A political reading of BJP's Lok Sabha list and why it has fielded 116 defectors or more than 1 in 4

28% of defectors have been fielded by the BJP for the General Elections. In episode 1425 of #CutTheClutter, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta explains why, who these defectors are and why the BJP is choosing winnability over ideology.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapters:
01:50 - BJP's 'brown vs green field' expansion
03:31 - BJP has fielded 116 defectors till now for Lok Sabha elections
04:06 - 97 out of 116 have joined BJP post 2014 Election win
05:16 - 37% to 40% of defectors are from Congress
07:32 - BJP is facing a rebellion in 100 seats across India
08:43 - List of defectors from across states & parties
19:35 - Highest percentage of defectors have been fielded from Telangana
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our KZread Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

Пікірлер: 419

  • @ThePrintIndia
    @ThePrintIndia2 ай бұрын

    Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/

  • @rajeshindust
    @rajeshindust2 ай бұрын

    I heard Rahul Gandhi is also planning to join BJP as root level kariyakarta

  • @Yourking645

    @Yourking645

    2 ай бұрын

    There is no need as Rahul gandhi always campaign for the BJP by his statement😂😂

  • @humptydumpty4773

    @humptydumpty4773

    2 ай бұрын

    Good riddance to bad rubbish. 😂

  • @sanjeevtiwari8347

    @sanjeevtiwari8347

    2 ай бұрын

    No no ZRG is already great vote catcher for BJP. Down with Khangress, long live Pappu.

  • @chanakyabharat756

    @chanakyabharat756

    2 ай бұрын

    No we don't want him 😂😂😂

  • @Jethya99

    @Jethya99

    2 ай бұрын

    Isn't he bjp's star pracharak

  • @nihithchandra8422
    @nihithchandra84222 ай бұрын

    Can't help but point out a mistake-16:49-the photo that you have displayed is of B.Vinod Kumar,the one who defected is T.Vinod Rao

  • @amoghkashyap2695

    @amoghkashyap2695

    2 ай бұрын

    hahaha :D massive error

  • @nitinpatel1039
    @nitinpatel10392 ай бұрын

    It can be termed as merger and acquisition by big corporations, kalaben de kar is very interesting, she won by election on shivsena ticket defeating bjp, and in less than 2 year bjp inducted her to fight for them 😂

  • @rajkumarganesan9417

    @rajkumarganesan9417

    2 ай бұрын

    A defector, Kalaben ,my mind says that she was elected in Shiva ticket. Morally she should have resigned her seat and that she could have contested again with the party she has aligned with.

  • @godarar
    @godarar2 ай бұрын

    BJP is cleaning BJP also. There are Congress type elements in BJP and BJP type elements in Congress. This is an overhaul of the Indian politics.

  • @sumeshp.s1644

    @sumeshp.s1644

    Ай бұрын

    reboot & rest , everyone has to play by BJP rules , they are not just setting the narrative , they are writing the rules ,,,

  • @glenmascarenhas7885
    @glenmascarenhas78852 ай бұрын

    What about ED, IT and CBI’s role in defections.

  • @rajkumarganesan9417

    @rajkumarganesan9417

    2 ай бұрын

    The ruling parties apparatus. True democracy in death bed.

  • @shivkumarrp8515
    @shivkumarrp85152 ай бұрын

    How can people who joined the party 5 years ago be still be considered as defectors. Also BJP is like a corporate which takes talent from all sections.

  • @mehmeetdhar7618

    @mehmeetdhar7618

    2 ай бұрын

    yeah they come to BJP and become talented 🤣🤣🤣🤣 otherwise they are corrupt

  • @jaigagandeep.s5100

    @jaigagandeep.s5100

    2 ай бұрын

    @@mehmeetdhar7618the same thing applies to opposition .

  • @mehmeetdhar7618

    @mehmeetdhar7618

    2 ай бұрын

    @@jaigagandeep.s5100 i dont see anyone joining congress from BJP please list

  • @Bengalifirst

    @Bengalifirst

    2 ай бұрын

    You should see today’s Indian express report ! These leaders and parties are just deceiving us .

  • @rishisahgal4529

    @rishisahgal4529

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@mehmeetdhar7618 It's purely a tactical thing. Defectors will go where they think they can gain...right now they don't see that happening with the opposition.

  • @easwarsankar
    @easwarsankar2 ай бұрын

    Most depressing list for both true BJP supporters and skeptics. For the former, because it is obvious that they don't care about any ideology. For the latter, this is overwhelming proof that BJP has mastered politics and is steamrolling all other parties using saam, daam, and, bedh

  • @elborrador333

    @elborrador333

    2 ай бұрын

    True BJP supporters want BJP to win because only by winning will they be able to expand the sociocultural agenda of Hindutva. If the BJP thinks that fielding these candidates maximizes their chances of winning, so be it. I give two hoots for "ideological purity" as there is not such thing in Hinduism.

  • @easwarsankar

    @easwarsankar

    2 ай бұрын

    @elborrador333 This is the true color of BJP and it's supporters. There is NO difference between BJP and other parties, be it in ideology or principles of winning or governing. Only difference is that they are very good at doing politics. This has been exactly my point to all BJP supporters since 2014 when they all told me that BJP is not like any other party

  • @elborrador333

    @elborrador333

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@easwarsankar Umm I literally said BJP has a sociocultural agenda of Hindutva, which part of that did you not understand. If there was "NO difference" between BJP and others, we wouldn't be supporting BJP and opposing others would we.

