To be fair, it should have been a blind test... by that I mean someone who doesn't know either one.

@arvanni

5 жыл бұрын

I think that Buddy and maybe others would recognize the taste of their signature banana cream pie though.

@yasmineelmoussadek8053

5 жыл бұрын

belly QBE6878 but buddy already knows what the original banana cream pie looks like and who made it cuz he told them too

@andreaaranda2806

4 жыл бұрын

@@yasmineelmoussadek8053 They mean like people off the street, not someone from the bakery.

@willowravenwright5518

3 жыл бұрын

I say.... bring in some customers off the street. Let them have a sample of both. Let the customers decide what they will pay money for.

The original looks more appetizing...

@daniellekeogan8554

4 жыл бұрын

Agreed... I’ve tried it before

@katilynnixon8181

4 жыл бұрын

Danielle Keogan really

@vinny4149

4 жыл бұрын

This is why businesses fail. They hire some newbie with gay flare and they try to create new things. If it's working leave it. You dont need gay cakes that look like nipples. Its inappropriate and not classy.

@nerdyprique9083

4 жыл бұрын

Vinny youre delusional

@BlahBlah-bb6rl

3 жыл бұрын

The original looks extra as hell. I like the simpler one.

Rule #1 if you are working in a family inc. NEVER INSULT A FAMILY TRADITION. I was so happy that Buddy kep the original family recipe. Chad, RESPECT YOUR BOSS AND THERE FAMILY

@debanyaguirre3941

6 жыл бұрын

THEIR*****

@zoecassidy3269

5 жыл бұрын

Debany Aguirre Don't be that person...

@debanyaguirre3941

5 жыл бұрын

Well.. Sorry to tell you I AM that person

@weewuwu7583

5 жыл бұрын

Zoe Cassidy and ‘that’ person actually knows how to fucking spell

@edwinasas5075

5 жыл бұрын

Axel González not always buddy prob hired him becuz he speaks his mind like he did. every business needs someone to challenge the status quo

When Buddy tried the traditional cream pie and said "It brings me back to when I was a kid" and the look on his face AWW it was really cute and nostalgic xD

Buddy says “it brings me back to when I was a kid” but not everyone is going to have that experience and memory. But I would still choose buddy’s version

@karlamariaramirezfigueroa4190

3 жыл бұрын

Probably not, but if the pies are not selling is for a reason. Why would I want to pay bakery price for something that looks (an apparently tastes) like something I can get from my local Walmart for half the price?

I’m surprised that Chad was hired as a baker he was known for more of a decorator on The Next Great Baker!! Also Chad need to learn when to respect his boss and shut his mouth

@blindpeopledostuff3587

4 жыл бұрын

Itzel Zaragoza that makes no sense. Why the fuck should someone hire you if you’ve gotten ideas? At some point they want people that can do things not just be a sheep. When people get tired of their fucking companies crap who do you think they’re going to look to you to try something new because eventually people get tired of it.

@ricardoe3404

3 жыл бұрын

@@blindpeopledostuff3587 it was the fact he disrespected buddy, his boss. When he called the banana creme pie Sh*t. You don't do that crap, he's lucky he didn't get fired, they're is always someone who can take his job.

Thay should have used chades crust with the orignail bnana cream pie

@unikorn_thekidd2321

5 жыл бұрын

Yeah because they did like it🍮

@jamesryan6224

5 жыл бұрын

My thought exactly!

@cejadal

4 жыл бұрын

Chades

I love the positivism in the end, what everyone said about Chad's pie...that's family.

I know it's not all about the looks, but Chad looks plain and unappealing, while the original looks amazing and upscale and classy

@tangerinetech5300

4 жыл бұрын

I mean yeah the old one looks better but its a pie of mostly whip cream and why is there a strawberry on it. they seem to just do what looks good.

If you work at a generational bakery you shouldn't expect the owners or family members to really want to change. Even if Chad had a better pie than buddy's family recipe Buddy wouldn't want to change it because it's emotion rather than taste.

