This shows open mindedness and humility of h c Verma sir as a scientist 👏👏

@AbhishekChaudhary-uq4xo

Ай бұрын

I won't call it open-minded. I will call it mixing your beliefs with science, which is certainly not good if you are in the science stream.

@myname-rj9vb

Ай бұрын

@@AbhishekChaudhary-uq4xo a scientist put his beliefs into tests/ experiments . That's why he said to do experiment or statistical analysis whether astrology is true or not .

@AbhishekChaudhary-uq4xo

Ай бұрын

@myname-rj9vb not true. Scientists put the thesis to test, not beliefs. Both are two very different things.

@myname-rj9vb

Ай бұрын

@@AbhishekChaudhary-uq4xo thesis is also belief of a scientist about certain natural phenomena before putting to experiment. If it doesn't match with experiment scientist change his thesis .

@AbhishekChaudhary-uq4xo

Ай бұрын

@myname-rj9vb not entirely true. Thesis stems from observations, which are then studied upon. P.S. - Btw, research regarding astrology was published in 1985, and it found that astrology is no better than chance. In short, it's all prediction, nothing more

That's how a true scientist speaks.. science is all about continuous exploration..

@kaushalkumarsingh6063

Ай бұрын

Scientist? What he discovered or what he invented?

@GauravSharma-oh8po

Ай бұрын

He is a scholar than a scientist..his point is right...but jyotish is way too absurd to be taken seriously.

@peace44833

Ай бұрын

​@GauravSharma-oh8po yeah

@sunandobanerjee7665

Ай бұрын

Jyotish is not an absurd thing. People who think it is lack common sense and they don't want to explore things which are beyond their control​. People believe in gods and religious practices but don't believe in Astrology 😂, thousands of years back lord parashara wrote the Astrology book BPHS and his son ved vyas wrote Mahabharata with the help of lord Ganesha. Everything is linked to astrology. If you say that Mahabharata, ramayana everything is fake that's your biggest mistake. I am myself an IIT graduate and pursuing PhD currently in IISc. Being a science and technology student, i never knew about astrology as such but was eager to explore it. I have seen my father making very accurate predictions about my friends , he is also an IIT graduate and has been practising astrology for last 15 years. Every major event which happens in our lives is predestined. We think we can change our fate and it's all in our control 😂😂😂. We are just mere puppets in the hands of God. Whatever be our path be, the outcome is already destined.

@shubhramandal3816

Ай бұрын

To sab pre destined hain Kisiko kuch karne ki kya jarurat hain god ne to likhi diya jo hona hain wahi hoga koi bimar hoga to doctor ko dikhane ki kya zarurat agar bachna hain to khid bach jayega marna hain to mar jayega​@@sunandobanerjee7665 Teacher ko padhane ki kya zaroorat jisko padhna hain khud padh lega Invention karne ki kya zaroorat jo hona hain wo ho jayega Bhook lage to khana khane ki kya zaroorat agar likha hua hain khana to khud hi pet k andar chala jayega Kisiko kuch karne ki koi jarurat nehi jo hona hain ho jayega sab log so jao Mujhe laga tha iit wale sabse tez hoye hain but nehi ye to ghor andhbiswasi hain Astrology ki bat karu to sirf predict kar sakte hain proof nehi Science me to kuch hi exception milega Lekin astrology k pass jao 99 percent exception hain Ekdum faltu hain agar astrology keh diye tum mar jaoge 2 din baad to 100 percent chance wo 2 din baad bimar ho jayega Sabkuch faith par chalta hain Phir arjun nehi ladhte shri krishna keh dete mat ladho arjun jo hona hain ho jayega Bar bar bataya geya hain karm par dhyan do baki result par nehi paristhiti hat me nehi hain lekin karm humare hat me hain Koi kisika bhabisya bata nehi sakta sirf prediction laga sakta hain .....

