"If you can see right through this letter, then all the tears are clearly shown." MMMM that line is just so good.

@82dorrin

6 жыл бұрын

*Celestia's answer* To my Faithful Student Twilight, it's been two hours. I was on the can. Chill the f*ck out. Sincerely, Princess Celestia

@JakinIrali

6 жыл бұрын

@Onyx1916 BWahahahaha!!! OMG....

@aa-nx3lk

6 жыл бұрын

It sung those lyrics just as I read this comment XD

@scorpion.6669

3 жыл бұрын

I know right

I saw this years ago and completely forgot the name, but never the song itself. So glad I finally found it again. Hasn’t lost a drop of its emotion.

I never knew this song existed, and oh my goodness do I regret that. This song is so strong, beautiful and sad. Its peak storytelling, I cry inside as I write my fics to this :')

@Sedgehun

Жыл бұрын

😄

+moon sisters No, it was the other way around. Fanfic was based on the song.

@MImsrock1

8 жыл бұрын

+4everfreebrony I'm unsurprised that other people find your work so inspiring, something I feel too! :)

@sylvashtda7681

8 жыл бұрын

+moon sisters what fanfic u talking bout?

@sylvashtda7681

8 жыл бұрын

moon sisters okay

@hectorgarces5383

8 жыл бұрын

+Zealous Spark o.O man why your life is quiet and sad? :( :(

@aurora4xabo665

8 жыл бұрын

My family is only me, my father, my grandmothers (one born in 1945 and has smoked all her life) . My grandfather died of stroke at christmas a month before i was born and my other grandfather died of cancer when i was 5 years old.

This is a piece in 4everfreebrony's most iconic style, the chant. I feel like it's beautifully mixed with absolutely perfect instrumentals here. The chant itself is executed perfectly, the soft back-up vocalizing is a welcome complement, and nothing overpowers anything else - the song sounds rich and full without being overpowering or overly energetic, balanced without being lethargic. And it's an incredibly moving piece, most importantly of all. It feels deliberately repetitive, not unwelcomely so, much like how people turn sad truths around in their head repeatedly. The pacing on this is spot-on. Bravo.

As someone who has never cried from listening to music, I feel like I have to commend you for finally making me crack . The events described in this song are terrifying to imagine. Twilight losing Celestia is akin to someone losing their mother, teacher, and god. Losing one's family, faith, and passion in such a simple thing as a lack of responsive letters is the saddest thing I could possibly imagine. Well done.

I always thought that the fanbases music is a million times better than what's on the radio.

@mattlatorre9084

6 жыл бұрын

John Brett It really is. Imagine how much people would love this sort of music if they didn't know these are actually brony songs.

@Sedgehun

6 жыл бұрын

you did not think it. it is a fact

@cirelesten

Ай бұрын

Because there's heart In it.

you never cease to amaze me! I always enjoy hearing your new songs!

@listless9384

6 жыл бұрын

So Shgurr is a brony? I have to say, I never expected that...

@javierpowell4705

5 жыл бұрын

@@listless9384 same

@steve6888

5 жыл бұрын

Listless she’s a pegasister

@birdy4696

4 жыл бұрын

Listless i know I’m a year late, but you don’t have to be a fan of the show to like this brilliant music

@silvy7394

4 жыл бұрын

6 years later this comment means a whole lot more now that I know who Shgurr is.

I forgot this existed and I wish I never did. I remember how this song would always make me cry. Even now after all these years it still makes me tear up. Truly timeless.

JUST BEING DEPRESSED AND SUPER SAD. DON'T MIND ME. *plays this song for the 50th time*

@4everfreebrony

10 жыл бұрын

Sorry, lol. ^^; I tend to make people emotional with my music a lot.

@trojanpony8447

10 жыл бұрын

In truth, I always have enjoyed "emotional" whether it be joyful or melancholy; melancholy especially, seeing how nothing else speeks to the soul as such.

You and Relative Pitch really sold the emotion in this song, you're voice was great, and just... it made me cry. I pray you continue making music unto your dying days, no matter what it's about or who it's for, so long as you enjoy it. I pray this for you, and all the other MLP fan musicians who've reached out and touched me with their music.

