Did Medieval People Believe in Ghosts? Historically Accurate Undead EP.1

Grab Atlas VPN for just $1.70/mo + 6 months extra before the SPECIAL CHRISTMAS deal expires:
get.atlasvpn.com/Metatron
The undead and the Medieval period are. From a narrative perspective a match made in heaven, or should I say in purgatory. The Middle Ages were both a time of incredible inventions, architecture and progress, but also a time for war, death, and a fascination for the occult, was present both within the educated elite, clergy and the common people, so no wonder we see these two concepts in so many fantasy settings.
Also check out the blog I read in the last section of the video
blogs.bl.uk/digitisedmanuscri...
But did Medieval people actually believe in all these undead creatures? And if they did, what sort of stories did they tell? Was there a regional variation in the way these monsters were perceived? And if we were to show our Medieval undead from our games and novels to an actual Medieval person, would they be familiar? Or confused?
And the oral and folkloric traditions that tie all of these sources together. Welcome to episode one of Historically accurate Medieval Undead.
Did Medieval People believe in Ghosts?
Contents of this video
Intro
1 - A world imbued with spirits
2 - Function of ghosts and role of cemeteries
3 - The living and the dead in medieval society
4 - The discernment of spirits
5 - Literary Analysis
6 - Byland Abbey
Conclusion
1 - The Medieval Ghost
Whenever we try to understand how something was perceived and understood in period, we have to approach the subject from an unfiltered perspective. The word ghost for us may have a specific meaning, but for a person from 1000 years ago the same word could have a slightly different or even completely different meaning to it. Any fixation with the “supernatural” needs to be contextualized also considering the fact that the term supernatural itself, for instance is a term not used at the time.
In other words, terms come with a certain cultural semantic baggage.
A world imbued with spirits
Ghost stories had been common in ancient Greek and Roman culture, and at least in the initial Medieval approach, were tinged with paganism in the eyes of the early church fathers. In early medieval Europe, a certain number of clerical figures rejected the idea that dead souls could return to earth. Tertullian (c.160-c.230) and Lactantius (c.250-c.325) dismissed ghosts as a vulgar superstition. Augustine of Hippo (354-430) allowed only for the ‘image’ of a dead person to return, as opposed to an actual spirit or soul, and explained that this image was created by angels or demons.
Instead identifying apparitions as angels or (more frequently) as demons. The main biblical justification for ghosts was the Old Testament story of the Witch of Endor (1 Samuel 28:3-25), which focused on the tribulations of King Saul of Israel and Judah.
He repaired to a medium who had remained in Endor, and by his request, she raised the deceased prophet Samuel. The story suggested that ghosts might appear on earth, but it was not conclusive. Moreover the apparition of Samuel was tainted by the association with witchcraft and necromancy, and might be read as a devil in disguise. In the absence of clear biblical guidance, medieval theologians expressed varying views on the orthodoxy of ghosts. Atleast from the point of view of ecclesiastical authorities we could say that scepticism became more pronounced with the sixteenth-century Protestant Reformation, when ghosts were widely identified as demons. This of course doesn't necessarily reflect the population at large though.
Ghosts and the Church
A study of the phenomenon of ghost stories Although the belief in ghosts existed already in antiquity and the early Middle Ages, only the interaction of the Christian Church and the subtle but powerful pagan cultures among the laity could produce a strong reemergence and growth of ideas about ghosts since the eleventh century.
In the early Church the discussion of ghosts centered mostly on the pagan aspects of the belief in ghosts, as the church fathers such as Augustine, Tertullian, and Evodius struggled to come to terms with this "superstition." But beginning in the ninth century the Church agreed to embrace a new liturgy of the dead which made it also possible for the general belief in ghosts to grow tremendously.
Aspects of ghosts in their appearance, functions, and actions. Beginning in the second chapter, he studies accounts of ghosts which appeared in dreams or rather nightmares. Following he turns to the large body of Christian miracle tales, exempla, and mirabilia which also were filled with reports about ghosts.
#ghosts #medieval #undead

Пікірлер: 538

  • @metatronyt
    @metatronyt3 ай бұрын

    Grab Atlas VPN for just $1.70/mo + 6 months extra before the SPECIAL CHRISTMAS deal expires: get.atlasvpn.com/Metatron

  • @GuitarAndWhatevs

    @GuitarAndWhatevs

    3 ай бұрын

    Please talk about the resurrection of Christ.

  • @Mark-xh8md

    @Mark-xh8md

    3 ай бұрын

    An elaboration to your #3 :) In Scandinavia, Christianization was complete everywhere by the 12th century - in as much as that's when worship of the old gods was outlawed everywhere. BUT The reason for forbidding it...was that it still took place. And there's reason to believe that a small minority in distant areas far from central authority worshipped the old gods into the 14th century. Some pagan practices (though not its theology) survives even to this day! Things like putting food out for the "nisser" ( en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nisse_(folklore) - though this is almost exclusively taking place during Advent and Christmas ), referencing "the gods" in proverbs and idioms, etc*. * = Based on how things are in Denmark. YMMV when it comes to Norway and Sweden.

  • @idris_haris_al-kalima

    @idris_haris_al-kalima

    3 ай бұрын

    How are you, o ghost of Enoch?

