AMI is spot on on Eucalyptus trees and green revolution

A lot disappointed from Modi but what terrifies me more is que: what other option we have?

@seekerseeker4112

Жыл бұрын

This is position of many voters in India.

@vivekmanjeshwar2039

Жыл бұрын

True I fully agree with you on this brother. We had super high expectations

@Babybitch67

Жыл бұрын

Exactly

@psbakewar1stn.k.400

Жыл бұрын

No one is amar the same question was asked in every decade Just sit home and enjoy movie on election day as no one is there for hindus

@Babybitch67

Жыл бұрын

@@psbakewar1stn.k.400 100 crore ki population hai fir v support system dhundh rhe ho to sharm aani chahiye

Hats off ranga sir & AIM. Felt I learnt more watching this 1 hr debate than my entire economics/business management class.

Fully Agree with all the panelists, These things are being discussed since 1984, Rajiv Gandhi too wanted a prosperous India but Same Manmohan Singh who was planning commission labelled as Bunch of Jokers, Best Election Commisioner TN Sheshan too was making the same points, Fundamental Reforms urgently required are judiciary police administration, then start privatisation. 👍

@arpanConYT

Жыл бұрын

Education - Judiciary - IPC - Administation and mostly the minds of genral public about politics

@rahulmehta1770

Жыл бұрын

Grumbling, grumbling, grumbling - NO solutions. Propaganda.

I wish the convo was longer 😩

This one hour of talk can be an eye opener for a billion people

I love AIM and AR. Two diametrically opposite humans with a core kindness intellect and love for the country. Those calling AIM mad in the comments , are a joke themselves and probably homophobic. Wish this was longer and I did not like the host.

@crypton_8l87

Жыл бұрын

But there should be a ban against sitting like sack of potatoes! 🤮 Sit up hold your stomach in. AR at least, has had a proper upbringing in basic manners in public.

@creatorjob6107

Жыл бұрын

@@crypton_8l87 chal ab jake ke bartan maanj

@pyazkachori123

Жыл бұрын

They aren't diametrically opposite 😂

1. Both are brilliant. 2. To be a critique is great. 3. Change can be brought about when in power. 4. To be in power one has to be pragmatic. 5. Idealism is great. To run a Govt. IS BLOODY difficult. 6. Loved the conversation.

I wish we had leaders like these 2 eminent personalities, 🙏🙏🙏

It was indeed a great discussion with 2 gems i totally agree with all the points raised by two gentlemen I hope the govt must take cognizance.

@pudurm

Жыл бұрын

Modi expiry date has come . Modi is full of gas .when Anand gives out facts modi shd listen or get out

@leenaidoo9463

Жыл бұрын

Seventy years of mismanagement cannot be fixed in eight years. All those who believe that they can contribute positively should engage the government and discuss their concerns.

@aurodeeproy997

Жыл бұрын

Even now we are incompetent. The problem is, nobody has the will to fix things.

@SamvedIyer

Жыл бұрын

The government will, alas, not take cognizance.

@SamvedIyer

Жыл бұрын

@@leenaidoo9463 Indeed, but the problem is that mismanagement is continuing.

Wonder interview! Anand and Abhijit have such lucid minds! Some rarely talked about issues like the negative repercussions of the green revolution were also brought to light. This is the hallmark of PLF. Digging out buried truths.

love from siliguri🇮🇳🕉🙏🏽 I don’t know why this channel has very few subscribers. more power to you brother👍🏼💵

@sudipbhaumik7905

Жыл бұрын

I am also from siliguri.are you a bengali Hindu?

@Noname-oq9mk

Жыл бұрын

@@sudipbhaumik7905 yes brother

@uzochiokeke4328

Жыл бұрын

@@sudipbhaumik7905 i thought siliguri is gorkha city

@sannickdey6160

Жыл бұрын

I am also from Siliguri..

@Noname-oq9mk

Жыл бұрын

@@uzochiokeke4328 sorry brother I don't understand what you say 😅

No one can beat Ranganathan sir

Where is Jay Sai ,this would have been a even better debate with him present too.

