Generation Tech: *Offering different ways to improve the Jedi Order* Legends Luke: "A little too late for that, kiddo"

@theempiredidnothingwrong3227

3 жыл бұрын

Legends Luke was based and made sense he was such a chad. Cannon Luke it literally a virgin.

@nicholashill6314

3 жыл бұрын

Yup

@dragonknight1560

3 жыл бұрын

Man I don't care if there's crazy logic in Legends, it's BETTER than the real thing in the sequel trilogy.

Only put someone on the Jedi council if you’re willing to grant them the rank of master.

@olafgurke4699

3 жыл бұрын

Because not doing so would be outrageous and unfair.

@senatorluxbonteri6065

3 жыл бұрын

@@olafgurke4699 how could you be on the council and not be a master?!?

@vinywild8202

3 жыл бұрын

Even more if they have more military feats and a fought more Sith and others dark-side users that half of Council.

@brianstabile165

3 жыл бұрын

Adoa

@asteroidalassassin6949

3 жыл бұрын

truth

Love doesn't lead to the dark side. Passion can lead to rage and fear, and can be controlled. But passion is not the same thing as love. Controlling your passions while being in love, that's what they should teach you to beware. But love itself will save you, not condemn you. - Jolee Bindo.

@Jungoguy

3 жыл бұрын

Exactly.

@waz207

3 жыл бұрын

“Fear leads to anger...anger leads to hate...but passion leads to the ladies”. -Yoda, probably

@jonharper4478

3 жыл бұрын

Even after all this time Jolee is a source of great wisdom.

@msihcs8171

3 жыл бұрын

@@waz207 when you're as short as Yoda you definitely need the mind tricks to pick up chicks (I'm sure Yoda can tell you all about it.)

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

Hence the ban on attachment.

One big thing that could've helped them is if Windu took a minute and said "Anakin, I know we have our differences but I appreciate all you've done for the order. Chosen one or not, you've become a fine jedi"

@eds1942

3 жыл бұрын

Or “Remember that time when the Council sent you with Padme for a few months despite Obi-Wan’s reservations? Yeah, youre welcome.”

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

Anakin should have understood there was a mutual respect

@MackNcD

2 жыл бұрын

@@emberfist8347 He wanted more than mutual respect, he wanted top dog status. If you don’t believe me - look where he ended up. Actions speak louder than words. Anakin was just not a good dude, as much as the prequels focus on his tragedy and how circumstances ushered him towards the way he went - it took his personal navigating to narrow the path down to what it became.

@johnpatz8395

2 жыл бұрын

Yeah, I had always questioned, with Yoda and Mace being so concerned over the dangers of training Anikin, why would they allow that task to be done by the orders newest Jedi knight? I mean if there was so much of a risk involved, if he was going to be trained I would think Yoda and Mace would oversee his training personally, as no one was more prepared to deal with it them those two together.

@Godzilla00X

2 жыл бұрын

@@johnpatz8395 Yoda says in ep 1 they're letting Obi-wan train Anakin since it was Qui-gons dying wish.

*Suggestion:* Top Non-Force Users who can beat Jedi and Sith.

@olafgurke4699

3 жыл бұрын

That would be a long list of Mando's.

@bladedninja8853

3 жыл бұрын

Yes that's a good idea

@bladedninja8853

3 жыл бұрын

Did you mean strategically or physically. If strategically, Jedi are shit, physically Jedi are OP

@olafgurke4699

3 жыл бұрын

@@bladedninja8853 Well, Jedi at the end of their order. Old Republic Jedi were a lot better strategically.

@Killjoy-cd7pc

3 жыл бұрын

Clones, jango, Ig88, Cad Bane, there is 4

If the Jedi are going to be Generals and Palawan be Commanders in the GAR, then the Jedi Order should probably consider giving some tactics and strategy training

@nobleman9393

3 жыл бұрын

They were just as good as normal officers. Actually! they were better than normal officers

@regwhite939

3 жыл бұрын

There not ment to go to war they feel closer to the darkness

@pizzedahff3127

3 жыл бұрын

Jedi strategy training: Use the Force.

