This performance elevated the song to a completely different level. Same with Bleeding Me.

@genemcavoy4254

10 ай бұрын

Yes! They both are amazing on S&M

@AndyTheRoo

10 ай бұрын

I'm the opposite. The symphony shrouds all the guitars and it sounds like a mess at times. You can barely hear James jamming at the end of the song which is a shame because it's the best part of the song

@genemcavoy4254

10 ай бұрын

@@AndyTheRoo That's fair. The guys are a bit overshadowed but the fullness of the orchestra, for me, makes it better.

@user-yk4gd1fl4z

10 ай бұрын

@@AndyTheRoo yep. shoe horning in Orchaestral melodies that have nothing to do with anything going, bar being in the same key, is NOT making a song better. Its laughable . He should have done the album version, ALL its impact is lost in this forgettable mediocre live performance.

@ericwilson5453

9 ай бұрын

2 of my favorites, and the orchestra brings it.

RIP Michael Kamen. This concert was his idea and is his legacy in the metal music. The Outlaw Torn is one of the hidden gems of Metallica (pure thrashers don't give a f about it, but their loss). From Load album, I like "Until it Sleeps", "King Nothing", "Bleeding Me", "Mama Said", "Hero of the Day" and "Ain't My b1tch", apart for The Outlaw Torn.

@sylvainvanduyl6143

10 ай бұрын

Oh yeah, Load and Reload are gems on their own! I always liked King Nothing.

@courtneyurman

10 ай бұрын

"Pure" thrashers don't know what they're missing. Metallica showed such a depth of musicianship in Load/Reload.

@cowsaysmoo51

9 ай бұрын

If you take the best songs from Load + Reload and condense them into one album, you're talking about one of the best rock albums of all time. There are so many good songs that people overlook on those albums.

@LuisRdzG10

9 ай бұрын

@@cowsaysmoo51 Mmmm....That got me thinking, wish songs would I choose for that condensed album... 15 songs: 1) Fuel, 2) Memory Remains, 3) Ain't My Bitch, 4) Until it Sleeps, 5) The Unforgiven II, 6) King Nothing, 7) Hero of the Day, 8) Bleeding Me, 9) Devil's Dance, 10) Mama Said, 11) Thorn Within, 12) Wasting my Hate, 13) Attitude, 14) Fixxxer, 15) Outlaw torn. Bonus Tracks 16) Better Than You, 17) The House Jack Built, 18) Low Man's Lyric. In a Limited Edition lol.

@cowsaysmoo51

9 ай бұрын

@@LuisRdzG10 I think that's a very solid selection. Fixxxer and Outlaw Torn are must-haves

S&M is probably one of the best live records ever. Does not get a bit old.

12:19 Jason rocking out with the orchestra's double bassist. Love it! Miss that dude in Metallica.

@koosa6289

8 ай бұрын

seriously, Metallica's not the same without him

@jatheshadow

3 ай бұрын

​@@koosa6289feel the same..

@mztweety1374

3 ай бұрын

Bless his heart, he kicked ass for almost 15 years😂 😂😂

@anastaciabluebeyondguide

16 күн бұрын

same...

@anastaciabluebeyondguide

16 күн бұрын

@@koosa6289 Yes...just not quite the same eh

James' lyrics are incredible.

@vikusen1857

10 ай бұрын

To bad they are trash on the latest albums.

@herrroy4963

10 ай бұрын

​​@@vikusen1857I was thinking more in general. I hope we will give him much more cred for his lyrics further on.

@vikusen1857

9 ай бұрын

@@ChuckUpchuck true, but you think lyrics is better after justice? Lyrics went from epic to trash.

As a depressed teenager with no ability to communicate my feelings this was one of my favorite songs to blast to drown out the world and also feel like my feelings could somehow come out. Even if the lyrics didn't exactly line up with my circumstances this felt like and exorcism of sorts of my inner demons. Thanks Metallica!

@iamradical

9 ай бұрын

Haha I’m 38 and I still feel that way when I listen to outlaw torn.

I'm so glad you're doing the first S&M. This version is miles better than the 2019 version.

@hawaii2k

10 ай бұрын

Jasoooooooooooooooooon! I love Rob till death and all that, but Jason is a monster on the bass here as well as the vocals.

