Thanks for showing us that Chat GPT isn't going to replace human created music any time soon.

@boratsagdiev6486

Жыл бұрын

Soon in AI terms is 6-12 months

@JMLRecording

Жыл бұрын

@@boratsagdiev6486 exactly. A joke rooted in truth.

@TilMayne

Жыл бұрын

Hey i see Mr Smith agents here 😑 nothing to acknowledge..

@commodoor6549

Жыл бұрын

@@boratsagdiev6486 AI isn't the same as ChatGPT. ChatGPT in its current iteration is a language AI... music would take more of a math machine learning, and highly nuanced; MIDI does not mean musical. AI sure, sooner or later it seems likely it can emulate human musical creativity and production, but ChatGPT? Highly doubtful.

@commodoor6549

Жыл бұрын

@@TilMayne

Your channel will be huge soon..... The amount of work put in is obvious.... All the best buddy

Man, what a fun and enjoyable video to watch! It must have taken a lot of work to make it. Congratulations!

@Blav2

Жыл бұрын

botted comment

@arquivosbackup1720

Жыл бұрын

@@Blav2 what?

@MichelBarbaro

Жыл бұрын

@@Blav2 shut up!😂🤷‍♂

Not only was this interesting, but i like your format, the ai voice reactions were a really nice touch

The amount of effort n time to explain what you want to chatGTP, complie, export, import e.t.c. you could've written something 1000 times better

@jantuitman

Жыл бұрын

Edison should have never invented the record player because all the time it took him to get the first record, he could have studied and played some very complex piano pieces in that time 😅. In other words, once you have a pipeline from AI to DAW you can run it over and over and over and over again and really start working on making the AI better at music, so it is no big deal that it takes a bit longer for the first pieces.

@vasoskyriakides

Жыл бұрын

@@jantuitman so playing an instrument and creating is the same as listening to music (the record player fallacy is hilarious)? Wow thanx for the insight 🤣👌 Also instead of spending so much time to make ChatGTP better at music, here's a thought, spend that time to make YOURSELF better in music? food for thought...

@jantuitman

Жыл бұрын

@@vasoskyriakides I agree that it is a good idea to get involved yourself with the music. But this doesn’t contradict the fact that it can be fun and interesting to use AI for making that music, as AI can help you teach musical concepts you don’t know yet yourself, or you can write music together with the AI, or you can have the AI generate accompaniments, and so on. There are tons of creative possibilities. Unfortunately it is also quite possible to do soulless things with AI, like generate a lot of dumb music that isn’t very deep and listen to that and mistake it for the real thing….

@jantuitman

Жыл бұрын

@@vasoskyriakides also I don’t get why you call the record player example a fallacy. It seems to me very probable that people were on average better music performers before the invention of record players because they all had to sing and play their own music. But that doesn’t mean that there is no place for record players in this world and I don’t think I prefer a culture where you have to learn about all music by going to people who know them over a culture where music can be transmitted through mediums. Yes, there is always something that gets lost when new inventions are being made. But for the things that are lost, new things come into place that are also interesting.

@vasoskyriakides

Жыл бұрын

@@jantuitman I don't think we disagree as much as you think. I do enjoy using it as a tool to improve my workflow. But at the end of the day it's a tool. U might know the difference and me too but I believe most people will use it in a lazy way and there's a possibility music might become boring and recycled. I guess we'll have to wait n see. Also record players are primarily used to listen, in a sense Record players did the opposite of what you're saying cause it encouraged people to learn music to make n sell records. If you used the synthesiser as an example which is more a creative tool that disrupted the way we write (arpeggiators, LFO's e.t.c.) it would've made more sense to me

This video does the internet justice. Made for it. Nice editing and meme tidbits from the archives. Good stuff. Keep it up.

@Blav2

Жыл бұрын

botted comment

Este es uno de los videos más creativos que he visto en toda mi vida. Mis respetos para ti compa.

@ArchivosPC

Жыл бұрын

exacto

Your narrations are 🔥and you know it

@nobodyandthecomputer

Жыл бұрын

hey noumenAI, yeah u know, spicing up the narration with a pinch of salt and a dash of pepper, I'm making it a lively experience! Let's toss the solemnity aside and have ourselves a good time.

