An excellent overview. I've just acquired a Cannondale Synapse road bike that has been modified with a straight handlebar to make it slightly 'hybrid' for a more comfortable riding position. The Brooks saddle was intended to be a gift to myself and a show of commitment to getting out more. Your wise words have now convinced me that it is the right thing. Many thanks. Dave in Yorkshire, England.

I have a bog standard saddle on my AWOL and was looking to get a new saddle, your here video was the final nail in the coffin to go out and get one of these. Thanks.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

6 жыл бұрын

Glad to help. Thanks for visiting! -Scott

Fantastic review, bang on too! Coming from an owner of 7 bike, 5 of them have Brooks saddles, waiting for a raise to equip the remaining bikes with Brooks saddles!

I had a B17 on my touring bike when I was in my late teens and early 20's. I'm soon 65 and just bought my second B17. I have it on my retro hybrid bike - it was comfortable from the first moment (do follow the instructions on break-in). It looks the business and feels great. And when you think that it's for life (if you're smart enough to transfer it to your newer bikes) then it's a bargain. A more expensive quality long-lived product will save you money in the end. All the best from Switzerland, Rob

@CaptainOverpackerRides

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks for sharing your experience!

@gustavochiozza6465

3 жыл бұрын

RobWhittlestone Could you explain for me the break-in instructions? Thanks!

@RobWhittlestone

3 жыл бұрын

@@gustavochiozza6465 Apply the supplied leather treatment to both sides, wait 24 hours for it to soak in and not leave a greasy surface. Done! The saddle is already surprisingly comfortable despite its appearance to the contrary. And it jusz keeps getting better. Many people transfer their existing Brooks saddle to a new bike to keep enjoying the comfort.

Put mine on today and expected the break-in to be a painful but necessary evil. I was amazed at how comfortable it was and rode 62 miles before I called it good. The nice thing is.....I know it's only going to get better! WOOT WOOT! Love the sweet 17.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

9 жыл бұрын

twotwentyswift - Very nice! I found mine to be comfortable out of the box as well. It will only get better for you! Thanks for the visit.

I've only really known trailer riding and mountain biking, never owned a street bike before. My first city bike is in the mail so I've been looking at saddles for the road, and this review definitely helped me be able to commit to saving up for a Brooks, thanks!

I just bought one about a month ago and it was hard as hell at first. Now I am really glad I got one because of your review. I have put about 260 km so far and now the saddle feels great, I don't even notice it. I am sure it will get better as the season goes on.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

+Seth lindland - Glad to hear the saddle is working out for you! Sorry it took so long for me to spot your comment. I hope the saddle is even better by now. Thanks for visiting.

In 1973 I had a Mercier with a Brooks saddle. I recall it as the most comfortable bicycle I ever rode. One night someone stole the bicycle from my apartment. I was sad to lose the bike but what I kept saying to myself was: "if only they had left the saddle!" Since then I haven't had a Brooks saddle and riding simply hasn't been as much fun. But now I'm seeing the light and am about to order a B17! I'm Just hopin it will be as good as I remember. Thanks for the great review!

So, I've been riding on my Brooks daily for about 2 1/2 weeks now, gotta say that it really is the most comfortable saddle I've had. I'm coming off of 25 m rides with only a slight feeling of pressure on my sit bones as opposed to the tingly numbness and soreness through my whole butt that I've had on other saddles. Like you, the comfort was immediate. So far I haven't noticed much of a break in, but I'm sure it's happening, and anyhow it's perfectly fine now. Thanks again for the review.

Thanks for your review... I have just received my first Brooks saddle, looking forward to many miles of use.. I watched your most recent review first of the Brooks as it came up in my feed..

@CaptainOverpackerRides

5 жыл бұрын

Thanks for visiting! -Scott

I've known of the Brooks saddle reputation for many years now. Your review is very objective and helpful. I knew the saddle would slowly conform to you (as I saw many of them in Antigua Guatemala streets in the 80's) but everytime I check one in the store it feels hard. I don't ride more than a few hundred miles a month commuting and over the weekends but with your review I'm thinking seriously about getting my first Brooks. We'll see. Thank you

