ये concept आपके अकेले की नहीं है, भारतीय मुसलमानों में ये फ़ितरत आम तौर पर पाई जाती है,. दरअसल ये इस्लामीक तालीम (मदरसा) के कारण होता है.

Had India wanted, she could have gobbled up Bangladesh after defeating Pakistan. But strangely you guys never accept this remarkable character of India of helping it's neighbours. And strangely you guys never mention China's annexation of Tibet for reasons best known to you.

Comparing warmongers with India is unfair

@sumondas9949

15 күн бұрын

Some bustards are so involved in defaming India. Government must stop giving visas to these so called intellectuals

@gopalramanathan7062

7 күн бұрын

But that’s what Khans indulge in.

Respected sir, India's per capita gdp is more than Bangladesh's per capita gdp. It is only during the 2 covid years that Bangladesh's per capita GDP overtook India's. Pls refer to latest datas.

@ramachandrankannan274

15 күн бұрын

Never the less, it is much higher than Pakistan and it did not merge with India after 1971. These are two important points in Dr Khan's observation

@Ab-cj8bs

15 күн бұрын

​@@ramachandrankannan274he was comparing with india

Akhand Bharat is a cultural concept and there is no military intent except POK, which has been illegally occupied by Pakistan

@manojchowdhary4208

15 күн бұрын

He needs to create something to criticize India, as he is American not Indian.

@nagarajgosukonda3381

15 күн бұрын

@@manojchowdhary4208 He spits venom on america too.....he is an islamist which is above nationlism for them.

@criticaldimension1615

12 күн бұрын

Well said... most people miss that part

That's factually incorrect statement fhat India's sovereignty was never on POK. With accession of J& K by Maharaja Hari Singh to india it icame under the sovereignty of india. Pakistan was the aggressor. So POK is in illegal occupation of Pakistan. Even then india never wanted it by force. We always wanted a negotiated settlement. And it will become part of india.one day.

India don't asking for pok because of historical reference, Pok claim is based on the 1947 -48 war when pakistan occupied part of Kashmir illegally

Sir, POK including GB were parts of J&K on 15.8.1947. So legally this area is part of India. Our perspective on such issues can't be overriding to Material facts.

Pok is conceptually different from Taiwan and Ukraine, moreover India will not merge her without public consensus in pok in favour of it.

@vipulsitut2462

15 күн бұрын

He has got fixed notion about POJK,no one can shake his delusion

Dr Khan you are comparing apples and oranges. Indian desire to take back POK(& COK) is neither irredentism nor a partisan goal, as: 1. Princely state of J&K acceded to India(like other 543 princely states), thus whole of it legally belongs to India, whether POK or COK. 2. Moreover ending this illegal occupation is an unanimous 1994 Indian parliamentary resolution. Hope you revisit your position.

@vipulsitut2462

15 күн бұрын

Don't waste your time in educating him,no use

@AmalTan

15 күн бұрын

@@vipulsitut2462 Really sad😔 that he does not understand Indian position on Kashmir, even after being of Indian origin. Quite ignorant of him to compare it with Ukraine or Taiwan.

@saurabhdharmadhikari4874

15 күн бұрын

​@@AmalTan yup I agree Kashmir is iridentism by Pakistan not India.

@AmalTan

15 күн бұрын

@@saurabhdharmadhikari4874 Exactly! It is irredentism, but by Pakistan. Dr Khan just turned the reality on its head.

@saurabhdharmadhikari4874

15 күн бұрын

@@AmalTan I've actually started to feel he twists, omits and sometimes subtly suggests things that are actually not right. I always had a good opinion about him but it has started to change. Even though Kashmir is legally Indian territory but how he spun the narrative very intelligently. I've disliked this one a lot. If he had said this about India claiming Afghanistan or any other country I would have accepted. But India hasn't done that ever, it doesn't even claim Nepal. This khanversation was bűllshït.

In INDIA as of now *nobody isn't interested nor discuss or talk about AKHAND BHARAT* or do they have any kind of agenda. INDIA'S need of POK & GB belongs to INDIA That's our agenda, dream & wish.❤🇮🇳

Ur speaking same Pakistani language they say kashmir should become independent country.. Through Instrument of accession Jammu Kashmir became an Integral part of India.. we r not afraid of your Pakistani masters 😅

@gopalramanathan7062

7 күн бұрын

All Khans are in a Papisthani state of mind.

