Automatic vs. Manual-Wind vs. Quartz Watch Movements
Тәжірибелік нұсқаулар және стиль
SOME OF MY FAVORITE WATCHES AND ACCESSORIES ON AMAZON
www.amazon.com/shop/chronomet...
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. You don't pay more by using these links.)
INSTAGRAM
/ chronometercheck
TWITTER
/ chrono_check
FACEBOOK
/ chronometercheck
FACEBOOK GROUP
/ affordablemechanicalwa...
PINTEREST
/ chronometercheck
BLOG
chronometercheck.com/
Taking a look at some of the most popular types of watch movements: automatic, manual-wind and quartz.
Пікірлер: 119
Quartz requires zero maintenance (except for the battery replacement) and tells the most accurate time. My Casio F91W will probably outlive me and still be running.
@msfjn130
6 күн бұрын
👍👍👍👍
@jeebusmcfries8114
4 күн бұрын
bro got 7 years to live 💀
You forgot the spring drive, the eco-drive or solar movement and the atomic movement. Also there is technically the pendulum but lets count that as mechanical.
@LockheedMartinF22Raptor7
Жыл бұрын
Eco-Drives are classified as Quartz movements, which takes artificial lighting and natural lighting and stores it in a power cell, much like a battery. Atomic movements are either quartz or electrical.
@provuksmc6619
Жыл бұрын
@@LockheedMartinF22Raptor7 so?
@nashooo5903
Жыл бұрын
I'd love to see a pendulum watch 😂😂😂
@provuksmc6619
Жыл бұрын
@@nashooo5903 You know shit like google images exists right?
@nashooo5903
Жыл бұрын
@@provuksmc6619 I know, I'm messing with you since there's no such thing as a pendulum watch. You meant a pendulum clock.
You forgot the most important one, the bowel movement. I just absolutely love the way the dial plays with the bathroom light. Ok, ciao!
@johnfadds6089
9 ай бұрын
It doesn't show the time though. But who cares about that, everyone has a phone.
@jeebusmcfries8114
8 ай бұрын
hublot uses those
I appreciate automatic watch and it's craftsmanship, but for me, accuracy is the most important thing for watches
@SectorS7VEN
7 ай бұрын
Same for me, accuracy for your value. Like I love my Seiko 5’s craftsmanship, but I can’t rely on it when its 10seconds off per day.
I’m new to the whole watch hobby, but the hate for quartz watches, moreso if said quartz watch is over a few hundred dollars, among some watch enthusiasts still surprises me. It’s a superior technology compared to the more traditional automatic but they act like they’re getting scammed.
@hydroxide5507
11 күн бұрын
paying big cash for cheap tech is crazy. i appreciate an affordable quartz tho.
I really love the tuning fork movements!:)
Photovoltaic cells under the dial plus a sturdy low-voltage capacitor eliminate the need for a button cell. Also, in a big watch, a conventional quartz movement combined with a big lithium cell like a 2032 can let the watch run for five years or longer. Those things store a lot of power.
Casio watches are the best
I really like mechanical watches, it's the interaction with the watch I like. Automatic s are cool too. 👍
Actually mechanicals seem to be more expensive in my opinion, there are alot more cheap automatics (seiko miyota) but mechanicals seem to be generally rarer and more expensive in the lower price range.
@friskjidjidoglu7415
Жыл бұрын
I’m confused…
@Ryann9
Жыл бұрын
@@friskjidjidoglu7415me too, how does adding a feature, automatic winding, make the watch cheaper?
@supremeleader5516
Жыл бұрын
Automatics are also mechanical
@tobiasnaylor
Жыл бұрын
@@supremeleader5516 i know, but theres no need to be awkward about naming conventions. Hand winding watches are called mechanical, Self winding watches are called automatic. That’s just what people have decided to call them
@Uno_Floydd
15 күн бұрын
@@Ryann9 would you rather have a lotus evora or a tesla?
Quartz for me .
