I bought one of these and love it! It’s functional enough for me and looks like a traditional watch. Nobody notices that it’s connected until you’re intently reading a notification.

@Danny-pq3jo

Жыл бұрын

I'm on the fence about this watch, does it have a "find my phone function"? And are there any cool features ?

@Casey_J96

Жыл бұрын

@@Danny-pq3jo no find my phone feature that I know of. There’s not much that these reviews don’t cover, notifications and fitness tracking stuff. It’s enough for me but not as advanced as like an Apple Watch or android equivalent.

@airmanfirstclass3535

Жыл бұрын

Wondering about some negative comments I've seen on Amazon. Folk saying the crown doesn't work or phone is just dead and won't recharge. Dial is off center etc. Have you had any problems with your watch in terms of functionality or manufacturing defects

@Casey_J96

Жыл бұрын

@@airmanfirstclass3535 I haven’t had any of those issues but can’t speak for everyone.

With that low power consumption a solar cell could solve the problem of charging or make the recharging period several months at least...

Looks appealing. And definitely something to consider. Mike like always you have out done yourself with this great video 🙂

Me and my wife both have have the lesser version of the watch we picked them up on a great offer the battery life is fantastic even if you have all the features turned on the steps dial is good for helping to complete your daily goals

I feel this is so close to perfect. There's just two more things I want out of a product like this that would get me to buy: 1 - NFC payments 2 - Ability to replace the rechargeable battery when it dies To me a watch is a device that lasts 10+ years. I'm old school like that. Even cheap Casio watches last that long. Smartwatches and Hybrids still suffer from being completely disposable after 2-3 years.

@123moe

Жыл бұрын

fwiw I've had a Steel HR for just over 4 years (turned 4 in June) and the battery still lasts 2-3 weeks.

@cesarvillalobos1692

Жыл бұрын

@@123moe can you control music playback from it?

@Bt-7274..

Жыл бұрын

@@cesarvillalobos1692I’m pretty sure you cant

@BloodScientist

Жыл бұрын

​@@cesarvillalobos1692 I have been using my Withings Steel HR for about 5 years now. Still running well. And no you cannot control music from it.

@BenBensen293

Жыл бұрын

I think even after 10 years, the battery will last over a week. In my opinion there are some more things missing. First is an internal storage, so that you can hear offline Music and an own GPS Module, so that i dont have to take my Phone with my while workout anymore.

Just got the Scanwatch Horizon yesterday, haven't received it yet; but I think I'll like it. That watch is really beautiful especially the Blue one

I have a Withings and it is great. The APP is insanely good and helpful. Diagnosed my A Fib and I was able to send the ECG to my cardiologist. Very well made. Diagnosis your sleep and give you feedback on it daily. Battery lasts about 20 days if you use the options a lot. Longer if you do not use all the apps. Several models are available.

@TsigolohcysP77

Жыл бұрын

Thanks your review really helped me tip the decision scale in my search for the ultimate Heart montiorig/Sleep analysis watch. Now I can focus on Withings

@Chris34720

Жыл бұрын

This is great to hear with the ecg and afib I felt like I’ve been tied to an Apple Watch for years because I’ve had a few health scares with my heart I love my android phones and don’t mind Apple to much but feel I need a change as there are so many great android phones out there now So you would say the ecg works well ? Also did it just alert you or did you have to run the ecg when you felt unwell ? Does the watch also monitor for irregular heart rhythm as I know Apple Watch does this in the background Did you have any symptoms as I hear some people live with it and don’t have symptoms and eventually can lead to strokes and heart attacks if not treated properly Thank you and I wish you good health

@petethecatable

Жыл бұрын

@@Chris34720 It does not automatically alert to Afib. You can set heart rate parameters for an alarm and that should work as Afib usually is associated with high HR. I generally know when I am having symptoms I want to check and trigger the diagnosis myself. The watch does an excellent job of making a recording I send to my cardiologist. The other parts of the app are really easy to use and very helpful-the sleep diagnostic and apnea diagnostics are helpful. I found out my problem is not as bad as I had feared. My cardiologist reversed his decision to implant a pace maker based on the records I have been able to produce.

