Genuine response: we like these videos because Bright Side is really popular and they put out ridiculous misinformation. Having reliable information from a real Titanic historian and having their misinformation corrected by one is really important.

@jasonhowell-lg5ig

Жыл бұрын

Agreed 💯.. it's important young people don't grow up thinking misinformation about a historical event so very much agreed.

@SamOfTheSmokies76

Жыл бұрын

I mean you can tell its obviously fake. Like..

@SamOfTheSmokies76

Жыл бұрын

Seriously, thanks for putting up with Bright Side and their inaccuracy. It needs to be addressed and thanks for going through their vids and pointing out the misinformation. 🫡🚢

@manoharmeka999

Жыл бұрын

Next possible video from Brightside would be what if Titanic was constructed not like a ship, but like a water train with 2 steamers and 3 cars attached. All people would have survived the disaster.

@redtailarts101

Жыл бұрын

@@SamOfTheSmokies76 Some of it's obviously fake yeah but some of it isn't so obvious

Torturer: “alright, time to cut your intestines open!” Sam: “No, we don’t have to do that! I have a family!” Torturer: “you’re right, let’s just go watch some brightside videos.” Sam: “NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!”

@Hjalle_Gaming

5 ай бұрын

As long as it isn't a Bright Side Titanic video.

@sepur_lempung34official

5 ай бұрын

Bright side Titanic now torture me to roast it

In the Wreck of the Titan the main character also climbs onto the iceberg and fights a polar bear after ship sinks. When talking about this coincidence bright side always fails to mention how much this “premonition” got wrong and only mention the few superficial similarities.

@Igstormchaser

Жыл бұрын

To be fair, most people who cover this do the same thing, it isn't just BS. Even Sam hasn't read the book, granted I havent seen him make a video on this topic as of yet.

Sam should get like a million dollars for every time he suffers through these Bright Side videos. Nice job on 100K Sam!!!

@Sprunged

Жыл бұрын

True

@TheMaritimeGamer109

Жыл бұрын

He will get infinite money from that.

@chris-nw8tz

Жыл бұрын

123

@alexsworld7970

Жыл бұрын

i know

@Katoshi_Takagumi

Жыл бұрын

Well, if that's not going to happen, Sam should always know we are right here for him, watching.

Ladies and Gentlemen, it's your friend Mike Brady from OceanLiner Designs. I have always wondered, can Sam from Historic Travels survive another one of these videos

@DoWutNow90

Жыл бұрын

I know u saw his face on dudes home page😂

@kasvinimuniandy4178

Жыл бұрын

I love your videos!!

@THE_AETHER

Жыл бұрын

​@@kasvinimuniandy4178I hate to tell you this, but that's not Mike. It's just a fan making a joke out of his intro.

@jasonwhittle6689

6 ай бұрын

Love both historic travel and ocean liner designs

@sepur_lempung34official

5 ай бұрын

It seem like what Mike Brady reaction when he saw Sam video reacting to bright side and i can sure he will also suffered

Rusticles are stalactite-like structures that are formed when iron-loving bacteria attack the steel in sunken ships. These 'rivers of rust' run down the sides of the ship (most famously in the case of the Titanic) and contain dozens of microbial species feeding off the iron.

@rredeyee2460

Жыл бұрын

So Titanic is basically becoming a river of microbial poo?

@GG-0808

Жыл бұрын

@@exxxz1999 I don’t know the exact amount but I think it is like 100 - 200 lbs a day. Correct my if I’m wrong though.

@DylRicho

Жыл бұрын

@@exxxz1999 Around 400 pounds (180 kilograms).

@cohengamertv6548

11 ай бұрын

@@exxxz1999it takes years for those to form

Something I've always wanted to see was a video on the aftermath of the Titanic. Specifically the media reaction, but also public opinion, ticket sales, legal backlash, ship design changes, etc all in one video.

