BEST Waterproof Case? Catalyst Waterproof vs. LifeProof Fre vs. Ghostek Nautical - iPhone XS

Ғылым және технология

The BEST waterproof case for the iPhone XS? I'd go with the Catalyst waterproof over the LIfeProof Fre and Ghostek Nautical. Why? Because at the end of the day, I can stomach using it on a day-to-day basis. I can’t say the same for the other two products.
The standout features of the Catalyst is the handling and overall design.
The Nautical is going to be the toughest, best looking case after a couple of drops.
The Fre is just bleh. The screen protector still makes your screen look like it’s from 2012. And it’s the most expensive case in this group. And despite my minor disdain for the case, it still might be worth getting.
Here's what I cover in this video:
00:01:31 - Design
00:05:11 - Functionality
00:10:03 - Protection
00:12:44 - Why waterproof cases SUCK
Support me by using my Amazon links to get your stuff!
--Catalyst Waterproof on Amazon!
Amazon US: mreh.ca/2wulGvj
Amazon CA: mreh.ca/2wC8aWH
--Ghostek Nautical on Amazon!
Amazon US: mreh.ca/2Ppi5qc
Amazon CA: mreh.ca/2Pox9Er
--LifeProof Fre on Amazon!
Amazon US: mreh.ca/2orGEqe
Amazon CA: mreh.ca/2ord5VW
-DESIGN-
When it comes to design, waterproof cases are going to be larger than the average case. That extra protection comes at the expense of handling but that shouldn’t be a surprise.
Out of the three cases, the largest case is the Ghostek Nautical. It’s a beast of a case but it’s designed in a way that the extra size doesn’t degrade the handling of the iPhone too much. The slimmest case is the Catalyst Waterproof.
When it comes to build quality, I didn’t have any issues with either case being flimsy and all cases fit quite well together. All three cases won’t slide around easily on a flat surface. The case that’s going to slide around the least is going to be the Catalyst Waterproof.
When it comes to overall wear and tear, the Ghostek Nautical is going to show the least amount of damage over time. The Catalyst case has a clear back which will scratch over time and the rubber edge doesn’t look pretty after a couple of sidewalk drops.
The Fre’s back is still a sink for minor scratches and the corners of the case will still show a bit of damage after a sidewalk drop.
The LIfeProof Fre is 90 dollars, the Catalyst is 80 and the Nautical is a paltry 35.
-FUNCTIONALITY-
In general, the performance of the iPhone is going to suffer a bit with any waterproof case. The plastic screen protectors are going to mess with the iPhone X’s OLED screen. The buttons are going to be tougher to use and sound is going to be muted. These are all downers BUT that’s the cost of protection.
I didn’t have any issues with accessing my port with any of the cases. The camera on the iPhone X performed normally as each case had separate lenses for each camera and foam to prevent light leaking in the lens during flash photography.
-PROTECTION-
When it comes to protection, the LifeProof Fre is going to offer you above average day to day protection. From a protection standpoint, it doesn’t offer anything above average.
If you want to go a little more extreme, you’ll need to consider the Catalyst or the Ghostek Nautical. The Nautical is going to offer the most drop protection. Theoretically as Ghostek says the case will protect between 10-12 ft.
Now when it comes to water protection, the Catalyst waterproof is the clear winner as it will offer you 33ft of water protection. The other two cases provide only 6.6ft of water protection.
So at the end of the day, the Catalyst Waterproof is the best case out of this grouping. If I was to extend and compare relatively to all the other waterproof cases I’ve used for the iPhone 8’s, it’s still going to be the case to get if you need a bit of water protection.
The Nautical is an attractive product only in terms of price. If you need something that can take a hit and don’t want to pony up close to a hundred bucks, go with the Nautical.
Now the only reason I’d go with the LifeProof Fre. The Fre is the most Expensive in this grouping BUT with the additional cost, LifeProof has a warranty where they will pretty much replace the entire case if you pay for the shipping of the product.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Subscribe to stay in the loop! We release 2-3 videos a week so there's going to be something new every week. We're all about helping you get the most out of iOS so click Subscribe!
WEBSITE: www.mobilereviews-eh.ca
T-SHIRTS: mobilereviewseh.spreadshirt.com
PATREON: / mobilereviewseh
INSTAGRAM: / mobilereviewseh
TWITTER: / mobilereviewseh
AARON: / aaron_the_ho
FACEBOOK: / mobilereviewseh

Пікірлер: 249

  • @MobileReviewsEh
    @MobileReviewsEh5 жыл бұрын

    Here's how I've scored each case: Catalyst Waterproof: 4.3 Eh's out of 5 Ghostek Nautical: 4.0 Eh's out of 5 LifeProof Fre: 3.6 Eh's out of 5 Totally forgot to mention them in the video.

  • @harveytrevino2257

    @harveytrevino2257

    5 жыл бұрын

    Sorry, side note, I love how at the end you said, Go, and Monte ran away!!.. lol..

  • @Starwarsgames66

    @Starwarsgames66

    5 жыл бұрын

    MobileReviewsEh My problem with the catalyst waterproof case is it makes my screen look like crap. Although like you said every one of them has that problem

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    Had to prove he was a real dog!