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

+arturothecook - Another option to consider is a B17 "Aged" saddle. I don't recall the details, but they're somehow softened a bit and "pre-broken-in." Look into that and see what you think. Thanks for visiting! -Scott

thanks for a wonderful review :) I've owned a B17 for the last 7 years or so and I am a commuter so I use it daily. couldn't be happier, I don't even think about my saddle anymore except for when it's raining, but that's a small price to pay for such a comfy ride

@CaptainOverpackerRides

5 жыл бұрын

Thanks for sharing. I address rain concerns by carrying an Aardvark seat cover in my bag. It's completely waterproof, but not slippery like some lycra covers. See one at amzn.to/2VVqcBK. Thanks for visiting! -Scott

@holger8797

4 жыл бұрын

Indeed, the perfekt Interface. Saddle Arse

great review man! seriously you have thoroughly convinced me and my wife. thank you.

Brooks saddles are great . I ride a lot and just didn't get ' butt toughness ' with the standard saddle on the bike . Brooks saddle has improved this to almost all day with out any complaints . I recommend brooks to anyone

Great review, I have gone through 3 saddles on my road bike and still have hot spots. I road a friends brooks in high school and loved it, why did it tale me until now to order one for myself.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

+John Cherry - LOL! Better late than never! Thanks for writing! -Scott

Just adding my two cents too. Great and thorough review. Spoken like a true cycling enthusiast! God Bless!

Awesome review! I'm getting a B17 for Christmas for my fixie, so stoked.

The Brooks saddle is pretty comfortable even before it's broken in. I think that is because it is so shiny that it allows your rear-end to slip imperceptibly without any form of resistance or gripping. It actually, felt a bit odd the first time I sat on one, but after a few minutes it felt great (once I got the tilt-level right)

On a cycling forum a few years back a bicycle manufacturer wanted input from commuters. Wanted to design a commuter for different distance, terrain, weather, etc. When they posted their final design. It was essentially a Raleigh IGH w/rear rack, 26x1.50 tires, rechargeable lights fore and aft, upright seating and cable disc brakes. With a coffee cup holder option. lol The IGH hub was either a 3 or 8 speed depending on terrain. Oh, and the saddle choices? Brooks B17, B17S, B66 or B72. Brooks pretty much nailed it over 100 years ago.

Bought one of these after watching review! Couldn't agree more... Definitely a must buy for anyone looking for comfort on long rides.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

6 жыл бұрын

Thanks for visiting! I still like my B17. -Scott

Agreed - best saddle I have owned. Use mudguards to protect saddle, your eyes and your back

On my second B17 (first stolen in NYC) don,t recall breaking them in, they were/are great from day one and get better with time. I ride a tourer but my friends ride road bikes, yet to convince them that the comfort will actually add to their performance. Here in the UK most tourers ride on Brookes; comfortable and adds class to your bike. Ok that's my comment now off to get ready to watch the TdF Grande Depart in Yorkshire this weekend. stay safe!

This is probably the best detailed review about brooks saddle. This actually helped me take the plunge !

@CaptainOverpackerRides

6 жыл бұрын

I appreciate your comments. Thanks for visiting! -Scott

This video literally made me go and order a Brooks Saddle (B17 Special). I'll let you know my impressions once it arrives and I give it a try.

Thanks I am enjoying my B-17, so far I have 293 miles so far, I feel like it will take to 500 miles to completely break-in. So happy I bought it. I noticed recently at a group ride that at least 50% had Brooks saddles.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

John - Thanks for visiting! It will get even better as the miles pile on. Happy riding! -Scott

Completely agree. It seems like they should be hard and uncomfortable, but they give just enough to be comfortable. I replaced my gel saddle with a B17 and never regretted it. Even before breaking in, it was better than anything I'd ever ridden. I then bought a B72 for my commuter and it's perfect. I seriously doubt I'll ever ride anything else.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

Thanks for the comments, Doug! I may try one of Brooks' wider saddles just to see if it's even better. :-) Take Care -Scott

2.20: It's by no means ugly :-) I love that well worn out look. It shows how much it means to the owner. We in India grew up with Brooks copies in the 70s and 80s. Most of them are still in service. Even they were much better than what we have today in the form of gel saddles. Thankfully Brooks is now legally available here.

@TheAgentAssassin

2 жыл бұрын

I've seen some of those older India versions they look really good as well.

