听GALA要的就是：”没有技巧，全是感情“

@mosesjane9456

Жыл бұрын

hhhhhhhhhhhhh

@ianwang1792

Жыл бұрын

多一點技巧都唱不出這味。

@user-mu2jn4hm9u

Жыл бұрын

就是要破音这个味

@haitaohua3242

Жыл бұрын

@@user-mu2jn4hm9u 虽然他永远都唱不上那个key，但打死都不降key，宁愿走音嘶吼着也要追求“完美”的唱完，一遍又一遍，完美贴合歌词要表达的意境。（我实在编不下去了😂）

@user-jo7ug8ku2z

Жыл бұрын

会不会感情本来就是技巧的一部分，而且还非常重要

主唱就是和我们一样的普通人，也一样唱不到那么高的音，所以和我们一起共鸣，每次听到这首歌都会让我热泪盈眶，这就是歌颂鼓励普通人的歌曲，是写给我们的。大爱！

故事是，这个歌不是故意这么高的。那个Keyboard录完了还要去打工，于是他自己先录了一轨。因为他们付不起两次录音费用，所以其他人只能硬着头皮将就已经录好的部分。GALA的口号是，可以破音，不能降调。没有比这更摇滚的事情了。

@leemav5136

11 ай бұрын

😂😂😂从此一辈子破嗓了

@how_do_you_turn_this_on

10 ай бұрын

笑死了

@pengxiao7415

10 ай бұрын

可以破音可以降调，可以不破音不降调，可以一切。

@Elon1musk2

9 ай бұрын

​@@pengxiao7415你是听不懂人话吗？他说了当时没钱录第二次

@user-xj1je5tz2c

8 ай бұрын

冥冥中自有天意。这首歌唯有唱出破音才能表现出中华民族筚路蓝缕的开拓历程与无所畏惧的的抗争精神。

這真的是一種氣場，他就是有那個搖滾的態度、歌聲裡有一股直率的真誠，很莫名的就會被打動。

@heyunlong9382

Жыл бұрын

摇滚不摇滚无所谓，什么是摇滚也无所谓。

@user-ph4cq6nj2p

Жыл бұрын

这是感情 歌唱源头就是感情的抒发 明显这一首就是 如同陕西信天游也是一种

@qufeiji3828

Жыл бұрын

就是很想跟着一起跳，一起乐

@ceciliahou3991

Жыл бұрын

著名的暖场乐队，Gala

作为一位80后，每次听这首歌都热泪盈眶，我想起了青春，想起了以前的梦想，想起了曾经的经历。尽管我并没有歌词里那么勇敢，但我向往《追梦赤子心》所崇尚的价值观

@JoeCreator

Жыл бұрын

谢谢看到了我的视频！😁

@pl7603

Жыл бұрын

同为80后，每次听到这道歌才感觉自己心中还有梦想

@jinniwind

Жыл бұрын

每个人心里都有一个少年

@seabraes213

Жыл бұрын

@@JoeCreator可以试试夜空中最亮的星吗？another moving song

@chenliang6479

Жыл бұрын

第二国歌

I can't believe I heard this song in 2023 for the first time. I love it and it keeps me crying when I hear it.......such a great song,great lyrics

每次听到这首歌总是能热泪盈眶，一身鸡皮疙瘩

所有藝術及表演說到最後，感動人心的永遠是裏面的真摯情感。

听过翻唱的版本，还是喜欢GALA原唱。他们将这种即使生活并不完美，却依然对理想满怀热忱的渴望表达得极为充分，会让每个人看到那个曾经为梦想无所畏惧的自己，从而完成一次对自我的审视

@user-dv6dw1uk6m

Жыл бұрын

我在2020的武汉明白了这首歌的含义。许多的年轻人在我采访时告诉我：他们可能会死，但是他们就是不服气，就是想干一场。

@feiyang2041

Жыл бұрын

和他们讲道理，他们拔枪；和他们拔枪，他们说你不讲道理。

@vincentdavinci9598

Жыл бұрын

kzread.info/dash/bejne/omR1xM6OZ7ixl9Y.html 这个版本听过吗?

