Debate: Radosław Sikorski vs. Andrzej Nowak on Polish foreign policy

Moderator: Dr Stanley Bill (University of Cambridge)
A debate on Polish foreign policy between former Foreign Minister Radosław Sikorski and Professor Andrzej Nowak on 28 January 2017 at the 10th Congress of Polish Student Societies in Cambridge, UK.

Пікірлер: 231

  • @eqramer
    @eqramer2 жыл бұрын

    Byly MSZ wysmiewajacy za granica poziom polskich uniwersytetow (i to nie w ramach wezwania do podwyzszenia ich poziomu, ale by zdyskedytowac interlokutora) - co za brak klasy!

  • @RobS64

    @RobS64

    2 жыл бұрын

    Ale czy poparcie kłamstw smoleńskich to świadczyć ma dobrze o profesorze z UJ? Po prawniku, doktorze Duda z tego uniwersytetu wiemy co nieco o tamtejszym wydziale prawa (ahahaha)

  • @RobS64

    @RobS64

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@jaroslawpeter3586 Brak klasy to w publicznej debacie atakować personalnie swojego partnera w dyskusji na wykładzie publicznym - to poziom profesora UJ. To, że polskie uczelnie są klasyfikowane ok 500 miejsca w rankingach światowych nie świadczy o nich i o kadrze dobrze. Prawactwo nacjonalistyczne: bycie dumnym z czegoś czego się samemu nie zrobiło i nienawiść do ludzi, których się nie poznało.

  • @jaroslawpeter3586

    @jaroslawpeter3586

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@RobS64 Brak manier Sikorskiego jest w Polsce szeroko znany. Jego słynne robienie "łaski" z Sowa i Przyjaciele, chamskie dowcipy i słynne "trzeba dorżnąć watahę" zajmują niechlubne miejsce na ścianie hańby menelskiej dyplomacji. Jeśli takich osobników masowo produkuje Oxford to tylko antyreklama tego miejsca. Największy nielot polskiej dyplomacji, zresztą były członek PiS. Typowy karierowicz, woda na niemiecki młyn.

  • @jaroslawpeter3586

    @jaroslawpeter3586

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@RobS64 Jeśli "atakujesz" kogoś CYTUJĄC jego własne słowa, to jest to jak najbardziej dozwolone w debacie akademickiej. To jest fair. Postsowiecki szderczy obskórny styl Sikorskiego, jego żałosna pretensjonalna maniera zgrywania lorda, którym nie jest, ataki personalne bez podawania faktów, dopełniają obrazu tego nieudanego, wysoce niedyplomatycznego polityka.

  • @Abc-th1lr

    @Abc-th1lr

    Жыл бұрын

    @@jaroslawpeter3586 Ale te "cytaty" są używane w sposób, który ma na celu manipulacje wypowiedzi. Natomiast chciałbym, aby Pan podał przykład "zgrywania lorda" i przykład tych "ataków personalnych". Tylko z góry zaznaczam - proszę mi nie pisać, że i tak tego nie zrozumiem, że jestem zabetonowany, że jestem zdrajcą etc. Naprawdę chętnie zapoznam się z tymi przykładami.

  • @mattbrody1424
    @mattbrody14242 жыл бұрын

    Clown Sikorski, Oxford's graduate, schooled by prof. Nowak on every issue they discussed. You can learn a lot from prof. Nowak how to discuss with idiots and humiliate them in an elegant way.

  • @richt7
    @richt77 жыл бұрын

    Przypomina to dialog inteligenta z gangsterem. Smutne.

  • @zawaprz

    @zawaprz

    Жыл бұрын

    Niestety...a jeszcze bardziej smutne że na tym lewackim uniwersytecie same gnidy w stylu zdradka...wspaniale Prof rozjechał tego antypolaka .... Gnida myślała że jak ma brytyjski akcent to wszystko mu wolno.... Mam nadzieję, że po wojnie takie gówno będzie z kraju wyrzucone lub osądzone...i osadzone.

  • @piotr8018
    @piotr8018 Жыл бұрын

    I AM writing in August 2022... How very much right prof. Nowak was and how very much wrong Sikorski was in this debate... I AM Polish and believe me, closly watching politics, every word prof. Nowak was saying was truth. Very sad.