This can work exceptionally well for Ableton. Their audio to MIDI is one of the best in the industry. If they go about integrating AI to it, and people provide a reference track, Ableton live can maybe generate similar chords progressions and stuff.

@askulkingfox

Жыл бұрын

I'd love to see it, but there's a lot of hate for AI among producers it seems. If Ableton doesn't have the appetite maybe someone like Bitwig or Serato will.

@yashgarg.official

Жыл бұрын

@@askulkingfox yeah but there's no other way around. Everybody will need to adapt to AI. I think we can see AI as more like a way to delegate boring work. For people who want to do boring work tho in this age of automating work, I don't know what to say to them lol.

@itube027

Жыл бұрын

The road to hell is paved with good intentions.

@ontheruntonowhere

Жыл бұрын

@@askulkingfox They'll get over it.

@MrJamesC

Жыл бұрын

@@yashgarg.official Of course, everyone has to adapt to AI, but the question is to what extent. It's disrespectful to an artist whose music you like to just let an AI imitate it to benefit yourself without lifting a finger. Besides, it doesn't matter what you personally find boring or not. There are people who are bored by almost everything - should they have the last word? Finding chord progressions is not repetitive and not boring for a real musician. Don't you want to live in a society where craft and human creativity are rewarded? You will not only be a profiteer, but also a victim. You won't be able to build anything for yourself if everyone who feels the mood can imitate your music without any effort.

Well, music composition is still In its infancy, but as we’ve seen photorealistic, images and 3-D images are coming along quite well

An artificial intelligence will never make a song that makes the person feel the emotion from the bottom of the Soul because an artificial intelligence will never know what it's like to feel the music! There are even human beings who make music and don't even feel the sound they are making, let alone a computerized artificial intelligence, they will never be, because to make music that sends shivers down your spine, you have to do it with your heart, with the soul!

@stridergaara

Жыл бұрын

Acho que a questão não é se é feito com o coração ou não. Mesmo sendo uma máquina gerando códigos e automatizando tarefas, ainda existe o fator humano por trás dos processos. Será cataclísmico quando uma máquina programar outra máquina para criar arte, eliminando 100% o fator humano. Por ora, esse é provavelmente um daqueles sinais de que atravessamos uma era em que tudo precisa ser ressignificado, até mesmo a forma como consumimos/apreciamos arte. Aliás, em termos musicais, quantos padrões melódicos e rítmicos surgiram nos últimos 20 (ou mesmo 50) anos em grandes obras que se assemelham ou se referem a outras? Não havia uma máquina por trás de cada composição ditando como deveria ser, mas já havia uma fórmula matemática da qual uma indústria cultural se apropriou por muito tempo, transformando a expectativa de criatividade em produto de consumo de massa. A IA como mera ferramenta talvez seja uma aceleração excessiva do processo. O mesmo impacto e a mesma discussão surgiram quando a fotografia e o cinema chegaram em tempos em que a apreciação se concentrava nos quadros de pintura. Hoje a pintura e a arte fotográfica convivem sem o grande debate do que é estritamente artístico ou não. Muito provavelmente, a IA é o sintoma de que o padrão de criatividade humana, sensibilidade e sua recepção crítica precisam se mover em outra direção, e como vamos ter que lidar com isso.

I had the same idea funny enough. Now that more videos are coming out about it, it could be the springboard for more innovation in music production. Great video.

I've been a programmer almost 30 years and I really love your attitude man. It's gonna be a while before LLMs like chatGPT can just spit out a full song or game or something, but it looks like you're used to tweaking and fine-tuning. I'm a Nintendo fanboy and part of the reason was they used MIDI up until maybe gamecube and that meant the track could be dynamic in the game. Once chatGPT dropped it puzzled me why more people didn't take this approach instead of trying to make it understand waveforms.

@dasczwo

Жыл бұрын

Ya. Me too. Same as with evs: low range, high torqe, sounds like a tractor to me… sure sportscar as a proof of concept. Makes sense.

@ShuShuShop

Жыл бұрын

I think it'll be a lot faster than people think. Compare V1 of Midjourney to V5.1 and the growth in under a year is insane. It's like jumping from the first computer to our smartphones that fit in our pocket in under a year. I'm all for working along with AI in the creative process though. People are going to make some awesome workflows with it.

bro! Good videos! good content! Good editing! I am sure your channel will blow up if you stay consistent!

