This is probably the best comparison video that I have ever seen.

@sushantasamantaray7140

3 жыл бұрын

I agree !!

This is exactly what I was looking for! Thanks a lot

This is perfect, exactly the comparison I was looking for U2419 vs P2419. Thank you!

@Tourism09

3 жыл бұрын

I have the same confusion between 2 versions

Thank u so much for this review. Excactly what I was looking for! And you went into every single detail, amazing work my man.

Thank you James for the detailed comparison. You have an eye for detail.

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks! Hoped it helped you :)

Thanks for clearing my mind! Choosing a monitor is the most difficult task in the world...

Great comparison and channel! I've just subscribed. Thank you so much!

Thanks. I actually watched the video for that last comparison. P vs U series display comparison. You just answered it for me!!

Thank you so much for the detailed comparison mate! Cheers!

Great review, you're very thorough, so thank you for that.

That was amazing, I watched this while waiting for Dell website customer support to reply about viewing areas.. lol This told me everything, thank you! :)

Very useful, especially screen shots showing picture quality. Thanks!

Congrats Man! Perfect video.

I really need this comparison, and you done it like super detail. I decide to go with U2419H. Thanks alot, mate!

@joonesmusic

3 жыл бұрын

Me too :)

@jpmc4715

3 жыл бұрын

why

Keep up the good work, great video. If possible please include technical comparison as well like connectivity, display experience, lags etc.

Thanks for clearing my doubts.

thanks man for the professiona and clean review

thanks for video. i have u2417H, works just fine till today thinking of buying 2419H to make a dual screen setup

Great comparison, thank you!

thanks man very detailed comparison ...

Excellent comparison. Really helped with my purchase

Nice comparison. Very detailed and really side by side.

Thank you for gr8 video! It was very helpful.

Thank you so much , it was very informative. 👌👍

Very informative. I decided on the U2417h. Thanks for your help.

@jpmc4715

3 жыл бұрын

why

great video! i bought recently the p2419h but i was so used to a great color monitor that it felt really blent, i guess for someone who doesnt know how good colors a monitor can get, it is definitly a great pick, specially if it is for some office/second monitor style. Im returning it to get the u2419h since the audio input is a great deal for me

@Scorpionhazer

2 жыл бұрын

which one do you recommend?

@baund_1453

11 ай бұрын

what do you prefer?

Thanks for this video. Best comparison

Amazing video! Would you say that, side by side, u2417 and u2419 have identical dimensions on the panel? I couldn't tell by the shot where they are side by side because it was a darkshot. I'd like to put both monitors together by I'm afraid they will differ on panel dimension some how. Thx!

It was the super best review video... I managed to get u2419h ... had lot of confusion between u2419h...and p2419h

Great, just great man.

very helpful video - thanks

Super reviewer always!

Very useful comparison, thanks.

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Glad it was helpful!

I bought the P2419HC and wanted to get a second monitor. The two choices were either the P2419H or the U2419H. Does it annoy you when using a dual monitor setup, that the P24 has thicker borders compared to the U24? I was going to desk mount both monitors.

Do we really need so much external specs? What about colours, calibration etc?

thx from BR help a lot

Better than most videos on the outside mechanics of a monitor but almost nothing on the monitor as far as text quality, sharpness, videos, or reflectiveness. With some added work, your videos could be the best on KZread.

Nice Unboxing...do you know if Dell 24 USB-C Hub Monitor - P2422HE will work with Macbook ?

Really Superb

Thanks for the video!! useful information! I just have a question! (I have a MacBook Air 11 - 2014 with Thunderbolt 2/Mini DisplayPort), and I want to buy a monitor with Displayport like the Dell P2419H. I want to have (always) a Webcam connected to a USB port in the monitor itself and not to my Macbook (bc I don't wanna connect and disconnect a camera any time I want to leave). Does the Mini DisplayPort works in that way? (on transfering data), do I need a Mini DisplayPort to Displayport adapter??? Thank you for your time! Greetings from Chile!