@TW_Kaputt

11 ай бұрын

@@vincentdavinci9598 這版本就是唱得太好了 而GALA那種声嘶力竭的破音 既使沒有天分，也要一往無前的熱血 更契合歌詞中的態度

@user-fn7fd9zk3i

11 ай бұрын

@@vincentdavinci9598 这首歌最大的魅力就是后面的破音呀

gala in giving us the feeling that they represent ordinary people, ordinary people who can't sing, ordinary people who have dreams, and although we are afraid and shy, they have worked hard for us to stand in front of the stage.

苏朵每次现场都会有着跟上一场不一样的跑调和破音，但奇妙的是这完全不影响他要传达的积极的欢乐的情绪。在循规蹈矩的社会，我觉得我们需要他。

@dangale2029

10 ай бұрын

你成功让我哈哈哈哈了😂😂每次都有不同的破音……

这个曲子如果用了技巧，没有破音没有错误那就是唱错了。要的就是声嘶力竭全力以赴。

@user-jo7ug8ku2z

Жыл бұрын

调写高了没有钱重新录😢

@user-xs9hi8et8g

Жыл бұрын

@@user-jo7ug8ku2z这才能成为经典，

@duoyanwei6789

Жыл бұрын

录制的时候调起高了 就凑合录下去了 想重新录又没钱😂

@cjkl1317

Жыл бұрын

就是up说的，一种完美的巧合，全力以赴不怕不完美也是歌曲里面要表达的精神

@ouo5515

Жыл бұрын

他其實是錄製的時候起高了沒錢重錄......

About 12 years ago, shortly after graduating from college, I was working alone in Beijing. Renting a very small apartment with a few young strangers like me, I spent 4 hours a day on my way to work and back home. After paying my monthly salary for rent, transportation and food, there was nothing left. It was the hardest time in my life and that song "zhui meng chi zi xin" accompanied me for countless nights of trying to work overtime and it encouraged me to keep going. Now my life has gotten better and I'm a little older. This song still moves me, and there are still young people like the person I once was who are inspired by it. THANKS GALA！

@JoeCreator

Жыл бұрын

Very inspiring story! I'm glad you are now doing much better 🙏

@sir-nk2pj

Жыл бұрын

@@JoeCreator Thanks. for me, the first song, more than graduation or struggle. He sang with all his might, he knew he couldn't do it but did it, likes everyone's youth that used to run

@peterchan6430

Жыл бұрын

和我一样，我是2012年，听这首歌，毕业去上海，租狭窄的小公寓。

@dsyy1000

Жыл бұрын

我初中毕业以后一直创业到今天，也是一路这样走来，确实人生需要努力和拼搏，听唱的歌曲会让你有对过去的回忆

In my recollection, this song gained immense popularity in 2015 when the anime "Those Things About That Rabbit That Year," also known as "Year Hare Affair," was aired. It served as the closing theme for the first season, accompanying a captivating slideshow showcasing numerous renowned and lesser-known patriots from China's modern history spanning the last century. Just a basic knowledge of that historical period is enough to evoke a profound emotional response, bringing tears to the eyes of those who witness this poignant scene. Consequently, a significant number of individuals have embraced and familiarized themselves with this song. Often, the true allure of a melody lies in its ability to strike a chord with the most fundamental human sentiments. In addition, I heard that Joe is interested in China and Chinese, you can watch this animation "Year Hare Affair", short and vivid.

这就是音乐的另一种魅力，即使没有浮夸的技巧，甚至还有破音，但都不能阻止它成为一首很棒的歌曲，被这情感和非常热血向上的价值观感动到，同时感谢Joe带来精彩又中肯的乐评。

这首歌最迷人的恰恰是除旋律之外的所有东西，唱的走调的声音，近乎嘶哑的破音，不在拍子上的所有演奏者，但是这就是少年的人生呀，不完美但是竭尽全力的呐喊，不怕指摘，不怕嘲笑，不惧困难，不在意所有的不完美，一个唱完这首“不完美”的歌的恒心 这是所有赤子之心的中国人的最好写照 也是依旧年轻的中国的最好写照

@user-bo7mm5uo6q

Жыл бұрын

完全同意，就是奔跑，摔跤了也就拍拍灰继续

@athbe1337

Жыл бұрын

不在拍子上有点说过分了哈

Everytime i heard the first song, my eyes run over with tears. You can’t image it is how popular and powerful to Chinese youth people. for most people after all, there always a moment, you wanna hold faith or dream regardless of fight to the world. By the way, Midi is a big old music festival.

