Are AirPods Safe for Shooting? : The Science of Hearing Protection

Спорт

In this episode, we take a comprehensive look at hearing protection in shooting sports. Are active noise cancelling headphones adequate to protect your hearing? We talk to two experts in the field of hearing loss and find out, once and for all, whether you are doing enough to protect your hearing.
electronichearingprotection.us
Chapters:
0:00 Intro
0:49 "The Problem"
2:02 Meeting our experts
3:22 Sound
4:24 How the ear works
5:47 Hearing damage
10:03 Active noise-cancelling headphones
12:06 Testing AirPods Pro for shooting
15:29 GOOD hearing protection roundup
23:00 SoundGear Phantoms
26:43 The Verdict
27:13 Making custom ear pro
30:27 Montage
Equipment:
DJI Air 2s Drone
Sony FX3 Cinema Camera
Sony A7IV
G-Master lenses
Rode VideoMic Pro Plus
Sony XLR Microphone
iPhone 14 Pro Max
Disclosures:
Electronic Hearing Protection (EHP) is a supporter of The Clay Lab. All hearing protection was purchased by individual Clay Lab members, with the exception of SoundGear Phantoms, which were provided by EHP.
Disclaimers:
All logos used in this video were used by express permission of Electronic Hearing Protection and SoundGear. The opinions expressed by our guest are their opinions only, and do not represent the positions of Virginia Commonwealth University or CarolinaEast Medical Center.
Music and Stock Footage:
Used under license from Envato Elements
Note: Aerial videography performed in compliance with 14 CFS Part 107 and all applicable FAA regulations governing sUAS operations. Maximum altitude was 200 feet AGL. Stock footage was obtained of downtown Richmond. All dirt roads in the video are private with controlled access. No flight was performed over people.
Remote Pilot in Command: Scott Hardison
This video and channel are a product of Clay Lab USA, LLC.

Пікірлер: 50

  • @SL33KDOT
    @SL33KDOT Жыл бұрын

    As someone who has only used disposable orange earplugs, I appreciate that you described all of the relevant options and what really shines as the best options. You also took the effort to emphasize how easy it is to get a mold and I hope to one day get a fitted filter ear plug

  • @1yehny
    @1yehny10 ай бұрын

    I subbed before I knew you guys were ENT. Nice to have docs who aren't afraid of showing shooting content.

  • @claylabusa

    @claylabusa

    9 ай бұрын

    Thank you! appreciate it and we definitely have tried to bring solid content.

  • @tommyleemaddox1033
    @tommyleemaddox1033 Жыл бұрын

    This is excellent and very welcome information. Many thanks from N. Georgia!

  • @cafowler1000
    @cafowler1000 Жыл бұрын

    good job guys!! well covered important topic, spot on.

  • @shawnobrien5447
    @shawnobrien5447 Жыл бұрын

    As always.....a great video. Has all the information for someone to make an informed decision on which product works for them. I have the SoundGear not the phantoms. Like them a bunch. I wear hearing aids because I do have hearing loss. So wearing my SoundGear gives me the ability to hear what is going on around me at the range. Saftey first! As always, looking forward to what is next!

  • @TheDks300
    @TheDks30011 ай бұрын

    I really enjoy the content but we need more of it!

  • @ttpnw1776
    @ttpnw17769 ай бұрын

    Good info always appreciate real world testing with some science behind it

  • @user-vj3ov7tq9d
    @user-vj3ov7tq9d Жыл бұрын

    Thank you so much for all the great information! Especially that AirPods are Not hearing protection!! Awesome video.

  • @dnhart6
    @dnhart6 Жыл бұрын

    Dr. Gina is awesome! She addressed the issues i was experiencing at Nationals/San Antonio with my Phantoms this last year and hooked me up! Unbelievable service above and beyond the call! It pays to use professionals, especially when dealing with hearing and vision!!

  • @168dac
    @168dac Жыл бұрын

    Another fantastic video! So much so that I've just ordered a pair of Sounder Phantoms which I'm having to import into the UK from the USA as they're not available to purchase over here at the moment. Are any of you guys coming over to the UK to shoot the ESP World Championships at the beginning of July?

  • @joeyd1636
    @joeyd1636 Жыл бұрын

    Love the video! Just disappointed you didn’t cover the silicone style ear plugs! I wear the safari land silicone ear pieces with passive filter and wanted to get a review on that style also.

  • @claylabusa

    @claylabusa

    Жыл бұрын

    Hey! Thanks for the feedback. I agree, those would have been a great thing to include but didn’t have any personal experience with them. I’ve looked up the Safariland plugs with the filters that you mentioned and they look like they’d be excellent! They have a NRR of 33 dB. Very similar to the custom plugs with filters, with the only difference being that the fit may not be exactly right for some people. Overall, though, great choice. I’d have absolutely no concerns about using them to protect my own hearing

  • @Frankyfromnj
    @Frankyfromnj Жыл бұрын

    Great piece.. very helpful. I’ve been using SoundGear product for a number of years. Well worth the price. However, those batteries are a real PITA.. I’m going to look into the rechargeable model.