  • @thepubknight6144

    @thepubknight6144

    3 ай бұрын

    @ 5:42 there's a movie I don't if you heard of called "Menace to society"' that takes that approach from an American Inner city perspective

  • @TheManWhoStoleTheShadows

    @TheManWhoStoleTheShadows

    3 ай бұрын

    You have a scam bot replying to people under your name(ish).

  • @UNATCOHanka
    @UNATCOHanka3 ай бұрын

    "I was coming back from the tavern when I heard me missus moaning. I could not find anyone else in the house, must've been a ghost." - Joshua the Peasant's Memoirs, 1431

  • @sondra4789

    @sondra4789

    3 ай бұрын

    Hmmmm

  • @wlodek7422

    @wlodek7422

    3 ай бұрын

    Truly, this man lived in house haunted by multiple ghosts...

  • @the_hanged_clown

    @the_hanged_clown

    2 ай бұрын

    twas a little death

  • @lawrence8724
    @lawrence87243 ай бұрын

    Interesting to hear about the discerning of the spirits, I was reading about Saint Simeon the stylite who spent time living on a pillar as a form of asceticism. One day he had a vision of a great light and a being approached him and told him that it was his time to be taken and to ascend to heaven in this amazing firey chariot. Saint Simeon began to step forward, but he paused for a moment and decided to make the sign of the cross, at which the apparition began to protest and then vanished. And Saint Simeon was stood one foot hanging over the edge of the pillar. The being was a demon disguised as an angel and it was trying to trick him into falling to his death.

  • @Blues2green

    @Blues2green

    3 ай бұрын

    Damn I thought it was an angel thank you for clarifying that for me! Could you imagine if we’ve seen one? “Always remember to entertain strangers because you may be entertaining angels unaware”

  • @brianmsahin

    @brianmsahin

    3 ай бұрын

    What an interesting story ! Of course Saint Simeon the Stylite, today would be Saint Simeon the Style Guru and would be posting every day on TikTok 😉

  • @miastupid7911

    @miastupid7911

    3 ай бұрын

    @@brianmsahin Two different belief systems. It's up to you to pick one or the other, or neither. Your choice: Oxford dictionary definition of Saint: noun 1.a person acknowledged as holy or virtuous and regarded in Christian faith as being in heaven after death. "a place dedicated to a seventh-century saint" 2. INFORMAL a very virtuous, kind, or patient person. "she's a saint to go on living with that man" verb formally recognize as a saint; canonize. "the sandy shores of the River Nid, where Holy Olaf's bones were laid to rest before he had been sainted" Oxford dictionary definition of guru: noun 1. a Hindu spiritual teacher. 2. an influential teacher or popular expert. "a management guru"

  • @michellebyrom6551

    @michellebyrom6551

    3 ай бұрын

    ​@miastupid7911 an excellent example of how words are contextualised by time,.Place and circumstance. St Simeon was fortunate in having the good sense to check himself (his senses) before taking irreversible action (stepping off the pillar to his death).

  • @miastupid7911

    @miastupid7911

    3 ай бұрын

    @@michellebyrom6551 yes, SAINT SIMEON had the good sense to follow Christ, and therefore, knew the difference of what was before him with that of Christ, and also therfore, SAINT SIMEON automatically had the good sense to CROSS ➕ himself. (This is what all Christians should do actually: cross ourselves and therefore check ourselves and not others. That's why the examples of the Saints are fundamental to a Christian way of life.) This would be and is the opposite of what a "guru" would do in Saint Simeon's day and does do today.

  • @SoilentBeef
    @SoilentBeef3 ай бұрын

    This reminds me of when I was young and sitting in social studies class, and the teacher was discussing Greek mythology and the beliefs of ancient peoples, and the kid beside me scoffed and said they must have been idiots to believe in daemons. He strongly believed in the existence of ghosts, and frequently went "ghost hunting". It just goes to show we really haven't changed much since then.

  • @cp1cupcake

    @cp1cupcake

    3 ай бұрын

    That kinda reminds me of a theory I have read from various places (I think Maimonides was one of them) which basically suggests that a lot of what we would today call supernatural things were people trying to justify events they could not understand given their understanding of the world. Just as a few example, banshees (or at least their wails) might have come from people hearing foxes at night and winter starts when Hades' waifu comes to visit and ends when she leaves.

  • @aj.j5833

    @aj.j5833

    3 ай бұрын

    Word "superstition" means "surviving belief". When read them thank about them many of them also there to teach you lesson or just common sense, such as "bad luck to walk under a ladder", "seven years bad luck for breaking a mirror" makes sense when you know how expensive mirrors were and easily worth 7 years of wages. Then you have wedding veil symbol of seclusion, to keep bride hidden so she can't do psychic harm to others, OK until you get to second part of why she wears the veil, to protect her from evil eyes of jealous rivals and spinsters. Then it makes more sense. Some were clearly just people having a bit of fun like young girls putting handkerchief on a bush on eve of may, hoping in morning it will show initials of one who they will marry. I can imagine some of the stories of spirits and ghost were tales told to children for fun or to keep them from wandering off at night, adults know it is foxes but tells kids it is wail of a banshee.

  • @Grygong555
    @Grygong5553 ай бұрын

    For those of you who don’t know, the ritual of Forefathers Eve in the Witcher is actually inspired by a real, pagan ritual, which was made widely known in Poland through a 19th century romantic poet, Adam Mickiewicz. It also involves fulfilling wishes of various ghosts so they could move on to the afterlife.

