I've given up on trying to figure out Kathleen. It's not like using a photo is anything rare in this series. Quite a number of artists do it and some who have done so have won. Yet she complained about it this time. She's inconsistent. Whatever. The artist created an amazing portrait and the sitter was happy with it too. That's what's important.

@pdatnc

10 ай бұрын

Very true. I watch these shows for the great art - no matter how they get there. I don't really believe in "judging" art, far too subjective.

@barbaraolson6783

10 ай бұрын

Yes a photo always remains in place, does not require a break, change of position. Photos have been used by artists, since photos became available. I use photos for landscapes as well. Light and shawdow remain constant in a photo.

@hogwashmcturnip8930

10 ай бұрын

​@@barbaraolson6783 Many older and great painters used 'tools' The Camera Obscura for example. There is no other explanation for how art suddenly leapt from children's drawings to the immense works of art we revere today. So I have No problem with someone using a phone.

@teresat5496

10 ай бұрын

I think it's pure art snobbery like not using black

@pamelacorbett8774

9 ай бұрын

Quite agree, it’s the results that count, not a happy comment from a judge.

It made me so happy to see David run out and shake the artists' hands with such genuine eye contact

Kathleen sometimes i think just say stuff just to have something to say. I've been watching this series for a bit, and it's not the first time someone used their phones. She wasn't even the only one in this episode who was using her phone, and yet she said the girl was "copying" the picture. That was a ridiculous thing to say.

For once agreed she did a terrific painting of David.

@TheDrohani

10 ай бұрын

2A2A2A2 T

The runners up were so gracious. I have been the winner of categories in competitions in my time and not everyone who doesn’t take home the prize is as gracious. This made me very emotional. Each artist was gloriously talented and I loved every moment of this, but Hetty was exceptional and this win was so well deserved.

The critics obvioulsy don't paint. "Copying reality" is ALOT harder than finding your inner artist.

Firstly, it's great to see a show celebrating artistry of any kind. I wasn't aware of any "live" portrait competition; what a great idea. The winner worked off a cell phone snapshot, which was an interesting choice. She nailed the likeness, obviously, and imbued the image with painterly energy. I thought it was the outstanding rendition. In portraiture, there is a tension between accuracy, and giving a painting or drawing something extra and unique. Someone mentioned Picasso, and I'm reminded how photography offered a way to essentially supplant portrait painting with a rapid alternative, so portrait painters became less documentarians in the 20th century, and more visual explorers. Now AI is entering the domain with computer generated art, which can create a near perfect likeness with painterly flair. Fortunately for artists, having a one-of-a-kind, tangible object, like a hand painted portrait, has added value due to its uniqueness as a real object, a fact that digital art simply cannot not get around. And, people are impressed with a good, free-hand drawing or painting. There's a guy gaining an online presence with his clips of himself drawing NYC subway riders, and presenting them with the finished sketch. He's quite talented, and built up a pretty massive following. So, ya, the market for art is alive and well.

I am an artist as well and i think the winner is the one that I am truly expecting! She did a great job of putting a swoosh texture on the face and the dripping red paint. The likeness was a masterclass as well. GREAT WORK!!! TRULY DESERVING❤❤

I cried when David made his choice! Well done!!!

The winning portrait was brilliant!

Loved so many of today's pieces. Hetty's self portrait is a gem. Can't believe none of Michaela's portraits made it to the shortlist. They were stunning, as was she!

wow the light is coming from one side, what a masterful unique skill which definitely not everyone does

Hetty Lola deserves it....and she is so young!!!

Loved this All great artiist. Special congrats to the young beautiful lady winning firstt....my choice as welll.

What a nerve wrecking experience! To have all those people looking at you while painting would make me so nervous!

Bravo!! She was my pick from the beginning!!! ❤❤❤

Glad she won after that judge compared using her phone for reference as "tracing".

Also the other Artist that left her pallet on the painting, I liked that a lot, like the Echer hand drawing, hand drawing it's own hand, this somewhat reminded me where the portrait comes from, so many times there is Nothing left but what the Artist sees, not where it comes from, the process

3:09am in Seattle, WA and I can't stop watching until the end!