Как же это прекрасно. То как оно манит переслушивать и переслушивать раз за разом.

I can't explain how beautiful this song is... *cries*

Ever feel just so unbearably SAD and DEPRESSED but for some reason just can't CRY? Sir I hate and love you and your music so damn much.

My first thought was "Ok, who died?"

@SnowyDragoon

8 жыл бұрын

No one, that's the sad part.

@10WTF011

8 жыл бұрын

Ikr, it sounds like a sad funeral....I love it.

@wuchta7812

7 жыл бұрын

Maijin Boo i think it's good that nobody died.

@arthas640

7 жыл бұрын

I love this song, its so emotionally moving without being sappy or corny. It really seems like Twilight is just beaten down by all the shit she's gone through, all the stress, and all the responsibility. It's like that old saying: "Sometimes (she/he) will cry not because they are weak, but because they've been strong for too long"

@10WTF011

7 жыл бұрын

Wow...slowly claps ...that old saying was truly the most relatable thing I've seen.

I liked how it sounded like it was gonna go into extreme but then it stayed calm, you earn to be listened to every day for that

I just found this song a few minutes ago. It'f beautiful and bittersweet. I love it and wish I'd found it a lot sooner. Very well done as is much of your work.

This song has been out for quite a while at this point, but I'm absolutely entranced by it, it reminds me far to much of some times gone by. Lots of nostalgia, lots of pain, and a good amount of somber joy, thank you for making this.

Just discovered this song. God, it's so beautiful. And goes straight into my heart For my best internet friend had disappeared... She stopped writing me back about a month ago. I don't know why. I don't know how to reach her aside of leaving messages in Skype in hope that she'll answer some day. I don't know what to do... So I'm just sitting here.... listening to this song... crying... The days are grim, the nights are dark My eyes, they slowly lose their spark And you, you left on me your mark Are you ever coming back? The world is dull, the skies are gray My laughter slowly fades away So many things still left to say Please, come back to me some day... Edit: It's been 5 years. They never replied. Why am I still not over this? I feel so dumb. The poem is kinda cringe too, hah. But I guess I'll leave it be.

@ilikeyoutube7224

8 жыл бұрын

Im sorry to hear about u and ur friend. I truly hope they get back to u soon. If u need a new pen pal or just someone to help keep ur mind off of it ill be there to chat (:

@Greyshi

8 жыл бұрын

Anaya Keyes Thank you... I do hope she'll come back some day. Though she's still gone... That's very kind of you... :) I would love to talk, if you're interested in Undertale that is (it's basically my life right now, I rarely even talk about something other than this damn game >_

@ilikeyoutube7224

8 жыл бұрын

+Greyshi I don't know much about it other than it has a large fanbase...so I'm sure I can get into it easily haha

@Greyshi

8 жыл бұрын

Anaya Keyes Aww, that would be awesome. Where it's convenient for you to talk? Skype? Maybe Tumblr?

@ilikeyoutube7224

8 жыл бұрын

+Greyshi email me? I guess you cant message on youtube or am i just not very tech savvy? My email is my name @gmail.com :3

This is a song that I just lay down and listen to when I'm having a bad day.. idk what to say this is just a beautiful song lmao

This song I still love. It's helped me cry myself to the point I was actually happy. Thank you for sharing your talent with the world. It's truly a beautiful song.

A single manly tear was shed (And no, I'm not joking, it was literally a single tear. Whether it was manly or not is a different question XD

@cocainer621

7 жыл бұрын

men can cry to, we are human as well

@sethsabres

3 жыл бұрын

This would make a grown man cry... And I'll let it, you go on ahead tear.

This is still one of my favourite songs to just put on repeat and leave running. It's just so poignant and mellow-sounding at the same time, it just... This song has feeling, and that's what music SHOULD have.