@Dimchek970

9 ай бұрын

You like Hetfields meowing during the 90s?

@9xqspx6

8 ай бұрын

@@Dimchek970 I for one sure do!

One of kirks best solos. Just fits perfect.

@dibbler5

7 ай бұрын

Always felt it was like a scream into the void. Love it.

@TheMaxyms

3 ай бұрын

Damn right. Best emotional solo ever done by Kirk, this screaming note is just something else, it never forgets to hit me right in the feels

No leaf clover should be the next Metallica Monday reaction. Along with -Human, they were both written for the collection collaboration with the SF symphony orchestra

@thiagoaaaaaaaaa

10 ай бұрын

He already did No Leaf Clover :)

@tosijster

9 ай бұрын

it seemes to me it was S&M II version @@thiagoaaaaaaaaa

Outlaw Torn and Bleeding Me are by far the best tracks on the Load album

@pigskinpoetry

9 ай бұрын

Those are top 10 Metallica songs to me. Any album.

@doocies

9 ай бұрын

@@pigskinpoetry Agreed, uninhibited masterpieces

@upinair4990

2 ай бұрын

Lyrically and musically amazing for sure

The intro into “Call of Ktulu” into “Master of Puppets” at the beginning of this concert is sensational. Worth checking out.

@gregbrown3764

10 ай бұрын

Have to appreciate their 'usual' "Ecstasy of Gold" at the open of the concert too.

@shmick6079

10 ай бұрын

@@gregbrown3764 yeah that’s what I was referring to

James has experienced loss in his life and the fact that we still have Metallica is close to a miracle. It has been touch and go there a couple of times and the boys have all the money in the world. Financially they don't need to do this, but mentally they do... It is their burden and savior in one breath... Their beast and their outlet. There is so much poured into these songs that you can't help but feel it... Feel it.

@anastaciabluebeyondguide

16 күн бұрын

Well said...

All of the first S&M Concert is worthy of your insights. "The Call of Ktulu", "Bleeding Me" and "Until It Sleeps" would be right up your alley...as would "No Leaf Clover"

@deank179

10 ай бұрын

Check his other videos, he did No Leaf Clover about a year ago :)

I think its their best S+M performance. Also, best vocals. Thanks for making me appreciate it even more.

As someone who started with the cello at age 10 and then graduated to guitar and heavy metal, I have always loved this combo of symphony and Metallica. Underrated song, too.

@leerobbo92

9 ай бұрын

Have you seen the double-bass (I know, it's not quite a cello!) solo from S&M2? It's bloody brilliant, highly recommend if you haven't!

"For whom the bell tolls" and "Devils dance" with the orchestra are other Metallica songs that deserves a Doug reaction!!! 🤟🎹

This is the best version of the song and one of my top five Metallica songs. When Kirk hits the solo three seconds in or stop and the wha opens up, it sounds like a scream of anguish and longing. It’s one of my favorite Kirk moments. So powerful. Thanks for covering it.

5:32 "It's kinda 'bluesy'." Yes, yes it is. Both albums, Load and Reload, have got Kirk's touch literally throughout. They got a lot of hate for the albums when they first came out, and gasp, cut their hair. But both albums are musically excellent.

@chupasaurus

10 ай бұрын

I mean, the common denominator for every band member ever was a little English band called Black Sabbath.

yes. more metallica please. maybe from their new album where they also post live performances on their own youtube channel? i'm curious what you'd think of the new stuff

@alarmgoesding

10 ай бұрын

Inamorata would be a good one! Very long though.

@Doug.Helvering

10 ай бұрын

I plan to get to some of their new stuff. Thanks!

@geeemm135

10 ай бұрын

@@Doug.Helvering nice. already love you for that.

@carlosnascimento9269

10 ай бұрын

​@@Doug.HelveringI think you'd really enjoy Innamorata.

@alexandremaireno-ni4ec

10 ай бұрын

​​@@AlexP1235it's 1:20 longer actually

If you get a chance, check out the studio version called outlaw torn (unincumbered version) it was released on the memory remains uk single, with the additional 1:30 that they had to cut from the CD. It's amazing, and is one of my all time favorite Metallica songs!

This song is one of my favorites and this version is unbelievable. James's vocals are so on point.