Thank you. Your review has helped me decide on which saddle to choose.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

Huey - Glad you found it helpful. Thanks for visiting! -Scott

@eagle14036

7 жыл бұрын

I recently purchased the Brooks b17 saddle and it was comfortable right out of the box. I couldnt believe the difference between it and my gel saddle, like riding on a cloud! No pain, no big breaking in period for me, although I know it will improve as time goes. Like wine it will get much better with age. Well worth the hundred dollars i paid for it.I love it.

I've been looking at a new saddle for a few weeks, I was leaning towards a brooks but after watching this its getting ordered. Thanks

@stevetaylor8698

2 жыл бұрын

9 years later it should be just about broken in.

Very helpful review . I just bought a Brooks Saddle , the B33 , to replace the one my fat bike came with . Am sure I will definitely will feel the difference. Thankyou

@CaptainOverpackerRides

7 жыл бұрын

Gustavo - Thanks for visiting. I hope your saddle is working well for you. -Scott

Thank you for your review. It has been the most informative to date. I'm 6'3 and almost 300 lbs(Think Michael Clarke Duncan). I currently have a Forte saddle similar to the one in your video. I will need a better saddle for centuries. My toss-up has been between the B17 and the Selle Anatomica Titanico X. I think I will purchase both, one for each of my bikes. I will keep you posted on the results.

my b17 was the most comfortable saddle i ever sat on right out of the box and since i've broken in it in i haven't had a sore ass once!

i use black shoe polish on mine,its 3 years old now and still looks new but comfy,so comfy

Allright. You convinced me. Im going to buy one. Maybe even two. One for my Single Speed Koga Miyate Roadchamp 1982 and one for my Fuji classic track.

Great review and excellent points you make. The Brooks saddle is very misunderstood... the initial impression many people have is that it'll be uncomfortable because it has no padding yet they don't understand the concept behind it's "leather hammock" design. After trying many of the latest and greatest saddles for more than 30 years, I've found that there's no other saddle as comfortable for long mile rides nor as reliable with a decades long life-span as what Brooks offers.

Thanks! I consider that high praise. I'm analytical and try to keep to the facts as I see them.

@joejones2700

3 жыл бұрын

I have a Brooks saddle B17 that I purchased in 1990. Still comfortable today with just recently tightened the adjustment to take out the saddle swaying. Looks like your pic in your video. I always enjoy hearing from other satisfied Brooks saddle riders.

I have had 3 brooks I still have two one on my Basso and one my litespeed they Brooks Swifts. I love them right out of the box.

Can't agree more about how good the B17 Brooks saddle is. I have owned a B17 for just under 2 years - 5000km of commute on it. Saddle sores are in the past. There will be no other saddle brand for me. When I switch bikes, the saddle comes along. Price is what's holding me back on putting Brooks on all my bikes. But who needs more saddles when with proper care, the B17 lasts 40 years. So thanks for the video. And thank you Brooks England for a great product.

Best B17 review I have seen. Well done. Like you, I found my B17 comfortable right out of the box, but I am 220 lbs. I'm thinking you are correct and my heavier weight helped. However, I did switch to a Brooks C17 Cambium with cut-out due to some middle-aged male issues. So far, it is great but I haven't used it that long. Really regret giving up my B17, but I was getting numbness on some long rides and that is not good. I don't fault the saddle though. It's just me. Ty

@CaptainOverpackerRides

7 жыл бұрын

Ty - Thanks for your comments. I cannot recall if I shared that I'm also 220 lbs. I find that the stronger I ride the more comfortable my saddles are, presumably because strong legs support more weight than weak or soft-pedaling legs. Take Care, Scott

I have two B17s one on my everyday, do everything rig and one on my 1966 Moulton F frame. I have tried the Velo Orange version on the B17 and despite riding for a good 500miles the Velo would not yield. Changing the Velo over to the B17 and immediate effect was a compliant and comfortable ride. After only 100 miles the new Brooks was perfect for my behind. I am about to swap the saddle off my folder for another B17.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

9 жыл бұрын

Les Crook - Thanks for writing. I have a Brooks B17 on each of my bikes. I use an inclinometer to ensure they are all set identically. At Amazon.com, enter "Johnson Level & Tool and Tool 700 Magnetic Angle Locator" in the search box and you'll see my tool. My LBS uses one when fitting customers. So I had to have one to mimic their efforts. :-)

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

***** - Thanks for visiting. Lately, I've been using a "leveler" app on my Android smartphone. It allows me to make adjustments on the road without having to carry the inclinometer with me. There's a free app called "Tool Box" that has the "Leveler" function within. Give that a shot. Good Luck! -Scott

just received the Brooks Flyer for my fitness bike, thanks for the informative video.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

4 жыл бұрын

Not sure how I missed this. But thanks for visiting!