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    I havne't come across any waterproof case that doesn't suck the life out of the screen...even ones with glass screen protectors (Love Mei, old Incipio Atlas & Lunatik Taktik). The lack of adhesive on the screen protector will always result in odd screen protector artifacts.

  • @rayroblesGP100

    @rayroblesGP100

    5 жыл бұрын

    MobileReviewsEh Just got my Catalyst Waterproof case for my IPhone XS & its awesome! But I noticed the buttons are stiff in a way where It doesn’t take much pressure to control the volume. The buttons work great when the back part of the case isn’t attached so I don’t know if I should contact Catalyst or not. Did you have the same problem as well??

  • @jacobgreenland2487
    @jacobgreenland24874 жыл бұрын

    It's not about just water. It's about dirt/dust/powder getting into the open holes. Not all of us work in cushy, clean office jobs.

  • @kristameldazy4775

    @kristameldazy4775

    2 жыл бұрын

    Agreed…I work in an office but I’m clumsy and I drop my phone in everything

  • @leviandhiro3596

    @leviandhiro3596

    2 жыл бұрын

    Facts

  • @zappamann
    @zappamann5 жыл бұрын

    Dropped my iphone 10 in the pool, must have been 3 or 4 seconds. Within 4 minutes, the iphone was ruined. Did not turn on and had water damage. YES. Waterproof cases are STILL needed. Trust this guy.

  • @brandondane4777
    @brandondane47775 жыл бұрын

    Dude. U forget about ppl that work in dirty jobs. Not office jobs. Water proof case dropped in tubs of oil. Trust me u want a fully sealed phone. Or dust and grit getting in the ear pieces.

  • @genegnome2556

    @genegnome2556

    5 жыл бұрын

    Exactly. I work in landscaping and I wanted my iPhone XS Max to be dirt/water/drop proof

  • @khs118

    @khs118

    4 жыл бұрын

    @@genegnome2556 So which case would you go with?

  • @khs118

    @khs118

    4 жыл бұрын

    Which case did you go for?

  • @ActionMax09

    @ActionMax09

    4 жыл бұрын

    Yep... Electrician in an Industrial environment surrounded by welders. Grinder Dust, Dirt, Oils, Copper... Etc. it either scratches the hell out of my phone or it messed them up... I bought an iPhone 11 Pro, and I didn't take my phone to work till my Catalyst Case came in... the Catalyst is my go to case nowadays as I wasn't impressed with the LifeProof FRÉ when I had it on a Galaxy S9 Plus.

  • @franzpolicarpio6642

    @franzpolicarpio6642

    4 жыл бұрын

    Isaac Pacheco welder here. Yes the grinding dust destroys the speakers of any phone. Any water proof case helps.

  • @mikes.8912
    @mikes.89125 жыл бұрын

    WOW! Great review! I’ve been a follower for a while. THIS video was spectacular! Loved the multitude of different shots, background music, the composition. The way you compared the three different products really drove home how different they are. Great job!

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    I've been working on my editing the last couple of months. Glad you noticed!

  • @RootSuitMan
    @RootSuitMan4 жыл бұрын

    I really appreciate you making a video with this Ghostek Nautical case. There aren’t many videos on it for some reason, and I def needed to see it in action.

  • @NicholoN
    @NicholoN4 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for this video. It's one of the best ones I've come across comparing recent model waterproof iphone cases, and I have a friend who works a job where a phone can fall into puddles of stuff you never want to have to think about being directly on your phone.

  • @LindsayShirk
    @LindsayShirk3 жыл бұрын

    One of the best comprehensive reviews for waterproof cases I've seen. Definitely helped me decide.

  • @DarthVirtus
    @DarthVirtus5 жыл бұрын

    I'm a relatively new viewer (4 weeks) and for whatever reason (ignorance, stupidity) I never realized that the husky asian guy in your clips of older videos was, in fact, you! I thought maybe he was one of your friends who, for whatever reason, stopped helping you with your videos. Wow, man, you've really gone through one hell of a body transformation. Nice job, and thanks for these great reviews.

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for the support! it's been neat watching the older videos and seeing how much I've changed over the years.

  • @andricheli
    @andricheli5 жыл бұрын

    Great video! I need a waterproof case during the spring and summer months, as we spend a lot of time in and around water. I usually always just use a Lifeproof case but was very disappointed to see that the screen protector on it still sucks and the company hasn’t made any significant improvements to the design. Think I’m going to check out Catalyst this year!

  • @jonlewis8884
    @jonlewis88844 жыл бұрын

    Hey, great video :) You gave the me a lot of very pertinent information and it helped me a lot with my decision making about waterproof phone cases. However you didn’t touch on the one thing I was very concerned about and that’s how well the person I’m talking too can hear me ! All of these waterproof phone cases make you sound like your underwater from the listeners perspective. The main thing I wanted to know was which one of these cases was the least obnoxious to the person I was speaking too. Also, my main attraction to a waterproof phone is the ability to use it in the shower. It sounds weird but it’s awesome to check your stocks or watch a video in shower so submersion isn’t the only application of a waterproof case. You make great product review videos , thank you for taking the time to make them and I hope my comment helps you a little bit.