I think your analysis of James’ lyrics is spot on but also very interesting. It was his inability to move on and heal from Cliff that ultimately forced Jason out. In my opinion, as talented as Cliff was, Jason WAS NOT just Metallica’s bassist but he was their heart and soul.

Jason jamming with the orchestra at the end will always be an iconic sight. He was the heart of the band at that time. James is the heart now though

@anastaciabluebeyondguide

16 күн бұрын

Well said

I don't know the first thing about music theory, harmonics, what key they are in, or half steps. But from my understanding, Mr. Kamen WROTE the music scores for EVERY instrument in the orchestra himself. When I listen to this concert, and how magical it sounds, I can't wrap my head around what Mr. Kamen did. Seems superhuman to me.

@MKDumas1981

10 ай бұрын

There's a story. He wrote the orchestrations while listening to the album versions of the songs. He then had to transpose some of them a half step down to match the guitar tuning. When rehearsing "The Call of Ktulu", one instrument, just one (I forget which one it was) was playing the old sheet music; he heard it, and called it out. Gifted beyond imagination.

love this siong so much, the lyrics of the chorus are so powerful

I love the bit at 12:19 with Jason rocking out with the double bassist. Great review, it's cool to see someone else excited about one my favourite albums! I think the volume was too low on this one though, I had my headphones at 100% and I was struggling to hear the basslines.

The first S&M has probably my favorite vocals from James ever. It has a perfect balance of the old school anger mixed with all the technique he learned in the early and mid 90s. Sounds incredible. Bleeding Me is another standout from this live.

@damianmoreyra9985

10 ай бұрын

¡Yeah! Bleeding me it's awesome version too

Load Is such underrated work. So intense, so full of emotions. They have been so hated for slowing down songs and leaving thrash behind but they were simply trying to do something new and they did in a Great way. Load Is a masterpiece.

This arrangement by Michael Kamen is as close to perfection as can be. While some songs on S&M (like Wherever I May Roam) only get a touch more interesting - Outlaw Torn and Bleeding Me were turned from mostly middling songs to masterpieces! This whole show is probably one of the best concerts ever recorded for a metal band.

This live performance is far and away my favorite live recording ever. As another commenter said, this performance took Outlaw to completely different level. I love the production and the orchestration, they both serve the original composition so well and bolster the emotional weight of this song.

Load is my favourite Metallica album. I've come to accept this now. Outlaw and Bleeding are unbelievable.

@MilanderLeavemealone

10 ай бұрын

Been that way for me since 96, welcome to the club.

@BFNope

10 ай бұрын

Bleeding Me is my all time favourite.

@jp7963

10 ай бұрын

I'm the same now. I always used to say MoP was was fave and its still probably the greatest metal album of all time. But now in my (cough) old age i find I like Load better than all their albums. It is brilliant from start to finish.

@HoracioGaray

9 ай бұрын

This album and specially this track hitted me in a whole different level during my teenage years. It's by far my favorite Metallica song.

Song is about cliff "Make me smash the the clock and feel, I'd rather die behind the wheel" After the bus accident, James smashed his alarm clock in the hotel room and threw it out the window and he wished he'd died in the bus crash instead of cliff

@tucoroto

2 ай бұрын

Concerning the quote that Doug read about the lyrics of the song (from Jaymz) at 14:35 , it makes sence. It can left open to losing anybody to death but your theory fits right in. James also referenced the death of his mom and dad in other songs on Load. Sh*t gets quite real on Load now that I think about it.

Michael Kamen is super incredible, beyond words....its so refreshing to hear you say what you have, you are cool my friend...its all music and this still gives me goosebumps every time...

James's lyrics are the CORE of their music in my opinion. So strong! The symphony was epic in this album, much better then the new s&m2

The chromatic climb and the double-time feel at the end of this song is a perfect example of brilliant simplicity. Coupled with the context that the rest of the song gives it, gradually building toward this perfect climax. Breathtaking, and all puns tastefully intended.

I love this song so much, it’s a prime example of why Metallica is such an amazing band (to me) and gives me goosebumps every single time: This build, this intensity, these incredible lyrics. Pure class.

@anastaciabluebeyondguide

16 күн бұрын

Same

This song relates to me so hard. I'm actually crying right now

I loved this whole performance ❤ Thank you for reacting to this wonderful piece 😊

You should definitely do the entire concert! That would be amazing!