@eds1942

3 жыл бұрын

But, they’ve got lightsabers and the Force... How cool is that? jk

@Dragon_Lair

3 жыл бұрын

@@nobleman9393 Not really. One simple fact is is that the Republic had gone 1000 years without any major conflicts. Jedi handled small scale stuff, and planets solved their issues internally because relying on the Republic Senate was useless, see Naboo. No one was really trained for war or tactical deployments or thinking strategically. Some Jedi did a great job like Anakin or Obi Wan Kenobi, but others were barely leaders at all and got troops and equipment killed and destroyed in far larger numbers than was necessary because they threw troops at the problems then ran off to fight themselves. Admiral Yularen didn’t like working with the Jedi most of the time because they lacked common sense and got troops killed a lot. The Jedi’s training made them susceptible to death and the dark side because they had become divorced from reality and how to empathize to others that so much exposure to so much pain, suffering and death, as well as the burden of being given command made them reckless, stupid or experiencing pain, anger and fear where they never had to before and did not know how to deal with it.

I've always felt that the way the Jedi treated Anikan after they basically left his Mother to die on Tatooine was the wound that drove him to the Dark Side. I mean, think about it. When adults of any kind, (parents, teachers, etc.) violate a child's trust on a deep level, that child could act out that rage and pain in adulthood. Even if thay don't, they will find it really hard to trust anyone around them. I always told my friends who love Star Wars that in my mind, Anikan never forgave the Jedi Council, their struct rules damaged his ability to embrace attachment to his Mother and led to him killing Padme and thus was much more suseptable to Palpatine's manipulation.

@realjoemavro

3 жыл бұрын

Here's the thing though; Anakin didn't have to be a Jedi. He had other options for a fulfilling career, especially after the battle for Naboo. How many other nine-year old boys could win a pod race and a space battle in practically the same week? Qui-Gon also should have made it perfectly clear the sacrifices Anakin would have to make as a Jedi. Sure, he warned him that being a Jedi was a hard life, but that doesn't tell you a lot, especially from a child's perspective. You can't be implicit with something that life-changing. Not that that excuses the Jedi Order's methods.

A suggestion I've made before for rebuilding the order … *breeding programs.* Being accepted in the Jedi order basically _makes your linage end,_ … having a high Midiclorian count means you won't breed and you therefore become a genetic dead end (and your parents may be hesitant to have more children in case they could also be recruited). The Jedi are unintentionally breeding out Force sensitivity! Imagine if the Jedi academy was like college or University… a lot of pairing ups, and future parents who have degrees. And after a few generations of Jedi on Jedi action they'll end up with a Kwisatz Haderach. Isn't that what the whole bloody Skywalker clan are? And as for the Order and it's recruitment polices, instead take the whole family if they are willing (and suitable). A lot of disadvantaged family would jump at the chance to be ancillary staff at a Jedi facility (and not just the academy … Anakin's mum could have been a general hand at off world agriculture centre, Ani gets to correspond with her occasionally and visits after certain milestones … and he knows she's taken care of by his "Jedi Family"). The Jedi academy is like a boarding school, not a monastery. The kid goes to Jedi school while the rest of the family does whatever mundane job they are capable of… and incidentally also make more kids that would be more than likely to be Force sensitive (even as a regressive gene, so generations down the line…). [That was my concept for post Order 66 - grab whole families and start a Force sensitives colony in the unknown regions or on a large ship].

@nathanhayes4028

3 жыл бұрын

In canon force-sensitivity doesn't pass through bloodline, rather, the force chooses who wil be force-sensitive.

@bhesseling9949

3 жыл бұрын

@@nathanhayes4028 it does seem to be common though

@GuntherRommel

3 жыл бұрын

The Jedi failed Anakin through their refusal to remove Shmi from slavery. Because you know Anakin asked.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

@@GuntherRommel Well sorry but that would require an entire war because you liberate one slave you going have to liberate them all and the Hutts will get pissed and boom war.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

@@bhesseling9949 No it is a crap shoot Anakin is the exception to the rule

A slight counterpoint for the taking of kids: It *really* depends on what those force-sensitive kids are capable of. If the kids have enough force powers to physically overpower their parents, they'll ultimately be impossible to discipline at home. Also, every generation of kids has a bullying problem. It'd be way worse if the bullies had telekinetic powers. So you'd probably want something like a boarding school like how X-men does it. Ofcourse the counter-counter point is most jedi need years of training to be able to use force powers.

@mattBLACKpunk

3 жыл бұрын

Boarding school=bullying central

@seprithlicastia463

3 жыл бұрын

Anakin is one of, is not thee, most powerful force user to have ever lived... And until Qui-Gon told him he was Force sensitive, he had no idea. Yes, there are some more serious cases, but I doubt you would have many such cases.