I would really appreciate some more in depth comparison of P and U series regarding picture quality. I would really like to know if U is worth the extra money if taking into account the picture quality :)

thank you good job

Hi James, i recently purchased the P series. Does it comes with the HDMI cable? Also other then the hdmi cable how can i connect this with my laptop

Super video! Can you turn the P2719H 180 degrees like the P2419H, and can you find a 27 inch edition of the U2419H? Subbed and liked the video! Thank you!

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Sorry, not sure about the 27" version. I would assume yes? Not about the Ultrasharp of 27". Probably, best is to look at Dell's website.

Excellent. Intelligent.

Thank u for info

Are the borders of the P2419h on the left side, on the right side and the upper side, the same size as the U2419h?

Great review! Since it has been a few months since this review, what is your impression of the U2419H now. The U2419H currently has a 1 star rating at 10% on Amazon where a few reviews are complaining of flickering and all out failure. which is high in my opinion. The U2417H model (2yrs older) only has a 1 start rating of 2% and much higher customer satisfaction. I like the fact that the 19H only weighs 6.9lbs versus the 13.9lbs of the 17H but if the quality is better in the 17H, that would be my deciding factor. The 19H is actually slightly cheaper than the 17H as well.

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Have been using both side-by-side and have had no issues using it :)

A great profesional video, extreamly helpful thanks..... I do have one question, does this monitor turn on from stand-by when it detects a signal from a PC?

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Yes it does :)

Hey James, great video on both monitors. A quick question; for graphic design (not photo or video editing) would be the P2419h be good enough in terms of color accuracy after a calibration? I presume you did calibrate the P2419h, how close is it to U2419H. I'm trying to decide if the extra money will be worth buying U2419H. Because I'm going to buy 3 of them :)

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Colour accuracy for design is just as important, especially with a lot of graphic design content being show on digital devices, so having an accurate display is important. If you do have access to a colour calibration tool, then the P2419H might be sufficient for your use. Thought you are in for a luck of the draw in terms of the exact panels that you get. The Ultrasharps go through an extra process and quality check for colour accuracy, something the Professional series do not have.

@rgnyldz

3 жыл бұрын

@@jcunboxing I understand, thank you for your answer. I will go and hunt for a discount on ultrasharp here in Turkey. Other than that I'll go for the P2319h series. That 23" might give a little bir more sharpness. For the outcome I'll post the results here so others can benefit ;)

@yerassylkelsingazin2408

2 жыл бұрын

​@@rgnyldz ​ Hi! What is your experience after almost a year of using U2419H? Now, I do not know what to choose too: either P2419H or U2419H. After this video, for me they are still very similar to each other. What will you recommend from your point of view?

@rgnyldz

2 жыл бұрын

@@yerassylkelsingazin2408 hey there, I ended up buying U2419 yes but how did you know that I bougth them :) If you are going to do simple graphic design than I think P2419 will do just fine because not all your customers or visitors will have a color accuracy as you will (Or as professionals). If you are going to do print design then I would recomend the U series. But other than that I believe that if you don't have that much of a sharp eye for details and colors I would go with P series since they are a bit cheaper. If you are at the right distance the pixel density will not bother you. But it's definately there. (I used a 17" 1080p monitor for a long time, that was sharp. ) For the pivot handling I really never use it :) But it is useful if you have a 3 monitor setup like me and want them to align them perfectly.

@yerassylkelsingazin2408

2 жыл бұрын

Ergün YILDIZ it is common, when people doubt what to buy, then they usually choose better option :D What about monitor stand? I read that U series’ stand is more thinner and when you lift up as much as possible, monitor becomes unstable and swings. But to my mind, other features are better at U series: more coolers, screen is thinner. Am I right? :)

Nice review that i’m looking for.. i’m thinking about having dual monitor setup including u2419D for editing. the other one is for gaming. Do you know any Dell 24inch high refresh rate suitable for gaming.?