The generated voices are getting very realistic now, only the intonation and flow between each line is left to perfect

Really you know how to edit a funny video to learn something new that, for some people, is not so exciting to learn. That's a good recipe to change the world.

You: Hello AI, can I have some melody? AI: Sure! Here's some major scales.

you are a treasure, my friend

this is the best edited tutorial ever created on youtube

Sooooooo, i am actually a prompt-engineer. I could modify your prompt a bit to a more professional level. I don't have time for that in the next few days, but if you reply something to this comment i will create you are better prompt next week (And hopefully you will be shocked how much better the output will be).

I just have a ball listening to you talk. I wanna ask Chat GPT to talk like you all the time, man.

What we need is for someone to create a new, different AI model that is trained on many thousands of music performances and music scores for each music genre. As of now, ChatGPT is trained on words, text, articles, books, and maybe images. If the new AI model is trained correctly, it will be able to figure out what makes good, enjoyable melodies and harmonized melodies.

@lucamatteobarbieri2493

Жыл бұрын

Apparently there is an abstract level in music that is related to abstract representations in vision, language, motion etc. So big companies are just going for large enough neural network that can do evrything in any modality by training also every modalities, just like humans do.

@tcl6454

Жыл бұрын

mmmm, why the f do we need it?

@dhightone6755

Жыл бұрын

@@tcl6454 We would like to have AI software that will quickly generate many musical pieces for us to choose from, with the instrumentation of our choosing. More specifically, I would like to be able to tell it (through prompts) what I want to hear in terms of: length of the piece, tempo, shortest note duration, longest note duration, use of vibrato, type of musical piece (e.g., symphony, pop song, church hymn music, etc.), and many other variables. Also, I would like to tell it things I do not want included in the music piece. I have no way of creating music like this now without spending a fortune on recording studio and musician expenses to create just one substantial musical piece. That is why we need this new type of efficient and cost effective AI model.

@dhightone6755

Жыл бұрын

@@lucamatteobarbieri2493 You are right that companies are building AI models that can work in many different areas. But from what I have heard so far, the AI generated music from these models is just not very melodic based on current western music standards.

@tcl6454

Жыл бұрын

@@dhightone6755 I don’t understand… if you don’t want to write the music then don’t do it. It’s not like there’s a shortage of real music to listen.. you are taking about removing from music the very thing that gives it’s meaning: the human aspect. By the way, if we’re talking about MIDI than all you need right now is a computer, some VSTs (there are free ones) and a midi controller (if you don’t want to spend the money you can program using a mouse or write using something like muse score, which is also free). Hardly a fortune Why would we want humans to “not make” music when we already have thousands and thousands of talented musicians putting on the work to make real meaningful music? More than we can listen in a lifetime We “need” food, medicine, sustainable technology… we definitely don’t need non-human art, non-human sports non-human literature... What’s the point of that?

midi isn't a language it's an interface. midi protocol is the language. 💯

i like this video. surely my first venture into watching a ChatGPT MIDI conversion actually happen

Well done. This is a game changer.

I've done this before to get some ideas, especially in keys I'm not super familiar with. Love that you're exploring this too. Nice results!

I found you today,..and already you are my favorite KZreadr!

Live performances will make a comeback!

That OSRS botting part at 2:23 made me LOL

Really great different feeling video!

I just wanted this video to know that it is loved.

@nobodyandthecomputer

Жыл бұрын

I just wanted to let this awesome audience that watches these videos know that you all make me the happiest person on planet Earth!

super interesting! Thanks for taking the time to put this together, this should be a lot of fun to mess with ;)

I see music as realtime tool to personally interact with your brain. MIDI was created simply to be an extra hand to enable replay of your performance or to act as an extra set of hands. Using LLM in this way seems like a tool only for external validation than internal. It's fine for people to do this but I should be pointed out that this excludes any of the feedforward benefits of music.

This is incredible. Thanks bro. As a tip, Noteable is a really good ChatGPT plugin that essentially gives you Code Interpreter capabilities. That combined with the WebPilot plugin would enable people to copy the colab link, ask for a rewrite, save the rewrite to a Noteable note, and run the file all in a few chats

@TrippSaaS

Жыл бұрын

Also the editing on the video was very entertaining. So many ChatGPT tutorials are mind numbingly boring besides increased capabilities.