Prime Minister:- Who will take Responsibility for the Results on june 4 ?? Some People have Already booked their Foreign Trips 🔥🔥🔥

Sir according to latest IMF data, India has surpassed Bangladesh in gdp per capita with $2731 to $2640 of Bangladesh. Moreover sir I believe Bangladesh got independent because india let it remain independent, India I guess won't allow POK, we have suppressed the so-called independent kashmir claims here in India. If India captures I see the same happening in POK as well.

@AmalTan

15 күн бұрын

True. Indian gdp per capita > BNG according to recent IMF data.

Dear sir , it would be interesting to look into reasons why India did not offer now Bangladesh to merge with India after 1971.

The only difference between the fight Argentina has with Uk and the fight that India HAD with Portugal is that we reclaimed our land long back. But to now say that all borders are settled and anyone seeking a change to borders is an irredentist is hypocrisy. UK has no right to the Malvinas.

Indian land size increased when Sikkim joined India. India also gave up some land to settle the border with Bangladesh. So border changes were happening. BJP is not actually interested in POK as this will increase radical people size. India is already suffering from remnants of PFI, IM SIMI. Some report says that Muslim size in India is over 17%, If this crosses 40% then India will become like another Pakistan. The ideology of most Indian Muslim and Pakistan's are same.

US would love India and China engaging in limited warfare as it will strengthen US position. China would love India Pakistan skirmish so that it gets an excuse to create a two front war situation for India. China would like to make more noise especially in the South China sea and provoke Taiwan. However, despite many Westerners saying US will go to war if Taiwan is attacked, Indians tend to think US will try to arrive at a negotiated settlement and/or limit themselves to ammunation & war equipment supplies. It was different in the past when Taiwan was a dictatorship. Now that it is a democracy, American support will be much less. The American principle has ben to support dictators ( who then view US as a benefactor) rather than any issues involving democracy, human rights or teritorial integrity. The sole exception is Israel which is a democracy but has treated Palestininans in an inhuman manner.

"Changing world order" not "collapsing world order". You need to change you spectacles khan.

@gopalramanathan7062

7 күн бұрын

Khans normally don’t do.

It was interesting but you compare Kashmir with Ukrain, Taiwan etc . Did any of these states sign instrument of accession? Were they formally and legally joined like Kashmir did ? I think you went overboard to compare Kashmir with the situation in other countries…

In our puran it is said there will be 6 fronts upto April 2025 ,2 or say 3 fronts have opened 3 more will be चीन ताइवान, रूस जापान, भारत -चीन पाकिस्तान । we already know it

Has not America increased tariff on Chinese goods. And India gdp per capita is more than Bangladesh. And India economy is much diverse. Pok will not be able to survive alone as industry is required and even companies which they don’t have.

Sir if ukrain tries to regain its territory lost to russia , will u call it expantion

Contd: after becoming vistorious in 1949 civil war PRC started ruling over more than 90% parts of mainland China and the defeated forces fled to Taiwan. The PRC could not take over the tiny island due to its weak navy then and also because the USA backed Taiwan later. Thus every one can guess who is right and who is wrong in the case of sovereignty of China.

Abki bar 400 par!! POK and G&B will be part of Bharat

its more important to take over maldives than pok, if india goes on invasion this time it will be by sea not by land.

Sir, I find your comments quite reasonable, but in this case, I believe you are quite mistaken. Let us be clear about one thing. Pakistan has illegally occupied a portion of Jammu & Kashmir since 1948. It is India's right to take back control over PoK. I also notice that you have not spoken about the Hindu Kashmiri pandits being ejected from their homeland. Maybe you should reconsider comparing India with Russia and China.

Professor Saheb - you always criticize India with Vishwaguru jibe and tendency to shut down internet during civil unrest. Hope you will be also covering France’s shutdown of TikTok in New Caledonia and how this is a liberal thing to do.

@ProfMuqtedarKhan

15 күн бұрын

France is a F#$%^ up state.

Sir what is your thinking about similarities between American in afganistan and Israel in Gaza

@vipulsitut2462

15 күн бұрын

Nothing about Afganistan, obviously Israel is agressor would be his opinion

Ye think tank waale pataa nahi kis duniyaa mein rahate hain. Bhai ab access to information un sabke paas hai jo information ko search kar sakte hain. Pakistan ne to form hone ke pahle se hi expansionism shuru kar diya tha. Jaise hi form hua, non state mercenaries as well as army dressed as mercenaries entered J&K. This means the planning was done before even Pakistan was formed ! Stop peddling west communist islamic agendas ! Your time is over !

How come you don't want to talk about china occupying Manchuria, Tibet, mangolia and east Turkmenistan?