आपका यह इंटरव्यू बहुत ज्यादा अच्छा लगा महोदय. और आदरणीय वर्मा साहब का सुझाव बहुत सही है कि किसी चीज को सीधे-सीधे नकारने की जगह उसका बड़े पैमाने पर वैज्ञानिक और गणितीय विश्लेषण करके उसका उत्तर ढूंढना चाहिए. विज्ञान और आस्था की तकरार इसी वज़ह से है कि अधिकतर पढ़ेलिखे बुद्धिजीवी वर्ग किसी बात को सीधे नकार देते हैं. 80% बातें धार्मिक किताबों और पंडितों की में भी मानता (विश्वास) हूँ. पर जो लिखा या बताया गया है उसको मानने या गलत ठहराने के पीछे तर्क की जगह मजबूत गणितीय वैज्ञानिक साक्ष्य हो तो बेहतर होगा.

@jackshulka428

Ай бұрын

जो बात बार बार लगातार गलत साबित हो रही हो उसको क्या गलत साबित करना, विज्ञान बकवास बातों को गलत साबित करने के लिए काम नही करता, अगर मे कहूँ के परियां होती है लेकिन खुद उनके होने को साबित करने के बजाए विज्ञान से कहूँ के विज्ञान स्टडी करके साबित करे की परियां नही होती, अजीब बात है ना? बस वैसे ही विज्ञान ज्योतिष जैसी बकवास चीजों के उपर क्यू अपना समय बर्बाद करेगा, ज्योतिष को सही साबित करना उनका काम है जो ज्योतिष को महान विधा बताते है,

@geolover5958

Ай бұрын

❤❤

@bahubali100bb

Ай бұрын

साक्ष्य देने की जिम्मेदारी उसकी होती है जो उसका दावा करता है।ज्योतिष लोग बड़े पैमाने पर सबूत देने को तैयार हो तो बात करे

@bahubali100bb

Ай бұрын

ऐसे तो कल को कोई भी कुछ भी दावा करके उसे गलत साबित करने की जिमेदारी अन्य लोगो पर डाल देगा!जैसे मै कह दूं कि यहाँ से 500 लाइट ईयर दूर एक गृह पे परियां रहती है।और आपसे कहूँ कि इसे एकदम से मत नकारिये बल्कि इसके गलत होने के लिए उचित वैज्ञानिक प्रूफ दे।क्या आप मेरे ऐसे क्लेम को मानेंगे?

@jackshulka428

Ай бұрын

@@bahubali100bb kya baat hai, same mene bhi aisa hi sawal yha par in mahashay se kiya tha lekin mera comment pata nhi kue delete kar diya gya.

Excellent effort from lallantop channel to invite professor H C Verma sir........ I grew up reading physics books written by him .........Now I am very happy to see and hear him in person.......Verma Sir is really having a charming personality and I got a great experience to see him in person 👌👌👌👍

सबको संतुष्ट करने की बाते बोलो यही सफलता का मूलमंत्र है😂

@Shawn_mike34

Ай бұрын

Side lega toh bologe side le raha hai

@vikasmadd

Ай бұрын

😄

@abhi9va26

Ай бұрын

Correct

@ShivamRaj-of1uw

Ай бұрын

Good analysis beta... 😅

I was in a 10 days training program at IIT kanpur and I saw this man such a lenient and humble personality .

HC Verma can be a good politician...he never answers negatively

@rjoshi619show

Ай бұрын

Achha Politicians negative nhi hote?

@sakshiyadav8534

28 күн бұрын

Agreed😂

@mohammadinamullah9380

25 күн бұрын

Hamare Guru dev ko Guru hi rahne dijiye. Unka contribution education mein bahut hai.

True scientific approach.

Wow stunned by this answer......a true scientist.....hats off Hc Verma Sir......

Thank you Verma sir, you have given a research topic for many mathematical students.

Absolutely right ❤

प्रोफेसर वर्माजी बहुत ही सुलझे हुए ज्ञानी ध्यानी महापुरुष हैं। जय श्रीकृष्ण राधे राधे जय सियाराम नमः शिवाय। नमामि देवी नर्मदे नारायण नारायण।

@Pain53924

Ай бұрын

No evidence of gods though

@vikasmadd

Ай бұрын

Prof Varma 70 ki age me bhi seedhe no khna nhi seekh paye abhi bhi believers ko khush krne wala jawab deke nikal liye

@nareshjoshi161

Ай бұрын

@@vikasmadd इसीलिए मैंने उन्हें सुलझा हुआ माना,हालांकि मैं उम्र में उनसे बहुत छोटा हुं उन पर या उनकी बातों पर किसी भी प्रकार का विश्लेषण करने के योग्य नहीं हुं फिर भी ईश्वर ने जो बुद्धि दी है और जो मेरी समझ में आया वो मैंने कह दिया।आपकी बातों से मैं सहमत हुं। जय श्रीकृष्ण राधे राधे जय सियाराम नमः शिवाय। नमामि देवी नर्मदे नारायण नारायण।

@anirudhroy6124

Ай бұрын

​@@Pain53924do you have any evidence of Aliens??

