This was one of my favorite bluey theories an I'm excited to hear what you think below (I did have this video out a few years ago but had to re-edit it due to some music licence changes)

@siennaandbailey1332

22 күн бұрын

I like this bluey episode!

@user-sp4xl2cb4h

22 күн бұрын

Gotta have those notifications on to see your vids! ❤️

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

yes ding ding ding!! thank you!

@Warlock3417

22 күн бұрын

@@aussiegirlmargie If this is a parallel universe then the dogs’ evolution is slightly different. I mean there’s a few episodes where they are shown to eat chocolate at times so maybe they’re just dogs with human traits. Edit: Wolves 🐺 are my favourite animals after owls 🦉!

@user-uv2zc2vr9f

22 күн бұрын

Had my notifications on!

I love that you used Babe as an example in this. Truly a classic.

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

Love that movie!

One thing I've always wondered is, is Chunky Chimp an animated or Live Action movie in the Bluey world

@A-Kira

20 күн бұрын

Maybe CGI

@Gracios.life-kq8qo

12 күн бұрын

You’ve made me rethink my whole life

8:14 why does that line get me every time😭

I agree to some extent. I'm an environmental studies student, and, correct me if I'm wrong, but you seem to have a fundamental misunderstanding of how evolution actually works. It is not deterministic, so for instance, the wolves seeing monkeys using their thumbs and trying to do the same; that is a learned trait, not something generically heritable. Instead, opposable thumbs would have had to become a mutation in dogs that then gave dogs with this mutation some sort of advantage (either in sexual selection, fitness, individual survivability, etc) so that the wolves with thumbs would reproduce more than the ones without and/or they didn't die as much because they had the advantage of thumbs. Hope this helps!

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

I’m aware, I’m just going by cartoon logic for most part here 😆

@JaimeBeazley

22 күн бұрын

@@aussiegirlmargie ahhhhh, gotcha! That makes sense as well

Here's a mind-blower... In spies episode when bingo is in the bathroom she sings "one man and his dog went to mow a meadow" in the bluey universe how does this even work?! The dogs are the men.

@kumachan9311

22 күн бұрын

and "I'm playing Sheepdog" in another ep

2:35 That clip of babe reminded me just how good the Animal actors are and didn’t need much CGI to show emotion…( something Disney could learn)

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

Yeah I miss live action and practical props too

@sweets_Cat88

22 күн бұрын

@@aussiegirlmargie I use to watch Babe a lot as a kid due to the border collie pups and characters of Rex and Fly. Plus babe the movie proves that you can get a pig to act LOL

Congratulations on 174k!❤️ I’m glad I could be with you and your community! Thank you for these amazing videos. Keep up the great work!👏

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

that is so kind of you!! thank you for watching and supporting my videos by commenting on them to!!

@nemitz4

22 күн бұрын

@@aussiegirlmargie Anytime Margie!

Lol, fun exploration but FWIW, human uprightness stems from a very tiny change in the shape of the base of our skull where the spine connects, unstooping our posture compared to the other great apes. It's the first bone to form during development and sets the angle of the neck and spine underneath the head. In quadrupeds, this connection point extends straight back from under the skull instead. The rest of the skeleton essentially comes online in alignment with this direction/shape. So in the Blueyverse, that could have been the shift, a combination of incremental mutation in the attachment point of the spine creating more upright postures and freeing up the forelimbs for manipulative tasks. Dogs already do a lot of pawing and puzzling, which could have really taken advantage of that anatomical rearrangement. Add in some degree of polydactyly that could be selected for if it improves manipulation of the environment, and you're on your way to Canis erectus and Canis sapiens.

The background music! It literally made this video 100x better!!

You escalated to almost 200k fast margie! It was a great journey from 50k to 174k subs it was fun with all the theories and stuff i enjoyed every moment i was watching all of these videos! Anyways congrats on the achievement you just made 174k is a BIG goal.

i like to imagine they evolved from some kind of canid from the hesperocyonidae family, they were canids but they climbed in the trees

@evangeloevoxi

22 күн бұрын

I love this theory lol. I love biology

Nice to see you taking a “Film Theory but for Bluey” approach here. 😅 I did always have wolves as the “ancestors” of the Bluey-verse, but I almost forgot about the whole intermarrying thing. Sounds wild, but true when you think about it. 😁

@itsbella8518

22 күн бұрын

I never thought of it like that :) (the “Film theory but for bluey”)

@JCE0713

22 күн бұрын

Didn't they. make theory on this as well?

