WHAT

@MudFlaps

6 ай бұрын

GET REKT

@Negativeduelist

6 ай бұрын

When you get called out for a bad reason

@dang3rguy337

6 ай бұрын

@@MudFlaps pin him

@brienhill1857

6 ай бұрын

Well you got rekt

@fusscup

6 ай бұрын

Ooohhh snap

It doesn't spawn the end portal because the dragon data is corrupt so when it dies it no longer registers it dying, you would need to pause the game during the BuD when the Enderdragon is killed and then update to a new version of the game. Alternatively click the copyright info on tbe title screen and you get the end credits that way.

@barneythedarney9666

6 ай бұрын

@MudFlaps hear this guy out

@god_is_above_all_of_us

6 ай бұрын

@Mud Flaps

@amandahyatt

6 ай бұрын

When I use the scrollwhell it breaks

@crazy-Cookie-kitty

6 ай бұрын

@Mud Flaps THEY FIGURED IT OUT

@Nyerguds

6 ай бұрын

Clicking the copyright info will only show the credits though; not the end poem.

When he had the idea of spectating the falling gravel, I immediately thought of spectating lit TNT. Stays an entity until it explodes even if it hits a block.

@CombustibleLemon77

5 ай бұрын

I was thinking that he took way too much time typing out "/gamemode spectator" when there's literally a keybind: F3 + N will set your gamemode to spectator, pressing it again will set it to whatever it was before you pressed it. You can press F3 + Q to see the full list of F3 commands too.

@Zebra_Paw

5 ай бұрын

@@CombustibleLemon77 yes + there's the well known F3+F4

@maxybg

5 ай бұрын

Even then you wouldn't be able to make that TNT since you have to die immediately when you spawn

@CombustibleLemon77

5 ай бұрын

@@maxybg maybe some insanely rare generation such as a temple generating right above a stronghold with a full portal so an animal jumps on the pressure plate and you can spectate the tnt falling directly into the portal

@maxybg

5 ай бұрын

@@CombustibleLemon77 hmm, even then, it would be difficult to spectate the TNT since as soon as it's lit up, it will fall right into the portal, also getting there fast enough (ignoring the fact a generation like this probably doesn't exist or hasn't been discovered yet)

In later versions, you actually can use gamerules to let spectators generate chunks so if you loaded the seed in 1.20, found the portal, then went to the snapshot and performed the glitch to enter it, you would have the issue solved in an easy way. Edit: This wouldn't necessarily invalidate the run because you can load the world with it enabled. Edit 2: Please actually read the comment before replying.

@paperbear03

6 ай бұрын

I was thinking abou that too but I think it means load previously generated chunks and not stick with the chunks you entered spectator mode in . I think you can’t load new chunks in spectator (not sure tho)

@gifer_snich5713

6 ай бұрын

btw there is /gamerule spectatorsGenerateChunks

@Ultrapwner45

6 ай бұрын

@@paperbear03 you can load new chunks with it

@thatguyhanzo3468

6 ай бұрын

you can also load the world with a bonus chest, only certain beneficial biomes, or hell just a superflat world made of diamonds with structures enabled. Changing the world generation is very much cheating (or at least should be imo)

@Shugunou

6 ай бұрын

@thatguyhanzo3468 It just enables gamerules at the start. There are certain ones that are banned like turning off damage but this isn't one of the banned ones since you normally wouldn't be playing in spectator mode during a speedrun.

The only way I can think of it entity cramming. At 8:23, 2 dragons spawned. If you can somehow duplicate ender dragons, then theoretically, if you get enough of them, you should be able to get one to die and activate the portal.

@electricmcpro8814

3 ай бұрын

@mudflaps SEE THIS

@robertbawell7738

3 ай бұрын

But how to get them to occupy the same space? Might as well use endermen if you attempt entity cramming.

@robertbawell7738

3 ай бұрын

But there is still the problem of not being able to interact with anything.

@gamerx5496

3 ай бұрын

there is one problem, your going to have to find the exact ender dragon that was spawned first because it showed only one bossbar and ones that dont have bossbars are considered normal mobs and the original one that has the bossbar is made so when it dies, it opens the portal. so you would have to find the exact dragon that has the bossbar to be able to open the portal, if im wrong than you can roast me as much as you want

@joshuadilgard1221

2 ай бұрын

Smart

Fresh concept, great personality, fun glitches, what’s not to love?