  • @gauravshah89

    @gauravshah89

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@easwarsankar So if BJP is like all other parties, you don't care if BJP wins and implements UCC. Correct?

  • @kakun63

    @kakun63

    2 ай бұрын

    @@easwarsankar u tell me follow ideology and loose power or win and then pursue ideology , atal ji was a true bjpian did he manage caa, ram mandir 370 NO, this new BJP is what we want

  • @sleepingduty2987
    @sleepingduty29872 ай бұрын

    Right wingers here cannot handle that their party just wants to win and does not give 2 paisa to have clean government or clear ideology.

  • @Vikramadithya02

    @Vikramadithya02

    2 ай бұрын

    When the core party is ideological... To retain political power, for numbers, if defectors are added, I think that's politics. Every party does that.

  • @gauravshah89

    @gauravshah89

    2 ай бұрын

    So you must be happy that BJP is moving away from hindutva ideology. Correct?

  • @HeavenRacer422

    @HeavenRacer422

    2 ай бұрын

    BJP always sticks to ideology. Defectors who comes to BJP adheres BJP's ideology. Why it shouldn't include talents like hemant, Scindia etc?

  • @memaze29

    @memaze29

    2 ай бұрын

    We want to win and not let the corrupt parties come into power . In the end, the election is about winning, and governing is about principles, and that's something you seem to be unaware of.

  • @kakun63

    @kakun63

    2 ай бұрын

    yes we cant handle ram mandir 370 ucc caa NRc on cards we are sad

  • @Bengalifirst
    @Bengalifirst2 ай бұрын

    I can’t say for other states but in Bengal they basically took in all the tmc rejects some of them got raided by ed and some of them are so corrupt that even tmc was like “no” think if tmc reject someone for corruption.

  • @sayakm6

    @sayakm6

    2 ай бұрын

    No one TMC rejected Suvendu defeated Mamata Arjun singh was inducted back and this time offred ministry Rathin Ghosh is a Doctor and former Mayor Rajeev Bannerjee Mukul Roy and Sabyasachi went back to TMC name Tapas Roy is called honest even by his opponent

  • @Bengalifirst

    @Bengalifirst

    2 ай бұрын

    @@sayakm6 sure 😅 bjp makes everyone beacon of honesty it’s a common knowledge no need to explain . I know .

  • @Bengalifirst

    @Bengalifirst

    2 ай бұрын

    @@gargvanit deplorable and offensive comment ! even if you don't agree with something or someone why do you have to use such language ? is this how you grew up ?

  • @anahita-bn6cy

    @anahita-bn6cy

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@Bengalifirstbjp has fielded far better candidates in WB than tmc... In balurghat tmc fielded a well known Gunda named biplab Mitra who is involved in many corruptions and murders ... At the bjp side it is dr sukanta majumder who has a clean outlook and did a lot of development in the area

  • @sankalp6872
    @sankalp68722 ай бұрын

    I get the feel that, 2024-29, if it happens, will be the BREAK or MAKE term for the BJP. Either the party will sink under its own weight or the crop of new leaders like Annamalai, Yogi, Fadnavis (sadly, a pale shadow of his former self), and Bandi Sanjay will take the party to new heights. A strong Modi euphoria, discredited opposition and a potent Hindutva ideology cannot insulate the party beyond a point. BJP is far from being the Congress of the 1950-89. In fact, another 2014 and 2019 like COLLAPSE will force the Congress to implement structural changes. If the party faces another rout, the Gandhis would have some serious questions to answer.

  • @pp_01123

    @pp_01123

    2 ай бұрын

    Fadnavis capability will be checked in next elections. Yogi can't throw Jumla and thus can't shift huge voters from his clout (Although he may become biggest by sidelining Shah), he handles law and order well (except judicial killings) but lacks vision. Annamalai is froth! As person from North India our news channels potray him as big leader but in down south he is nothing. Without Modi he can't even pull 5% voting share this LS (nor other two BJP TN Ex-Chiefs can)

  • @libshastra

    @libshastra

    2 ай бұрын

    I doubt it would split. The BJP didn't split under Advani, it will less likely split after Modi. I think everyone in the BJP realizes this is a make or break election and I don't think they will let it go that easily. But yes, BJP needs to invest in maintain some level of continuity in the organization - keep producing good leaders, campaigners etc.

  • @surajs5913

    @surajs5913

    2 ай бұрын

    Lol the gandis will claim no responsibility and continue doing their business. They have no ideology, no vision but great sense of entitlement. They will remain even if it is just 1 seat for rahul gandi...

  • @sankalp6872

    @sankalp6872

    2 ай бұрын

    @@libshastra I nver said that the BJP will split. I am merely commenting on its inorganic growth. Maharashtra, Haryana, Assam, and WB are states where BJP has grown through LBOs and defections. The enthusiasm for BJP in Telanagana appears natural. UP revival was nothing short of a miracle and pure Modi-Shah magic. 2024-29 would be real test by fire for the BJP. Natural decay would party many of its state Govts at risk. So I want to see who will remain and who will exit.