@CillianMurphy.

Ай бұрын

​@@Pain53924u r right but show me the evidence that there is no evidence of God.

Did Mr. Jayant Narlikar discussed with reknown astrologer of current times Mr. K.N. Rao. Mr. has the largest collection of horoscopes (more than 75000) with 5 to 10 main events of the native's life noted in his record. He can help Mr. Narlikar in his quest. Mr. Rao taught astrology in Delhi's Bhartiya Vidya Bhawan since 1980's. He is now 92 years old and currently residing in Bangalore.

Thanks to lallantop team who invited our beloved HC verma sir.

Such a great answer, truly HC Verma Sir is a deep ocean of experience, wisdom and truth❤

The best opinion I have seen on the internet

वर्माजी आयु के उस दौर में आ चुके हैं जहां ईश्वर के अस्तित्व को मानने का मन करने लगता ही है।युवावस्था में स्वयं की शक्ति पर बहुत भरोसा रहता है।उम्र बढ़ने के साथ साथ जीवन में कईं घटनाएं ऐसी घटित होने लगती है कि समझ आने लगता है कि इतनी बड़ी दुनिया को चलाने के लिए और सबको प्रेरित करने के लिए कोई शक्ति अवश्य है।मन कही न कही अच्छे अच्छे नास्तिक भी ईश्वर के अस्तित्व को स्वीकार करने को मजबूर हो जाते हैं। वर्माजी के परिवारिक संस्कार उन्हें आस्तिक ही बनाते हैं।उन्हें इससे इन्कार नहीं दिखाई पढ़ता। जय श्रीकृष्ण राधे राधे जय सियाराम नमः शिवाय। नमामि देवी नर्मदे नारायण नारायण।

@jackshulka428

Ай бұрын

शायद इसी को बुढ़ापे मे सठियाना कहा गया है हमारी भारतीय संस्कृति मे 😁

@nareshjoshi161

Ай бұрын

@@jackshulka428 सठियाना एक सामान्य अवस्था है।जैसे बचपन में सामान्य बच्चे सामान्यतः खेलकूद और मस्ती करते हैं किशोरावस्था में थोड़ा गंभीरता के दर्शन युवावस्था में जोश खरोश जैसा।ऐसे ही वृद्धावस्था जिसमें थोड़ा धैर्यपन का आना थोड़ा अहिंसात्मक विचाराधारा आना गांधीजी के सिद्धांतों और कईं विचारधाराओं से सहमत होना धार्मिक और आध्यात्मिकता का जीवन में आना स्वाभाविक बातें है। जय श्रीकृष्ण राधे राधे जय सियाराम नमः शिवाय। नमामि देवी नर्मदे नारायण नारायण।

Great answer by a great scientist. We cannot outrightly reject or accept a thing without knowing the truth.

The perfect answer. This is a true scientific temper.😊

Satisfied Answer

That is how real scientists think. Always open to all possibilities, without bias.

Baat toh sahi keh rhe ho (btw ye comment sirf mere new contact lens sahi hai ya nai dekhne ke liye kiya hai) poora video bhi nai dekha thank you.

When i was in 10th my school arranged dr jayant naradikars seasion...i after a decades i got here here his name here in this programme ...👍🙏

What a great answer! That is a sign of a true scitific temprament ❤

I liked it very much...the great H.C.VERMA...

Great response 👏👏

Salute to the explanation

Very true sir That's why HC verma sir is a institution itself. Regards

हमें आपके वीडियो बहुत अच्छे लगते हैं प्रोफेसर के रीजन भी बहुत अच्छे लगते हैं हम आप को दिल से धन्यवाद देना चाहता हूं

I rarely comment on social media. Here, I could not stop myself without replying. That was outstanding and fantastic approach. Nice to hear you sir. Being from Bihar, I feel proud of you sir.

