part 2 and the rest of the playlist here: kzread.info/dash/bejne/amplxLmqctXakZs.html

@Tony-dh7mz

5 жыл бұрын

Subbed

@dietermill2271

5 жыл бұрын

Excellent work, the evidence is self explanatory.

@AC-gb7do

5 жыл бұрын

You are doing the Great Bird of the Galaxy’s work, thank you!

@FoxMonkey-xw5yf

5 жыл бұрын

I was considering making a video on STD lore errors - should've known you'd already done it much better than I could. PS don't let the copystrikes censor you!

@letoatreides4041

5 жыл бұрын

...Ahh man. In the last couple episodes of discovery this season they fixed all the continuity errors that plagued the other series as well. It was really brilliantly done. You guys would get a kick out of it really.

Janeway: "Wormholes, spatial rifts, new technologies to help us..." Chakotay: "Space Mushrooms..." Janeway: "What?" Chakotay "What?"

@Mongler37

5 жыл бұрын

Mr. Neelix, bring up all your Portobellos. If this doesn't work, we'll be in deep shitake.

@Rhythmicons

4 жыл бұрын

Janeway: Coffee Nebula

@Mephilis78

4 жыл бұрын

Is this loss?

@jdorritie

4 жыл бұрын

Tom: "It's... some kind of... spore drive?"

@tytusromek9267

4 жыл бұрын

Space mushrooms, they probably smoked them

"Mr Discovery Writer....I have the Star Trek universe continuity book here". "Ah great" (throws it out wibdow) "there, that's that taken care of"

@davidfleming1115

5 жыл бұрын

True there will many mistakes along the way but but this time let the fans help out this way you won't get into a lot of trouble

@davidfleming1115

5 жыл бұрын

There problem was they thought explaining away about the reality of that world they didn't do it right that was done way to late in the season witch is why it failed and as like other companies they failed to listen to the fans as well , Now i see why Star Trek isn't going anywhere you totally screwed up Gene's work and he isn't very happy with you nutless

@Deuteromis

5 жыл бұрын

Hey! That's what Disney did with Star Wars also! 😂...😦 I just made myself depressed now....

@Zlogical1

5 жыл бұрын

These are not errors. See when someone speaks they can only attest to THEIR knowledge. Since Star Fleet would not document a covert plan using a covert ship to blow up the Klingon home world I doubt data would know about it. That VERY episode most of the crew had no idea about a phase cloaked ship OR the mutiny on board it. Half of the stuff he complains about was answered in season 1 and 2. The treat ment of Klingon bodies is definitely covered in season 1.

@kamenkojistonira

5 жыл бұрын

....picks up warhammer 40k novel, hey this is pretty popular now...

Star Trek: 50+ years of lore Star Trek: established canon Discovery: lol what

@klutzspecter3470

4 жыл бұрын

I’m not defending std but The other Trek’s have a handful of errors too.

@yessir.7937

4 жыл бұрын

You aren't a Star Trek fan, are you? The actual creator of this franchise did not think continuity is that important. He changed things and even made a statement that he didn't think anyone in the future should be limited by what previous series did. He didn't even think the original series was canon anymore, because he liked his other ideas better - he was big on changing things. Plenty to hate Discovery for, but this ain't it.

@CardboardSliver

4 жыл бұрын

Yeah, and if course to make it work, they went with the "the ship's mission was classified and sent to the future to not effect actual canon" McGuffen. Basically, lazy writing, and not paying attention to any prior Trek shows.

@rprince418

4 жыл бұрын

@@yessir.7937 Changing things just "because I like this better, fuck all the fans" is something not to hate the show for?

@Mephilis78

4 жыл бұрын

@@klutzspecter3470 Do you think they have 99+ videos worth of errors? We aren't talking about the momentary visible cameraman, or a "wall" that accidentally wobbles too much.

"Enterprise was a terrible show" Hold my beer ... After 14 years ENT actually looks like super canon to me.

@fakegeek5462

4 жыл бұрын

Enterprise had it's good episodes but it ended to early and hoaky before it got good.

@histguy101

4 жыл бұрын

Or the truth has just been revealed, Enterprise is a good show.

@namelesske

4 жыл бұрын

@@histguy101 I miss enterprise. The last seasons were amazing, expect the final.

@ChrisKunix

4 жыл бұрын

@@histguy101 indeed it is...

@marsneedstowels

4 жыл бұрын

They also went their own way the first two seasons with Temporal Cold War and Xindi.

Their shuttlebay also contains atmosphere with a force field. The old Enterprise had to depressureize its bay whenever a shuttle took off and repressureize it after it landed.

@brianreiss9494

5 жыл бұрын

The constitution ships are older than Discovery

@skwills1629

5 жыл бұрын

@Valami Izé Not all things are modernised at the same Time. And Discovery was a testbed for new Technologies, so its possible that this is something still being worked on that isn't installed in all ships yet. I agree that Discovery has flaws with Continuity, but some things can be Reasonably explained.

@DanielRichards644

5 жыл бұрын

@Valami Izé and the Constitution got "modernized" many years later with the Refit for the movies.

@bogustoast22none25

5 жыл бұрын

@@skwills1629 Such things such as new technologies are emohasized, usually a single one sentence conversations are enough. "Wait why aren't you depressurizing?!" "Relax, the area has a force field to keep atmosphere in, watch." The constitution might be an older class, but refits and upgrades tend to happen when a ship is going to be passed down.

@skwills1629

5 жыл бұрын

@@bogustoast22none25 efits do happen, but not right away. And for all we know, Discovery is the First ship to hve this, and it may still be experimental. I realise its probably because the Writers didn't watch TOS, but this isn't a hard one to Ratrtionalise after the fact, so I'd give it a pass.

1:24 Janeway's been hitting the helium a little hard.

@MarCuseus

4 жыл бұрын

The pitch of the sound on DVD is very off at the start of Voyager

@msb8792

4 жыл бұрын

Hahaha 😂 ... I remember it took me a long while to be able to digest her due to her voice when I watched Voyager.. but eventually it grew on me and Voyager is actually one of my favorite STs.

@reactions5783

4 жыл бұрын

@@msb8792 Heck! Even 'Enterprise' is looking better with each passing day, in the wake of woke Trek.

@msb8792

4 жыл бұрын

Reactions haha, Enterprise is a masterpiece in comparison to Discuckery

@smegleymunroe863

2 жыл бұрын

@@reactions5783 I mean, Star Trek was always really socially progressive. Back in TOS it was insane to have an interracial bridge crew, and to portray Russians in a positive light. The problem now is that the current writers think that’s ALL they need to do. No interesting explorations of alien life forms and different forms of society, or portrayals of how humans could advance economically and politically. Hell, in Picard they use money! They were mocking old Earth of using money back during TOS.

most potential telepath in the galaxy: "yes telepathy across light years is impossible" Vulcan, with extremely subtle telepathy: "we mind melded across a *THOUSAND* light years" Okay that one actually got me.

