She had no actual argument, she just spews out what her college professors tell her to think.

@kender1412

9 сағат бұрын

Catch phrases and buzzwords...

Charlie might hurt your feelings but he aint lying.

@Jeptheplay

12 күн бұрын

and feelings these days are damn irrelevant!!

Whether you believe with the charlie kirk’s or not, this girl is more of a problem.

@Mina4t20

19 күн бұрын

The people that don’t agree with him on this issue are also the problem

@GazzaBoo

14 күн бұрын

She is a classic woke liberal useful idiot who will always be right and will never listen or accept facts. These are the fools colleges are graduating. Stupid to the core mixed with arrogance and self righteousness.

@hadesdogs4366

13 күн бұрын

It’s not exactly her that’s the problem it’s her ideology that’s the issue where she’s only regurgitating what she’s been told to believe, the real issue is the ideology she represents which is eerily similar to the book Big Brother where a select few have all of the power, mixed with modern technology where they spy on everyone like the FBI but in a more open manner as well as having the power to change not only reality but facts such as the color red is in fact blue

@fuzzymctwitch1906

7 күн бұрын

Yepp.. she's trying to force him into one of two opinions when there are infinite opinions to have.. she's saying YOU HAVE to either believe this or this.. theres no other possibility.. which is absolutely ridiculous. She did not argue in good faith at all.

Came in the country with $2000 in pocket as a student. No relatives or friends. As an Asian, never thought I had any privilege over anyone.

@donquijote6030

5 күн бұрын

And that is why you will be successful in life. When you work hard, do not have children out of wedlock, attend university or engage in a professional trade, stay the course when difficulties arise, and you will find success.

Something tells me this girl is offended by a LOT of things.

@bobfranke2347

5 күн бұрын

Growing older will be difficult for females with her mindset....

I’ll bet that girl has to show ID to purchase alcohol, get on a plane, purchase an IPhone, & the list goes on!!

Call me crazy but it looks like the crowd disagrees with her.

@overlord3850

5 күн бұрын

True, but crowd support should be kept out of debates. We don't want to have an ad populum fallacy.

😭😭😭;OMG, the reason this lady keeps chuckling is because she realizes how intellitually dishonest her argument is!

@ghostinthesystem3872

6 күн бұрын

She thought she was goijg to win a argument but got publicly humiliated

@bobfranke2347

5 күн бұрын

Maybe she just needs to leave the microphone....?

The core issue is Fatherhood

@HypnoticHollywood

3 күн бұрын

Taking it further the core issue in black America is liberalism.

@reformcongress

2 күн бұрын

@@HypnoticHollywood "Democratic Party". Vote out the Democrats in the urban centers and get better leadership there, there will be more opportunities for them. However, it won't happen overnight. It will take a couple of generations to see progress that can be applauded, and the Democratic Party will fight it all the way because as blacks rise in the economic spectrum, they will move further away from the Democratic Party.

@viperdemonz-jenkins

2 күн бұрын

lack of.

Give her 20 years or so, when she isn’t just out of her childhood.

@jimmcintosh2087

3 күн бұрын

Most of these Delusional Children Will Have a New Understanding When & If They Receive Their First Paycheck & Read the Whole Stub! First Taste of Reality!

@viperdemonz-jenkins

2 күн бұрын

she will not ever be out of childhood.

She was insufferable, when she was dead wrong which was 99% of that exchange, she laughed and said "I don't care". Kirk won hands down

Its funny that everything is a “great question” for her, but she had no answer

@scapelaine4529

3 күн бұрын

Why does she remind me of the middle child in the Brady bunch series!

Debating the stupid is inequitable.

He didn’t say genetic he said cultural!!! The culture changed.