Wish it continued for longer😄

Seeing these two gems together hits different.

So happy to see you all in PLF 🙋🏻‍♂️🙏

Just awesome to see these both legends together 😅

Great conversation !!!

Exactly my thoughts. Thanks for giving words for my thoughts.

Very realistic and rational discussion. Opposition is useless and govt is incompetent. Because of that India is loosing.

@asutoshpradhan2921

Жыл бұрын

Hnn yaar dukh lagta hai

@ET-si7rl

Жыл бұрын

Yes

6. And most incompetent judicial system and judges. Ridiculous!

Its always a pleasure and informative to watch AR Sir and AIM... thanks for your intellectual and informative points!!

Mind blowing discussion 😎👍

This blows my mind. I aim to be this articulate in my understanding of India.🥺🤯

JAI SHREE KRISHNA 🙏🙏

Nice discussion 👌 👍... want to listen more

Very good interview.....

superb, not missed a second. 100 % agree

thanks

Economic growth & boom must be accompanied by a quantum jump in the 'liveability' of Indian cities & villages. City-neighbourhood-Residential planning & Design must permeate to each & every city & urban environment. Natural landscape and their perpectual maintanance must be hard-wired in to the infrastructure. Without Live-ability, ppl will just leave in droves.

Eye opener conversation.

Well said. We are the responsible critics and we our voices must grow in number and volume, so we can get the Govt to sit up. It is capable of providing the best governance, they just have to act. Inspite of having the best we cannot move backwards

Modi is now old….he was young as a cm…how much will Modi do….now we need young leader…This discussion was👌👌…hope all Indians watch it ….and put their thinking hats…

Great panel discussion! But one point, BSNL, to the extent I have understood fr the media, has some "strategic" mportance in terms of it's reach to remote places in India...so the govt. has decided to back it...isn't that true?

@adarsh2282

Жыл бұрын

Absolutely!

Wish Modi had adviser and critic like them close to modi

Super to see both

what a wonderful conversation with these two gems!!!!!

Prof. Anand Ranganathan, PLEASE focus and talk about YOUR area of EDUCATION. How to make India - Global Educational Centre. Education. Education. Education - 360 degree perspective. How to make India a learning, experimental learning country.

Nice Talk...

Good to see KOO🙏

Loved the End - "Pata Nahi kya ho gaya ise"...😃😃

If Anand Ranganatham stops wearing polyester British style blazer and trouser suit in the hot and humid climate of Pondicherry it will do more justice to a man with a sharp and logical mind

@babasharma6694

Жыл бұрын

Never judge a book by it's cover..

You guys are taking words out of my mouth. Now what next!

Good video 👍

The fact is BSNL is reducing its losses from 15k crore in FY20 to 7k crore in FY21.. so it's reducing, they are managing it well

@ronmiller3741

Жыл бұрын

And you are using BSNL to post this comment ? No ? Maybe someone in your 1 km radius does. The only good thing bsnl does is providing connectivity in the remotest areas where companies don’t find it feasible.

Commenting to make this video reach more pps

Indian bureaucracy has run the country down to its knees. I am a doctor and work as public health professional & have seen through years of experience the rut that is the governement program officers and bureaucrats. General population doesn't know that indian public health system is so deeply incompetent, that in every single state there are healthcare NGO supporting the programs extensively and we do 90% of the technical work for them without any public recognition. Have seen first hand that they take up hefty salaries and please the higher ups, attend all technical workshops just as leisure stay in big hotels but don't learn anything and hence don't impart cascade learning as well! There are only 2 reason Indian public health system is working relatively fine- Consultants from NGO including UN & ASHA/ANMs (who are the overburdened and exploited lot for years in running now). It's because of this public health professionals have one of the highest burnout rate or they eventually also become corrupt and redundant like their government counterparts. So much money is siphoned off from back door of the NHM, 15th FC, ECRP budgets. It's a sad and ugly reality i witness everyday. You choose the leaders like yourself. India has never had a dearth of astute, honest, deserving individuals to run the system and country but they are always on the sidelines hussling while the mainstream corruption goes on minting money with the blood of their very own people!