@MarioWenzel

4 жыл бұрын

In TOS Spock sensed the destruction of a Vulcan manned vessel over a distance of light years. While Vulcan telepathy was not of the "talky" kind, like the Betazoid's, it was kinda established, that it worked over vast distances.

@elronman

4 жыл бұрын

​@@MarioWenzel to be fair that does sound like an ass pull by TOS and could be considered retconned. Thats a good call though, still doesn't explain why a vulcan mind melded over a thousand lightyears. Also the sheer implications of telepathy rivaling subspace communications would raise a bunch of questions.

@FanboyFilms

4 жыл бұрын

It was explained very clearly. Sarek gave Burnham a piece of his katra, or soul, so they can mind meld across a thousand light years because they share a soul. The reason he gave her half his soul in the first place is because katras can heal physical injuries if you give them to someone who's wounded. No plot holes here.

@MarioWenzel

4 жыл бұрын

@@FanboyFilms Also consider that Tucker and T'Pol were able to katracall each other over vast distances in Affliction. Discovery has many problems. Communication by katraphone is not one of them.

@MarioWenzel

4 жыл бұрын

As it's audiovisual, we should probably call it katravision though.

"Discovery was deleted from Starfleet records" is the possibly the laziest, most blatant, cheap plot device EVER written into a show. That doesn't excuse the canonical mistakes, it just exemplifies the utter burning sewage that is STD

@MajorGrin

4 жыл бұрын

and it makes no sense that no one else in the galaxy invented it . only a human did ?

@NuAngelDotNet

4 жыл бұрын

This is why I think writing a prequel story isn't safe. You're handcuffed to not creating anything new, or else everyone else will just ask why it hadn't been used in other items that were written before. They should have just placed it as the latest thing in the time line if they wanted to do a bunch of new stuff.

@MajorGrin

4 жыл бұрын

@@NuAngelDotNet yes . if they want to have more advanced technology just set it in the future . if you set it in the past you have to limit technology to what would make sense in the time period

@OurFantasyLife

4 жыл бұрын

@@NuAngelDotNet Then they couldn't use Spock and try to cash in on the name recognition.

@esotericVideos

4 жыл бұрын

@@NuAngelDotNet You can make a prequel safely, you just have to care.

Spock is so ashamed of his adoptive sister he pretend she don't exist

@TheDaks27

5 жыл бұрын

Just like his half-brother and the 5th movie

@carloschamorro7836

5 жыл бұрын

TheDaks27 Spock ignores his parents and they ignore him just in front of his coworkers and Captain.

@hmikky

5 жыл бұрын

there is a possibility that she won't exist by the end of the series...

@fredricksmith-something.2125

5 жыл бұрын

He is mad at her not ashamed.

@SatyricalWidget

5 жыл бұрын

DeathCloud “didn’t” or “doesn’t”.

Perhaps Discovery is just a holodeck simulation made by Professor Moriarty (who himself is in a holodeck simulation). The final episode of Discovery, titled: 'Ship in a bottle, in a bottle' will reveal this. I'm also guessing CBS will read this post and turn it into reality.

@Shiirow

5 жыл бұрын

Im assuming they will do what they had plans for and this is just another mirror universe.

@emoAnarchist

5 жыл бұрын

they'll read this post, make the episode, and then when you say they plagiarized they'll promise not to sue you

@megaporch583

5 жыл бұрын

We hope

@DanielRichards644

5 жыл бұрын

they sure don't have any issues stealing ideas to use to create this show.

@MikhaelAhava

5 жыл бұрын

Maybe.

Why not just set Discovery like 100 years after Voyager.

@radioflyer68911

4 жыл бұрын

Kazmark_gl : These ideological pinheads want to overwrite Star Trek, just like the aholes who did Ghostblusers,Star Wars,Dr Who and the rest. They'll Greedo shot first all the classics given the chance.

@robertidonotsharemyfullnam496

4 жыл бұрын

cause u can't redcon spock into it.

@ashwinarun9817

4 жыл бұрын

Robert idonotsharemyfullname That thing in discovery is not Spock. It’s an abomination

@robertidonotsharemyfullnam496

4 жыл бұрын

@@ashwinarun9817 can't really say anything againt that... still kurzman thought u need a spock in trek so thats what happened. i could have done a better job than him and i don't even do movies nor stories nor am i a particularily hardcore trekkie.

@joecostantino3684

4 жыл бұрын

It would have made it alot better, having it as a prequel at least in its first 2 seasons made 0 sense. As for the Klingons in Discovery those should have been called something else they could have made up an entirely new race and it would have been perfect.. (new era... new villain).

To be fair... it's completely logical for Starfleet to erase any records that are remotely related to Burnham in any capacity. Would YOU want people to remember Michael Burnham? Of course not.

@eddieolshefski6467

2 жыл бұрын

Agreed. That’s why she and Discovery belonged in the future. They didn’t belong in the present and needed to be erased and never mentioned.

@Diogene1936

2 жыл бұрын

In one TNG episode Picard, underlined that Startfleet is committed to the Truth, no matter what. This basically is the difference between Rondeberry Start trek and the STD...

@damientom

2 жыл бұрын

True. But Voyager got scewed.

@wowtosl

2 жыл бұрын

Exactly discovery was top secret and spok deleted all records he really did hate her

@Canthatcrazy

2 жыл бұрын

We're all trying to forget her right now 😅

I feel like Picard's "It is WRONG!" should be followed up with Sisko's "But it's REAL!".

@reactions5783

4 жыл бұрын

​@Number One To be honest, every review of new 'Trek' should both begin and conclude with that 'It's a FAAAKE!!!" clip.

@Unethical.Dodgson

3 жыл бұрын

Archer: Humans don't throw morality out the window when things start getting a little rough.

I am a big Trekkie and have watched all of TOS. When I saw that the series was based on a Mutiny even after TOS said there never had been one in history, I knew I was in for a series without a regard for canon.....I was right.

@SweetBabyGray

4 жыл бұрын

Her record is expunged and she's reinstated at the end of season 1.

@antoman142

4 жыл бұрын

Also at the at the end of season to they expunge all records of the discovery, it's mission and crew and make it treason if anyone talks about it.

@HistoryisBoss

4 жыл бұрын

Just stating this for the record, In Roman history they did this too, expunging the records wiping people from history books and stuff. So just because it doesn’t exist in the records doesn’t mean it didn’t happen. But still STD looks bad. I haven’t actually watched it yet.