Meanwhile people from 1950s : we didn't know we are rich
Literally have that exact orient Watch it is so pretty
Quartz is the one for me. Why? Because I’m lazy. Set it and you forget it. 😂
@menadionnassertamtama379
Ай бұрын
but you still have to replace the battery..automatic watch go on and on with no maintenance if you want to
@Uno_Floydd
15 күн бұрын
@@menadionnassertamtama379 solar quartz is the best
@Uno_Floydd
15 күн бұрын
@@menadionnassertamtama379 but its not that classy which is the draw back. Its like saying a tesla is faster but its an electric car so it has no soul
Kinetic, tuning fork, digital
I'm so in love with sinn 856
Just some pro tip. Its okay to have a quartz watch you may actually wear ur quartz more in your collection. Its very convenient and it looks good. Good quartz movement are the tissot prx, citizen eco drive, victorinox inox to name a few. And ofcourse the casio and swatch.
@mathiashallstrom4982
9 ай бұрын
Tissot prx etc is not watch movements but watch models, a Watch movement is something like the selitta sw200 that is found in alot of Automatic watches. If you are gonna talk shop, learn it properly, just a tip
@midnightfun1277
9 ай бұрын
@@mathiashallstrom4982 "with" good quartz movement.
In your first clip for your "quartz" movements you showed an ESA 9162/84. That one is a tuning fork movement and not quartz. Might want to add those to the list of movements cause you showed one.
what about the solar power Citizen Eco Drive & the Electromatic Seiko Kinenetic.
Quartz chronograph all day every day!
What about the spring drive? Mecaquartz ? And the electrostatic movements ?!?!
I really need someone's unbiased opinion, how good really are those sugess mechanical chronograph watches?
What about solar watch
So many watches here are depicted 10 past 10. I just saw a video 3 shorts up explaining how watches are displayed at 10 past 10 and if its a rolex its just a display with no mechanism ect.
@ChronometerCheck
Жыл бұрын
The 10:10 thing is interesting. Brands often use it in ads/shops/etc. as supposedly the symmetry looks better, and a bit like a smiley face (not sure about that one, ha) and more likely to buy. For Rolex, the myth is that if you see a watch in a Rolex store specifically set at 10:10, it might not have a movement. I've been in a Rolex store recently and plenty of the watches were running, so maybe they only do it with their rarer pieces? Not sure.
@CACOPHONIE
Жыл бұрын
@@ChronometerCheck without movement watch's second hand should lay down to 6 O'clock position due to not having angage with the initial torque.
@melody3741
Жыл бұрын
@@CACOPHONIE d lmao if this was true then the hands would fall out. It's a dummy movement. It holds them.
@jamesfair9751
Жыл бұрын
Also notice the date is always the 8th
That orient dial color is magnificent
@realistic_delinquent
6 ай бұрын
Champaign on the Bambino or syrup on the diver? Either way, yes!
I wish you didn’t introduce manual-wind/hand-winding mechanical watches just “mechanical”. I’ve noticed a lot of watch people do this and I think it makes things very confusing newcomers, especially since we don’t talk about the movements this way. Most uploaded comment here is a good example of how misusing “mechanical” makes things ambiguous. Do they mean that all mechanical watches are more expensive or sur manual-wind ones? It was difficult for me, a watch person, to tell Similarly, I’ve noticed the problem of watch people overusing the term “automatic” almost synonymously with “mechanical watch”, ex. “Quartz and automatic”.
@ChronometerCheck
Жыл бұрын
Fair point!
If you have even a slightly decent sized collection just go for the hand wind watches. The cases are smaller, the watches are lighter and the movements look better. Your auto is going to be dead anyway if you have a decent collection.
Good
Anyone have a genuine recommendation for quiet watches?
I switched to quartz watches....because of my job
I am new to all this and I was wondering. Why don't you watch KZreadrs add spring drives to this list. Are they considered automatic?
@ChronometerCheck
Жыл бұрын
It's one of the best types of movements, but it's quite niche (only exists in Grand Seiko) so more appropriate for an extensive video rather than a brief high-level (IMO!)
@melody3741
Жыл бұрын
Yeah they are VERY unique.