Charlie Kirk is absolutely right. I am old enough to remember when most black households were made up of a mother and a father. You are absolutely wrong about black fathers being in prisons and that is why they were not around. In late 1960's and beyond, welfare made it more profitable for black women with children to NOT have a man in the house. The carrot being dangled was to offer more money to single mothers alone. If a man entered the household, or the father was present, the benefits were reduced or stopped. That is when single black motherhood spiked. Welfare is a trap. It offers false security, but just enough to keep you from stepping out from under it and making more money (we still do this with older citizens now and collecting Social Security checks. The government raised the age of retirement based on the expectation of length of life and when the average death age is. The longer you wait to collect, the higher the paycheck, but the better chances you have of never collecting because you will be dead, whereas if young people were encouraged to set up their own strong retirement plans in the prime of their lives, they could afford to retire whenever they felt it was right, not because without working until they are good and old will assure they can maybe live in controlled, low-income housing and need food stamps). When men have no families they feel encouraged to provide for, they turn to other appetites that are not healthy ones. And it is PROVEN that without a man's influence in young men's lives, most will begin adopting things like street gangs to provide that relationship. (An interesting study was done with male elephants that became more aggressive and abusive when there were no older male elephants around to steer them in the right direction). Older men teach younger men how to be a true man who handles his responsibilities with family and to provide and raise his children. Another thing is education. Black people FOUGHT for education in slavery when it was forbidden. It was against the law for slaves to learn to read and write. More blacks did more with elementary school education than they do today graduating from high school. Part of this has to do with the deterioration of education. Schools in mostly black neighborhoods have abysmal grades. Schools actually graduate seniors who still read at elementary school levels! This was NOT the case 60 years ago with blacks, who understood the value of an education and had to fight to get it. Now they will keep passing them on. My mother was from the Dominican Republic, and i remember when public schools decided it was unfair for immigrant children to have lessons in English, so they began bilingual classes. To the white liberal, this sounds so wonderful. It's not! My mother stated that they used to put children behind a year when they immigrated here. The reason was so that they could become fluent in English and then continue with the level they left off with in their native country. They could continue their education stronger. Having children who grew up and graduated and still did not have a handle on English meant we had lots more low-income earners like janitors, maids and fast food workers. The need for immigrant children is to command the language so they can continue on to higher education, higher paying jobs, pursuing their dreams and goals. Please do yourself a favor and read some of the black economists and authors Charlie Kirk mentions, like Thomas Sowell. Even Denzel Washington has spoken many times on the need for black fathers in the home. And MOST black men 60 years ago were NOT in jail. They were working to support themselves and their families.

@louellacharlton4425

13 күн бұрын

Ty for this.

@MrPetej00

18 сағат бұрын

I agree, but I also agree that fathers not being around because they are in prison. HOWEVER, if the culture in African American communities was different there would be less black fathers in prison. If black men stayed with the women they got pregnant and supported them, they would be out at a job/career instead of running the streets getting into trouble and getting other women pregnant. There is ZERO expectation for black fathers to stay around and support their families. Change that and you solve half of the issues in the inner city. You solve education, job availability, home ownership rates (generational wealth) and most importantly IMAGE.

The government has been trying to fix this community for 60 years and after 60 years of work. The community is worse off than they were before To suggest that the government is the solution to the problem that they created is ludicrous.

@cellycel8TV

14 күн бұрын

But White Americans never needed the help because they prospered on colonized land. Black people were helped for a reason. It wasn’t a favor

@J0n4THANOS

14 күн бұрын

They are slow and they inflate costs WAAAAAAY too much. If private business were to do it, they’d get it done faster and likely under budget.

@blnunya6689

8 күн бұрын

​@@J0n4THANOSI work in county government in the facilities department....I'm the guy who keeps the building systems functioning. You are correct but what also happens is on big projects as soon as a contractor sees it's a government job the cost immediately goes up. It's a combination of government not putting in place regulations to stop that and private industry taking advantage of it. One of the buildings I maintain is a work release facility and parts and materials are automatically more because they magically become "institutional" parts and up goes the price. Somehow there are screws then there are institutional screws.... it's all ridiculous.

@Pammyspoint

6 күн бұрын

@@blnunya6689 Very well said👍

@strawberry48535

5 күн бұрын

They have not tried to fix it, they have done exactly what LBJ wanted, the black people will live off the government & would vote for them for the next 200 years. The plan was to keep them dependant on the government & democrats!

She's supposed to be at college to learn. Charlie's trying to teach her but she's not able to comprehend she could be wrong

@gunztommiegunz

6 күн бұрын

That’s what they don’t teach

Does she not realize that the Chinese were brought here as slaves and were subject to the same discrimination as black slaves? Who does she think built the railroads?

She just wasn’t arguing in good faith, she kept making false equivalencies and trapping Charlie into banal this or that’s it’s your only choice.

Sowell is a genius.

@Pammyspoint

6 күн бұрын

@greglaney3516 You are so right👍! To say he is a genius is almost an understatement.

@whitway12

6 күн бұрын

And yet none of his books are on the ‘BLM reading list’ strange that is! 🤔

There are no locks on those chains that she chooses to cling to.