  • @FerdySG
    @FerdySG5 жыл бұрын

    Love this new format with more music and action. ESP simple things like the iPhone and case side by side, then swing *poof* iphone is in the case. I know this format is overused by many youtubers, but I feel it works well. Great content! Been subscribed since 2015, I think. Many years, lost count.

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for the comment. I've been working on my editing the last couple of months. I'm actually really excited with the new format...the transitions seem to work really well when there is an actual point to them.

  • @PickleFace
    @PickleFace5 жыл бұрын

    Great and informative video as always 👌🏻

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    :)

  • @tomcronininc
    @tomcronininc3 жыл бұрын

    Just ordered my catalyst, thank you

  • @kabsatdario3584
    @kabsatdario35844 жыл бұрын

    Hello., im now o one of your hundred of thousands subscriber., i like the way you explain., thumbs up👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

  • @swms1021
    @swms10215 жыл бұрын

    Great review. Find you’re correct as to no improvements on the lifeproof. I work in a water rich environment so I want the extra protection

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    Phew. It's not just me.

  • @dannysonn6057
    @dannysonn60573 жыл бұрын

    thanks for the thorough review sir, helped me make up my indecisive mind on which one I should get from amazon haha. i'll use your link to help you out too! cheers

  • @BossPenguin
    @BossPenguin5 жыл бұрын

    Hey Aaron, nice editing :)

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    Thanks! It's been something I've been working on the last couple of months.

  • @pattycarljackson
    @pattycarljackson5 жыл бұрын

    I still buy waterproof cases just for the fact phones today say they are waterproof but they are not people still do get water damage on these phones and it is not covered under warranty.

  • @Hi-uv7nn

    @Hi-uv7nn

    5 жыл бұрын

    Same I bought the ghosttek just for waterproof

  • @FzjClay
    @FzjClay4 жыл бұрын

    Very good video. Very informative. Looking at the FRE for the XS and not sure if I will buy now.

  • @samiam732
    @samiam7325 жыл бұрын

    Great video. Always like your videos. What glasses are you wearing in this video? I like those too.

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    They are a brand called Japonism. Bought them a long time ago.

  • @vikingnorm6935
    @vikingnorm69355 жыл бұрын

    I bought the Fre with my XS Max,3 days later I bought the UAG Monarch, that & the Apple battery case seem to be my go to cases even though I own over 20, love the channel!!!

  • @Only1Krystal
    @Only1Krystal4 жыл бұрын

    Outdoors fishing, swimming and hiking YES we DO need a waterproof case! My son lost his iPhone 11 in a lake today and was not able to recover it so we will be investing in a phone pouch that floats! I’d like to see a review on two different waterproof cases sold frequently on Amazon one called Cozy Case and Sportlink. You definitely have some followers that want and need waterproof so please keep reviewing them. Thanks

  • @robertcameron8619
    @robertcameron86195 жыл бұрын

    I have 4 lifeproof fre cases for my Xs Max absolutely love them!

  • @noiisserpmii
    @noiisserpmii5 жыл бұрын

    Ok so ive had 3 iPhones in my life 4S, 6 & currently X for almost 1yr. With the 2 aforementioned phones i had the FRE. But like you said waterproof cases arent that important of an factor. Most important for me is protection of screen with a built in protector. Thats why i always liked the FRE. Is there any other cases that fully cover the phone besides these 3?

  • @hottolo
    @hottolo5 жыл бұрын

    Great editing!

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    :)

  • @rs7113
    @rs71134 жыл бұрын

    I have had Lifeproof Fre for several years and am still a big fan of the protection they offer. But they do have issues. Firstly, I got frequent complaints from my listeners that they could not hear me well. Secondly, the back and even the front scratched a ton and looked awful after a while. The front screen always seemed to get air into it, causing bubbles. And finally, and most important for me( since I take a lot of photos), the protector on the camera lens would get dirty and the picture quality would be bad. So this time I am trying out the Catalyst - non waterproof - with a screen protector. Let's see how this works out. PS. I plan on taking my phone outdoors a lot. Things I am going to watch is the drop protection, Camera protection and Sound clarity

  • @The_Spencer_Chronicles
    @The_Spencer_Chronicles5 жыл бұрын

    I pretty much have to use one of these cases. I am a wildland firefighter and having the phone in your pocket or sitting in your fireline pack you’ll collect tons of dust or dirt and ash. So you’d need that protection also from the dirt and rocks and or whatever falls into your pocket it could scratch up the screen. I’ve have a life proof fre and also a catalyst the catalyst was my favorite... I want to try to use the ghostek. I’m afraid to use a slim case with an screen protector since I know I’ll get dirt and all that in the ports and speakers...

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    Stay with the waterproof cases!

  • @DcYpHa2o4

    @DcYpHa2o4

    5 жыл бұрын

    Brent I can relate as I used to be in the mudding and taping of drywall and drywall dust is a definite killer of Phones I had a Lifeproof Case on my old 5S and it worked well but since Subscribing to this Man's Channel I've discovered Ghostek & am really considering a Nautical from them or a Covert I have a iPhone xR now

  • @tmings1208

    @tmings1208

    5 жыл бұрын

    Hmm, weekdays are a mix of too many office days mixed with weeks of field time walking thru wetlands and forests. And weekends on the water in a canoe or on a trail (think Provincial parks with canoe trails, not the nice camper camping) with SantaDog. Both waterproof and shock resistance matter and the day-to-day functionality won’t do in the outdooor context

  • @Wheeldude888
    @Wheeldude8885 жыл бұрын

    Fantastic video mate, I know your channel is dedicated to the iPhone but you seem like the most knowledgeable person on KZread when it comes to waterproof cases so was wondering what waterproof case would you recommend for the Samsung Galaxy S10? Thanks.