Every time hear this song, my tear drops.

真的很喜欢Joe，真的特别真诚，而且能够包容各种的情绪，而不是趾高气扬的在judge

Love this! Sometimes a song transcends the sum of its parts, because it has true heart. And you can feel that here. Great to see a band step away from seeking perfection and just believe in what they do.

Dude, for the first song, It means so much more than the its lyric and melody to the Chinese youth right now. literally. it is the 'Online National Anthem' for the Chinese youth for about the recent decade.

😂确实很高，传闻是GALA当时录音时给人的谱子放错了，高了一个调，录完之后没有钱负担再录一遍，就只能拼老命唱高调😅

@lawcoscare5097

Жыл бұрын

真的吗😂，好有喜感❤

@user-zk8to1jh3v

Жыл бұрын

其实是他们去作曲的时候调就高了，然后那时候gala乐队没有余钱再去改谱作新的了，主唱就没辙就用这版谱子硬着头皮往上顶，结果无心插柳柳成荫了😂

@user-jo7ug8ku2z

Жыл бұрын

@@lawcoscare5097 毕竟一个专业乐队都不希望出现破音跑调

@how_do_you_turn_this_on

10 ай бұрын

​@@user-jo7ug8ku2z 聽這首歌就是為了聽到破音的

@Guozhenjun

9 ай бұрын

完美的错误

This song lifts up my spirit every time when I listen to it! Heads up guys!

Thanks, Joe, yes,the emotional music is good to cry for. That’s the light of life. It’s not in my graduation but, hope those young people enjoy the tear moments they would encounter❤

不仅是唱法，这首歌的歌词也写的非常好。 我曾经因为很大的打击，抑郁痛苦，想过自杀，感觉无法继续下去了。后来坚持下来终于走出来重新起步。 “向前跑，迎着冷眼和嘲笑，生命的广阔不历经磨难怎能感到” 一次次绝望到找到新的希望，生命广阔到你永远可以找到新的值得追求的东西 “继续跑，带着赤子的骄傲，生命的闪耀不坚持到底怎能看到” 只有真正艰难的，无数次想要放弃又无数次坚持下来，才最终能看到生命的那种伟大的力量 这两句我感觉是非常深刻的

@Yaya-mt5cf

9 ай бұрын

GALA的這首歌很大一部份就是抄襲 「五月天」憨人中文版「鹹魚」這首歌的歌詞。這就是一首抄襲歌。

@sssal3914

9 ай бұрын

​@@Yaya-mt5cf呃你指的是“也许我没有天分，但我有梦的天真”这句吗

@chriswong5765

9 ай бұрын

@@Yaya-mt5cf旋律上完全不一樣，歌詞上的確有一句相似，但這樣不足以說是抄襲吧

@user-lm1zr7jg9r

7 ай бұрын

加油，生命本来就是一场斗争😊

@Gentlemiao

2 ай бұрын

@@Yaya-mt5cf 五月天真是惜字如金啊。14个字就是很大一部分了。

The best part is his attitude, like "I don't care if I am not good enough." 🤟

@nihijason9840

Жыл бұрын

i konw I'm not good enough，but i will burn myself 向前跑 迎着冷眼和嘲笑 生命的广阔不历经磨难怎能感到 命运它无法让我们跪地求饶 就算鲜血洒满了怀抱

@donglin1411

Жыл бұрын

@@nihijason9840 "迎着冷眼和嘲笑" Isn't it an original lyric from Beyond band?

Much appreciated that how much positive energy they give! Just smile naturally when the song starts

Hi Joe, thank you so much for your well made video! Keep up the good job!

Gala is definitely an interesting band, and the song "Young for you" gives me a comfortable feeling. I know their pronunciation may not be considered standard, but among many Chinese people born in the 80s and 90s, their pronunciation sounds like how ordinary people speak English in China, with a touch of clumsiness and humor. Perhaps this is one of the reasons why this song is popular. Just like he tried the high note, he tried to sing the whole song in English is the whole point lol. I can speak better English but I LOVE how he sings that song. Love your reactions and comments on them.

@turemanchina4091

Жыл бұрын

if they speak better english i think this song will not bring that much happy to the people they mean it song like this

I like your explanation about this songs. It really made me to understand the emotion of the song.

your interpretation of the song and the band is awesome!