@ruchi3667

Жыл бұрын

Like other policies you guys mentioned, in health also rosy dreamy policies are made without any feedback and understanding of reality, hence most implementation falters when it comes to the ground. They don't even understand their own terrains for god's sake. I see the blatant ignorance the center has when it comes to the northeast (where I am working right now).

@CP-ne2md

Жыл бұрын

Don't admire yourself u peoples nothing but modern yemdoot, modern allopathy is not a science, it's pure business, tell me which chronological illnesses cure these fake science allopathy otherthane accute operations,

@SK-om6tt

Жыл бұрын

Hey, what organisation r u workin with? R there specific policies u belive that the govt has passed but they r on the ground simply not working? If yes, kindly lmk, I’d like to do a story on it.

@ruchi3667

Жыл бұрын

@@SK-om6tt I have worked with W.H.O, PATH, PHFI, currently with UNICEF. There is no one specific policy but All policies are not rooted enough in ground reality, and bureaucratic process of fund release, incompetence of government officers adds on to the problem

@MaTara01

Жыл бұрын

@@ruchi3667 unfortunately, that has been a perennial Indian problem, but still I am amazed that some govt managed things still work even in the chaos - in some places, the government university hospitals are doing pioneering, world class work at 1/10 th of the funding that an average Western University gets. I don't think that the inherent ineffeciency of the system can be changed overnight, especially given India's federal structure, lack of accountability, political interference etc. And in spite of the Indian tendency to forever criticise Indian union or state governments/admins etc, I have lived encountered the same incompetence, corruption and ineffeciency in Europe. I can get to see a GP in India in a city government hospital immediately and get a diagnosis or medical treatment straight away, but that doesn't happen in the NHS of UK (which all UK residents have to pay for monthly) - the waiting time to get a GP appointment in some places is almost 6 months. Dental appointments are even worse - there are no dentists for miles and people pull out their teeth themselves! India handled the Covid crisis much better than the UK did and when you compare the size & per capita health spending of India to UK, the achievement is even more remarkable.

Wonderful discussion indeed. Only glitch is the low voice of Ajit datta which is irritating

Have guys heard about processing sound after recording. I just get pissed off when I want to watch a video but then I don't bcoz of poor sound quality.

I hope jsd and kushal also included in this video

Line of the session. भजन मंडली 🙏

The movie's name is "Edge of Tomorrow" which Abhijeet refers to us at 43:50.

Wish more people in India understood the ramifications of the green revolution as explained by Abhijit IM

WooooW

Modi's biography should be titled "A lost opportunity"

@patrioticindiansgj6704

Жыл бұрын

Agree ,but as Mitra and Dr Anand both agreed,the offsprings of the green revolution which nearly 60% of india still vote for are the barriers which stops and allows the opportunity lost .

@AndyDutta

Жыл бұрын

@@patrioticindiansgj6704 they used to vote for them but they voted for Modi in 2014 and even more in 2019. Modi has taken these voters for granted and rubbed their noses in the dirt

@ashutoshdutta821

Жыл бұрын

I fully agree with Ranganathan on points of nation and pm or for that matter any policy maker must be impatient as the story in last 75 years are the story of missed opportunity and thus fallen back even compared to many many fast developing nations .

Great Discussion --- what this PPL said is right --- it is the votes which make all the policies

44:02 Edge of tomorrow

Did the host have a microphone? The discussion was very good. Next time have a competent Government representative to answer and debate.

Excellent point by Ranga Sir on how the Modi Govt is a subsistence model Govt; it'll ensure people survive but not ensure that the people will thrive

this discussion is exacltly what i need everyone to do! I will vote for Modi and BJP because this govt has done better for the country BUT that doesn't mean they are doing everything right! WE NEED STRONG OOPOTITION for the GOVT to work STRONG! the fun fact is the BJP voters, even just a single educated BJP voter knows more about what are wrong with this govt than oppotition parties combined!