  • @blackbushido
    @blackbushido4 жыл бұрын

    Hello. Excellent videos!! I was wondering if the Catalyst has a case that has a screen protector?? Thank you for your timely response

  • @BIGBADWOOD
    @BIGBADWOOD5 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for a great 5 star video !

  • @Horvath0819
    @Horvath08195 жыл бұрын

    I work in a restaurant and always around water and do lots of boating. My galaxy s9 actually got ruined when i was at work and it fell into some blueberry glaze lol. I now have an iPhone X and just ordered the Ghostek Nautical 2 for it after watching this awesome review. Can’t wait to check it out and get some good protected for my iPhone X 👌

  • @kperttul
    @kperttul5 жыл бұрын

    I have the LifeProof for X and I must say that it feels like going 10 years back to resistive screens. The plastic on the camera is really bad: it has already scratches even though my I bought the cover last month. So the photos are unfocused and blurry. However there were two reasons I bought it, well three if you count that it was the only “more rugged cover” left in the store that day. Firstly, the X has glass back. One must cover it. Although my previous phone was 7 and I dropped it and it did not brake the glass, it bend the phone so much than one could see inside it. That brings me to the second reason I bought the cover: it feels robust. So I hope that the bend energy goes to the cover rather than to the phone. Now that the new phones have come out, I just might take the cover out and buy a more appealing one.

  • @i-DH
    @i-DH5 жыл бұрын

    I’ve used Lifeproof Fre for my iPhone 5 & Nuud for my iPhone 6 plus & frankly I would say that the most annoying thing about Lifeproof’s case is the audio for the mic during calls. Seriously everyone who calls me when using these 2 cases will say they can’t hear my voice clearly, I sound far from the phone. (And yes, removed the air from the case before closing the ports. So every call I got I ended up opening the charging port before answering or before making a call.

  • @mr.j-1592
    @mr.j-15924 жыл бұрын

    Thank you. For sharing the only reason I’m looking to get another waterproof case is because they’re the only ones that have a phone screen protection for the iPhone X you go to OtterBox you go to any other iPhone protector please and they don’t have a front screen for Tection on it but thank you for what you showed looking forward to seeing more videos.🤙🏻

  • @cmikres
    @cmikres3 жыл бұрын

    Hey great reviews. How about the extreme hydro gt case. Any reviews on their stuff?? Thanks.

  • @mooch91
    @mooch915 жыл бұрын

    Sound quality! I wanted to LOVE that Catalyst case - I actually tried two of them for my iPhone 7, but they had some strange issue where my transmission would just completely cut off during a phone call. It didn't just mute me a little bit, callers on the other end said my voice went completely dead during a phone call. It would happen after an extended period of the other caller talking. Could never figure it out. Catalyst was of no help - said they had never heard of it - despite multiple reviews stating the same on Amazon.

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for the comment! This issue never happened when the iPhone was out of the case?

  • @mooch91

    @mooch91

    5 жыл бұрын

    No, the iPhone works perfectly outside of the Catalyst case. And it worked perfectly when inside the Lifeproof Fre case (other than being a little muted) as well. I'm convinced the case was doing something to negatively affect the noise-cancelling microphones. Catalyst kept wanting to send me another case, but I just returned them to Amazon - I didn't have any confidence that a new case would fix the issue.

  • @Midnight9400
    @Midnight94003 жыл бұрын

    I’ve been considering upgrading to a lifeproof for my new phone and on lifeproof’s website it looks like they are much more strict on the warranties now which is really unfortunate. That was the biggest reason why I felt I could justify that price.

  • @kirbymatteo8747
    @kirbymatteo87475 жыл бұрын

    I bought the catalyst case water proof last week i love it 😍

  • @canmiller5971

    @canmiller5971

    5 жыл бұрын

    kirby matteo how is the screen protector on it? Does it scratch easy?

  • @RobertOKruk
    @RobertOKruk Жыл бұрын

    Awesome comparisons! What about best/slimmest dust resistant cases? Any recommendations? Use case is protecting a phone mounted on bicycle used in extensive outdoor touring

  • @PudgeFree
    @PudgeFree5 жыл бұрын

    Great video! I’d love to see a video on the best 2-in-1 or multifunction type cases like those ones that have wallet attachments that can be removed, that waterproof one that has a thinner inner case that slides in and out of it. That sort of stuff.

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    I wish cases like that existed! The old Optrix XD6 was like that but they stopped making them after the 6.

  • @PudgeFree

    @PudgeFree

    5 жыл бұрын

    MobileReviewsEh oh I didn’t realize they stopped making it. I’ve really been wanting something like the totallee cases that I can put something like the dbrand bumper/case *over* when I need the drop protection. Most of the day I only need scratch protection but I like changing the look of my phone often so skins would be a huge pain. Maybe I need to invent one myself. Lol.

