Faith Hill did an outstanding performance of the song on the "Pearl Harbor" movie soundtrack, and I give her her due credit for it. But I have to say, in my opinion, Lucy's performance of it is other-worldly! I hear Faith, and I think "what a wonderful voice." I hear Lucy, and I think "what an absolutely angelic, soul-stirring, emotion-laden voice hitting me squarely in my palpitating heart!" This is one of my favorites of hers, and one that is not nearly covered enough by reactors! Thank you for your choosing this for your reaction!

I don't listen to Faith Hill much so I had not heard her version of this song. I think that Faith Hill did a wonderful vocal performance. However, I had listened to Lucy Thomas's cover of the song. I am biased because to me, Lucy Thomas is the best female vocalist that I have ever heard. So obviously, I am going prefer her performance of the song.

@jeffhoffman8370

Жыл бұрын

Totally understand!

The song is from the movie : Pearl Arbor. I remembered the movie, but forgot the song until I listened to Lucy. The two singers are very , very good, but: I prefer Lucy , because everytime I listen to her, I feel her voice is like a warm blanket wrapping around my heart .❤👍🤗

@jeffhoffman8370

Жыл бұрын

Yes! Me too and thanks Antony

This great review between the two version: For me this version she excellent beautiful talented singer.

Thanks for the video. Both ladies were super. I hope Lucy becomes as famous as Faith because she’s perfect.

@jeffhoffman8370

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely!! I believe she will if she doesn’t let life stand in her way

I asked you to do this cover. I hands down, feel Lucy Out sang Faith Hill, 100%! Ty for playing this.

@jeffhoffman8370

Жыл бұрын

Hey Lynne !!! My brain failed so thank you for reminding me I’ll try to remember to take a note and give you a shout on the channel Good call!!

Lucy for me 17 years old here what a fabulous voice. good review thanks.

@jeffhoffman8370

Жыл бұрын

Thank you!!

Evolution. Someone has to be in succession to replace/carryon the Diva class. Lucy is the only one capable of doing that. It comes down to who is better now. Lucy should carry that torch now. She is mellifluous!👍🌹❤️

What’s more important is more important always 🙏🙏🙏. What 2 amazing voices there. They sing just so easy and so great. Great song , great singing. Take care 🙏🙏🙏

Two very nice versions. A real easy on the ears and eyes show. Keep it up Jeff Thanks

@jeffhoffman8370

Жыл бұрын

JK! Agreed I owe you a call. Later this week

I love your comparisons. I get a kick out of your personality and your knowledge of music. Keep ‘Em coming! Have you ever covered Post Modern Juke Box? My favorite is Creep.

Great original song! Love that movie ! But a also a great performance by the younger generation. Thx for reacting 🎤🎶💜

hey jeff...movie was "pearl harbor" long time, hope things are going well. both these versions are great. been watching faith hill recently in the 1883 yellowstone origin story last few weeks. she and her husband both star in it and are really good as is the whole show. take care 😎

Lucy as usual never disappoints. This is a hard pick for me. I love both of these artist. I will have to call it a draw.

@jeffhoffman8370

Жыл бұрын

Me too Thanks Jim

I admit that I am a fan of Faith Hill as I think she has a beautiful voice. Can't really fault the "Pearl Harbor" music video as it was very good as was the award winning movie. Lucy easily matched Faith in this song off. Hard to pick a winner here for me so I will also call it a draw.