Interesting ❤

Bilkul Sahi baat hai analysis bahut jaruri hai...

Very good explanation

Dr Narlikar did complete one statistical study regarding astrological prediction of intelligence. The conclusion was that horoscopes cannot predict intelligence. The paper was published in the journal Current science

A true scientific approach

Nice approach

Very scintific answer..

Please 🙏🏻 sir bring these types of people on this show maza aa gya ❤

Nice explanation 🕉️

Resealable Man talking very pragmatic way os scientific analysis 👏 👌

HC Verma ji ka jawab sahi hai.

Our Beloved Great HC Sir..❤ This is how a true genius looks like. Until we can't prove something wrong we can't say it's wrong.

Absolutely 💯

Guru ji sahi baat kr rahe h

Excellent teacher ❤❤, pranam gurudev

How fantastic man sir 🙏.. Ar bahat a6a explain Kiya answer.. I solve HC Verma sir physics...

Great personality sat sat naman

Wow, extremely amazed by HC Verma's views , view is accommodative and rational

@vikasmadd

Ай бұрын

Prof Varma ne majority ko naraaz na krne wala ans diya hai bas

@shaunakroy4

Ай бұрын

@@vikasmadd Majority kaun hai bhai? Zara population census batana

@vikasmadd

Ай бұрын

@@shaunakroy4 majority is believers minority is non believers

@shaunakroy4

Ай бұрын

@@vikasmadd believers of what?

@vikasmadd

Ай бұрын

@@shaunakroy4 believers of higher power. citing God as reason for universe's existence

Real intellectual person 🙏❤️

सौरभ भैया का दिल टूट गया सर के आंसर को सुन कर , सौरभ भैया हमारे यहाँ एक पीर बाबा भी हैं , वो भी जोतिषी काका की तरह भविष्य देखने की बात करते हुए कहते हैं की कयामत का दिन आएगा इत्यादि, उनके बारे में भी जरूर पूछिएगा और अंत में कहना चाहूंगा की मेरे प्रश्न का उत्तर जरूर से दीजिएगा , व्याकरण की अशुद्धि ढूंढ कर खारिज न कर दीजिएगा। धन्यवाद

@PolymathHindi

13 күн бұрын

You exposed his hypocrisy very well🤣🤣

It's great to see that H C Verma Sir has a believe in astrology...

This not not an interview this is masterpiece of communication between a physics and journalism legend ❤

सहयोग इस लिए नहीं कोई किया क्यूँ कि हो सकता है जो मार्केट बसा है उजड़ ना जाए 😂😂

@Nawaab904

Ай бұрын

Farzi walo ka pta nhi , but astrology is a true science

@rdmmishra2994

Ай бұрын

Date of birth aur time share kar Bhai apna tumhara bhram door kar deta hu

@ARutkarsh

Ай бұрын

@@rdmmishra2994 kya btayega?

@PositivismAtItsBest

Ай бұрын

@@rdmmishra2994don’t - let them suffer and be ignorant - it’s meant for only intelligent and few people 🎉

@quantsconnection

Ай бұрын

@@rdmmishra2994 09/12/1992 05:45 am Bhai please mera btao 🙏

Mera Manna hai jyotish Jo hota hain wo sach hain bas batane wala aur samjhane Wale acha vyakti mil jaye .ek log ne mere bhoot mere vartman aur mere bhavishya ke bare me Jo kaha wo sach hua aur sach ho raha hai isiliye muje bhartiya jyotishsi par poora vishwas hain

Jyotish is an ancient astronomy of india, developed over time thousands of years ago. Planetry positions could be calculated eaisly by seeing the observed data of planets. But the further claim of life events dependent on planetary positions should be researched in details.

@Abcdefgh-zl1pw

28 күн бұрын

Nice joke.... Jyotishi has no relation with science. It is s t u p I d. And has no logic.

Love you ❤

Great

There is a thing called tad patri and this was written 100s of years ago and it has written about the people of present times. Its very accurate i myself experienced it.

HC Verma Ji is unbiased. Open Minded ...

