Simply brilliant! Thanks Sanjeev for illuminating our souls!

Very excellent explanation by Sanjeev sir. Rahul was speechless as always😂😂

✔️India Bharat both are valid words as per Constitution In Constitution both are there, there is NO debate about one word being more important than the other. Very well explained 👍

@parimalachari8432

11 ай бұрын

Excellent rxplanation

Sanjeev Sanyal makes Devdutt Patnaik look like a primary school kid.

@ashyjager

11 ай бұрын

@@bsachin1239 Ya one sided rebuttal because the other side dis not have any facts. All he said was Aryans Brahmins oppression depression blah blah... Devdutt could not even give one legitimate historical source for all his claims. He would have been right if he had said that in 1990's now most of these myths have already been scientifically busted.

@sandy1048

11 ай бұрын

@@bsachin1239 debate happened, rahul deleted the original and split the video 😂🤌

@DavidDLalsa

11 ай бұрын

Debate with yourself after reading the first article and honoring the National Anthem. Then you will be able to secede the fallacies from the facts.

@Avinashm7

11 ай бұрын

English translation of Bharat is India

India is the best name ♥️😍

India is Not British name It was used and world renowned name much Before It comes From Indus and Indus Valley Civilization Also Why is BJP creating unnecessary conflicts In Country Why it want wants to Bring India to zero by reducing brand and international influence

@sitarampradhan8488

11 ай бұрын

Lol Rahul Gandhi can do " Bharat jodo yatra" and Indira Gandh can put secular India forcefully on construction. Irony dies thousand death.

@s4stats698

11 ай бұрын

there is a difference between renaming a country officially and call india as hindustan/bharat/ india for internal poltics@@sitarampradhan8488

@Avinashm7

11 ай бұрын

​@@sitarampradhan8488your ancestors bootlicked Britishers lol

The biggest problem India facing is lack of education. People are unable to choose between goodness and evil. The literacy percent is very low 77% while China is 97%.

@ramrao668

11 ай бұрын

How does the Chyna literacy rate matter if you are slaves of the CCP ?

@sitarampradhan8488

11 ай бұрын

Because you prefer child labour for your mean job on low cost. How can they get education.

@SreekanthYerram

11 ай бұрын

Wow!! And??

@MrAntonysimon

11 ай бұрын

We are a nation of idiots even though we are educated

@maureensamson4863

11 ай бұрын

Maybe we choose evil because we're just that !!😢😢

First Amit Shah should change his name... Shah is persian...is he related to Nadir Shah ?

@teamMandir

11 ай бұрын

A merchant from Gujarat had name Dharmasena Shah in around 600 ad. You sub literate 40 iq pajeet.Shah is very common surname in Gujarata comes from Prakrit Sahu meaning merchant from Sahukara.

@RaviShankar...

11 ай бұрын

He can change it to Amit Shadani or Amit Shambani😅😂

Rahul have to change the name, BHARAT TODAY. no more INDIA TODAY.😁😁😁😁

Why was the debate between Pattnaik and Sanyal not shown in full?

@mridulagrawal6687

11 ай бұрын

It is bro,just search it

@BishalNath

11 ай бұрын

Devdutt Patnaik trained by Wendy Doniger a anti Bharat force,who try destorted our history and try to call our history as myth, Devdutt is snake 🐍,Astin ke Saap

@abmmmec

11 ай бұрын

Because they might have wanted to keep history and fiction separate.

@Narasimha_TheSher

5 ай бұрын

​@@abmmmec 🙌

There is a compelling reason to use the term Bharat- its meaning. A swami explained it. "Bha" means bright light (as in Bhaskar); the term blinding light has been used to mean divinity in Upanishads- It is so bright that one cannot fathom it (Tagore also mentioned it in poems). "Rata" means absorbed in. Thus the term "Bharat" means One who is absorbed in meditation on God. There are countless sculptures all over Bharat that remind us of this meditative state, and that is Bharat - deep in meditation to realize the Ultimate Truth. Jai Bharat.