@gopalramanathan7062

7 күн бұрын

Though he’s a Khan he is still a scared one.

Khan, you are trying to spread fear and rumour citing concept of Akhand Bharat. None of the current

China wants to change the order as the current order makes sure that the commanding heights of finance and technology remains with the west and if China is to be allowed to compete fairly then the current order would not allow it to compete fairly.

The two nation theory was probably the only political truth spoken in the Indian subcontinent in the past century. There's no compatibility between muslims and Hindus. Your sympathies lied with Pakistan and you despise Bharat and the Hindu civilization. India should find some solution to this muslim problem or time and necessities would impose their own crimson remedies .

Mr.Khan you are drawing the parellel between Taiwan and Ukraine while talking about irredentism is not based on historical facts as you have yourself said that until ninteen sixtees both PRC and ROC were claiming to be the real China and USA including most of the Western nations were in favor of Taiwan and the UNSC membership was also offered to it. When USA and the western world needed China's help to counter the mighty USSR they shifted their support to China making the UNSC member

NATO's timeline: 2000 Nepals and Bhutans of Russia, China, India, Iran and the Middle-East.

Kashmir will never be a free country. Even if it will be, it will be like Syria between India, Pakistan and China. It is best for It to join either India, Pakistan or China. Best for them would be to join India to enjoy democracy and more freedom than the other two.

In my opinion the nation state paradigm will change with change in global power with that the most vulnerable status will be of people who are following peaceful religion.

Professor, you lost your mind. You call India Irredentist!

Constantinople was the center of the Eastern Roman Empire. Washington is the center of the Western British Empire. The 5i group is that.

How about Gazwa hind

it would be good if pok is independent rather than part of any country it will be a bridge between pak and india which is good

Mr Khan I get lot of knowledge th your video , even though I don’t agree to all of your views.

@ProfMuqtedarKhan

15 күн бұрын

Thanks

Kya bakwas hai.. What about those 800 usa bases And balochistan mai aag kaun laga hai .

Haye re

Sir Military Action Nahi Lega Bharat Yeh Sirf Jazbaati Baatein Hai Agar POK Mein East Pakistan Jaise Haalaat Ban Jaate Hain Tab Ho Sakata Ho Army Bheje POK

I don't think Indian public really wants POK...it's of no benefit for us to get that piece of land. All the chest thumping right now is political rhetoric.

@ProfMuqtedarKhan

15 күн бұрын

If people do not want it then why are they saying it during elections. Who is stupid, the politicians or the public?

@AmalTan

15 күн бұрын

Hope you know about the *unanimous* 1994 Indian parliamentary resolution on taking back POK and COK.

@shekharavhad7687

15 күн бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/ZJmlo8mEiqfcis4.html Islamic Political Commentator Tells White Christians To LEAVE Britain

You are doing propegenda, nobody in this world want to merge jihadis and their land in their territory. Akhant Bharat is cultural concept which can help resolve conflicts in the region and can develop this whole region.

@ProfMuqtedarKhan

15 күн бұрын

indianexpress.com/article/cities/kolkata/pok-india-pakistan-amit-shah-west-bengal-9331316/

@shekharavhad7687

15 күн бұрын

@@ProfMuqtedarKhan We gave Pak away and look what they have done to it....nincompoops ....good for nothing people

@VinodSinghatjnu

11 күн бұрын

@ProfMuqtedarKhan Dear Professor POK is part of India , not Pakistan there should not be any doubt. There should be fear that if they will occupy, Indias territory then Today or tomorrow India will take it back. Regarding people we can easily tell convince them that they and us share same ancessostors. How Islamic invaders converted them, with references from invaders' written texts, before full integration of the region. I wish Muslims all over the world could get a progressive leadership, that can take them to a path of progress instead of confronting and killing Kafirs. Otherwise western countries will always exploit their countries by keeping them emotional towards religion. Forget India, what problem majority of Muslims have in Europe? They are nurturing on kafirs tax and are more concerned about umma than kafirs. Believe me there is some fundamental problem with Islamic Ideology that needs to be reformed, instead of confronting the retaliatory acts of kafirs.

@ProfMuqtedarKhan

11 күн бұрын

@@VinodSinghatjnu many Indian states have passed laws to prevent Hindus from converting to Islam or Christianity and you think Kashmiris will easily be convinced? Has it worked on the Indian side?