I have Withings Steel HR Sport bought Sept 2020 its going on Oct 2023 and mine still work great. Will definitely upgrade. Battery life is still great so good you can forget to charge

I wish that you make a video comparing hybrid watches for battery and ecstatics and functionality for different types of users

@Pungba

2 жыл бұрын

Aesthetics?

@MacNilssen

2 жыл бұрын

@@Pungba i’d rather see the ecstatics compared

Great video! Right now, I use a Fossil Hybrid HR and that is also a nice one. But this would be a great upgrade when the time comes :)

Thanks for the review

I got both the Scanwatch and the Scanwatch Horizon. Love them both, depending on the occasion, I can easily switch. Love the review Mike!

@mr.bouncealot9047

2 ай бұрын

I was thinking of doing the same. Is the transition from watch to watch in the app smooth?

@yck1126

Ай бұрын

@@mr.bouncealot9047it’s smooth, just need to select which watch you’re using through the app.

Thanks for the review Mike. I'm considering this device because l'm a time piece enthusiast and am looking for a serious and as accurate as possible health monitor.

What I'd love to see here: solar face seeing so much of the face is not a screen, NFC for payments, compatibility with external sensors and finally a replacible battery.

I have had this for about 4 months and I only charged 5 times. That would be only 13-15 times a year! It is a nice-looking hybrid watch with functions that I need. And I am loving that every moment even after 4 months. I hope it would stay that way longer

@jibransadozai8294

Жыл бұрын

Hi how does this watch perform with steps counting & heart rate accuracy?.Pls share your experience.

@johnpark9742

Жыл бұрын

@@jibransadozai8294 hi, I am not sure about the accuracy on step counts, but heart rate seems to be accurate.

Love my scanwatch. Got sick of waiting for the horizon to be released here. So I got the scanwatch on sale and added the Withings metal band. Beautiful watch with all the tracking most will ever need. Only complaint I have is that the step tracking seems to be very conservative like the Steel HR sports were. If you are a watch person, this is the one to get. You won’t feel like a fool like these people wearing Nike edition  watches with dress clothes.

@MrTomro

Жыл бұрын

what do you mean by conservative step tracking?

Outstanding design and utility for a balance between form and function 11:38

Whenever I wear my Withings Steel, a lot people comment about it, they always are in shock when I told them is a smart watch.

Exactly what I need. I had a heartrattack, and I want a watch, what is designed tó meassure ECG. But do not want to let know with everybody. Seems watch, what is watching me😀

I’m considering the green one. Like ekg and oxygen sensor features. I agree it is pricey. Never considered a 500 dollar watch before. This is not a typical watch

Thnx Nice Review

great video, love the watch, really want to purchase it but what about the watch ? no one talks about the watch movement or how accurate it is.

Beautiful watch! for smart watch apple is mile ahead the competition and i would not change it, however i really appreciate withings watch!

Can I disable the ecg? Thanks !

can you add a photo or video with the watch under no light situation? like when you are waking up or going to sleep.

Will you review the Mi Band 7 ? Once it's available where u are?

When you get messages notification, can you read the texts on the watch or you have to go the phone?

Does the ECG work in Canada?

I was wondering if the watch can be set to WAKE you up/ALARM if your HR drops below say 35 or stops, or O2 level goes below 90 while you're sleeping

Does the Horizon show weather? This honestly is the only requirement I have for hybrid smartwatches coming from an apple watch.

Mike, how would you compare this with the Garmin Vivomove series?

I've owned three different Withings watches. All of then have been very accurate. Oh yeah, the best part is the battery, over a month on a charge.