@austinkersey2445

3 жыл бұрын

@@seprithlicastia463 He wasn't the most powerful, he had the most potential. He never ever lived up to it either. The Force can manifest in different ways. Darth Bane was able to use the Force more innately in his teens and early adulthood, like using the Force to crush his father's heart after a night of harsh abuse, or using a sniper rifle to kill five or six Republic troopers in less than seven seconds. Palpatine in his teens unconsciously used the Force to vaporize his parents, siblings, and bodyguards in his teens. To be fair that was because of intense emotional buildup and release but still shows it can be dangerous given time and the right circumstances. That said Anakin wasn't really at a breaking point of that sort before the Jedi Order.

@englishlady9797

3 жыл бұрын

Ummm, I hate to break this to you, but bullying was also a problem in the Jedi academy. The canon Obi Wan and Anakin comics, and the Kanan Jarus comic shows both Kanan and Anakin were bullied in their days in the academy.

@ailius1520

3 жыл бұрын

@@englishlady9797 Yep. Now imagine what those bullies would do if they had force powers and their victims didn't. Oh, and they can beat up the teacher too.

best way to make them better: Divorce from the senate

@1000nod

3 жыл бұрын

star wars reading club said the samething

@zacwhatevs2439

3 жыл бұрын

I would give you a like, but you're at 66

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

No that isn't a good idea.

@mongolianfishingvillages1371

2 жыл бұрын

@@emberfist8347 it is in fact it’s the best idea

@emberfist8347

2 жыл бұрын

@@mongolianfishingvillages1371 No it is not as that is them abandoning the good people of the galaxy.

I would like a video on the differences of the new Jedi order under luke(legends) and the previous one

By banning almost all the most basic experiences from their members from such an early age, the Jedi made it trivially easy to tempt their students to the Dark Side. Who needs of offer unlimited power when just promising some emotional support would be just as tempting?

I think that one of the reasons that the Jedi didn't realize clone soldiers were basically slaves is that they themselves were practically slaves to the Jedi Order.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

No it was because they were actually championing the clones and securing rights for them.

@AgnesIona

3 жыл бұрын

@@emberfist8347 Is that a head-canon or in a book I havn't read yet?

@christophersalinas2722

3 жыл бұрын

@@emberfist8347 where

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

@@AgnesIona It is shown in the show with and the lore with how they encourage they nicknames instead of numbers and the Essential Guide to Warfare mentions the reason someone like 99 wasn’t flushed out of his growth jar was the Jedi were keeping the Kaminoans on a leash preventing them from purging the clones who were too far from their high standards

@MackNcD

2 жыл бұрын

@@emberfist8347 Ember Fist has our back. May the force be with you.

Having absorbed a lot of lore lately. I'm noticing a lot of parallels between the jedi and the space marines from 40k. The pov that normal citizens are lesser and can't relate, childhood indoctrination and being taught in a bubble so they don't understand the enemy. The jedi don't prepare their inductees for dealing with the darkside and sith. This lead to their downfall. The space marines and primarchs were not taught about chaos which led to the horus heresy.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

No they prepared Jedi to protect the Sith.

@Allronix

3 жыл бұрын

I've snarked that Star Wars is Warhammer 40k with a nicer paint job. No matter how much you want to dress this up with talk of Jedi being "intergalactic therapists" (Seriously, Lucas, where's the therapy?), the Star Wars universe is a grimdark shithole of demigods slugging it out in a never ending religious conflict where the "god" in question empowers both sides, manipulates events to get their pawns where it wants them to be, and then waits for them to clash and get trillions killed while it feeds on all the blood and death like some demented god. It'll sleep for a few years, a century, a 1000 years...but it'll always wake up again, thirsty for blood sacrifice.

Yes, finally a channel who managed to offer the solutions to the Jedi Order to improve! I hope I can say the same about the Sith too. But only time can tell despite how much unlikely it is.

@Spartan3D213

3 жыл бұрын

Yup, rather chose lightside for my Swtor Siths, makes them much more interesting.

@MackNcD

2 жыл бұрын

LOL it’s funny how much criticism the Jedi order gets when the Sith gets zero tips on how to be better. I guess waving your fist at the Sith can only be done for so long, you know they wouldn’t be taking any advice.

You missed one: let them carry blasters. We’ve seen what a Force-User can do with the Force or a Lightsaber. Imagine how accurate they’d be with a blaster. They could use the force to make sure they always got the hits they needed!

