Chanel Allure Homme Edition Blanche EDP - Worth the Hype?
No doubt Edition Blanche is an extremely pleasing scent but to me it is nothing extraordinary, and it is hard to recommend it for the price that it goes for!
Let's stop referring to this scent as lemon meringue pie. This is a more woody scent than you might expect, based around the note of sandalwood. The creaminess comes from that dry shaven texture of sandalwood. The lemon here is not as sharp, tart, or green as I expected, and instead this fragrance has a more generic "sport" fragrance DNA about it, similar to Allure Homme Sport. Performance is an issue as it smell great and projects fairly well for the first 2 hours, and then dries into a basic musky scent with a hint of vanilla. Better summer alternatives at this price range are the EDT versions of Tom Ford's Portofino collection. Or spend a little bit more and get Creed's Himalaya. Or spend FAR less and go for Hanae Mori HM which to me doesn't smell as high quality, sure, but is more interesting at just a miniscule fraction of the price.
Пікірлер: 102
*"I got so tired of hearing this smells like lemon meringue pie"* You and me both.
I just picked this up yesterday and I find it quite pleasant. I agree with you that this is not a gourmand fragrance and it’s much more fresh than I expected. I have to wonder about all the reviews I have watched where reviewers have called it gourmand and groundbreaking. Like I said I’m enjoying it and don’t regret it but do feel it’s overhyped and misled by so many reviewers so thank you for your honesty in this review.
Very well put 👏🏻
Great review!
I agree with you 100 percent on this scent. I love hanae mori so much more. That’s so underrated
I watched this review after I ordered mine from Chanel and was a lil skeptical about my purchase after watching it and reading some of the comments…to each their own I suppose because my batch is FIRE. You smell lemon, then vanilla right after, it definitely isn’t lemon meringue, or any other food, just a chemical romance of alluring sensuality…creamy dreamy feels boi boi…i’m sooo glad I bought the 5oz bottle! In my opinion Chanel outdid themselves with this one…as a habit I never purchase from discount marts, not saying anyone else here did, but as I mentioned my bottle is the killer diller 🚫🧢
@jimlittle5769
Жыл бұрын
Couldn't agree more.
I just subscribed and appreciate your take on fragrances. Agreed that Allure Homme Edition Blanche does NOT smell like lemon meringue pie lol and not nearly sweet enough to be labeled a gourmand. I get more of a fizzy lemon iced tea powder meets vetiver sandalwood musk barbershop vibe. I love mine which is the EDT before they "reformulated" it...
I finished my bottle long ago, and not in a hurry to repurchase. You hit the nail on the head - it should be priced comparable to other designers at discounters. I have Xerjoff Uden and it 's in the same vein perhaps not as effervescent/ lemon heavy as E.B. Love the placebo affect analogy at the end btw. Great review!
@jorgeloo3131
Жыл бұрын
Hi Adriano! Between this EditionBlanche and the Xerjoff Uden which will be your pick? Do you think having both is redundant? (Have Uden and was thinking on this one and if this deserve a purchase). Thanks in advanced!
Great review! I own Guerlain L’Homme Ideal Cologne, and I thoroughly enjoy that citrus aromatic vibe mixed with that semi sweet undertone, so Edition Blanche was on my shortlist. Maybe I’ll try Lolita Lempicka Green Lover instead.
@johnf5752
2 жыл бұрын
I’ve heard really great things about that cologne. It’s discontinued though, right?
@uberboiz
Жыл бұрын
Love L'Homme Ideal Cologne. I still have 2 50ml bottles which I haven't opened yet - not sure if I ever want to considering it's already discontinued. 😞
I recently subscribed some fragrance viewers. You're the best among them
@UrbanDwellerNYC
3 жыл бұрын
Hope I delivered some useful info!
Keep it going 👏🏼👏🏼
The EDT C is creamier and heavier in vanilla. EDP has brighter lemon, more fresh and instead of vanilla it gives a sugar vibe- huge difference.
@jameshusband3392
Жыл бұрын
To me it smells just like Lemonheads candy with just a touch of vanilla
I agree with this 100% I just got mine in, and it smells amazing! It's definitely not a lemon pie, I don't get how people get that it does not have the sweetness a pie would have. Now longevity is pretty poor first day, but I knew that going into this by seeing all the reviews. So I knew buying this I was 1 buying it for the name and 2 the scent not the longevity or projection. But all in all happy it's in the collection. Was more of a buy for myself cause I just wanted to experience it. Plus have a bad habit of collecting frags :/
Allure homme is a masterpiece 🏆 thanks 👍
@chipmcgee4393
3 жыл бұрын
Allure Homme is the BEST of the line. The OG.