@freyrds8870

4 жыл бұрын

@@HistoryisBoss I'm not a huge Trek fan so I probably have a different view of it, but I thouroughly enjoyed it. Great effects, decent acting (in my controversial opinion) and there are some good stories in there. As I'm a huge fan of any type of time travel story I really enjoyed season 2 and can't wait for season 3. Sure their excuse for the Discovery never being mentioned in any other Star Trek series (by Damnatio Memoriae) is a bit unoriginal and could've been dealt with better, but they still pretty much managed to tie it into the timeline. If you have an open mind and aren't as indoctrinated by Star Trek as some fans are, you should enjoy it.

@neonknights

4 жыл бұрын

You do realize that they contradicted that literally 7 episodes later, in "Whom Gods Destroy", when they stated that Captain Garth's crew mutinied against him? You're a big Trekkie and watched all of TOS and can't remember this?

Being interviewed to write for Discovery: CBS:"have you watched star trek tos, TNG, ds9, voyager or enterprise?". Writer:"No, but I know they have ships, pew pew guns and transporters." CBS:"you're hired".

@mitchkeller5055

3 жыл бұрын

You know I think you’re more right than anyone would think.

@animatewithdermot

2 жыл бұрын

@@mitchkeller5055 The Borg are the baddies. Right?

Discovery would work fine as a post-dominion war show. A war weary federation unable to sustain another conflict. A captain with PTSD sent behind the lines to wreck havoc. Gorn instead of Klingon, slipstream drive instead of mushrooms, phase cloaks instead of invisibility screens. Most problems just disappear.

@Diogene1936

2 жыл бұрын

Agree, but this requires a minimum knowledge of Start Trek, and they have none

@ADivineFellow

2 жыл бұрын

congratulations you have more skill at writing then every discovery writer combined.

@YaBoiAltair

2 жыл бұрын

It hurts how easily they could have made the show watchable just by putting it at a different point in time, but they wanted to drive this IP into the ground so they took some shrooms instead of doing anything sensible 🙃

@brentc2411

2 жыл бұрын

I agree, it even makes sense to keep them Klingons, if it's post dominion. While the Council knows another war would be bad for the Empire, the people have tasted blood, and want more, the resulting political turmoil fractures the houses once again, until one Klingon seeks to united them, under a banner of war against the Federation, who has softened and weakened the Klingon culture through alliances and treaties. Replace the Enterprise and Pike with the Titan and Riker. Not much else even needs to be changed to slide it right in to post DS9.

TBH, STD should be set after the event of DS9 or Nemesis, the era where Starfleet start to realize the benefit of militarization programs thus cause the conflict in the core ethic of the Federation.

@christianriddler5063

4 жыл бұрын

Yeah but that would require originality and creativity, something the creators of STD doesn't have.

@Mega-Brick

4 жыл бұрын

@@christianriddler5063 At least they're _trying_ to fix it with the 'moving it super far into the future' thing.

@christianriddler5063

4 жыл бұрын

@@Mega-Brick Too late now. It's better to just shoot this TV show in the barn so that it doesn't have to suffer anymore.

@khfan4life365

4 жыл бұрын

That would require writers that actually about the plot and characters.

@zorlockthewarlock5961

3 жыл бұрын

Yeah, no, the less militarization in star trek the better

I wish the Discovery crew would turn into salamanders as a result of their shenanigans.

@robertidonotsharemyfullnam496

4 жыл бұрын

this is what should happen if you go past warp ten, so...

@farkleberry867

4 жыл бұрын

Salamanders are too cool. Worms.

@dibershai6009

3 жыл бұрын

@@farkleberry867 Worms are also too fascinating. Bacteria

Every time I see these contradictions I get a voice in my head saying "but it was worth it for the visual right!?" And subsequently I answer "no! No it wasn't!"

Until I saw Sarek I thought Discovery was a century ahead of Next Generation based on technology alone and even then I thought Sarek must have been a recycled name but then I saw Amanda and I was really confused and after meeting Pike I watched the rest of the episodes awaiting a logical explanation. But all I could think of was Norman of "I Mudd" repeatedly saying "ILLOGICAL, ILLOGICAL, ILLOGICAL" just before the smoke comes out of his ears.

The issue with using a gravity well to bend light, is that the amount of gravity required to bend light, would pull everything within an AU straight towards the cloaked ship. Not to mention that Starfleet ships have been able to detect gravitational forces since the NX class at least. So a Klingon ship generating one would be pretty easy to detect with sensors alone.

@Savenya_Amari

2 жыл бұрын

Lolol we here on earth right now have been able to detect changes in gravitational forces

@mikesully110

2 жыл бұрын

@@Savenya_Amari plus it would lense background stars making it easily visible, if you look up a black hole on wikipedia (one that doesn't have an Interstellar-like acretion disk) you can see it warps the background stars.

@revdope1

2 жыл бұрын

Not to "nerd out" but we could be talking about amplified ATOMIC gravity. Extremely strong, but with a small field. Like what Bob Lazar talked about.

@cb-gz1vl

2 жыл бұрын

We've already made objects with mirror/camera projects to let light pass through. And it doesn't take all that much energy. I would imagine if they have shield tech they probably can cause light to flow over the surface.

@ministryofwrongthink6962

2 жыл бұрын

Like covering your secret base with a neon blinking “Here I am” sign lmfao

Discovery was wiped from Starfleet Records.

@mattdelvecchio1537

4 жыл бұрын

Sys Failure yeah not getting why he’s ignoring this. like it or not, that does explain most of what he’s cited here. the new Klingons are just stupid tho.

4 жыл бұрын

@@mattdelvecchio1537 tech evolves and star trek cant keep using 32 bit colours screens if tomorrow we use augmented reallity for everything and discover thats unbearable stupid

@elana1463

4 жыл бұрын

@ Considering that in reality touch screens for ship controls were a costly mistake that lead to a drastic increase in accidents, which is why all ships that had them get retrofitted with old physical controls, I guess The original Star Trek might be the closest to actual star ship technology of all those serieses.

@RandomAmerican3000

4 жыл бұрын

If only we could be so lucky.

@tytusromek9267

4 жыл бұрын

Discovery should also be deleted from the canon 😃

Star Trek: will you respect canon? Discovery: yes lots of cannons! Good idea!

Good that you labeled it 1/99 because it's never going to stop. Calling it Star Trek was the first mistake they ever made.

@georgeray1906

21 күн бұрын

I wouldn't be surprised if it goes to infinity for every second of STD, a new continuity mistake is discovered.