@ItzEndrr

6 ай бұрын

how its all clickbait

@FiniteMC

6 ай бұрын

@@ItzEndrr clickbait means he’s misleading us I’m the title or thumbnail. The title asks a question, and he answers it. If it said “I beat Minecraft in spectator mode”, that would be a bit clickbaity but still kinda true,

@ItzEndrr

6 ай бұрын

@@FiniteMC thats wrong tho it means just what you said its also staged, i tested, and the “glitch” he showed… doesnt work, you cant even enter the end 💀 also that defenition is straight up wrong

@krypto661

6 ай бұрын

@@ItzEndrr your actually right

@father76

6 ай бұрын

I Beat Minecraft in Spectator Mode (no cheats) is not a question @@FiniteMC

You could try the method that they use in the TAS category of speedruns. It would have to be frame perfect when you first load the end, you need to quit the game BEFORE the dragon spawns. Then load the game and the dragon can't spawn so the game will plop down the portal to the overworld. Then just do the same thing you did to get into the end to get out and you should get to the credits?

@FurryAnimator

6 ай бұрын

Hi! 🥰🥰💖💖💖💖

@idotsinabucket5547

6 ай бұрын

i dont see how this cant work tbh

@texugo_branco

6 ай бұрын

its literally frame perfect

@arc4na_

6 ай бұрын

what exactly does "frame perfect" mean? if it is actual frames then u can limit them to make it far easier.... thats obviously not possible if it's game ticks or something (which seems more likely but i have no idea)

@idotsinabucket5547

6 ай бұрын

@@arc4na_ lowering the framerate would most likely make it harder bc you need to leave the millisecond you load in

"im an idiot" Mud is such a mood

@BruhOfficial_YT

6 ай бұрын

I didn't expect you to be on this channel

@boredbear1828

6 ай бұрын

Sup nigga

@user-ic1je9gn5j

6 ай бұрын

​@@BruhOfficial_YTHe looks like Walter white yo

@user-ic1je9gn5j

6 ай бұрын

Walter white yo confirmed?

@fathergascoigne1457

6 ай бұрын

Get a life😊

I remember there being a snapshot where you could move some entities in spectator mode, such as minecarts. This might be useful.

Torches are blocks, not entities. You may have been thinking of item frames.

@realchiknuggets

3 ай бұрын

can't expect much from someone who can't understand the difference between a bug and a glitch

@Jzombi301

3 ай бұрын

@@realchiknuggets they are the same tho?

@Lrulkiewicz

2 ай бұрын

Why did I think this followed roses are red violets are blue Rhythm?

@sas.tronaut5055

Ай бұрын

@@realchiknuggetsnot everyone knows everything about coding. i bet a majority of people wouldnt know theres a difference

12:49 The reason why this didn't work is that the Entity Terminator used to destroy invalid entities isn't a function to "Kill" rather "Decimate" as in it doesn't act as if the health hits zero, it just deletes it out right.

@Muho_is_me

5 ай бұрын

Id think it wouldnt even spawn it since it didnt even know the entity?

@thewolfstu

5 ай бұрын

@@Muho_is_me well, not exactly, it'd kinda already be existing if you revert the version so it wouldn't need a spawn function, and when Minecraft reads the map data and finds an invalid entity, it then Decimates that entity as to not cause problems... wiiith exceptions, I am sure there's at least one invalid entity that has an existing ID name that if you revert your version from a version number to a lower one you might be able to see, but I'd use see loosely there cause it'd probably brick the game hard in that instance orrrr just be completely invisible due to not having any texture or model data.

@Muho_is_me

5 ай бұрын

Ok i see

If you want to join my minecraft event, hop onto the discord and wait for updates :) discord.gg/bHnkfXE5EM

@Coolguy0608

6 ай бұрын

(●’◡’●)ﾉ hi

@RedWisp.

6 ай бұрын

Hello

@MemesFromYieldingArts

6 ай бұрын

im ok thanks

@malikbickell4451

6 ай бұрын

Good luck!

@metallicafan112

6 ай бұрын

i really want to be in it

I once heard of a glitch where if you enter the end and immediately place an end crystal on the obsidian platform. The dragon doesn't spawn and the exit portal is open. I think it only works on bedrock edition.