  • @dukhi_aatma372

    @dukhi_aatma372

    2 ай бұрын

    Recent RG statement makes Congress strategy (or mindset) very clear. They are just waiting for Modi to retire, and they believe that they'll eventually return to power. As of now, just hang around for sometime. So I don't think Gandhis will answer any questions. Not in 2024, neither in 2029.

  • @sathvikreddy2106
    @sathvikreddy21062 ай бұрын

    From Telangana , Tandra Vinod Rao was originally from bjp and the photo is of BRS candidate from Karimnagar 😂! Both ways you were wrong !

  • @jithinpoliyedathmohanan7237
    @jithinpoliyedathmohanan72372 ай бұрын

    BJP human resources group are very good they are different thing for different people..capitalism for corporates,Strong leader for Nationalist, Washing machine for corrupt politicians,’ true’ Hindu for religious people

  • @sumeshp.s1644

    @sumeshp.s1644

    Ай бұрын

    BJP are good HR manager ? nice one

  • @jauhariakash
    @jauhariakash2 ай бұрын

    Not sure on your definition of greenfield and brownfield. Generally it's used in context of market or area of operations. Greenfield is new area, like TN or Kerela for BJP, and brownfield is growth in existing market like WB or MH for BJP.

  • @bindurao3463
    @bindurao34632 ай бұрын

    It is about weakening the opposition

  • @sleepingduty2987

    @sleepingduty2987

    2 ай бұрын

    who is he really weakening the party or the ideology? Because the people with different ideology are coming in no problem.

  • @MaestroAms

    @MaestroAms

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@sleepingduty2987Nothing is permanent in politics

  • @kakun63

    @kakun63

    2 ай бұрын

    @@MaestroAms besides ideology

  • @jaypatel7189
    @jaypatel71892 ай бұрын

    Award winning excellent analysis n commentary !

  • @aryavarta2047
    @aryavarta20472 ай бұрын

    Useless episode. Tomorrow lallantop will make an episode on how many The Print employees are earlier with other media houses. What matters to viewers or voters is final output. That's it. If a Shezad Poonawala or a Himanta can be used better in a BJP set up, it doesn't matter to us.

  • @rajkumarganesan9417

    @rajkumarganesan9417

    2 ай бұрын

    Rightly said brother

  • @sumeshp.s1644

    @sumeshp.s1644

    Ай бұрын

    Come work with us for the Nation - BJP

  • @satgubi
    @satgubi2 ай бұрын

    What exactly is the clutter in this CTC?

  • @AshwinMaloo79
    @AshwinMaloo792 ай бұрын

    Dhanyavad 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @siddharthg8134
    @siddharthg81342 ай бұрын

    Why Maharashtra analysis is skipped?

  • @AshokKumar-hs4tn
    @AshokKumar-hs4tn2 ай бұрын

    Even at this age the man works extremely hard, wish him long 18:13 years on media horizon

  • @indianatlarge
    @indianatlarge2 ай бұрын

    It is not just winnability it is spendabililty

  • @girish6064
    @girish60642 ай бұрын

    Thanks

  • @dukhi_aatma372
    @dukhi_aatma3722 ай бұрын

    I have observed in this LS 2024 elections, BJP is relying more on negative campaigning against the opposition as against previous two terms where it ran a positive campaign highlighting its own achievements and what it will be achieving in coming years. Not sure where this restlessness comes from.

  • @chandankumarchand6686

    @chandankumarchand6686

    2 ай бұрын

    Now BJP is acting like a dukhi aatma😂😂

  • @rajkumarganesan9417

    @rajkumarganesan9417

    2 ай бұрын

    "Restlessness" nice coinage of words. It means that the BJP sees no light at the end of the tunnel - but a cyclonic defeat.

  • @smoraes3655
    @smoraes36552 ай бұрын

    Not heard from the opposition parties telling voters not to elect defectors. Every politician should have top priority in their campaign

  • @AmitKumarAlphaX
    @AmitKumarAlphaX2 ай бұрын

    CONGRESS MUKT BHARAT BANANE CHALE THE, CONGRESS YUKT BJP BANA DIYA!!😂😂😂

  • @sajalkumarmandal6659

    @sajalkumarmandal6659

    2 ай бұрын

    be happy about this 😂 there are big game after election you will understand this

  • @impedimenta934

    @impedimenta934

    2 ай бұрын

    @@sajalkumarmandal6659 every move of supreme leader and his side kick is a master move!

  • @akssssss777

    @akssssss777

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@impedimenta934 Definitely. Atleast the master is on merit unlike yours who is your supreme leader because of his family 😅😅

  • @gauravshah89

    @gauravshah89

    2 ай бұрын

    Now that BJP is Congress yukt , you support BJP?

  • @impedimenta934

    @impedimenta934

    2 ай бұрын

    @@akssssss777 I am not surprised by your presumption that I support him, it's expected of the simpletons. Merit? C'mon! use your brain if you're still able to, after years of numbing it with fantasies and propaganda.

  • @satish918
    @satish9182 ай бұрын

    👍 G8 choice of issue and analysis by SG after a long time. The data on the proportion of defectors in UP is an eye opener 👀 It would have been even more insightful if the defectors with criminal cases, like Janardhan Reddy in Karnataka, were highlighted as evidence of the depths of shameless opportunism that the BJP can stoop down to 🧎 This video should be shared with all "Andh Bhakts" who believe that the "Modi wave" is a pan india phenomenon, and that corruption in high places has really declined.