  • @lordInquisitor

    @lordInquisitor

    3 ай бұрын

    Yet another reason to love that game

  • @Hevdan1

    @Hevdan1

    3 ай бұрын

    This is what I wanted to write about. I also have an interesting story related to this custom. In Poland, this is the equivalent of Halloween. On October 31, I was with my girlfriend in the forest, picking mushrooms. Suddenly we came across an unusual find - a tree (probably a spruce) and various fruits spread on the litter around the trunk. We got closer and noticed small coins lying on plums, grapes, bananas, oranges and tangerines. Additionally, the trunk and these "offerings" were sprinkled with some milk by someone. It looked really mysterious and magical, I have never seen anything like that randomly found in the forest. Amazing stuff, I really liked it.

  • @kingofhearts3185

    @kingofhearts3185

    3 ай бұрын

    @@Hevdan1 That's an interesting find. What country or area was this if you don't mind me asking?

  • @Hevdan1

    @Hevdan1

    3 ай бұрын

    @@kingofhearts3185 Poland, Warmia-Masuria to be precise. These are the lands where the Teutonic Knights' crusades against the native Prussian and Baltic tribes took place in the past. People here often attached importance to traditions and customs, even long after the area was christianized and inhabited by other nations and ethnic groups. It has not changed to this day.

  • @kingofhearts3185

    @kingofhearts3185

    3 ай бұрын

    @@Hevdan1 Fascinating. Looks like the tradition stayed alive, just in a new context.

  • @jeffreyromain7336
    @jeffreyromain73363 ай бұрын

    I recall about 30 years ago I was running one misty morning ( it was still dark) along some country lanes (Ayr) when I heard the sound of loud thumping coming towards me. As the sound came closer and the mist started to swirl I thought that my time had come. Turns out it was just a horse (friendly) who wanted to see who was making the puffing sound. Logic goes out the window on such occasions.

  • @gavinmatthewlyall
    @gavinmatthewlyall3 ай бұрын

    Reminds me of when American anthropologist Laura Bohannan tried to tell the story of Hamlet - which she had assumed would have universal appeal - to Tiv tribesmen of West Africa. They quibbled over pretty much every detail, but were particularly put off by the ghost of Hamlet's father - an entity they had no analogue for. “No doubt in *your* country the dead can also walk without being zombies.”

  • @skeletorlikespotatoes7846

    @skeletorlikespotatoes7846

    3 ай бұрын

    Embarrassing

  • @tsemayekekema2918

    @tsemayekekema2918

    3 ай бұрын

    That's what happens when anthropologists wander too far from their sphere of expertise. They of all people ought to know that no two tribes can ever be the same - despite possible broad/vague similarities, especially sub-Saharan Africa that had been developing it's indigenous cultures for too many millennia without any form of contact with Europe & the Middle East prior to the very-few centuries/decades preceding the time of Columbus

  • @Ghost_bros

    @Ghost_bros

    3 ай бұрын

    I read that on anthropology clas

  • @cp1cupcake

    @cp1cupcake

    3 ай бұрын

    I just read the account, and wow, I like the changes the locals did to the story.

  • @Gabi-Alex
    @Gabi-Alex3 ай бұрын

    As someone who loves fantasy and folklore, I love this series already.

  • @Hollie0981

    @Hollie0981

    3 ай бұрын

    And as someone who has dealt with a few many things I couldn't explain, I CANNOT WAIT for Surgeon Raph to attack this 😂

  • @bigguy7353

    @bigguy7353

    3 ай бұрын

    And this isn't really fantasy and folklore, as ghosts have been reported by all cultures across the globe and are an extant phenomenon. Drunks, crazies and fame seekers are not the vast preponderance of those who have witnessed them.

  • @danielmalinen6337
    @danielmalinen63373 ай бұрын

    Belief in ghosts has certainly varied locally by region and culture. For example, Finnic people have believed that a person has three souls: Itse (the Self, the soul of consciousness), Haamu (the Ghost, the soul of health; or alternatively Hahmo (the Shadow)) and Henki (the Vigor, the soul of vitality). The belief continued for a long time until the 19th century, and souls were thought to be able to wander freely during sleep and after death. Even at the beginning of the 20th century, it was believed in some places that a sleeping person should not be woken up suddenly, because the person's Itse soul might be far away from the body and might not have time to find it again, and the person woken up suddenly would lost itself and die. In turn, the departure of the Haamu soul from the body has been considered to lead to illness, or if it was seen moving detached from the body, to premature death. The Haamu soul of a dead person was believed to remain wandering among the living until the birds, especially the soul grouse, would transport them to the afterlife. However, modern Finns no longer publicly admit that they believe in ghosts, at least as openly as before because they are unscientific, but many talk privately or only to their acquaintances about their haunting experiences and ghost sightings. Christianity also brought to Finland the belief in poltergeists, raging spirits (Räyhähenki) that caused noise in apartments as well as hid, moved and threw objects, driving people crazy. It could only be exorcised by a priest, but after that it would return with seven even more powerful and evil spirits. In addition, there was also a belief in the ghosts of abandoned babies, a lovechild, called Ihtiriekko (the Bastard), who appeared like the flame of will-o'-wisp. And they tormented their mothers who abandoned them with endless screams and the child's cries until they went mad and died. Ihtiriekko stopped haunting only if someone found its body and buried it properly. Unfortunately, no medieval ghost stories have survived from Finland, and theories about what people once believed in are based on folklore and remnants of old folk religion. However, the oldest restoration story dates back to the 16th century, according to which the spirits of drowned people sometimes gathered in the yard of St. Olaf's Castle with odd music and disappeared into the air like smoke.

