Wonderful comparison. But humming a small piece of music is always exxpected from you. It soothes our mind.

@TheSeeking2know

4 күн бұрын

I agree. She has a lovely voice.

@7h7o7p

4 күн бұрын

Ha ha... U said what was on my mind too. I needed some excuse to hear Anuja's voice. Cheers

@patshakes1

4 күн бұрын

She makes everything so easy and simple to understand. Commendable. I don't where she had dissappeared for sometime in between. I really look forward to her videos eagerly. God bless her. And I missed her Om Shanti in this nice clip😊

Also, when Anuja introduced us to Tanuja, she really got me.🙏

This explanation was out of this world !! You are an excellent teacher !! God bless you always !!

Hey I am just so glad to see you back on the channel producing content that I love. much love.keep creating. I want to hear your views on the "exceptions to the rule" approach in Raag definitions. it makes the learning a bit complicated especially if the student is logical and looks for firn boundaries and structure in the musical grammar.

Beautifully explained. And equally, the skills from learning raags/memory drawing feed back into songs/the other kinds of drawing, and vice versa!

You are so expressive.

Can we expect a video where you would explain how to translate a song into swaras?

Great analogy! Thanks for sharing your thoughts. They really gave me a refreshing perspective.

The beautiful interweaving of drawing and music used in this video somehow reminded me of the book "Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid" by Douglas Hofstadter. It delves into certain complex ideas while illustrating how these themes interweave in mathematics, art, and music.

Nice way of explaining! You make it so simple!

Only a few video from such a great artist and teacher....

Only I want to write " God blessed you for special task" God bless you Move forward 👍

I like your analogy. I can say from experience that it is relatively easy to draw from a reference (Portrait/Scene) than from imagination but drawing from a reference teaches you enough fundamentals to be able to draw from imagination. Analyzing a song as a part of learning has greatly helped me improve my musicality over the months. Most songs in the past 30-40 years seem to have been composed based off of Western Scales rather than Raag. It has been very difficult to understand Raag, as the concept seems to be so fluid and every teacher seems to have their own interpretation and explanation for it. I hope it all makes sense one day.

Excellent explanation correlating with drawing art.

My grand daughter Ciya is just 10 years old, She is good in drawings painting & Music too! For last two to three years she is learning शास्रिय संगीत Your present link is very useful to her!

You are really knowledgeable and I thank you for sharing this. Dennis Mahabir from New Jersey, USA.

I am n your channel since many year may be before corona lock down ! very good imressive in simple language you explain

Glad 2 c u back🙏🏻👍😊

Glad if you share few more episodes on this very Important topic

Thats a fantastic analogy

You are a great teacher 😊

Such a clear explanation- / example- thank you !

Wonderful analogy !

A difficult concept beautifully explained.

Wow what a teaching talent you have.❤

❤❤❤ to see you return all of a sudden! ❤❤❤

Where have you been Anuja? Your voice is like meditation.

Amazing as always ❤❤❤❤❤

Well explained !

Just like I tried to explain my friends that I may be an Electrical Engineer but I cannot know everything about all the Different Industries an Electrical Engineer works in. They just thought and still think that I know nothing about Electrical Engineering. I quit Engineering this year (2024), after 10 years, because there's no science in it, only management and I am a bad manager. I am doing/studying/trying music now but myself, at the age of 34😅. I have had a terrible experience with Gurus all my life. I am sure Anuja is a better guru for me than anyone I would like to confront. I started learning about Indian Classical with a video by Anuja, suggested by Adam Neely, many years ago.

Nice to see you after a long long time.

Seeing your post after a long time. Good to see you back. Always enjoyed your posts.

I love ur vidz

Brilliant. Beautiful. Bright start to this morning. Thanks for your videos. It helps a lot to understand music. Can we say music that is closer to God is more unstructured, very difficult to explain? Raag is a template, which is semi structured, operates like a bridge between God and humans. Songs are more structured and rigid, Songs can be created using Raag. Your painting analogy is awesome to understand music. Thanks again.