@TheGoodLuc

3 жыл бұрын

Let them carry all kind of weaponry they want.

@loyalcav1575

3 жыл бұрын

@@bigredwolf6 If anything they have the Force as their weapon.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

@@bigredwolf6 That would be overkill man. Thermal Detonators are miniature nuclear devices. One detonator would be enough to level Jabba's palace. A wall would make Tsar Bomba look like a firecracker.

@loyalcav1575

3 жыл бұрын

@@bigredwolf6 And thats how deadly the force can be

@reklessbravo2129

3 жыл бұрын

They should do what people did in real life where you hold your sword with your primary arm and your pistol with your other arm. IRL it was because early pistols were so limited that the sword was more important, and with jedi it's sort of the same thing. Jedi vs randoms and you've got excellent defense and good offence. Jedi vs other jedi/sith/force user you can either use the blaster to keep the other guy off balance or holster it and use both hands to hold the lightsaber like we're used to seeing

See, Jake Skywalker? The fact the Jedi Order caused its own downfall doesn't mean you need to eradicate it in order to defeat the Dark Side. Try to learn from your Chad Counterpart and his hot redhead wife, buddy

@goodmind4940

3 жыл бұрын

let's thank Abrams and Rian for this

@tomcat124us

3 жыл бұрын

Hot Red Headed Wife who was ordered to kill him.... Would have loved that conversation with Force Yoda lol

@ilovejettrooper5922

3 жыл бұрын

@Jedi Prince "The fact the Jedi Order caused its own downfall doesn't mean you need to eradicate it in order to defeat the Dark Side." Pretty sure - especially with the phrasing used here - that it tried to be an allegory to some political issue of the real world. Don't know about anyone else, but I immediately thought of the line of arguments that (roughly speaking) said, "tear down U.S.A because it was created when slavery was still practiced". *Humanity itself* started off completely f**ked, it still deserves the chance to grow and become a better version of itself - U.S.A included. But, hey, what do I know? I just pretend to know things on the internet :D

@MackNcD

2 жыл бұрын

@@ilovejettrooper5922 Lots of allegories. The idea of the sith in the senate, how it went from republic, to empire…

4:30 Qui Gon Jinn is looking a bit different in that clip

@asliceofcheese7152

3 жыл бұрын

Ur like that guy who keeps commenting in every popular channel except star wars The guy with no moustache guy

Imagine Jedi on a _gap year_ or if they had a Amish style _Rumspringa?_ Now that would be mayhem … *Jedi Gone Wild.*

@englishlady9797

3 жыл бұрын

So glad I'm not the only one who bought up what the Amish do. The Amish are sensible.

Hello there

@ayanman2345

3 жыл бұрын

General Kenobi. You are a bold one

@Capitulated000

3 жыл бұрын

Bye here

@Bucketlord_

3 жыл бұрын

Kenobi

@archonmage2486

3 жыл бұрын

General kenobi you are a bold one You must realize you are doomed

@sombrerosaur

3 жыл бұрын

General kenooobiiii

Maybe one way of making the Jedi Order better, would be to allow marriage to be practiced in the Order, with the understanding that at some point, your partner will eventually die, and while you can mourn their passing, you shouldn’t allow it to consume you?

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

Except they tried that before and it didn't work. That is why the ban exists to begin with.

Yoda who "saw through Anakin" should've said when Anakin went for guidance something like "Look, we all know You love Padme and are worried about her. Careful of these attachments You must be, as trusting Your emotions can lead to the dark side. If it can help You then leave the order as love is usually forbidden here, especially amongst younger padawans and knights." Like, they knew he's unstable considering how he was voicing his opinions in front of the jedi council, show some damn humanity and understanding.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

He did but Anakin ignored him.

They should mainly not be so strict, keep away from ALL politics and be allowed to form attachments like c'mon kenobi was just fine and he did it

@crusader8102

3 жыл бұрын

tbf obi wan was an exceptional jedi

@waz207

3 жыл бұрын

Obi wan had a very non-conformist master as well to help him end up exceptional...just about any other master and I think he’d be more corruptible

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

If the Jedi were less strict there would be more Anakins they need to be involved with politics because they are guardians of peace and justice, and Obi-Wan was the exception that proves the role.

A potential follow-up to this video could be a look at Luke's (Legends) New Jedi Order and whether it's a demonstrable improvement over its predecessor. At least a few of your points are addressed in The Lore Master's comparison between the NJO and the older eras, and it'd be interesting to see what a deep dive into the subject turns up.