@maxmustermann7365

Жыл бұрын

In terms of accuracy there is - no REM sleep detection at all - no way to decrease measurement intervals from 10min to every few seconds so you can measure peaks while training (--> Max bpm --> cardio age) - no rest pulse but only an average heart rate over the day which says basically nothing because: 1) Doing sports lowers the heart rate in general 2) while doing sports the heart rate is higher --> therefore the effect of a lower heart rate by living an active healthy life can not be measured because the average heart rate is increased by the active healthy life...due to Withings not referencing the heart rate data to the gyroscopic data in order to tell wether one is physically active at that moment or not. Fitbit and Apple perform way better in terms of accuracy while Withings artificially restricts it's users.

@neilmac4730

Жыл бұрын

@Max Mustermann Rem sleep with the apple watch isn't really possible, 🙄 they need overnight charging, my wife's Apple is down to 30% by the time we retire at night. The Withings is an activity watch ⌚️ that does an adequate job. I also have a Garmin Fenix 5 that is much more in depth but isn't astetically pleasing to the eye. If you are a hardcore fitness sports guy or gal the Withings isn't for you, but if you are a daily walker or hiker, Withings is more than sufficient. Cheers 🍻

@chicoc8637

Жыл бұрын

If you start a workout you get continues heart rate. You can leave the screen on. I use it to run via heart rate. Can definitely get a max heart rate out of it. Dont understand what you mean.

@maxmustermann7365

Жыл бұрын

@@chicoc8637 My ScanWatch saves my heartbeat every 30s in training mode and every 10minutes in normal mode. For your usecase to watch your pulse live it's great but looking on the data afterwards, a 10minute interval is too long to measure for instance symptoms of stress as a student or short term heart rate increase e.g. after standing up and loosing vision

I was looking for a good hybrid for a long time and this seems to be it, if only hey made a black/gunmetal grey version... those colorful watchfaces and ligh metal - just not my thing

I’ve been looking for a fitness tracker but i cant seem to find one i like

Can it be dual time? Ie used as a GMT?

wonder does it has 2nd time zone .thks

can the watch show the seconds somewhere?

I only wear mechanical watches, but this is the best smartwatch I’ve ever seen.

@frankstefan3201

Жыл бұрын

Take a look at the Tissot T-Touch Connect Solar. Also very nice looking hybrid watch.

Mike, I don't know how to contact you directly so I hope you can offer to give me your opinion of the best smart watch for a man with smallish wrists. Maybe a watch with a square bezel....?

The only problem I have with this watch is that it is a diving watch but there is diving setting in the sports settings!

Pro tip, not Wtihgins specific but buy a few cheap nylon bands for sleeping with your watch, much more comfortable than silicon or stainless steel.

This would be so dope if it were able to show Notifications lol.

Good vid

I puchased this watch. I absolutely love it. It does everything I need it to do and as a traditional watch lover, I find it beautiful

I bought the HR Steele for the battery - charging once a month makes me smile when I think of friends who charge each night with other watches - going on three yrs now and still happy with the $180 price when I purchased it

Wish they made a black dial option.

By "only one in this category" you mean price? Because the Alpina AlpinerX Alive Titanium, upon which this this watch is arguably based (a hybrid sport 'diver'), is out there for a while already. Yes, this is not the first, nor the only one in this category (hybrid sport 'diver' watch). Maybe you could review it?

Might add that with the nighttime sleep-apnea function activated every night battery drastically decreases to around 5-7 days, without it I get 20+ days with regular use!

@mr.bouncealot9047

2 ай бұрын

How does it work in detecting sleep apnea, like how accurate. And does it wake you up?

... in fact I have been thinking about such a watch long time ago... BTW Breitling has its expensive version.

@alcito101

2 жыл бұрын

True -- this concept is not new. BTW, the Alpina AlpinerX series is more affordable than the Breitling Exospace B55 (and still Swiss sport luxury, from Frederique Constant's sister brand).

Can you use this with your mobile turned off during the work hours?

does the watch have an integrated memory and I can transfer all the data at the end of the day onto my smartphone or do I have to keep bluetooth on all the time? Thank you.

