hit strong in the best way. I'll train having this in mind. Aside all that it's Mike Portnoy ffs.

Way to go all out on the new studio.

Best hack I ever had for clenched jaw like you mentioned; was to stick your tongue out a little & rest your teeth on it The moment you start getting tense you end up biting down on your tongue, it hurts & you learn to chill real quick

@AndrewRooneyDrums

Ай бұрын

Great tip! It really works

Andrew, have you done a video on Todd Sucherman? Todd is one of the very best at there now. A beast.

@AndrewRooneyDrums

Ай бұрын

Yes I have! One of the legends

Ha! Just saw this vid yesterday and your reaction vid popped into my feed today, giving me the immediate pleasure of seeing it again. Loved drums since childhood but can't speak the language. What I gathered is that Nickelback made a conscious decision to bring let guitar shine a little brighter than drums but Mike's version leaned toward the opposite. Man, can that guy improvise. One of my favorite Drumeo performances so far. Need to visit their library and see who else is out there.

I would love to see nickelbacks reaction, and he’s not wrong they are a great show

That was fun to watch 😁

@AndrewRooneyDrums

4 ай бұрын

DEFINITELY

LOVE this version! Played the drums on Rock Band version. I wouldn’t be able to play Portnoy’s but the key word is FUN.

Hi, Andrew! Love your new studio, although that strobing red circle on the wall behind you is a huge distraction, try a lava lamp instead. The video is awesome and Mike just rocks it. He had a lot of fun doing it, that was cool. Also, just love his TAMA drums! For some reason Nickelback is truly hated here in Canada, I don't know why. It might be the perception that they have not been loyal to their fan base.

@AndrewRooneyDrums

4 ай бұрын

They are hated here too! But I imagine most people who hate them have never listened. I prefer to stay away from that type of bullying

Nickelbacks drummer is a monster. Daniel

looks good

This song used to be WWE’s Monday night Raw theme song back maybe 10 or 12 years ago

Not hard or tense, dude could play anything. Top 10 current drummers.

You should absolutely listen to some of Avenged Sevenfold Nightmare album cuts. Save Me is probably the best

Enjoyed your reaction! Mike really did well on the track, in my opinion!

@AndrewRooneyDrums

4 ай бұрын

Yup smashed it!

OMG!

great guy🤣🤣🤣 how to kill the Original-Drummer😂😂😂

Funny thing. I've been grinding my teeth all mourning. When you told "me" to relax my jaw, I finally relaxed. So thanks! Check out Eloy Casagrande in drumeo! The song "Revolution" is mindblowing.

There is a reason that MP has been peer voted as the best drummer ever for multiple years Peer reviews!

@AndrewRooneyDrums

4 ай бұрын

MONSTER player

Such a groove compared to the original. Great feel player for such a technical player.

The original version still rocks but if I have to add something I'll take the double bass of Portnoy and put that in the original version. But still Mike Portnoy the GOAT ❤

I would like to see them bring Pau from the warning in studio. Romeo has her nominated for rock drummer of the year, she’s in pretty dang good company though.

There are two types of people. Those that like their steaks plain, and those that like their steaks bathed in sriracha. If you're the latter, you're probably in camp Portnoy. 😂

Yesterday I saw a reaction of another creator who was like "this dude's been doing the same drum fill for 30 years" and now I cant unhear it and see it (not that I didn't notice it, but he's right) and I burst out laughing. But to be honest it is his signature move and he's done it all so, just can't get enough with Mike. What a great musician and chill man. Loved the reaction btw! \m/

@flatnicable

4 ай бұрын

The fill in question is called a "Portnoy-fill" for a reason lol Nothing to unhear, it's all meant to be exactly the way it is.

@thepooz7205

4 ай бұрын

I have to imagine any drummer’s first take on any song is going to include whatever go-to fills they do by default. That would be something that would only need polishing late in the process.