  • @nagaiahgovindarajalu8110
    @nagaiahgovindarajalu81102 ай бұрын

    your are best of all in reporting since for more than a decade

  • @karthikpandirla807
    @karthikpandirla8072 ай бұрын

    Sir the photo you posted as T vinod rao ar 16:49 is not the person who joined BJP Telangana. As a fact bjp's vinod rao is notba defector, he was an active member of RSS who recently joined BJP. The photo you posted is also vinod rao who is a close friend of kcr and lost the karimnagar mp sear to bjp in 2019. He is still working in BRS party

  • @manishgadia
    @manishgadia2 ай бұрын

    Shekhar Sir- Can u one do cut the clutter on Indian areas or earlier buffers occupied by china in ladakh post 2021 still?

  • @shockwaveXstream
    @shockwaveXstream2 ай бұрын

    all the BJP fanboys getting butt hurt- i like modi when he came, but shekar is as neutral as it gets, if u guys cant take any negative opinions about him(modi), then worship him, no problem. But for me he is the servant of the people, who we elected to do what i expected & we can criticize a govt. for what i feel they didnt do or did wrong.

  • @7hills812

    @7hills812

    2 ай бұрын

    SG is ‘neutral’ - taking ‘un-hyphenated’ joke a bit too seriously!! 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

  • @gauravshah89

    @gauravshah89

    2 ай бұрын

    He is not servant of people. He is servant of bharatiya civilization. All the traditions and Values of our ancestors. If today all people become slaves of an Arab man, (like in pakistan) modi will still remain servant of Indian civilization only.

  • @scienceaffairs2919

    @scienceaffairs2919

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@gauravshah89aare bolna kya chahte ho

  • @rchennuru
    @rchennuru2 ай бұрын

    Good analysis.

  • @umeshshah5431
    @umeshshah54312 ай бұрын

    Sirji, You missed to name Navin Jindal who got the ticket within few hours of joining BJP

  • @himarsingh6522
    @himarsingh65222 ай бұрын

    Worth the wait, thank you Shekhar.

  • @ThePrintIndia

    @ThePrintIndia

    2 ай бұрын

    Thank you, Himar. I'm glad you liked this episode. Thank you also for appreciating and supporting our journalism...best wishes, Shekhar

  • @kannanpugazhendhi9153
    @kannanpugazhendhi91532 ай бұрын

    Gonna backfire for sure....

  • @SantSharma-zb4ug
    @SantSharma-zb4ug2 ай бұрын

    Excellent analysis. This is what journalism is all about. This is how it should be. The RSS completes 100 years next year. May be by then, over 25% of BJP's MPs will have nothing to do with its ideology.

  • @Natarajan4262
    @Natarajan42622 ай бұрын

    Excellent narrative.

  • @sri2017
    @sri20172 ай бұрын

    T. Vinod rao image shown wrong

  • @sachingadage2306
    @sachingadage23062 ай бұрын

    Sir, see some non correspondence between two op-eds. This article differs from your opinion article titled "7 takeaways from BJP's list of 405 & yet..."

  • @kaushikvarsani4053
    @kaushikvarsani40532 ай бұрын

    Why doesn't print tell that many of the defectors are because of ED.

  • @ganeshdore
    @ganeshdore2 ай бұрын

    Shekhar Ji ...Gatbandhan means no more 3 way contests... thus changes have to made by Nadda sahib.

  • @VB-ff7sk
    @VB-ff7sk2 ай бұрын

    It appears as if BJP has become a Corporate "poaching" "talents" from everywhere !!!

  • @rajkumarganesan9417

    @rajkumarganesan9417

    2 ай бұрын

    Rightly said brother . Poaching done with the help of Agencies. Not with Ideological mindset. But how long. It reflects that the BJP is. getting weaker. Around 22 nominated candidates of. BJP - politely said " no thanks I don't want to contest". What does it show. . Except Telugu Desam, there heavy wait parties in the NDA. I could see only Letter Pad parties . I don't have a ground reality to speak about the Hindi Heartland politics. But the ground reality in the 5 Southern Peninsula States speaks this way. " Not more than 10 seats for the BJP". And that she would be a NOTA party in all the 4 states, except Karnataka Moral is that Media tycoons hiccups, never win elections and only the ground reality speaks the hidden truth

  • @sumeshp.s1644

    @sumeshp.s1644

    Ай бұрын

    @@rajkumarganesan9417 BJP got more seats than Congress in 2019!

  • @sumeshp.s1644

    @sumeshp.s1644

    Ай бұрын

    @@rajkumarganesan9417 BJP got more seats from South India than Congress in 2019! For BJP except Karnataka , there are strong regional parties , be it Kerala - CPM, TN - DMK & ADMK....

  • @amar1584
    @amar15842 ай бұрын

    I think you guys might have missed 1-2 defectors from your list.

