My opinion: 1. SERA - she has a problem controlling her breath while singing, still she's the best among Nine Muses vocalists. 2. HYEMI - she's very stable in live performances, but her voice somewhat lack of emotion 3. KYUNGRI - she improved a lot as I seen in Hurt Locker, but still lower notes are airy 4. KEUMJO - Keumjo sounds good in all Nine Muses songs so far, her best performance would be "Secret". A bit lack of power. 5. HYUNA - she's lead vocalist with noticeable voice, but Kyungri outstands most of her moments, since Kyungri always has more lines or better lines to show. So I can't say anything about Hyuna, she's #5 because she's lead vocalist. 6. LEE SAM - she's next best vocal to the leads/main. Glue & Just A Girl are examples. Too bad she's left. 7. SUNGA - noticeable, but then not so much when it comes to live performances, she was good (Gun, Dolls, Glue) then she was not (Hurt Locker, Sleepless Night) 8. ERIN - she was a vocal, but now she's main rapper. I find Erin kinda stable when singing, not so good but can be average. 9. SOJIN - in their latest comeback - Sleepless Night, she has more lines to show her vocal, and she did well (she's a main dancer not vocalist). And Sojin has a very good head voice. 10. EUNJI - Eunji has never have enough lines to be considered vocalist, she has a nice voice, but she's not a singer. When it comes to rap, she was better. 11. MINHA - slight vocal & if she keeps her mouth shut while singing like she always does, she'll never improve. Anyway, she's visual, and she does her job very well!

@elijahpham8048

6 жыл бұрын

i dont know but i always love Sam's part but unlucky she was underrated :(

@milkyyy4443

2 жыл бұрын

Not the minha shade 🤡 I do agree, she's not the best vocalist but you did not have to kill her like that-

@donnietd

2 жыл бұрын

@@milkyyy4443 I love Nine Muses, all of them cause they are my only K-Pop art, there is no reason to bash Minha. I said what I think she did best and she could have done to improve, there is no killing there.

@milkyyy4443

2 жыл бұрын

@@donnietd No no! I was just joking, I totally understand LOL

@user-ku9ko5pv4p

2 жыл бұрын

LOL the minah one, it’s true tho, she can’t sing, she’s out of tune even when standing

1.Sera: There will never be such a powerful vocal like her though Keumjo with a similar voice with proper training could be on Par. Sera usually never got the most lines and was the main vocalist which made me mad cause she had so much potential! 2.Hyemi: The most stable, but her voice is very monotone even if she goes a few notes higher she sounds the same just higher sometimes, always loved her High Notes so iconic 3.Hyuna/KeumJo: Hyuna was added as a lead but always got less than Kyungri since Kyungri was popular, but Hyuna has lovely falsettos and head voice. Though I personally hate her live note on Glue it was always flat but she did it well/Keumjo is like Seras grudge that came to haunt the group though during hurt locker she didn't seem to stable with that dance and they even gave her first line to Minha.. MINHA OUT OF ALL PEOPLE >.> 4.Sungah: My bias Wrecker who replaced Sera. Her voice is so husky but in the the right place, she's so underrated, and she can get very high in her range if you seen their live of Figaro with new OT8(or whatever number we on now 5??) I love her tone, and the way she carries her singing its unique and different 5.Kyungri: She's the reason I gave this group a chance loved her in Wild though I feel she's overrated in vocal, yes she's good but there's times where her singing is questionable not to mention the strain she put on her chords in HL 6.EU -rap queen - AERIN: Debut song on the second part of her first line hits you with that high note! I was shocked when I saw she was a singer before rapper she had potential! Though the only other singing line after the early days she got was in their song Action wasn't strong but was good 7.Sojin/Lee Sem: Sojin in Nasty Nasty was amazing and in Sleepless night otherwise she was just average. Though her role is dancer mainly and now rapper so >.> / Lee Sem started as a rapper and when I heard her sing I was pleased by the ears she's nothing dramatic but she's good too 8.Eunji: I feel she never got to evolve in her voice much, her line in the ticket audio was good but live she was usually out of breath or shaky or unstable. 9.Minha: She went from performing loud and live during No Playboy & Figaro to whispering or just never singing at all. Hands down the most wasted lines in history like when she was given Keumjos lines in heart locker she would just lip it or mumble it like girl speak up! Not to mention in their a song for you version of HL she was the most quietest one and even though the audio is prerecorded and filter to sound really smooth her ass still crack and broken notes. But what people always claim twice to be and that's just a "visual" . .... My opinion feel free to share your thoughts I would love to see someone else's thought :o. And this wasn't biased cause if so Sungah would be #1 with Sera 😂