1. BSNL is being propped up because there needs to be a provider who can focus on laying OFCs. The plan is to tie up with Prysmian cables (the world's largest manufacturer of OFCs) and lay more OFCs throughout the width and breadth of India. The private telcos are focussing on wireless which will eventually saturate as subscriber counts increase. Latency is lowest through cables and not wireless. 2. The draft of the new Electricity Act will enable One nation, One grid. This would empower and encourage all electricity consumers to be prosumers. Basically, a household with 1000 sq. ft of roof space can install a 10 kW solar power plant and go fully off-grid. The bottleneck here would be battery storage for which a national-level grid is an absolute necessity. The primary opposition here is from state-level utility cos. 3. Most Indians inherently have an understanding of systems optimization and control theory, even without explicitly doing the math-heavy university-level coursework. The lack of criticism is because the current government, even with its multiple faults, is functioning at a "near-global optimum", given the systemic constraints and environmental variables.

@youtubeaccount1134

Жыл бұрын

Great

@Bruh-jw2ze

Жыл бұрын

FAXXXXXXXXXX 🗣🗣🗣

@youtubeaccount1134

Жыл бұрын

@@Bruh-jw2ze also police and intelligence agencies use BSNL their network is different from civilian

@YOTUBE8848

Жыл бұрын

do you mean "Latency is LOWEST through cables and not wireless"?

@MrLee-gj2jz

Жыл бұрын

@@YOTUBE8848 yes, you are correct. Edited the post. Thanks.

🔥

Look less people commented on this channel and very few likes

The growth that's needed to fund welfare policies is shunned by our bureaucratic mismanagement and judicial overreach.

I agree on farm laws.

AIM speaks truth to power

We trust Modiji. and he is honest.thats OK. Let's see people mandate on 2024. They r politicians. Yes they are in electoral. They have to win election.Even you are not right to man

WHERE intellect mingles with love Kindness radiating for wholesomeness of society Intellect is a useful tool OTHER WISE it is becomes A weapon to DESTROY OTHERS Thro arguments

Abhijeet iyer is a mad lad .🙂

8 years me KUCH nahi hotha hai. We have just started the journey to fulfill our potential. Since independence, India has progressed, for a period of 55 yrs, in spite of the government not because of it. Good that you are criticizing the government.

The unwanted background noise is irritating.

Iyervval we miss you in Twitter Please fix echoing audio. Very bad audio

Who chose the ultra comfortable chairs

I agree with both but from 2019 October I think govt is changing . From power to psu they have started reform however slow they may be . I think direction is right and would change may be in decade

At 43:40, Abhijit is wrong. It is essential to build toilets and give cylinders to people who don't even have them. You have to fulfill basic needs before you move onto higher needs such as entertainment and education.

@vineetcv261

Жыл бұрын

Yahi karte raho, 8 saal ka achievement, toilet

@sannickdey6160

Жыл бұрын

Now who is going to pay for toilets and this social welfare projects??? Before you distribute money you have to create money..

@reardelt

Жыл бұрын

@@sannickdey6160 But there is already enough money in the budget to build the toilets. Adani and ambani are already creating the wealth. But you can't create wealth when people are too busy thinking where they can take a shit.

@Mkayou

Жыл бұрын

DK if it is true but Mother Theresa gave medicines to the poor to keep them barely alive so that when they near death she gives better medicine in some holy way to make them believe in Christianity and guess what it was a successful method of conversion. Similarly even BJP is playing *Hindu card* when they don't do a sh*t either on economy or hindutva. The point I want to make is *sirf toilets banwana se nahi thoda middle class aur economy creators(rich) par bhi focus kare nahi tho is tharah ke basic needs ka fulfil karne kaa Paisa nahi hoga hamare pass*

Bad audio 🔉

AH AHA THIS HAS TO STOP ...WE HAVE TO STOP

Abhijit da are you ok? Please maintain your health. You have to work for us for long time. I love you and want you to be healthy and wealthy.

Hail AIM... Hail Anand Ranganathan ...

Let another Dharmic party generate in India until then, I have no doubts in my mind at all to whom my money, support and vote goes to.

👍

Introspection is needed.