@anushghosh4606

5 күн бұрын

God doesn't exist, it's a creation of human beings from a time when the knowledge of the world and the laws governing how natural processes take place wasn't as developed and as widespread as they are today. Music is something very human, on the other hand, as prehistoric human beings did create musical instruments and played music - even if that music eas relatively primitive by our standards. Please don't disrespect music by associating it with any kind of non-existent divinity.

@rajac2053

5 күн бұрын

Where there is Silence, there is no music. Does that mean Music doesn't exist? It's all in the mind, I guess.

@anushghosh4606

4 күн бұрын

@@rajac2053 silence doesn't mean the absence of sound, it means that there's no sound, but the absence of sound doesn't mean that sound doesn't exist. Seriously, get the hell out of here with your idealistic and metaphysical nonsense

@rajac2053

4 күн бұрын

Did you say 'Hell'? So you believe 'Hell' exist? But God doesn't exist?

@ThePrasadgurav007

Күн бұрын

​@@anushghosh4606 how can you differentiate Between Noise and Music? Both are sounds. There is some consciousness in you ( and all of us ) which makes this happen and the same is the source of all the life activities and happenings going on around us. Hope u understand.

Nice to see you again, Anuja ❤

Thanks! Been watching for years. So proud of you. Keep it up. ❤🙏🏾🥹

@AnujaK20

4 күн бұрын

Thank you! 🌷

@rajashreehebbalkar4702

4 күн бұрын

Anuja mam i can't create my own taana when I sing. Please make some video for it. It's like how you said in the beginning I byheart and sing

A beautiful illustration of the art of drawing and the art of music. Quite an impressive and spirited presentation of the similarities and differences between them.

Thank u for creating these videos for us ❤

A intelligently put fwd the importance of learning raags and consequently singing and in doing so o crossing the bridge from raag to song like imaginary to portrait drawings . U are too good in explaining music in simple language.

I think that the comparisons between drawing and training in the realm of Indian classical music are pretty accurate, because both of them clearly show the restrictive aspects in the pedagogical aspects of both forms of art. Both sacrifice the creativity and initiative of the artist in the name of refining and honing in of one's skills, whereas everyone knows that an artist's creativity and initiative can't be restricted in any shape or form under any circumstances. It's possible to give precedence and primary importance to one's creativity and artistic initiative without sacrificing the necessity of refining and developing one's skills and techniques, but unfortunately, the pedagogical approaches to the training of a visual artist and of an Indian classical musician begin from the position of underestimating and devaluing the creativity and endeavour of the artist. Whereas I'm yet to investigate how these restrictive pedagogical practices in relation to training a visual artist came into being, I'm certain that the restrictive aspects in the training of an Indian classical musician can be found in the function of Indian classical music as the vehicle through which feudal and Bramhinical culture could be propagated in the realm of cultural expression, which necessarily makes Indian classical music highly restrictive and initiative and with no space for creative improvisation or bending of the rules in order to give precedence to the musician's creative capabilities.

Absolutely true.👍

अगं अनुजा ताई असेच व्हिडिओ करत जा ना मध्ये मध्ये सारखे आम्हाला तुला पाहायला, ऐकायला खूप आवडतं आणि तुझी विषयाची मांडणी ही खूप आवडते!❤

Very nicely explained, thanks

Very apt examples from two different art forms.

Very insightful. I love your channel. I think you are saying that a song has a structure to it and Raag is more like an improvisation using a given mode or scale. I like your analogy to drawing. I also appreciate what you said about some artists are better at one type than the other and that we shouldn't expect all artists to be excellent at both.

@AnujaK20

4 күн бұрын

According to me, more than it being about scales and modes, Raags have a framework of phrases!

Well said

Anuja's back

A very knowledgeable video........ . Keep it up

🙏❤️

I want to learn music from you. What should I do? Please guide.

Itne din kaha the aap? Janta jawab chahti hai 🤗

❤️❤️❤️🙏🥰💐🌷

Hii Anuja watching you after so long

Anuja, what have you done to your beautiful hair. 🌹

You were in US Return to India? I am Pune based

Better to give some practical

Hindi me video banaonahi to Mai unfollow ka duga

Nicely explained....learners must take it positively n perform healthy Music..