Technically? No, all automatic are actually and literally mechanical. Why are people saying mechanical and automatic are two different types of movements. I really don't get this. 🤔
@friskjidjidoglu7415
Жыл бұрын
This. It makes talking about automatic movements and hand wound movements very frustrating, cause it makes things needlessly ambiguous. No one talks about the movements like this only the watches, which is very frustrating
Solar powered over battery powered watch every day
I have atomatic watch
I swear by mechanical
@ChronometerCheck
Ай бұрын
I prefer it
The features of three types of watches are good, the battery type can last up to 10 years depending on the battery, while wind and mechanical-quartz/automatic are also precision based designs, including balance, making it as accurate and genuine.
I don't see any spring drive here🤔
Eco Drive
Spring drivee
I want one with a sweeping second hand, are all automatics sweeping?
@OriginalLoLRandom
Жыл бұрын
All automatic and hand-wound movements have a sweeping seconds hand, yes :)
@keithchegwin1222
Жыл бұрын
@@OriginalLoLRandom Thanks 👍
@ChronometerCheck
Жыл бұрын
Yes!
@ChronometerCheck
Жыл бұрын
You got it. :)
really? most of Patek's highest end watches, like most of the Grand Complications are hand wind.
Im confusion my watch is quartz because its using batteries but its also mechanical because I have to set the time with a dial and its solar powered so the battery never runs out. Super confused its the Seiko v158 0A0B rail road approved watch I had to buy working for Metro in LA
@ChronometerCheck
15 күн бұрын
Sounds like it's solar. Solar powered watches are battery powered, they just use a solar powered battery.
@Uno_Floydd
15 күн бұрын
@@ChronometerCheck which last longer than conventional batteries or solar powered?
@ChronometerCheck
15 күн бұрын
@@Uno_Floydd Solar
@Uno_Floydd
15 күн бұрын
@@ChronometerCheck thank you. Its just quartz solar you are correct
Smart watch is now most popular.
This is all wrong. Conflates how energy is stored and how time is kept. You have batteries (be they replaceable or solar recharged), springs (be they manually or automatically wound), and capacitor (see Accutron 2020 spaceview). Then you have quartz movements (digital or automatic) and escapements. Then you have things like Seiko's Spring Drive, which stores energy in a spring, but the time keeping comes from a quartz movement.
Quartz watches are also mechanical even though not classified as such but they do have a setting function and drive train as well but are only powered by a battery and quartz. No mainspring …
@BananaSchoolBus
Жыл бұрын
The classification system refers to how the movement receives power. Since a battery has no moving parts, a quartz watch would not be said to be mechanical.
Solar?
@kevinsonnenberg2868
6 күн бұрын
Eco drive by Citizen.
You forget to mention digital watch
@pravnav
5 ай бұрын
That’s quartz..
handwound automatic is the best for sure
It's really dumb that manual-wind watches are just called mechanical watches the term mechanical does nothing to differentiate it from an automatic, why not just call them manuals and automatics?? The worst part is that the nonsensical nomenclature is used by horologist/watch enthusiasts ... one of the only examples I've seen in all the hobbies and fields I've dipped my toe into where the true enthusiasts of a subject matter all accept something that's just objectively wrong
Quartz movement doesn't have to be powered by a battery.
@ChronometerCheck
Жыл бұрын
Such as?
@salty-chips
Жыл бұрын
@@ChronometerCheckThey might be referring to watches like the Seiko Kinetic which has a rotor that is coupled to a generator which charges a capacitor. Other than that there's the famous Grand Seiko Spring Drive. Both involve a quartz crystal buts it's a far cry to call them quartz movements.
@friskjidjidoglu7415
Жыл бұрын
@@ChronometerCheck solar
Wt about eco drive??
@antaeus716
Жыл бұрын
Quartz but the battery is charged via solar
@ChronometerCheck
Жыл бұрын
It's a type of quartz movement. An awesome one!
@ChronometerCheck
Жыл бұрын
Exactly! Thanks sir
digital watch crying in the corner
3 main types of watch movements? You mean: electronic, quartz and mechanical I guess...
@friskjidjidoglu7415
Жыл бұрын
Quartz is electronic
Gay?