@VinodSinghatjnu

7 күн бұрын

@@ProfMuqtedarKhan @ProfMuqtedarKhan Dear Prof there is no concept of conversion in Hinduism. We just want these people must know that they share ancestory to us and live peacefully. If understood correctly, these madarsas teach Only muslims are there brothers and others are Kafirs. U will see muslims are only happy in countries where kafirs are in govt and paying taxes for their life style.

Stop your snide ways of smearing india. You are a disgruntled ex citizen of india.

A relevant lecture, very interesting. Future cannot be predicted, I disagree on the Taiwan question. Taiwan and Chinese are the same nation, their difference is political. Sooner or later they will unite in peace. I don't understand why Pak will fragment, economic disasters happened in many countries like Zimbabwe and they are still intact. If Kashmir goes independent why should IOK still be in Indian union. My understanding is that they always wanted azadi. Indian irredentism will lead to more trouble. Fascinating lecture 🤔

@ProfMuqtedarKhan

11 күн бұрын

Thanks

Dr Khan very realistic analysis though as a Indian I would like POK to become part of India but still your analysis looks pretty correct in modern days but in future things can always change.

India is not expanding into POK. Pakistan has illegally occupied our territory. Mr Khan please first think like Indian first and then like a Muslim. India is secular because it is a Hindu majority country. Can you show me a secular Muslim majority country. Indian Muslim community should become secular first and put their country first if they expect the Hindu's to follow the secularism. You are living in a secular country and all muslims want to run to secular countries because they feel strangulated in their own country. Show some patriotism.

@gopalramanathan7062

7 күн бұрын

Don’t ask for the impossible, you can’t argue with a Khan.

99 percent population in Azad Kashmir is Muslim. They all either want to merge with Pakistan. Some of them want to have an Independent Kashmir comprising of IOK (Indian occupied Kashmir) and the Gilgit Baltistan. China has already worked on CPEC through Gilgit Balitstan and by 2028, the CPEC will be operational which is already operational by the way. The Gaward port is already active and the only things that remains is the building of motorways that will connect China with Gawadar. Any attempt to attack on Azad Kashmir will result in a pro longed war like Afghanistan which may result in disintegration of India into more pieces. India is already stuck in IOK with over 0.7 million army depoloyed. Even If India try to capture Kashmir , it will result in nothing for India. This Old Uncle does not know what is happening in Ukraine. The damage Russia has taken is beyond recovery. What happened in Afghanistan is in front of every body. It is very obvious that India will attack Pakistan in coming future possibly between 2026-2030. Let it happen and then see what this Uncle has to say then. By the way, this Uncle does not talk about a new country which is about to merge on Map of the world that is Khalistan. The referrendum is already taking place all over the world. Sooner, It will yield some results.

PoK becoming independent is a double edged sword for India

Hello sir it's knowledge to listen to u

@ProfMuqtedarKhan

15 күн бұрын

Thanks and welcome

Bharatvasis should be careful what they wish for. A Balkanized Pakistan would be a greater headache than a unified one despite its hostility.

@ramachandrankannan274

15 күн бұрын

This has long been the view in Indian security circles. In 1980s, many in India felt that the response to Pakistani supported terrorism in Punjab & Kashmir would be a strike across the border. Apart from the question of US coming to the aid of Pakistan, there was a question of what India would do if Pakistan balkanises and we are left dealing with several minor wars in that region. However, I think the current Administration has adopted the best possible course - ignore Pakistan and let it disintegrate or have internal strife instead of allowing the Army to consolidate by pointing at India s the imaginary opponent

@ratnakamal1

15 күн бұрын

@@ramachandrankannan274 I am with you.

Population of pok cannot sustain a free country nor gb. Pakistan is not going to balkanise as Chinese will not let it happen. Pakistan is bridge between china towards Afghanistan Iran and central asia. Wakhan corridor is very difficult high altitude mountains which can't be crossed atm. Chinese are trying to make a road from Tibet to GB as before its from Xinziang.

@ProfMuqtedarKhan

15 күн бұрын

Pok population is more than Bhutan and Maldives.

@satyamjha7790

13 күн бұрын

​​@@ProfMuqtedarKhanProfessor Saab, You talk about Russia- Ukraine, China-Taiwan, India -POk but you forget to mention that china claims ladakh, Arunachal Pradesh and Sikkim so, Do you think china will try to occupy these states especially Arunachal Pradesh in the future?

What about Gazwa =E =Hind😂😂You forget this Terminology Dr. Khan 😂😂😂😂😂

@ProfMuqtedarKhan

14 күн бұрын

Ghazwa-e-Hind already happened that is why there are only two Hindu majority and four Muslim majority nations in Akhand Bharat.