Charlie is absolutely right. I didn`t find one flaw in what he said. If he did, enlighten me.

No wisdom behind her, she is so condescending

Excuses, excuses black people come from all over the world to America, set of businesses and now living the American dream .

People have fought hard to remove segregation in this country since Plessy v. Ferguson. Why are we now trying to bring it back?

Her biggest problem is she believes she is smarter than she actually is.

@RS54321

Күн бұрын

She has to be right no matter what.

That poor girl is so lost. I feel bad for her.🙁

She’s still a kid she hasn’t learned a proper debate style yet. Her sarcasm downgrades her points impact like when she giggles inappropriately or says “great question” or “my favorite” when either example is obvious it’s pure sarcasm not genuine. If you are in a debate rely on your facts to win not sarcasm or like some other kids usually use, insults. But what’s better than arguing just to win it’s superior to seek more truth and to be correct rather than incorrect.

I can't believe how patient Charlie is day after day after day!

Another obnoxious know-it-all college student who dismisses everything Charlie says. She is not interested in learning, only accusation.

Got my girlfriend pregnant at 20 thought it was the right thing to do to get married I'm 40 now and I have two beautiful children together forever

i had a conversation with my black nextdoor neighbor a few years ago about voter IDs. he said what i already knew, most folks, black, white, etc... whom are legal US citizens have US Gov IDs. if you do not but want one, it is very easy, quick and cheap or free to get one. we are 60 year past civil rights with programs over the decades to specifically help blacks. but we have designed social programs that have kept too many poor blacks, poor. most white Americans are pulling for blacks to succeed thru hard work, effort and talent. hispanics and some asians come over here with nothing and do not know English every day. but they quickly find success and their children often do well in school and with Asians, outpace all other Americans in average wealth. there is racism against many of them just like against whites, blacks, etc... but no systemic/institutional discrimination holding anyone back from the pursuit of happiness. in fact, like i mentioned earlier, there are more programs to help blacks succeed that no other race in America gets.

She thought she was smart and understood more than she truly did. She made herself look foolish.

Her giggling is so annoying. Almost couldn’t listen to her.

She is using big words that she was taught in college, but she is all talk ,no substance

I was retired before I was 40 . Racism has never held me back, Because I never let it. If Cry that you are a victim from the time you wake up till you go to bed. Then you are holding yourself back!

New drinking game. Drink every time Charlie says "hold on"

I think Charlie is on track with the argument that incentivizing single motherhood removes a father from the family. This in turn has been shown to harm the children and increase the likelihood of them growing up in the criminal system. I think that being in a loving family relationship promotes men to be real men and decreases the likelihood of them getting into trouble.

Where do these kids learn this foolishness? Must be foolish teachers.

@jannabailey6800

17 күн бұрын

In highschool or college Colin 😮😮

@colingan9412

17 күн бұрын

@@jannabailey6800 might be both Janna, scary.

@vitalipopkhadze369

14 күн бұрын

Her parents didn't do much teaching either.. Because she's completely out of the obvious. In my opinion.

@joanneesposito3295

7 күн бұрын

This girl is an unfortunate example of the failure of our school system. Thomas Sowell should be required reading starting in high school.

Name one country worldwide that doesnt that doesnt require a ID to vote.

@constantineceasar

20 күн бұрын

North Korea

@temujinkhan6326

20 күн бұрын

It's racist to ask that question

@constantineceasar

20 күн бұрын

@@temujinkhan6326 damn right bro to the purple people from the moon justice for the moon monkeys!

@billstream1974

20 күн бұрын

@@constantineceasar How many countries are there?

@constantineceasar

20 күн бұрын

@@billstream1974 there's 3 countries on the moon and they are The 5th Reich, Soviet American Land, and the The Great Spligger Empire

there are 58 black people in the us legislative branch out of 535 seats that's pretty close to their % of population......

@MrMd5555

15 күн бұрын

Good point. What is that like %11 or %12 when the black pop is like %13. That's pretty good representation

@timkelly6985

7 күн бұрын

​@@MrMd5555 Especially good seeing that the black population has dropped to around 12.5%. The reality is that they will not be happy until they control every single top position in government, schools, and businesses. They are using the same Marxist tactics as they used leading up to and during the Russian revolution of 1917. Notice how BLM and the Democrats now proudly proclaim to be trained Marxists and Socialists?

It must be awful for her to be so sure and so wrong.

