Maybe add a "Save of the Week" at the end of the show and break that down why it was so good. Just to end on a positive.

@peterkleintdc

25 күн бұрын

Yes, +1 from me!

@Ethan0tto05

19 күн бұрын

I agree

@LandonByerly

18 күн бұрын

Great idea

Thank god someone is analysing Goalkeeping properly there are so many people who have an opinion on the role and probably never played the role at any level of the beautiful game. So people would just say should of saved it and provide zero explanation to what the scenario and the context of the situation is. GREAT ADDITION TO THE SHOW KEEP IT UP LADS 👍🏽

@Peterbrendanalbert

Ай бұрын

My club manager. Never given a minute of training but must have read a book or something recently.. Talks all this keeper jargon at me after a match! It's bizarre, i preferred no input instead of this.

@asaifali99

Ай бұрын

@@Peterbrendanalbert the best advice I can give any fellow keeper is learn at your pace if you feel that a manger , a coach or any individual is hindering your development it's about using skills you have learnt in sports and in life and developing to what suits you as long as your style and technique are effective for your desired outcome and are not putting you at risk due to poor technical advice and misleading instructions. That's the best way to combat anyone who provides random instructions for the sake of acting as if they understand somthing to a higher level then yourself.

Goalkeeper here. The very first analysis that is clear and concise when it comes to the actual decision making keepers make every single play. What I would love is for you to clip all the times announcers say "The keeper should have done better there" and show them why they are wrong nearly every single time they say that.

LOVE THIS! Great to have a proper GK segment.

Man Utd goalie coach is delighted he's now got something to use for Tuesday morning training! He'll be tuning in every week I reckon at this rate...

Amazing! We need this on saves as well, explanation and breakdown of saves

@peterkleintdc

25 күн бұрын

+1

As a GK coach this is great to see, this is not GK bashing they have to make multiple split second decisions and at the top level any wrong ones result in a goal. Love the one on Onana and pointing out Harry Maguires position covering half the goal just like a wall. I have watched Onana closely and he bounces too much for me and rarely gets a power dive right. The GK position is very technical and I spent a lot of time explaining to keepers no matter how great a dive you do if your starting position was not right by inches the ball goes in. Superb.

@Skiptoomyl0u

29 күн бұрын

Another thing I have noticed while watching Onana is that he will read shots incredibly early. At times it pays off for him and and times he has already made his decision on where to move before the ball is even struck and that can lead to some really simple shots going in. Onana is such a unique goalkeeper and would love to here other people's thoughts on him.

@inthelittlelightning

26 күн бұрын

@@Skiptoomyl0u personally I wouldn't have bought him and would've kept de gea. Great ball playing keeper but we have rarely played possession based football this season so we are not even utilising his biggest asset. Waste of money imo and cost us european football because he had not settled yet. Hopefully doesn't end up like Fabien Barthez.

Pro goalie here…absolutely love it. Let’s add in some saves as well next time if ya can. Top segment 👍🏼

@chris-727

Ай бұрын

Great point, let’s also see some goalies that did a good job and analysis of what they did right.

@dancetranceandmore9913

29 күн бұрын

Yes agree 🎉 best 3 worst 3👍🏻👌🏻

@2k8Spoon

29 күн бұрын

Good shout

This is a great idea, love it! It’s always good to experiment with new segments, keeps things from going stagnant.

@thecyclinggk

Ай бұрын

Thanks

Quality. Would love to get a keeper action at the end that you thought showed excellence in mechanics, creative thinking, or unbelievable reading of the game. Different styles of keeping are fascinating and your insight is always 100%. Thanks!

@havokanddisorder

Ай бұрын

Great idea

Fantastic analysis! This show can do a lot for the community and educating younger keepers!

These need to be longer pls

@thecyclinggk

Ай бұрын

Working on it mate

@Goncalo.