I kept hoping…the red one!

thank you for posting this! I've never been able to find any episodes past season 3 (plus sometimes the most recent ones). Please keep up with them!

Inspired to continue learning my painting. This was truly a wonderful experience to watch!

Wish these were in order, they're so hard to find!!

Just found this. What an amazing show

I Liked the drips running down in the portrait , for such realism, I mean PERFECT, TO LEAVE IN the paint drips was like flesh and blood

All magnificent portraits!

Painting portraits..womens exellent..talent good job 👍

Thanks so much for posting these!

Thanks so much for posting! Could you please post other episodes of this season? Thanks 😊

@linengray

8 ай бұрын

This is the series from 2018. I am sure you can find other episodes already posted.

Thank you, that was such a joy to watch ❤

Loved this.

This is the best thing on KZread

Magnifique, Bravo💯👋👋👋.

Minute 22:40 I see a fantastic portrait emerging!

How exciting.

I am so addicted to watching this competition. It’s so inspiring and just plain beautiful and compelling, as well as inspiring as an artist. I find it curious that I always manage to choose the painting each sitter chooses to go home with them as their favourite. I’m not sure why exactly. That said, I don’t always know how the judges are going to choose their favourite for the top prize, that one occasionally stumps me. 💜💜💜

Thank you!

I kind of hate that it is a competition. Cos all of them look soooo great. It's such a pity rather than just look at all of them individually in their own worth. That you keep comparing them now. 🥴

Amazing!

VERY , VERY USEFUL

I chose her from the begining..I am an artist.

Excellent, love the concept and watching all the artists. Love all these creative people. Love light to all.

Opinons on art are subjective. Why do art competitions exist? Why would someone ever want to be rated by some narrow minded critics? Their opinions don't matter anymore than anybody else. And frankly, why care about what anybody else thinks? There will be *somebody* who is drawn to anybody art.

@LauraBCReyna

6 ай бұрын

Art competitions exist as a form of PROMOTION. They promote the sponsoring organization, art as a medium-- in order to expose new generations & keep it going. And they promote the artists themselves. Because this is a televised competition it's done a lot of good for the careers of the participating artist.

@Federgeistchen-cg2nr

5 ай бұрын

I agree with the previous commenter. For not yet well established artist or even amateur artists, art competitions can be a great way for being discovered and making connections.

I can’t believe I can’t find anything from Alan Speed online! He’s so good!

Kathleen struggles with someone working from a photo, but doesn’t struggle with the grid?

As a fellow artist, all lovely paintings and mixed mediums. However, I have to disagree with the top 3 finalists here, Charlie, Hetty, Charlotte should've been in the top

I wonder if the artists who manage to be chosen for more than one opportunity to participate are asked to come back by the judges who like them but couldn’t necessarily give them a win initially, or, do they have to re-submit for each leg of the competition. There have been many repeat artists over the span of the seasons. It’s cool to see actually. Don’t give up after a “no”!

Maybe she mentioned it before and it just didn't make the cut. They can't put every little detail into the episodes ... 🤗 So happy for the girl, she's a great artist ❤🎉

Two things: I wish the "comedians" wouldn't try so hard to be comedic. I wish that competitors wouldn't be allowed to come back. Aside from those, I love this show.

I think that's the first time I've got it right.

Wonderful! Let's stay in touch.

This is from 2018. The new series does not start until October this year.

If painting from a photo is like tracing, everyone could be an accompanied artist. Judge Katherine sounds jealous of this lovely young girl's talent, and that's not a good look.

They’ve turned everything into a competition … sad & pathetic. They were all good. But congrats to whomever won.

I don't normally agree with the judges, but they got it right this time. But as for the copying comment, It's just as hard to copy an ipad image. You've either got it or you haven't, and the winner has definitely got it. Shame about Judith's. I think she cold have won if she had left the painting alone after the first hour and omitted the red/pink bruise on his head.

I almost forgot there was a time people actually respected doctor who

The thumbnail made me think he was on trial for murder.

Eventually people will get so sick of KZread ads ruining their videos that they will just stop watching

@lobstermash

3 ай бұрын

They're trying to make you pay for Premium. It gives YT more money and cuts out the content creators' revenue from ads. Double greedy double nasty.