@AndrewGallimore

3 жыл бұрын

I have been looking for a few months also and the best I seen was an IPS with 75hz. Probably better to get a TN panel (only downside loosing color accuracy). Because I'm a professional designer I went with a dual setup (U2417H & U2519H). Can't afford loosing color accuracy but I give up frame rate :( If anything I can also use my Razer blade with 144hz but screen is 15" .. oh well. Hope this helps

@kaistudio8229

3 жыл бұрын

@@AndrewGallimore Good info friend. I have found a monitor with 144hz and low respond time like Acer Xv240y and Aoc 24g2 but the size of the bezel does not match when paired with dell. But I would like to know if a gaming monitor like Dell S2721dgf or LG 27gl850 is able to provide benefits in video and photo editing. i need help.. i need a decent editing monitor for a best price while having a good gaming experience😌

@AndrewGallimore

3 жыл бұрын

@@kaistudio8229 hey, try this -> www.rtings.com/monitor/tools/table On this website you can go through various filter categories to determine the strength and weaknesses of the monitor using the sliders, it may be able to help. Keep in mind that they have reviewed a lot of monitors but not all! (note: I'm sorry James Chia I don't mean to advertise another channel/link under your video)

Which one buy from DELL P2419H vs LG 24MP88HV

Thanks for comparing

Hello! Im a beginner about monitors, Im just looking for a good quality not expensive monitor to do some work, basically answer emails or working with word, excel. I found the Dell E2417H as an option but im not sure if its a good option for what i explain before, i needed as a second display for my dell xps 13 laptop.

Thank you

Is the U2419H worth the extra money vs the P2419H? I'm not upgrading from anything and my main uses revolve around productivity, presentation design on powerpoint, webrowsing and movies. I can afford both but it would be nice to spend the extra cash on other accessories if the difference isn't worth it.

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Aside from physical differences, I would go with the P2419H based off what you've told me. But if the physical things are important than by all means.

Thank you James, anyway in Indonesia, U2419H and P2419HC is same price (little different), so what do you think? should i buy P2419HC with Type C or take U2419H ?

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Completely depends on your needs and if the C is going to be beneficial for you, or if the Ultrasharp colour accuracy is more important.

@jemirokasih

3 жыл бұрын

Thank you Brader ,anyway in P2419H If i connect USB upstream to my Macbook (using type a to c converter), can i use USB on monitor?

Thanks

Do all the changes you mentioned for the BASE on the U2419H apply to the P2419HC?

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

I'm not entirely sure, but I think the physical aspects of the monitor are the same, only difference is the USB-C cable. I'm not entirely sure though...

This looks to me like U series has extra glossy layer, or smth like that, because this is pretty much same to me, insignificant difference really.

Do you have a video on trouble shooting how to connect monitor with USB with cord provided? Thanks

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

USB is just for data, it won't do video. You still need to connect a display cable such as HDMI or DisplayPort

@AndyK.1

Жыл бұрын

You need the HC model for that and firmware update

Which is better ?? P2419H or S2421HN

p2719H vs u2419h which is good for photo, video editing and 3D modeling texturing ,i'm confuse between this because i need big monitor can i consider p2719H is good for me because in same price i got 27 inch monitor ,really tough to decide please help me out.

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Depends if you need the high colour accuracy. If so, go for the Ultrasharp. If not, then then pro. But you may notice pixels due to it being 1080 for a 27"

@factfusion705

3 жыл бұрын

@@jcunboxing ok then please tell me which is best between u2415 and u2419h.. im looking for my graphic and 3d work

Grt

I'm using P2319H but I don't like the text. So considering a monitor with sharper text. How's U2419H in that regard?

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Honestly, it'll be probably be the same because the PPI is the same. You want a monitor with a high PPI.