Theory: Klingons in Star Trek Discovery are not really Klingons.

@darthvader0219

4 жыл бұрын

They grow their hair out in the second season. They shave their heads during time of war.

@ClarinoI

4 жыл бұрын

@@darthvader0219 That doesn't fit with the appearance of Klingons in TOS and STE. The whole Klingon species in STD seems to be non canonical.

@cdeer17

4 жыл бұрын

Sorry but no they still wouldn't look that much like a normal Klingon it's too much of a leap in look

@kyle8952

4 жыл бұрын

Theory: Star Trek Discovery is not really Star Trek

@ElectricStardust

4 жыл бұрын

@@kyle8952 Theory: this guy nailed it

All of these continuity mistakes can be solved with one solution. And that is to acknowledge that STD is not Canon and never will be.

@MasterHobbes

4 жыл бұрын

Hell, all nutrek is done for me. I'll be happy with TOS - Enterprise .

@ashwinarun9817

4 жыл бұрын

Nobody needs to acknowledge it. The plot holes speak for themselves

@neonknights

4 жыл бұрын

I offer another solution: grow up, realize it's just a TV show, and move on.

@ashwinarun9817

4 жыл бұрын

@@neonknightsPerhaps you need to stop lecturing people on what they should care about especially when it's something as benign as an interest in a television franchise

@kenetickups6146

4 жыл бұрын

Already is to me, just like picard

I liked enterprise before discovery. After discovery, I realized that enterprise was great...and possibly the last real trek we will ever get.

@ironinquisitor3656

Жыл бұрын

I liked Enterprise from the first time I saw it in middle school in 2010.

And this ladies and gentlemen is why I think that this show should be put in the Kelvin universe it's just got more in common with that Universe than with the original

@NihilusShadow

6 жыл бұрын

The only problem with that is Discovery contradicts the Kelvin Universe about as much as it does the Prime Universe.

@LeonidSaykin

5 жыл бұрын

I already thought that it has more in common with Kelvin then the original

@brianreiss9494

5 жыл бұрын

Has a lot more to do with the prime time line considering The Enterprise is already an much older ship

@Howyaduing

5 жыл бұрын

It could be it’s own universe with no connection to either the kelvin or the prime timeline

@shanepfeifer4207

5 жыл бұрын

@@Howyaduing that's what i'm starting to think. Remember that one guy did state multi-verse.

"Those are Klingons?" Discovery summed up in a nutshell.

@aiosquadron

4 жыл бұрын

Jay Dowg I call them Klingoffs

@JAnx01

4 жыл бұрын

What about Into Darkness? When I watched it in the CInema, I somehow missed that they reached Qo'noS because it didn't make sense that the Enterprise hadn't encountered any Klingon ships on its way there, so I thought they stopped at some random planet in the middle of nowhere and had no idea those low quality CGI thugs were actually Klingons until I watched youtube videos about the film. Those Klingons were much more poorly done than the Discovery's.

Discovery should honestly be part of the Kelvin Timeline

@axenledgie1423

4 жыл бұрын

Discovery fits into literally no timeline. Like, even if you created a universe specifically built for STD canon, with every sentence of the show accounted for, KUNTzman would still find a way to mess up that chronology.

@drumkommandr9779

3 жыл бұрын

IT IS

@HepCatJack

3 жыл бұрын

No longer possible since Vulcan exists in the future.

@anyuisbjoern

3 жыл бұрын

it should be a new timeline

@honzasenbauer612

2 жыл бұрын

Hey Kelvin timeline is better than this

"Huh, I was wondering when someone would make a list.. Let's see..." *Part One* "Oh, episodic." *...Of ninety nine.* *"...Oh..."*

People need to calm TF down a tad. Next they’ll be saying “in TOS they didn’t have CGI so that’s now inconsistent”. Get a grip and enjoy the damn show!

@rickylovesyou

5 жыл бұрын

Ikr???

@avery9076

5 жыл бұрын

If the show was enjoyable people would watch it instead of doing things like this. Suspension of disbelief is a hard thing to keep up when the show is bad.

@michaelkeha

24 күн бұрын

Okay my guy lets just give Julius Ceasar a brand new smartphone next time we do a period drama if consistency doesn't matter

An episode of DS9 involved a time travel incident where the crew of the Defiant were sent back to the Trouble With Tribbles Episode. Throughout the episode, they addressed many differences in technology between the two eras, from technology to species to culture. Dax walked around flaunting the skirt she wore, Worf addressed the physical differences between the Klingons of different shows, and we saw how much of a legend Captain Kirk was to future generations.

I saw "Continuity mistakes", saw "7 minutes" was like "Theres no way he can do this in-" *part 1 of 99* AAAHHHHHhhhhh

@justsomeguy7921

4 жыл бұрын

Uh, it’s 299 now.

Me: "it's in the Kelvin timeline,it's in the Kelvin timeline"

@CavZippo

4 жыл бұрын

Then why is Enterprise not Abrams' Enterprise?

@nolandavis1129

4 жыл бұрын

Kit 1982 let people dream.

@CavZippo

4 жыл бұрын

@@nolandavis1129 don't confuse dreaming with delusion.

@cosmobayston3750

4 жыл бұрын

@@CavZippo actually I think discovery is different because of enterprise and startrek nemesis, the Borg incursion completely changed the timeline, giving them a whole new set of tech

@freiinmajor2511

4 жыл бұрын

It's not?

You forgot that tribbles were encountered for the first time on tos, and specifically used to detect sleeper agent Klingons who were surgically altered..

Continuity mistakes? What continuity mistakes? Those are rookie numbers! - Star Wars

@brucebridges8631

6 жыл бұрын

"Continuity? Hold my beer, I mean soy beverage!" - Ruin Johnson

@MonkeyspankO

6 жыл бұрын

nice

@MikhaelAhava

5 жыл бұрын

Yup.

@kmichael9787

5 жыл бұрын

Star Wars Lords of the Sith: YOU AINT SEEN NOTHIN' YET

@timmaximilian9286

5 жыл бұрын

@@brucebridges8631 ever read anything expanded universe related? Believe me canon is nothing compared to that mess

Why didnt they just set discovery after Next Generation?

@ColemanMulkerin

4 жыл бұрын

I was told a while ago that writers didn't want to go beyong TNG because the level of techology hindered storywriting. They always had to come up with reasons tech couldn't work at the moment. That's why they made Enterprise. But why set it before TOS and then still have all of the super advanced technology that surpasses even TNG?