  • @kingofhearts3185

    @kingofhearts3185

    3 ай бұрын

    Interesting, thanks for sharing. The child especially surprised me, can't think of a story like that.

  • @damyr

    @damyr

    3 ай бұрын

    The first example is basically what we call today Astral projection. It makes sense... That belief, in or another shape, exists practically since the earliest civilizations. And it probably existed even before that. It's really ancient.

  • @jokuvaan5175

    @jokuvaan5175

    3 ай бұрын

    This reminded me of my Finnish grandmother once telling me that she had a dream where she was lsitening to a professor tell about how human souls would wander off from our bodies when we slept and then in an instant return when we woke up. I don't know if she had heard these old beliefs before. She was born in 1932.

  • @kimfleury

    @kimfleury

    3 ай бұрын

    The poltergeist folklore sounds like a conflation of a couple or few different Christian teachings. I don't remember the Gospel verse, but Jesus warned His disciples that if a possessed person is delivered from torment through exorcism, the person had to take care to fill his mind and life with God, because if the demon returns and finds the house swept clean and empty, hell go get seven other demons, and the person's plight will be worse than before. So then if a person asks for deliverance but refuses to pray, it's more compassionate to refuse to deliver him rather than to let him suffer worse effects. I haven't heard it in relation to an actual house, though. Sounds like it might have been a tale started by people who only half heard the Gospel and then filled in the rest.

  • @wormwoodcocktail

    @wormwoodcocktail

    3 ай бұрын

    Amazing!

  • @murmor6890
    @murmor68903 ай бұрын

    Here in Vienna we have a huge collection of stories from the late medieval period that feature the Devil as a protagonist. Usually he is buying the soul of someone in exchange for fame, wealth or talent. The contract is signed with blood and usually contains some double meaning or clause that appears innocent and leads to the devil collecting the soul early.

  • @ynpavo

    @ynpavo

    3 ай бұрын

    same as in record deal contracts today „in all of the universe and in perpetuity“ and the „death clause“

  • @TalesofDawnandDusk
    @TalesofDawnandDusk3 ай бұрын

    I'm a student, translator and appreciator of Classical Japanese, and I absolutely love comparing and contrasting the ideas about spirits, ghosts and supernatural phenomena between East and West. Of the stories I've actually translated, the only one dealing with these topics is one about 天人 (tennin, heavenly beings) but I know there are stories about 变化 (henge, shapeshifters/changing spirits) and 鬼 (oni, demons/ogres) in the collection I'm working on. I'll have to keep a closer eye on your work to see if there are any particular interesting points of comment.

  • @kingofhearts3185

    @kingofhearts3185

    3 ай бұрын

    I haven't heard of henge, thanks for giving me something to read up on. Know any good videos in english to get started?

  • @TalesofDawnandDusk

    @TalesofDawnandDusk

    3 ай бұрын

    @@kingofhearts3185 Well, I'm translating a collection of very old Japanese folktales and putting them up on my own channel, though I have yet to get to any stories that specifically deal with the aforementioned henge, but they I will eventually get to them. As far as other people's work, I'm afraid I can't say. Linfamy has some videos dealing with folklore but again, I don't know as he has anything about henge specifically, which is part of why I decided to start my own project, because there's a whole world of very old Japanese literature that is largely unknown in the West and I'd rather it wasn't.

  • @kingofhearts3185

    @kingofhearts3185

    3 ай бұрын

    @@TalesofDawnandDusk I see. I'll watch them toorrow, seems you have a new subscriber.

  • @TalesofDawnandDusk

    @TalesofDawnandDusk

    3 ай бұрын

    @@kingofhearts3185 Very much appreciated. I can't hold a candle to someone like our guy Metatron here, but hopefully I can provide at least a bit of both entertainment and education.

  • @trattogatto

    @trattogatto

    3 ай бұрын

    @@kingofhearts3185There is Shigeru Mizuki who is an expert and made an encyclopedia book about monsters and spirits in the japanese folklore. I have the italian translation, they made two books "Enciclopedia dei Mostri Giapponesi" and "Enciclopedia degli Spiriti Giapponesi". Each creature is accompanied with a nice drawing.

  • @LuizBarrosPoa
    @LuizBarrosPoa3 ай бұрын

    Why ghosts are always people from the 20s and 30s? I want to see a movie with a neanderthal apparition. 😅

  • @michellebyrom6551

    @michellebyrom6551

    3 ай бұрын

    Check out the BBC series Ghosts for the character Robin. Its a comedy with innumerable ghosts in an old Manor house.

  • @johnfisher247

    @johnfisher247

    3 ай бұрын

    Maybe they did not have immortal souls?

  • @LKMNOP

    @LKMNOP

    3 ай бұрын

    Considering your life was pretty hard back then, they're probably too smart to want to come back!