Ай бұрын

@@thecyclinggkdisagree ben, this was just the right amount of time

@Tofuninja7

Ай бұрын

Could analyze other parts of games too? 3 goals/keeper analyzed then a var moment or something? Loved it though 👌🏻

@havokanddisorder

Ай бұрын

Yeah felt like it was over too soon!

@sjaakbral83

26 күн бұрын

This is very interesting for defenders too

This is brilliant. Love, love, love that I can go full goalkeeper nerd watching two top professionals talk about the things every outfield pundit would miss. When you have been in these situations yourself and recognise the minutae that could have been done better then it's so satisfying to finally watch experts articulate so well to others what you normally just keep to yourself! I was watching with a massive smile on my face. Please make this a regular thing.

As an amateur goalie, this segment is super insightful, entertaining, and educational. Please keep doing this, it has already taught me some fundamental practices to improve my performance. Would be cool to see you analyze some worldie saves that by all probability shouldn't have been saved. If you want a punny name, call it "Upkeeping"

Glad you’ve done this lads as I really enjoy your keeping opinions and loves the idea when you mentioned it a few shows back. Keep up the great content team! 👏

This is absolute class! Thanks lads, more of this is needed.

Outstanding!! Like a few others have mentioned, I'd love to see 2/3 saves broken down too to show the detail of where the keepers got things spot on to make the stops.

Fantastic! I coach my son who came to me and said - You've got to watch this! Please keep it coming, we'll learn so much, and as a young keeper it's perfect to see how even goals that are not mistakes can be analyzed to learn from them.

Great content and great analysis! Finally goalkeepers are properly analysed on the technical and tactical level. Too often this type of commentary is afflicted by the most common (and boring) tropes, but with so much top class experience it should not be the case here 😉 I would only try to add some graphics to visualize the angles and the distances, for context and comparison 👍

Amazing stuff. Great to have some keeper content :)

This was brilliant. More of this please!

I really like this, so nice having more analysis from the goalkeeper's perspective

This is an amazing show can’t wait to see another one. I’m a 64 old active keeper and look at my own GoPro in the goals and saves to help me improve, so your analysis is super helpful. Plus your not bashing them your coaching us all. Bravo keep it up!

Great idea and could extend it to other parts of matches. Class 👌🏻

love this lads! two proper ex-professionals giving insightful advice which is so helpful for a young keeper like me

Great idea. Only suggestion would be to also include the clip at full speed-maybe 1) full speed, no comments; 2) slow it down and break it down; and 3) full speed again

LOVE the new show! Onana situation is very harsh, Maguire is the only player defending in a mile zone.

@davepayne164

26 күн бұрын

Nah. Like they say, if it goes in off the post then fair play. But a meter from the goal post with half a goal to worry about? For a top pro?

Love this, great analysis. This is where the powers that be, should be letting channels use video footage. It's educational for keeper's and "normal" fans alike. I agree with some of the other comments about showing why a keeper has made a good decision too. Most of us can get what happens "on the pitch", but channels for keepers and refs can help the understanding of some of the finer details.

As a goalkeeper for 25 years and no professional training, I absolutely love this show and your guys' takes! It's so helpful to see a GK Coach and a former pro talk about how to prevent goals from your perspectives. I greatly appreciate the insight and I cannot wait to see many more episodes!

Great work. Really insightful 👏

The cycling gk, I’ve been watching every week for over a year and not seen you ride a bike once lol

@erikarzensek

29 күн бұрын

Need to watch the first season episodes at watford

i love the insight into different positions. goalkeeping, midfielders, forwards etc. LOVE you and dave disecting 1 certain aspect of the game. more please. :)

Really cool concept keep this up !

Love this! As a goalkeeper in my school days, this is fantastic stuff! Personally, I'd change the name to the Goalie Guidebook or playbook since I imagine a lot of young keepers and even professional keepers would get great insight into how to fix their own game from watching this

Love this guys, brilliant work! 👏🏼👏🏼

LOVED THIS VID❤, keep them coming 👍

what a pair of legends!!! keep it coming boys !!!