I've been writing a series of, well essentially fanfiction, about a time a hundred or so years after the sequels, and so much of what you are saying here is where I went. Jedi are no longer a part of the Republic, or any of the other galactic governments that formed in the wake of the First order. They are still too few and far between to even consider mass adoptions of force sensitives, and most often when a Jedi is looking for an apprentice, they are looking for a more developed individual who can handle a life of travel, and training. With some level of education already

@TheGoodLuc

2 жыл бұрын

Where? On what site?

You should make a video explaining stuff about the Trade Federation or Nute Gunray

Legends had Je'Daii which embraced both light and dark side equally

@justtherabbithole2577

3 жыл бұрын

Legends also had Revan.

@dboymax1

3 жыл бұрын

IMO Luke should have brought back the Je'Daii order and bring true balance to the force!

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

And the legends point out they were destroyed by themselves in a civil war.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

@@dboymax1 That is not balanced.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

@@justtherabbithole2577 Who only used one side at any given time.

So glad you make points about our world with Star Wars.

Suggestion: Cover some of the high republic lore. I know not everyone likes the books, but there’s some new cannon topics to cover at least

@wizard_of_poz4413

3 жыл бұрын

Heard it's cancer

If the Jedi wanted to recruit a Force-Sensitive Child, they would need the approval of the Parents.

@CloudyNight2156

3 жыл бұрын

They have the approval of the parents. If the approval is due to respect, fear, or force persuasion is a different question.

@hziao6751

3 жыл бұрын

well your parents want you to become a doctor doesn't mean you want to become a doctor, right? the child's own will should come first, not the parents'

@fulcrum7455

3 жыл бұрын

@@hziao6751 well at the point the child doesn’t really have a will of their own

@psychologymajorptsd62

3 жыл бұрын

They usually do get the approval of the parents. Of course it could be after hearing “Your child could kill you accidentally in a tantrum” so...yeah

@hziao6751

3 жыл бұрын

@@fulcrum7455 yes so that's why the jedi should wait until they're older (16 or something)

Do a video on Korkie Kryze/ Kenobi

One of the issues of the Jedi order was that they functioned in a republic that lacked the constitutional strength for separation of powers. This forced the Jedi into multi-tasking roles they weren't prepared for. For example, if the republic had developed their own, organic military it would be separated from the Trade Federation's agenda. If the judiciary were separated from the trade fed, their aggression wouldn't have been tolerated. If the senate & exec (Palp) were separated & term limited by a clear & strong constitution, the Empire wouldn't be created. A good constitution would have clearly separated the powers of; executive, senate, Jedi council, judiciary, legislative, banking, media, military, police, etc. This would mean the Jedi council is a part of the republic, but not under bureaucratic control at all. So the Jedi would be free to follow the will of the Force & serve the republic.

New grand master every 100 years

@Godzilla00X

3 жыл бұрын

100? Why not 25?

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

Why would they need that? The Grand Master is a meritocracy that only gets given to the Order's best. They shouldn't turn it into a political position because it is a position that nobody should be actively seeking.

How about a Generation Tech video about how Mandalorians can change and improve themselves for the better?

Given a choice to stay in the Jedi Order or leave, kind of like the Amish Rumspringa.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

There is an option.

@MackNcD

2 жыл бұрын

So you’re just going to let the Force Sensitive become aboslutely lethal and then at some point you say “Hey go out and get wild, come back if you decide you’re more into being devout with your powers.” lol

Get *Yoda* _tested for Aphasia_ [transposing words in a sentence] and look at possible therapies.

@MackNcD

2 жыл бұрын

They have a word to describe anything unique about anybody huh? And they have solutions for it too…. Ugh.

I felt like the whole time Alan was asking me: "bruh have you even read Locke?"

Great vid Gen Tech, very good points.

Thank you 🙏 respect to your list!

The Jedi need to be like the Amish and have Rumspringa (teenagers can go out into the world and decide whether they want to leave or commit to the faith)!

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

They have that option.

Good ideas, thanks for this video.

Y'all should Make a discord!

1: No Xenos allowed. 2: No Baby snatching. 3: Enlistment after 18 years of age 4: Meritocracy 5: Let them expirience the Galaxy.

@justtherabbithole2577

3 жыл бұрын

18 years old?

@bgcvetan

3 жыл бұрын

@@justtherabbithole2577 i've tried to make it sound more formal.