@skyenight-by8yh

22 күн бұрын

@@JCE0713 They did, but apparently they think that the dogs descended the same way as humans did: by primates. It’s honestly weird.

This makes even more sense than Mat Pat's theory.

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

what was his theory??

@lovepeople777

22 күн бұрын

If you know about biology, it kinda doesn't...

@SpukiTheLoveKitten75

22 күн бұрын

Yup. I thought the "Dog-people descended from primates" sounded ridiculous.

@SpukiTheLoveKitten75

22 күн бұрын

​@@aussiegirlmargieAnthropomorphic dogs descending from primates.

@sadhbhcorr942

22 күн бұрын

Is his theory the one about how the Anthropomorphic Dogs in Bluey were descended from primates. I mean, that part of his theory isn't that far-fetched (admittedly, I did not buy most of it, btw) because, we humans are descended from primates too for real life. So, in the Bluey-verse, because dogs are basically homo-sapiens, it would make sense for them.

I always enjoy your theory videos Margie and this one is interesting

I actually wanna see chunky chimp as a Bluey short movie😭

Wow that vid was sooo good I just watched it keep up the great work!,!

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

so glad you liked it!! thank you for taking the time to comment too

*Meanwhile in another another universe...*

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

Cat Squad!

I like the direction you are taking since bluey isn’t getting any new episode for now

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

Yeah their will be lots of Bluey lore videos, theory’s, and episode breakdowns from season 1 and 2 that I haven’t done yet

Margie, have you seen all the cute Bluey shorts on their channel!? I found them last week, and they are like 90 seconds of cuteness! I would love to see you reviewing a few of them at a time.

This is obviously one of the only theories that I actually agree with

Hi Margie! I’m pretty sure you’ve done an Easter eggs video on ‘backpackers’ series one, but I don’t think I’ve seen it. Around 4:17 next to a yellow and grey gnome is a Pixar ball! I don’t know what this is for but this is pretty cool! Btw I love ur vids!

@ExplosionMare

22 күн бұрын

Maybe it's a nod to Disney since they stream Bluey on their TV channel

@ColettexRoblox

16 күн бұрын

@@ExplosionMare yeah maybe, but in Australia (where I’m from) I checked Disney and it’s not there? So what does it mean in Australia?, the same thing

The constable in The Sign is referred to as a police*man*. Boy, did that throw me for a loop

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

Omg…I didn’t even think of that!

I loved theodd1sout’s animation about Bluey and his deep dive into flat pack in it. I think it really explained and theorized the episode really well without changing the base of the episode. What did you think of the episode FlatPack?

Hello so excited to watch :))

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

Hope you enjoy!

@Duck_wcue

22 күн бұрын

@@aussiegirlmargie omg!!!! I can’t believe you replied!!!! And I will :))

I have something you can look into! In the episode horsey wedding were uncle stripe and bandit get married as horses they walk on tiles...wered that come from?😅

I definitely think they did not evolve from apes. Im incredibly into speculative biology and theres no way an primate could evolve to be so similar to dogs. Convergent evolution (when 2 unrelated groups of animals evolve similar traits) does happen, but never with such similarities. On the other hand, canines evolving to walk upright is much more plausible. A much more reasonable theory is that an early canine evolved to be a tree dwelling canide, around 35 million years ago, around the same time most modern primates evolved in our world. When forests and jungles started turning into savannah's, the same pressures that pushed our ancestors to walk upright effected these tree dogs. They started walking on the ground more, walking more upright, and eventually, evolving possible thumbs and hands to interact with the world. Simple (its really not i know) Bluey and bingo just said monkeys because they didn't know the name of that tree dog ancestor (I.E. bluey and bingo are idiots)

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

lol your ending 😂 but love the in depth comment!!