Very touched, we are not in perfect life and a lot of circumstances but never give up, still keep chasing our dream and keep our heart pure. Even we have known that we could never on the top.

what a great song! thx for sharing this song :)

last part was awesome Master JOE❤

Joe, although he is an ordinary singer, but because of that. His lyrics and singing voice are more like ordinary us.

Love this song, some how found your channel, it’s brilliant. Keep it up!

听了一句就掉眼泪了，这首歌成功的地方就在于没有技巧全是感情

@M-A._.6.29

10 ай бұрын

一样一样，每次听都掉泪❤❤害得我都不敢轻易听，怕家人朋友看见以为发生什么大事😂

喜欢这首歌，每次都热泪盈眶。因为《那年那兔哪些事》，每一集都无法控制自己的情绪。

@karencho6819

9 ай бұрын

我四十几岁人，第一次看动画看到泪流满面，尤其抗美援朝和钱老回国，我要2天时间，情绪才援过来

@user-sr9kj8on7f

8 ай бұрын

每集都有泪点，志愿军遗骸回国时，那里真的哭出声了，我也快40了

其实有些歌曲不用很华丽，很完美，不过观众参与了，与观众有共鸣了，然后大合唱，演唱会就会变得很完美，也很圆满 Joe 分析的很合理，很到位，很严谨，不会夸大其词，解析的很好

完全没法想象我竟然第一次知道GALA是通过外国人的视频。这首歌我听了一遍竟然就哭了。歌词，情感太棒了。感同身受。

@user-su9ep9ze1n

Жыл бұрын

那是你可不包括我们

@user-ck9if3vz7h

Жыл бұрын

@@user-su9ep9ze1n 他也没说包括你啊

@user-su9ep9ze1n

Жыл бұрын

@@user-ck9if3vz7h 所以你可以靠边了

@emilygu2840

Жыл бұрын

​@@user-su9ep9ze1n 臆想啥呢

@user-kv9wn8ki6m

Жыл бұрын

这歌有年头了，还有 Young For You，他火起来并不是在乐坛，而是年轻人的群体，有些明星也翻唱过，但味道都差了一点 啊，我没有看到后边就回复了

thank you for sharing this. love it so much.

And once for a while I play "Young for you" on weekends. The song is really bright and reflects the relaxed and indulging heart.

@yvonne_gao

Жыл бұрын

🎉🎉🎉十几年前2004年我在收音机了听到young for you 我惊呆了，为什么没有很多人知道？这首歌快20年了

这首歌至今没有被任何人超越。原唱的破音才是灵魂

@china5169

11 ай бұрын

灵魂的呐喊

@Yaya-mt5cf

9 ай бұрын

這首歌抄襲五月天的地方也是靈魂。

@jinsongli3251

9 ай бұрын

​@@Yaya-mt5cf抄襲了五月天哪首歌？哪部分？能不能提供實質證據？

@barryhuang9496

9 ай бұрын

@@jinsongli3251咸鱼 就3句歌词几乎一样 论文查重都能过

@barryhuang9496

9 ай бұрын

@@jinsongli3251不是这首是追梦赤子心

This is my favourite song that I would not tired of❤❤❤ I often sing this song in front of my family, and whenever I get to the chorus, I always get very excited, and that's why I like this song, because it gives me a kind of fervent, inspiring power to go forward. In addition to this song, this band's other songs are also worth listening to.anyway,GALA YYDS!!!

Yes, Joe, after these Gala songs, I believe that we can find out bueaties from everyone's voice and the unique way they sing, melody and skill are good salt and pepper in food, but the meat is where the food is from. Please sing more and loud!

it was around 13 years ago GALA was interviewed by a radio program talking why the key was unnaturally high that his voice range cannt reach, the host of the show (and including everyone i supposed) thought this was composed on purpose in order to deliver the msg of never giving up and trying harder, but their answer was hilarious: they found that too high after its been made but they were too poor(not famous yet) to afford another hour for hiring the studio in which such flaw made it a masterpiece...God was really helping them

@dylanzhang1641

Жыл бұрын

lol

Joe, you are a gem.