@heliostud

3 жыл бұрын

@@jcunboxing which monitors have a high PPI? because I am researching for reading text - thought the U would be better but now I am not so sure.

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Nah no difference because the ppi is the same. 1080p at 24". You would want something like a 4K at 27". That has a higher ppi and good for text.

@heliostud

3 жыл бұрын

@@jcunboxing thanks for the advice; a quick search and the dell S2817Q popped up. I see what you mean now. Will try and find something newer and more affordable though. :)

@Rnato08

3 жыл бұрын

@@heliostud You can look for 1440p 24'', should be much cheaper than a 4k panel

so should i get the older model U2417H and still beats the new p2418H model? the new U2419H is not in stock

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Depends on what you want for the monitor. Like do you need the colour accuracy? If not, then can look to get the P series, or you can get the new U2421HE.

@JimmyWayne7

3 жыл бұрын

@@jcunboxing where I’m at the 2 cost the same right now, been the new p2418h and the old U2417H , I don’t really need the colour accuracy right now but I will down the road, so I figured I can do it all with the U series where p series can’t really do video editing as good so

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

I would wait to see if you can get the newer Ultrasharp model if you're not desparate.

Hi is the U series monitor better for photo editing than the P series.

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Yes! More colour accurate.

Man, I would like to see more than 1 image when you compare them... texts... deep black comparison...

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Sorry. My main intention for this video was the compare the physical and basic differences, not really the detailed stuff. Not really my area of expertise.

very useful and deatiled video! 3 of them are also monitors i concerned about lately.

Is there any speakers that I can use with the P2429H or nothing is compatible with it?

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

A USB speaker should work.

@captainnutty4168

3 жыл бұрын

@@jcunboxing I just plug it into any of the usb ports?

Price-wise there is a huge difference between P series and U series monitors.

Guys my samsung TN panel hurts my eyes too much. Can you answer me, Is Dell Ultrasharp 24" U2419H a good monitor for my eyes?

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

If your monitor is hurting your eyes, maybe you should invest getting some blue light filter lenses. It has been theorised to help eye strain. My friend recently got some and it worked for him, reduced his eye strain.

How do the bezels compare in the two u24s?

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Pretty much identical.

@davidsmonkeyroost

2 жыл бұрын

@@jcunboxing Thanks, that's exactly what I needed to know. I want to add to my existing dual U2417H setup with a monitor which basically looks and behaves the same, and ignoring the stand, it sounds like the 17H and 19H are as good as identical.

how can I get the audio out of p2419h model... Can it be done with USB to 3.5 mm jack

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Yea you should be able to get a USB to 3.5mm audio interface. Orico have a cheap model that works well.

Excelent! Thanks for this video. Solve my doubt about color and sharpness between U and P series. I have a U2417H and a few weeks after the garantee has expired the IPS panel screen burned out. Dell has not repair program or technical assistance in Brazil and no spare parts to sell. A great product, but disposable when out of garantee period. Good Bye Dell, never more.

Can I charge my MacBook Pro using a USB-C to a DisplayPort cable to this monitor? the U2419H

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Nope

Can you Daisy-chain the U2419H to the P2419H

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Yes, you can. Just need to make sure that the display port is going to the Ultrasharp from your computer, then from the Ultrasharp into the Pro

Is P2419H serie more valuable than U2419H serie?

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

The main differences beside physical differences is that the Ultrasharp comes factory calibrated for colour accuracy.

Hey guys do you think the P2421D even being a P series instead of U, is better than the U2419H? I know the better resolution is a plus but overall, did anyone copared both?

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

All comes down to whether you need the colour accuracy. If so get the Ultrasharp

@4bianchi

3 жыл бұрын

@@jcunboxing Im actually looking for a more comfy looking screen for long work hours, reading texts and graphics. If collor acuracy delivers that, im definately trying it! but if resolution makes more sense... i'd go for the QHD. Im asking because I had a LG ultrawide 2560x1080 and it was soooooo smooth to work with it. Not the same feel with the P2319h. I even compared them but it looks like they have the same specs.