What cheaper clone or alternative can you recommend to this Chanel or what do you think comes closest for someone on a low budget.
I think you’re comparing it to the taste and not the smell of lemon meringue pie.
MY GOD FINALLY! You described my thought of this fragrance perfectly, I never got lemon meringue pie from Edition Blanche ever. It's a nice scent overall, but Chanel really need to amp up the vanilla sweetness a bit if they want to present the "meringue pie" aspect of it. But hey FragranceDoc, if I wanted something lemony similar but with a little bit more vanilla sweetness what would you recommend? Can Hanae Mori HM be worn in the summer? Thanks
@AD-cp6uw
3 жыл бұрын
The best way to determine if you feel comfortable wearing a particular fragrance in a particular season is to imagine what outfit you would wear with it…to me, scents can smell like a look with some imagination👍🏽
@titozamora9500
2 жыл бұрын
Nishane ani . Fragrance
@theandroids
2 жыл бұрын
When I first smelled this it was very lemon pie like very very nice. But that was years ago. Maybe they changed the scent.
I thoroughly enjoyed this in-depth review. I get tired of reviewers describing it as a “lemon meringue pie” scent cause I don’t have a good idea of what the heck that even smells like. My mind immediately goes to key lime pie and I don’t find smelling like that appealing at all 😂
@Gerien66
3 жыл бұрын
00
@pedrorojas0116
2 жыл бұрын
Lol that's so true. Reviewers need to up their game
One of the best fragrance ever ..its on my top 10
yeah, i love the psychology/placebo effect (i always think about it when i expect something from a blind buy) ... and then it comes (a disappointment :D)
I have CAHEB and Creed's Sublime Vanille. To my nose they are very similar. I have Lelabo Bergamot 22 as well and prefer that one over all of them. Compliments would go to Sublime Vanille though 🤷🏾♂️
It’s actually $157 right now I just checked it on Chanel’s website.
Hola ¿La recomiendas para primavera y verano? Gracias.
The old concentree version smelt amazing now it's just a light woody smell with a very faint lemon smell
@oceansoflorewi
2 жыл бұрын
Agreed- I ordered the EDP after having the EDT C - I'm shocked how different they smell!!! EDT C far more creamy unique and dreamy.
@100zz100
2 жыл бұрын
@@oceansoflorewi 👌🏼
Where did you get the sample?
absolutely agree with Creed Himalaya as a better, more interesting smell ... i have Allure Edition Blanche and it bored me after 2 wearing ... too sharp lemon in the intro ..... yeah, it projects a lot but it´s not a round, soft , uplifting lemon, it´s an aggressive syntetic lemon .... i like Allure Homme Sport the best (fresh yet has that vanilla creaminess and it has much more rounder smell)
@watchandspray
2 жыл бұрын
What do you think is a good affordable clone or alternative to Edition Blanche?
@miles-178
2 жыл бұрын
@@watchandspray i don´t know anything similar
Do you know which batch you reviewed by chance? My fiancé just ordered me a bottle for my birthday and I wanna know how the performance is. Thanks!
@killmonger4169
3 жыл бұрын
The new ones are still great! Just not an eau de toilette. Literally almost no difference.
Glad u did this. Ur spot on. It's overrated 😒
my pick TOM FORD Grey Vetiver Eau de Parfum
I think it’s well worth the price
0:20 100% agree...just copy/paste repeating ,even in countries where don't have l.m.p. 🙂
Layer Tom Ford Metalique with Chanel Allure Home edition Blanche then you will create heaven
Its still very pleasant, but Neroli Portofino is way too pricy an alternative plus doesn't last and silver mountain is even stupider pricing and is even further away from this scent dna
I disagree. Its only “very fresh” upon first spray, for a minute or so. It becomes really dense, really thick, sweet and “lemon cheescake”y within 30? minutes or so. In fact i wish it was less thick. I have to disagree because i order lemon desserts a lot, and when i first sprayed this one without any prior priming or knowledge, first thing i thought of was Espresso Lab’s lemon cheesecake.
In Germany I can get 100ml for 85€, which makes it a much better deal.
100ml is Not very expensive in. Europe :) I guess Some countries have very high import taxes?
French perfumery is not about beast mode... it is all about style mode... simple but also daring ;))
I'm not a fan of Dior Cologne either cause it doesn't last. Too many reviewers over hype it as well. Jimmy Choo Ice for the $ is better
@UrbanDwellerNYC
3 жыл бұрын
Agree I could never hype that one that it’s too fleeting but compared to edition Blanche I think it accomplishes the job a bit better. More actual use for it.