I have chatgpt writing code too. Creating synths. Also had it rewrite my resume, was offered a job within days .

this video and the history behind the vulf compressor are the most beautiful videos on earth

Comparto todos tus valores y visión del presente! Te amo como humano!

🎉 Dude, the video was awesome and hilarious! great job all around 🙌🏽 kudos

Can’t wait for the reveal that nobody’s voice is also ai generated

just went through your channel, great work Mr. Nobody!

Masterful presentation, the dry humor and ChatGPT tips are well explained. However for many of the comments posted below please consider the following.. As cool as this may seem, it will lead to the demise of many of music’s magical moments.. The point and click method of music loses a little more value with every click. Soon it will have little if any significance as it becomes brain dead easy and takes the skill of a 2 year old to tap a button. That aside it’s a great time to be an actual musician, the tools available today such as DAWs and amp sims ‘yes I’m a guitarist..’ is astounding. It’s like having the keys to Guitar Center.. however that magic will disappear if you set your instrument down and just start clicking.. Know one will ever go with some friends or on a date to watch someone click a mouse . And making something unique and meaningful that will get any attention in today’s world of 20’000 songs a minute being uploaded to the internet with copy and pasting is laughable.. Use AI and technology as a tool to enhance your music not create it for you and you and others will have a much greater appreciation for it.. This was a great video on how to generate some musical ideas and he clearly understands music theory, use this to your advantage.. ✌️

What a funny style and mad video editing skillz. I like it.

Being a music producer, this video gave me peace that AI aint taking my Job anytime soon

@shanehen

Жыл бұрын

Totally agree. It’s interesting to see all the nerdy, programmy stuff used to make this happen, but one could have written or played those poor, soulless examples in a fraction of the time spent jumping around on different techie platforms to generate a midi file.

@chrisngb

Жыл бұрын

@@shanehen Literally seconds 😂🤝

This memey editing style is great - nice work

Alright, you just became a god to me. Brilliant! Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

Awesome! This video shows how to make CharGPT compose in a fun way.

Video of the year ! 👏🤩

I laughed so hard on that, great explaining :)

Nice video, thanks. You don’t need AI, just have a Casio PT-87. Same “musical” experience.

Thank you for saving me the time needed to try this. We going back to the hood with this one 🔥🔥🔥🔥

Excellent video thanks a million. What a time to be alive 🙏🏻❤️🙏🏻

Thanks for the laugh :) Awesome video

Well, you're definitely a believer. I do love ChatGPT for all things text, but I think I'll stick to doing my own midis.

Loved the video❤

Good Stuff! 😎

Masterfully crafted sir

Awesome video man

you can just ask it to write it for you in notes, you can ask for different verses to the same song too, then go to the piano roll and write it in there yourself. you can ask for a genre or something too.

I prepare only the idea of harmony and chording. Recently I composed a Béla Bartók - like tune. I have strong harmony ideas on alternate tunings (still it's possible to withdraw modern harmonies from standard tuning) and can link those materials to Tux Guitar (MIDI file maker) and Native Instruments software. Sometimes AI is a big supporter for my compositions to inject complexity into my tunes. I'm not going to be a guitarist because it's easy to imagine what kind of a creator you can become if you practice blues everyday. Rather I don't like practice, any learnings that are pushed by outside of me. Of course, I don't know about piano at all. I'm really lazy but can stub professionals with my creative knife.

Awesome video! i'm inspired to try this out now!

Well, that was more than a little amusing.

Not AI content, but there is one dude that made an algorithm capable of procedurally music generation. It sounds really cool and complex

Text to steak & fries would be neat. Thanks. :)

@aaagaming2023

7 ай бұрын

Tea, earl grey, hot.

Ableton Gang🤘❤️🤘

I thought of this before you.

cool video sir

Amazing video and epic edits

How you animated Bach sweet sir?? Awesome!

Haha! Great work!

Great work

@nobodyandthecomputer

Жыл бұрын

thanks Neil

If we are dumb enough to create something that can cause ourselves so much harm and possibly destroy us, we deserve every inch of it.

Text to....anything (is coming)

Yeah, I know that superduper basic melody! It's the first five notes of CCR's disaster track "Rude Awakening #2".

Damn, what have we done 😂

Super cool video!