It's a comparison between monitors and the most important stuff, the image, did not last more than a few seconds of talking. : (

put buy link for India also

I got P for programming :)

so what the best ?

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

All have their pros & cons. Just depends on what your budget & needs are.

Hi guy. I just bought a Dell u2419h when I watched a movie on youtube, some videos with fast moving scenes appeared a blurry stripe to see closely, but when I pressed pause at that moment, I couldn't see it, press play, it came out show. Or a gentle shake of the head. I don't know if it's an error or not. Anyone know how to explain it to me! Thank you everyone

@TrungLe-pb6qx

3 жыл бұрын

u2417 is me

@Tuananh-hb2td

3 жыл бұрын

@@TrungLe-pb6qx bro cũng bị hả. Có phải là lỗi ko bro ?

@TrungLe-pb6qx

3 жыл бұрын

Dell dòng u nó thế bạn ạ. P thì k bị nhưg dòng P màu k ok bằg

@Tuananh-hb2td

3 жыл бұрын

@@TrungLe-pb6qx mình dùng nó khó chịu quá. Nhìn nó cứ sọc sọc. Nay bên dell gửi cho cái mới tinh mà cũng bị y vậy 😅

@TrungLe-pb6qx

3 жыл бұрын

@@Tuananh-hb2td vậy là ấm rồi b. Bạn báo lỗi kiểu gì mà được đổi thế

Mine says U2419HX?

Tbh this channel is second to LTT

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

Thanks man! Means a lot,

What if I add sharpness on P series monitor, wouldn't it be sharper? :D

@jcunboxing

2 жыл бұрын

It would look sharper but I wouldn't recommend it. It's artificial sharpness and I think it doesn't enhance the overall image, unless you have a very specific use for it.

5:00 What laptop are you talking about? Or are you referring to the screen having higher NIT rating? Very dodgy review

Get some glasses. Both have identical display unless you have owl eyes

??? What kind of Monitor Review spends 98% on the Stand and how the Monitor looks "turned off" ? What about "TEXT SHARPNESS" ! ! !

@jcunboxing

3 жыл бұрын

It's in the title video, this is purely a comparison video. You can find the links to the full walkthrough/reviews of each of these monitors in the description :)

just got my P2419hc version (not the U2419h): Dell is a TOTAL RIP OFF!! The P2419hc --- which WAS MADE IN 2019 -- came with the OLD STAND --from ALL the way back in 2017!!!! This makes a BIG difference in my work station set-up! I was counting on that stand and the new Flexibility --- IT SHOULD have COME WITH---ESPECIALLY since it was MADE in 2109!!! There is ZERO REASON( except -- GREED) on Dell's part to NOT INCLUDE the STAND that WAS MADE IN 2019--- with the P version --- that was MADE IN 2019!! This is the KIND OF GARBAGE that sent DELL down the tubes the FIRST time it LEFT the STOCK MARKET( plus its overwhelming debt)!! I thought Dell had by now got its act together----- but -- NO --- same old SCAM--- just dressed up differently! The stands SHOULD have BEEN the SAME in P2419hc and U2419H!!

Would you recommend the DELL P2720D over U2419H? Does the ultrasharp makes difference? My budget cant reach the ultrasharp 27 inch

@DesignsByMario

3 жыл бұрын

The P2720D is definitely a much better monitor overall if you're not doing colour critical work, like graphics design. It's a good amount bigger over the Ultrasharp, but also has a 1440p resolution which is a lot better than 1080p. You are missing out a few features, the stand on the Ultrasharp is a bit better, the colours on the Ultrasharp are better and some small details like the specifically charging port on the left side of the display. But overall, I'd say the P2720D is a much better deal.