I've never seen woodwinds moving in unison like ballet dancers. Only Ms Stutzmann can pull that one out of her magic hat! What JOY!!!

@marysalisbury9270

2 жыл бұрын

Yes!

Loved the tempi and the clarity. Orchestra wonderfully responsive to conductor and each other. Performance energy sustained throughout..admirable.

One of the best performances of this symphony. Beautifully clear recording too

@cynthiabeltran1680

19 күн бұрын

No. Too mild! Erwache! I'm not on the side of adolf, but on the side of music. kzread.info/dash/bejne/pZZ8ppNxaaenoJM.html

Amazing performance. By everyone. I don't think I've ever seen a conductor show so much pure joy in what they are creating. Brava Ms Stutzman, brava.

This really is one of the greatest performances of this piece to ever exist! Such great clarity!!

Merveilleux ! Juste énorme !!! Salle magnifique, et avec une bonne acoustique ! Bravo Nathalie !!

the way Nathalie allows the oboe solo section at 43:53 to be so slow and so serenely beautiful is breathtaking

@frogmouth

4 жыл бұрын

Stunning. So much movement in tempi. Adds to tension build and release. Gripping throughout.

Great conductor !!!!

In my opinion this performance is not lacking anything ... and is ~ in spite of the size of the orchestra ~ beautifully expressing Ludwig van Beethoven's intent of his so popular Third Symphony. Great rendition! Bravo Tapiola Sinfonietta! Bravo Nathalie Stutzmann! And ~ thank you for the listening pleasure :o)

Interpretazione Meravigliosa, Sublime. Grazie.

She is a wonderful conductor with a very skilled orchestra. And pretty sleeves! :D

Bravo ! Bravo! wonderful performance of Beethoven's Heroic Symphony.

Your orchestra does not have the moment to get bored. It was the best performance I have been listening the sympony with a sense of tension until the end.

@milannoah3306

2 жыл бұрын

sorry to be offtopic but does any of you know of a method to log back into an Instagram account..? I was dumb lost my login password. I would love any tips you can give me!

@kylenbrock408

2 жыл бұрын

@Milan Noah instablaster :)

Only two words : perfectly perfect !

Nice interpretation by the conductor Nathalie Stutzmann. I liked it indeed! I would appreciate very much if I could see her again conducting other Beethoven's Symphony.

wonderful and intelligence performance with the music spirit from that era

Ambrose Johnson, Bahamas. This is my favourite symphony, and I found this rendition to be particularly interesting; especially for a small orchestra. Beautiful!!

ottima performance..GRAZIE.

Bravo! Wonderful!

WOW! Some things I´ve never heard before ... It seems, that many smaller traits become clearer with a smaller orchestra...

Bravissimaaaaaaa !

Every note is new under this conductor's baton though the piece has been performed innumerable times.

Excellent! The challenge of Beethoven 3 nowadays is that it's often performed with a rather small orchestra. But maestro Stutzmann was really good at making a small orchestra sound grand! Congratulations on the Atlanta Symphony post! ASO has been trailing behind in the US top orchestras. Hope Stutzmann can bring it back to the front!

Vous avez LE FEU SACRÉ!

Jeśli symfonie Beethovena to tylko pod dyrygenturą Nathalie Stutzmann ! Kocham jej interpretacje, mam wrażenie że rozumie muzykę mistrza w pełnej rozciągłości.... Cudowne !!!!

@brave74

2 жыл бұрын

Полностью согласна!!! Натали самый выдающийся дирижёр современности)))

inconsueta taglia dell'orchestra ma alla fin fine all'epoca non avevao queste orchestre giganti di oggi e comunque suona molto bene....bravi e brava la Stutzman grintosa e precisa...

Surprisingly small size, but she makes the best and most out of the orchestra and the result is as good as - if not better than - any other monster size orchestras !!

HERMOSO

Bất hủ...

With modern instruments. Sound very well, dinamyc, con brio.

l'orchestre symphonique recommandé par Beethoven pour cette symphonie est 2 flûtes, 2 hautbois, 2 clarinettes en si♭, 2 bassons / 3 cors en mi♭ et en ut, 2 trompettes en mi♭ et en ut / 2 timbales (mi♭ et si♭) et des Cordes (Premiers violon, seconds violons, altos, violoncelles, contrebasses). Cet orchestre est peut-être un peu gros.

You hear something bizarre at 24:09....

@frogmouth

4 жыл бұрын

@Thomas Munn you are right. That is her voice joining in!

classic classical music

実に生き生きとした楽しそうなベートーベンたね．

5:00

31:50

15:02

Vania romero

Disapprovo totalmente l'op. 55 eseguita con un'orchestra da camera o poco più. Beethoven le sognava le orchestre dei nostri tempi. Peccato perchè in questo modo il suono non ha spessore, non ha corpo; peccato perchè l'interpretazione è molto buona, la lettura è davvero buona, ma certe scelte PSEUDO-filologiche lo sono molto meno.

@pilouetmissiou

9 жыл бұрын

beh però proprio perché Beethoven se le sognava le nostre orchestre penso che questa taglia sia più che accettabile anche perché i nostri strumenti sono comunque più brillanti di quelli dell'epoca di Beethoven, siamo noi che ci siamo abituati a degli orchestri giganti ma non è necessario e poi l'esecuzione è brillante

@jmrecillas

6 жыл бұрын

Credo che nessuno sappia quello di chi parla. Beethoven non poú avere in mente una orchestra che non era possibile al suo tempo. Questo argumento é semplicemente ridiculo, totalmente falto d'informazione. Beethoven pensando un'orchestra al ventesimo secolo? Absurdo!

@ilpulcinocosmico7399

6 жыл бұрын

José Manuel Martínez Recillas Sono d'accordo: gesto e intenzione sono qui più significative della massa sonora effettiva o auspicabile. Il suo carattere incisivo a dispetto dell'esiguita' dell'organico rende ancora meglio l'eroismo. Questa artista ha qualcosa da dire, può essere discutibile, non piacere, può sorprendere, ma fa senz'altro discutere. Ce ne fossero di direttori così!

Does anyone else here someone singing in the background at times? Kind of ruined it for me.

@trevorjones3273

6 жыл бұрын

I think Natalie Stutzmann was enthusiastically punctuating some of the rhythms with her voice. Sir Colin Davis had the same habit and so did Sir Thomas Beecham.

n my opinion , the conductor needs a more elegant technique in conducting this grand symphony. She certainly conducts like an amateur. Why does she use a book to conduct.

@frogmouth

4 жыл бұрын

What is an armarture please. She is an accomplished conductor. What is the book you refer to?

@k.s.naturalist6852

4 жыл бұрын

@@frogmouth Obviously you have no clue on conducting!! Stick with you apple pie, and be happy.

@frogmouth

4 жыл бұрын

@@k.s.naturalist6852 note you answered no questions. Osawa Seiji and Simon Rattle both backed Stutzmann. Kristiansand RTE and OSESP enjoy her collaborative style . Your comments are trollisch

@k.s.naturalist6852

4 жыл бұрын

​@@frogmouth Neither you nor Natalie fully understand Beethoven's music.. specially the symphony No. 3 Eroica. Nathalie Stutsmann should stick with conducting the early classical period composers.. Easier and more fluent. Beethoven's giant romantic era symphony is (Beethoven's key contribution and transition from classical to romantic).. is way above her head.. and as I mentioned she lacks correct emotions to conduct this type of music.. thus the comment! Good day.

@MegaVicar

3 жыл бұрын

@@k.s.naturalist6852 , you’re such a pretender. You seem to have no clue.