OceanGate employee: “Uh, boss, do you think it’s a good idea if we name our submersible the ‘Titan’? I don’t like it myself, because anything with the name ‘Titan’ in it, historical or mythological, seems to have a notorious habit of crashing and burning. I’m not superstitious, but if something bad did happen by accident, we might look like fools and braggarts.” Mr. Stockton Rush, CEO of OceanGate: “You’re fired, Murphy!”

@DixieTheTrainFan2024

Жыл бұрын

Titanic: You done did it now.

I voted to him not to do it, bright side is even killing my brain cells with fake information about titanic

@cheese7071

Жыл бұрын

They’ve been milking the hell out of tragedies since they made the channel

@SamOfTheSmokies76

Жыл бұрын

sarcasm

@SamOfTheSmokies76

Жыл бұрын

I mean I know what most of what they say is real inaccurate but im not losing braincells bc of it...

@Katoshi_Takagumi

Жыл бұрын

So, one vote from you, and... Sam must have clicked the 'No' button himself for little over 900 times, then.

Who is more to blame for Sam loosing his sanity, him for suggesting that he reacts to another BS vid (take the abbreviation as you will), or us for voting "yes" when he asked us if we wanted him to?

@Jackie-th4ph

Жыл бұрын

Yes 😂

I want a brightside part 8. These are funny. But in all honesty Sam, I also suffer with you.

@SamOfTheSmokies76

Жыл бұрын

why do you suffer. As Titanic enthusiasts, we should be making Bright Side suffer. We know the truth and what they say shouldn't weaken us, but make us stronger in our Titanic knowledge so we can defend the truth

@PowerRangerfan

Жыл бұрын

@@SamOfTheSmokies76 It does make us stronger. It is the knowledge of knowing that so many people watch Brightside and take their word as truth, making our work of spreading the actual truth that much harder. But we will win the fight. With our knowledge of the truth we will defeat Brightside. We have to. To keep the memory of those that were lost that night alive.

@SamOfTheSmokies76

Жыл бұрын

@@PowerRangerfan Ik but it still makes us stronger (or some of us at least)

@PowerRangerfan

Жыл бұрын

@@SamOfTheSmokies76 It does indeed. I rewatched the James Cameron Titanic movie not too long ago and after watching your videos it made it that much more fun to watch.

@SamOfTheSmokies76

Жыл бұрын

@@PowerRangerfan oh nice

Yes, us Brits do use date/month/year instead of month/date/year. If you ask me, date/month/year makes a lot more sense with it being in chronological order and all

@Katoshi_Takagumi

Жыл бұрын

Or the reverse order, either makes sense, but the usual US standard way of mixing it by having month/date/year makes the least sense.

@AdamArBast99

Жыл бұрын

I usually write in YYYY/MM/DD because then I could, if necessary, write YYYY/MM/DD HH:Mi

@oliversherman2414

Жыл бұрын

@@Katoshi_Takagumi exactly

@kiryn5977

5 ай бұрын

@@Katoshi_Takagumi When you say the date (for instance, "the Titanic sank on April 15, 1912"), you say it month/day/year. So why does it not make sense to reflect this when writing down dates? Seems perfectly sensical to me.

@Katoshi_Takagumi

5 ай бұрын

@@kiryn5977 It doesn't make sense because you are not then using any logical order, meaning a month is longer than a day, but a year is longer than either of them. Saying April 15, 1912 means you are jumping about, in a sense. I know, of course, this does not have anything to do with logic or lack thereof, it's do with a convention. The real confusion sets in when you have any of the first 12 days of a month and you don't use the names of the months, then you end up with something like 1/4/1912 and 4/1/1912.

as frustrating as it is to watch these bright side videos for you, I believe its extremely important to debunk any misinformation that the video could be spreading, you are doing important work for the titanic community

As for a lifeboat drill, things have changed a lot. When I did a Greek Isles tour, an announcement was made that those of us who joined the ship in Athens were to check for their life jacket ( mine was in the closet)& to find out what lifeboat we were assigned and show up at that station at such and such time. The crewmember acknowledged me when I got there and that was that.