छा गए हमाय प्यारे सौरभ दाऊ बहुत अच्छो लगो आपके मो से हम ओरन की भाषा सुनके ,,,,❤ सई में गुरु गजब ढा रए ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

@diligentsoul

Ай бұрын

अरे बस करो, यार वीडियो को मत देखना दुनिया की बात लेकर आ गया बीच मे

He is true academician, that's why he want to explore the possibility

Great teacher 👏

plz kervao naa, ❤❤❤❤❤❤, as it's the most needed arena

Astrophysicist was waiting for astrologers to come and join him. But Astrologers ka graha thik nhi tha isiliye nhi aya😂😂😂

@ashwinigautam7282

Ай бұрын

He should have invited Lunar astro and Punneit Astrology

Yes! there might be working some undiscovered theory which is still out of our understanding but we cannot denied blindly that's why a proper experiment is required by collecting all those random events to check the percentage of accuracy whose astrology is more correct and why❤

Right sir, Analysis honi chahiye.

Finally I got the answer...

सर विज्ञान तो है मगर आवश्यकता इस बात की है कि अलग विभाग बने और रिसर्च किया जाये हो सकता है कि विज्ञान और इसको समझने में बहुत कुछ, सामने निकल के आ सकता है। खेल पूरा गणना का है।

@Venom-uu1ge

Ай бұрын

Already bahot log kr rkhe h, kuch nhi pta chala. Now tm hi koi genuine astrologer ko dhundh ke research krlo aur paper publish krdo, noble prize waiting for you.😊

@mayankpandey5797

Ай бұрын

​@@Venom-uu1ge since you are telling so many research has been done in past, so could you please refer some research paper link in the comment box? If not so please stop spreading wrong news .

@Venom-uu1ge

Ай бұрын

@mayankpandey5797 Sure dear, some of the famous tests that have been done are blind experiment by carlson. Geoffrey Dean debunking Mars effect. Thagard study of 1978, Fichten and Sunerton 1983, I can list like this countless study and research done to debunk astrology.

@peace44833

Ай бұрын

​@@Venom-uu1gebro you're right.

@jackshulka428

Ай бұрын

@@mayankpandey5797 ab bol😁

Right Saurabh bhai... discard kar dete hain ya maan lete hain... koi janna nehi chahta.. bahot zarurat hai janne ki.

Very well said sir, Isiliye education is important.

Me sochta tha kab buleyge lallan top wale hamre guru ji ko thanks a lot

Sir apki sound. And apki personality my high school teacher

Indian Government and Big Agencies needs these types of experiments.

Saurabh look out if you can reach out to Mr K N Rao and get an insight of his research and experiences which he came across his journey as astrology teacher and a spirituality seeker. This can be as scientific as possible which you are asking H C Verma Sir.

@akashdubey7903

26 күн бұрын

Someone still trying to hope that it is proven. Science works on what is proven and not believing what is not yet.

❤

Spoken like true scientist

Astrology WAS a part of science for a long time throughout the world. Then they corrected that with astronomy. Yeah India is very late to introduce astrology in science and will be VERY late to remove it !!

@akashdubey7903

26 күн бұрын

Bhai dono alg alg hote hen...and science is not your science or my science. If it cannot be proved by cause and effect relationship it is not science. Which it was never

@sangramraje5667

24 күн бұрын

Kamasutra was also a part of science, it should be reintroduced in schools.

he is not making conclusions that's the best quality of scientist or researcher..

@rationalist455

10 күн бұрын

He is not a scientist,understand that.He is academician,he will always trust the things which are evidence based. that's what his point is.scientist who doesnt want to reach to conclusion is failed scientist

🙏

While it's important not to fully endorse or discard astrology, those who champion science and its solid factual basis should recognize that the atomic model has evolved through more than six revisions in the past 300 years. Despite this, scientists still debate the validity of the current model. This shows that even scientific theories and projections can have flaws and uncertainties. Rather than immediately dismissing practices or rituals, we should foster open dialogue and exploration through debates and inquiries to gain a deeper understanding of such ideas and beliefs.

@akashdubey7903

26 күн бұрын

Until we get proof we should discard and not believe in bullshit on the name of religion and culture

सहमत

Apki Bundeli boli sunke bahut Acha laga Sir.