  • @jackswiatek5221
    @jackswiatek52217 жыл бұрын

    A Polish Foreign Minister (however former) acknowledging that the educational institution in his own country is inferior to any other education institution in another country - even if that might be true - is negatively significant, to say the least. Minister Sikorski.... if you feel inferior in dealing with other countries, then what do you want to achieve?

  • @mattbrody1424

    @mattbrody1424

    2 жыл бұрын

    Agree. This comment was inappropriate and only shows what kind of clown Sikorski is

  • @ewasvensson7939
    @ewasvensson79392 жыл бұрын

    Jego machanie łapami i jego nerwowość jest dowodem na jego brak panowania nad emocjami a to brak jego profesjonalizmu!!

  • @ewasvensson7939
    @ewasvensson79392 жыл бұрын

    Pan Nowak skompromitował sikorskiego jako ministra i jako Polaka i jako człowieka!Sikorski dal świadectwo swojego prymitywizmu paroma komentarzami i każdy wie typ dobić watache.

  • @ewaleski7158

    @ewaleski7158

    Жыл бұрын

    👍👍👍🇵🇱👍👍👍

  • @MM-bj2ux
    @MM-bj2ux6 жыл бұрын

    Brawo Prof.Nowak !!! Excellent arguments vs. Sikorski !

  • @andrew.r.lukasik
    @andrew.r.lukasik Жыл бұрын

    32:10 Radosław Sikorski is no person of academic nature but a ruthless politician interested in being perceived as a winner, no matter the cost. This moment illustrates that attitude of his rather well.

  • @Gregory98
    @Gregory987 жыл бұрын

    Nowak is right. Politicians subject the citizens to a therapy and impose on them the way they should live. The citizens said a big "No" and ousted those politicians with a ballot.

  • @bartasniewazne5552
    @bartasniewazne55522 жыл бұрын

    I co Radek Zdradek?! ZatkaŁO kakaŁO. Dawno nie widziałem żeby ktoś tak spokojnie uzbrojony w wiedzę i argumenty rozjechał Radka Zdradka.

  • @arekgalat8334
    @arekgalat83343 жыл бұрын

    It is really pitty to see the forner minister of foreign affairs make a political campaign speech in the debate like that. Mr Sikorski did not lose his arrogance even as an ex minister. The truth of the matter is that so called new tactics in approach to russia revealed to be a misshot. Poland was a big absent of any negotiations related to ukraine. Needless to say that poland had a great an honorable seat in the normand format ..... of a reporter. Mr sikorski mentioned fantastic collaboration within weimar triangle. Well this is probably the best what he could say. Weimar triangle went into phase of cerebral death in this period. In 2012 the comitee of this triangle was dissolved. The main problem with sikorski is not even his ignorance but the fact that he is a political partisan and player. Mr nowak clearly pointed out the weak points and flaws in his opponent approach. Ps waszczykowski was probablly a foreign minister as bad as sikorski was.

  • @wojciechbalcerzak8004
    @wojciechbalcerzak80047 жыл бұрын

    Behind Sikorsky's elegance, smoothness and fluency there are real acts of political hatred towards his political opponents and in particular to president Lech Kaczynski. Had the visits of the Prime Minister and the President not been separated in April 2010, the Smolensk catastrophe would not have happened.

  • @lesniewskis

    @lesniewskis

    7 жыл бұрын

    So instead of two visits, there should have been only one? Are you saying that the PM and the President should have been on the same plane?

  • @wojciechbalcerzak8004

    @wojciechbalcerzak8004

    7 жыл бұрын

    It was Lech Kaczynski who was to organize the official Polish delegation to commemorate the 70th anniversary of Katyn massacre. Not until the very last moment did the government confirm the booking of the plane for the presidential delegation when the Prime Minister suddenly had an idea to make a separate visit. The media was informed that the official visit is Prime Minister’s visit but Lech Kaczynski’s visit was private. Over 500 memeber delegation to Katyn was classified as private and its security standards were not enough.

  • @izabelajoannabarry9361

    @izabelajoannabarry9361

    7 жыл бұрын

    Not true.

  • @smoothcriminal7596

    @smoothcriminal7596

    7 жыл бұрын

    @Wojciech Balcerzak So what are you saying? Should Tusk and other cabinet members have been onboard, when the President decided that no matter what, we have to land in Smolensk? :/

  • @SZabow

    @SZabow

    7 жыл бұрын

    Our President never decided to land in Smolensk. Are you a Russian agent or sth?