Canceling the lifeboat drill makes sense now. At first even I was confused by it all, but I slowly started to find out that there was a drill in Southampton. Then the whole "Captain Smith is the blame" came in, then the whole switch fraud claims. Sam, this is why I love yours and Mikes channel. The two of you give straight out explanations and analysis.

It’s not only the UK, but pretty much the whole world who does dates as DD/MM/YYYY. The cheese part is hilarious 😂😂😂 thanks for suffering for us through this 😂

@Katoshi_Takagumi

Жыл бұрын

Don't know about cheese... maybe if they had had Big Mac's back then?....

just saw "A night to Remember".....colourised version on YT......very good movie....1958....

"Futility" by Morgan Robertson First Edition, yes that was the correct book cover for the Titan

Bob Ballard named them "rusticles"... First he thought it was organic growth, then he thought it was rust formations... Some time later they discovered it was waste from bacteria eating the steel.

@MakerInMotion

Жыл бұрын

I've heard of collectors buying pieces of rusticle from the wreck. So there are people out there showing off bacteria poop in glass display cases.

Titanic's Wi-Fi signal was strong when it broke...

One of the better Titanic videos Bright Side has made as of rn, not good but it is not the worst, no wonder Sam did not rage much, Sam only raged when he got out of his chair when they said Titanic sank at 1:45AM when in reality it sank approximately between 2:20AM to 2:23AM. Overall this is the calmest Bright Side reaction video Sam has made so far.

@ilovebeinagirl

Жыл бұрын

"raged", LOL! 🤣

@shadowpulpfan1810

Жыл бұрын

And followed a moment later with a small, long suffering "I have a headache." I don't know whether to laugh or give him an aspirin.🤕 Poor Sam, and you do this all for our edutainment. Thank you.

I'm in the early stages of a first-time deepdive into "everything Titanic"...would absolutely love to see an upload or more information related to how such specific 'time keeping' was maintained relating to the events of the sinking? I'm quite impressed at how accurate the timelines are, considering the vasste array of perspectives!

Ladies and Gentlemen, Welcome to Part 7 of Sam raging!

@BMTEnjoyer160

Жыл бұрын

Can’t wait

@dinobattles5688

Жыл бұрын

Wrong

@ThatMaus

Жыл бұрын

Ladies and Gentlemen, its seems the show îs over, unfortunatly Sam didnt rage as hard as previous shows!

@BMTEnjoyer160

Жыл бұрын

@@ThatMaus:(

@ThatMaus

Жыл бұрын

@@BMTEnjoyer160 Do not worry, Part 8 of Sam raging Will come out soon!

That nurse, Viola Jessep, was on all 3 ships - Olympic, Titanic and Brittanic

Fun fact, there's only ONE video that I've seen that has ever gotten what the distress call sounded like to any receiver, correct. ONE. It was a video from the 50s with interviews of survivors. I'll look for it and post it in the comments if I find it along with time stamps. Beeps didn't come around until WW2. The old Marconi spark gaps basically just interrupted background static, and white noise. Edit: here it is! kzread.info/dash/bejne/kax_prSmmNOcnLQ.html 6:50 is where it starts. That's what it would have sounded like to anybody receiving it.

This is my first reaction video I’ve watched and I can see why 76% voted to see another one! Your reactions are so genuine, funny and accurate!! I’m voting yes for another one :) Love your channel!

Do a video on PTSD and suicides among the survivors? I counted 15 suicides which is WAY more than one would expect out of a population of 705 people.

@Diotallevi73

Жыл бұрын

YESSS! That crossed my mind just a few days ago, too. Seconded!

They forgot to mention that Violet Jessop was also on the Olympic when it collided with HMS Hawke.

Why don't we just petition Mr. Travels here to live watch the animated Titanic movies? He'd lose more than just some braincells, he'd most likely be strapped in a jacket, in a padded room requiring some shock therapy. All in favor say aye?

@noobiumbaconate

Жыл бұрын

aye

@mateoley6630

Жыл бұрын

aye

Honestly I’m just amazed the thumbnail shows titanic sinking the right way round

@FLAGZMan12

Жыл бұрын

You Mean Wrong Way?