World class segment, analyzing goalkeeping is really missing in football journalism, so many pundits and journalists have no clue about goalkeeping, and also you kept it respectful and professional, please keep it coming. Cheers from Germany 🍻

The science behind goalkeeping and analysing how to get the absolute best and the most out of making saves and how you move as a goalkeeper is truly fascinating. Great vid 👍

Amazing analysis from the best to deliver

Yas, so glad you took on the feedback and made this! Gives us non GKs a much better understanding on how we view the game as a whole

Love you two guys, love this analysis!

As a field player back in the day, it is so nice to see how goalies analyse their own, with the onana goal my first thoughts are that maguire should have closed the space to prevent the shot. But now hearing you two talk about the intention of him of closing that left hand side is such a different perspective. Would be amazing to actually see slow by slow movement to pin point every step of the way, although that might not be possible. Liked the comparison with ederson would be a great touch to compare why one is a "mistake" and why in the same scenario it is a save. Long story short amazing looking forward to seeing more!

As a erstwhile goalkeeper, I love these breakdowns! Keep them coming!

This is fantastic. Top notch analysis from both. I didn't think Onana was particularly at fault for Solanke's goal, but when you break it down like that, you can clearly see that he could have done more to save it. Keep these coming!

@inthelittlelightning

26 күн бұрын

idk onana just seems very top heavy and seems really slow a lot of the times when he has to dive low he doesn't have that flexibility and reflexes like de gea had(don't get me wrong de gea's reflexes are world class not many can come close to him in that aspect) but hopefully when (hopefully "when" maybe it could be "if" but i hope not) we get varane and martinez fit we can push that defensive line higher and really see his best feature, his ball playing ability come into action.

Absolutely class boys 👏

With Newcastle goal I'm actually surprised Vicario wasn't further out. He seems like the kind of wild sweeper modern footballer and I could have sworn I've seen him sweep these kinds of balls up before.

@conor459

Ай бұрын

Yep he has been all season mopping them up, I reckon last week vs Forest where he was almost lobbed may have played on his mind and so wasn’t as high who knows

Love this! Great to hear a “keepers” view on these things as no former GKs tend to be on TV. Keep up the great work Ben 👍🏻

Love it. As someone who didn't grow up playing/watching football, this really helps me understand the game.

This is excellent so good to listen to 2 guys who know the ins and outs of goalkeeping. Talking sense about it. Could listen to you guys all day.

this! i love it when you guys go into gk analysis on the football fill in, and this show is perfect for that! love seeing analysis from people like you and watto who know exactly what they are talking about! up the cycling gk!

Great idea for a new show, but please and I feel like we all gonna agree on this, we don't need background music in my opinion. I don't want to listen to it in the background if I listen to something that interesting. I don't think like it's needed when you have so much to say. It was very loud for first three minutes as well, after that it was much better

Loved you on sat night takeaway Ben great to see you back on telly

@thecyclinggk

Ай бұрын

Thank you

This is a brilliant series please keep it up

Great idea this show. Vicario has been excellent all season sweeping up the high line and was slightly surprised he wasn’t there tbh maybe it was because the week before Murillo almost lobbed him vs Forest so he was holding a lower start position

Very excited to see a goalkeeping segment, this could be so enjoyable for young keepers! Keep it going!

Love a good ole keeper segment! My only suggestion is that maybe you break down a couple great keeper spots as well, that way you can also show some positive play and coach by showing what to do right, instead of just wrong. As for a name...hmmm maybe something like Between The Sticks?

Love it, this is as good as a proper goalkeeper session. More on analysis though. The best way to learn is learn through playing

We all needed this,

Love it! Suggestion; long shot and a lot more effort but seeing demos on a pitch of each save and the changes would be really helpful

Absolutely love this concept!!