@solanatorales5851

2 жыл бұрын

@Sebastián Baeza the pies she put in trash was the new recipe

I don't like chad I think he is new and he already wants to change the recipe

@ThePrincessCH

6 жыл бұрын

He may be a bit arrogant, but Buddy has admitted that his version is pretty good.

@jamesryan6224

5 жыл бұрын

All you liberals hate people with great ideas.

@DavidDavid-fp6gv

4 жыл бұрын

It's a scripted TV show!

I’m surprised chad stayed after calling buddy’s recipe shit

I wanna taste buddy's banana cream pie so badly!

@morganmiller5413

5 жыл бұрын

Same! Now I want banana cream pie

@adore469

5 жыл бұрын

pinklips90 yess

@jessicaleach3757

4 жыл бұрын

pinklips90 Cool

Those aren’t pies anymore. That’s just some crust with whipped cream. One big mush 😂

Chad should get his own bakery if he wants to change the recipe whenever he wants. I would have fire him if he were to be my employee

To be honest every classic at Carlos is needed as classics always last for a log time

@trentmorgan5600

Жыл бұрын

well they always say if it ain't broke don't fix it

Chad’s pie looks very WEiRd

@libertymckenzie7001

4 жыл бұрын

Titty

I think Chad starting shit is just fo show he seems okay and to care about new creations

Chads just looks like something out of Publix’s while buddy’s looks like it should be in a bakery

the original cream pie looks so good

It's been a long time but I stop watching these videos ❤️

The original looks so so good

The carlos bakery ones looks better

@Kt-cn2rq

5 жыл бұрын

True, people see eyes first then their mouth second. True if Chad name it something else and guys come up with better design for it should sell well too.

Chad is a great baker very good recipes like his pies

Idk why people are offended in these comments. I like people who challenge tradition and bring new ideas to the table.

I been binge watching this chann. I swear im going to be so fat after trying all these recipe's at home!

Now I want to make a banana cream pie

Both of the recipes looks good !!! Buddy looks more fancy!!! Could call it chocolate banana pie !!

Honestly I don't see why they can't sell both cause Chad's looked good to be honest. I mean I don't blame them for going old school, but there's no harm in updating the pie.

Chad putting ripe bananas in the French cream is genius it's not using pudding mix it's natural not artificial

@dightonazpeitia4350

3 жыл бұрын

Lmao if you are a bakery using jello pudding mix then you are fucked before you even start

Cuál eligió? O cuál fue la mejor ? Al final creo que dice que cada una tiene lo suyo no?

amo ver cake Boos

I really don't like chad he' thinks he's top notch

@colemartin8526

5 жыл бұрын

His name is chad for a reason

His name is Chad, what were you expecting?

I WANT CAKEEEEEE!

But the million dollar question WHAT HAPPENS TO THE REST OF THE PIES

i’m just confused with the strawberry on top but i can see that the piping and bananas on the original makes it better, though i would for a limited time sell both versions to get an idea of if it’s good or not

@kathybear5818

Жыл бұрын

I think it’s because strawberry and banana go really good together and the strawberry adds that pop of color to make it more appealing.

Love the original

Why not try selling both and see which one shakes out..or keep two!

I want to try their original banana cream pie. It looks heavenly, yummy. 😋

I love eating cream pies so delicious warm and gooey

@dightonazpeitia4350

3 жыл бұрын

That’s probably why you’re so fat

Chad is a great baker a lot talent

Does anybody know what whipping cream brand they use?? Please 00:20

Neither one is a traditional banana cream pie. Banana cream is My favorite. It has a vanilla cookie crust, vanilla custard, bananas, whipped cream and almonds!

@jackaaroo1671

4 жыл бұрын

They mean their traditional banana cream pie, not the Americanized, processed kind

I have his receipe... and I plan on making it soon:-)

He was on the next great baker

Maybe use Chad’s crust with the traditional pie.

Idk maybe they could've compromised. Chad's recipe with buddy's decoration?