  • @cp1cupcake

    @cp1cupcake

    3 ай бұрын

    There was a series I read (before the author realized she would make more money writing smut and changed the series to that) where there is a pre-homo sapien hominid vampire. Not quite a ghost, but I think it fits.

  • @mds_main

    @mds_main

    Ай бұрын

    If you're interested in that, I highly suggest to you to watch the YT short movie called "Dinosaur Ghost" from David Romero.

  • @douglascolquhoun8502
    @douglascolquhoun85023 ай бұрын

    I love the idea of a series like this. Eventually, other "monstrous" creature types could spawn other series. Many thanks for all the info you put out on so many topics.

  • @matthewlentz2894
    @matthewlentz28943 ай бұрын

    You should cover the Norse draugr. Undead revenants guarding treasure in burial mounds.

  • @Dowlphin

    @Dowlphin

    3 ай бұрын

    Annoying blade fodder. 😄

  • @diegoborges3716
    @diegoborges37163 ай бұрын

    The catholic church isn't entirelly against the idea of souls of the dead appearing to the living. It is said that Saint Father Pius received regular visits from souls of the purgatory asking for prayers. But that visits were graces granted by God for certain souls in pain, and they just appeared to very faithful and sanctified people, like Father Pius himself.

  • @ignaciocamargo

    @ignaciocamargo

    25 күн бұрын

    And the purgatory museum

  • @KingFancyson
    @KingFancyson3 ай бұрын

    It would also be intresting to see you cover medieval witches, from what I can tell the beliefs of medieval people on witchcraft vary slightly from the 16th-17th centuries with all the witch hunts

  • @michellebyrom6551

    @michellebyrom6551

    3 ай бұрын

    Indeed. Terry Pratchett presented them as wise women and herbalists. Corresponds to the crone stage of the Sheila na Gig - maid, mother, crone. I suspect that's where the lore of witches began.

  • @kristianferencik8685

    @kristianferencik8685

    3 ай бұрын

    So I did a of research about this a year ago, at and from that, the conclusion is that at least the cleargy and theologist believed that witches were nothing more than pagan superstition. Its not till the 16th century till we see witch trials occuring initiated by the pope during that period. However, it's difficult to know if they did believe in it or if it was mainly used for political purposes such as the Catholic church combating the rising Protestant movement. However, during this time, some of the church and theologist did try to combat and put out their resentment against the witch trial movement (naturally because they could just get accused and "tested"(executed)) and by the late 17th century, the witch trials are pretty much extinct in most parts of europe.

  • @DoloresLehmann

    @DoloresLehmann

    3 ай бұрын

    @@ConontheBinarian Try saying this quickly: "Three Swiss witch bitches watch three swatch watch switches. Which Swiss witch bitch watches which swatch watch switch?"

  • @johnfisher247

    @johnfisher247

    3 ай бұрын

    There is a History Today article that shows what mainstream Church before the Reformation regarded as folk superstitution was regarded by Calvinist in Switzerland, Scotland and later North America and by Lutherans in Germany and Puritan faction of the C of E treated as demonic witchcraft. The paranoia of the Protestants particularly under King James VI 1597, who released Daemonologie, a treatise about witchcraft.

  • @altf4217
    @altf42173 ай бұрын

    7:22 missed opportunity to to warn about ghosts in the machine.

  • @UtamagUta
    @UtamagUta3 ай бұрын

    Im my country, the one that was the very last to embrace christianity and did not persecute pagans afterwards, we still have some traditions carried up to modern days. For example our 'ghosts' are spirits, most usually, of our ancestors who come to visit us from time to time. On all hallows day (a day dedicated for the dead) or on Christmas Eve -we leave food behind for them when they come to join our family dinner.

  • @Chaydex
    @Chaydex3 ай бұрын

    Huge thanks for this series in advance Metatron, this will become a valuable resource for my upcoming DnD campaign

  • @jeffzeiler346
    @jeffzeiler3463 ай бұрын

    "A Christmas Carol's" Jacob Marley, as an example of a cautionary, educational ghost. More of these, please, The Metatron!

  • @andrewd7112

    @andrewd7112

    3 ай бұрын

    Dickens wrote that in the 1840s iirc, so it's a few hundred years later than the medieval period. But, it shows that by the early 1800s there were concepts of ghosts widely known and commonly agreed upon so he could use a ghost as a major story element. The Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Future don't seem to be spirits of people returning from the dead; my impression has always been that they are very different in nature from Marley's ghost. That the term "ghost" is used for both Marley and them indicates medieval ideas that ghosts could be something other than a human coming back were also common.

  • @DoloresLehmann

    @DoloresLehmann

    3 ай бұрын

    @@andrewd7112 That's a very interesting point. I never stopped to think about the clear differences between the ghosts in the Christmas Carol. I'm of the impression that the Christmas ghosts don't fit a certain fixed idea of ghosts being something other than returned humans, rather that they are a metaphorical representation of the "spirit" of those events.

  • @bob7975

    @bob7975

    3 ай бұрын

    Even more than Halloween, Christmas was seen back then as a day when spirits walked abroad and could approach ordinary mortals.