@jayvhoncalma3458

3 жыл бұрын

@@bgcvetan Sorry I don't speak xenophobia

@aayushagarwal4138

3 жыл бұрын

@@jayvhoncalma3458 humans are clearly superior than say, the primal animal like wookies or the dolphin like kaminoans. And these are some of the _respected_ species. Now imagine all the other species! Now of course, if you are xenophobic _among_ the humans,then you need a mental checkup.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

You are a dumbass. Aliens were needed for the order they didn't steal babies 18 year olds wouldn't have what it takes to be Jedi and the last two already exist.

The Jedi should have had the jedi temple built on Zenoma Sekot instead of corusant.

@goodmind4940

3 жыл бұрын

they did?

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

They did in Legacy but that is easier said than done. Zenoma Sekot was a very obscure world in the Rise of the Empire Era, and then disappeared until New Jedi Order.

@derekkizzee7940

3 жыл бұрын

@@emberfist8347 DAMN

I like your way of thinking

You are very wise Alan

Can you made video about MON CALAMARI factions and weakness.

Do the clone war series

Some other essential changes that need to be made to the Jedi recruitment practices should be to give new potential members the option to choose whether or not to join the order in the first place, develop a system of auditioning type tests to help find out what their lack of Jedi potential is (since anyone could claim to be force sensitive), and not let there be an age restriction because their could always be force sensitive adults out there who need as much training as any child (in fact, I hope that Rey will make this video’s changes to the Jedi going forward). I also hope that a step back from their fundamentalism would include allowing them to have human attachments.

Interesting. This does remind me of the comics and Ulic Qel’droma

A lot to be taken into consideration . ( A BIT OF A MIND FLIP from THE TIME WARP - from "The Rocky Horror Picture Show" ) !

I just want to point out a small detail I think you might’ve missed, as far as I know the Jedi do give babies back or ask permission to take them as seen in a comic book which heavily featured a family trying to get their baby back from the Jedi(they ultimately succeeded) Mace Windu and also a small cameo from an actual baby version of gods not sure if it’s still canon but I wanted to point that out

@mongolianfishingvillages1371

2 жыл бұрын

Cap 🧢

@Jiub_SN

Жыл бұрын

@@mongolianfishingvillages1371no it's true, Jedi got consent from parents and would allow Jedi to leave if they or their parents wanted to

One big improvement would have been having in-house therapists, preferably ones that come from outside the order. Jedi are suppossed to let go of negative emotions, but to do that you first have to process these emotions, which often times is not easy all by yourself. Anakin turned to Palpatine because he felt that he had no support within the order and likely was afraid of getting punished for the whole marriage thing. If he had had the opportunity to talk to a neutral third party about his worries, in the knowledge that nothing he said would get back to the council, he might have been less susceptible to the dark.

Can you cover canon New Separatist Union and Confederacy of Corporate Systems? Also maybe cover Legends Corporate Sector Authority, Day 3

I think they where right about romantic filings :One of the main reasons for the fall of Rome was that the families of the legions were allowed to settle near military camps.

I really appreciate these kinds of perspectives that the good guys you think are actually no better than the bad guys. The Jedi are basically licenced cult The Rebels are a bunch of criminals Luke is a shitty teacher The new republic is nothing

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

No you are an idiot. The Jedi are guardians of peace and justice and the Rebels never blew up planets.

@hziao6751

3 жыл бұрын

@@emberfist8347 As long as you hold on to this fan-boy-audience point of view then I don't think this channel suits you. And where's your manners?

@catherinemoore5603

2 жыл бұрын

Hahahaha

@catherinemoore5603

2 жыл бұрын

Hahahaha 😂

The Jedi lost their way when they became servants of the Republic rather than servants of the Force.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

No they were serving both the Republic and Force aren't mutually exclusive.

@Vigriff

3 жыл бұрын

@@emberfist8347 The Republic doesn't serve the will of the Force. One cannot have their cake and eat it too.

@MackNcD

2 жыл бұрын

@@Vigriff They’re not against it either. The true republic, outside of the Sith’s influence, was for individual liberty, freedom of experssion, etc. All these ideals translate to supporting the Jedi in their service of the Force and all that such entails.

What if rey & fin repairs everything using the book of octu on the new Jedi order Will be operating on balance of 2 jedi knights being support with other Jedi branches like normal military?