I've tried buddies recipe... it's phenomenal

Let me give you guys an idea you guys can make strawberry cream pie 😳😳😳

I know this is a super old video, but I hope Chad modified that and made a s’mores pie since there’s graham crackers and chocolate already in it; all it needs is the marshmallow.

The family one just looks old fashioned but you have to check your numbers - what sells? People's tastes change

carlos looks way better and it tastes better too, and they should have used the crust and then the original banana creme

What they should do is make chads pie and call it like.chocolate covered banana pie 🍌🍌

I don't know y he saying their original banana cream pie is not selling when it was his banana cream pie tht wasn't selling like step down dube u can't beat tht nice looking pie buddy's guys made

The old version what?

That guy thinks he’s better then THE BEST FAMILY RUN BALINB COMPANY EVER!

They should've let the public decide

Buddy i love u

What episode?

I wonder is there still successful now a days

I like how he incorporated banana into the banana cream I think that's a great idea cause it's not artificial and I look delicious

@dightonazpeitia4350

3 жыл бұрын

Put banana into the banana cream pie. I mean, it’s not fuckin’ rocket science.

Y is their a starberry on a banna pie

No se como no están gordod , con esas delicias que preparan, son una tentación.

@dightonazpeitia4350

3 жыл бұрын

Estas loco? El hombre mayor y Buddy son gordos

They could change up the crust.

You hire an expert and don’t let the expert do his job

I tried this, it tastes like toothpaste. Sour and metallic taste.

@blindpeopledostuff3587

4 жыл бұрын

600firefly1 which one?

To see what the banana cream pie should have looked orginally makes the one they found in the bakery at first so sad..

@delilahsamsons6503

4 жыл бұрын

K-Poppin Apsara Right, now we can understand why Buddy was upset..the original banana cream pie is such a feast on the eyes..gorgeous to the max..😊!

What a typical CHAD

I don’t like bananas 🍌 but that looks hella goood

That cake looks like the one of the buy at price smart for 3 bucks

@AndrewIndoChannel

Жыл бұрын

Price smart still exists?

@alejandroevl5890

Жыл бұрын

@@AndrewIndoChannel : in Panamá yes

When I seen this video I Wanted Hey banana

so wats the point of all this drama then?

I’m going to Carlo’s bakery today I want to try both of the pies

Y is their a strawberry on a banner pie

Quem tá assistindo 2017 👏🏼

The old version looks more tempting.😈

chad had no chance

I hate when how buddy says baby

I wish I could eat the banana cream pie 😭😫😀😋

Quien gano? No se Inglés

Bro like its a reality show you people are taking it really seriously

Banana cream pie with a strawberry on top 🤔

To be fair they should have blinded folded them to taste it

Vine a ver la segunda parte aquí jajaja

They should just change the crust

If I was in charge I'd sell both. Just give the new one a different name. If people buy it, then keep making it.

No lo tienen en español

I would of done blind test Then have the customers vote what they prefer. 🍌🍰

Pena q não tem tradução

Joey (baker) is a HOTTIE......me like alot

The the banana smore pie

Yall kno buddy wasnt changing shit

Chad needs to realize he is not the Cake Boss

@dightonazpeitia4350

3 жыл бұрын

He might as well be. Thanks to his injury, Buddy may never bake again.

Bolo de cenoura

I dead thought the three of them were bout deck the living shit out of chad for calling buddy pie trash

in spanish please

Poor Chad... you can tell he never got out of the house much as a kid and now he has a narcissistic side because I bet mommy and daddy gave him everything and no one was mean to him at culinary school that mommy and daddy paid for so when Buddy tells him he’s doing something wrong, he gets offended. Welcome to the Real World, Honey! Everyone ARENT going to coddle you like mommy and daddy!

This Chad guy keeps saying that their not selling because the original is messed up. THE REASON THEIR NOT SELLING IS BECAUSE THE ORIGINAL WAS SWITCHED OUT

But didn’t someone say it’s not selling? Then fuck it use the new one.