Beyerdynamic M88 (2023 Version) Review - Earthworks Ethos & Shure SM58 (USA) For Comparison

Музыка

00:00 Introduction
02:12 What Does The Manufacturer Say?
05:05 Frequency Response & Polar Pattern
07:34 Close-ups & Accessories - Comparison With SM58 Visually
17:23 What I Notice Immediately - On Plugging In
20:31 Tonally Matching An SM58
22:18 How Am I Invited To Phonate & Sing?
23:55 Bringing It Closer, EQ'ing The Proximity Out & Comparing To The SM58
25:44 Low Female Voice Proximity Lift Compared To SM58
27:37 Breath Tones Resolution
28:58 Sibilance, Whoosh & Pops Compared to SM58
31:10 Handling Noise
32:11 Summary
36:59 The Porsche 911 Analogy
40:54 Mr. Manual Takes The Beyerdynamic M88 (2023 Version) For A Spin

Пікірлер: 36

  • @freebeerecords
    @freebeerecords9 ай бұрын

    Many thanks Anton, nobody susses out mics like you. Your thorough, comprehensive side by side comparisons are really helpful, and quite enjoyable as well!

  • @AaronPerkinsMusic
    @AaronPerkinsMusic3 ай бұрын

    I just sang on this version yesterday and really enjoyed singing on it. I’m keeping it in my top 2 to use. Love the low end on it.

  • @stallionproductions666
    @stallionproductions6669 ай бұрын

    Well done! :)

  • @AntonBrowne

    @AntonBrowne

    9 ай бұрын

    Thanks! 😊

  • @user-nx5on7qu6d
    @user-nx5on7qu6d5 ай бұрын

    I have probably 30-40 handheld vocal dynamic and condenser mics. Thanks to watching your videos, I've learned so much about vocal technique. Wish I'd paid more attention years ago! Up until recently, my favourite was an AKG535eb and I under-used my Limited Edition (silver) M88TG. The handing noise is very noticeable (so now I handle it more carefully) and the plosives have been controlled much better by using a foam cover on the screen, which cuts down on the breath noise. Thanks to you, I've learned to point the mic at the corner of my mouth and am much more of aware of distance between mouth and mic when singing. All good stuff. Of all my mics, the M88TG (used properly) is now my favourite, it's soooo smooth and full and suits my baritone voice the best. I have some nice old Audio Technica mics (ATM61HE is lovely) which sound good, so maybe you should take a look at the AE6100. Thanks for all your videos, I've learned so much! Keep up the great work.

  • @AntonBrowne

    @AntonBrowne

    5 ай бұрын

    Well, thank you so much. Very glad to of been of help on your journey.

  • @josku5
    @josku59 ай бұрын

    I’d love to see you review the AKG D5 at some point! It’s relatively inexpencive at around 90€ new and I find it to be a good competitor for the sm58. I’d very much like to see your style of very in depth review of it ☺️

  • @edword3457
    @edword34577 ай бұрын

    Excellent review as always! I would be interested in a direct comparison with the SE v7x with the v7 foam&mesh Thanks!

  • @stallionproductions666
    @stallionproductions6669 ай бұрын

    I am loving my M88s too. Owning a M88 nc and the 90th Anniversary

  • @boonfire3714
    @boonfire37147 ай бұрын

    Works great on kick 👍

  • @ruiteles817
    @ruiteles8178 ай бұрын

    Hello. Great video as always. I'm a baritone/bass I'm singing with a telefunken m80, not completely happy. I'm thinking to change it to a beyerdynamic m88 tg. What is your opinion. Thank you so much

  • @jtops3000
    @jtops30006 ай бұрын

    Great microphone review. I noticed that you haven’t reviewed any Audix, Audio Audiotecnica, or Electro-Voice. I’d be interested to see how they compare to the Beyer.

  • @Ricky_007
    @Ricky_0079 ай бұрын

    Pls compare with AKG D5C... which can down to 20Hz...

  • @tom_k_d
    @tom_k_d9 ай бұрын

    I had the M88TG for testing, and returned it - solely because it let trough too much pops and plosives. So the big elephant in the room here: does the new grille perform as good as the vintage one again?

  • @AntonBrowne

    @AntonBrowne

    9 ай бұрын

    I'm planning on a comparison across those that I have - 70's to TG, to the new one. So far I have had difficulty spotting a difference between the 2023 and the old pre TG ones, in any regard other than cosmetic!

  • @tom_k_d

    @tom_k_d

    9 ай бұрын

    @AntonBrowne Thanks Anton, that's excellent news - still looking forward to your comparison, prior to pulling the final trigger...

  • @scot_smith
    @scot_smith9 ай бұрын

    Greetings, Anton! Thanks for another thorough comparison and review! On the company name pronunciation of Beyerdynamic, I wonder (and I speak with no authority) if they chose the English word 'dynamic' intentionally as Beyer wanted to become a global electronics company. Otherwise why not call it Beyerdynamisch? While [doo]namisch is in the German wörterbuch I couldn't find [doo]namic.

  • @AntonBrowne

    @AntonBrowne

    9 ай бұрын

    Well, I just went on what my German friend told me but of course, I could tell you at least three different pronunciations of 'yesterday' from across the length and breadth of the UK, so... I'm happy to be corrected.