We should change everything then. Shouldnt call ourselves Hindu as Persians called us that. Should get rid of every food/ clothing which is not Indian. Get rid of buildings/ monuments which is not built by us. Dont use English, only use Indian languages. This is just another gimmick from politicians and nothing else. Be it India / Bharat we will always be proud. Only changing names wont make any difference. Give us good healthcare, education and jobs. We have always been Indians & supported our Team India in all sporting events. During cricket matches have always used Indiaaaa...Indiaaaaa..clap clap clap as our go to cheering. Do something which will lead our nation forward. Dont sit and debate on such silly topics. India and Bharat can both be used but just hope that this govt doesnt ban the word India then it will be worst situation than demonization...stand in lines to change documents / currency notes which mentions "India".

It is not understood why some are opposed to changing 'india ' to 'bharath.Why did they change Madras to Chennai and Bombay to Mumbai.If they agree on these changes,why do they oppose Bharath?

@stairwaytoheaven1719

11 ай бұрын

If someone wants to change your religion or name will you allow it?India is also identity and motherland for 140 crore Indians,nobody has given the right to change its name to a political party.

@subramanianramajayam2467

11 ай бұрын

@@stairwaytoheaven1719 sir,we have been changing merrily names of cities,towns and even streets for decades.Why? Did you go to people and take their consent?There is nothing wrong if you change names used by the British to our own names.

@stairwaytoheaven1719

11 ай бұрын

@@subramanianramajayam2467 just answer my question if someone wants to rename your religion to another will you allow it?it's the same with name of your country.Its very hard to change the name of country you are loyal to and proud of.Its like cutting off a piece of your heart.Only traitors and power hungry can easily do it without any problem.

@subramanianramajayam2467

11 ай бұрын

@@stairwaytoheaven1719 sir,when Burma can become myaimar,Ceylon be named as srilanka,East Pakistan can become Bangladesh,Soviet union can become Russia,why not India become Bharath?Bharath is our own name and India a colonial name.

@stairwaytoheaven1719

11 ай бұрын

@@subramanianramajayam2467All of your examples are either after disintegration or independence of a country,no country has changed their name to win elections or gave up their name for a party. When one's eyes are shut consciously they can't be opened ,if you want to impose you can try,hope such arrogance is given suitable response by the people

Yes, There are Multiple evidence is there in our Vedas, Upanishads & in Sacred Hindu scriptures as 'Bharatha' varsh or 'BHARATHA' to our Land & in Chanakya Neeti also, but the Europeans are seeking every thing from Greek & Latin, so they studied Greek & Persian Books regarding Our Country before coming here calling It as India, because they can't Pronounce it properly, so after Independence most of the countries changed there name to original, why we still waiting, we always refers our country as Bharatha or Hindustan more than India till today & India comes only when we are watching Cricket ....

@joslittleworld8145

11 ай бұрын

“India comes only when watching cricket” Are you sure about that statement?

@suvish0468

11 ай бұрын

But all those scriptures doesn’t recognise whole of india😂

@RajDas-ob4mp

11 ай бұрын

It’s bharat for the uneducated Hindi speaking people of the cow belt overpopulated , underdeveloped, dirty .states . And INIDA. for the 54% of Indians who are educated . And are non Hindi speakers! Time to throw these uneducated Hindi speakers to their own Hindustan. In the north .let’s see how educated they are ? And developed . Sure won’t be sending missions to the moon. They will be building temples . And lving of one bag of rice dal and oil praying to modi and yogi.

I repeatedly hear Bharat in the national anthem. I never hear India. According to Guardian Nigeria News, the national anthem is akin to a melodic hymn representing a country's values, history, aspirations, and primarily its identity. Therefore the country’s soul has always been Bharat which in essence means light/knowledge. Words have power. Bharat gives light/knowledge to the country. What energy does the word India give to the country?

