Anyone watching this video who thinks anything that this man has just said is wrong does not understand FIBA basketball rules. This is a very good educational video.
@21beal212 жыл бұрын
Fantastic vid, I struggle differentiating and this helps huge!!
@jeffotte66724 жыл бұрын
The comments prove how many different opinions on refereeing there are
@TheOfficialQU4KE5 жыл бұрын
If anything, I think the play at 5:40 isn't a charge, but a push or illegal elbow. Still an offensive foul, but not really a charging call.
@rileynorton5062 Жыл бұрын
Play at 2:54 is not a charge but rather a push. The foul type is “charging with the ball” but offence passes the ball before contact is made. Offensive push correct call.
@STANIS-LA-ROCHELLE Жыл бұрын
What a very GREAT video, thanks a lot💪🏻🏀
@discbandsforbasketballoffi26182 жыл бұрын
Discbands Alternate Possession Wristband is a new & helpful accessory for officials. Be professional. Be right.
@Krittin05 жыл бұрын
First situation If it isn't clear that Red used the left arm to push White away, then it's a block.
@dr.shobhitsharma62723 жыл бұрын
The first two were right calls , because the defenders were still in motion if the defenders had stopped and stabled themselves then it would have been a charge by the offensive player
@dr.shobhitsharma6272
3 жыл бұрын
White 8 (1:10 ) still in motion and haven’t took a standing defensive position and is still going back , ( 2:13 )look carefully at red 7’s feet they are still in motion going back with the incoming white 15 .
@asapmimic1289
3 жыл бұрын
You don’t have to be not moving too take a charge. You can be moving and defending and still take the charge. That’s why there’s a difference between legal guarding positions and non legal.
@bartpatton3409
6 ай бұрын
@@asapmimic1289 i don't think you quite understand what you are saying.. for a legal guarding position, your feet are set, amd your shoulders are square. A tilt in the shoulders to follow the offensive players momentum nullifies the charge and makes it a blocking foul.. automatically.
@asapmimic1289
6 ай бұрын
@@bartpatton3409 no I understand what I’m saying. A legal guarding position must be established before contact. Once a legal guarding position is established the defensive player is allowed to move laterally or obliquely to maintain the guarding of the player. The defender no longer has to keep his hips or shoulders square to the dribbler once legal guarding position is established. The defender has as much of a right to his spot on the floor as the dribbler, so in order to identify a block or charge you must identify who had the right to that spot when contact occurs. Who moved into who to gain an advantage.
@MS-ho9wq
16 күн бұрын
One of the biggest misconceptions among non-refs (and some who call themselves refs) is the idea that the defensive player is not allowed to move while defending. You don't have to stand still like a statue as a defender. smh, why do so many people think this is how it works?
@jamesroberts8275 жыл бұрын
I could only stand to watch the first few scenarios of this video. At least in the beginning the officials were CORRECT in their calls as the defenders did not have their feet set and are moving into the way of the offense as they drive
@user-xu7db8oc1y5 жыл бұрын
If the defender is backing up when u dribble with your back to the basket, slowly getting forward, would it be a charging foul or would it not be called as the defender is moving
@coopzr
5 жыл бұрын
That is called a post play. There is going to be some resistance from both players (Defensive player trying to keep his position and offensive player trying to get closer to the basket) and as long as they are both resisting and respecting each others positions - then it shouldn't be any foul. However it is a foul by an offensive player or defensive player to shoulder or hip his opponent out of position.
@Saintzel
4 жыл бұрын
If a defender has legal guarding position, he or she may move backwards or laterally while maintaining legal guarding position. A post offensive player may back his opponent down as long as they don't impede on their defender's ability to play defense (i.e. shoving them so that they fall or they are backed up too far)
@drago48039 ай бұрын
12.09 how the **** is that a charge?? The defence moved in after take off. How can u expect someone to control himself post take off??
@hilbertp7 жыл бұрын
I have a question regarding the scene on 8:17. It should be legal defense, weren't it for the use of white's right forearm, wouldn't it?