I don't think it's canon but in "No Prisoners" there was that splinter Jedi group the "Altisian" jedi order, who basically were the perfect example of how to do things but of course neither Ahsoka or Aniken or anyone else had ever even heard of them despite the council knowing of them. Can't be teaching your younglings there are other options out there! One of their members could do some pretty amazing things with machinery.

It’s ironic that the Jedi and Jedi’i actually married and had kids for awhile.

@samchindedza2012

3 жыл бұрын

It's also ironic that the rules to stop Jedi ussuly become the sith Because the rules are strict So they kinda make sith

I love you Allen

*Catachan Jungle fighters vs Jedi* who you got?

Anakin: This isn't the Jedi way, he must stand trial. Mace: Like Dooku?! Sidious: Well this... umm awkward.

"If an entire group needs to be saved from itself, it should be annihilated." -an Ultramarine I disagree with in most cases

Only the Sith deal in absolutes. And yet, when confronted with a Sith, the Jedi absolutely had to kill them. Ironic

Everything you said Legends Like pretty much did for his Jedi order

To be a Jedi is to reject ones humanity but I believe its the force which creates this duality.

Please do more comparison seires I have lots of ideas if you need them

@mattd2026

3 жыл бұрын

Bet ur lying

@dylanthomas385

3 жыл бұрын

They could do comparison super soldiers like Spartans or space marines sometimes they implying they do. They could do best super or secret weapons there no stranger to thaws. They could do a fantasy army comparison they already made a list or monst dangerous fantasy monsters need I go on

@mattd2026

3 жыл бұрын

@@dylanthomas385 bump

@dylanthomas385

3 жыл бұрын

🖕

Well, there are plenty of points that I would technically defend, but I ultimately agree with the direction you’re going with this. Sure, I’d take in Force sensitive newborns as soon as possible, but I’d never deprave them the essentials to grow up with the ability of what the modern world needs the most: self control. A good example of self control, but in the Covid-19 pandemic context, is where masks function in a similar way to the X-Men’s Cyclops’s visor, except that visor/mask is covering the mouth, not the eyes. Thus, with proper training, those who’re pretty powerful in the force can control themselves better & live fairly normal lives of their choosing…

Although I don't agree with your points on how jedi knights are psychopaths and war criminals, I think that some of your suggestions would improve the Jedi Order.

1:22 lego tie Fighter mini

Fully agree. Except that it (wasn’t) the 1st Schism, It was the 2nd Schism which led to the Sith.

Luke’s Jedi is basically what you talk about

Sugestion: is there a scenario where jedi and sith could find peace? Did sideous violate the rule of two rules?

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

First one the answer is no as the Sith are evil will never accept peace. It would be like giving pork to a Muslim. Second one no Palpatine was perfectly following the spirit in the rule of two. The rule was made with the specific intention that there would at least one potential apprentice held by the current apprentice and a few backup apprentices for the master. This is actually shown in Darth Plagueis where after having killed his own master, Plagueis is attacked by one of the potential back-up apprentices his master had and then killed the other ones he had on stand-by.

Are there any force hat groups in star wars.

How would the iron man suit fair in the starwars universe

Not be intolerant and go psycho at other Force using orders like the Grey Paladins, … accept franchises.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

Well those other force users are dangerous because they will fall to the dark side from their ignorance.

Maul is just Ezra’s creepy uncle who offers to buy him cigarettes he doesn’t want 😂

Nothing can save the jedi from my wrath muahahahah

Maybe learn an ancient Jedi force power that prevents sand from being coarse, irritating and getting everywhere.

I think it's because of Court dooku Fall and sifodu Making the clone army is the reason?

I got an idea to improve it! Give'm guns! 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

Suggestion: how to take over the galaxy

Restructure the order to be open to non force sensitives. Everyone can be guided by the force, even if they cant lift objects, and opening yourself to the wider public would be useful for many people and the jedi

@wizard_of_poz4413

3 жыл бұрын

Kinda defeats the purpose

@iszox2973

3 жыл бұрын

@@wizard_of_poz4413 i dont mean this in a: you become a jedi for the rest of your life way but more of a guiding way similar how priests also help with social problems etc. The whole point of this would be to teach people about the force and let them be guided by it. If the Jedi are more of the things stated in the video above this hould be so much of a problem

@wizard_of_poz4413

3 жыл бұрын

I mean regular church's aren't based around having superhuman powers or anything. And tbh I thought the part about buying food for a shoplifter was a pretty bad take.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

The Jedi Order is like the Xavier School for Gifted Youngsters it is a place for force users to train safely and learn how to control and use their powers for good in a safe environment. They don't need any non-force users.