@maureensamson4863

11 ай бұрын

" INDIA IS MY COUNTRY " .... OH , so sorry .... The values enshrined in that beautiful Pledge are long dead and discarded ... probably considered foreign !!😢😢

@zoropiratehunter4103

9 ай бұрын

@@maureensamson4863 that is included by the school......it is not our naitonal anthem ..lol

Everyone stop speaking English...its a foreign name... Stop using google and KZread its foreign 😄😂😜

@adityabhatia1035

11 ай бұрын

No one is changing the name India to Bharat they are just campaigning to give the second official name Bharat more importance, but you will not get it because you are quite stupid to understand this and giving your flawed logics

@RaviShankar...

11 ай бұрын

Stop facebook and selfie with Zuckerberg😅😂😂

Even this news channel name will be changed😂😂

Changing name doesn't matter. Decolonizing British ways or names or anything related is inevitable. Can they bulldozer all the British architecture structures and rebuild in today's world? Indian were slaves to the British that can't be changed eternally. That's history untouched.

So we will change the Indian ocean name to Bharat Ocean, no other country in the world has this pride of oceans named against them. Everyone were looking to come to India back then, hence they named it. I also think south indians are much more attached to India than Bharat, i think hindi speaking belt are much more inclined towards Bharat

@RahulRaj-sn8rg

11 ай бұрын

There is a name in sanskrit indusagara.

@puneeth253

11 ай бұрын

Haha it was indusagara.. im a southie and I like Bharat.. janganamana national anthem says Bharat nd not India.. 🤣

Sanjeev ji - It’s Tolkaappiyam and not Tolpaakkiyam.

@parashnathpandit4850

11 ай бұрын

Sanjeev is bengoli so bare with pronunciation. If you're from south, can you pronounce a bengoli word the way bengolis do?

@vaakkaalan

11 ай бұрын

@@parashnathpandit4850 Sanjeev is Bengali and is not expected to pronounce Tamil accurately. And that’s precisely why I’m correcting his wrong pronunciation. And yes, my Bengali pronunciation will be incorrect and when it is, I’d expect any Bengali to correct mine. So?

We were given HINDU name By the Muslim Invaders who Crossed Hindukush region in Afghanistan. Muslim invaders used to call us hindus or hundustani.

I think India should be renamed as Bharat. In Bengal we grew up using the term Bharatbarsha; Bengali literature uses that term a lot. But Bharat is fine.

Looks like the host didn’t understand what Mr Sanyel narrated!

Yes India is given by British Like Madras which is changed as Chennai.

Its a shame to see Bjp and its supporters become Anti India I am proud to be an Indian always

@adityabhatia1035

11 ай бұрын

How bjp has become anti Indian can you explain please?

I am a history graduate, I have never heard or red about this Tribe called Bharath who claims to have lived in Haryana druing broze age. Where is the historical evidence of it. Is he cooking up new history

@varun9213

11 ай бұрын

this guy thinks whatever he has read is the only thing that exists LOL

@liberalManifesto68

11 ай бұрын

@@bsachin1239 RV is not history

@liberalManifesto68

11 ай бұрын

@@bsachin1239 RV is not history

@AhamBrahmosmi

11 ай бұрын

​@@liberalManifesto68it is ..without how could you know Indus is indus

@apostate9397

11 ай бұрын

It is not your fault . We all read books of romila Thaper , Irfan Habib , Satish Chandra . So we don't know encient history of India .

He is wrong about tholkaapiyam. There is no mention of vedas.

@AhamBrahmosmi

11 ай бұрын

😂 really

Hindu name if is derived from the word Sindhu river, that run mostly in Pakistan should logically title Pakistan as India and not meddle with Bharat

Why need to change now,?the name is not the major problem in country,

India is not a word in any language originating in this land. Bharat word originates in this land.

English is foreign ...So is internet ... Also the device you use to access the net ! Why keep them ??

@user-mc5fc1zj2j

11 ай бұрын

Europe mei English K koi puchta vi nehi. We think.

@parjanyashukla176

7 ай бұрын

How is internet "foreign"?