@gameguru1234
7 жыл бұрын
If you look at his left knee, it is clearly outside of the defender's natural cylinder, so I don't blame the trail official for calling a block here.
@the_joker7020
5 жыл бұрын
contact occurs on right should, right arm and left arm, almost no contact on the torso => No legal defence
@andrimaulana62624 ай бұрын
But today was different, cause nowadays have semi circle area..
@ailenortado2827 ай бұрын
😊
@22gomdory4 жыл бұрын
nba rule and international rule are different?
@stevetuohy5629
3 жыл бұрын
FIBA set the rules, but almost every league around the world makes slight changes to suit their style. It makes it hard to referee games between multiple leagues
@user-rc7lx4jp9f6 жыл бұрын
On 9:14, did the defender actually move towards to the offensive player? In my opinion, the defender moved laterally thus the movement was legal.
@7heLostAndDamned
5 жыл бұрын
No expert myself but in the video it looks like the defender was moving into the attacker's current trajectory and is late (very important point); a legal movement would be legal containment instead of illegal body interception, or setting a charge beforehand. This scenario was mainly about who got there first.
@Michael.S.Ryan.5 жыл бұрын
This video helps a lot
@JasonBrand79
5 жыл бұрын
Michael Ryan it’s a bad video
@rotciv4ever116
3 жыл бұрын
@@JasonBrand79 why?
@batanggamaytv28 Жыл бұрын
Can these still be applied in 2022 FIBA rules?
@MS-ho9wq
6 ай бұрын
Probably not a great reference anymore, unfortunately (despite being a well-put-together video). They still have the old-timey keyhole-shaped restricted area here without a no-charge semicircle, so I'd especially ignore anything close to the basket in this vid.
@cunha47913 жыл бұрын
what is he calling restricted area?
@russellwestbrook87475 жыл бұрын
90
@deyongrant31313 жыл бұрын
hang on like is there no restricted area?
@samsubby8371
3 жыл бұрын
Deyon Grant Back in 2004, there wasn't.
@stdenis175 жыл бұрын
what I understood from the video - referees on olympic games are dorks )))))
@faithhopecharity28433 жыл бұрын
Waiitt a minute. If the purpose of defending & blocking is to impede your opponent's progress towards the ring, then why at 8:20 is called a foul. Damn man, those rules make basketball soft. Not good. Not good.
@tyh41805 жыл бұрын
Had to stop watchin this video after the first clip. Jus WRONG
Пікірлер: 41
Anyone watching this video who thinks anything that this man has just said is wrong does not understand FIBA basketball rules. This is a very good educational video.
Fantastic vid, I struggle differentiating and this helps huge!!
The comments prove how many different opinions on refereeing there are
If anything, I think the play at 5:40 isn't a charge, but a push or illegal elbow. Still an offensive foul, but not really a charging call.
Play at 2:54 is not a charge but rather a push. The foul type is “charging with the ball” but offence passes the ball before contact is made. Offensive push correct call.
What a very GREAT video, thanks a lot💪🏻🏀
Discbands Alternate Possession Wristband is a new & helpful accessory for officials. Be professional. Be right.
First situation If it isn't clear that Red used the left arm to push White away, then it's a block.
The first two were right calls , because the defenders were still in motion if the defenders had stopped and stabled themselves then it would have been a charge by the offensive player
@dr.shobhitsharma6272
3 жыл бұрын
White 8 (1:10 ) still in motion and haven’t took a standing defensive position and is still going back , ( 2:13 )look carefully at red 7’s feet they are still in motion going back with the incoming white 15 .
@asapmimic1289
3 жыл бұрын
You don’t have to be not moving too take a charge. You can be moving and defending and still take the charge. That’s why there’s a difference between legal guarding positions and non legal.