@digitaal_boog

Жыл бұрын

@@FLAGZMan12 no

@FLAGZMan12

Жыл бұрын

@@digitaal_boog Dude, Thats Starboard, Not Port. You Might Be Talk About The Angle, Which Is True, Titanic Sunk In A 25 Degree Angle When It Split, But The Angle It Was Leaning To Was WRONG!

@digitaal_boog

Жыл бұрын

@@FLAGZMan12 I know. I’m not…well I thick but I know my history.

@digitaal_boog

Жыл бұрын

@@FLAGZMan12 I was referring to the fact she’s shown sinking bow first and breaking

Wow, that was amazing ( Big fan, Sam ❤ )

I agree with you, Sam they got 1 detail wrong of the titanic. The ship did not sink at 1:45 AM. It sink at 2:20 AM.

0:48 I laughed so hard because of the music and how intense the moment is when sam has to react to another bright side!

Sam, can you please do an episode about the "unsinkable" thing? It unleashes a huge Sam Rant every time it's mentioned lol, yet it's so commonly associated with Titanic. I'd love to know more about the actual perceptions of Titanic's safety in 1912, the history of the "unsinkable" misnomer, and how it became so entrenched in Titanic lore after the fact. Pretty please!? EDIT: OH you already did! I just found it! Sorry, I'm a recent subscriber, will watch it next :)

@subjectc7505

Жыл бұрын

It was because of the safety features of the Titanic at the time they named her "Unsinkable", really any ship of good engineering was called unsinkable. That title is more fitted for the Olympic.

@ThatWolfFromHyruleGaming

Жыл бұрын

Except Olympic was called “Old Reliable”, but yes I agree. Also Olympic rammed and sunk a U-boat

The video starts off with Sam walking into the room disappointed at us That'll never get old

This has me wondering, an idea for bright side, if the Titanic did the drill Sunday...would enough time have passed that the iceberg would've never been in their path.

@DylRicho

Жыл бұрын

Interesting question. Personally I don't believe so as the currents aren't that quick. It takes about half a year for the icebergs to travel from the north to where they might pose a threat in the Atlantic.

You strolled in there cracking your knuckles, like when Bruce Lee fought Chuck Norris in the Coliseum. Ready for battle! 🤣

I love the dramatic intro 😂

I cannot wait! I love watching your reactions! lol

Paused the video to type this. I got out my copy of A Night To Remember. The foreword of the book talks about Robertson's book and does a brief comparison of the real and fictional ships. The quote is "Both could carry about 3,000 people and both had enough lifeboats for only a fraction of this number."

22:52 cheez wheels are generally encased in a 1” thick layer of wax all around it to preserve it for long periods of time. Seeing as the university of google tells me that water doesn’t interact with wax and assuming there are no large air bubbles inside the cheese wheel itself. It is plausible that somewhere in the ships galley there is still a fully intact wheel of cheese still waiting to be served.

For your next Bright Side video, make sure that drink is a Long Island Ice Tea! 😉

Also. During the inquiry, the surviving crow's nest employee stated on record; had he been provided binoculars he would have seen the iceberg sooner

@TheWPhilosopher

Жыл бұрын

Half right. Both Fleet and Lee survived and were interviewed. Fleet was not asked and Lee said they were better than just eye sight but the question wasn't put re when are the glasses used. Glasses are primarily used once something has been spotted otherwise you lose your field of vision

@tysenbrandsma6996

Жыл бұрын

@@TheWPhilosopher I'm not always right. Fair example

@TheWPhilosopher

Жыл бұрын

@@tysenbrandsma6996 nobody is always right, I know I'm not 😅

Awesome Work Bro, Thanks 👍👍👍 Greetings from Helsinki, Finland 🇫🇮

The bacteria causing the "rusticles " are named for the titanic. The rusticles were named specifically for the fact that they look like rust colored icicles or stalactites and stalagmites and first termed at the wreck of the Bismark.