  • @sudheerkumarpaidimarri5104
    @sudheerkumarpaidimarri51042 ай бұрын

    Dear The print while speaking about BRS you showed B. Vinod Kumar's photo in place of Vinod Rao. B. vinod kumar is contesting for MP Karimnagar constituency from BRS party

  • @PrashanthPuranik
    @PrashanthPuranik2 ай бұрын

    Superb strategy by the BJP. BJP Andhbhakts do not care who is fielded - they may have completely different ideology and may be corrupt. It’s ok as long as they wear the lotus. As you said, if BJP fields a lamp post, they will all vote for the lamp post 😂 additionally the defectors bring in their own vote bank. This strategy basically banks on the fact that not one BJP Andhbhakt will vote for another party just because a defector is fielded 😄 💯 marks to the BJP for strategy

  • @ab20037

    @ab20037

    2 ай бұрын

    Same like how gulams vote in name of Gandhi family

  • @PrashanthPuranik

    @PrashanthPuranik

    2 ай бұрын

    @@ab20037 how sad that Andhbhakts have been reduced to the same kind of people they oppose. You become what you hate with all your heart. How true!

  • @ab20037

    @ab20037

    2 ай бұрын

    @@PrashanthPuranik There is big difference now we are voting for Modi now next we will not voter for Modi son next We will vote for the guy who leads our ideology Not like you who voted Indira Gandhi Rajeev Gandhi & now Rahul Gandhi just because they were Nehru family

  • @PrashanthPuranik

    @PrashanthPuranik

    2 ай бұрын

    @@ab20037 I am laughing in a corner as you have proved my original message correct 🤣🤣🤣 I rest my case.

  • @ASNJKM
    @ASNJKM2 ай бұрын

    Defectors have been struck with ED (Erectile Dysfunction). Please pray for their speedy recovery and retirement from politics so that they can rest and improve their health.

  • @chandangowda2341
    @chandangowda23412 ай бұрын

    Make video about DK Suresh vs dr Manjunath for mp election

  • @rajanbalasubramanian
    @rajanbalasubramanian2 ай бұрын

    Definitions of Brownfield and Greenfield are completely wrong. Brownfield is not acquisition but where you expand into areas where you are already experienced. Greenfield is when industry goes into completely unchartered territory. It could be a new geographical area or new type of activity. For BJP induction of Mr Jaishankar and Mr. H S Puri in ministry may be at best considered Greenfield

  • @kanchanchakraborty5
    @kanchanchakraborty52 ай бұрын

    Good

  • @memaze29
    @memaze292 ай бұрын

    In a corporation, the way for growth is mergers and acquisitions. A political party can also grow that way so that wherever they are strong, they enhance their chances by mergers, and where they are weak, they do it by acquisition.

  • @srinum6774
    @srinum67742 ай бұрын

    What will BJP do, if they get 300 including 50% of the defectors? Can the defectors be loyal? It’s a bad strategy ! We simply can’t afford for BJP to lose, I cannot even imagine the disaster if INDI alliance wins !

  • @inthevoidreality

    @inthevoidreality

    2 ай бұрын

    Yeahh 100% defectors can never be trusted. But we have Himant Biswas Sharma who is a top quality CM, and Jyotiraditya Scindia who is doing an excellent job for aviation

  • @navinambastha1253
    @navinambastha12532 ай бұрын

    BJP why dont take Ovessi brothers and Afzal Ansari too.

  • @eyeinfinite27

    @eyeinfinite27

    2 ай бұрын

    They will join 72

  • @veerakumar8033
    @veerakumar80332 ай бұрын

    Same brown field is happening in congress also

  • @saanvi08
    @saanvi082 ай бұрын

    Green field is something new, right from scratch. Brownfield is on the lease of another setup.

  • @user-sj6eu8sp9v
    @user-sj6eu8sp9v2 ай бұрын

    Dear Shekhar, this is more of curious question than rhetorical. Why do we go over lists? I watch Cut The Clutter to gain a more high-level understanding of the topics you choose. What am I missing here?

  • @FloraFauna321

    @FloraFauna321

    2 ай бұрын

    Absolutely agree. Reading out a list is meaningless and a waste of time. One expects more from a senior like SG. Hope he reflects on this point.

  • @deepankars5957
    @deepankars59572 ай бұрын

    There was no ‘cut the clutter’; only narration of stats

  • @RajSadagopan
    @RajSadagopan2 ай бұрын

    Political organization has become like corporate organisation. People switch organisation when they find opportunities in alternate party. We should not talk about these movements as defections. Another aspect from a party point of view is winnability and without ability to come to power the party can not serve the people/ nation. If an employee of Print find better opportunity in another competition outfit he may shift to the competition.

  • @muralidharars
    @muralidharars2 ай бұрын

    Many of the defectors are returnees as well i think

  • @sachingadage2306
    @sachingadage23062 ай бұрын

    Considering Congress Manifesto, it appears bringing in 116 new faces from outside appears long-term strategic error. Considering projects parlance, brownfields are tricky, legacy issues are sometimes quicksands.

  • @relaxedleisure4766
    @relaxedleisure4766Ай бұрын

    While most defectors come for opportunistic reasons, some do come for ideological reasons. A perfect example is Himanta Sarma, who came from the INC in 2015 and is not a secularist or a “Muslim appeaser” to say the least…. Milind Deora who joined the Shiv Sena earlier this year also had a significantly more nationalistic record than most other INC members of the Lok Sabha and probably remained there the this long because he didn’t want to disappoint his father.