@the_vine_queen

6 ай бұрын

It works on Java. It's used in the Minecraft Any% TAS run by DylanDC14

@HahnKreis

6 ай бұрын

In version 1.5.2 there was a bug that caused all monsters to die instantly! When you're at the end, set the world to version 1.5.2! Then enter the world again! The dragon dies! While the dragon dies, you should change the version back to 1.5.2 so that a portal is also generated

@Der_Einzigwahre

6 ай бұрын

how to place it when you are in spectator?

@plighting_engineerd

6 ай бұрын

1. That only works in java 2. You can't get or place crystals in spectator

@Kyleplaysgames567

6 ай бұрын

@Der_Einzigwahre I don't know, but at least it would be a way to open the exit portal.

This is prolly the toughest challenge he had

Someone beat Minecraft in spectator mode! They used the 2023 AF snapshot and the celebrate voting thing to kill the ender dragon

@alexandredumas3384

2 ай бұрын

It was samswi

@maritoguionyo

21 күн бұрын

ez 500

Challenge suggestion: At the start of game use cheats to give yourself levitation 255, which puts you in a glitchy state where you don’t rise nor fall. This causes many issues, obviously the fact that raising or lower your vertical position is near impossible. But there are other issues such as difficulty picking up items (even if they’re right below you) and not being able to use the crafting table menu. You should title it “beating Minecraft while floating”

you can load 1.7.10, spectator mode was not yet available at that time, so you would be in an invalid gamemode, then load the world back in newer version and go into the portal like you did before

@J.T._Entertainment

5 ай бұрын

If you change gamemodes bc of a build can't register spectate and give you a mode that is, wouldn't it ruin the challenge if you can just force yourself to a competent mode?

@fr0ntend

2 ай бұрын

@@J.T._Entertainment That's kind of what he did in the superflat challange, so it's unclear if it breaks the rules, really

Can we agree that MudFlaps is a huge sweat. But all jokes aside I love a good MudFlaps video

Torches, signs, and chests are all tile entities, which are different than traditional entities. Entities and Tile Entities have some overlaps (such as with item frames); however, an item drop is very different than a chest.

@kwak0

6 ай бұрын

Are torches tile entities? Because the wiki doesn't say so, and they also don't really do anything other than emit light.

@HimitsuYami

5 ай бұрын

Torches are not tile entities. You can tell cus they have no data other than where they're placed and how they're oriented. Same applies to redstone torches too. Signs are tile entities because of the extra text they store. Chests are because of all the items. Same for furnaces. And anything else with an inventory that isn't a proper entity like a mob or dropped item.

@MudFlaps Have you heard of the 22w13oneBlockAtATime update? At the End Endermen will spawn with all sorts of blocks, including rare and illegal blocks like gateways which lead back to the overworld.

Mud never fails to entertain. He doesn't pay, but he is a funny boss to have.

@agentk677

6 ай бұрын

Do I know you?

@dtuberkid7920

6 ай бұрын

@@agentk677 i dont care

@Jzombi301

3 ай бұрын

wdym he "doesn't pay"?

Tip: When the dragon dies load your world in 1.20 so it might be helpful

Oh this is cool!! Epic video and enjoyed your take on it. Also ngl when you asked for my help in discord I just thought you were some casual player looking on how to beat it. Didn’t expect you were a content creator. Epic video tho!!!

If you watch older videos and start watching newer and newer videos you will see the quality of the editing go up. Keep up the great content!

winning in spectator mode is basically backseat gaming

@sillymanstudiosgames

5 ай бұрын

spectator mode = confirmed Freddy???

This man went through the whole hero’s journey

Bro this channel is SO UNDERRATED

Muddy chicken flaps really out did him self all though i liked fried chickens boiled in a pan

@Fireplush_

6 ай бұрын

Whaaaaaaat?

0:56 best edit

0:43 My obscure Minecraft knowledge compells me to let you know the Ender Dagon is canonically female. And may or may not be named Jean, depending on who you ask.

Albert Einstein once said, “The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.” Mud, you're insane. But I enjoyed the video, so thank you. Good job

What the fudge got me, thanks mud for not saying IT.

Mud flaps next video: I beat minecraft without playing it.