This video will never age, I don’t notice my B17 saddle, that’s how good these saddles are.

my 1973 raleigh raleigh grand sports came with a b17 champion narrow as standard eqipment.it looks better than ever and is more comfortable every ride i take.raleigh carlton worksop knew how to build a quality bike.only thing i have replaced are the wheels and of course, the tires. i have no idea how many miles the bike has on it, but it still moves rapidly and turns heads.thats a beautiful old raleigh,i hear a few times a week.that the original seat.yep,its a 1973,original white blue trim .the wheels are weinmann about 10 years old thats it.people cant believe it.the saddle is a 1973 also.i never think about it. i guess that is the sign of quality and proven design.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

5 жыл бұрын

Bennett - That's an excellent report. Thanks for sharing! -Scott

Just remember to give it time. It will probably feel pretty good right away. But it'll take a few adjustments to hone-in the nose up/down adjustment. I have a new B17 Special that I'm breaking in. It doesn't feel as good as my older B17. But it'll get there. I'll probably get a B17 Titanium, too. Three B17s will give me saddles for rando, sport and tandem. :-)

I had a Brooks saddle on my first 10 speed bike in the 70's. When i finally got a new bike the saddle was the only thing i missed, it really had conformed to my body, my brother had the exact same bike and were both the same size, but we always knew if we switched bikes.. i forgot how much i liked that seat. worth considering next time a get a saddle. thanks for the Vid

@CaptainOverpackerRides

9 жыл бұрын

anlacombe Thanks for your comments! I finished a 400-km brevet last month and was surprised that my rear end wasn't sore at all. Okay, perhaps the rest of my body was so sore than an aching butt slipped my mind. ;-) Regardless, the saddle is not what made me anxious to leave the road after 22 hours of riding. I have a 600-km brevet in three weeks! Brooks rocks!

@anlacombe

9 жыл бұрын

nice, no better endorsement than that

I use Aussie Saddle conditioner on mine. As far as I can tell it's the same stuff at a fraction of the price of Brooks contitioner. Use any conditioner sparingly, if you get the leather too soft it will ruin the saddle. I love my Brooks and will ride nothing else. Great video, Jack

Very good review...seriously that was worthy of a TV show.

Thanks, Jack! I still choose the Proofide. I paid $15 for a 40g can. Sure, that's a lot from a gram/dollar perspective. But, since it's only applied twice a year, the can should last me two years if I don't lose it first. We bike owners tend to spend more than $15 on less important things. ;-)

I used a brooks professional on my fixed gear for 2 years, riding quite often (at least once a day commuting, long rides pretty often) and it still hurts my butt a lot... For some reason I decided to buy a B17 for my new road bike...and man. After 1.5 months it's already very comfortable as a saddle. I'm not saying the B17 is more comfortable for everyone than the Pro, I'm saying everyone's sit bones are different. If you can try out the brooks line before buying, I'd advise it.

My tip. When applying Proofide use a hair dryer. Put a little bit of Proofide on the saddle then use the hair dryer to melt it. Now it can be so easily spread over the saddle and it goes into the saddle. Before you put the saddle on the bicycle for the first time you can put Proofide on the underside of the saddle. With the hair dryer you'll find this is very easy and you can put quite a lot into the saddle on the underside. This will give a bit of protection from water spraying up into the saddle.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

+Patrick James - Not sure how I missed this great advice! Thanks for the note! I put my Proofide on a little heavy and then let it sit overnight before buffing it out in the morning. I guess I treat it like shining my boots. HAHA!

I own 2 Brooks B17s, one with springs & one without. I guess I'm lucky because they were both fine out of the box. Not light, but on a loaded touring or commuter, comfort > weight.

@bigtechdude

9 жыл бұрын

If you had to keep just one. Springs or with out?

@misterfunnybones

9 жыл бұрын

Gary Swinson Springs. Comfort > Weight

@misterfunnybones

9 жыл бұрын

Gary Swinson check out the cambium too www.brooksengland.com/cambium/

@bigtechdude

9 жыл бұрын

misterfunnybones Thank you for the reply....