  • @Gregory98
    @Gregory987 жыл бұрын

    Sikorski: "Poland might make sacrifices". He already said to the Ukrainians: "you sign the contract with Janukowicz and Russia or you are all dead".

  • @oszolom

    @oszolom

    7 жыл бұрын

    At that time it might have been the only good option for Ukrainian opposition.

  • @jibbyjabs

    @jibbyjabs

    2 жыл бұрын

    He was right at the time.

  • @hannahumerczyk4749

    @hannahumerczyk4749

    Жыл бұрын

    @@jibbyjabs Jesteś glupi jak Sikorski

  • @moojcik
    @moojcik7 жыл бұрын

    Sikorski ma tiki nerwowe i mimikę Mussoliniego. Nie przydaje mu to wiarygodności.

  • @lubanskigornik282

    @lubanskigornik282

    7 жыл бұрын

    niebezpieczna debata - all can came out suddenly

  • @franksmith6297

    @franksmith6297

    7 жыл бұрын

    To nie tiki nerwowe tylko reakcja na utrate koryta

  • @smoothcriminal7596

    @smoothcriminal7596

    7 жыл бұрын

    Skup się na tym, co kto ma rozsądnego do powiedzenia, a nie na sprawach bez znaczenia. Nie oceniaj wartości czyichś argumentów po tikach i mimice. Ktoś, kto nie ma tików może ze spokojem wmawiać innym, że 2+2=6, a osoba, która to widzi, może ze złości dostać tików. Więc tiki nie mają nic wspólnego z mądrością, wartością i wiarygodnością dyskutanta.

  • @olafonm

    @olafonm

    7 жыл бұрын

    Sikorski zarabia obecnie wielokrotnie więcej niż jako szef MSZ synku więc trafiłeś kulą w płot.

  • @heroooo848

    @heroooo848

    7 жыл бұрын

    Dziwię się Sikorskiemu że zdecydował się debatować z prof. Nowakiem. Przynajmniej po raz kolejny wyszło, jak małym człowiekiem jest zdRadek. Zarzucać swojemu adwersarzowi, że żle przekłada na angielski polskie sprawy i że dlatego UJ i inne największe uczelnie nie dorównują tym z pierwszej światowej 10tki, to szczyt chamstwa.

  • @alicjaw3016
    @alicjaw30163 жыл бұрын

    I na kogo Sikorski się porwał?😱 jeszcze nie zaczęłam oglądania, ale w ciemno,znając wiedzę i erudycji prof Nowaka, wiem kto wypadnie słabiutko w konfrontacji z panem profesorem 👍

  • @47morlock

    @47morlock

    3 жыл бұрын

    Zdanie wyrobione zanim obejzales ? Obiekrywny I poinformowany jestes 🙄

  • @ambercasa9299

    @ambercasa9299

    2 жыл бұрын

    A moze,sie zastanowimy kto rzadzil Polska po smierci Narutowicza ( wyksztalconego w SZWAJCARII-,Polacy to taki fantastyczny narod ,ze wybieraja ( mam swoje prywatne okreslenie " wyksztalcona Holota),Absolutnie prof. Nowak i jego "poszerzony horyzont myslenia",moze blyszczec w jego bezposrednim otoczeniu -zob. wyzej wyksz.holota-absolutnie Yes,niestety Polacy nie potrafia nawet dostrzec ,a co dopiero wykorzystac talent jak chociazby RADOSLAW SIKORSKI-to tak na poczatek

  • @JolantaGaj12
    @JolantaGaj122 жыл бұрын

    Niebywale,jak mozna sie mierzyc z p.Prof.Nowakiem panie Sikorski..

  • @zawaprz

    @zawaprz

    Жыл бұрын

    Jakby Sikorski Radek zdradek miał choć odrobinę honoru .. ale przecież go nigdy nie miał...

  • @michalakaga1

    @michalakaga1

    Жыл бұрын

    Dokladnie! Zaba podstawia nogę gdy konia kują!

  • @januszjanuszowski3344

    @januszjanuszowski3344

    Жыл бұрын

    Zdradek forsuje politykę mocarstw zamiast własną (notabene jej nie ma)UWAŻAJĄC ŻE POLSKA MA BYĆ SILNĄ SIŁĄ MOCARSTW.Tu od razu zrzeka się własnego zdania nas wszystkich i de facto robi z Polski niewolników.Żenujący agent wpływu Taki koń trojański trujący polskie interesy wraz z tuskoidami.