Great explanation. Small correction it’s Tholkaapyum and not Thilpaakyum

There was never one India , India is a geographical area, not one country we are different tribes

You are a foreigner an aryan , who came to india through bolan and kyber pass.

@user-mc5fc1zj2j

11 ай бұрын

Yes, our civilization and history began just after the birth of jesus Christ and the British came and civilised us. In the meantime,some poor and uneducated families got a few bags of rice and changed their religion....

Why do these people talk in English then?let them speak in Hindi and live .They can study ,work and make money from foreign but common Indians shouldn't?Such petty minded people are quite shameful to see

@vaakkaalan

11 ай бұрын

Silly comment. Supposing you’re Indian, just because you speak English your name cannot be ‘David Sidebottom’ or something. Your name would still be something that’s rooted in the culture, history and language. Why should it be any different for our nation.

@Jon_Tanjore

11 ай бұрын

@@vaakkaalan why TF you wanna change it now when election is on its way. Elaborate

@rotrautmellin7543

11 ай бұрын

I love Indian culture ❤ I have been visiting Your country 7 times. So, I enjoy listening to Your very important Diskussion! Personally, I would vote for its name to be BHARAT 😂❤

@rotrautmellin7543

11 ай бұрын

P.S. Warm greetings from Germany 😂❤

@vaakkaalan

11 ай бұрын

@@Jon_Tanjore Please elaborate where the govt has said that they are looking to change or replace the name. I’m waiting.

So is HINDI its a result of Islamic colonialism

@rbnjdd

11 ай бұрын

It is quite opposite bhartendu harichandra always hated urdu and was cultural nationalist who is father of hindi literature but some illegitimate child of British cheated his motive by promoting urdu in the name of hindi. Bharatendu harichandra hindi literature was very sanskrised hindi then moden urdu in the name of hindi

Sanjeev is too good for these leftist questions; vedas were not done by brahmins- Viswamitra was not one; Valmiki was not one; Vyasa was not one.

India got bad name because of the political alliance abvr I.N.D.I.A , WHY DOESN'T OUR NATIONAL ANTHEM DOESN'T HAVE INDIA. Bharatiya who identify is free to call their homeland BHARAT.

India in Portugese /Spanish dictionary 1600 means The Indios,Cental South American Indian tribes subjugated as their Slaves. The British 1759 soon followed their SUBCONTINENT empire with Indios as British Indians.

Bharat and india always coexisted as names and be respected , regardless of the decision to use either of the names or one of them now . But to reduce these two names as one superior to other is disrespectful to our culture . Bharat is as good as india and vice Versa !

Bharat name is after saint bharata - not bhrityu as you distorted - bhrtyu means slave - that is again the construct of europeans.

Even the game of cricket was introduced by British. Should that be that we now ban cricket and go back to desi gully danda

@adityabhatia1035

11 ай бұрын

no one is changing the name neither the government had said this , the idea is to give the native name 'bharat' more value

@satishkamtikar958

11 ай бұрын

@@adityabhatia1035 But it already is being given importance. We always say Bharat Mata ki Jay. Bharat Ratna. The one question which no media person will dare to ask the party is Why nationalism is being misused to gain electoral mileage. Please don't play on the patriotic sentiments of the people to fulfil your political ambitions

@adityabhatia1035

11 ай бұрын

@@satishkamtikar958 yeah that's the thing if it's given value by the previous governments why they are making a ruckus out of it now, just for their own political gain and Bharat is also the official name of this country so your argument really falls flat sir

@satishkamtikar958

11 ай бұрын

@@adityabhatia1035 Disagree Sir. By previous govt it also means BJP govt from 1997 to 2003. Also From 1989 to 91 1977 to 1980 I am not a Congress supporter. But has anyone raised this issue of changing name of country. No. We were also proud of being called Indians. Come on India , Dikha do. Merely supporting every decision (one sided with no parliamentary discussion or process) cannot be termed patriotic

@adityabhatia1035

11 ай бұрын

@@satishkamtikar958 that's the point you are not getting and repeating it like a parrot no one is changing the name Bharat is also the official name as per the article 1 of Indian constitution but the opposition has to make fuss out of everything when they don't find any issue

Mr. Intelligent, please tell me. If other countries with having 2 names, do they ever use two words in thier govt papers that goes like " govt of india / bharat sarkar in hindi". It only happens in our bharat.