@MrTonyBarzini

4 жыл бұрын

Coleman Mulkerin to take advantage of the nostalgic references available to them with that time period

That's why I love Enterprise, they worked extremely hard to not do more advanced things than previous shows. Even when they did, they made sure it was aliens with no connection to future federation as an explanation. And then everything involving cultures and and communications. I don't mind mistakes, every long running franchise will have them. It's the big ones that just blatantly ignore the history, it punishes you for paying attention.

@user-oi9vh1po9z

6 ай бұрын

This is thanks of time traveler innovation when they crew stuck in past and leave their tech to company or the military

Huh, funny. Considering holodecks weren't made on Federation ships before the 24th century

@brentc2411

4 жыл бұрын

Unless you watched the animated series.

@mtr801

4 жыл бұрын

Brent C But it’s not canon

@brentc2411

4 жыл бұрын

@@mtr801 how do you figure?

@mtr801

4 жыл бұрын

Brent C Roddenberry himself de-canonized it after the first season of TNG

@neonknights

4 жыл бұрын

1) The writers did actually clarify in the Aftershow that it's not a holodeck, and those characters are not like the holograms of the 24th century. They're not solid, Lorca and Tyler could pass through them if they'd wanted. 2) TAS was re-canonized after Roddenberry's death. 2a) According to Roddenberry, Star Trek II - VI were not canon either...

Excellent job Nitpicking Nerd! Bravo!

@davfree9732

5 жыл бұрын

Time to open a new Chapter in the ongoing series... A Nitpickers Guide to Star Trek - To Discovery... And Beyond!

@Famousminkey

5 жыл бұрын

STD sucks

@MrPaulmorris7777

5 жыл бұрын

Hardly nitpicking. STD simply ignores previous series.

@locutic1

5 жыл бұрын

This is NOT nitpicking! STD is so far removed from star trek I don't consider it canon at all. The only way STD could be true is if it takes place in another reality lol

@MrPaulmorris7777

5 жыл бұрын

@@locutic1 "Canon".

This is what you get when you have people who like star wars, don't know anything about Trek and try to turn it into star wars. The 21 minute story film Prelude to Axanar was more Trek than Discovery or Picard.

Honestly at this point they've gotta admit that it's an alternate universe.

You missed the one where they beam Ash from outside another starship's sensor range, even though transporter range is notoriously short in TOS (less than 40,000 km - that's about 1/10 the distance to the moon).

@90lancaster

6 жыл бұрын

Yes that wasn't the only time the Discovery was plenty close enough to be seen but was mysteriously un-noticed. The show seems to have a serious problem with putting full stops on things and considering that the end of the matter - such as 'The Emperor' destroying the rebels. or the way the Parvans or Harry were handled. I sometimes wonder if this is a consequence of not wanting to mention something from someone else's script so they have to pay someone else - that is why the stories are all in little clusters. and why there is no continuity with the show - even with itself (at times).

The "Klingons" gathering the dead pissed me off way too much. Just let them freeze in space. That would've made sense.

@AndrooUK

5 жыл бұрын

They would just vaporise them, right? Transport them and don't rematerialise them? Chop them up for targ feed?

@InfernosReaper

5 жыл бұрын

"The body is a useless shell. Dispose of it as you see fit."

@maxcondie75

5 жыл бұрын

Except when in a temple?

@AJNavales

5 жыл бұрын

fwiw, T'kuvma's "house" had a different culture than the other houses, probably why he was an outcast.

@vitorhq1

5 жыл бұрын

They were a fanatical faction of the Klingons, that at that time weren't an unified empire. It seems reasonable that they had different cultural aspects

most of these have an explaination, most of them in this case were that discovery and its logs were all classified to hide the existence of the mycelial network so it couldnt be abused again.

@MajorGrin

4 жыл бұрын

still makes no sense that no one else in the galaxy discovered the spore drive. only a human did ? and no one else ? and Mudd knew about it and wanted to sell the information . also you'd think Starfleet would de-classify this to bring Voyager home or to help fight the Dominion or the Borg

I know they say that discovery is part of the regular time line and with Picard the original enterprise remodel is shown from discovery but to me it is and will always will be a kelvin timeline series and I’m willing to sacrifice Picard series as cannon to keep it that way

@leatherworkstation

Жыл бұрын

Seems to me that Picard only adheres to its own canon loosely with every new series. Praying for the day the people overseeing Trek TV move on and everything made after Enterprise gets wiped from the timeline. Make a show set after DS9/VOY and make it stand on its own two feet. Enough of the brand recognition fan service stuff. DS9 shows if you are willing and talented you can make some of the best Star Trek without needing to latch on to past glories for all you're worth. Bring the joy and adventure back to Star Trek, and adequate lighting while you're at it.

did you mean: the entire show's existence. literally nothing adds up. i'm devastated

@nisher15

5 жыл бұрын

Forced diversity and social justice issues are easy to see because they are shoved in your face... I think that was the only point to this show. How many times did Sisko use the black card to pander an issue.. How many times did Janeway complain about equality..

It's almost as if the writers of Discovery didn't care about the legacy of Star Trek at all.

@lIngrimmschl

5 жыл бұрын

more like: It's almost as if the writers of Discovery didn't have the licenses of the Star Trek legacy. Oh wait, that's excactly their problem! :/

@AK-gt8zy

5 жыл бұрын

@@lIngrimmschl Is this true?

@lIngrimmschl

5 жыл бұрын

Sadly it is. Even though it is a bit messy. In 2006 Viacom was split into two different companies. The old Viacom was renamed CBS Corporation and a new company was founded that was called Viacom (strange enough, but keep in mind, this is a completely different company than the orignial Viacom). The Paramount Studio - which holds the rights to the original 10 movies - was moved to the new Viacom. Since this was not the original Viacom however, they didn't have the rights to the rest of Star Trek (including the series) and neither the rights to make new films. Those licences remained with the old Viacom, now called CBS. The new CEO of CBS however had no interest in Star Trek (he personally dislikes science fiction), which resulted in more than 10 years withouth a new star trek series. However, CBS still got all the money from sold star trek merchandise. Nevertheless, Paramount wanted to make new Star Trek movies. So they made a deal with CBS. They were given a new Star Trek license which allowed them to produce content that "visually and tonally" differs from original Star Trek. This was done to prevent them from getting a claim to merchandise revenues generated by the original Star Trek. This new license was used to create both the new movies (Kelvin Timeline) and Discovery. Long story short: Discovery legally has to differ from canon Star Trek. They are simply not allowed to produce the series we all wanted to see.

@AndrooUK

5 жыл бұрын

@@lIngrimmschl So they should have made a new scifi with original characters and premise... instead they use the name Star Trek to hook people onto a piece of crap.