May be

Pehle bar sahi bände ko bulaya hai 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩

Umang Taneja ji Nadi Astrologer ko bulaye sab baat clarity or logically samjh aa jayegi Astrology se related.

True..science is unaware of many things till now..may be just explored hardly 1% universal theories

Achha jawab tha ye

यदि हमारा जीवन ग्रहों या नक्षत्रों से ही तय होता है हमारी चेतना और श्रम का कोई जरूरत नहीं । हमसे कुछ होना ही नहीं तो क्यों कुछ करें । ये बस लोगों को मूर्ख और उसकी जैसी जिंदगी है उसे सही ठहराने की शाजिस है । लोग किसी बाहरी चीजों को बड़ा मानते रहें और सरकार और पैसे वालों को पूजते रहें ।

Abhi bhi time he koi research paper publishe kardo nahi to kisi din sunne ko milega ki foreign ki koi professor👨‍🏫 r Ye discover kya ki planet and star ki movement se hamare life ko affect karte he or nobel Prize le kr jayaga😅😅 Phir indian bolenge hamare pass to ye chiz 1000+ sal se pehele thi humko koi pucha nahi😅😅

bharat ki sanskriti ka kendrabindu hi vigyan...so astrology is a pure science based method.. but yes let's do a scientific analysis of it ...I agree with you sir

Ab ye sambhav hai stochastic process, markov chain aur advanced probablity ko AI ke saath milana padega. Han agar data sufficient hai tab.

भारत में ज्योतिष का पाखंड इतना है कि 51 रुपए में ग्रहों की दिशा बदल देते हैं 😂😂😂

@AshishSingh-tq3fd

Ай бұрын

Jhola chhap doctors hote hain to iska matlab ye prove to nahi ho jata na ki medical science farzi he. Kundli ke upar debate ke alawa agar vikram samwat calender ko dekho to surya grahan aur chandra grahan ki calculation bhi to jyotish satik karke batata he.

@manishtripathi3096

Ай бұрын

ज्योतिष को विज्ञान कहते है, तुमको अगर भौतिक विज्ञान नहीं आता तो क्या भौतिक विज्ञान नहीं होता😂🤣🤣😂😂

@mohsinalithecver8

Ай бұрын

Tere jaise hi 36 firte Hain un pakhandiyon ke aage piche time aane pe 😅

@indrajitdas8254

Ай бұрын

​@@manishtripathi3096 vigyan kehne se ee ho gaya vigyan ya uska kuch pta v he 😂

@ashutosh3628

Ай бұрын

Greek technology hai​@@manishtripathi3096

He is legend of physics

I also have the same temparanent

Universe is a summation of random things. If universe is random how can astrology be organised? If astrology proves to be right it is only because of random guesswork nothing else. Prof Varma is a shrewd man he knows how to answer a question which is debatable- he would not outrightly reject the astrology but would give a balanced answer so that to maintain the equilibrium and be in the good books of believers.

@shrin210

Ай бұрын

Universe is random. But in this randomness there is chance when conditions are met and Life being exist on a planet. I think using Science to destroy that the jyotishi is nonsense and a guesswork Rather than outhrightly rejecting things. Because Sciencitic testing has been done on monks that Meditations, Yoga actually works for depression and stress rather than just eating medicine.

@vikasmadd

Ай бұрын

@@shrin210 Look bro, I never questioned Yoga. I didn't say Astrology as a nonsense. I merely said it is a random guesswork nothing else.

Astrology app es time chhaya hua hai❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Like only for professor Saab❤..... not for lallantop

Prof वर्मा सचमुच वैज्ञानिक दृष्टिकोण से ही उचित उत्तर देते हैं।

Modern physics और classical Physics दोनों ही astrology के tools हम क्या सोचते हैं कैसे अपनी सोच बदलती है क्यों सबकी सोच अलग अलग होती है ये सब physics से prove किया जा सकता है। Lallan top एक बार अपना मंच दे हम perfectly prove कर देंगे।

May be when astrology was introduced in past at that time humans used to transmit or receive at the frequency at which other plants of our SS used to radiate and could affect in one or the another way their lives. But today obviously we humans are so disturbed that we might not get affected by those planetry forces being on low energy. Just a random thought😊