I want to thank you for making music. Aside from some good friends, music was the only other thing that helped me during my depression during my divorce. And out of all the music I listened to, yours was the one I listened to the most because it helped me the most. This song and "Here On The Moon" were the most influential to me out of all your music, and were often my go to songs whenever I felt myself slipping deeper into depression. It's hard for me to express how much they helped me and the value I put into them whenever I hear their tune or lyrics, but thank you so much for making them and your others songs. It really helped me during the most difficult time in my life.

@4everfreebrony

8 жыл бұрын

+Roulden Garrison is of course away serving as a missionary for another 10 months, but we will share with him your kind words. And so grateful that his music was able to help in even a small way. Some people think that some/most of his music is somber and sad. I like to think that he helps people express the sadness that is in their hearts that they need words for, but don't have, and they relate to the emotions. Then he always tries to mix in a feeling of hopefulness, that all is not lost.

You're a machine! Beep boop, keep the good songs coming!

Found this last year and I still love it. Very sentimental 😇

Well, with the show coming to an end soon, I'd say this is quite fitting. Love this, forever always.

It's hard for a song to get you choked up with emotion.I think we can all say this has accomplished those levels.Definitely remembering you 4everfree.

I keep coming back to this one :'^

@qbrooks751

5 жыл бұрын

It might be one of the best brony fan songs.

God I can't believe it has been 8years god so much is different than back then, I miss those days.

@98mrrico

Жыл бұрын

It honestly hurts, time flies too fast

Curse you for giving me depressing ideas for a fanfic based on this! Man First Chant of Immortality, then Starswirl's Frankenstein, Now this, I know I could have mentioned more but these three right here... stand out the most for me.

@alexwong3365

9 жыл бұрын

Then make it a Tragedy :D *not saying I like tragedy*

@XTestament

9 жыл бұрын

Archibald Fredrick Well not so much a tragedy since that would imply death... most tragedies do, but it would definitely be sad...

@alexwong3365

9 жыл бұрын

well not necessarily death. maybe loss of limb, or a falling out, or whichever.

@mr.outlaw231

9 жыл бұрын

Archibald Fredrick Or the "Curse of Immortality" though I perfer to see it as "The Gate Way to the Circle of Life". But that's just me, other people don't want to live forever.

@alexwong3365

9 жыл бұрын

yeah, eventually one would get bored, or lose all of their friends and family, or other ties to the world.

I know this feeling all to too well. Feeling when friend stops writing you back for unknown reasons (probably just busy with college, but still...)

This really hits hard. Never read the description until relistening to it, and man it hurts.

30 seconds into the song and I'm on the brink of tears.... It's a sad song but a good one none the less. /) (to 4everfreebrony)

@mr.outlaw231

9 жыл бұрын

There there Zoniy. Do you want mental therapy? I know...a good program for sadness.

@4everfreebrony

7 жыл бұрын

(\ Thanks!

Amazing work. All those tears in my soul... can't stop 'em. Thank you.

This is one of the only songs ive ever listened to that has made me cry, even if unintentionally, you have made an amazing song that sparks an emotion ive rarely gotten from music. Good job :)

I've got to say your lyrics are something special. I haven't come across many musicians with the same level of writing as yours, and I honestly can't stop listening. Love the violin and guitar as well.

@4everfreebrony

10 жыл бұрын

I'm so glad you like it! A lot of my lyric writing inspiration comes from listening to Classic Rock/Pop (70's and 80's) and Choral music.

Even after years i still come back to this song maybe cause i miss the series or maybe cause of a pain hidden idk the reason but i love coming bacl to this song

What a gorgeous takeaway to 2014. The year I joined the fandom and 4everfreebrony dominated every single music post on EqD :3

i cant help but listen to this song. i thought id let you know. its so beautiful dont you know. oh yes it was. cause ill be around for as long as you may may know. if i can cant get away, i will always love this song. id thought id let you know.....

This is absolutely gorgeous. I can play this all day and just relax :)

@TheMaskedFrenchMan

10 жыл бұрын

So can I, but I am not relaxing. . . I am fighting back the tears that threaten to escape my eyes

I hate this song. Do you know why I hate this song so much, Mr 4everfree? Because I can't re-listen to it. the first time I listened to it, I got shivers and felt tears well up in my eyes. I now can't watch it again for fear of a) actually crying this time or b) not feeling the same emotion and losing something beautiful. very well done, sir. very well done indeed. But, similarly, god damn it.