Abhijit how is your leg . I hope you get well soon

No audio

Digitisation. The greatest empowerment tool

Agree with the callouts and noted failures 1. Give is still playing silly appeasement politics. You can only do it when you have money. And Govt with majority seats must not play victim card. 2. Govt failed at making India a law and order state. Laws are applied differently for different people. And people who are known or caught breaking the law are not brought to justice. 3. Really poor marketing. Sharing data is not the same as sharing information and that is not the same as informing people with the right details. 4. Govt has shown that they can think big. But not enough, not sustained. 5. One person CANNOT do everything. Leverage Others. Delegate.

Tom cruise film - Edge of Tomorrow

I like both of you. We have our own mind to whom to vote. Why not both of you stand against Modi lets see.Because we do not have a single person in opposition who we would like to see as PM.Those who are critical about Modiji then identify a man who can compete against Modiji

@Bruh-jw2ze

Жыл бұрын

good point

@AK-fd1tb

Жыл бұрын

I don't see any thing wrong in criticism for Modi. There have to be people to point out faults.

@Bruh-jw2ze

Жыл бұрын

@@AK-fd1tb there have to be people to do something about it as well. Constantly talking without taking any concrete steps to solve it is futile

@SamvedIyer

Жыл бұрын

@@Bruh-jw2ze It is not a good point. It is the most diseased point one can come up with. Why must _we_ stand against Modi? We voted for him. Is that not enough? We vote for political parties precisely because we are the electorate, and they promised to work on our behalf. Seek accountability from _him._ Do not ask _us_ to fix his problems.

@Bruh-jw2ze

Жыл бұрын

@@SamvedIyer lmao relax. I'm talking about the so called 'influential and vocal' lot like Abhijit and Anand. They definitely can reach out to people in power if they seriously wanted to. Putting out tweets or vlogs doesn't change policies

Abhijeet is very good at self-validation from an internal locus of control.... aka the Indian version of Jordan Peterson!

@lazyartiste_2357

Жыл бұрын

He's better than him.

@Aa-tq9xt

Жыл бұрын

@@lazyartiste_2357 JP is a clinical psychologist. But i like AIM as well.

@neeldeshmukh124

Жыл бұрын

Said like someone who read one simply psychology article lmaoo

@sandeepsigroha6935

Жыл бұрын

We need people like these 2 in our politics

@kanhaibhatt913

Жыл бұрын

Peterson has become a full blown Abrahamic now. He recently made a cringe video pandering to Muzlims and other Abrahamics.

Is this exclusive ¿

43:47 Edge of Tomorrow

Yes I admire Modiji .I don't like Modiji blindly.We use our own conscience and thought to like someone. It's alright, wining election should be purpose of any political party

@DhruvPatel-zg1zs

Жыл бұрын

But what did it cost ? Everything

Lively debate but they underestimate the magnitude of the problems faced by the government.

@ytadltspv

Жыл бұрын

like???did modi have worse probs than the elders that inherited a shambles in 1947???for once a party got a majority after a long time, prayers and hopes for a revival, knowing fully the bad events of 2002- we had no choice. then we also had good monsoons , world oil prices dropped, etc . all signs were in our favor - but everything was wasted in just months and the damage continues until now and we're paying for it.

@SamvedIyer

Жыл бұрын

It does not matter how many problems it faces. The government does not have willpower, period.

Constructive criticism is always welcome and the present Government should look at this the same way. Somewhere, get the feeling that the current government is getting very complacent about the fact that people are likely to vote for them in 2024

निंदक नियरे राखिए ऑंगन कुटी छवाय, बिन पानी, साबुन बिना, निर्मल करे सुभाय।

The issue is that even with so many issues, i shudder to think what this incompetence will rise to if the current opposition comes back to power.

One telecom company is important to be under govt so that it can be used at strategic locations and border areas....where no private company will be willing to go . That's the reason govt is investing in BSNL .

Patience is Dharma.

@nemesis1ization

Жыл бұрын

Modi is safe with such moronic followers.

Question asked by Mr AR at 40:00, had been asked by Mr TV Mohandas Pai, when there was govt adjournment to not to sell BSNL and Air India during Vijay Malya and Nirav Modi's scam.