For all suit & boot guys, the name India was ok for over 75 years, and they all made their fortunes in india. These characters now favour the name Bharat over India because one modern day, thuklaq who all of a sudden became scared of the world, INDIA wants to change the name.

@Invictus007

11 ай бұрын

You are another who hasn’t read the first line in the constitution 😂

@SreekanthYerram

11 ай бұрын

Hahaha what else?

Isn't it the same Rahul kawal who ashamed himself of asking questions without having info few years back and pushing agenda

I may be wrong, but India/indian was a name given to uncivilized, uncouth people. Native Americans were called Red Indians, the people of tiny carribean Island were called West Indians, natives of Indonesia were named as such. Similarly, India and Indian were used to undermine the beliefs of the people who were natives of Bharatvarsh.

@vickyvirk4424

11 ай бұрын

You are wrong

@anilmenon3701

11 ай бұрын

@@vickyvirk4424 prove it, if you can.

@kavinanil7406

10 ай бұрын

From the Church emancipated yet highly influenced by religious notions, melanin lacking White Britishers had this notion that anything or anyone who are not similar to them should be looked beneath them. So their view on humans who are brown, or non White are because of the Stories they listened from Spice merchants, they made up Stories about where these species came from. They made up Stories on pepper, cardamon, cinnamon, cloves etc . They did this to amp up the value and thereby the prices. The way the natives dressed with less clothes due to the tropical weather made them look beneath their superficial sophistication.

@kavinanil7406

10 ай бұрын

Britain and who of Europe was in the dark medieval ages before a renaissance happened. There was huge plague and bodies were floating in Thames river. The streets of London were filled with human feces all over. So their view on who people from the rest of the world are very skewed back then. Doesn't mean it has to be acknowledged or attributed as a norm.

Actually, the real India is now Pakistan. The reminiscent of Indus valley civilization are physically located in now pakistan. Bharat should do away with this name. We support Modi to change his country's name.

Perfect response from Sanjeev Sanyal

Within the historical period upto 1949 Bharat, in no time, was the name of this country.

@adityabhatia1035

11 ай бұрын

The country that lies north of the oceans and south of the snowy mountains is called Bhárata, for there dwell the descendants of Bharata. Bhárata is the land of works, in consequence of which men go to heaven, or obtain emancipation. - The Vishnu Purana, Chapter III [400 BCE]- And this is for example that name Bharat is being used for many years , so gain some basic knowledge before spitting your half baked theories

From tomorrow onward Cricket name will be changed to Gully Danda.

Who that Vedas were written by Brahmins ? Do you know, the caste of Vyasa, Valmiki ?

While this is well explained and articulated On this subject rubbish there are disscussion and debate should not even exist and many news channels are acting as mouthpiece of the govt they have their reasons or compulsion god knows best And if opposition is smart enough they shouldn't give any importance to what names this govt uses and focus on voicing key issues of the country, economy , jobs , inflation etc etc and work for betterment of its people which clearly many media channels are missing out or dropping it in as a foot note opposition should not deviate and get sucked into these debates All our names our beloved we love India we love Bharat we love Hindustan Jai Hind

Common sense should prevail brother, did Indus Valley Civilisation (India) happen first or the Vedic Period(Bharath)?

@mindgame4479

11 ай бұрын

Tell yesterday you didn't have any problem with the name india... Go to Pakistan then you anti national

@parashnathpandit4850

11 ай бұрын

😂😂😂😂😂 so much common sense needed

@shrithimmaiah-mn5mx

11 ай бұрын

@@parashnathpandit4850 correct brother, BJP/RSS MADRASA educated students do not have common sense brother🤣🤣🤣

@kavinanil7406

10 ай бұрын

What archeological or scientific evidence do you have for Vedic age..? There are no texts or relics or artefacts for proving a Vedic age in India.