@SM-wf4ki

2 жыл бұрын

the minah slander

@milkyyy4443

2 жыл бұрын

@@SM-wf4ki FRRRR AKNSMAJAAK

MY OPINION 1. SERA - Powerful and Emotional - MAIN VOCALIST 2. HYEMI - Powerful and Stable - MAIN VOCALIST 3. KEUMJO - Powerful and Emotinal, but not very stable - MAIN VOCALIST 4. KYUNGRI - Powerful, but in some higher notes her voice goes a little flat - LEAD VOCALIST 5. HYUNA - Soft voice and lacks power, but still can hit high notes - LEAD VOCALIST 6. LEE SEM - Sweet Voice - VOCALIST 7. SUNGAH - Strong voice, but sounds to me a little nasal - VOCALIST 8. SOJIN - Sweet voice, but few vocal lines - SUB-VOCALIST 9. EUAERIN - Used to be part of vocal line, but she's better at rapping - SUB-VOCALIST 10- EUNJI - Used to be a little nasal, but has a good tone - SUB-VOCALIST 11. MINHA - Singing almost every time in head voice but sweet voice - SUB-VOCALIST

They really a group of great vocalists that everyone have different opinions on who is better than who

I personally feel Lee Saem's singing is way better than sungha. Her voice is a lot more clear and her placement sounds better as well. Like sungha sounds too nasally especially in comparison to saem. I can also see why hyuna is lower than kyungri because if you see how hyuna sings in the studio it's not the same live. Like she depends way too much in the back track and it showed during wild. During her chorus.

@stephanieguerrero9485

6 жыл бұрын

L

@wheelie642

2 жыл бұрын

I’m late to reply, but I like the lowest ranking singers as much as the highest. They all have the “it “ factor, I like every one of them. Miss them being around.

SeRa > HyeMi > HyunA > KyungRi > SungAh > Lee Sem > EuaeRin > EunJi > MinHa.

@myeaasa

5 жыл бұрын

Yass.. Same😄

@EpicThe112

4 жыл бұрын

Same but how about Sera vs Taeyeon vs Jihyo or Eunji vs Sooyoung vs Dahyun

Minha harmonization in Sleepless Night was amazing.

For me, it's: 1. Sera 2. Hyemi 3. Gyeongree 4. Hyuna 5. Keumjo 6. Lee Sem 7. Sojin 8. Sungah 9. Erin 10. Minha 11. Eunji 12. Bini 13. Jaekyung 14. Rana

@liyoung03

3 ай бұрын

Finally someone mentions bini Rana and jaek

this is my opinion, Sera ~Keumjo > Hyemi > HyunA > Kyungri > Lee Sem > SungAh > Sojin ~ Eunji ~ EUAerin > Minha.

I really really like this ranking... Hyemi is The only one in The group who can sing like that... And in your vídeo one can realize it.... I agree whith your vídeo :) thanks for it :D

9# Minha 8# Eunji 7# Euaerin 6# Lee Sem 5# Seungha 4# Kyungri 3# Hyemi 2# Hyuna 1# Sera

I love Sungah's voice

ABSOLUTELY RIGHT

Hyemi 👏🏽😍

I agree with all of it except Hyuna is better than Kyungri

1. Park gyeongree 2. Ryu sera 3. Pyo hyemi 4. Moon hyuna 5. Park minha 6. Lee sem 7. Euaerin 8. Park eunji 9. Son sungah

@illyuzion

3 жыл бұрын

ur probably biased cz u kept minha wayyyyyyyy higher shes the worst like shes soo silent but her vocal is soft i hope she could not be silent cz she will never improve . and u kept sungah wayyy lower, she should be 6th in terms of vocal and sem 5th. well ryu sera is wayy better than gyeongree but i think she should be 4th or 3rd(shes improved alot or maybe second too cz she hyuna, keumjo and hyemi are in same level though so its okay but subjectively shes 3rd )well no hate on you cz its ur personal taste so okay i respect your opinion pls dont feel bad😅😅😅 my ranking would be Sera>>>Hyemi~Keumjo>/~Hyuna~Gyeongree>Sam~Sungah>Aerine~sojin(she improved alot)>>Eunj(shes good singer tho)i>Minha(she maybe had improved!!!)

Queens😍❤😭

Sera was bias at a very young age of mine

But why did you put the parts where euarin and eunji rap if they are not vocalists...

her voice is amazing

Kyungri is best 😄😄😄😄😊😊😊😊😊😀😀😀😀

Mi opinión ❤ Sera>>Hyemi>>Kyungri>>Hyuna>>Keumjo>>SungAh>>Erin>>Lee Sam>>Sojin>>Minah>>Eunji>>Jaekyung>>Bini>>Rana

1. Sera 2. Keumjo 3. Hyemi 4. Hyunah 5. Kyungri 6. Sungah 7. Euaerin 8. Lee Saem 9. Eunji 10. Minha

good

Nine muses got many great vocalist but I'm really sad about their disbandment T^T I think Eunji and SungA have good tone for vocalist. They can be main or lead vocalist with more training. I didn't include Sem here because she's one of good singer. She can be lead if she debut in other group.