  • @brettg9025
    @brettg90255 жыл бұрын

    I am in the military and just got an iPhone X. I do a lot of various mission from jumping out of aircraft to water operation, what is your suggestion for the most rugged waterproof case? I know you mentioned the catalyst is that about the best?

  • @elgalandenoche
    @elgalandenoche4 жыл бұрын

    I had a lifeproof case and the silence mode switch broke. I used it for a while until I got a new one. It was so annoying having to open the case to flip the switch. However, for the time I used, it it protected my iPhone 7 to keep it still looking great, to the point I was able to trade it in for my new phone.

  • @spidennis
    @spidennis3 жыл бұрын

    Just got the SE in December 2020, and require a waterproof case. This review is ok for the city dweller but not for the outdoorsman. I’m a kayaker that lives on a saltwater beach, protection is primary! So while these three cases, mostly the catalyst, is on my list I do want to look into those other adventure cases you mentioned. I was out with the dolphins in my sea kayak, my most epic encounter of all time and of course had to video it. Yes, it’s on my channel. My greatest concern was dropping my phone in deep water, so a wrist strap is important plus having a float on it would be important too. Still I keep my phone in a waterproof hard case as added protection. So the search continues! Presently my new SE resides in my modified lifeproof case from my iPhone 7 as impact protection only. My goal for the new case is not to use the ports, wireless charging, wireless earbuds, so I can keep the lightening jack clean and trouble free. I mentioned I live in salt and sand right?!

  • @baggedtacoma
    @baggedtacoma2 жыл бұрын

    I always use a water proof case cuz I’m a heavy equipment mechanic for a living but the image quality drops so much and the screen touch sensation is way different. Need a water proof case that your still able to use a good quality screen protector. Maybe you can do a review on cases for construction workers and mechanics the dirt/mud and grease/oil is a different animal. Chemicals do crazy things to some stuff. Love your channel. Long time watcher and follower of your channel. 👍🏻👍🏻

  • @haileyferwerda2932
    @haileyferwerda29324 жыл бұрын

    So for paddle boarding, taking some pictures while out and maybe doing some snorkeling while on vacation for a few weeks I picked the catalyst...had the GoPro but then had to get all these accessories and you end up being so busy with all this stuff just to get some great video or pictures...just wanna have some decent protection and take some great pictures while out with friends on the water...but was still wondering between catalyst or proshot for when I will be doing some snorkeling in the Caribbean...Will catalyst be just fine??

  • @WranglerRunner1
    @WranglerRunner15 жыл бұрын

    Great video. I'm eyeballing the Ghostek Nautical but I am concerned my aftermarket lightning cable will not be able to fit into the female end on the iPhone 8. I own a Pelican Marine which I'm not too thrilled with and it has this exact same problem. Any input as it relates to the Ghostek?

  • @tubeitup937
    @tubeitup9375 жыл бұрын

    Hi, of all cases you've tested thus far which one has the hardest and thickest clear cover on the back of the case for the rear camera lens on the iPhone 7/8? I am looking for the toughest protection for the camera lens, it's hard to tell by looking at the video reviews and in most cases this is not a feature that it's spoken about. Most of the cases seem like flimsy plastic films over the rear camera lens cutout opening on the back of the case. Thank you in Advance!

  • @khs118
    @khs1184 жыл бұрын

    Which one is better for preventing lint and stuff getting underneath the screen? Lifeproof fre or Catalyst? Thank you...

  • @LordFarquaad007
    @LordFarquaad0075 жыл бұрын

    Which one fits a glass screen protector?

  • @jacobgora8942
    @jacobgora89424 жыл бұрын

    The glass of the back of my iPhone has chipped away to the point where I can see the panels in my phone, what case will work for me

  • @understandable.
    @understandable.5 жыл бұрын

    I never drop my phone but I bought the lifeproof fre a couple days ago because I just like knowing my phone is protected and looking good. I have a tempered glass screen protector and I don’t want to take it off, can you really not use the fre with any screen protectors?

  • @lhorner1977
    @lhorner19774 жыл бұрын

    good review better than most people out there

  • @FoxxFire
    @FoxxFire5 жыл бұрын

    Speaking of improvements, I wish catalyst put a marking of some sort so you could know whether the rotary switch is on mute or umm, non-mute. That would make a big difference (on both of their cases, not just the waterproof), especially if you're in a meeting or something and just need to look down real quick at your phone rather than turning the screen on and moving the switch back and forth to make sure it's on mute. Hopefully they can do that....

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    I think it use to matter but looking at the inside of the case, I don't anymore. One turn of the knob should set the mute switch in place.

  • @nevergoingtopostonthisthin4058

    @nevergoingtopostonthisthin4058

    5 жыл бұрын

    You could have said Unmuted.

  • @F.D.W.
    @F.D.W.5 жыл бұрын

    Out of all waterproof cases, which ones can I use with a screen protector?

  • @danmele1
    @danmele14 жыл бұрын

    Great video! I live in the U.S. Virgin Islands and as a coral biologist, I'm on boats everyday surrounded by saltwater. I think it's important to include that just because phones are water resistant, doesn't mean they're protected from saltwater. That's a whole different ball game.