@JoeCreator

Жыл бұрын

Aww thankyou 😄

前几天在b站看了这一期，现在在油管又刷到了。很巧的是看b站那天正在经历一些迷茫，听到这个瞬间觉得我又行了哈哈哈哈哈，顺带一提，九爷的分析完全就是观众的嘴替。感谢九爷这一期节目❤ 有些人说这是网络红歌，但是每个人听这首歌都有心中所想，它只是一首歌，每个人都有自己的解读。我尊重祖国解放军，但是我希望有些人不要说它是什么什么，不要定义它，请让它变成无色彩的歌才能赋予它更多的意义。

Joe对young for you还是挺客气的，吹的都是感情。gala的歌还是有时代背景，当年听的时候好笑又感动，一点儿不违和，现在的小朋友大概是感受不到这种淳朴了。

十年前大一暑假作为工作人员去音乐节舞台下面听过他们，现场太好了，本来还预约了采访他们，但是可惜他们临时有事溜了。音乐节有挺多没太大名气但是很不错的音乐人。

@sym3086

Жыл бұрын

7,8年前在LA听过一次他们的现场，真的完全相反，现场唱的很烂，不知道是那天状态不行还是现场就那样。

@noobhunter9582

11 ай бұрын

@@sym3086 林俊杰的现场好是说唱功好，GALA的现场好只能是氛围好😂这首歌给他们唱现场估计就是顶上去一句，剩下的瞎喊，或者交给观众。没办法，毕竟GALA是一个开除了主唱就能火爆全宇宙的乐队

wow，joe, the last part is AWESOME!!!!

gala真的是一股精神氮泵，学生时代参加运动会的当天早上，尤其是参加长跑项目，一定要听。。那你即使累哭了都可以跑完全程

@M-A._.6.29

10 ай бұрын

对，就是特别能鼓励我们这些普通人

这首歌可不仅仅是毕业歌，也不仅仅是年轻人追求理想的呐喊，它还被誉为中国年轻人的网络版国歌，了解中国历史就会明白这首歌的意义，这种面对困境不妥协的坚韧精神，正是我们的信仰。 向前跑 迎着冷眼和嘲笑 生命的广阔不历经磨难怎能感到 命运它无法让我们跪地求饶 就算鲜血洒满了怀抱 充满鲜花的世界到底在哪里 如果它真的存在那么我一定会去 我想在那里最高的山峰矗立 不在乎它是不是悬崖峭壁 用力活着用力爱哪怕肝脑涂地 不求任何人满意只要对得起自己 关于理想我从来没选择放弃 即使在灰头土脸的日子里 向前跑 迎着冷眼和嘲笑 生命的广阔不历经磨难怎能感到 命运它无法让我们跪地求饶 就算鲜血洒满了怀抱 继续跑 带着赤子的骄傲 生命的闪耀不坚持到底怎能看到 与其苟延残喘不如纵情燃烧吧 为了心中的美好 不妥协直到变老

@allenpitt5906

Жыл бұрын

赤子，这个词用英文没有直接对应的翻译

@joynikk8709

Жыл бұрын

new born 我记得好像是

@xworld021

Жыл бұрын

​@@joynikk8709 赤子在这里可以理解为纯真、勇敢、坚韧、善良、忠诚的少年或人民，而不单单是新生儿，对应的是母亲，比如母校、祖国母亲。 Brave, strong, innocent, kind, and loyal people 中文很多词在不同意境下有不同内涵，直译肯定无法准确表达，实在要想用单词来翻译，我觉得the people或utter innocence相对准确些。

@joynikk8709

Жыл бұрын

@@xworld021 你说的那些品质，本来就是刚出生，赤条条的婴孩的特点。只不过现在被西方文化洗脑，大家都觉得刚出生的孩子是最弱，最啥都不是的。其实不然，我们的文化里，赤子来自于阴，叫做阴中赤子，和阳里黑子对应的。赤子代表的就是纯阳，纯阳不用我说了吧，和你说的那些道德类形容词都是一回事。new born可不是单纯的新生儿的意思，我记得这个词我好像是从宗教连续剧里看的，本来就和我们传统文化的纯阳之体一个意思。

@karimbinfuadalibrahim7180

Жыл бұрын

​@xianren zhao 是活用够多

This song is pure raw emotion. The moment you use any singing technique to hit the high notes pitch perfect, you instantly lose the magic of this song. 必须呐喊，必须破音，必须筋疲力尽！