Can you do a KOTOR vid

Was it sifo dyas or count dooku who commissioned the clone army? Jango states it was tyrannus but clone wars states it was sifo so which was it?

@wizard_of_poz4413

3 жыл бұрын

They got sifo dyas to be their fall guy to place the order to the kaminoans while dooku set up the contest in order to get the genetic stock needed to make the clones with. I believe the kaminoans didn't know the difference between the Jedi and sith as they met with Darth plagueis as well before

@justanotherglorpsdaymornin5097

3 жыл бұрын

After a bunch of force visions of the end of the jedi Sifo Dyas tries to convince the council they need an army, they essentially tell him to go screw himself because they don't like force visions so he goes to his bff Count Dooku and they commision the clone army in secret. I can't remember the precise timing but Dooku betrays Sifo Dyas during his move to the darkside and takes control of the commision but leaves it in Sifo Dyas's name.

I agree though case by case every situation should be evaluated individually. Clegal corruption and stupidity destroy peoples lives

I think this was kind of the idea behind The Last Jedi was Luke realized that the Jedi order didn't and doesn't work. Instead he realized a different way should be taught that is balanced with both sides of the force.

@partydave1067

2 жыл бұрын

Which was one of the reasons why the trilogy sucked, the legends made it so Luke recreated and reformed the Jedi Order.... You could even use and practice dark side elements, but it was importent that you used it to save lives and was in control of yourself.... The last Jedi made Luck absolutely pathatic to highlight the newer generation and characters like Rey

@chrisyanover1777

2 жыл бұрын

@@partydave1067 I think you are absolutely right! I think the message the sequels and even the prequels were trying to tell was both absolute methods of studying the force were wrong. However the sequels were so horrible that the message got completely lost and leaves thr viewer confused what if any message was trying to be told!. The Force Awakens made it seem like you can wield the full powers of the force without any training or even knowledge you have the force. Forget about the years of training, just pick up a lightsaber and you can get all the skills that use to take years of training to aquire. Then there was the Last Jedi and I have not clue what they were trying to tell other than Luke is a grumpy old man now! I don't know why Ray wanted to be trained by Luke because I thought she got all the skills she needed when she picked up her lightsaber? The Rise of Skywalker didn't really have anything to do with Skywalkers and was so concentrated on fixing the Last Jedi that no Ray has the powers of all the Jedi's now!

Funny how Luke fixed most of these thing with his order in the legends continuity. He created a better jedi order by choosing not to be the old jedi order.

Most of your discussion is why I don't hate the Martez sisters episodes. They gave the perspective of the average sentients, they dont even understand the jedi really.

There should be more roaming Jedi training schools. Like you pointed out they are removed from the conflicts of the republic and the citizens who populate it. The mobile training schools spread throughout the galaxy getting to know the people and customs would help the Jedi know how to work with the populace. The schools could be on small to medium ships to accommodate various equipment needed to be apt at what is commonly used on their area of studies.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

And they do have those.

@yungo1rst

3 жыл бұрын

@@emberfist8347 yup, they just need more when implemented with the strategies here. Luke found one and made it the main training facility for a while if I am not mistaken.

I get the feeling darth sidious's final plan was an army of dolphins with head mounted blaster rifles.

The chad Jedaii vs the virgin jedi

Suggestion: Why jedi had no mental health department.

@emberfist8347

3 жыл бұрын

They do but Anakin didn't want to admit his true problems to anyone even Yoda.

Wow

Jedi Rumspringa

Could the rebel alliance beat the republic?

How about top 5 strategies to save the sith order.

Okay so if grievous is a robot that doesn't use the force, why won't jedi use the force to take his lightsabers away?

In the first prequel film there is a scene which to this day infuriates me. This is when Yoda, who is a throughly annoying and infuriating character, says that Anakin should not be trained because he is too old and more important because he is fearful for himself and his mother and this fear will lead to suffering and hence the darkside. In otherwords Anakin's fear based on his love for his mother, mainly, is bad. Whatever. Further suffering is always bad. Really? In the context of Yoda's comments this seems to mean that empathy that causes you to suffer because of what might or is happening to someone else is bad. After all Yoda is clearly saying that Anakin's fear for his mother is bad so then so is empathy for his mother's position. This all goes to the sense of detachment that the Jedi seem to prize above all. A sense that can best be created by seperating infants from their families early so they can be more effectively brainwashed into being detached.