@Igstormchaser

Жыл бұрын

Halomonas Titanicae for anyone curious

@42LGK

Жыл бұрын

very interesting didnt know that thanks, theres always something new with the titanic

You should watch titanic 666 or the 1999 animated titanic movie. They are the definition of a bright side video in somecases

@tracyrunyan3329

Жыл бұрын

That animated movie the one where sea creatures saved Titanic?

@Alienman-eh1qz

Жыл бұрын

Yes

You need to start dragging our friend Mike Brady into these. Share the love.

the first 8 seconds was sam doing the walk of shame 😂

I usually don’t seek out Bright Side Titanic videos (or Bright Side in general) but if it pops up, I’ll watch. Mainly as an exercise in correcting their bullshit. I write long, loooong comments supplying not just corrections but citations. The work Bright Side doesn’t bother to do. I prove that so-and-so wasn’t even a passenger, etc. Some of their videos don’t even have their own internal accuracy, aside from the inaccurate inform they feature. Bright Side is ABSURD but honestly, it’s kinda entertaining in a “what will they get wrong this time?” way. Thank you for the work you do, Sam! ❤

“Why is the titanic with red funnels?” Good question. If you look the 2010 Titanic II trailer from the Asylum Studios, you’ll get the answer…

I've seen a few Bright Side videos. After watching this video, I had no idea how potentially inaccurate they might be. Very informative.

Hey! I’m a history student interested in the true story of the Titanic and have come across your videos several months ago during my research. I’ve heard you mention a handful of times that the White Star Line wasn’t responsible for the tag line “The Unsinkable Ship” and was curious as to why several testimonials from survivors still mention it in their accounts from the sinking. If you or any other commenters know the answer I’d greatly appreciate the feedback. Thanks again for putting in the time to keep us all informed!

OK, I endured the agony with you. Your reactions were hilarious, especially when you just threw your hands up and walked off-screen when they said Titanic sank at 1:45 😂. What I don't understand is how these people got so many easily verifiable details incorrect. Well, this is my first video so if you feel this was the best one---ew--I'm afraid to look at the rest! Be well, and thanks for sharing!

I haven’t been on this channel for a while. That’s such a cool intro.👍🏼👍

Hey so I’ll answer a question from last video “Who are these people” When they showed the married couple, It’s a stock image from a marriage in Berlin between 1897-1910 and the couple never went to America, britan, or Ireland

Sam's face when doing a bright side video he loves it 😂

If you're ever interested, Tom Lynskey over at Part-Time Explorer made a Series of Videos where he reads the book (The Sinking Of The Titan).

Hi there. I have a what if suggestion. Imagine you a time traveler with nothing but your clothes but somehow you managed to board Titanic. How to convince the crew that you know what will happen if they don’t believe you. What arguments to use? Nice work! 🤘🏼🤠💀

I’m surprised that you didn’t comment on the iceberg weighing less than an average car lol 29:10

@HistoricTravels

Жыл бұрын

I must of missed that comment.

i felt that when my guy walked into the frame lmao

Seeing this upload on my lunch break just flipped my day around completely and I havn't even watched it yet

genuently i cant belive sam can stretch an 8 minute video into a 30 minute documentary lol. Give this man a break XD

LMAOOO I was so impressed with bright side up until the 1:45 am comment and I died Sam just got up lmfoaoaosks

Guess I'm never gonna know for sure what super power to have to survive the Titanic sinking. Thanks a lot pal

I would love you to do a video on the Chief engineer. I saw the “save the titanic” doc/movie and I got so fascinated with Mr. Joseph Bell. I would also love to hear where you think he was during the break up. Did he mange to get on deck or did he die inside the ship? Love your vids Sam!!!

@ThatWolfFromHyruleGaming

Жыл бұрын

None of the engineering staff survived, its safe to say Joseph Bell died in the engine room

Hey from Jackson, MS. Thanks for the info. I just sub.