  • @codemonk1999
    @codemonk19992 ай бұрын

    It is too sad to see people who worked for a party for years didn't get their fair right to be a candidate, an outsider gets to enjoy the fruits of his/her hard work and dedication. Hopefully voters will stick to their ideology and vote for their own benefit.

  • @ErmaLante
    @ErmaLante2 ай бұрын

    The Loyalty Trap: Why Kind People Often Get Hurt Ellen J. Barrier says, "Loyalty is a characteristic trait. Those who have it, give it freely." But what about the cost of unwavering loyalty? Loyal people are essential, but sometimes they are the target of those who see their kindness as a weakness. Being loyal is a strength, but we also need to be smart. Don't let your loyalty be blind. #loyalty #kindness #betrayal #opportunist

  • @sgbgl
    @sgbgl2 ай бұрын

    I have understood your argument! Why similar arguments are made against opposition

  • @rajajjchiramel7565
    @rajajjchiramel75652 ай бұрын

    Good morning Sir

  • @DevKumar-cv3yp
    @DevKumar-cv3yp2 ай бұрын

    Its elections fever. So sekar in safe game, to hold his name.. 😂😂😂.. From "G tag"media" to Proffesional "editor in chief "😂😂😂

  • @Rameshkrishnan22
    @Rameshkrishnan222 ай бұрын

    Shekarji point to note is the type of acquisitions. The way Congress acquired Sidhu. It was a disaster for Congress. Hiring the right resources is more critical than just hiring.

  • @bha3265

    @bha3265

    2 ай бұрын

    Oh now it's called hiring

  • @bhiwaji
    @bhiwaji2 ай бұрын

    Great analysis by shekhar sir, just one suggestion. Please don't call them talent.

  • @rahulrajsingh1672
    @rahulrajsingh16722 ай бұрын

    Being a bjp supporter I must say shekar Gupta is the most neutral journalist,true journalist

  • @akashchaturvedi7995

    @akashchaturvedi7995

    2 ай бұрын

    Chal jhuttha

  • @introvert_2023

    @introvert_2023

    2 ай бұрын

    I can say he and Barkha Dutt are far better and more logical than the rest.

  • @shishirsks

    @shishirsks

    2 ай бұрын

    No man! Unlike the openly leftwing media, Theprint is smart, they play their left bias very subtly and silently!

  • @rajbaniwal3236

    @rajbaniwal3236

    2 ай бұрын

    He knows that all his views come from RW audience so he has toned down his anti RW rhetoric. But he carefully embeds LW propaganda by using words like “RSS indoctrinated cadre” and tried saying that BJP is stressing on winnability and has let go of ideology. These are subtle ways to make RW audience distrust the BJP and swing to the Left.

  • @ranjitinamdar

    @ranjitinamdar

    2 ай бұрын

    This is a good point. However it may honestly be in his subconscious mind rather than a plot.

  • @ab20037
    @ab200372 ай бұрын

    Defectors are not problem but they must have good leadership Like Himanta, Shezad poonawala, Power hungry politicians must not be brought even ultra corrupt people are not worth it is giving negative image of party

  • @amarsrivastava3790
    @amarsrivastava37902 ай бұрын

    Background goes with the kind of journalism 😂 just for fun 🤞🏻😜

  • @BotswanaThabo
    @BotswanaThabo2 ай бұрын

    There is always at least once Azan howling in his background 😂

  • @dsouzan1
    @dsouzan12 ай бұрын

    Considering those who defected in the last 2 elections and this list, i guess BJP must be having about 40% to 50% outsiders in active politics. I think it's their way of creating a party that can stand the test of time and give them space to create internal leaders. During a fast paced expansion its always difficult for any organisation to produce large no of leaders from within, and this happens in corporates also. Existing members do get a feeling of not getting opportunities, but its also for them to introspect if they really have the capability and capacity to take on large roles. Especially in politics where both capability and gift of the gab matter. There are many existing members who have let their tongues loose, something a person in politics defenitely needs to think about thrice before opening their mouths to say something.

  • @rajeshbnarasimha934
    @rajeshbnarasimha9342 ай бұрын

    I have been following him sicne many years and I swear I couldn't complete wathing his whole videos because of his presentation. This guy used too many analogies and makes me lose the context. To make us understand his analogy, he literally explains the technicalities of the analogy his used. Rather he could have used few idioms and phrases to keep his point focussed and strong.

  • @vramana2011
    @vramana20112 ай бұрын

    Guptaji talks like a school teacher.

  • @shivambajpayee5801
    @shivambajpayee58012 ай бұрын

    Brownfield is when you keep shitting across the field😂

  • @narayanan5804
    @narayanan58042 ай бұрын

    During BJP greenfield phase, you presstitutes were trolling them as communal

  • @senrohit1
    @senrohit12 ай бұрын

    I think organic and inorganic growth more represents what bjp is doing that greenfield / brownfield 😀😀😀

  • @anand288050
    @anand2880502 ай бұрын

    Who is here after Druv Rathee video. Why s.gupta is not bold enough to oppose things that are suppressing the democracy of this country. Talking on general topic is ok. But voicing out for the general public is all about journalism that matters. Defending Congress when Congress is in power is not the actual journalism. Hope you read my comment.