  • @Shotgun93Alexander

    @Shotgun93Alexander

    2 жыл бұрын

    That’s where I’m from and I use the nautical for my phone

  • @RBRM3
    @RBRM34 жыл бұрын

    What was the red case? It looked the best and had a flat smooth stretched front case on the curb next to the black and white one? You didn't say anything about what phone gets the hottest in what case, with it being well over 100 degrees in the summer time especially for people that ride motorcycles, that is a very important factor! Could you say if any have overheated and closed the apps? Fre, Spartan/Stud are all 3 great and waterproof cases are amazing because they, well are water proof lol but seriously though, I love that they have the screen protector built in! Unfortunately I have not gotten to use the ghost techor the catalyst and I'm currently looking between all of these to order another one right now because all they had when I bought mine was the Defender and I absolutely hate it! I do have to say though, you are absolutely wrong about waterproof cases not being slim, there are several out there that are just as thin as a standard case, even the steampunk cases are "slim, ultra slim and razor thin"! The amount of glare that you gets all depends on how type the screen is, a lot of these are kind of just common sense things and all depend on how it fits the phone. STOP RUBBING THE MIC HOLE! It is good enough after 5 seconds lol

  • @junettewatson9236
    @junettewatson92365 жыл бұрын

    What were the 2 brands you mentioned at the end for cases to take into the ocean?

  • @kinggiorgio5156
    @kinggiorgio51565 жыл бұрын

    Can you do a review on hitcase pro

  • @RaffaeleSanseverino
    @RaffaeleSanseverino5 жыл бұрын

    So to use my XS Max in underwater at the sea, do you recommend Catalyst? Does this support wireless charging? IF I already have a glass screenprotector, is the input affected? To use every day okay? I ask because in other videos everyone praised the FRE . Thanks ;)

  • @braedonharvey3030
    @braedonharvey30305 жыл бұрын

    How do the cases stand up against dust? I’m a landscaper and I’ve had a lifeproof and a pelican in the past and with both overtime people have had difficulties hearing me. Any experience would help

  • @instyle4freestyle290
    @instyle4freestyle2905 жыл бұрын

    Nice video! I was wondering (since you’ve tested both of these cases) what you would pick between the Pitaka Magcase Pro and the Mous carbon fibre case?

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    Definitely Mous. Handles better.

  • @instyle4freestyle290

    @instyle4freestyle290

    5 жыл бұрын

    MobileReviewsEh Thanks! And which is more slim?

  • @karenmilner3696
    @karenmilner36964 жыл бұрын

    I have had 4 fre iphone cover the front of the cover keeps melt in my hand where i always touch it. when on the phone

  • @welchtim
    @welchtim4 жыл бұрын

    So, Otterbox stopped making the built in screen protector when the curved edge iphones came out. What do you recommend that has a built-in screen protector? I don't like the limited protection of the aftermarket screen protectors. Thanks!

  • @mariasandratimosan1976
    @mariasandratimosan19765 жыл бұрын

    Which one is way more better? Catalyst or pelican marine?

  • @Young_Travels
    @Young_Travels5 жыл бұрын

    I watch your adds to help you out. I don’t do that for everybody haha

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    Thanks for the support!

  • @clevername333
    @clevername3335 жыл бұрын

    CATALYST FOR THE WIN!!! Love my catalyst case. I just saw them in the apple store also. Nice.

  • @christianolivera8019

    @christianolivera8019

    4 жыл бұрын

    Are there any waterproof cases that work with glass screen protectors too??? @cumward @clevername333

  • @227DFET
    @227DFET4 жыл бұрын

    Can you do an updated review on waterproof cases for the iPhone 11 models? (Pro?) Please! I had to replace my old SE because it went swimming at a water park, even though it was in a waterproof bag. I don't need it for daily use, but after dropping this much cash on a phone, I need to make sure it doesn't get wet on a trip, and can last me a few years! Thanks!

  • @Sejkcmj

    @Sejkcmj

    4 жыл бұрын

    E T don’t use the Lifeproof Frē. The bubbles on the screen are freaking awful!!

  • @bradwright5968
    @bradwright59682 жыл бұрын

    My 2 concerns. 1, I was watching another review and it showed the Catalyst having MUCH clearer video (camera) than the Lifeproof. It appeared in your video that Ghostek had the clearest, Catalyst had the 2nd, and lifeproof was the least clear. However, I think the other review said that he has had the lifeproof longer. Of the 3, were they all "new" or at least not worn? 2nd question, is if you could use a micrometer or other device to measure thickness compared to the 3 in your review. On amazon, the lifeproof has the cheaper price, then Ghostek, followed by Catalyst being the most expensive. This is searching for the Iphone 12 mini. GREAT REVIEW!!! THANK YOU!!!

  • @Zeorymer300
    @Zeorymer3005 жыл бұрын

    Have you tested the Hitcase PRO for iPhone Xs Max?

  • @rosewillis6018
    @rosewillis60185 жыл бұрын

    Does the catalyst sorry on the spelling for the iPhone X S max have a build in screen protector?

  • @Prufrock186
    @Prufrock1864 жыл бұрын

    Hey there I work in a metal shop and i'm constantly covered in metal filings i feel like the only option i have is waterproof cases i need my phone totally sealed speakers, camera, charging port . is my only option waterproof cases for something like this? Any ideas?