@4everfreebrony

10 жыл бұрын

I've never had someone love a song so much that they hated it. xD ...ehhhh, Achievement Unlocked?

@dragoncrystal24

10 жыл бұрын

It's the same feeling when you complete a video game with a really emotionally intense plot and characters you've grown to love, or finish a book series that you invested a lot of emotion in. It's a moment that you don't want to lose, so you just sit there for a while and just absorb every last drop of emotion.

@user-rb9lq3eb3w

10 жыл бұрын

4everfreebrony I'm on the Internet found a video about a little Dashes from the world of MLP, I have found people from our world and raised her. And then... broke up with her, let her into your world she came from... this video I again if I can see, it is already to late, and the pause will not put. (there are grammatical errors - used dictionary) Я на просторах интернета находил видео про маленькую Дэши из мира MLP, которую нашёл человек из нашего мира и вырастил её. А потом... расстался с ней, отпустил её в свой мир, откуда она пришла... это видео я повторно если и смогу просмотреть, то уже до конца, и на паузу не поставлю. (есть грамматические ошибки - пользовался словарём)

@dragoncrystal24

10 жыл бұрын

Are you talking about the video My Little Dashie?

@user-rb9lq3eb3w

10 жыл бұрын

Верно)) Exactly))

KAPOOYA! Right in the FUCKING FEELS.

Such, a touching song, so many memories. Your work along with others in the fandom are really life-changing for many of us observers. I would like to thank you along with the others in the fandom for their masterpieces

Excuse me while I go curl into a ball and cry

@tiashadrows3469

5 жыл бұрын

Fetero Ill join and convert u

This song gives so maany emotions, almsot like i was crying. And this echo in the ending of song also deepens this feeling.

i feel like this hits harder after the end of FIM ... we will never see celestia write back to twilight again

Finally! I've been waiting for another song with Relative1Pitch since "Chasing Fate". His violin added a whole new layer of emotion to the song, and your voice chilled me to the bone. Fantastic work, 4everfreebrony.

Beautiful as always man. Keep up the phenomenal work!

ahhhhh the feels... it was sad but when i saw the description i litteraly started crying. This song is beautiful, as well as the rest of your music. Your combination of feels worthy music and happy music is amazing, and i want to go through and listen to every one of your songs tonight! keep it up your songs are awesome

Great song! I know the feeling of someone who just stops replying to you after knowing them for years; with them giving no reason for it. Spending time asking if they are there and waiting for the reply that never comes. This song really hit home for me on that part. Beautiful melody as well. I'm normally not one for sad songs, but this holds a special place in my heart. Thank you for sharing it with us.

I love the instrumental to this song way to much. That violin really just brings it together. And interesting choice of topic for the song man, this is why your one of my favorite musicians.

I keep coming back and back to this song, its so bittersweet

Always as I listen to I have a strange feeling and a memory of old times :, D brings me to cry.. Love it

sweet lord this is the kind of music that got me singing when I was young... just gah frickin you and your acoustic style man great job

Wow... I'm speechless - this is the god-level of making songs, especially if you're not "superstar" with a backup of tons of managers, composers and lyrics-writers. Simply... wow.

once again im just floored by the genius and emotion you never cease to amaze me

all the feels in this song....this emotion.....

Thanks alot, here I was, having a good day and you had to come in with your sad song. I'm going to go cry in a corner now D: But seriously, you never crease to amaze us. Bravo.

Omg... This should got billions of views for this such a beautiful music

Chillingly beautiful. Its like a rose carved out of the coldest darkest stone

another awesome piece! Really starting to love ur stuff, Chant of Immortality was amazing and now this one!

This song just moved me so very much......so many feelings of different situations and people in my life. So sad but so beautiful.....thank you! You are a very talented writer and singer.

When I listen to music of this caliber, I find myself seeing the story unfold in my head. Bravo.