@evangeloevoxi

22 күн бұрын

I just commented a shorter response similar to yours, I'm glad you put in effort for extra context lol. I love biology so freaking much 💜💙💚

I feel like the mentions of going to outer space are the characters' predictions of the future (the same as what humans would predict), and not indications that space travel is already more widespread than it is in our world.

I love your vids

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

aww thanks so much

Do you agree with film Theory

@taraseomalley355

13 күн бұрын

Game Theory never dies❤

DID YOU MAKE A MATPAT REF-

So excited to see r opinion on this

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

hope you enjoy the video too!

Google "what happened S1E2 of Rick and Morty". Google will say "Morty's dog got super smart and at the end of the episode, the dog takes all the other dogs on earth and takes them to a new place away from humans". Then, hundreds of years pass. This is that universe. MATPAT COME BACK WE NEED YOU FOR THIS ONE

I agree with this!

I don’t even believe in evolution, but it’s still a really great video. Keep up the great work.

@evangeloevoxi

22 күн бұрын

I'm a Christian who believes in evolution because it's been proven through science. We don't know everything about the world or universe we live in, but it's unbelievably irresponsible to refuse to believe facts.

@ExplosionMare

22 күн бұрын

@@evangeloevoxi Same here. I like to think that when God reset the world after Adam and Eve, he started it over with evolution. I know in the first few days of the original Earth that the animals came first and everything, but perhaps this time around he made humans at a slower pace to see if sin was still a part of them or not, or something like that. Perhaps it's possible that Adam and Eve look a lot different than how we imagine them.

@mcweekly0

22 күн бұрын

@@evangeloevoxi OK listen I’ve never met a Christian who believes in evolution. But I don’t want get into a disagreement. I’m a nice guy so I respect your opinion.

@evangeloevoxi

21 күн бұрын

​@@mcweekly0 you'd be surprised how many of us there are 😅 tons of religious or spiritual scientists out there. Scientists understand that we as humans don't know everything, and that makes many of them open to unusual or different ideas, including spiritually-based ideas. Not everyone obviously, but some people. Have a good life!! 🙏🏻💚💙💜

@evangeloevoxi

21 күн бұрын

​@@ExplosionMare I can't get into details of my creation theory/big bang theory or I'd write a book lol. I just believe the Bible is extremely metaphorical, and it was written by ancient humans who had little understanding of their world, and they based their beliefs on spoken teachings before they even understood how to write. Over thousands of years men worked together to try to bring the word of God to life. That resulted in multiple religious texts over the thousands of years, including Christian texts. Anyway sorry that's all I'm typing for now.... Have a good life!! 🙏🏻💜💙💚

i'm thinking, since many animals that are normally on two legs, often get up on their back legs to move around a little easier, the dogs in the bluey universe did the same. over time, they adapted the muscles for walking like that and they eventually found it uncomfortable, to carry things in their mouths, so they started using their front legs like arms. dogs do have a thumb claw, it's just shorter then animals like rodents. what i'm curious about is the lack of representation of the most iconic animal in Australia, other then the dingo, the koala. wasn't the show blinky bill, recorded in a studio in Brisbane?

7:02 This caught me off guard. From Normal to Skinny to Plastic💀

Thoughts on bingo and dougie?

Bluey's breed the Australian cattle dog was being Exist since the 1800s and bluey family did being in my headcanon

But hey thats just a theory A FILM THEORY!

At least it's not as unlikely as some of the theories of the Pixar Cars universe.

One thats always got me, Rustys Dad 'in the Army' who are they at war against or potentially need to defend against [cats ?]

I am from israel and love bluey so much also mekunzi in season one is refered to female in the hebrew dub and after season one he reffered to male and i saw his breed on the street i love your vids

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

hey! thats so interesting, i always love to hear what bluey is like in different countries thank you for sharing!

@user-gi5cd9rc6v

22 күн бұрын

@@aussiegirlmargie thanks

@anisa2273

22 күн бұрын

@@aussiegirlmargie im sure you like to know how it;s like i n different coutnries, but this guy is from a nonexistent one... so sad

The fact they need there hands for tools could also be why they needed to stand on there legs ... cant use your hand if they are on the ground

8:39 I think robotic dogs will appear in 2070s and the action of last scenes of "Surprise" take place in early 2050s

As a creature designer absolutely obsessed with biology, especially canids and felids..... I would imagine if the ape ancestors never took the niche that they did to eventually evolve into humans, in the Bluey world the canines would. But I think it would have been kind of a parallel, like the kings and queens would be pugs or shih tzu, while the farmers and police dogs would be Anatolian Shepherds or Schnauzers, respectively.