@klems7308

Ай бұрын

Actually possible with endermens, lit end portal and woodland mansion with tnt

@user-ji3yk3my2j

7 күн бұрын

@@klems7308yes

Truly one of the videos ever made.

@rapidtechhelp4508

Ай бұрын

indeed it was

There is a setting in some server consoles by which spectators can generate chunks maybe its in java too

1:41 best ASMR

It is done. Samswi beat it

Samswi be doing this one

I was happy when I was there the first time watching his stream. And honestly it was hilarious and it hurts my brain while trying to think. I WAS THERE MUD FLAPS. 🤪

This video is a masterpiece. 👌

Can the end gate things send you back to the overworld if there's no portal on the end island yet? I know they normally teleport you back to the main island, but it's worth a shot.

In fact, going back is very simple, as long as you go deep enough into the void (I'm not sure now, the previous version had the observer mode, and as long as you go to a very deep void, the actual blood volume will be deducted. It seems that it is twice the depth at which the blood deduction starts in survival mode or At a deeper level, just like creating will cause void death, the creative mode has health, but because the character obtains the "invicible" tag, it cannot receive damage, and the void does not belong to entity damage, it is the same damage as the "kill" command Type (I completely discovered it before, but it may be that I recorded the creative mode's blood deduction as observer mode)

@HimitsuYami

5 ай бұрын

Unfortunately, while that would get you back to the overworld, it wouldn't help as it doesn't give you the credits.

I have a theory: You first need to get to the end like u did in the video, then after u change ur versions so that dragon is killed, before going to the last version make sure to stand right in the exit portal. After you update ur game you can see that dragon health doesnt dissapear immidiatley. This is cuz minecraft needs a few secs to load all of the stuff cuz u were going troght alot of version, so before updating to the final version stand right in the exit portal. After u update the exit portal will be lit for a second or two, but this only works if u are standing right in the exit portal, so after u update the last time, u shoud be greeted with a credits screen :)

Can someone stop him pllllllz 😂😂 Crazy guy ❤ I didn't even watch the video yet 😂

>I Beat Minecraft in Spectator Mode >Look inside >He didn't

4:02 torch is a block entity, end crystal is an entity.

@Hlebuw3k

6 ай бұрын

torch is not even an entity of any kind its just a wonky block

@yaldamasevpro4862

6 ай бұрын

@@Hlebuw3k its a block entity

Everyone: *dies and deletes world* Mud flaps: *dies* it seems my journey has only just begun!

this is why Bedrock and Java different bedrock is so much more beefy

if you use a TAS you can get to the open end portal before the dragon spawns in. maybe figure out a way to get to the portal before dragon spawns without TAS

I think this content is better that 100 days

@skeleton819

6 ай бұрын

thats a fact

This is the most coolest video I love your content!

@danialfarooq5314

6 ай бұрын

U have to watch it first yk

@Shawn_546

6 ай бұрын

@@danialfarooq5314 huh? I already watched it😐

@danialfarooq5314

6 ай бұрын

In 13 seconds? U commented before watching it 😶

Fun fact if you spectate a mob it will move it self so if it go through the portal you will also go through at once

The only way I can see this happening is a combination of "beating Minecraft without the player" and the end portal glitch. The thing is, that is so unlikely you will never do it.

@SyntheticNuclear

6 ай бұрын

Don't endermen attack the dragon if provoked? If RNG, and enough enedermen are aggro and hit it, it will eventually die from damage.

@katieg1071

6 ай бұрын

​@@SyntheticNuclearAs I understand it, Endermen aggro on the Dragon when she hits them with her attacks. If she doesn't see a valid player (for example, if you're in Creative Mode), she won't attack. So unless I'm wrong, with the rules stating only one player is allowed, this one's a bust. 😔

@akitteninabowl8872

5 ай бұрын

@@SyntheticNuclear They can't hit the dragon even when perching

What next? Beat minecraft while being blindfolded and being able to only move backwards

Yayyyyyyyyy love your videos!!!❤

love that little animations in the video

torches aren't entities! they're blocks that give off particles (particles aren't entities, despite moving). I don't think the shaft of the torch even uses the entity render path, unlike some other blocks like chests and banners and probably a few others that I'm forgetting

Question. Why you not make an challenge like escaping the nether to over world without resource and only by help of nether mobs?