  • @olo7341
    @olo73417 жыл бұрын

    Andrzej Nowak has utterly demolished so called policy of foreign affairs pursued by Tusk and Sikorski.

  • @AM10001000
    @AM100010007 жыл бұрын

    Jedna rzecz jest uderzająca, w Polsce taka debata nie mogłaby się odbyć.

  • @sebastians1918
    @sebastians19182 жыл бұрын

    Wystarczy zobaczyć twarz pana Sikorskiego po wystąpieniu pana profesora.

  • @TomAsz-zx4ff
    @TomAsz-zx4ff7 жыл бұрын

    Nervous Sikorski has no credibility. Zero. Prof. Nowak devastating him just talking kindly about facts.

  • @lesniewskis

    @lesniewskis

    7 жыл бұрын

    Facts? Prof. Nowak said that PM Tusk's first foreign visit was to Moscow. In fact his first visit was to Lithuania (November 2007). Then Belgium, Italy, Czech Republic, Germany, France, Portugal, Belgium again, Czech Republic again, Slovakia, and then Russia (February 2008). The visit to Russia was his 10th foreign visit, not the first. All the way through this debate Prof. Nowak blatantly serves us plain lies, intertwined with half-truths and insinuations.

  • @mikiabis4735

    @mikiabis4735

    7 жыл бұрын

    tusk is a traitor Polish

  • @pninpnin1

    @pninpnin1

    7 жыл бұрын

    Tusk may be a traitor but that doesn't change the fact that you're a boorish dimwit who can't even write a simple sentence in English correctly.

  • @mikiabis4735

    @mikiabis4735

    7 жыл бұрын

    I know Polish correctly. it's your childish arguments

  • @pninpnin1

    @pninpnin1

    7 жыл бұрын

    I wasn't writing about your knowledge of Polish, silly billy.

  • @TomAsz-zx4ff
    @TomAsz-zx4ff7 жыл бұрын

    Sikorski is completely aware of critical things he has on his conscience. Easily visible to the naked eye.

  • @olafonm

    @olafonm

    7 жыл бұрын

    Co ma na sumieniu Sikorski? Zamiast insynuacji kawa na ławę!

  • @oszolom

    @oszolom

    7 жыл бұрын

    Still waiting for those 'critical things'...

  • @agnieszkatobiasz8772

    @agnieszkatobiasz8772

    7 жыл бұрын

    oszolom Sikorski - Kulczyk recorded conversation which was the reason he was dissmissed by PO's PM

  • @zaujrudy7484
    @zaujrudy74847 жыл бұрын

    Sikorski nie jest suwerenny - reprezentuje w 50% Ann Applebaum.

  • @CrazyLeiFeng

    @CrazyLeiFeng

    6 жыл бұрын

    on reprezentuje Niemcow i pare innych rzadow.

  • @czeslawborkowski995
    @czeslawborkowski9952 жыл бұрын

    Radosław Sikorski powinien dostać głowną rolę w filmie "Zmiennicy" . Te "elity" po transformacji, to sfora zmienników czychających na posadę w kolejnych ugrupowaniach.

  • @Stan732
    @Stan7327 жыл бұрын

    Andrzej Nowak just nailed it down about flirting with the evil. The Method of dealing with Russia is... let it go bankrupt by over spending for this "constant carnival of proudness" and then deal with Russia like in 1985. But next time make sure it really changes.

  • @arthurheidt6373

    @arthurheidt6373

    5 жыл бұрын

    russia cant go bankrupt its not in debt, by nonrussians, unlike poles that have debt on foreigners

  • @sylwiadrozd9899
    @sylwiadrozd98996 ай бұрын

    Ex foreign minister discrediting PL universities, president's role and prerogatives and Poland's voice in EU. What does he do in our politics still is more than alarming!