To create a stunning melody to build a song, you need a soul! So a song and it’s melody can be very simple or very complex. It is a feeling of it all and the lyrics make it round, and the same here, lyrics can be simple or very complex. And all together is a feeling, or a adventure that you have lived In your life and you wrote a song from it. There are VSTi‘s that wrote you complex chords …you say only you want a D, E, #F …and the VST Instrument Play it. That can be very helpful….! But GPT Chat … mmh … no not today…. When GPT can do it, GPT must realize what Emotions are!

love this keep it up! Rachel always sounds grumpy ;)

Holly Guacamole man !

loved your language dude. i might even copy your style using AI

Fascinating!

Fine,i have to do it myself..

Only a matter of time until someone makes an app or plugin that does this and sends the files straight to your DAW

you cool man this video was fun ....thanks!!!!

Great video! it's cool to see people get creative with chat gpt. 6:45 that part really cracked me up 😂 I asked chat gpt for some unique guitar chords, and it was also able to write out the tabs and chord diagrams.

@melvin4553

Жыл бұрын

Exactly. People get creative with it, but AI isn't creative by itself

FIRE VIDEO

a DAW?! run that .mid through FluidSynth with a .sf2 in and out baby

This is really cool, but honestly. The vast melody sauce 2 literally generates melodies using ai. The results are very artistic and usable

Ok ok… we are about 2 years from not needing composers nor musicians for some jobs

As a developer, chatgpt scares me a bit as far as work goes though i leverage it quite a bit. As a music creator im not worried at all lol

@TweakMDS

Жыл бұрын

Just remember, ChatGPT is still actually the first useful generation of general purpose LLM. Once these things are offered as specialized tools, they will drastically improve. As a developer, you might want to be slightly more concerned and maybe consider pivoting your career more towards architecture, design and requirement engineering. As a music creator; just imagine two generations further, where content farms are barfing out pop hits left and right, where both artist and composition are fully AI generated. There's no way it will replace actual creators, but I think the industry will be flooded. In my estimate it will be less than 5 years (heck, maybe less than 2) before we see a top 10 song by AI. Of course that's when the real fun starts, when people start suing based on copyright infringement, and we get AI lawyers.

@xgskrillax

Жыл бұрын

@@TweakMDS learning to build ai apps and custom ai models. UX design is already one of ny strengths. I use AI a lot. True creative music using lots of layers of live instruments and synths with automation is gonna take a bit i think. Some cliche pop may get produced and even move up the charts but i think overall truly original music has more time than most other stuff. But i could def be wrong. But so far, i havent seen anything involving music creation that has really even come close to impressing me.

@MarkEDark

Жыл бұрын

@tweakmds...I think some of today's top 40 pop radio crap is already SECRETLY made by a.i....big record companies have Big $$$ to spend !!!

So if you're interested - we did almost the same a few weeks ago (well my producer did) - he got Chat GPT to write the hook, the base line and set some other parameters for the beat and key etc (based off the last 5 years of dance music hits)... it then came up with the lyrics for us (they are ... erm interesting). We then asked chat GPT to come up with a home made video script that is "quirky" but for me Ginny.... and had to be made at home on an iPhone and had a twist at the end. Could be shot in 3 hours (we didn't want to waste too much time or money) - and this is the weirdness we ended up with... kzread.info/dash/bejne/qYClrtVshZrFYbw.html - not gonna be a billboard hit but -- you gotta experiment !!

@fatassj

Жыл бұрын

That's amazing, how do I even do that? Like the video here?

This video is 90% memes

really cooool. Any updates ?

😂😂 You have nailed it. I sent you an email.

Am belling this cool cat

very cool, chat gpt can do a lot, but composing music is not one of them 🥰

@YAH_ONLY

Жыл бұрын

As long as emotion is invoked through music and sound, I have to agree.

as a music producer, I'm quite excited and hopeful that AI can study my work flow and copy it so it can do the things I find boring and tedious... but making decisions I would

Hello Internet, can someone tell me how you can achieve the "Bach speaking" sequence at 7.07 ? Thanks a lot !

Or you can just play the keys on the keyboard

Wouldn't it be easier to actually ask for chord progressions on roman numerals and some melody notes?

This is very interesting, thanks for sharing ! May I know which version of the Chat and which version of the API you are using in this vidéos. I'm a bit lost about API's, beacause there are so many different options, I have no clue which one would fit better for this kind of experiments... Thanks !