@ColoSon

Жыл бұрын

bought it. step tracker is very inaccurate. returned the watch.

Do watches like this function fine (like a normal watch) after the softwares and the phone connectivity are out of service (after 5-10 years)? Since you said the time is set by the connected phone I’m assuming not. I would probably get this for daily life and get a cheap fitbit or something like that for running with. I’m deciding whether to get a smartwatch (like AW or Garmin) or not for a long time now and can’t quite bite the bullet. Having nfc on the wrist for like train pass and music on my runs sounds nice but having a good looking watch like this hybrid watch for the 98% of the time when I’m not doing that sounds more important to me, but in the end can’t decide. If it works like analogue watches even after the smart/digital parts of it are obsolete it would be worth it IMO, if the lifespan can be expected to be the same as a regular smart watch it’s kind of eh.

@lexistential

2 жыл бұрын

the time continues to run so long as the battery doesn't die, regardless of whether it's connected to another device. there is no way (as far as I can tell) to manually set the time without the app, so if it dies or if the time gets off and you don't have the app, you won't be able to fix it. there may be a solution, but if so I can't find any documentation for it online.

@Pungba

2 жыл бұрын

I've had this same problem for a long time and it's kinda frustrating.

Can you rotate the bezel like a traditional diver?

@ayarnold9523

Жыл бұрын

Yes you can.

I'm just tucking into the video. If it's made by Withings does that mean its data will port really well to popular health tracking and exercise apps? Is it's weight compatible with a workout, or is the metal band and case make it too cumbersome to run a few miles with it? These are my biggest concerns to hybrid watches like these.

@Scott_C

2 жыл бұрын

Seems like a decent watch. The look with the polymer band wasn't too bad and I bet that reduces the weight of the watch a lot. Thank you for reviewing it.

@mr.bouncealot9047

2 ай бұрын

Isn't it around +70 grams? Seems like a lot to run with or sleep

I don't get why so many people love the heart rate feature so much....hammers the battery, is always inaccurate and what does it actually tell you?

@maxmustermann7365

Жыл бұрын

Rest pulse would be informative to see wether the training has a positive impact on cardio health...but unfortunately this isn't possible in the Withings App, only average heart rate which basically tells you nothing. 1) Doing sports lowers the heart rate in general 2) While doing sports the heart rate is increased If we can't separate them with gyroscopic information (rest pulse), then the interpretation of what's healthy or not would contradict each other

I really wish we had a smart watch with the aesthetic of this one but none of the health tracking, Instead a business focused watch with notifications, voice reply, and calender. And at least a week long battery. I don't need a smart watch for my sleep or track my heart. I need to know as messages come in asap if they are worth bringing out my phone for or not. And if they are if I can save time and reply right from my wrist. If I have to charge it overnight for a day or two of use, not worth it.

@edbee8508

2 жыл бұрын

Crazy how different people have different needs. I need a watch with ECG tracking but I don't want a smart watch. I really enjoy divers and this aesthetic is OK for me. My phone notifications can just say on my phone. I don't want any of that on my wrist.

@codythronsedt7087

Жыл бұрын

Same here, give me this watch with step counter, heart rate monitor and phone notifications. I've got the Samsung active 2 and it's quite annoying charging daily

Best watch I ever had, except for swim tracking. Software completely fails here.

Are wrinkled shirts a new style or something that I just missed?

Has Withings released this first now in the US? In Europe it's available already like half year. I guess (hope) the successor will be soon released.