  • @007skumarajay

    @007skumarajay

    2 ай бұрын

    German shepherd

  • @suniltimothy429

    @suniltimothy429

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@007skumarajay Yes, shepherding everyone in the right direction.

  • @legoooo09

    @legoooo09

    2 ай бұрын

    He's APP party member, so doesn't hold much value in neutral voters eyes.

  • @bha3265

    @bha3265

    2 ай бұрын

    Are u expecting from Shekhar..who was once a true journalist has become sanghi..he is English speaking bhakt

  • @bha3265

    @bha3265

    2 ай бұрын

    @@007skumarajayand u gobar chap

  • @revathisegar8268
    @revathisegar82682 ай бұрын

    So the party has become Bhartiya congress janata party 😂

  • @tanmayparmar2208
    @tanmayparmar22082 ай бұрын

    Namaste sir

  • @sunderj4774
    @sunderj47745 күн бұрын

    Mr Shekhar Gupta must understand Politics in India is also modelled on the lines of I.P.L. where political workers are traded on the basis of their oratory cunningness and money they bring to the their parties All analysis on Politics are Bunkum.

  • @chanakyabharat756
    @chanakyabharat7562 ай бұрын

    Lol CM Ramesh is not taken, he presented himself 😂😂😂

  • @puiachhangte4784
    @puiachhangte478424 күн бұрын

    Brownfield= washing machine. Period

  • @biluvarghese6371
    @biluvarghese63712 ай бұрын

    What a wonderful world😍

  • @Sk-cr2bl
    @Sk-cr2bl2 ай бұрын

    This shows BJP-RSS is going to loss .....that can be seen on the face of Modi...🤣😂😂🤣🤣

  • @neilbhatt7096

    @neilbhatt7096

    2 ай бұрын

    mandbuddhi like papppu

  • @adityajekkula1593

    @adityajekkula1593

    2 ай бұрын

    Katte lulli spotted

  • @suniltimothy429

    @suniltimothy429

    2 ай бұрын

    ​@@neilbhatt7096 Yes, unlike the jhumla 'mujhe credit nahi chahiye '

  • @neilbhatt7096

    @neilbhatt7096

    2 ай бұрын

    @@suniltimothy429 your torment will be infinite when results come out in June. The credit given by the public will be too soreful to bear. For a lot of old Congressi butt hurts, their second half of life has nothing but agony and torment. They will take it to the grave but a lifespan shortened by the agony of hate comes as a huge rescue.

  • @ab20037

    @ab20037

    2 ай бұрын

    This means BJP is very serious in getting 400 Whereas Cong is sleeping & may not cross even 50

  • @premtiwari3161
    @premtiwari31612 ай бұрын

    India deserves to be administered by the best talent available in the country. BJP is doing the right thing.

  • @azzeyify
    @azzeyify2 ай бұрын

    When people joined congress u said nothing.

  • @khanlatifahmed
    @khanlatifahmed2 ай бұрын

    BJP is loosing this time. People are fed up with BJP and there has been no major change in Economy. Further the electoral bonds has really put a big blot on BJP. I heard BJP workers doubting their top leaders and blaming them with corruption..You can see there is no Euphoria that was in 2014 or 2019... BJP may go well down 200..

  • @shankares388

    @shankares388

    2 ай бұрын

    🤣🤣🤣why are you secularists so predictable- BJP owes a lot you guys to make them win. Always religious fanaticism with shameless hypocrisy

  • @sleepingduty2987

    @sleepingduty2987

    2 ай бұрын

    @@shankares388 read what you wrote again and look up fanaticism.

  • @shankares388

    @shankares388

    2 ай бұрын

    @@sleepingduty2987i did and still same thing about secularists. If I was a fanatic I will not vote or oppose in the name of religion nor preach in the guise of secularism. So F

  • @sleepingduty2987

    @sleepingduty2987

    2 ай бұрын

    @@shankares388 now read it again.

  • @yrt1761

    @yrt1761

    2 ай бұрын

    When a mullah comments no one gives a shit about it, not even another mullaha

  • @suryanarayanananjangaudkri9521
    @suryanarayanananjangaudkri95212 ай бұрын

    Abrahamic religions are also engaged in accepting defectors from any sect. When religions do it rampantly ,then whats wrong in a political party doing the same. I dont see any difference.

  • @loktantra2020
    @loktantra20202 ай бұрын

    List is a fool of loop holes, how does anybody who has spent more than 5 years in BJP can be called as defactors. Now the list has sarwanand sonewal,now that is commedy he is in BJP from 2014. Defectors are those who have spent less than 5 years and have changed sides for current election

  • @chittaranjansingha2217
    @chittaranjansingha22172 ай бұрын

    Wah Guptaji wah, immoral acquisitions were never given such a great name 'brownfield expansion'.

  • @user-eh8qy1rs5b
    @user-eh8qy1rs5b2 ай бұрын

    Ideology today is Modi's charisma why other parties individuals join BJP sure of winning

  • @Jun_kid
    @Jun_kid2 ай бұрын

    RSS "indoctrination"?? Gupta ji, please choose your words carefully. Terrorists are "indoctrinateioned". Prisoners are indoctrinated. Maoists are indoctrinated. Patriots are raised. RSS are full blown PATRIOTS. Meet and talk to them. Anyway -- *Ayega to Modi hi*

  • @abhinav5847

    @abhinav5847

    2 ай бұрын

    RSS also indocrinates if you think otherwise either you have never met them or you are indoctrinated yourself.