@DanielRichards644

5 жыл бұрын

obviously, I mean fuck they killed the Blue Shirt and not the Red Shirt on the away mission

"Part 1 of 99" 😂

discovery fucks up for me the moment were they make an inexpirienced ensign, commander jumping probably 12 year of expirience and 4 ranks..

Sees thumbnail on youtube recommended page "All Star Trek Discovery Continuity Mistakes with th....." Checks length; only six minutes, fifty-three seconds - hmmm seems a little short to cover this canon-wrecking disaster Opens vid to reveal rest of title "…. (part 1 of 40)" Yeah. Now that sounds about right!

@imperfectly_megan

4 жыл бұрын

Now it says part 1 of 99 lol.

I've been itching to do my own video similar to this to outline the problems that STD has created. Mainly that TNG onward fully embraced where they came from and acknowledged TOS on more than one occasion. All the previous shows tied together pretty well and sure, there were slight inconsistencies at times... but I do mean SLIGHT. Completely changing the Klingons to look like Orcs with so much prosthetics on that the actors can't even talk is just insane. Making the tech so advanced it goes well beyond Voyager is preposterous. There's no fucking way I could watch that show and believe it takes place a mere decade before TOS. It isn't the Prime timeline. And STD fans are just too stubborn to admit it.

@poetofreason

5 жыл бұрын

dude if you took away the Star Trek title would the show still be bad to you?

@ZeroB4NG

5 жыл бұрын

It would still be bad, but it would not be insultingly bad...

@poetofreason

5 жыл бұрын

@@ZeroB4NG lol yea ok

@the7percentsolution

5 жыл бұрын

Ok that's a fair question. If the show was just called "Discovery" and a friend suggested I check it out, I would say that first episode would immediately turn me away. The main character is not interesting at all. She's actually pretty detestable based on her actions. It doesn't help that I hated that actress's character in The Walking Dead because she was bland and unlikable. I guess that's the extent of her acting range because she's doing it all over again here. The "Klingons" are laughable. In fact I DID actually laugh when they started talking and it sounds like their mouths are full of gum. And the show itself just comes across as trying way too hard. Not to mention the fact that it's on a streaming site I have no interest in. Why would I bother paying for and watching something that doesn't interest me? I know STD fans hate this comparison but look at what The Orville is doing. You can watch any single episode and see how closely it takes on the tone and themes of Next Generation. It's a very Star Trek show without Star Trek being in the title. What Zero said isn't wrong. The fact that Discovery DOES have Star Trek in the title is insulting because the show in no way FEELS like Star Trek. Basically you're a fan because you feel you're obligated. You've convinced yourself the show is good and fits within the timeline, which is what REALLY baffles me. But hey, if you want to waste your time and money then by all means do so. Not my problem :)

@brentc2411

4 жыл бұрын

If the show wasn't called star trek, and followed a completely different design for ships and such, it would still be a mediocre scifi.

I believe that due to the huge amount of continuity mistakes, it is likely that Discovery is actually not canon, and in a different universe, where none of this happened.

@emjackson81989

4 жыл бұрын

Indeed, it is not in the continuity of the previous series. It was made under the alternate license that was used to make the most recent Star Trek films and it is not even in continuity with them. You should check out a channel called Midnight's Edge. They have a whole video about the issue.

@HistoryisBoss

4 жыл бұрын

Emmanuel Goldstein Wait how did the year of hell impact Enterprise, I’m actually curious.

@2bituser569

4 жыл бұрын

Samual Jager me too. I would think Enterprise was a spawned universe of First Contact movie.

I like how a majority of these are because of Discovery not paying attention to any of the lore

Its fine. They will just make all of the continuity errors vanish by erasing the Discovery from history. *Suddenly, a wild short trek appears* DAMNIT!

STD doesn't exist in my trek universe anyway. Nor does the Kelvin timeline. ST ended with the last episode of Enterprise. Anyone else sees it like this here?

@thisismyname3928

5 жыл бұрын

Enterprise? Ha. DS9 here.

Shaka...when the walls fell.

Wonder why they decided to position it at that point in time.

@Swamprat44

4 жыл бұрын

So they could shoehorn in some TOS characters to trick people into watching. That’s literally the only reason.

@JamesLinenX

3 ай бұрын

So she could be the first female captian in time line and not janeway

A lot of people here seem to think that because a lot of these can be excused through roundabout explanations that are half guesswork that the point of the video is moot. Discovery isn't an insult because it changes the previous canon, it's how it goes about it, with no respect for the shows that came before it. The now fired director literally said before the show was launched that he understood the canon was important to fans but that he didn't care anyways. Yeah some of these are legitimate nitpicks, but they are meant to illustrate the pattern of total disrespect to anything besides Discovery, resulting in a product that feels like an original franchise with the name "Star Trek" slapped on afterwards. The fact that Paramount's Star Trek movies feel closer to the older shows than Discovery is sad, and at least JJ was respectful enough to say it was in a different timeline instead of trying to pass it off as canon just to boost CBS All Access subscribers.

@thisismyname3928

5 жыл бұрын

Don't let Abrams off the hook that easily. That whole timeline b.s. was laziness more than anything.

@Xenotaris

2 жыл бұрын

also JJ hated Star Trek because he was a Star Wars fan... he also ruined Star Wars

And then Discovery explains everything away as no one knows they or anything they did existed

This and another video regarding TNG and Short Treks convinced me to watch TNG. Thank you.

In defence of the first one, not hearing something didn't meant it never happened.

Since the second season is over, and a lot has been revealed, this video is not up to date anymore

@GermanLeftist

5 жыл бұрын

Yes and no. Some things are now explained but not all.

@MajorGrin

5 жыл бұрын

starfleet top brass still knew about the spore drive , so explain this : kzread.info/dash/bejne/lI6qydBtnMradKQ.html

@RimWulf

4 жыл бұрын

It was to fix their previous meth session they called "season 1"

@AzurePursuer

4 жыл бұрын

yea but STD is still traaaaaaash

@gusp6612

4 жыл бұрын

Vanitas Remnant season 2 is pretty decent. All thanks to Pike.

No matter how many times they try to say this show is in the main continuity, this show is clearly in its own tune line or the kelvinverse.

I always wondered how a group of Klingon or Romulan cloaked ships flew around without crashing into each other, especially a large fleet?

@enriquejoseantequerasanche6180

2 жыл бұрын

I always thought they kept track via communication and the ship computer predicted their positions

Ha, the whole dam shows existence is a continuatity mistake!

@saquist

5 жыл бұрын

Just like Enterprise

@Taios87entertainment

5 жыл бұрын

WILL GRIFFIN what if it’s just an entirely inaccurate holodeck sim, made with the impression of trying to look cool, but fails in so many levels?