I mean it doesn't look too mad it could use a bit of a bigger screen though

Ouch the price on Amazon 😮

Hi Mike. Thanks a lot for your excellent reviews. Your videos are really helping me choose a suitable hybrid smartwatch 🙂 I just got a Vivomove Style, but I'm having second thoughts with it and I'm considering getting the Withings Scanwatch instead (the regular 42mm one, not the Horizon). Since you also reviewed the Vivomove Style, could I ask you a couple of questions on how it compares with the Scanwatch in terms of "smart" features? 1. Which one is better in terms of notifications in your opinion? Even though the Style has a larger, "double" OLED screen, I find it very inconvenient that you have to tap on the notification icon to see the message contents at all, especially considering the touch controls aren't the best. Does the Scanwatch display text messages in that scrolling fashion rightaway as they arrive? Is it convenient to just glance at them without interacting with the watch? I come from a Pebble Time that would simply display the message on screen as it arrived, which I loved. 2. Which UI is more convenient to navigate? Looking at your video, I feel like the rotating crown provides a more reliable and precise way to control the UI in general, and the OLED screen in the Withings seems to have a very high refresh rate too, with nice animations and bouncing effects. The Vivomove Style has a larger screen, sure, but touch controls are finicky and transitions can feel choppy and unintuitive at times. 3. When you have unread notifications, does the Withings display some sort of persistent icon in the homescreen whenever you turn on the OLED display? Is it easy to go back and read notifications that you didn't cach as they arrived? Thanks in advance and keep up the good work, your videos are beautifully crafted and really help people get a good feeling of each watch, both aesthetically and functionality-wise.

@matrhein

Жыл бұрын

The vivomove is more of a sports tracker with a lot better health metrics and - in my experience - better notifications, as it simply mirrors your phone. Withings has a special section in the app where you can customize the notifications that you receive, but some of my apps are not visible there. Messages arrive instantly when they are allowed. You can't go look at them again, though. The digital crown vibrates and is a wonderful way of interacting with the UI - especially if you detest touch screens. The Withings oled screen on the watch and the general design is really minimal: no notification indicator, no weather info, no stats, or additional apps. But You get a WATCH that can also do some Health tracking, and in terms of the watch, this is the closest thing to the analog experience that you will get. If that's what you're after, get it.

@VictorML

Жыл бұрын

@@matrhein Thanks a lot!

This is miles better with just the leather strap . Brings out it's elegance .

If it had contactless payments and a replaceable battery it would amazing, it would last as long as analog watches and if you forgot your wallet at home you could use the ewallet

@maxmustermann7365

Жыл бұрын

Li-Ion accumulators usually last around 500-700 cycles which should be 20 to 25 years with 2 weeks of battery life and then the battery would be at roughly 70% capacity but still should work

Is there an always on display option?

@mr.bouncealot9047

2 ай бұрын

This watch is always on

Someone please tell me how to buy it in India!!!

Wow sweet about time they made an update. Love the previous ones but not big enough diameter. Nice

Smooth. Now, find out that the sensors accuracy is below average. 500 euros for sub par sensors. Pleease

I've been obsessed with smartwatchs and tried most of the popular ones in the market. That said, I settled for a withings watch for three main reasons: 1. Battery life 2. Looks professional 3. Clinically validated Also, there app is outstanding and provides you with helpful tips and health information on a daily basis. So, it feels like a complete package that goes beyond owning something cool or interesting.

@meric12131415

Жыл бұрын

Wait it's clinically validated?

@brainactivity737

Жыл бұрын

@@meric12131415 Check their website. They provide detailed information about the research and studies used to validate their products.

@meric12131415

Жыл бұрын

@@brainactivity737 🤔 now you got me intrigued

@brainactivity737

Жыл бұрын

@@meric12131415 After trying Withings it was hard to settle for regular smart watches.The standard Scanwatch is a fantastic choice and cheaper than the horizon if you want something lighter and a bit more practical. Also, the Withings app makes the experience much more enjoyable. I use it everyday to track my steps, calories, heart rate, workouts, and get general health info to assist me in living a healthier life.

@meric12131415

Жыл бұрын

@@brainactivity737 ah that's good I mean for me I'd prefer a smart watch over everything else mostly because of the additional functionality speaking of which care to guess which smart watch I own?

Does the screen scratch ????