I always felt “bleeding me” was a bit more special. Both are great.

To me (and there are many) but a lot of Metallica's success over other metal bands is having clean vocals... and beyond... James is amazing. Check out some stuff from this summer. They've never sounded better

in 1991, Kamen did the "elevator version" of Nothing Else Matters. Kamen suggested that the band should play a concert with the symphony. "Michael, Metallica called. They'll do that concert you were talking about" Michael "That was 10 years ago"

Considering Jason's later statements on why he left the band - about how the other members (James esp) never made him feel like he fit in, that they never quite let him belong as the "replacement" for Cliff - this is an especially interesting take on this song and its meaning.

Great rection and elaboration. Especially loved that you joined the band on a keyboard and was wanting to do more of that

The song is shortened, BUT they did release the full unedited version as a B Side to The Memory Remains on a CD single

I am really happy to see you listen and enjoy this song, I also suggested it to you probably last year. Load and Reload are two great albums that deserve to be checked out

Yes, Eb. That's their main live tuning.

I hope Bleeding Me from this gig has been mentioned. The best song, in my opinion, they played that night.

I was in high school when Load came out. I was disappointed the first week cause they cut their hair and all that "meant." I was a dumbass. Load is tied for my favorite Metallica album at this point. The more I hear it, the more the music hits. Emotionally, it's hard to beat.

This whole album has songs about personal issues. and James's family. Check "Until it Sleeps" and specially I would like to know opinions about the lyrics of "Bleeding Me". I always thought there is more to that song.

Best performance of the song ever...just perfect and wayyyyy better than S&M2... Miss Jason

So happy to see this one! I love this song so much, and I love this version specifically even more. RIP Michael Kamen! This is my favorite solo from James and there are so many beautiful moments in this song. My favorites are Jason Newstead headbanging with the bass players in the symphony during the last solo, and James modulating his volume manually on his guitar to get that haunting tone. Wonderful!

Jason.... What a beast here in this whole show

full thing would be a great listen. interesting to hear how the orchestra changes the feeling of each song.

Always loved the S&M tour.. its the one where my mum walked past my room as i was watching the DVD , poked her head in to say "oh, that sounds interesting??" Grooving with the band at the end is one of my favorite parts of this song 🎸🤘🎶

"Hero of the Day" and "Bleeding Me" are two other OUTSTANDING tracks from Load.

Never realised how great this version actually is! Great commentary, subscribed!

Recently found your channel Doug. Really digging it. Came to the comments to give my support and to throw a band in to the reaction mix… and so I present: Ween. This is an unpredictable band with an excellent but underrated guitarist that covers a lot of different genres of music (primary influences of pfunk, Prince, dickie betts), even on the same album. I would steer your first listen to their more accessible albums like White Pepper (clear nod to the Beatles) or maybe Quebec. Best of luck with the channel.

Awesome song. Simple but complex on many levels ❤ thanks Doug

Speaking of amazing lyrics by James, have we done Bleeding Me yet? Especially the live S&M version from back in the late 90’s

this is one of my favorite songs of all time, you react to a lot of great shit. a lot of my favorite deep tracks taht i've seen few people ever react to

It took me a long time to appreciate this particular tune. I think it took this particular version. It's now one of the songs I wish I'll get to hear live from Metallica.

Would love to see you react to this whole concert, a match made in heaven..

You need to react to the whole concert! You’ll love it

Bleeding Me is another great listen from Load and S&M

I loved 'Outlaw' and 'Bleeding' The orchestration made them both into perfect songs. Outlaw especially. 🫶

One of your best videos Doug!

This is my all time favorite song, this version for me is just beautiful. So dynamic and hits so many rhythms.

OMG. My favorite Metallica song. Shortly before they performed this in 2019 at the S&M2 concerts, they played it in Germany. It was so incredible, very emotional. James's solo at the end always sends an arrow straight through my heart. The video for the 2019 performance ends with James looking over to Kirk and Rob and they look right back at him, an incredible moment of connection between them all.

Jason’s fingers all I hear! ❤ such a performance

That outro is the best in the Universe! \m/

One of my all time favs. Thank you sir!