  • @vd495
    @vd4956 жыл бұрын

    Radek Sikorski: me, I, myself... Such high flying ego. And there is no substance behind it. Real R. Sikorski shows himself through "tapes of truth" from Sowa & Friends. Very eye opening experience. And still he has audacity to be seen publicly is beyond comprehension. No honour whatsoever. That what one would call "murzynstwo"

  • @cimg9673

    @cimg9673

    Жыл бұрын

    yeah, egomaniac

  • @thomasmazur5787
    @thomasmazur57872 жыл бұрын

    Sikorski: "Weimar triangle to save the Ukrainians". 2022 :)

  • @piotrgalon9927
    @piotrgalon9927 Жыл бұрын

    Thank you!

  • @wolfwind1
    @wolfwind15 жыл бұрын

    Debate starts at 11:38.

  • @kmatuszynski
    @kmatuszynski7 жыл бұрын

    Despite the evident antagonism, they actually tried to throw a bridge across the other side. Twice or thrice they admitted they do agree or that they have the same goals. I really appreciate it. While at the same time the debate in Poland is nothing close to this format. They talk throught media, in which best interest is keeping the atmosphere hot as hell. I wish we could have more of those debates.

  • @zkrwiikosci

    @zkrwiikosci

    3 жыл бұрын

    Good afternoon, you've got the point, Sir. When was the last time Mr. Donald Tusk or one of other leaders of respective parties met with, say, Mr. Kaczyński in private, to talk and have a cup of coffee together? They should do it on a regular basis. This is the difference between the way Polish politicians act and UK's people in charge received practice of behaviour. It would seem the overwhelming inability to restrain their emotions and serve in best interest for the middle European country and its people bears tart fruit. I share your wish. A debate with Mr. Tusk and Mr. Jacek Bartosiak could be a proposal of an interesting meeting.

  • @randomperson1870

    @randomperson1870

    2 жыл бұрын

    The civic platform and the left don't behave at home. So far from home they have to keep facades up.

  • @zawaprz

    @zawaprz

    Жыл бұрын

    @@zkrwiikosci spadaj na Onet ruską onuco! You don't have a cup of coffee with Putin's and Berlin's traitors...

  • @olo7341
    @olo73417 жыл бұрын

    Sikorki is unhinged.

  • @47morlock

    @47morlock

    3 жыл бұрын

    How come ? Explain ?

  • @mattbrody1424

    @mattbrody1424

    2 жыл бұрын

    for a good reason cause I think he might finally get it how ridiculous his foreign policy towards Putins' Russia was

  • @marcinbach4237
    @marcinbach42372 жыл бұрын

    TODAY Sikorski is recognize like a scam in Poland. He was wrong. Prof. Nowak was and is fantastic with All predictions. Hope True will come out. Best From Poland :)

  • @Abc-th1lr

    @Abc-th1lr

    Жыл бұрын

    Today Sikorski is recognize like a scam in Poland, by Poles who only watch Polish National TV, witch is on this same level of propaganda as it was during communism times... So it's like 30% of Poles who voted last time, so it's less that 1/3 of Poles in Poland... That's mean it is just supporters of one of polish parties, not a nation. Plus he have being elected as a MEP, so... But I am sure, germans voted for him, not "truly poles" ; )

  • @adamkostrzewski6350
    @adamkostrzewski63507 жыл бұрын

    Sikorski went crazy after Nowak's response. Sorry, shouting 'conspiracy theory' doesn't convince anybody anymore. Especially since Nowak didn't mention anything about causes of the crash.

  • @adamkostrzewski6350

    @adamkostrzewski6350

    7 жыл бұрын

    And 'making peace with Europe' seems to be working alright recently... I'm not a PiS fan, but Sikorski was a terrible minister...

  • @oszolom

    @oszolom

    7 жыл бұрын

    He didn't but Mr. Kaczynski played this card successfully since 2010. This is rather prof. Nowak not responding to Sikorsky's references about PiS using conspiracy theory and hate speech in the last campaign and before. The same prof. Nowak was speaking about 'national consensus' Ridiculous :)

  • @agnieszkatobiasz8772

    @agnieszkatobiasz8772

    7 жыл бұрын

    oszolom Hi again, what exactely you can quote as "hate speach" in this particular case you refer to?

  • @jaroslawpeter3586
    @jaroslawpeter35862 жыл бұрын

    Nikodem Dyzma in Cambridge! Guess which is Dyzma. LOL

  • @MaciazSzu
    @MaciazSzu2 жыл бұрын

    In polish we say Prof. Nowak plowed him ;)

  • @agnieszkatobiasz8772
    @agnieszkatobiasz87727 жыл бұрын

    Professor Andrzej Nowak AGAIN showed the strength of calm and factual approach while Mr. Sikorski still not aquired any sophistication. He is known in Poland for his butcherly style

  • @oszolom

    @oszolom

    7 жыл бұрын

    Apparently we watched different debates...