11. minha 10. Sojin 9.eunji 8. Euaerin 7.sungah 6. Lee Saem 5. Hyemi (so nasal) 4. Hyuna 3. Keumjo 2. Kyungri 1. Sera

i think Sera is the best one lol

I'll just drop mine here (2013 lineup) : 1. Sera (Bias) 2. Hyemi 3. Kyeongree and Hyuna are tied for me.. 4. Lee Sem 5. Sungah (Bias wrecker) 6. Erin 7. Eunji and Minha

Sungah 😍😍

I agree with this ranking and then when Keumjo came she has the best vocals of 9muses. Her runs and high notes are the best and sounds the most professional.

Main Vocal Material 1. Sera 2. Keumjo 3. Hyemi 4. Kyungri Lead Vocal Material : 1. Hyuna 2. Sungah 3. Lee sem the non vocalist 1. Euaerin 2. Sojin 3. Eunji 4. Minha

How about putting them in a three-way vocal battle with Snsd & Twice. That will mean Sera vs Taeyeon vs Jihyo

@illyuzion

3 жыл бұрын

it would be i think 1)Sera 2)Taeyeon 3)Jihyo Or 1)Taeyeon 2)Sera 3)Jihyo I prefer sera more but taeyeon and sera are in same level, and jihyo shes great but not really in taeyeon's level but shes super great singer

@EpicThe112

3 жыл бұрын

@@illyuzion okay then how about the vocalists rappers & visuals they're Following Snsd Jessica Sunny Tiffany🇺🇸🇰🇷 Hyoyeon Sooyoung Yoona & Seohyun 🇰🇷9muses Kyungri Hyemi Minha Lee Sem Erin Eunji 🇰🇷Sungah 🇫🇯🇰🇷 & Hyuna🇰🇷. Then followed by Twice Chaeyoung Momo Sana Dahyun Mina🇺🇸🇯🇵 Jeongyeon & Tzuyu 🇹🇼

@illyuzion

3 жыл бұрын

@@EpicThe112 lol, thats unnexplainable tho- im not a professional but i got trained just for one year and im again gonna continue after coronavirus(ill just learn more from yt) so i kinda know some things but i need to learn more

1. Sera 2. Gyeongree 3. Hyemi 4. Hyuna- she was given more lines that show her singing skills but she is unstable specially in live perf. I think lee sem and erin has more stable voice than her. 5. Euaerin- she would be the lead vocalist if Hyuna and Gyeongree will not be added 6. Lee Sem- has a more solid and clear voice than other 7. Sungah 8. Minha-her voice is unique and angelic 9.Eunji- thats ok she is the greatest dancer of 9 muses and in her generation. This is just my opinion

rip

our muses disbanded....

song at 0:23

@shira4511

7 жыл бұрын

Dolls

1. Sera

living godess HYEMI

Hyemi best vocal ever 💜💜

For my opinion kyungri is better than sera in vocal her voice is more powerful but its just my opinion 😊😊

@KrulciferEdenfelt

6 жыл бұрын

VIP forever kyungri more powerful than sera...that's new lol

@ggstan958

6 жыл бұрын

Luvia Sama its my opinion but i like seras voice more than kyungris 🤔🤔

@KrulciferEdenfelt

6 жыл бұрын

VIP forever I know, I'm just saying it's new to see someone rate Kyungri above Sera I can unstand Hyemi or Hyuna lol. I was just saying it's your opinion of course (: no worries 😁

@ggstan958

6 жыл бұрын

Luvia Sama okay 😄

@maria.3499

5 жыл бұрын

LOOOOL

Kyungri is actually the best singer here.

1 - Keumjo 2 - Hyuna 3 - Hyemi 4 - Kyungri 5 - Seungah 6 - Erin 7 - Sojin 8 - Minha

what is minha doing nowdays?

@mariapopa1890

5 жыл бұрын

Inquisitve m she's an actress

Kyungri kinda looks like Tao from EXO idk...

@pili4087

6 жыл бұрын

wayra c. are you blind or something? Kyungri's beautiful. ;^;

Hyemi > Keumjo > Hyuna> Sera > Kyungri

You have lost your dam mind, putting Hyemi over Sera. Sera will always be number 1.

@khanhnguyenngoc7526

5 жыл бұрын

It's a personal opinion. You cannot say s/o lost their mind because they didn't make a ranking that is same with your idea. In my opinion, this ranking is still fine whether Hyemi or Sera on top. Sera is better in terms of emotion and Hyemi is more stable, she can control her voice very well. Sorry for my bad English but I just want to show what i'm thinking about your comment. That's all

Sera sing better that Taeyeon

@ryoferdinand2322

4 жыл бұрын

Pffft really?

EuaeRin is the best rapper 9Muses never had, though.