@misterfunnybones

9 жыл бұрын

Gary Swinson You're welcome.

Fantastic review. I agree with it all! Took me 30 years to buy one. Won’t ever buy anything else. Just ordered a couple of more for my other bikes.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

4 жыл бұрын

Good choice!

I own/have owned a Brooks B17 Standard, B17 Flyer and B17 Narrow and they have all been super comfortable over long days cycling. The many hundreds of positive reviews on the web are not wrong, for the vast majority of owners this is a fantastic investment. Recommend!

I have a Brookes Swift and B17 Imperial. Firstly, the quality of both is exceptional. Secondly, from all of the pain I get from cycling in hilly Yorkshire, sore hands, legs, and even my neck, it's never in my arse!

@CaptainOverpackerRides

4 жыл бұрын

Very nice! Glad it's working for you. Thanks for visiting.

B17 Titanium Champion Special in Green is my saddle of choice!

I just purchased Trek FX3, i love this bike, but i am not getting along with the stock saddle. Brooks B17 looks like it will be my first upgrade.

I still have the brooks saddle on my 1972 Raleigh 😆 it's ultra comfortable.

MAN' you must be a real good salesman..because you are making me buy this no joke

i just bought this saddle a few days ago. The first 2 days my ass was sour, after that the saddle is getter better and better. You can feel the quality and i dont think i have made a mistake by buying this thing. Thanks for your video, it helped me to make my choice. Greets from the Netherlands

@CaptainOverpackerRides

6 жыл бұрын

Gekke - Glad the saddle is working for you. It'll get better the more you ride it. Thanks for visiting! -Scott

Hello Jorge CC. I have 3 bikes all fitted with a brooks saddle, a road bike fitted,Brooks Professional saddle this one has outlived 3 different bikes age of saddle 28 years ( been riding many years). a brooks B17 flyer[springs] fitted to my Guvnor bike very comfortable, don't care about the weight comfort is more important. Also have a Titanium railed B17 that is fitted to my cyclo cross commuting bike. Extremely comfortable & light. Mr Stealth is quite right good ,I feel honest review.

I got my first Brooks B17 Standard recently and put about 35km on it. The comfort was okay at first.. very hard... By the end of the ride I had swelling I'd never experienced before that lasted more than 2 days. I'm hoping in time things will improve

got one, never want to miss it

@CaptainOverpackerRides

5 жыл бұрын

Thanks for visiting! -Scott

best review of a brooks saddle!

@CaptainOverpackerRides

7 жыл бұрын

Thanks for visiting! -Scott

I have four Brooks and an ideal and a right saddle that I'm currently writing on

Hey there, Love this video. I also have a Trek Madone, and also have a Brooks B17 on it. I took this saddle off of my cyclocross bike, but am thinking of swapping it for a Brooks Swift or Team Professional... Bon velo.

My mate Tony has owned the same Brookes for over 30yrs and transferred it from bike-to-bike at least four times - convinced by this I replaced my gel-pad to a B17 and wish I had converted years ago - stop reading the reviews and get comfortable. Living in Yorkshire it was also important for me that these are still made in the UK - what could be better?!

@CaptainOverpackerRides

5 жыл бұрын

Daniel - Thanks for your comments! Take Care - Scott

Liked the review! I was thinking about switching to one of these. Do you know if the "narrow" models are narrower throughout the saddle or only towards the rear? JSWTDi driver here :)

Brilliant review, will be getting one cause of this. Cheers

Heya, I ordered english Oxford Claud urban bicycle and been researching what kind of seat fit it? or would you guys recommend seat with spring ones? Thank you, have nice day

As somebody who rides in all weather, the not getting it wet part would be a huge inconvenience, so I just ordered a C17. Also, while I love the classic look of the Brooks, it's in complete opposition with a carbon road bike.

im the same way as you. get the best and forget the rest, ignore blind, and ignorant people , let them lose out. but just the looking at the crafstman assembling them in the plant in England is enough for me. nice music on the video, and people walking and doing thier thing in midlands. cheer's.

I just bought a new carbon frame bike and thought I'd better give the factory saddle a try. After couple hundred miles of discomfort, I pulled my B17 off my old bike and got out for a quick 25 miles tonight. Heaven! I could do a century every day on my B17 if my legs could stand it.