  • @javel114
    @javel1143 ай бұрын

    One story from finland. Origin of Ievan Polkka (Ieva's polka). A folk song with very well known internet song, leek spin and loads of influencers butchering the lyrics. Talks about a neighbour boy and girl going dancing and not minding about the girls mothers orders. The historical story: A young girl died and was taken to the local church. A young boy was guarding the church at night, and reported the dead girl stood up, started dancing wildly, the boy fled and when the priest was brought, the girls feet were dirty (the body had been washed prior). Well, the boy was charged for necrophilia and sent to the russian army as punishment.

  • @RogerS1978
    @RogerS19783 ай бұрын

    There are a couple of experiences that make me believe there is something. The first is mine, I left a club in Nottingham early (and sober as I was on antibiotics) and was walking home with my friend. We was in the Meadows when we noticed a couple walking along the road wearing odd clothes (looked Victorian/Georgian) about 40ft (12m) ahead of us, we were catching them up but hadn't saw them before this road, walking from town. When we were about that far out I turned to my mate to comment on it and he looked at me then back ahead, under a second. The road was empty, to the left an 8-10ft spiked metal fence surrounding a school field and on the other side of the road, row houses with front walls about 3ft high. They couldn't have ran ahead in that time, couldn't see how they got over the fence and out of the street light coverage on the field and I crossed over and looked over every wall. Mate said he saw a couple but didn't notice anything specific, he was as confused as me as to where they went.

  • @RogerS1978

    @RogerS1978

    3 ай бұрын

    Another was my grandads story. Him and my nan had come back from a holiday to Blackpool, arriving in the dark. He went out for a walk down the garden to the toilet. At the bottom of where all the gardens finish was a pond with some damson trees (was still there at the time and I saw it). He saw the neighbours girl sitting by the pond about 10ft away, he thought it odd, called to her and went to ask if she was ok, but by the time he got through the gate, no one was around. After finishing, he came back into the house and told my nan, great nan and great grandad what he'd seen. They were shocked. My great grandparents had just been telling my nan how the neighbours girl drowned in the pond a few days earlier, while he was up the garden. I saw the place before it was built over.

  • @kungpowsesame8260

    @kungpowsesame8260

    3 ай бұрын

    Emotional residue

  • @RogerS1978

    @RogerS1978

    3 ай бұрын

    @@kungpowsesame8260 interesting, sort of like an imprint on the place?

  • @DoloresLehmann

    @DoloresLehmann

    3 ай бұрын

    @@RogerS1978 Those are really interesting stories. I'm convinced a lot of those sightings are genuine, but I don't think it's about dead people "returning" into the world of the living, or "staying in this dimension because they still have unfinished business". My take on the matter is that time doesn't really exist (a concept that's actually being pondered in physics). And since it doesn't really exist, past, present and future are all simultaneous. Things don't "pass" and "cease to exist", they just move out of sight of the living. It's all still there, we just can't see it anymore. Some people, though, who have a finer perception, can, at certain times, when the circumstances are ideal, catch a glimpse on so-called past (or also future) events, and that's what we call either ghost apparitions or foreknowledge. I've actually pondered writing a ghost story where, in a house, two people who live(d) there at different times perceive EACH OTHER as ghosts.

  • @jokuvaan5175

    @jokuvaan5175

    3 ай бұрын

    My dad told a story about his own dad. A drunken violent man. He was once out in forest alone when it started raining. There was an empty cabin nearby where he went to seek shelter. After a while he heard a knock on the door and went to open it to find a woman standing alone outside the door. She asked if she could come in and my grandpa let her in, but then quickly packed his things and left the cabin after the woman just walked through a wall of the cabin.

  • @drip369
    @drip3693 ай бұрын

    First episode? Keep em coming!

  • @RealMrBruh
    @RealMrBruh3 ай бұрын

    Great video, hope you make more of these.

  • @ForfexSceleris
    @ForfexSceleris3 ай бұрын

    This series is going to be absolutely FANTASTIC. Brilliant idea, Metatron, 🤘🏻

  • @nazarnovitsky9868
    @nazarnovitsky98683 ай бұрын

    Thanks for the new video ! 😊

  • @dianahowell3423
    @dianahowell34233 ай бұрын

    Great episode! I'd love to see more.

  • @nickmanzo8459
    @nickmanzo84593 ай бұрын

    Great video, Metatron, I loved it, and am definitely in the “more, please!” Camp on this subject.

  • @kostasmanousakis1081
    @kostasmanousakis10813 ай бұрын

    Outstanding!!! Please make more episodes!!! It is really interesting!!!

  • @SheakiFreaky
    @SheakiFreaky3 ай бұрын

    Great concept metatron i look forward to seeing more from this series. Thanks for all the videos and keep up the amazing work u do :).

  • @nlm6183
    @nlm61833 ай бұрын

    Fascinating. Please make more!

  • @wesrobinson3294
    @wesrobinson32943 ай бұрын

    Can't wait to see more!

  • @internaut4257
    @internaut42573 ай бұрын

    Very interesting new series, I’m looking forward to watching more in depth explorations of this topic!

  • @ShagShaggio
    @ShagShaggio3 ай бұрын

    This was great, super interesting! Would love to see much more of this! Cheers!