  • @nortonco_shootingsports
    @nortonco_shootingsports Жыл бұрын

    Interesting video. 2 things, 1. I’m currently looking into are quality glasses and hearing pro and both combined are the cost of low end guns 🥲 and 2. Do a funny “What to do and not do” sporting clay etiquette video. Competitive shooter myself (met Jeremy at the NC State Championship this past weekend) I’ve seen the angry, the rude, and the careless. Would be a funny topic to cover for any level of shooter. Just an idea.

  • @alanwise7868
    @alanwise7868 Жыл бұрын

    Really great and informative video! Thank you! Here's a question for you, or maybe it's a bit of something supplemental you could cover on this topic: Within what distance of people shooting do you want to make sure you have hearing protection in your ears? My father was a physician and would shout at me as a kid for not having ear plugs in unless I was either on the line shooting (trap and skeet) or probably within 30 yards of others shooting; but I was a dumb, rebellious kid then and now wear my ear protection almost at all times (especially with the advent of the electronic models), like he used to and wanted me to. However, I notice many, many people don't wear anything unless they are essentially actively shooting. Would love your thoughts on this.

  • @quinnsmith5704
    @quinnsmith5704 Жыл бұрын

    Great video gents. I have had an interesting journey with ear protection. Ive worked with an audiologist a few times but cant find a custom fit plug that seals in my ear when I mount the gun and when im just standing about. It seems that the way I mount changes the shape of my ear canal too much, so ive had to go back to the foam plugs.

  • @budzo100
    @budzo10011 ай бұрын

    One further question I have. Great video by the way, very informative. Hence my question. I was informed that unless you are using a full ear muff, like the Walker's or Peltor's, that cover the whole ear, you'll still receive damaging vibrations and noise to the ear bones. Because the ear muff covers that back of the external ear and along the head. This point was not brought up on this particular video. But I'd like to know if this is the case? I have switched back to Walker ear muffs from the shot cancelling ear plugs for this reason. My shot cancelling ear plugs are designed by company's that specialize in shooting ear protection so I know I'm getting a good sound cancelling with the ear buds. But this question of the ear bones along the back of the ear is my concern and the damage that could result because of using an Ear bud/plug. Can you please assist?

  • @gloriousasssquat1876
    @gloriousasssquat18765 ай бұрын

    Y’all gotta be in with some kind of think tank lol, insanely well made content and great information with so few views is wild

  • @claylabusa

    @claylabusa

    5 ай бұрын

    Thank you! That tends to happen lol some people want education while others only want to be entertained regardless of the quality. Going to keep trying to put out good content. Thanks for being a subscriber!

  • @TPVPRO
    @TPVPRO5 ай бұрын

    Why did you not include AXIL and other brands that are readily available off Amazon?

  • @claylabusa

    @claylabusa

    5 ай бұрын

    I believe at the time the point we were trying to get across was there are different categories ear protection that functionally work and those that didn't as Apple ipods were not designed for ear protection and that noise canceling is not protection. All of the other brands out there designed for ear protection would fall into simple categories that are either plugs, filtered plugs, or electronic assisted. Then either fitted or non-fitted. What specific brand a person goes with is subjective to personal preference, value that people put on their hearing, economic feasibility etc. Plenty of quality options out there, some better than others but all have pros & cons. Educating folks on hearing protection was the main goal. I'm personally happy with .50cent foamies or $1600 Electronics. But I prefer the electronics for ease of use when interacting with people all the time. Hope that helps.

  • @thebigguy5538
    @thebigguy5538 Жыл бұрын

    Dang! I thought my tinnitus was getting worse. Glad it was just the video!!

  • @jonkryman5254
    @jonkryman5254 Жыл бұрын

    Another excellent video. I am also an M.D. and this video has the perfect balance of technical/science and practical info for all shooters to appreciate and learn from. Please keep the videos coming !!

  • @nathanschock4858
    @nathanschock485810 ай бұрын

    Can anyone share actual lab data that shows why air pods are not acceptable for shooting? A friend says "I feel like they work" and I bludgeoned him for having no supporting data, so sharing a video that says "we feel like they don't work" isn't going to help us out.

  • @claylabusa

    @claylabusa

    9 ай бұрын

    ehs.umass.edu/noise-cancelling-devices-vs-hearing-protection-fact-sheet Here you can find the University of Massachusetts entire Hearing Conservation program if you wanna point your friend in the right direction haha. The link is merely a sample of the medical studies that have gone into hearing protection. The entire shooting community is behind that stance not just the medical industry.