  • @SlavkoStorm
    @SlavkoStorm9 ай бұрын

    And when things settle down, is this 2023 version as good as the old vintage one?

  • @AntonBrowne

    @AntonBrowne

    8 ай бұрын

    So far, so indistinguishable!

  • @Ricky_007
    @Ricky_0079 ай бұрын

    So is it better to compare with the tg m88 ?

  • @AntonBrowne

    @AntonBrowne

    9 ай бұрын

    A deep dive across the models I have is to come.

  • @Ricky_007

    @Ricky_007

    6 ай бұрын

    @@AntonBrowne Thanks Anton. I have a TG M88 and a TG V70. I am considering to buy a M88 (2023 version). What is your opinion ? I highly appreciate your suggestion . (for vocal singing)

  • @romerbass2813
    @romerbass28137 ай бұрын

    Rule no.1:Tthe mic clip ALWAYS lives at or with the microphone! Never leave it at the mic stand, when taking of your microphone. Besides that, I loved this comparison a lot. As a singer and voice over artist am using the M88(from the mid 80s) for years and am very happy with it.

  • @phatboyzband831
    @phatboyzband8319 ай бұрын

    Anton I've asked you to try the Beyer tgx80 mic best mic on planet Earth!!! Please get one try it !!!

  • @paulcarruthers9489

    @paulcarruthers9489

    9 ай бұрын

    I totally agree,I’ve swapped from an SM58 after spotting one for trades,never looked back.

  • @jm6734
    @jm67348 ай бұрын

    Recording vox - does the M88 pick up the room? Home recording.

  • @thegreatsiberianitch

    @thegreatsiberianitch

    8 ай бұрын

    Every mic picks up the room, but it depends upon how loud your source is and the directionality of the mic, how open or tight the pick-up pattern is. Louder sounds equal higher sound pressure levels pushing against the walls, that is what interacts with the room. If you whisper into a mic in a giant room you won't hear the room, you'll also need better preamps so the mic will pick up quiet sounds... If you're singing loudly in little bedroom you will hear the room. You work with it by positioning and direction of the mic in the room because of how sound waves travel. Different spots/directions will sound better or worse. The best way to get the best results with any mic is to experiment. People like to say the SM7B "doesn't pick up the room" because it's a dynamic mic... I think the sm7b is marketed cause they know people will have to buy more gear to make the mic happy cause it's so gain hungry. Maybe best to start with a sm58 or sm57 and work up from there. Shure KSM27 is also a good all around starting mic that no one talks about, kind of cheap used. Its a condenser though and people say that it will "pick up the room" because of that, but if you filter off some of the highs it will be more like the frequency response of a dynamic and you won't have to crank the gain like some dynamic mics. It's whatever, that's just some my experience.

  • @alexmegavolt9010
    @alexmegavolt90109 ай бұрын

    I think Anton is biased against the m88. He likes them. Nostalgia. This video shows it. But I'm disappointed. For its price, the microphone is frankly bad. The song at the end sounded terrible. The singer is good, we have heard this song on the channel many times. But the microphone is terrible. Incredibly, the sm58 in this comparison, in my opinion, won.

  • @thegreatsiberianitch

    @thegreatsiberianitch

    8 ай бұрын

    Nothing about the end of this video was "terrible". Maybe you have a bias because you listen to a lot of over processed recordings where computers are more dominant than humans? And "biased against", means "don't like", not "like". "Like" is when you have a "bias for". Like you having a bias for the sm58. I can't speak for this 2023 version definitively but I know personally that the m88 tg is a way better microphone than an sm58. It hasn't existed for this long because no one was willing to pay the premium for it. As is true with many other mics. As in it's being a tool for recording sound. Whether or not it's worth the money is based upon your use case, budget and experience. But to say the 58 "won" when it wasn't even performed with at the end is logically and objectively pure bias on your part. Idk man, "terrible", really? I don't think it was anywhere near "terrible", the recording or the performance.

  • @alexmegavolt9010

    @alexmegavolt9010

    8 ай бұрын

    @@thegreatsiberianitch Dude, in case you haven't noticed, the video compares two microphones by different parameters. Based on this, we can conclude that the m88 is a failure. And if you listen to the song in the finale, there will be no doubt about the previous statement. If you can't hear this, change the speakers, or clean your ears.

  • @thegreatsiberianitch

    @thegreatsiberianitch

    7 ай бұрын

    @@alexmegavolt9010 your ability to reason is very flawed

  • @alexmegavolt9010

    @alexmegavolt9010

    7 ай бұрын

    @@thegreatsiberianitch Go away. Think again. You can do it, we believe in you. Then come back.

  • @christopherkiyui8071

    @christopherkiyui8071

    6 ай бұрын

    ​@@thegreatsiberianitchI fully agree with you.

  • @josku5
    @josku59 ай бұрын

    I’d love to see you review the AKG D5 at some point! It’s relatively inexpencive at around 90€ new and I find it to be a good competitor for the sm58. I’d very much like to see your style of very in depth review of it ☺️

Келесі