  • @carlettoburacco9235
    @carlettoburacco92353 ай бұрын

    Maybe you can help: I remember reading about at least 2 monasteries, famous in medieval times for the "visions" that the residents constantly had. Apparently in both cases the water source from which they obtained supplies for drinking was contaminated (lead, poisonous mold... I don't remember) One thing I'm sure of is that one was in Italy and one in Spain. I can't find a single reference anywhere.

  • @hiselbii5326
    @hiselbii53263 ай бұрын

    What a great topic! I would really love to see more episodes!

  • @marklaurenzi1609
    @marklaurenzi16093 ай бұрын

    This sounds like a great series! I look forward to your next video.

  • @caspianbchalphy
    @caspianbchalphy3 ай бұрын

    fascinating! I definitely want to see more of this!

  • @orlandodiciccio2748
    @orlandodiciccio27483 ай бұрын

    One of the most interesting and entertaining things I’ve seen in a long long while, I hope this will be a long series! 😊

  • @Yattayatta
    @Yattayatta3 ай бұрын

    This was excellent, I really really enjoyed it, I would like more of this!

  • @YazzyFairy
    @YazzyFairy3 ай бұрын

    Really excited for this series! I can't wait to learn more about the medieval folklore :)

  • @draconiusdracen836
    @draconiusdracen8363 ай бұрын

    This was very fascinating. Please keep making more.

  • @KamiSeiTo
    @KamiSeiTo3 ай бұрын

    Oh yes, this is SO INTERESTING! Please make it a long looong series. n_n

  • @martincougoulat1306
    @martincougoulat13063 ай бұрын

    Love this vid! please do more it is such an interresting subject

  • @Kargoneth
    @Kargoneth3 ай бұрын

    Thank you, Metatron. I would be interested in hearing more about these ghosts and other undead.

  • @dangerich530
    @dangerich5303 ай бұрын

    Thank you Metatron, very interesting. Scaring stories next to come 😅

  • @enricopiu4658
    @enricopiu46583 ай бұрын

    THIS SERIE OF VIDEOS CAN BE A BANGER METATRON

  • @gryaznygreeb
    @gryaznygreeb2 ай бұрын

    I love your channel and I love spooky stuff. I'd love to see more of this series!

  • @luckyels3034
    @luckyels30343 ай бұрын

    Loved this series, keep it on.

  • @kentspeak465
    @kentspeak4653 ай бұрын

    I wish this episode was hours long, hope you will do more about this topic

  • @JohnTBlock
    @JohnTBlock2 ай бұрын

    All of these subjects are fascinating to me, Metatron.would love more reasearch!

  • @diegoc.8931
    @diegoc.893123 күн бұрын

    I loved it! Keep doing more of this videos

  • @sameechaos1
    @sameechaos13 ай бұрын

    Your videos give great info, and your passion is refreshing as always. More please~

  • @colinmackay92
    @colinmackay923 ай бұрын

    Hello Raf. Just wanted to say that I really appreciate all of your videos and they always help me out when I'm feeling down. I've been a noble one for a very long time and I always appreciate the hard work that you put into these videos. You're a class act my friend.

  • @pedromiguel3227
    @pedromiguel32273 ай бұрын

    Metatron! Back at it with more divine educational entertainment for us. Thanks again for sharing your latest gem.

  • @SteveVonBacon
    @SteveVonBacon3 ай бұрын

    Yes, please more of this. Very interesting topic!

  • @r.j.amadeus9128
    @r.j.amadeus91283 ай бұрын

    This was very interesting, definitely enjoyed this episode.

  • @coyotejake9164
    @coyotejake91643 ай бұрын

    This was succinct, yet fascinating. I would love to hear more!

  • @ShadowBaneling
    @ShadowBaneling3 ай бұрын

    Really good video about ghost stories and their origins. Definitely make more!

  • @kamenriderkfp6684
    @kamenriderkfp66843 ай бұрын

    A most fascinating and interesting topic. And that transition to the add read was beautifully executed

  • @Calu114
    @Calu1143 ай бұрын

    Love the content metatron, keep it up !

  • @Fred-px5xu
    @Fred-px5xu3 ай бұрын

    Kudos Sir! Brilliant video lecture on the subject of the function ghosts in The Medieval Period.

  • @revan23117
    @revan231173 ай бұрын

    Fantastic concept.

  • @gabrieljean906
    @gabrieljean9063 ай бұрын

    Yes, this was very interesting! I'd love to hear more on the matter from you!

  • @Silverlightlive
    @Silverlightlive2 ай бұрын

    You are always interesting, but the background images you chose were absolutely fantastic! Keep up the great work!

  • @tHiSfUgGgiNdUdE
    @tHiSfUgGgiNdUdE3 ай бұрын

    Definitely interested in seeing more from this series Metatron. I was wondering when you were gonna go back to doing fantasy -esque topics through a historical lense.

  • @mjisabelle18
    @mjisabelle183 ай бұрын

    I really like the idea of the series. I would be very happy if you continued the series.

  • @MikeBison_
    @MikeBison_3 ай бұрын

    I would absolutely love to see more of this. Scholarly approaches to the supernatural have always fascinated me.

  • @Polloles
    @Polloles2 ай бұрын

    Loved this subject! Please do make more content about the paranormal/mythological aspects of the past!!

  • @RishPanjeetJr
    @RishPanjeetJr3 ай бұрын

    LOVE IT. More of this kind of fun/historical/supernatural stuff. The only thing I’m not super-into that you do is, say, armor/weapons testing. Everything else I think is fascinating.