  • @agnieszkatobiasz8772

    @agnieszkatobiasz8772

    7 жыл бұрын

    oszolom Really :-) ? Don't you notice the aggressive manner in Sikorski's style of communication?

  • @oszolom

    @oszolom

    7 жыл бұрын

    I see, but pay more attention to arguments. I believe Mr Sikorski's indignation may be to some extent attributed to accusation of 'treason' (seen even in the comments here) and other propagandist, populist slogans used in the last campaign, eg. "Poland in ruin".

  • @mwdesignmeblezmetaliimetal4507
    @mwdesignmeblezmetaliimetal45077 жыл бұрын

    Radek telepał się jak owad. :)

  • @gracekowal3171
    @gracekowal3171 Жыл бұрын

    Sikorski radosław do dymisji. $800,000. dostał od Rosji za wpis oskarżając stany zjednoczone ze wysadzili nortstream 1, 2, Ten wpis naraził polske na atak rosji na polske.

  • @madana1
    @madana17 жыл бұрын

    Ró,znica w poziomie duża- cóż za upadek p.Sikorskiego.

  • @oszolom

    @oszolom

    7 жыл бұрын

    Mam wprost przeciwne odczucia - wydaje mi się że w każdym wystąpieniu górował na argumentacją prof. Nowaka.

  • @peyotl66
    @peyotl667 жыл бұрын

    Sikorski -empty phrases ,Nowak -hard facts

  • @oszolom

    @oszolom

    7 жыл бұрын

    Rather the other way round, imho

  • @peyotl66

    @peyotl66

    7 жыл бұрын

    oszolom Maybe .It depends of point of view: Sikorski presents Tusk's goverment point of view,Nowak presents polish point of view.

  • @agnieszkatobiasz8772

    @agnieszkatobiasz8772

    7 жыл бұрын

    oszolom Dear, I see you really like Mr Sikorski :-). It in not forbiden :-) What do you think about his opinion on Warsaw Uprising?

  • @oszolom

    @oszolom

    7 жыл бұрын

    I don't know Mr. Sikorski personally, so it's not a question of liking or disliking him. What opinion are you referring to?

  • @slabart12

    @slabart12

    6 жыл бұрын

    Nowak- wishful thinkung, Sikorski- realism

  • @jakubpomorski4485
    @jakubpomorski44857 жыл бұрын

    Karierowicz zawodowy kontra patriota. Jak można mieć wątpliwości w starciu profesora z politykiem, składającym hołd innemu państwu (Berlin)...?

  • @oszolom

    @oszolom

    7 жыл бұрын

    Kiedy sie to wydarzylo?

  • @agnieszkatobiasz8772

    @agnieszkatobiasz8772

    7 жыл бұрын

    oszolom +/- listopad 2011

  • @oszolom

    @oszolom

    7 жыл бұрын

    A brzmienie tego holdu to...?

  • @mkciusiek
    @mkciusiek2 жыл бұрын

    zdRadek bardzo zdenerwowany, ciekawe dlaczego?

  • @LethalDozePL
    @LethalDozePL7 жыл бұрын

    Prof Andrzej Nowak o Sikorskim - "To cham i prostak który poniewiera słabszymi i liże buty silniejszym." Prof Andrzej Nowak on Sikorski - "He's a boor and lout who kicks around the weak and licks the boots of the strong."

  • @user-mq9oo6ze2i
    @user-mq9oo6ze2i6 жыл бұрын

    When poland produces food products of its own, they are of very good quality. Especially in the bio non gluten world and there own view of cafe and coffee shops are original inventive and fresh. Generally workers on the ground working in service type worlds, are more content working for there home grown countries. How this is in commerce I can not comment on. The new generation of workers need more motivation and profit incentives based on the sincerity their work.

  • @lagwan
    @lagwan7 жыл бұрын

    I would rather make debate with Sikorski's wife Anne. This would be more interesting. Sikorski is compromised by his political involvement in PiS and later PO.

  • @MuadPL

    @MuadPL

    3 жыл бұрын

    But she has no interest in any kind of sovereign Poland's foreign policy...