這首歌，真的讓九爺跟著一起被歌詞的情緒渲染 如何讓聆聽者深深感應到的情緒，化繁為簡，不完美其實真的很完美，因為有深切地歌詞

喬，你能想像嗎？我聽到第一首歌，我真的想哭，50歲了，因為我很喜歡我兔，20歲也當過解放軍，也很愛中國歷史。－聽到我就想到50年

@user-zs9ge5io1m

Жыл бұрын

同样的感动，我45岁

@user-zw4zk7vh8x

Жыл бұрын

35也一样

@samguochen7588

Жыл бұрын

向老兵致敬！！！

You are right, we love his confidence. He will do it, even if he is not good, also he has nothing to hide. You know some chinese do speek english like this. In the past, if you speek english like this, people will loughat you, but nowadays if you speek like this they will thing you are a simple a good guy.

每晚下班回家練吉他時，必須先彈唱追夢赤子心這首歌作為預熱，1方面是時間還早，叫起來不會有人投訴🤣，其次是C#5是我能吼的最高音了。😂這首歌能源源不斷的帶給我練吉他的動力。

The song really is simple, but this simplicity is amazingly consistent with the message it tries to deliver (the lyrics). It is about the simple young men who are simple enough to believe in dreams. The highest pitch the singer wasn't able to reach, is just like the dreams that would never come true - but young folks will still go after it, knowing they are likely to fail. It takes courage to fail, but they are young, so they can afford. The song is not sophisticated and not perfect but very genuine, just like people at their early 20s. I guess this is why it got so popular in college students.

Because in China the Graduation Ceremony always comes BEFORE the final examination...like before 100 days around xd. So students are easily to get inspired by this song with full of hopeness, and it makes you brave to do your best in the last days. With such a fierce competition, senior school students at grade 3 are told to do nothing but study for enrolled by a better university, so this song does really movivate us.

Apart from singing skills, these two songs can touch our true emotions. I think this is the most essential meaning of music.

The first song, "Chasing Dreams with childlike Heart," is also used as a song to support the college entrance examination in Taizhou City, Jiangsu Province. Taizhou is a small city in central Jiangsu Province, and it’s where I’m from

@ligoo-my5pp

7 ай бұрын

我是靖江的 哈哈 在这边刷掉老乡

感謝介紹這麼年輕有活力的表演! 真情演出! 讓我想起年輕時的陳昇！

Everyone fighting for their dreams will love this song

It’s so true. Even he knew he couldn’t get that high but he still tried. This is exactly this song is telling.

you got the point here. You can sing this song until it goes off key, but absolutely cannot lower the key.

I dont know GALA and music😂,but it is easy for me 2 remember their songs even the singer's voice 😏, cuz the emotion I heard is very direct, it is easy to be infected and resonate at once❤

Dude! I got a exam tomorrow 😂 haha ! It is nice to watch your videos before exam

@JoeCreator

Жыл бұрын

Good luck!!!

@user-fm3qg5bz6k

Жыл бұрын

@@JoeCreator Thank you! I just received my exam result. I passed 🎉

@JoeCreator

Жыл бұрын

@@user-fm3qg5bz6k congratulations 🎉🎉

Do the best what you can, be yourself! !

With this song I finished my first Marathon.

Thumb up for your performance 😊

8:11 You definitely got the idea, is imperfection.

Because you must keep running,for the sake of your future life and dreams in your heart!

I recommend almost all songs from them. Their albums are the kind that one can enjoy from the intro till the last song. As you said, they are not perfect in any aspect of their music, but the passion that they put into it just makes everyone resonate.

这首歌就像年轻的新中国，什么都没有，不怕失败，永不屈服，朝着有光的地方跑去。

音乐无国界，你是真的懂音乐的，因为你说你要哭的那几句歌词，我也是在那个时候掉眼泪了😭。👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻，关注你这么久果然没错

看了你好几个视频。真的很棒，你能很好的感受到歌曲里的东西，而且很真诚。

Love to hear your professional perspective! BTW, some UK accents are the killer. It takes a while to understand.

to be honest, the very first time I know this bank was in 2006 or even earlier, I wouldn't say I like their melody, I could even feel the vocalist's pitch is wrong. but, but I really like them, like you said, their emotion was really deep and they sing hard.