@lukasmalmborg785

6 ай бұрын

That is too easy

@epicdeltadustsans9269

6 ай бұрын

@@lukasmalmborg785 oh really? Being on nether only food is by killing peglen or that large pig that already hard in fact you dont have any wood to work and two nether place has wood also the only tools you can craft (even if you get wood) is only wooden wopean and stone wopean and gold its hard some youtuber did it in two damn month 😱

@lukasmalmborg785

6 ай бұрын

@@epicdeltadustsans9269 just make a firechargr and go to a ruined portal

@iamnotpeterson8385

6 ай бұрын

me when mushroom stew: me when diamonds from bastion and fortress:

@Anupamprime

6 ай бұрын

​@@epicdeltadustsans9269You Can get wood in the nether easily from nether trees & Black stone can be used to make stone tools... And broken nether portals already exist in the nether & You can find obsidian everywhere in the nether + Flint and steel is also found in fortress... So you can indeed beat the game from the nether

Well the condition is to enter the credits portal as spectator so. You can do a normal run, jump in the void, get spectator, swap to the other version to enter as spectaror and redo the same thing for the credits

Arrow of judgement returned to sender THATS MUDFLAPS FOR YOU

Seems like there was a glitch that automatically activated the portal. Like you go into the end and jean is dead with exit open.

Can the void kill spectator players? Or was there an April fools update that got you back to the overworld if you fall? Then maybe there's a version in which if it doesn't detect a dragon it assumes you beat it when you reenter the end

@sandwichqueen

6 ай бұрын

Or endermen can damage the dragon? Or maybe the hugs and love April fools update might do something weird

@kyzerbuhnzi6403

6 ай бұрын

mobs can only damage the dragon in really old versions

@IvanoktVan

6 ай бұрын

​@@kyzerbuhnzi6403creepers still can damage it with explosion. But creepers don't spawn in the end :

Ok so, I think you need to find a seed that specifically contains and ID of a dying dragon. So, for example seed A contains 2 types of dragon, 1) Dragon Alive = dragon1.json and 2) Dragon Dying = dragon2.json. So when you change the version to seed B, you have to make sure that the dragon alive contains the file = dragon2.json, so when you change for the third time to seed A, it recognize immediately the file dragon as the dying version of that seed and technically you killed the dragon and finished the game. BUUUTTT This leads to 3 main problems, 1. Finding that specific combination of root files from the different versions 2. Containing a Complete Portal 3. Been close to that portal. That's my theory :3 Not even going to attempt it but it should work

9:27 you can enable chunk loading with a game rule I think, I might be wrong but I think there is a game rule called "spectators_generate_chunks" or something

Can You Acually Like Your Own Comment? (yes, you can)

@anushaZulfiqar

6 ай бұрын

Yes

@bigmobman4747

6 ай бұрын

🤖

@MrY7zz

6 ай бұрын

🤖

@WoolHat730

6 ай бұрын

Nobody asked

@charlieleseman7847

6 ай бұрын

@@WoolHat730 Be nice Wool hat.

Hi I saw a video that said when you that go o the end in 1.12 then switch to 14w05a and then 1.9 to trap and deafeat the dragon and go to the portal and switch back to 14.w05a and then go through it also sorry I don’t have Java edition so can please test it to see if it does.(video was from @FlareD_shorts)

@Luke_Clarke

6 ай бұрын

Ok

@Luke_Clarke

6 ай бұрын

What ur bedrock username?

@Luke_Clarke

6 ай бұрын

Mine is Eli35641

@octaviomolina-fu3cd

6 ай бұрын

Mine is WeGamer987

The editing is top tier

A man of culture drinking the blue ICE. such an underrated drink.

There is a way to spawn the exit portal without killing the dragon, but it requires placing an end crystal before the dragon is loaded in (this takes ~1 second), which tricks the game into spawning an exit portal for some reason. However this most likely isn't viable for this challenge; you can't place blocks, and you've already probably spent too much time in the end for this to work. It's a cool exploit tho!

@huuue_

6 ай бұрын

This was proably patched.