  • @MistahKurtzASMR
    @MistahKurtzASMR7 жыл бұрын

    We remember "Succumb or you will all DIE" and we, me, my family, my neighbors prefer straight and united response to aggression like pres Lech Kaczyński. We are not rusophobic, but we will not be Chamberlains and Daladiers of xxi century either.

  • @franksmith6297
    @franksmith62977 жыл бұрын

    23:10 "Dorżnąć watahe"

  • @bozenamatela2833
    @bozenamatela28333 жыл бұрын

    Gładka gadka Pana Radka vs. konkrety prof.Nowaka

  • @emanuelczyzo2681
    @emanuelczyzo26817 жыл бұрын

    Niestety, nie ma u mnie dźwięku?!

  • @mattjaworski3586
    @mattjaworski35862 жыл бұрын

    so, 5 years on an we have the answer who was right. Unfortunately many Ukrainians scarified their lives for that check.

  • @adamodimattia
    @adamodimattia2 жыл бұрын

    Wow, Sikorski might have scored a little better in this had he admitted at least some errors in judgement that he had made during his presidency. Simply accusing 5he opponent of misquoting while he had all the papers in place to read from was below weak. Also Sikorki's argument that he had graduated from a better university than the professor had and therefore he Sikorski must be in the right was well, self-evident of him lacking the true arguments in this duel.

  • @jibbyjabs

    @jibbyjabs

    2 жыл бұрын

    He wasn't president ever

  • @adamodimattia

    @adamodimattia

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@jibbyjabs I meant during his service as a minister

  • @seniorwilson7307
    @seniorwilson73077 жыл бұрын

    Wstyd mi, że taki człowiek jak Sikorski był w Polsce ministrem. Potrafi tylko obrażać. Profesor Nowak dobrze wytknął mu fakty a ten mu bluzga w odpowiedzi. Żenada.

  • @marekfru
    @marekfru7 жыл бұрын

    Obnażenie LESZCZA .Dzubasek ala POlsirwer

  • @Gregory98
    @Gregory982 жыл бұрын

    Sikorski comitted treason

  • @dzikiwaz8987
    @dzikiwaz89877 жыл бұрын

    Angielski Sikorskiego jest bardzo zły, wymawia angielskie słowa polskimi zgloskami.

  • @stanislawkazimir6465

    @stanislawkazimir6465

    Жыл бұрын

    no to dobrze.

  • @dzikiwaz8987

    @dzikiwaz8987

    Жыл бұрын

    @@stanislawkazimir6465 jego potencja umysłowa jest na poziomie typa z konstruktorki.

  • @annaorczyk313
    @annaorczyk3137 жыл бұрын

    no tusk is not Polish,he just speak Polish. ..!!

  • @izabelajoannabarry9361

    @izabelajoannabarry9361

    7 жыл бұрын

    Ależ pani niemądra.

  • @izarost

    @izarost

    7 жыл бұрын

    Proszę posłuchać Pana prof. Chodakiewicza i nie pleść bzdur w stylu orczyka.

  • @Gregory98
    @Gregory987 жыл бұрын

    Tusk is a Kaszub. He once said that that Kaszuby should be independent and have its own currency and that being polish is not normal.

  • @mareklakomski2256

    @mareklakomski2256

    Жыл бұрын

    tusk jest niemiecka kurwa na zawolanie ,ruska onuca .

  • @briannxx
    @briannxx6 жыл бұрын

    Trump 2020 because up yours world

  • @januszjanuszowski3344
    @januszjanuszowski3344 Жыл бұрын

    Radek - Very bad and wrong person in polish policy and nice betrayer of polish interes for Superpowers playng such naive rather calculating person.

  • @POLAK149
    @POLAK1499 ай бұрын

    TYYYY SZUB...OOOOO😂😂😂😂 ROSYJSKI 😂😂😂

  • @gregardon
    @gregardon Жыл бұрын

    sikorski is a warmonger.......

  • @LethalDozePL
    @LethalDozePL7 жыл бұрын

    Sikorski dobrze punktuje zagrożenia dla Polski i słabości polityki PiS, ale sam był fatalny jak cały jego rząd. Prof Nowak którego osobiście bardzo cenię i czytam jego książki (Dzieje Polski) starał się jak mógł aby obronić słabiutką politykę tego klauna Waszczykowskiego i chyba dobrze o tym wie ale jakoś dał radę.