@bartpatton3409
6 ай бұрын
@@asapmimic1289 i don't think you quite understand what you are saying.. for a legal guarding position, your feet are set, amd your shoulders are square. A tilt in the shoulders to follow the offensive players momentum nullifies the charge and makes it a blocking foul.. automatically.
@asapmimic1289
6 ай бұрын
@@bartpatton3409 no I understand what I’m saying. A legal guarding position must be established before contact. Once a legal guarding position is established the defensive player is allowed to move laterally or obliquely to maintain the guarding of the player. The defender no longer has to keep his hips or shoulders square to the dribbler once legal guarding position is established. The defender has as much of a right to his spot on the floor as the dribbler, so in order to identify a block or charge you must identify who had the right to that spot when contact occurs. Who moved into who to gain an advantage.
@MS-ho9wq
16 күн бұрын
One of the biggest misconceptions among non-refs (and some who call themselves refs) is the idea that the defensive player is not allowed to move while defending. You don't have to stand still like a statue as a defender. smh, why do so many people think this is how it works?
I could only stand to watch the first few scenarios of this video. At least in the beginning the officials were CORRECT in their calls as the defenders did not have their feet set and are moving into the way of the offense as they drive
If the defender is backing up when u dribble with your back to the basket, slowly getting forward, would it be a charging foul or would it not be called as the defender is moving
@coopzr
5 жыл бұрын
That is called a post play. There is going to be some resistance from both players (Defensive player trying to keep his position and offensive player trying to get closer to the basket) and as long as they are both resisting and respecting each others positions - then it shouldn't be any foul. However it is a foul by an offensive player or defensive player to shoulder or hip his opponent out of position.
@Saintzel
4 жыл бұрын
If a defender has legal guarding position, he or she may move backwards or laterally while maintaining legal guarding position. A post offensive player may back his opponent down as long as they don't impede on their defender's ability to play defense (i.e. shoving them so that they fall or they are backed up too far)
12.09 how the **** is that a charge?? The defence moved in after take off. How can u expect someone to control himself post take off??
I have a question regarding the scene on 8:17. It should be legal defense, weren't it for the use of white's right forearm, wouldn't it?
@gameguru1234
7 жыл бұрын
If you look at his left knee, it is clearly outside of the defender's natural cylinder, so I don't blame the trail official for calling a block here.
@the_joker7020
5 жыл бұрын
contact occurs on right should, right arm and left arm, almost no contact on the torso => No legal defence
But today was different, cause nowadays have semi circle area..
😊
nba rule and international rule are different?
@stevetuohy5629
3 жыл бұрын
FIBA set the rules, but almost every league around the world makes slight changes to suit their style. It makes it hard to referee games between multiple leagues
On 9:14, did the defender actually move towards to the offensive player? In my opinion, the defender moved laterally thus the movement was legal.
@7heLostAndDamned
5 жыл бұрын
No expert myself but in the video it looks like the defender was moving into the attacker's current trajectory and is late (very important point); a legal movement would be legal containment instead of illegal body interception, or setting a charge beforehand. This scenario was mainly about who got there first.
This video helps a lot
@JasonBrand79
5 жыл бұрын
Michael Ryan it’s a bad video
@rotciv4ever116
3 жыл бұрын
@@JasonBrand79 why?
Can these still be applied in 2022 FIBA rules?
@MS-ho9wq
6 ай бұрын
Probably not a great reference anymore, unfortunately (despite being a well-put-together video). They still have the old-timey keyhole-shaped restricted area here without a no-charge semicircle, so I'd especially ignore anything close to the basket in this vid.
what is he calling restricted area?
90
hang on like is there no restricted area?
@samsubby8371
3 жыл бұрын
Deyon Grant Back in 2004, there wasn't.
what I understood from the video - referees on olympic games are dorks )))))
Waiitt a minute. If the purpose of defending & blocking is to impede your opponent's progress towards the ring, then why at 8:20 is called a foul. Damn man, those rules make basketball soft. Not good. Not good.
Had to stop watchin this video after the first clip. Jus WRONG