Didn't you get enough from trying beating the game from the void😑

7:45 i remember this from some random hardcore video where they used that to change the version and not corrupt their chunks and looser newer items and blocks or something

Now this is insane! 😆

In version 1.5.2 there was a bug that caused all monsters to die instantly! When you're at the end, set the world to version 1.5.2! Then enter the world again! The dragon dies! While the dragon dies, you should change the version back to 1.5.2 so that a portal is also generated

@ZeliotL

6 ай бұрын

it would've worked if spectator mode was available back in that version

@LineOfThy

5 ай бұрын

@@ZeliotL goddamit

Why is this video named I beat minecraft in spectator mode? You TRIED to beat minecraft in spectator mode

GREAT choice of hoodie

I've got an idea. Creepers could end up going through the end portal, either through walking into it or being bumped into it by other mobs. Then, when you go through the end portal, the ender dragon could hit creepers, causing them to aggro on the ender dragon. The creepers would then go to the ender dragon when it is perching and explode, which would deal damage to it. The ender crystals could be dealt with by skeletons, which could get into the end the same way as the creepers, and they could then get hit by the ender dragon, causing them to start attacking it, at which point missed shots aimed at the ender dragon could hit the crystals. The ender dragon could then be killed by a combination of the creepers exploding and end crystals exploding. The skeletons would be unable to kill the end dragon on their own due to how the ender dragon only takes damage from explosions and the players, thus necessitating the creepers. This would, to the best of my knowledge, work. However it would require ludicrous luck. If you are able to return to the overworld and go through the portal again without causing the ender dragon to disappear or heal to full or causing the crystals to respawn this would make it far easier, due to you being able to have more creepers travel through.

Bedrock players

@Ripudaman_gaming

17 күн бұрын

Here

@olgagorinova6457

4 күн бұрын

I'm ready to spam click with you boys

Every like this comment gets ill do a push up (litteraly)

@MMonkeyMannn

Ай бұрын

Get bro to 1000 pushups and post it

@unaha1185

Ай бұрын

You goddamn lucky

@ucn_maki

Ай бұрын

My highest push up is 37 lol

@malvusverse

28 күн бұрын

mortis

@fedymunke8684

25 күн бұрын

Do 46 if u did not already

really well-made video!

“No” *Sees that it is Mud Flaps* “Well, I guess it is possible(Proberly)”

I liked my own comment

@taigafrost4936

Ай бұрын

And?

@achergamez9679

Ай бұрын

@@taigafrost4936 and I liked my own comment and this one too

I liked my own comment.

@Dragonking-69

6 ай бұрын

Thanks fir honisty\

@Dragonking-69

6 ай бұрын

I also liked both of these replies

bruh when the plane crashed at 1:37 seconds i heard thunder. PERFECT TIMING

I was able to get to the overworld, but not actually encounter the end credit screen back to the drawing board

I liked my comment

@smokingralseyeh

Ай бұрын

Well done, I too did

@Conor-bz7fs

20 күн бұрын

I love orange

I liked my own comment 🎊

@abcdefzhij

6 ай бұрын

Pabislarity!! Hahaha

@randomaccount550

6 ай бұрын

stop begging for likes

when ur in the end , go in 1.9 version then go back to 14w05 version and take thrown end pearls when dragon accsidentaly killed endermans, then go in portal with end pearls .ur best and smartest minecraft gamer.hope this helps :)

I remember theres a version of the game that kills the dragon and spawns the portal without you doing anything

To get to the end of game screen all you have to do is wait for 20m to a 1h and the game will process that the dragon is dead and open the portal

Mudflaps underrated 🗿

Do it like that join world open settings and credits and you have it :D

Amazingly amazing.

This man is crazy!And this soo funny

bro was confused about two enderdragons spawning. I once had 5 spawned lol

I think I have an idea on how to the credits screen. idea: maybe u can use the same glitch that u used to get into the end portal and just use that same glitch to get to the credits screen maybe it will work idk

My brother, keep going, the best channel in the world😊😊

Stikin up the gyat for the rizzler

I think enderpearls and other throwables are entities so in theory you can kill the ender_dragon if the arrow your spectating is op enough?.

Love your vids

Only way i can see this working: Making a datapack that set you into Spectator, taking control of mobs acts as a morph mod, but no inventory, the coordinates of the portal are revealed, the portal is lit, the ender dragon's health is set to 0 upon touching end stone, and the final portal's lit tag is set to valid. Otherwise, changing versions shouldn't be a valid option. After all, there's no Herobrine in 1.20 so why should version changing be allowed?