@mr.bouncealot9047

2 ай бұрын

It's Sapphire crystal, about 4 times more scratch resistant than Guerilla glass 👍

Does it play well with IOS?

@andyburns6496

2 жыл бұрын

Yes

For a hybrid watch that actually goes with a suit, see (maybe review?) the Frederique Constant Vitality. This is a sport 'diver' watch.

@dane2427

2 жыл бұрын

Except that there is no diving in the sports settings!!

@alcito101

2 жыл бұрын

@@dane2427 Indeed. By diving we just mean the style these days, unless otherwise noted. Another example, the Citizen CZ Smart. A diver just in looks -- see its bezel! 🤣

Great review but this watch is not accurate : steps, HR ( during exercise or when on bike even worse). I have rerurned my scanwatch for Huawei GT3 pro.

Why wouldn't you swim with the steel bracelet? Most dive watches are steel

1. No on board GPS 2. Monochrome display. 3. Dual display would have been better.

@ivayloivanov3744

Жыл бұрын

No GPS is disappointing since step trackers are very inaccurate.

I prefer the normal scanwatch

I bought the Withings when they first launched and loved it (love their app too). Since then my purchases have gone back and forth between Apple and Withings (I also have their smart scale). I currently have an Apple - while I truly HATE HATE HATE the look of Apple watches (yes x hater 3) - I wear an Apple because my perception is that Apple might be a little more accurate. @mikeobrienn, you've reviewed so many wearables - which is the more accurate of these two in your personal opinion? Is Apple still the clear winner? Or are they pretty similar in terms of tracking fitness sleep and movement? (And honestly I wouldn't have a problem with the slightly higher price of the Withings). Hope you see this question and have a few minutes to answer.

Apple Watch 41mm stainless steel with stainless link bracelet blends with a suit.

Unfortunately too expensive for the delivered smart watch features and competition!

I honestly hate the generic look of the watch, like I've seen it a million times before on every street corner of NYC....otherwise, it's a nice concept, they just need to hire a designer that isn't lazy and it'll be a success.

Is there a version for women?

@alcito101

2 жыл бұрын

That would be the Withings Steel HR 36mm. It's not a 'diver' though -- it's more dressy. However, the ultimate dressy hybrid for women is the Frederique Constant Smartwatch Ladies Vitality.

Too bad it doesn't have Fall Detection. I'm looking for something that isn't clogged with useless stuff but want fall detection.

I liked it until I seen the price :(

500 bucks aannnnnnd there goes my wallet 🤣

Amazfit watches can easily get 1 week on a single charge, if not more. And you're not faking classic watches. And Amazfit ones are hardly the only ones.

Cool watch, but I'm not paying $499.99 for an quartz movement. I can buy a nice automatic watch for that price and have my steps tracked by the accelerometer on my phone. I don't need super accurate data, but I do need a great watch.

Nice watch but it only tracks heart rate every 5 or 10 minutes outside workouts, while a Garmin does it multiple times per second. So therefore unfortunately not accurate.

no nfc, no calls. might as well buy a decent analogue watch

huawei ??????????

$500 for this piece of metal ???

Honest feedback from experience after working with Withings support for months with no improvement. Got the latest app version. Sadly, it got worse. New problems: BPM (blood pressure devices) no longer works. It crashes the app. Old problems (not able to test) Notifications don't work. Calls are the most reliable, but the rest don't work or are unreliable. BPM results are not readable when using a dark theme. Background color competes with foreground text, making it unreadable for someone with normal vision. If you are color-blind, I imagine it would be worse.

Did he just say wawa?

Not working good....

Too expensive

500 euros 💀💀

Don't buy this watch because it's not repairable, not openable ! I had mine for 2,5years, side button is becoming faulty , apparently it's a common problem, it's not under warranty anymore but they told me it's not repairable , so you pay 300€ for a disposable watch !

Man atleast press your shirt 😑

Not a good smartwarch. Not a good real watch.

First