  • @AmitKumarAlphaX

    @AmitKumarAlphaX

    2 ай бұрын

    NO, RSS GUYS ARE INDOCTRINATED ONLY. THE FACT IS THAT RSS IS THE ONLY ORGANISATION IN THE COUNTRY THAT HAS A RECORD OF HAVING THE HIGHEST NUMBER OF RIOTEERS AGAINST WHOM COURT PROCEEDINGS ARE ALREADY ONGOING. IT OBJECTIVELY SHOWS THAT RSS IS INVOLVED IN HIGHEST NUMBER OF RIOTS.

  • @essvecan73

    @essvecan73

    2 ай бұрын

    This guy is indoctrinated by communists and corrupt congress - so he is not able to digest BJPs success

  • @AmitKumarAlphaX

    @AmitKumarAlphaX

    2 ай бұрын

    RSS IS AN ANTI-NATIONAL OUTFIT TRYING TO BREAK INDIAN SOCIETY IN THE NAME OF RELIGION.

  • @AmitKumarAlphaX

    @AmitKumarAlphaX

    2 ай бұрын

    SHARAB GHOTALE KA EK MUKHYA AAROPI SHARATH CHANDRA REDDY SE MODI NE 60 KAROD LIYA AUR DUSRE MUKHYA AAROPI RAGHAV REDDY KO NDA SE MP CANDIDATE BANAYA. PAR JAIL ME MODI KO NAHI, KEJRIWAL KO DALA JAA RAHA HAI!! ELECTORAL BOND SCAM KA KING PIN MODI NE ED KE ZARIYE COMPANYON SE 2800 KAROD KA CHANDAA WASOOLI KIYA PAR JAIL ME OPPOSITION KE LEADERS KO DALA JAA RAHA HAI!! YE TANASHAHI NAHI TO KYA HAI???DESHDROHI PATRAKAR ISME BHRASTACHARI PM KO DEFEND KAR RAHE HAIN AUR DESH KE UPAR TANASHAHI LAAD RAHE HAIN. BHARAT MATA KE UPAR TANASHAHI LAADNE WALE SARE GODI CHAMCHAANDU PATRAKAR IS PAAP ME BHAGIDAAR HAIN.😏😏😏😏😏

  • @yaruingamawungshi7708
    @yaruingamawungshi77082 ай бұрын

    So indian political parties have become a corporate group. 😂😂😂 This shows how low the standard of politics has gone down

  • @menoncrc322
    @menoncrc3222 ай бұрын

    This defections r under compulsion/ coercion/ arms twisting/ through engaging ED,IT,CBI etc

  • @chandankumarchand6686
    @chandankumarchand66862 ай бұрын

    It is a good strategy for BJP to strengthen itself in regions where they are not very strong...as long as the top central leadership are ideologically commited and not corrupt everything is good.. No party can be 100 percent good...if one have to defeat crooks like sharad pawar,. Uddhav thakre and lalu yadav everything is justified.

  • @FloraFauna321
    @FloraFauna3212 ай бұрын

    Taking the corporate analogy ahead... What matters is ensured success and risk mitigation. Having built a formidable brand called Modi which commands a large and loyal base BJP knows that this vote base will not vote for anyone else. They will vote for Modi endorsed candidate whether home grown or acquired. The strategy here is to acquire a new voter base that the incoming candidates bring along. These are people who would otherwise not vote for BJP. So this is a strategy to be applauded ratehr than frowned upon. The issues to be addressed subsequently are ensuring this acquired talent gets assimilated into the BJP culture and inhouse talent that got sidelined due to the acquired talent is pacified and given other opportunities. In politics there is nothing called PURE ideology. Winning is important. Delivery on agenda is only possible by winning.

  • @mujtabalokhandwala6745
    @mujtabalokhandwala67452 ай бұрын

    I pity the BJP karyakartas, who spent a lifetime of volunteering and are now being used for sweeping the floor and rolling the carpets for the defectors, who will now boss over them! What a wastage of sheer dedication! 😢

  • @rajbaniwal3236
    @rajbaniwal32362 ай бұрын

    He knows that all his views come from RW audience so he has toned down his anti RW rhetoric. But he carefully embeds LW propaganda by using words like “RSS indoctrinated cadre” and tried saying that BJP is stressing on winnability and has let go of ideology. These are subtle ways to make RW audience distrust the BJP and swing to the Left.

  • @apexmemator7239

    @apexmemator7239

    2 ай бұрын

    These Congress lapdogs will never change…as soon as they will see BJP weakening they will again go full throttle on woke propaganda😂

  • @sleepingduty2987

    @sleepingduty2987

    2 ай бұрын

    We found him people. We've found the really smart one over here. Gather around, hear here what he has to say.

  • @rajbaniwal3236

    @rajbaniwal3236

    2 ай бұрын

    @@sleepingduty2987 Okay.

  • @DevKumar-cv3yp
    @DevKumar-cv3yp2 ай бұрын

    Green field(cow dung). Brown field (💩)..🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️

Келесі