Ah love this - we need more of this 🙌

AMAZING PLEASE NEVER END THIS SHOW

Maybe try drawing lines on the still images to help illustrate what you mean? Like on the Vicario chance instead of saying “He should be farther out” You could draw a line to exactly where he needs to be? Either way, good analysis from some goalie experts

Didn't think i would enjoy this but it's been entertaining so far🔥

Would love to see a save or two added in that might have gone *UNDER*appreciated and explaining why it was so good

If you get a free kick goal, you could go through how to set up a wall and what attributes in the wall you are looking for. Also At the end you could go down to the pitch and run through a drill that addresses the issue that you pointed out on film.

Brilliant use of the platform you’ve created. More please!

This is great! just what is needed to show young goalkeepers like my son. Can’t wait for more of this!

I think for the future video, you can also highlight some of the brilliant GK play and break it down from yours and watto perspective, not only preventable goal. Brilliant stuff ben

Brilliant analysis as always 👏

Absolutely love this as a goalkeeper ❤❤❤

This is perfect thank you, exactly the type of content you should be going for.

Great idea for a series loved it

This is really good. It’s about time someone did this. As always ahead of the curve.

Can’t wait 4 more😁👍

Quality insight into goalkeeping that punditry has always been lacking, well done.

Love this breakdown and analyzing of goalkeeper mistakes that others may not see. Keep this show going!

Never realized the nuances of the position. This is awesome

Love the aproach❤

I feel validated seeing that Onana analysis. He always seems to me to have his diving mechanics wrong. Like he is a second too late on such shots or he goes with hands sometimes where DDG would go with feet

@tychatel478

23 күн бұрын

He's overrrated. Any pro keeper can make regularly routine saves by facing a lot of shots and get praised, for me it's the exceptional saves that differentiate the great shot stoppers from the bare minimum. He hasn't had those moments and has let too many saveable shots in

Love this! Would love to see you analyse amateur/semi-pro goalkeepers aswell!

Keeping me entertained, seriously enjoy the perpectuces of professionals such as yourselves.

Really enjoyed this. As a very casual American (soccer) fan it was a real education on what the keeper should be thinking and doing to make these saves. I hit the subscribe button and will be looking forward to next weeks segment!

Absolutely brilliant. Breath of fresh air

Love it! Can we see bigger images on screen though please?

Suggested name: Hit The GK Spot! Or: The GK Spot! Superb show lads, the time flew by very fast though...so PLEASE make these much longer. Also if possible could you break down a few good saves and what Goalies did to make that happen, also what strikers couldve done to beat the goalies in those occasions. Thank you both. Really loved this!

@pluck3y

Ай бұрын

The Goal Post

Absolutely brilliant segment guys, probably not what the keepers on this vid would want to see but 100% correct in your analysis.

Great show - top-class analysis. Loved it. It would have been good to have actual video rather than just still photos. Also for every mistake where you talk about what the keeper should have done how about showing footage where another keeper has done it right. eg on the last mistake by Bart, you mention Edisson's save/block against Rashford. It would be great to see that in order to compare the good and the bad. Looking forward to the next episode.

these are great. shame you can't play the video replays

Love this segment 👏🏼

At last. Top class analysis. Needs to be a feature on MoTD

Great segment, I think it would be good to see 3 great saves as well, that way we can see what they did to achieve it and compare it to where a goalie has made a slight error (and that’s all we are talking at premier league level, a slight mistake can be extremely costly) On a side note Ben you must be pleased for your old club achieving Back to Back promotions. I know you hung up your boots after a few games this season, but you still made that penalty save against Wimbledon to win Wrexham the point, so you still played a little part in it👍🇬🇧

Love the new series

Should do more for young keepers on positioning, communication, and maybe a segment where you use AI or something cool to show a keepers eye view of an attack building against you and where you’d be wanting your defenders to be

I love the concept Fozzy, would like to see some more perspectives from other GKs in this kind of segment... How about.... *The Box View* as the new name for this. Love the stuff Up the Fozzy

So many people are talking with no knowledge, this is so refreshing to see

Brilliant analysis for people who wants to be goalies

Glad this segment started later on in the season, imaging how many Matt turner episodes we’d of had up till now 🫣🤣

Love the new show lads!!