Thanks for the video. What seat post are you using? I've heard it's difficult to get the seat back far on modern bikes with this saddle.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

7 жыл бұрын

Barry - Sorry for the late response. I use a Specialized CG-R Carbon seatpost. Thanks for visiting.

Mine was perfect right from the beginning. No brake in time needed. Comfortable like a couch.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

4 жыл бұрын

Agreed! Mine felt good right away, but got better as time passed. Thanks for visiting! -Scott

@jules-wl9gt

4 жыл бұрын

@@CaptainOverpackerRides Also without wearing padded cycle shorts?

You can buy it from pretty much any shoe shop. It is like proofide but thicker. I was told by old timers that you coated the underside before use. Heat it up a bit and melt it into the nose of the saddle and under the back support. This smells.. Let it dry and then do it again. I only did this twice and rode it in snow and rain for all those years. the only reason I have a new one is that the leather has now stretched to the point where I have no more adjustment on the screw at the front

Thank you for this detailed Review! Have you tried any Brooks Saddles with springs?

@CaptainOverpackerRides

9 жыл бұрын

Rolando Riggio - Thanks for the note! I have not tried a Brooks with springs. I've considered one for my aluminum bike. But it hasn't been a priority. I think I'll get one eventually. Take Care! -Scott

Would you recommend this for someone who commute? Not a competitive rider*

Thanks for this great review! I just bought a fine retro-style bycicle today and will get it in about 6-8 weeks, even tough the brown leather saddle on it looks good i have no idea yet if it will fit to my behind or not :-/ I will also buy the brooks leather handles and if the original saddle troubles me i considered the B17 or even the B66, anyway, after watching i´m sure i´m not wrong if i go for the B17! The only thing that could bother i heard is that the black one sometimes rubs off especially on light trousers so i will definitly go for brown or honey colour... Kind regards and thank you again for the video! :-)

@CaptainOverpackerRides

9 жыл бұрын

Mainswitch55 - Thanks for sharing! I think the Brooks saddles really finish-off a good retro look, especially if the bike can pull off the natural or honey color. Regarding bleeding, I suspect any color other than natural can bleed or, at least, has the same potential to bleed as black. Thankfully, I only wear black shorts and have never had a problem. :-)

great review! lots of good information, gonna have to get one now.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

9 жыл бұрын

HAHA! Glad it was helpful. Thanks for the visit!

Thank you for the review, you were factual and sounded like you we're honest. I know what I'm putting on my Christmas list....

Silly Question: how did you determine your sitbone or which brooks saddle to purchase?

Excellent review!

I got a second hand one from eBay and refurbished it, it’s much better than the one I had on my new Brompton electric bike and I would definitely buy a new one for my other bike.

Phenomenal video; thank you very much for sharing! I am shopping for a saddle, and I am convinced that Brooks is the brand for me. However, I am not too sure on the exact model. I know I want a B17, but I am not too sure on whether I should go for the Standard, Special, Imperial Wide, or Imperial Narrow. I am a male and my main concern is perineal protection. Have you had experience with these other models? If so, I would very much appreciate hearing your thoughts about them. Thank you again!

Good review!

Hi, great review. Made me sure to be wanting to buy mine almost 5 years ago. The only thing I don't like about it is that it leaves black marks on my pants... That's a problem resolved since a while, as I've put a waterproof protective sleeve onto it, bought for 6 euro from decathlon. It also protects the saddle from the rain. I was wondering, are you still riding on the one you've reviewed in this video?

@CaptainOverpackerRides

3 жыл бұрын

Hello - Yes, still the same saddle. Though I must admit that I haven't been riding as much. I had some health problems a few years ago and still haven't made a full return to the bike. Recent events have made group rides a bit scarce in my area, too. Someday... Thanks for visiting.

There's a third camp: Those (like myself) who own several Brooks saddles but prefer one over the others. The B-17 is a fantastic saddle, but for me the B-15 "Swallow" is the only one that is comfy out of the box. Each saddle in the Brooks leather range is made from different grades of leather. It isn't just the shape of the saddle that will inform a person to purchase one, it's also the leather grade. For you, the B-17 obviously hit the shape/grade sweet spot. For me, it's the Swallow.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

6 жыл бұрын

Thanks for visiting. Yes, sometimes a different saddle for each type of hip is a good thing. Someone once told me that my hips are wide for a man. Perhaps that's why the B17 works for me. -Scott

@blex5579

6 жыл бұрын

wrong-all brooks are using the same leather. just watched an official documentary on brooks...