@AndrooUK

5 жыл бұрын

@@saquist Enterprise really feels like the writers are trying to honour Star Trek and its canon. They have to cook food, force fields are still new, they don't like the transporter, they don't shit all over previously established characters and such. Star Trek: Discovery is a hollow endeavour where the writers don't give a shit, or are ordered to not give a shit, about canon and the spirit of Star Trek.

@DanielRichards644

5 жыл бұрын

@@saquist Season 3 and the multi-episode arcs of Season 4 of Enterprise are pretty good, they solve continuity issues like TOS Klingons lack of cranial ridges vs all other Klingons having them, develop more of a backstory for the Vulcans and season3 embodies the very spirit of Trek, even when Archer tracks down the facility where the Kemosite comes from, he is able to recognize that not all Xindi are Earth's enemy, much in the same way not all middle eastern people are terrorists, those kinds of parallels are exactly the type of thing Gene did with the original series.

@saquist

5 жыл бұрын

@@DanielRichards644 Granted there was improvement but the Primary problem of the series was it's violation of canon and the Bad Acting from Bakula, Blalock and Montgomery. STD is going through the same problem. And sure, I understand ENT has it's fans but I'll tell you the same thing I told them in 2002. Don't support bad Trek because it will only lead to more bad Trek. We have a responsibility as consumers to demand quality over quantity if we really appreciate why Trek was Good in the first place. If anything we should always demand better.

This hurts to watch. If that Picard show is this bad, I think it might finally be time for the noose.

@rickylovesyou

5 жыл бұрын

Find a girlfriend dude. Who tf would kill themselves over a tv show. Smh

"Repeat to yourself, 'It's just a show, I should really just relax.' "

Let’s face it….Alex Kurtzman never saw not one episode of Star Trek before taking this on. Smh

can you please offer a Dropbox link for your 'Scotty Reacts to Continuity Mistakes in Star Trek Discovery' video? because CBS blocked the one you uploaded.

6:06 - Listen closely and you'll hear the sound of Jetsons aircar...

@DoomKid

4 жыл бұрын

LOL

Gotta love Kurtzman...he didn't want to work within the constraints of the franchise, so he just said "well I am a God, so I will just do whatever is easy and looks cool"

If you watched Enterprise, later episodes explained why Klingons for a period had no rigid foreheads. A way to explain Trouble with Tribbles episodes

The sound effect at 6:06 inspired the tune lyrics "Meet George Jetson"

STD's Klingon ships look like a space turd!

@hapokas112

5 жыл бұрын

I agree.

I love the site-to-site transporter goof up...not only was it dangerous, but on discovery the computer can do the job, no silly technician or transporter pad required.

Discovery is not prime timeline.it comes from the fan fic timeline.

We need a new genre for shows like the appropriately names STD. Call it “magic fiction”.

@richardsilva-spokane3436

Жыл бұрын

I so agree. It is beyond incredible…it is cartoonish, as are all of the superhero movies. I cringe when Tony Stark’s suit just simply materializes.

Whether CBS admits it or not, we all know Discovery takes place in the Kelvin universe

@Nersius

4 жыл бұрын

Because everyone knows it's absolute zero?

Star Trek Discovery's continuity mistakes with the other shows. Video begins. Star Trek Discovery title card. Video ends.

6:04 I spit my coffee when Picard said "It is WRONG!"

STD season one was a roleplaying video game on a streaming service. One step (or several) below a fanfilm. However just to count the continuity errors between The Cage, TOS season one to TOS season three would take more than seven minutes. They beamed onboard a tight ship in the third episode filmed to drink Tranya with Opie's little brother, then later claimed it was hard. No United Federation of Planets in the first dozen episodes. Vulcan conquered then never conquered. Smiling Spock. Spock the smirker at sexual harassment and even attempted rape. Penal colonies to threaten Scotty with for disobeying an AssBassidor, insane asylums and then this is the only one left with Garth on it.....

@thisismyname3928

5 жыл бұрын

Brah, do you even Trek?

There's no mistakes. According to Midnights Edge, STD is made under a NEW Star Trek License with any Star Trek films or TV shows made under that licesnse having to be 25% different to that of the original ST license. Essentially, the original Trek is now Dormant. It is NOT connected to this new batch of Trek. Midnights Edge also explains the whole Prime/Kelvin timeline stuff, with Prime actually not meaning CANON. It's messed up, but this is is possibly why bryan Fuller was fired from the show early on, because he wanted to actually have his show based in the original canon. Check out Midnights Edge covering of all this. It's fascinating. So basically, STD does NOT have to follow canon. You can basically call this a reboot. And not a good one at that.

@Myuutsuu85

5 жыл бұрын

In short, someone pulled a Disney on Star Trek?

Discovery only has one continuity error. That error is the whole thing. The simple idea of setting it 100 years after TNG would have fixed it all. STD is a great nickname for the series. It is awesome in one respect. It gave us Captain Pike and SNW, which is a MUCH better show.

They have to be doing this on purpose to be doing it this consistently.

Wait did the Klingons actually attack Starfleet Headquarters in Discovery? And they made Paris look like a dystopia

@star-army

4 жыл бұрын

Euro-City One. 800 million people living in the ruin of the old world and the mega structures of the new one. Only one thing fighting for order in the chaos: judges.

@mikicerise6250

4 жыл бұрын

What are you talking about? Paris looks awesome.

Regarding 'Enterprise' and how they handled it: Enterprise really feels like the writers are trying to honour Star Trek and its canon. They have to cook food, force fields are still new, they don't like the transporter, they don't shit all over previously established characters and such. Star Trek: Discovery is a hollow endeavour where the writers don't give a shit, or are ordered to not give a shit, about canon and the spirit of Star Trek. This could have been set in the future, and have a whole load of subject material to use. Many trajectories are available. CBS didn't have the licence to make a proper Star Trek, so they should have made a new scifi with original characters and premise... instead they use the name Star Trek to hook people onto this piece of crap. Just like the Kelvin films. Generic scifi action that again shits all over the canon.

@AndrooUK

5 жыл бұрын

@AllegedPhilo Gotta get them clicks and eyeballs, boiii!

@verververververver

5 жыл бұрын

I feel like people should go back and watch Enterprise because it's actually pretty good, especially after midway season 2

5 жыл бұрын

@@verververververver It's not so bad as long as you skip that shitty nonsense song at the start,

@maxkuz334

5 жыл бұрын

At least Kelvin cared enough to make a separate universe, as to not completely shit.on the cannon...

@goldo1107

5 жыл бұрын

They dont care about the spirit? Lmaooo you are such a fucking clown. My god. Get a fucking life.