  • @user-iz2fv8rx7l

    @user-iz2fv8rx7l

    5 ай бұрын

    @@claylabusahow old is this though? The Apple AirPods Pro specifically has a different type of seal and noise cancelling to older style headphones. Research would need to have been conducted at least in the last five years

  • @charlesseekssilver2985

    @charlesseekssilver2985

    5 ай бұрын

    When they say “we feel” they are drs and their opinion is that of a professional nature. They gave plenty of explanation why in the first 15 minutes. Shooting sound is quick and the noise cancellation will not react properly to cancel out the loud sound whereas with regular/constant sound, noise cancellation can properly work.

  • @stevekunde123
    @stevekunde123 Жыл бұрын

    The hardest thing to get used to for me with the phantoms was being able to hear the pellets hit the ground/vegetation after the shot.

  • @scottcriddle1177
    @scottcriddle1177 Жыл бұрын

    Similar to the comment above I am curious what you think of the Xcore and ISOtunes with the foam plugs.

  • @stampede230
    @stampede23010 ай бұрын

    Definitely have active noise cancellation off. I have been using my galaxy buds pro when skeet shooting with no issues. Although, I wouldn't recommend using these for pistol or rifle shooting.

  • @Luke-ke8qw
    @Luke-ke8qw Жыл бұрын

    If y’all ever feel like taking another trip down to Georgia I’d love to see y’all check out Garland Mountain sporting clays up in Waleska.

  • @kairoward7738
    @kairoward77386 ай бұрын

    if you dont have options it works fine

  • @danawalkerley1395
    @danawalkerley1395 Жыл бұрын

    What do you think of the new AXIL XCOR?

  • @KinetikES

    @KinetikES

    9 ай бұрын

    I was wondering the same. But it seems they have a thing for SoundGear.

  • @Clearthestreet
    @Clearthestreet10 ай бұрын

    Bro it works for me. I was listening to music while shooting and bearly heard anything

  • @XCaPTainClipzX
    @XCaPTainClipzX9 күн бұрын

    Are the $250 Filtered earplugs from soundgear safe enough for an indoor range?

  • @claylabusa

    @claylabusa

    9 күн бұрын

    Safe enough, absolutely. Foamies are truly safe enough, so im assuming the idea is to be able to communicate better at the range, filtered earplugs are better, than electronic hearing protection provides better benefits than that. Safety is key but truly all we are doing when spending more money on ear protection is buying more capability in communication and how many times we don't have to remove our ear protection in environments where it could be harmful to enjoy communicating with others. All safe, which ones best is just how much ease of communication matters to you. Regardless of the brand. Hope that helps!

  • @XCaPTainClipzX

    @XCaPTainClipzX

    9 күн бұрын

    @@claylabusa Safe enough to be worn without over ear muffs? I should’ve clarified in the initial question

  • @Krysis219
    @Krysis219 Жыл бұрын

    Here first. Looking forward to this one.

  • @basshnter1997
    @basshnter1997 Жыл бұрын

    My home clay ground!

  • @hbarradah
    @hbarradah Жыл бұрын

    What I wasn’t clear on is what is better in the electronic buds compared to the one with filter. The filtered one has no batteries and cheaper, why go the electronic route?

  • @drewt.4353
    @drewt.435310 ай бұрын

    Sounds like someone can make better tips for airpods?

  • @claylabusa

    @claylabusa

    9 ай бұрын

    Not a bad recommendation?

  • @aeron-mw7ofs
    @aeron-mw7ofs10 ай бұрын

    👍👍

  • @danawalkerley1395
    @danawalkerley1395 Жыл бұрын

    I always wonder if people have wax build up from using in ear protection. A few years ago I would use the foamy ones and eventual I had hardened wax. The ENT (yes I can’t spell the other word) wouldn’t remove it until I softened it because he was worried it was stuck to my ear drum. Anyway that’s when I switched to over the ear which are fine for pistol but I want to get back to in the ear. Oh side note I wore them not only for shooting but my job so it was a lot of time with them in my ear. I just worry that switching back to in the ear will result in the wax build up.

  • @mikereynolds3294
    @mikereynolds3294 Жыл бұрын

    Swimmers silicone formable ear plugs you buy at the drug store for me is the best at sealing up in your ears and stopping all harmful noise and inexpensive

  • @russreadsbooks
    @russreadsbooks9 ай бұрын

    I think another factor that makes AirPods unsuitable is the fact that unless the AirPods can make a sound in your ear as loud as a gunshot, there is no way for the noise cancellation to make a negative waveform of large enough magnitude to cancel out the incoming wave.

  • @jhayden1111
    @jhayden11113 күн бұрын

    Selling headphones huh lol

  • @claylabusa

    @claylabusa

    3 күн бұрын

    Haha nope, just educating folks that noise canceling and ear protection are not the same. Could you imagine. #SponsoredbyApple haha

Келесі