喜欢Joe的感同身受地说出我们听歌的感觉，很细腻的感觉和变化都能指出，🎉🎉。🤔️听joe分享 朴树的《平凡之路》《那些花儿》

totally agree that you should go live for this band because their beauty is they can't sing one song the same every time, the voice cracks or emotional things are very different from time to time and they can't control it, I think it's their special thing that I don't see in any other professional bands...

這首歌真的是我最愛的歌之一 如此的純粹感人激勵人心 就是沒有技巧 才能完美詮釋這首歌的意義

我也是越來越喜歡Joe的真情流露的評論影片..常常重複看.喜歡Joe很願意學習中文.很認真的樣子.希望他能多發點影片.愛看~

平凡人奋斗而不平凡，这首歌是出现在那兔那年那些事的片尾曲😊

@lemonchaos5671

Жыл бұрын

把这个歌毁了。。。。。不知道被解放军的坦克碾的时候还能不能唱的出来😂

@unl3569

Жыл бұрын

@@lemonchaos5671 撵你的时候 肯定可以撒

音乐本来的意义就是表达人的情感，我觉得这首歌真的完美诠释了这一点。它没有很好的技巧，但让我感同身受

Every time I listen to it, I cry

I also like this song very much, not because of how powerful the lead singer is, but because the lyrics of this song can drive people's emotions, make people brave, positive, and yearn for beauty, I like it very much.

I've been listening to recently. It's a very distinctive song.

这首歌我第一次听就热泪盈眶。特别是它作为动画片《那年那兔那些事》的片尾曲，很好地贴合了中华民族（种花家）一路走来的艰辛与蓬勃的生命力。这首歌真的很棒！

@zxsong

Жыл бұрын

听一次哭一次

@binzhao2312

Жыл бұрын

不是中华儿女，是没有那种感觉的

@user-xq5oq3nd6j

Жыл бұрын

没看过那兔，没那么强国家荣誉感的人听不出那种心痛和声嘶力竭的，其实一路走来，太不容易了。

@arthurhuang7491

Жыл бұрын

@@user-xq5oq3nd6j 可以看看，挺好看的

@noneone3310

Жыл бұрын

我听的时候也是不由自主就想到我们祖国，因为歌词里面的这种顽强不屈，我自己没有做到……但所有这些，祖国都做到了，近代史以来到今天，兔兔那么那么难，但是兔兔真的做到了啊，这么多前辈们，他们做到了啊

“a perfect coincidence”, you can never put it better. such is a life worth living.

the lyrics show all attitude that people should have, especially for the young generation who is still quite uncertained with their decision and future. Fight hard and stay positive, that's what we all can do.

this song so great not only because it's emotional, but the path of this country walked, and walking so hard....

可以的話還是希望Joe聽一下專輯版的，Live版本真的是只剩感情😂

I went to their live once, and that was a moment I felt I was truly alive, and I cried. Life's been hard, and there's so much pressure and unintended stuff happens every day. Sometimes you just need a moment to release yourself. As a typical Chinese, I have typical Asian parents. Not exactly like other Western people's stereotypes of Asian parents, they've never said I want you to be the best at this or that. But they always ask you, did you try your best. It sounds alright, but I always felt maybe I was just not trying hard enough, and I don't want to let them down. Here is where much pressure for young Chinese comes from. It can be indirectly from your peers or parents, but primarily from yourself. And those emotions can be hidden pretty deep, since Chinese people tend not to express their emotions that directly. Surely, young people need such a way to scream out, to truly be themselves. And their performances and live for the first song definitely did that. I believe the reasons for this song to be so touching can really differ from person to person, but the way they perform and the lyrics surely let people find their own reflection somehow, with the screams and shouts. These are all the emotions that can be expressed and reconciled with yourself somehow.

这首歌必须配那兔才有灵魂！“不能哭，眼泪也会冻住的。”

I literally cried listening to the first song.

5:56 exactly like what's in the lyrics, he maynot gonna make it, but he is going for it anyway

How can you not love the emotion they put in, and the lyrics are also very emotional.

cause it’s the song of always being young ,of acting like you are young forever. We will all miss our youth😂 of all time

young for u 是年轻时的每一个欢乐的回声，赤子心是每一次失落后重新振作的力量源泉