Bharat. Iam no more indian citizen. Iam a Bharatan Citizen Change passport.

Well done sanjeev

If Vedic Age precedes indus valley civilisation, then the Vedas have the origins to the Varna system. In Rig veda, there is something called Purusha Suttha which describes the four different varnas, by God sacrificing someone named purusha, from him Brahmin, Kyshtria snd vaisias were came into being from different parts of the body. This is the origin of caste system. If vedas influenced all parts of India and even mentioned in Tamil Sangams grammar text Tholkappiyam then, the varnas sysyem and its evolution of caste system stratified into the society through the Vedas and by its beholders. Hence the people who seek social justice detest and wants to eradicate all these notions that associated with religion these days. The stratification of castes in the society had been from the Brahminical notion, from Vedas. This struggle of vedas free, anti Brahminical, varna devoid society has happened all across at various times in history. Jainism in a way was incepted in opposite to this, Buddha denounced his life and moved from karma based life principle mentioned in Vedas or vedism to a dharma based principle. And many siavaites and vaishanavite in the South Especially in tamil nadu opposed to this idea of Varna system and vedas as it was socially discriminatory and creating a divisive, unequal society.

in which basis India is assigned as foreign name

@parashnathpandit4850

11 ай бұрын

In which basis India is assigned as Bharat's name?

sheshadri hills not venkata hills

Why did u delete sanyal vs the mythical historian of yesterday?

Saar , nabhi’s son is Rishabadeva not the other way around as you say. By the by, DevDutt does not know anything… he is far a expert … pls talk to experts vidwans in vedas, mahabharatha

Why this Anchor seems so Anti Hindu or Anti Brahmins..

Be more inclusive to the South. Either Bharath/Bhaaratham. After all Bharathanatiyam is from a Great Southern civilization.

India is a foreign name. But so is Sanskrit a foreign language! Sindhu is perhaps appropriate but it’s geographical location is also foreign

Only.mythological books He ia not historian

My suggestion if we use name our country Bharat what is going to BRICS will becomes BBRCS

@newbee2262

11 ай бұрын

Invite Indonesia to the club And call it BBRICS

If it is India foreign word why blame them you all bharat go to feed your stomach there cos bharat cannot...

All very nice except two of the examples used by Mr Sanyal are nonsensical. Great Britain and United Kingdom are NOT the same. They refer to two totally different regions. Same with Holland and The Netherlands. For someone who is considered such an expert, quite baffling he’s making such juvenile mistakes 😂

Mr. Intelligent. In hindi i call you Sanjeev Sanyal. Please tell me, by what name i call you in english. U have an your one identity. Even if u write yr name in hindi or in English will have the same utterance.

Stop this rubbish and waste money on these silly things.

Some Storiy

Devadutt is a kook... 😂

Original homeland of the vedic tribes including the bharatas is central Asia ..its a shame this guy calls himself a historian

So now we are going to destroy everything that links us to the British? That’s kinda funny realizing it just before the elections, shows how desperate they wanted to hold on to that throne 😂

@satishkamtikar958

11 ай бұрын

Funny thing is they are discussing it in English which surprise surprise was spoken by the British

@SreekanthYerram

11 ай бұрын

Because this is an English channel..

@adityajoshi6422

11 ай бұрын

India was a name given by the Greeks not the Brits.

@Avinashm7

11 ай бұрын

​@@adityajoshi6422India is the name of Bharat in English

@adityajoshi6422

11 ай бұрын

@@Avinashm7 There are no restrictions on using either of the names in any language. I can use Bharat while communicating in English, just like I am doing now. This whole controversy started when "President of Bharat" was used in one of the G20 documents.

MARCEDRIC.KIRBY INC.