  • @jangwozdz834
    @jangwozdz8342 жыл бұрын

    The Oxford vestibule can be compared with the Jagiellonian University?!, wow, only a clown can ...

  • @andrewfabia4638
    @andrewfabia4638 Жыл бұрын

    Bigest problem isPIS criticizm of the west,and PIS do not understend E Union role,despote of staborn germańskim.

  • @Zbyszkoz
    @Zbyszkoz7 жыл бұрын

    Trump: Only 'stupid' people, fools oppose better Russia ties . about missile shield , what about INT treaty ?

  • @zkrwiikosci
    @zkrwiikosci Жыл бұрын

    This film is a crystal clear display as of why it was Mr. Sikorski, not Mr. Nowak who worked for seven years as Polish Foreign Minister. I have to admit I hadn't known Mr. Andrzej Nowak is characterised with such narrow horison, apparently being completely rid of psychological factor in politics. His way of thinking is too strongly affected by fear of being 'used' by Russians and this effectively prevents him from seeing long-term consequences of actions, let alone giving the optimum advice. As a matter of fact, even assuming that Russia is so aggressive and imperial, Mr. Sikorski's way of getting around in diplomacy is by far more effective, safer and better not only for Poland but also for Russia, than the current policy now embodied by the Polish state and represented here by Mr. Nowak. Update 2023: Today, Jarosław Kaczyński, with his 50K payment to Ukraine's armed forces, apologized to Radosław Sikorski for calling him a 'diplomatic traitor' and this speaks for itself.

  • @j.l.473
    @j.l.4736 жыл бұрын

    Excellent Radoslaw Sikorski. Conspiracy theory is not the way to implement Poland's foreign policy.

  • @jarekj9901
    @jarekj99016 жыл бұрын

    Nowak ględził a Sikorski mówił sensownie chociaż nerwowo czym wywołał złe wrażenie

  • @olafonm
    @olafonm7 жыл бұрын

    Sikorski zaorał Nowaka :)

  • @CrazyLeiFeng

    @CrazyLeiFeng

    6 жыл бұрын

    Nie, nie zaoral.

  • @pythagorasnine

    @pythagorasnine

    5 жыл бұрын

    Have you understood that debate or is this just an expression of wishful thinking?

  • @danilodjurdjevic7436

    @danilodjurdjevic7436

    2 жыл бұрын

    .

  • @olafonm

    @olafonm

    2 жыл бұрын

    @@pythagorasnine Yes, I understood

  • @IRYSowaty
    @IRYSowaty6 жыл бұрын

    Nie mogę z tych komentarzy xD. Sikorski, jeden z najlepszych polityków i najlepszy MSZ Polski po 89' rozjeżdża merytorycznością Prof. Nowaka, a pisowcy fanatycy i tak twierdzą, że to "upadek Sikorskiego" xD.

  • @MaHa-jf4qc

    @MaHa-jf4qc

    6 жыл бұрын

    najlepszy polityk no bo jebneeeee normalnie zaraz, to ten sam co prosił niemców aby przejeli władzę w Polsce? koleś jebnij się o ścianę to może zmądrzejesz ale nie gwarantuję.

  • @pythagorasnine

    @pythagorasnine

    5 жыл бұрын

    @@MaHa-jf4qc Trzeba pzyznac ze twoja odpowiedz to jedyna mozliwa rozsadna na te zalosne bzdury od Atlasa.

  • @beatakozicka5468

    @beatakozicka5468

    3 жыл бұрын

    Jeden z waszych najlepszych, tu zgoda. Mając to na uwadze nigdy nie stawajcie do debaty z gigantami intelektu i wtedy jakoś od biedy możecie wbijaç te wybitne głupoty w sformatowane mózgi poborejszowskie.

  • @arthurheidt6373
    @arthurheidt63735 жыл бұрын

    poland is just a big fat nationalist central bank scam. its an epedemic in whole of europe.

  • @cartmann227
    @cartmann2275 жыл бұрын

    Mr Sikorski is right and has clear vision for a good future of Poland

  • @kornellenrok3248

    @kornellenrok3248

    Жыл бұрын

    No his is not. He was wrong from beginning. Now after full invasion is cristal clear.

Келесі