@8mcneely
3 жыл бұрын
@@UrbanDwellerNYC I'm looking for a Signature scent, one I can wear year round. I live in Atlanta GA where we get all seasons. I'm a Business Executive, College Professor, & Minister. Can u offer a few suggestions on the Designer and Niche side? Thanks!
@UrbanDwellerNYC
3 жыл бұрын
@@8mcneely on the designer side, have you tried Chanel platinum egoiste, Tom Ford Beau de Jour, Dolce Gabbana Pour Homme? On the niche side I might suggest Creed Viking, Creed Royal Oud, or if you want to smell more fresh and aquatic, Parfums de Marly Sedley. Oh another good signature designer would be Acqua di Gio, and I actually do like Profondo, esp if you live in a hotter climate
@UrbanDwellerNYC
3 жыл бұрын
@@8mcneely oh how could I leave out Acqua di Parma (either Essenza or Intensa), and you may also like Floris No. 89!
@8mcneely
3 жыл бұрын
@@UrbanDwellerNYC bro I appreciate all these suggestions. Gonna ck them out for sure
I really like honest reviewers like you. I have my honest criticism on Lataffa Assad and I felt like I was part of a witch hunt! 😂
I watch every one of your videos. You said you were giving your objective opinion…but opinion is subjective. Being objective means to lay aside your opinion, in light of the facts.
@UrbanDwellerNYC
3 жыл бұрын
Absolutely! 😂
@golfbuddy1969
3 жыл бұрын
@@UrbanDwellerNYC but I probably agree with your subjective opinion…but I may like Allure Sport better than Extreme. Maybe…
@TheRealLeeM
3 жыл бұрын
Is there such a thing as an objective fragrance review?
@UrbanDwellerNYC
3 жыл бұрын
@@TheRealLeeM there isn’t no
🥇 first 😄
I found this video because I guess I fell for the hype. It smells nothing like a lemon pie. it's nice, but the longevity is nonexistent and smells very confused.
Lol I love that this doesn’t work on people skin. More for me. Elegance, class, and citrus. Chanel is not for the cheap hearted. People truly don’t understand this fragrance. Its a bomb on me and lasts 8hours. It’s perfect
@AD-cp6uw
3 жыл бұрын
💯
@zxcvbnm2428
2 жыл бұрын
true bro, something about chanel's quality is just different, its masterpiece very well thought. i hvae a lot frag and some niche but i kept coming back for chanel, bleu and allure line is just fireee.
@killmonger4169
2 жыл бұрын
@@zxcvbnm2428 same! Two of the best lines
@garywashington6757
Жыл бұрын
@@killmonger4169 just ordered a 100ml of blanche cant wait to get it friday! What are couple things u like about this? An in your opinion how many sprays do u need to get the job done in your opinion?
just picked this up for £60 for tje 100ml lol and looking at reviews
Can anyone tell me where you can find Himalaya for around $200?
Musk therapy review ??
@UrbanDwellerNYC
3 жыл бұрын
Good idea! I've been curious about that one
@terrwes2807
3 жыл бұрын
@@UrbanDwellerNYC ⭐
Can you do a video for me... Versace Eros EDT vs Dior Sauvage EDT
@UrbanDwellerNYC
3 жыл бұрын
Wow those are such different scents - any particular reason you want me to compare them?
I agree. Edition Blanche totally sucks in my books. Not worth it and over hyped for no reason.
this dont smell gourmand at all.. And is way over hyped! can get similar scents for half the price.
cheaper alternative?
@annlue1
2 жыл бұрын
It would be impossible
Designer fragrances aren't meant to be masterpieces just colognes that smell good so let's not really overthink things
@UrbanDwellerNYC
3 жыл бұрын
Tell that to the people hyping it up
@UrbanDwellerNYC
3 жыл бұрын
Not everyone’s got $100 to throw away!
@infamousaries1095
3 жыл бұрын
You're paying for the name their better then what you get compared to the cheapies companies have to cut quality for quantity it's a business you want to find better then find better
@vanessabarryhudgens
2 жыл бұрын
I disagree at least not for Chanel
It's called your "subjective" opinion, not objective. How come you say that your opinion is the correct one? 😂
Blind buy, expensive, good smell, i like it but not worth the hype
"Eau de parferrrr", keep it real
@saltywaffleZ
3 жыл бұрын
The hells he supposed to say
@killmonger4169
3 жыл бұрын
@@saltywaffleZ not that
@DuSeun
Жыл бұрын
@@killmonger4169 He pronounced that perfectly. Learn French
Lovely smell. But doesn’t last on my skin. Not worth the money
this lasts for a hour then it’s almost gone …
@AeowCorpse21
Жыл бұрын
Same maximum 1 and a half forme too sad 😢.
Have watched your channel, after this review will not watch again. You have no idea what you are talking about, bye bye