Can you do a video about Pat (Lucky’s dad) next?

I love learingabout Evolution

Here’s mine: So when humans went extinct dogs evolved to cave dogs but then they discovered technology humans used so they decided to be like humans by acting like humans it also happened to cats and they also discovered human technology but dogs and cats went to a war and Chili’s dad aka grandad was in the war and he met a nurse when he was hurt and him and the nurse got married once the war was over and also a law was made and it was that cats were not allowed from Australia and the uk So that’s my evolution

I do think that the blue reverse is a parallel universe, but I think that humans had to exist at some point. I think that something killed them off that wasn’t dogs. I think that humans only lived long enough to make a little bit of technology and then the dogs had to learn how to survive on their own Which is why they have technology same as today is age so it can’t be based on today’s future. I think that flatpack is really just a game the kids played.

Maybe it’s season four Bluey finally has a little sibling and if she had another sister, her name would be blossom and if it’s a boy Benson

Interesting that ins't any mention to wolves but if wolves exist in they universe, they will be like chimpanzee(to us) or like a native of a tribe(like natives to us)?

@JamesDavy2009

22 күн бұрын

Given where it takes place, I can see wolves being equivalent to Indigenous people.

I have a theory, why almost everytime someone mentions Pat/luckys dad, everyone always say Lucky's dad even the adults! Is somthing wrong with his name? Is he uncomfortable?

Lion guard theory why did Kion lift Pride Rock

What abt mr monkeyjocks?exactly

Probably is a pararell world without humans, maybe in the world of Bluey anthro dogs are not the only talking anthro animals, maybe somewhere there are the anthro talking cats in the world of Bluey.

It kinda locks like socks ngl it could be socks!

It mostly makes sense, but there's one breed that doesn't make sense than - specifically, Pugs. Most of the other breeds make sense with this line of thinking (like how certain professions might encourage certain traits over time, and even how families with similar jobs might pick up a similar trait. This would be like how both sides of my family are very detailed-oriented since I have: an accountant, a editor, a needle-pointer, and a former teacher as grandparents). Why have a dog that literally has a breathing disorder if it's meant to have positive traits from a family line?

@JamesDavy2009

22 күн бұрын

My headcanon is that pug dogs are a result of blue-blooded rich dogs not wanting to breed with have-not breeds (e.g. cattle dogs like the Heelers).

@Shadowcat753

22 күн бұрын

@@JamesDavy2009 I might believe that if the actual Queen of England in Bluey was a Pug or something, but the only Pugs we see in Bluey seem like everyday dogs. So, it doesn't make sense unless they lost their royal status or something.

@JamesDavy2009

22 күн бұрын

@@Shadowcat753 No, she's the dog on the 5 dollabuck bill.

@Shadowcat753

22 күн бұрын

@@JamesDavy2009 No, we have the racist old pug and Buddy the Pug as the only two pugs. The royal dogs are Charles Spaniels instead. The dogs on the bills all have ears that are too long looking to be pugs.

❤

I have an idea that are world is in the same world just on the other side of the solar system but how can this work? Well humans probably could have put multiple dog breads female and male and they had pups and some how they eventually went upright and the humans couldn’t handle the journey so they died and left there human things and they used it to make things like houses and cars and eventually drowns

How about a theory about who the baby shower is for in daddy put down

I would just like to remind everyone that evolution is also just a theory. It probably is true, according to the evidence, but everyone seems to treat it as fact.

@JamesDavy2009

22 күн бұрын

That's because a scientific theory is a proven fact as opposed to a scientific hypothesis. There still exist holes in a lot of scientific theories, but that doesn't mean they're wrong (as Stan Marsh points out)-astrophysics still uses two contradicting theories (general relativity and quantum mechanics) to explain our understanding of the universe. You can see evolution on smaller scales through the studies of viruses and bacteria. It's how the SARS virus from 20 years ago evolved a variant that caused the more recent pandemic and it's how superbugs came into existence through our mania for cleanliness.