Beautiful song, great reaction

Doug you MUST MUST MUST DO THE STUDIO VERSION.!!! In my opinion, it is a top 3 most epic rock songs EEVVEERRRRR!

Bleeding me is one of the best metallica songs and you should give a listen !!!

I like that you analyse the songs technically but then also give words of wisdom relevant to the lyrics. Very therapeutic to many

So glad you’re watching the first one, because I believe the first S&M is the best

INCREDIBLE performance

Hey Doug, I thought of you when I came across a video of Pakistani musicians playing Brubeck’s “Take Five” on sitar and traditional instruments. It was the Sachal Studios Orchestra, check it out very cool!

I’m so glad that a reviewer of an S&M song finally acknowledged Michael Kamen. No way this album (nor S&M 2) are as well received if not for Kamen’s compositions. And this is only a fraction of the contribution that he made to rock and metal. Seriously, Google the guy. The list of bands and artists that he worked with is a who’s who of rock and roll.

Please do the full concert!

When S&M came out and I listened to it for the first time I though "hummm, the orchestra is slow, behind the band". Then I gave it a second turn, and a third, and... well, my favorite song ever in its best version is there (One). About this one in particular, the orchestra sets the ambient and the band just breaks through. I liked the original, but this is just on a level of its own. Too bad Michael Kamen didn't live to make the second one... and a third one at least, as there are songs that I would love to hear with an orchestra (ehem, Unforgiven trilogy anyone?).

The whole S&M concert is just amazing.... really love it :)

If you like this one. You have to listen to Inamorata on Metallicas latest album. Now their longest song ever recorded. Just Epic.

It just amazes me that you knew the tuning was e flat, love your vids. Just a guy that I likes jamming and it makes me want to learn more. I always use my ears, and I want to get back into reading too.

When I was about 14/15 I had a big TV on my bedroom wall, directly over my guitar amp. I bought the DVD of this S&M concert, and I learnt it all. I would just play along pretending to be in the band. This was always one of my favourites to play because that end is just so smooth. My parents got seriously bored of hearing two hours of Metallica like twice a week lol

I love that at the ending of this song Newsted is just there jamming with the whole bass section!!!

I think this might be my favorite arrangement on the S&M album, where the orchestra elevates the original tune. Band and orchestra totally in sync, and the vocals here are perfection.

One of my all-time performances of a Metallica song that I really like...and you decide to cover this on a Metal Monday!!! Thanks

man, you really need to check out Ne Obliviscaris - "And Plague Flowers the Kaleidoscope" or their more recent song "Equus", both are seriously master classes in composition for heavy/extreme metal music. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED.

Great song. Nice reaction!

I love how much you loved this.

Excited for this one....one of my Metallica's favourites.

i would really recommend trying hero of the day s&m version really underrated gem also your vids are amazing rwally glad that i found u a while back keep up the amazing work sir ♥♥

Never given much attention to outlaw torn, really enjoyed listening to it properly this time. I just love that its one of james' favorite songs and he should play it live more often for himself instead of pleasing the crowd

You gotta check out Eric Clapton's performance of Layla from Royal Albert Hall 1991 with an orchestra, it was also led by Michael Kamen. Probably one of the best versions of Layla out there. Another good one to check out from those concerts is "Edge of Darkness" which was a theme for a BBC TV show of the same name, with music written by Kamen and Clapton.

James’s voice has evolved so much over the years it’s really amazing.

One of my favoritessss ! 🤘

I actually love the 90s albums. Outlaw torn is a great track.

Was fortunate to see Maestro Kamen play keyboards on Roger Waters first solo tour, The Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking. His team recreated all of Rick's synth sounds perfectly. Ever Fliyd song sounded EXACTLY like the album, due in large part to MK. This was the only tour Rig did this. On every subsequent your, the songs were retooled by The Bleeding Hearts Band. Growing over the years into new and unique pieces that fit the current performers. I was very bummed to not be able to attend this show. When I heard that he'd written arrangements and new material with James, I was more than excited. The performance was expertly recorded, the band and orchestra working together and not fighting. Due in large part to the brilliant arrangements. You can even hear Jason! My favorite part of this video is when they cut to Jason and he's "locked in" with the guy on the string bass, just jamming. 🤘🧙‍♂️🤘 Rich the Ancient Metal Beast