Are you in Virginia? I did a century ride there "Notts Island" and we had to take a ferry. I have two of these and like you one of them is on a road bike. The other on a commuter that I ride to work.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

+Brian McLamb - I have one on each of my bikes. Thanks for visiting!

what about that this saddles doesnt have space in your perineal zone? i dont think that area would get softer through time, and i saw brooks sell one with that zone cutted off, but i dont know if them would last as long as the normal ones, do you know something about this? or do you feel the saddle put pressure there?

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

+metalg33ksolid - It's possible to adjust the saddle's nose-up/down positioning to minimize the pressure. But it's a very fine adjustment. I haven't tried a Brooks with the cutout. I consider it, but I haven't been having any numbness issues.

So do I buy a brooks or a really nice Marco?

Thanks for the great review. I've got a Colnago CX Zero Alu and I'm wondering if a Brooks B17 Special would suit it. Some guys were telling me that it could be too wide and it may be uncomfortable on rides over one hour. I'm not so sure. Can anyone give me advice on whether I should get a B17 to fit on my CX Zero Alu?

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

+Nicholas Gomez - It's tough to say. It depends on how wide your "sits bones" are. Mine are sort of wide, so the B17 is good. Some people do better with a narrower Brooks model. Sorry, I can't suggest anything specific. Good luck and thanks for writing! -Scott

@scudonepercenter

8 жыл бұрын

+Captain Overpacker Thanks for the reply. I've been reading up and it looks like the B15, Selle Anatomica or Brooks C15/C17 carved may be a better bet for me.

I have a B17 aged and it is awesome!

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

+James R Davis - Glad you like it! Thanks for writing. -Scott

We have three B17's and a B67. I've had at least another four Brooks saddles. It's all we use. Question about weight. My weight goes up and down a couple of pounds each week or perhaps each day of few hours. My bikes range from lightish to downright heavy. Is there any difference in my weight going up a bit vs having an extra few ounces in saddle weight? I've never understood why it always gets mentioned. Are all bike riders in the Tour de France? My bikes are for getting around town, not racing.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

+Robert Ennor - The weight of a saddle almost never comes up when riding with casual riders or touring riders. However, I'm still fast enough to ride with "sport riders" (not racers, though). A lot of them still get a thrill out of lifting a bike to show off how light it is. The extra few ounces of saddle weight is a real turn-off to them; they still haven't figured out that that weight is irrelevant at our riding levels. ;-) Thanks for visiting! -Scott

Ron - I don't know the details specifically. But Brooks' website lists all of the dimensions right on their website. I cannot post links here. But search "Brooks saddle" and their site will be close to the top. Good Luck!

great review - thanks (got mine yesterday) :)

I just put a B17 on my bike and went for a 10 mile ride. I would describe it to riding on a brick, and that was with my padded bike shorts on. I hope that this saddle becomes more comfortable with time.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

4 жыл бұрын

Thanks for visiting. How is the saddle now, after a few weeks?

@5777alan

4 жыл бұрын

@@CaptainOverpackerRides It has gotten a little better. My last twenty mile ride was better, but still pretty uncomfortable. I am doing 62 miles this weekend. I'm going to put up with the pain for awhile, and hope that it continues to get better.

Thanks. I just installed a Brooks Champion Flyer on my touring bike. We'll see how long it takes to break in.

@claycampbell4757

8 жыл бұрын

That's what I have done. The Flyer is practically broken in seemingly because of the spring action absorbing road bumps. Rain helped a lot with forming, maybe not such a good thing but it fits perfectly.

@CaptainOverpackerRides

8 жыл бұрын

Keefe - Looks like I missed a batch of comments about 3-4 months ago. I hope your new saddle is working well for you! Take Care. -Scott

Thanks for a great review!

I don't own a car, & I ride at least 4000 miles per year on my bicycle just around town commuting. Some days its 70 mile trips, but often just 10-20 for a daily commute/errands. Although it is pricey, & that it is really just a leather hammock you sit on, I wouldn't go with another seat. I'm heathy & athletic & my perineum is never in pain. This saddle helped me align my sit bones & sacral alignment for miles of ease.

You still have it?