New intro?

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

yeah i use it every now and again haha, im a bit slack with it sometimes

Humans did not come from monkeys. The Lord created us.

Wwo❤

What if the characters in Bluey aren't actually dogs at all? What if they're actually human, but fictionalized to be portrayed as dogs! Because now that you mention it, it really doesn't make sense for dogs to evolve this way, especially considering all the man-made breeds. Now my headcanon is that the world where the events of Bluey actually happen is our Earth with human children and parents, then someone takes those events and animates them in a world of talking dogs with some minor changes to make some things more in line with canines. There is a hidden layer of Bluey where the characters are actually humans, but when shown to us, they are converted to canines!

@evangeloevoxi

22 күн бұрын

I mean..... That's basically what animation is. You understand the concept of Bluey now lol

@TiMoThY211991

20 күн бұрын

@evangeloevoxi More that there's an extra fictional layer between us the viewers and the world shown in the bluey show, where the events of the show actually (fictionally) happen, but with humans, before converting the events and stories to animated canines for our viewing pleasure. It is a bit convoluted, I grant, but it seems like the best way to explain away certain incongruities and inconsistencies in the worldbuilding, without labeling them as outright mistakes.

There's a better, more realistic way, to explain how the wolves evolved to dogs in the alt world. Dogs today are Already beginning to learn how to use their paws in a more dexterous way, my own dog Holds up toys with her paws and manipulates her digits to get a better grip. As evolution goes, if that was a needed trait to survive: then that's how they'd evolve. The successful wolves with more dexterous hangs would live longer and produce more. Over time, that trait would become more and more prominent, leading to hands. Hands cannot support the full weight of running and the force that would ve exeted onto them if running in all 4 limbs. The wrists would crumble, the digits would snap. As hands became needed and unable to support such motion, so too does the need to move in that way less. Having highly evolved brains and being able to use tools also likely meant they were farming their food and didn't Need to chase it down. As wolves became civilized, they eventually started taking on similar traits to those around them. Forming different breeds in different parts of the world, until we get to the current bluey time when civilizations are mixing

In my opinion yes or no

Slay

Oh Haaaiiii! (ﾉ◕ヮ◕)ﾉ*:･ﾟ✧

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

Hey!!

They just using their imagination to play like other animals they might've seen at the zoo or something.

Hi

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

gday!

Hello

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

gday :)

69%

I’m not sure, honestly I am just not trying to dig into that 😅

Hii

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

gday!

But what do you think is the religion of bluey family ? For me they are either Protestant Christians or atheists

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

honestly hard to tell, and due to ABC (australia) regulations they cant technically show any religious iconography. but because most australians religious or not celebrate easter and christmas we could have those episodes

@danielatunno9202

22 күн бұрын

@@aussiegirlmargie but what religion have you alweys imagined them to have ?

I swear yoy already did this exact same video.

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

Yup see pinned comment! I had to Re-edit it cause the music I used initially changed licenses so it was copyrighted and I had to take it out and reupload it

o o ohio welcome to my skibidi toilet

First!

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

so fast!

ᝯׁ֒⁠ᨵׁׅׅ⁠ᨵׁׅׅ⁠ᥣׁׅ֪

But why on the episode the sign the terriers said to wintin’s mom said “my mom is in love with your dad” I think

Lol

You should do a theory about if the blind dogs from the sign are actually blind because when they are by the binoculars and they see them even though they’re fur is covering their eye

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

i definitely want to do a deep dive on them

@Corajade1869

22 күн бұрын

@@aussiegirlmargie ok

First

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

thanks for getting here so quick!

Haha first

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

woo hoo so fast!

@ameliaabed-fq6yc

22 күн бұрын

OMG YOU ACTUALLY REPLIED I FEEL LIKE A CELEBRITY I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS

Me a Christian and I think God made us no evolve thing

this video is sentered around false things. Eveloution is fake. We did not evovle from monkeys. God created us. I know that this is just a show, but this video does not make sence. ( sry bout my spelling )

First

@aussiegirlmargie

22 күн бұрын

woohoooo!!!! thanks for coming to watch