  • @noweg2299
    @noweg22993 ай бұрын

    Great topic. I would love to see more of it. How many of the modern topics and tropes we already had in the medieval time? Zombies, Liches, undead Kings? Did they only see undead connected to devine or satanic deeds or also as influenced by human magic? How much of the fantasy tropes were already there...priest to be able to revoke ghosts and undead...holy water etc?

  • @kristianferencik8685

    @kristianferencik8685

    3 ай бұрын

    So when we are thinking about zombies in the modern sense, the term only started to be used in the 60s, before then zombies were the hypnotised dead voodoo doctors controlled. Vampires, were the zombies of the past and there mythology might also be linked to real life phenomenons such as corpses moving due to the build up of gas and the ensurement of the corpses being dead as to avoid them waking up alive in the coffins during a time when that wasn't uncommon. So if you're going to put old Bobby 6ft under, just put a steak through the heart, cause he's not going to have a good time if it turns out he didnt actually die.

  • @swankelly
    @swankelly3 ай бұрын

    I love learning about what people thought of the dead throughout history. Please make more of this sort of content.

  • @Xxtayce
    @Xxtayce3 ай бұрын

    This was great, thanks!!

  • @elburropeligroso4689
    @elburropeligroso46893 ай бұрын

    Please do more of this!

  • @ghostdog1117
    @ghostdog11173 ай бұрын

    I loved it please make more!!! Different ghosts from different countries would be cool!!!

  • @jessicabaker1274
    @jessicabaker12743 ай бұрын

    Really enjoyed this bud ❤😊

  • @BlazingKomet
    @BlazingKomet3 ай бұрын

    That thumbnail is SO cool! Thank you for the continued intensely interesting content

  • @st0rmrider
    @st0rmrider3 ай бұрын

    Wow, great video!

  • @NecroticRampage
    @NecroticRampage3 ай бұрын

    Please make more like this!

  • @aevenova9780
    @aevenova97803 ай бұрын

    What an awesome idea for a series!

  • @anzerupnik1442
    @anzerupnik14423 ай бұрын

    Cool idea for a video series!

  • @sharonsellers6247
    @sharonsellers62473 ай бұрын

    Love the subject. More please.

  • @victortitimas6904
    @victortitimas69043 ай бұрын

    I liked it, please make more episodes!:)

  • @dianetheone4059
    @dianetheone40593 ай бұрын

    Good series!

  • @IamZeus1100
    @IamZeus11003 ай бұрын

    I don’t necessarily believe or disbelieve in ghost or spirits but I always find the occult to be so fascinating . This was a great idea , Metatron ! Might just be a new favorite series of yours (it’s hard to pick , you have so many great videos) . Thanks for the great content !

  • @JeffDrennen
    @JeffDrennen3 ай бұрын

    This was a fun topic. Keep it up.

  • @margueritelouw5790
    @margueritelouw57903 ай бұрын

    Please make more videos like this one! Your approach is excellent!

  • @metatronyt

    @metatronyt

    3 ай бұрын

    Thanks, will do

  • @Shay33s
    @Shay33s3 ай бұрын

    Gladiator is my favourite medieval horror film followed by troy .

  • @KingFancyson

    @KingFancyson

    3 ай бұрын

    Two truly versatile and formidable movies

  • @derpatrizier

    @derpatrizier

    3 ай бұрын

    You forgot the best medieval film of all times... "Stalingrad"

  • @brandonrossjr
    @brandonrossjr3 ай бұрын

    Good one!!

  • @neiljohnson6815
    @neiljohnson68153 ай бұрын

    Well done. Carry on.

  • @MishaDark
    @MishaDark3 ай бұрын

    I love you Metatron, you’re always keeping it interesting and cheeky but also educational and fact-based. Keep it up, my man!

  • @Nyctophora
    @Nyctophora3 ай бұрын

    This was interesting, thank you!

  • @MyLobotomy14
    @MyLobotomy143 ай бұрын

    I would love to see more content regarding topics of folklore and mythology throughout history, especially in the medieval period.

  • @franz6595
    @franz65953 ай бұрын

    Very interesting loved it!

  • @funkymuskcrat73
    @funkymuskcrat733 ай бұрын

    Great, please continue

  • @MinomeEslinde
    @MinomeEslinde3 ай бұрын

    Great video and looking forward on more on story telling and belief between then in medieval times or other historical times and now on skeletons, vampires, werewolves, dragons and more.

  • @nitrotortoise5677
    @nitrotortoise56773 ай бұрын

    Another great video, as always. There's so much about human culture that they dont teach in schools, so I'm glad you're around to share things like this with us! Keep it up, and please give your mother my family's best!

  • @zombiefolklore
    @zombiefolklore3 ай бұрын

    This video brings to mind the stories of the Yuki-onna, which serve as a fantastic explanation for the effects of hypothermia.

  • @embee7434
    @embee74343 ай бұрын

    I appreciate your clean and clear discussion format. I LOVE that you include the outline and progression. Enjoyable topic!

  • @metatronyt

    @metatronyt

    3 ай бұрын

    Glad you enjoyed it thanks

  • @anta3612
    @anta36123 ай бұрын

    Fascinating subject!