  • @cassandramondragon6180
    @cassandramondragon61805 жыл бұрын

    Can you try catalyst waterproof on actual iphone xs and xs max? Because catalyst said that the iphone x and xs is the same knowing that the camera modules are not the same. Thank you

  • @joshmami9882
    @joshmami98824 жыл бұрын

    You’re right about not needing a waterproof case... last summer my son jumped in the deep end of the pool🤦‍♀️ I dove in fully clothed to get him out. Once we were out of the pool and calm, my uncle pointed out that I had my iPhone in my back pocket. No damage!

  • @manueldignard7842
    @manueldignard78423 жыл бұрын

    I didn’t think I needed waterproof case either but I use my iPhone XS Max as my GPS on my motocycles and on one wet, rainy 6 hour ride, my phone ended up with water damage (first time I use my applecare since for ever). So, I will be getting one for when I ride. Otherwise, I agree, no need for waterproof.

  • @aaronfung1506
    @aaronfung15065 жыл бұрын

    What are your thoughts on the HitCase Splash? I'm not loving the built in screen protector look and a bit wary of the simple installation which seems to have an easily removable front.

  • @brandonhorn7887

    @brandonhorn7887

    5 жыл бұрын

    Can you describe more? Thinking about getting it. Is it good waterproof? What are the pros and cons

  • @CindaMurphyRealEstate
    @CindaMurphyRealEstate3 жыл бұрын

    I’m looking for the best case for underwater shooting with an iPhone 11 ProMax. I’m going to Xcaret in Cancun and I have a 9 year old boy I want to capture in and under the water. Any suggestions?

  • @deand7799
    @deand77995 жыл бұрын

    My friend has the green one with the edges but it’s broken but the has a 7 plus so she thinks the case is protecting it from water but it’s really just the phone

  • @manp1039
    @manp10395 жыл бұрын

    i have the lifeproof free. I don't find any trouble with the buttons or the mute switch at all. the problem i have with the fre is can camera cover on back becoming dirty and causing a foggy or flairing of lights in pictures. And because of the way they designed it .. it makes it hard to clean properly. Anyone have any of their own thoughts on this topic or your experience?

  • @meaganmendoza7279
    @meaganmendoza72793 жыл бұрын

    I’ve been looking for the same blue catalyst waterproof case. I work as a veterinary technician and sadly occasionally get messier then id like and need a waterproof casing ASAP. Do you ever consider selling your cases that you no longer use? I’d be more then happy to buy it off of you. Please let me know. Thank you for your time.

  • @Peizxcv
    @Peizxcv5 жыл бұрын

    You gonna review how you get biceps like that?

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    Lift heavy. Eat clean. Eat lots.

  • @jaxv94
    @jaxv945 жыл бұрын

    i just need a case that will to keep dust from entering my iphone from work 😥

  • @araw1212
    @araw12123 жыл бұрын

    I hate the loss of functionality on the screen. But went kayaking with my 11promax and it went in 3-4 ft of water and got ruined. Water behind the camera lens and kept restarting every two minutes. Just turned it in to upgrade and bought the catalyst of Amazon by mistake thinking I clicked on the life proof and am still unsure if I should keep it. What’s the best non water proof case?

  • @andrepianco1961
    @andrepianco19615 жыл бұрын

    What about the Hitcase pro for the iPhone X/XS?

  • @chrisleblanc40
    @chrisleblanc404 жыл бұрын

    My xs max was one of the few to get water damage and not have working Face ID. I dropped it in 12 inches of water. Ended up getting replaced.

  • @knifesmithe
    @knifesmithe5 жыл бұрын

    What’s the pattern light on your wall?? Projector?

  • @auntcc3553
    @auntcc35533 жыл бұрын

    Thank you for these video reviews! I got smart and decided not to solely go by stars and customer reviews on Amazon after sending back my 3rd waterproof phone case , I have been having a heck of a time ordering! Ugh 🤦‍♀️ I thought as long as I got something better than my first random and cheap brand which I didn’t notice the reviews said anything about it being made of cheap Barbie plastic 😝 I thought I’d go with Ghostek Nautical which I loved their packaging and “comics like theme” figured gosh they go through a lot to market these things so they must be great! So I missed ☝️ important review about the touch screen and tapping multiple times it like didn’t fit right on my NEW iPhone 7 (I know I’m Living in the Stone Age) haha only iPhone I could afford so my daughter and I could fact time etc.. they’re so expensive! Prior to this I was an Android/Samsung gal! Any-who back to Ghostek then I moto the inside of the back cover by the edge had a crack sticking up like a sliver 😩 and the rubber seal kept coming out of the edge inside back cover! I thought it was the ☝️ 👎 negative might try their atomic one though? Third one was a Lanheim waterproof case which is what I got for my daughter forever ago and figured this has to be the one well.. WRONG no one could hear me talking or they kept saying hello hello screaming what’s all that noise, especially on speaker! 😨 Idk how I never noticed it on my daughter’s phone bc hers does it too but not as bad! Your video on sound quality is exactly what my lanheim did trying to make Tiktok Videos! Sorry for my long novel here but I appreciate these and will take all into consideration and will try to use the link to order as I noticed it’s from 2 years ago am I ever in the Stone Age?! Ha thanks again!