Ketrell ? I would told you to shove your contest...

@samcroft7084

10 ай бұрын

Nobody asked for your opinion José .

Id do anything to draw a portrait of real david tennant

This is SO old. 2022's competition was season 9, so this year (2023) should be season 10. This video is of season 4. Wish we could see this year's competition. I've seen older seasons.

I think that there should be a division of this portrait talent. It is FAR harder to pain from a person sitting in front of you as ooposed to painting from a picture that is 5 inches from your canvas. She should not have been allowed to work from her phone, imo.

@snusmumrik1910

9 ай бұрын

totally agree! although it came out good, it is unfair, not a real artist process. never liked realism because it is so close to photography. I was stunned by a portrait of Charlotte and Judith. they are artists, trying to catch the light or color and energy... that's the idea!

@somewhereupthere785

9 ай бұрын

@@snusmumrik1910 Yup, I agree completely.

Isn’t it all just copying… whether your copying the actual person or a picture of the person…

@richardwebb2348

4 ай бұрын

Degas used photos and tracing.

I guess I think they should have to wait a couple years before entering a second time, in order to give someone else a chance. The lady that was discussing the ears needs to stand back. She is paiting the ears too big. The judges are better this round

A copycat 😮…no

I actually hate this show. They try to make painting like Master Chef or something and a painter can't be judged by time. I watch it to see the art and the artists but it's a stupid concept..

@cjmatviyak6606

10 ай бұрын

Would like to see of thet completed in own time.

@jaimeochoa7256

7 ай бұрын

Love to see talent expressed in so many different ways...Congratulations to all!

I have the impression , by the very other english shows like this, that it is so predictable the result. They were content to have a very young woman in the competition. That' s it.

Nope. For a competition like this she was too reliant on technology. Why bother having the subject there, if you're just using photos to copy.

I didn't realize David Tenant had been tried for a crime.

luv this show, but I hate that they use photo taking, like common guys 🙂

@richardwebb2348

4 ай бұрын

Degas used photos and tracing.

What can I say? Yuck!!! I love how the judges try to save face as they try to explain away those messes (or more frightening, they were serious)

Why is this comment section filled with Americans criticizing? Were they expecting to see something like Kardashians?

I don't like any of them.

This is so sad that that type of painting is #1,a work from photograph..really?No wonder the art is in such a bad position nowadays

@tzeege

10 ай бұрын

Exactly. It totally defeats the purpose of having a model, just sitting there for 4 hours... And more importantly, it is infinitely easier to paint from a photo. This is cheating, plain and simple. I blame the judges though, they should know better.

@dr.wingdings4926

9 ай бұрын

Both of you are being absolutely ridiculous. Cheating? are you kidding me? if using photographs as references really were an issue they wouldn't have allowed it, and guess what, you'd have to say painters from the 15th century were cheaters for using the camera obscura as a painting resource. It is also quite silly to claim that the portrait chosen by Tennant "won" or whatever, he just liked it a lot.

@tzeege

9 ай бұрын

@@dr.wingdings4926 Yes, the Renaissance painters were cheaters for using the camera obscura.

@richardwebb2348

4 ай бұрын

Degas used photos and tracing.

some of them used photo, are you kidding me xD drawing from photo you basically copying 2d image on 2d canvas, and the main thing is - you will never get the REAL life colors and proportions that human eyes can see.

The paintings of the girl were awful ,they name her look like she’s scowling,The judges always see something in crappy paintings ,but the winner was the right choice,

James Morrison needs to stop moving and talking so much. As an artist, fidgety sitters are so annoying to me. Not that they shouldn't move occasionally and subtly to deal with crapping and stiffness, all those huge gestures, talking and head movements are frustrating (and inconsiderate) --- to me. Michaela talked when she was asked questions, she didn't change her pose or make big movements. Just sayin...The middle portrait of Michaela was terrible!!! I'm not sure why she liked that one. Oh well...

Judith should have won this. Both her paintings were incredible. She captured feeling and artistic interpretation. The winner did a good photo copy basically.