Sam is an absolute legend at this point for enduring so many of these mind melting videos for our amusement. I love hearing him debunk Bright Side’s obvious misinformation.

Lets see what Bright Side has going this time...

Love how the video is called "what the survivors heard when the Titanic was sinking" when it starts out like it then basically goes into a totally different direction way off course from what the thumbnail says

@ThatWolfFromHyruleGaming

Жыл бұрын

Clickbait 101: make as good as brightly colored thumbnail as possible to be eye catching, then make the title something relatable to the subject. Then once the video starts, change gears and fly off thr rails with misinformation and outrageous claims of fact

5:35 "The entire bow was ruined except for some parts that weren't ruined"

Glad I found this channel in the last few weeks. Had a ton of fun watching.

Bright side is the best source of information about the titanic

I wonder how many videos before Bright Side is going to say the sinking of the Titanic was done by a kamikaze... I mean, they came up with the torpedo and kraken.

A video about Lightholler would be really interesting! Same with one about Collapsable B

Me: (tapping on my mom’s gravestone) “MOOMMM!!! He’s back with another bright side!!!!”

They said the iceberg weighed 1.5 tonnes, it actually weighed about 75 million tonnes. lol

You need to make a video study on why it was not as academically known 25 years ago about Titanic’s SB and port lists and how that has now changed

There is oxygen down there that deep but not a lot of it.The Titanic wreckage has rusted significantly, but the term rusticles was the name given to the bacteria that are eating it

@Diotallevi73

Жыл бұрын

If bacteria are involved, they could break up H2O and use it's oxygen to oxygenate the iron from the ship's hull. No need for the water to contain lots of O2.

You rage so well.😊 I wanna see one about collapsible b sometime too .

Hey, just wanted to say congrats on 124k! I’ve been following you since you very first started and you’ve always made fun and engaging content. Cheers from Virginia!

Hey Sam...ty for the video

He is gonna rage for sure

4:31 your internet died to save you from loosing brain cells

You know I use to see bright side as a bright side, now I see it as the dark side

I read Futility. Calling it "the exact story of the Titanic " is a _streeeeetch._ The similar name of the ship and the fact that it hit an iceberg are the only similarities; the book isn't even about the sinking, it's just something that happened at the beginning of the story, and it's not even a good story. If a ship named Titanic hadn't been sunk by an iceberg soon after it was written, it would have fallen into the slag pit of bad art. Nobody would have any idea it ever existed.

I thought that cheese would get moldy if was sitting out for long periods of time but if cheese is kept sealed if won't get moldy until after the expiration date. If you do see mold in cheese throw it away. Some people will get sick if seeing moldy cheese.

5:19 neighbours at 2AM

@johanbrand8601

Жыл бұрын

💀

I confess Sam, i contributed to this 😂😂😂😂😂

By all means. Keep it up 💫 You make great content. Many thanks. 🌺

a theory if the lifeboat drill happened on april 14th 1912 would titanic manage to be delayed enough to miss the iceburg

@TheWPhilosopher

Жыл бұрын

We cannot know. It may be the ice would have drifted further which on the flip side means they might have stopped for the night if there was more visible ice about but yeah we cannot know but maybe 🤷‍♀️

Holy heck, we’re seconds and seconds in and Sam isn’t raging!😳

if one spreads and repeats a lie enough, it becomes as if it were true. Only what we think we remember really matters. :)

the man that made this bright side video should actually make all bright side titanic videos (if its not a voice filter or smth)

i have to wonder if the California would have reacted differently had the Capt. shot off the rockets in 1 minute intervals?

I genuinely don't understand how bright side confidently spews their bs. If you are someone who knows even bare minimum about Titanic, one of the most commonly known things is that it was a dark night with no moon. That part got me.

Oh! New Historic Travels intro music goes hard Sam!

this man can never escape bright side.

Sam after that poll: "Why i'am still here... Just to suffer"

This will be good, and hilarious lol

thank you for calling them out. Especially with the violin haha. I am pretty sure that violin would have been somewhat crushed by the time it hit the bottom. Keep up the great content