  • @bigbullet9224
    @bigbullet92244 жыл бұрын

    Well I use them because of the dusty proof the water tight seal keeps dust from getting in my speakers in my line of work after a few months I can’t hear out of my ear peace or my speakers

  • @gavinw4165
    @gavinw4165 Жыл бұрын

    I use a waterproof case all year long because in the winter time I put my phone in my snow pants pocket that is wet and has snow in it and if your riding for 4+ hours I don’t want my phone to get water damage

  • @qazifaisal5
    @qazifaisal52 жыл бұрын

    I work in a factory and I use the Ghostek nautical for my note ten ultra and note ten plus . I live in chicago I love waterproof cases because we have rain snow all kinds of stupidit things. Yes Samsung phones are water resistant but I rather have the extra layer of protection.

  • @bditman4740
    @bditman47403 жыл бұрын

    One thing that I would love to see included in your reviews is comparing the quality of photos(stills and video) in the case. I have a life proof and my pictures ( on an 11 pro) have a white glow that I noticed on your video as well. Second- the vulnerability to rubber breakdown with sweat, bug spray, and sun block. I get it you are in Canada but nevertheless...life proof really stank at bring up the camera fast too. IMHO.

  • @alexanderradec317
    @alexanderradec3172 жыл бұрын

    I was distracted with the arm flexes lol I use to love lifeproof but it’s always been a case with crappy sound quality coming in tingy, and wasn’t sure if cell reception was affected due to the case or not, now a days I don’t think they are especially with the “5G compatible” ones. It’s so hard to shop for a dust proof case these days :/ colors suck depending on the model, like the 13 mini doesn’t have good color selections versus the bigger phones which sucks because it’s a nuisance for me with small hands

  • @DJaquithFL
    @DJaquithFL5 жыл бұрын

    Just a thought .. "waterproof" isn't as Important as its *ability to float* and not sink to the bottom in water. Most cases simply sink and most phones now are either IP67 or better IP68. In addition 360° impact resistant with at least 1/8" of uneven surface protection for a more robust case. For a ruggedized case I like the OtterBox.

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    For me, I don't mind having the case sink when I'm snorkelling. Easier to deal with than having the iPhone constantly trying to float to the top while swimming. As I said in the video, if you need it to float, the foam wrist strap is a good idea. In terms of protection, I'm confident that all three cases provide 360 degree impact protection. The plastic screen protectors on the case are quite tough.

  • @DJaquithFL

    @DJaquithFL

    5 жыл бұрын

    @@MobileReviewsEh .. There are cases made specifically for diving .. none of these are for that purpose. IP67 and IP68 are not meant for anything but clean fresh water, not salt water, cokes, coffee, etc. Personally, I want something that floats even if I was scuba diving.

  • @jonathancarlos2187
    @jonathancarlos2187 Жыл бұрын

    Is there a perfect case for the new iPhone 13 pro max ?

  • @stevengabriellaworld9785
    @stevengabriellaworld97855 жыл бұрын

    I need it for swimming what’s the best one for waterproof ty

  • @techboy37chinito_boy98
    @techboy37chinito_boy985 жыл бұрын

    I love to watch these videos I have broken about 5 phones and I'm only 12 years old by testing dollar and speck, tech 21, and otter box commuter and I have similar results

  • @FlyingSparks12336

    @FlyingSparks12336

    5 жыл бұрын

    why do you need a phone at 12 years old. let alone 5 lol

  • @oggody1409
    @oggody14094 жыл бұрын

    Is the back case camera glass?? Do u think its possible??

  • @paulmorris6177
    @paulmorris61775 жыл бұрын

    The difference between tech-boy here and people that actually GO OUTSIDE is the fact that WE (people that go outside) NEED a quality waterproof case when we're hiking, biking, camping, shooting, kayaking, climbing, etc...and NOT sitting in a cubicle-farm all day long, stuck in an office, staring at a computer screen. For those of us that are ACTIVE, we need a good, functional waterproof case that is also affordable. Overall this was very informative and (once you ignore his biases, slams and sarcasm), gave me more info than I had before. Advice...when addressing these cases in the future, add a caveat that says something along the lines of, "These cases are designed for the outdoor enthusiast that hikes, kayaks, snorkels, etc., and NOT the average, everyday, office worker-bee that has no life outside of their home and their office-prison".

  • @pearlesme8561
    @pearlesme85615 жыл бұрын

    Catalyst is fave. Love the lanyard one (non waterproof).

  • @MobileReviewsEh

    @MobileReviewsEh

    5 жыл бұрын

    The impact protection is sweet.

  • @shespeaks1971
    @shespeaks19714 жыл бұрын

    Ok check this out: here’s your proof for a waterproof case. I use my iPhone in the jacuzzi bath. It’s a distresser , quiet time for me away from an insanely hectic life. I often spend 1 to 2 hours jn the bath and I like to audio journal using notes app on my iPhone. Not to mention the perusing of Amazon which requires a lot of clicking on screens so I need both great audio and touch. I don’t think I can accomplish those without them is my intent is to do this in the bath can I?

Келесі