Everything Charlie said was valid. Father's not in the home & being told America is against you is a big & almost the 2 main reasons why of what happened in the black & brown community

And how are they racist? You need ID’s for the bank, drive a car and many other things. So one of the MOST IMPORTANT THING IN OUR COUNTRY, VOTING, DEFINITELY NEEDS ID’S!

I have employees that speak no English, but they are just as valuable if not more than others that do. She is delusional

I’m Asian and I’ve got ID how am i oppressed 😂

@victoriavernon-bt4jo

7 күн бұрын

You didn’t realise you were oppressed. I hope you are glad now 😂

I so wish I could’ve accessed this “white privilege” during my working life! Where was it when I was immersed in my career in the U.S. Military? As a disabled Veteran I DEMAND my “privilege”!

West Virginia is the one of poorest states yet has the least crime. I bet she dont know that tho.

This points to the importance, relevance, influence a of “Family” - the basic unit of society. Which Parents = Father and Mother and The Children,😊.

As a lifelong resident of the south side of Chicago, the son of a poor immigrant who also had family here for over 100 years, I can confirm that woman is wrong and that Charlie Kirk was spot on. That is what happened and is happening here in Chicago.

Gangsta culture, simple answer

Regardless of race we should be encouraging young men to do better than our fathers it’s the only way

She needs to go talk to Jesse Lee Peterson lol

@timkelly6985

7 күн бұрын

That would be hilarious.

Institutuonal racism INCREASED? she has never read a history book

I completely agree with Kirk!!

@victoriavernon-bt4jo

7 күн бұрын

I think he made a lot of great points- backed up with facts, which is what anyone needs! Not based on opinion only!

This girls answer is ridiculous. I grew up in the Bronx and had to fight my way through by being stalked and attacked by blacks and Hispanics. My parents migrated here from Ireland and believe me they were poor. Blacks sold blacks.

College produces people like this woman.

That girl wasn’t very bright

@annmarieblanc6363

15 күн бұрын

You're right but unfortunately SHE doesn't think so! SMH, Andy, Annmarie's husband

This chick was schooled…..

One thing about welfare is that you can be thrown off of it easily. welfare encourages unmarried mothers, having more kids. when you're low income, welfare will subsidize your rent, your food, your healthcare, while not having to work. for most of us work socks, to be able to have 70% as much while not having to work is very tempting. It also encourages working under the table or committing crimes. since welfare isn't making anyone rich, you can still be on welfare and commit crimes or have a job that pays you under the table. so not only has welfare encouraged irresponsible behavior, it has encouraged crime

@brisumoonah

17 күн бұрын

And that’s a system in place that encourages this specific community to be in a sunken place no? I’m trying to hear Charlie’s point on the welfare aspect also playing a systematic role on this lifestyle being more widespread.

She is her favorite fan.!

@J0n4THANOS

14 күн бұрын

And I bet she got an A in that class too. Probably the teachers pet….sad.

Charlie forgot to take crack into account 😂

@josephpearlman4010

14 күн бұрын

"Charlie forgot to take crack into account" What about it?

My parents were dirt poor and never considered crime and murder a way of life.

@robertewalt7789

Күн бұрын

I note you said “parents.” Two parents makes for a better family.

I shattered my leg years ago and lost my job my wife applied for assistance and the social worker told her she would get more help if she divorced me and tried several times to convince her that's how our society collapses

@OffGridAlaska

2 күн бұрын

@jamesmitchell6619 my husband is 69 and has Medicare. I had medicaid because I am 60 and our income is low. With the Cola increase in Jan. It put us a few dollars a month over the limit and I lost my insurance. I was told divorce my husband so I would qualify for Medicaid. My only other option was spend 63% of our monthly income to purchase insurance that has a 10k deductible!

@jamesmitchell6619

Күн бұрын

@@OffGridAlaska I truly hope things are better for you now I wish people would just read the writing on the wall our society is definitely showing signs of the decades of neglect

Let me give examples of things that need a photo id's: Get on a plane(unless illegal), get welfare, open a bank account, buy alcohol, but cigarettes, rent a hotel room, rent a car, buy a gun, or any number of other things. JUST SAYING!

Wait- Asians were brought here in the 1800’s to build railroads.

Just a statistic the lady left out. Currently, there are 62 black people in congress. This constitutes 11 percent of congress. They make up 13% of the population. Just a fact, she said they were very underrepresented, and that isn't true in that context.