The part about the Klingon bodies isn't necessarily a canon error. T'Kuvma & co. were part of a religious sect; it's not impossible there are different religious beliefs among the Klingons in this regard. Discovery is set about 80 years prior to TNG. The sect could've faded into obscurity.

Discovery was basically black ops. Their achievements would not be well known.

The show doesn't care about anything except itself. This is more than nitpicking; It's a blatant disregard for anything that's ever happened in Star Trek. It exists to serve itself. STD is an abomination.

@tehbing

5 жыл бұрын

@@DavidNicholson101 I enjoy the show for what it is, however, I'm sure you realize just as much as anyone else that there will never be another TNG, DS9, or VOY. If there aren't the Abrams' reboot movies, or these "abomination" TV shows, there would be nothing new at all, and an entire generation of people will grow up without experiences similar to those we had as children. Sure, they may take a lot of creative liberty with canon, but let's face it... TNG, et al. wouldn't survive TV today. You have to have a seasonal story arc with somewhat convincing effects and humor. If you don't like the show, you are welcome to your opinion. However, saying that fans of the show are somehow destroying your Star Trek universe is really short-sighted and indicative of someone who is unwilling to change. Quite the opposite of Star Trek's spirit.

@redgeneral5792

5 жыл бұрын

​@@tehbing "I enjoy the show for what it is, however, I'm sure you realize just as much as anyone else that there will never be another TNG, DS9, or VOY." Yeah, until the new Picard series comes out. "If [ they ] aren't the Abrams' reboot movies, or these "abomination" TV shows, there would be nothing new at all, and an entire generation of people will grow up without experiences similar to those we had as children. " Please don't be so dramatic. There was a ten year gap between the cancellation of TOS and The Motion Picture. Trek survived. But at the rate STD is pissing off fans, it might not be the case. "Sure, they may take a lot of creative liberty with canon, but let's face it... TNG, et al. wouldn't survive TV today." "Creative liberty" doesn't necessarily mean crap on existing canon. And TNG does survive today in syndication, and on streaming sites. A lot of young people seem to appreciate the old series, even if they weren't alive then to see them. "You have to have a seasonal story arc with somewhat convincing effects and humor." Who says it has to be a "seasonal story arc"? Effects and humor? Are these the only things you look for in a show? Just eye candy and silliness? I'm sorry, but those two aspects are meaningless unless you have a meaningful story that forms the backbone of the show. Also with meaningful character development so that the audience can relate and invest their time and attention to. So far, STD doesn't have any characters that are even worth the audience's attention. "However, saying that fans of the show are somehow destroying your Star Trek universe is really short-sighted and indicative of someone who is unwilling to change. Quite the opposite of Star Trek's spirit." We can agree that fans of STD are not destroying Trek, however to suggest that other fans are "unwilling to change" is a massive assumption. They want change. Why are fans pushing for the continuation of the Prime timeline, after Romulus was destroyed? With the myriad of prequel shows, and movies ( even though they are in a alternate timeline ) they are tired of the same old shit. They want a change for a more optimistic and hopeful future. That's the spirit of Star Trek.

@billiecruz4399

5 жыл бұрын

Red General sorry bud, nothing optimistic or hopeful is going to happen in the prime timeline if I remember where it left off right.

@AnelFissures

5 жыл бұрын

Geez it may not run everything by the old source material but with so much old content through so many time periods it would be hard to write on, aslong as they stick to the foundation of the series and they dont intentionally shit on it like disney is doing star wars i dont mind and i will watch it

@monkeymox2544

5 жыл бұрын

@@tehbing No one is saying you can't have story arcs, good special effects, or humour. But you can have those things without needlessly messing up canon, and without meddling with the core of what Star Trek is supposed to be. Its pure condescension on the part of producers, they seem to think that if five minutes pass without someone having a moody monologue, or something exploding, or someone betraying someone else, then audiences won't be interested - that modern audiences can't handle slow and cerebral, and don't notice when the writing is awful and the plots make literally no sense. Its nonsense - people can still be discerning, and there is clearly an appetite for a genuine star trek show. Unfortunately I doubt the new Picard series will give us that - same useless people as always are involved in the production. Greedy arseholes, milking the brand for all its worth with no regard for the fans.

HA! Amazing. Well done

To be fair for the first one, all knowledge of Discovery’s mission was buried

@Howyaduing

3 жыл бұрын

That’s called damage control in season two of STD

The Klingons lost their head crests due to genetic mutation creating a virus. It's always possible that it affected a large group in a different way. Perhaps exiled Klingons who possibly are mixed species. That would explain why it affected them differently. Additionally perhaps their own culture changed slightly to care more for the dead. Paris possibly experienced a nuclear attack and therefore had to be rebuilt (Nah that one is definitely a stretch.)

Scotty says intership ship beam has rarely been done. Star Trek enterprise did it in season 3 episode Chosen Realm.

@Nulono

5 жыл бұрын

Listing one instance of something happening doesn't exactly prove it wasn't rare.

@DanBen07

5 жыл бұрын

@@Nulono Well I was posting an example of it happening before tos was set.

@AC-gb7do

5 жыл бұрын

Rare: 1 : seldom occurring or found Scotty was still right.

@gatebuffles

5 жыл бұрын

Just to be clear none of us know the science on this but let's be honest what's different from beaming urslef from inside of the ship to another part of the ship. Sounds like a bad plot device from the 60s on the original show to make a few episodes more difficult for the characters to solve their problems. It's stupid and doesnt make sence since they beam from one ship to another all the time or down inside a building. I love this show. I'm also not obsessed about the details either, just annoying having more material.

I thought the show was set in the new timeline and therefore any old stuff could be considered rewritten?

for the first one lets be fair he said unaware he didn't say it's never happened and that ship was classified. so it didn't breach continuity

As someone who's avoided STD like any other venereal disease, I'm a bit confused. Is STD supposed to be set before TOS?

Actually, the animated Star Trek series had a Holodeck.

@PokemonBoy-de4jd

4 жыл бұрын

William Merkel it not canon according to Gene Roddenberry

@williammerkel1410

4 жыл бұрын

@@PokemonBoy-de4jd Gene was alot like George Lucas, he created the series but as it went on it was best when he wasn't involved much, The Motion Picture vs The Wrath of Kahn for example and DS9 and Voyager would not have been as great as they were or have been made at all.

@PokemonBoy-de4jd

4 жыл бұрын

William Merkel I know how Roddenberry was most of the time but he the animated series is still considered non canon

@Shoddragon

4 жыл бұрын

certain events of the animated series are canon (mostly those referenced in canon shows like DS9) but as a whole, TAS is not canon whatsoever. It's probably for the best as it would have interfered with TNG and DS9 very heavily.