I just started listening to your music, and I can't believe what I have been missing out on! I got to say, your works are amazing

absolutely fantastic once again

I love your use of the violin in your songs! The overall ambience of this one in particular is absolutely beautiful! Well done! This one is definitely going on my MP3 player when you have the download link up!

@6-dpegasus425

2 жыл бұрын

mp3 player... man does time fly...

4everfree, you're excellent at punching me in the feels. I of course mean this in the best possible way. I love your work.

_What is this clear liquid dripping down my cheeks?_

@Durynspokemon

8 жыл бұрын

Liquid sadness.

@CaramelTrash

8 жыл бұрын

liquid pride

@tiashadrows3469

5 жыл бұрын

SpookyGhost couldnt have sad it better

@Dowlphin

4 жыл бұрын

Silicone oil. You are a robot.

@cobalius

4 жыл бұрын

Probably rain. Weather is crazy today, eveb starts raining inside houses

This song brings the feels, great job as usual

I just can't stop coming back to this song...

I just watched the pmv on eqd, i have to say, this song really hits you were it counts, it really is an amazing song, well done, to both of you, and to the artist as well, it captures the feeling of the peace perfectly, bravo.

This song really makes me cry when I am sad but it’s such an amazing song I just love it. I also love the story behind it as well.

You never cease to amaze me, Kody would love it.

Simply beautiful this is amazing...

Just wanted to go to bed and this came out. Love it....... gaahhh need to sleep, but can not stop listening to it.

*Celestia's answer* To my Faithful Student Twilight, it's been two hours. I was on the can. Chill the f*ck out. Sincerely, Princess Celestia

@normanclatcher

3 жыл бұрын

"Letter From a Disgruntled Friendship Teacher."

@michaelvicario2584

3 жыл бұрын

Ok

@michaelvicario2584

3 жыл бұрын

Yes

@michaelvicario2584

3 жыл бұрын

Htankyou

I just wonder how can you be so incredible in making songs? each time you made one, just hearing five or six seconds I was already thrilled! and each time I am listening to them I always am thrilled again! you are the best! congratulations and never stop! (sorry if there are a few mistakes, I'm French ^^)

Instant subscribe and watch for updates. Sir, you are talented.

Ya know, Even with me just strumming along to this with power chords, it sounds so beautiful, like my emotions about this song reflect through the old Les Paul herself... Bravo, I say. Bravo. You absolutely need to keep doing this. You're an amazing artist who has potential...

yyyyeeahh, man. was a pleasure to play in this and in every single thing I've worked with you on thus far.

Thanks for the help :3 I really appreciate it

This greatly reminds me of "Of Monsters and Men". You did a really great job of creating this song. I love it man.

Okay, new favorite artist. I've listened to some of your other songs, and can easily say that, without a doubt, you're my favorite.

@Ash21

8 жыл бұрын

Indeed.

this is really good and the image fits the song in a way like the slow tempo and how it's kinda sad very beautiful

Oh...ow...the feels. Oh, why do I keep listening to this. The feels really hit hard this time around.

Your songs are always very emotionally driven, I love it. :D

Oh holy hell... this is so sad... Wow. Great work.

This is sad, but beautiful. Great job

Never heard this until it poped up in my mix. happy it did.

Love it thanks 4everfreebrony :)

I love you. You are my favourite musician and nothing will ever change that, you are just amazing. I love you

@4everfreebrony

8 жыл бұрын

+The Angry Owl Will share your nice comment with Garrison in our next email!

this musik is the perfect fit to the fanfic reading of the same genre , very well done , its really deep touching

When someone doesn't reply after 10 minutes. Nah I'll be series 😂 this is really good and it is extremely emotional, amazing 👍🏻

This is beautiful

Beautiful

Even in a sauna, which is colapsing into the sun, I would simply get goosebump by just listening to this song.

God this topic doesn't seem like it'd be that sad, but that is so wrong, great job with the song, very beautiful, and very heartbreaking at the same time.

Somehow this song pops up on random shuffle mixes for me to this day. It still holds up.

Simply amazing song. There's very few songs that can get me to tears after just one listen and this is one. Thank you for creating it. -thedarkprep