Is this girl a teaching assistant or even a prof or propaganda? She keeps conceding point after point that Charlie makes and yet can not concede to his conclusions! If that isn't intellectual dishonesty I don't know what is! All she ever said was it's "complicated and nuanced" but she knows, somehow, Charlie is wrong?!! LMFAO and SMH all at the same time! Just for the record I'm Andy, Annmarie's husband and I'm responsible for the content of this post not her.

she really just laid out how she really feels.... either you believe her or you think it is based on genetics, ie you're racist.

Always remember, stereotypes come from a place of truth

Tnere was a time when the Irish were treated much how she describes. They managed to rise above it. So did Jewish people. And Asians. What is the black man’s exscuse?

I grew up on a small farm in the northwest. Our school system is one of the poorest in the state. My mother had poor health all my life and was unable to work. My father had to work away from home and try to farm after work and on the weekends. My father died at work when I was 17, leaving my 15 year old brother and I to take care of our drug and alcohol addicted mother. As soon as I got out of school for the summer, I started working farm jobs. I started buying my own things, clothes, etc. The next year, still in high school, I started working for the U S Forest Service as a fire fighter and data collector. Then, I went back to school for my final year of high school. I was working as soon as the senior class was let out 2 weeks before graduation. I worked the day of my graduation planting trees in the mountains. I never felt sorry for myself. I just did what I had to do. Oh, and we were poor growing up. We only took 3 vacations in 17 years. So the way I look at things if my brother and I could be successful after having to grow up as we did, why can't others make a life for them self's. Stay in school, go get a degree, and get a job.

Watching that girl talk is like watching someone on the deck of the Titanic saying the ship isn't sinking, when 80% of the passengers are already in the drink...

She's so uncomfortable with having to hear hard truths

Students trying to talk smart. But they fail.

This girl knows very little another college student that thinks they're smart

Schools - the CTR does not teach the basics or life skills. Graduation rates are depressing. Vote Trump and let's give these families School Choice. . ALL Americans should be given a quality education....not a CTR indoctrination of intolerance, racism and deviance.

I would love to hear your reaction to Thomas Sowell truth about slavery video

Thank you for bringing up sensible questions and answers, people need to start thinking for themselves and facing actual facts

This woman will be lost forever. I would not like to meet her parents.

Another example of "You CAN'T fix Stupid" and that going to college DOESN'T make you smart. There is NOTHING RACIST about requiring and ID, BUT Affirmative Action is.

In her mind she has the answer to everything…. A Legend in her own mind.

If she wants fair representation then 13% of everything should be Black . Govt. , Sports Teams , Colleges and Businesses should be 13% .

@OlWhtWmn

7 күн бұрын

Doing everything "by the numbers" disregards merit, ability, and education/training.

@robertewalt7789

Күн бұрын

I’m a 6 foot white in my 70’s. Can I play in the NBA?

The girl is more offended by truth. What she says should be the truth ?

Charlie, You sure are very patient with these naive simpletons!

Isn't the educational system a form of institutional racism? Funding for schools should be equal for everyone regardless of what neighborhood a child lives in.

When I was growing up both my parents worked. I had an older sister and we had chores to do as well as homework to complete. When they got home, one of them would sit down and have me show them what homework I'd gotten finish so far. Before bed time one or both had insured my work was done. If a kid, of any race only had a single parent they wouldn't have thetime to devote as my parents did. I think that shows the difference between black and white families

At least they disagree in a polite way.

Black women have been rewarded for not having a black man in the house. It’s nobody’s fault but ours and we need to have the balls to say the ish out loud and unapologetically!

Two of the dots that cannot be connected are those of ID cards and racism.

Her whole argument is based on quicksand.

I’m white af. I need a id to do TONS of stuff.

Her responses are typical of narcissistic chaos/word-salad.

My favorite part is always how they get angry when they get cornered with their own BS talking points.

She is so very sleazy and dishonest. She knows exactly what she is doing. She is shameful.

My father grew up poor. They didn't have to lock their doors in nyc bc there was no crime.

Remember this folks, the same people that are against voter ID, wanted you to have to show your vaccine passport, to go out to dinner.

If she would only listen to Kirk's words. She has problems with paying attention.

The mental gymnastics to protect CRT. Wow.

My buddy is a police officer and he said if you are white you are at a disadvantage, they are looking for black and minority candidates, if you happen to be one of those categories of people you get hired first.