3rd World GTA - [171 review]
Ойындар
an old lesson we often must relearn...........
if you want more information about the things i cover in this video, please visit www.mixmods.com.br/2022/11/jo...
the takeaway is this: 171 is built on a lot of hot air. there's NOTHING wrong with using pre-made assets to help aid the game development process, but only if you're using them correctly and know what you're doing. Betagames seems to have no idea how to actually make an efficient game and is relying on a heavy use of pre-made blueprints to hack their build together. that can only take you so far. the game feels like its being held together with duct tape and bubble gum, and as an early access title I feel like it's a bad investment. They made $75k+ in crowdfunding alone, but the gameplay at its core is mostly made up of $500 worth of pre-made code and assets. Now they're releasing it for $30. Hell no. Don't buy into the hype. As soon as they can code something that isn't a janky checkpoint chase, then maybe it'll be worth a second look. "well to be fair it IS pre-alpha"... yeah which is more reason why $30 is an ABSURD price they're asking for.
I Made a GTA V Clone in 24 Hours - @reubs
• I Made a GTA V Clone i...
Пікірлер: 391
See, the game is perfectly realistic, that's just what life in Brazil is like. Choppy, glitchy and full of random violence.
@Mateus_Carvalho
Жыл бұрын
...Eh, in a way.
@lacryingbaby3005
Жыл бұрын
200th like
@semioval
Жыл бұрын
And bad
@izabelaguedes3444
Жыл бұрын
Aqui é oh Brasil kkkkkk
@izabelaguedes3444
Жыл бұрын
Orgulho de ser brasileiro kkkkkk
Flippy: "Stop calling 3rd world games GTA clones" Also Flippy: "New 3rd world GTA clone"
um, sorry about the choppy footage, game was killing it.. to my friends in Brazil.. you might have to take the usual L on this one... rooting for you in the world cup.. for pele.. also please recommend some games for me to play, thx :)
@xbmpr
Жыл бұрын
Come to Brazil
@fredster594
Жыл бұрын
I'd really like if you made analysis playthroughs like your SR1 series for the games you played in the PS2 era. Judging from your worst glitches videos, you seem to know a lot about games from that era.
@AdamLB
Жыл бұрын
Assassin's creed ezio collection
@ejpsucks
Жыл бұрын
Nuclear Throne
@skatermanbuns
Жыл бұрын
Its okay I didn’t even know this was a game until now
Damn, that's the best looking crate I've ever seen made in blender
@Lua0x07
Жыл бұрын
hello again mr godzilla
@zerozeroone4424
Жыл бұрын
Waddup playa
@flameguy3416
Жыл бұрын
So close to 100k
@mrsaintsgodzilla21
Жыл бұрын
@@Lua0x07 Hello :)
@mrsaintsgodzilla21
Жыл бұрын
@@zerozeroone4424 Sup playa
In case you are not aware yet, 171 is the Brazilian Penal Code for 'embezzlement', so the title is very fitting.
The timer running out thing wasn't a bug, when time runs out on a delivery job you still can deliver the thing but you don't get any money and the person complains about you being late
@Flippy
Жыл бұрын
appreciate it
@janpaulus3977
Жыл бұрын
ANY money? bro these people are ruthless, at least give me a little bit of the money, I still delivered the fuckin package
@XR_TheOneAndOnly
Жыл бұрын
each delivery gives you money unless you're late, let's say that you managed to do 2 deliveries on time but got late on the last one, you will receive the money from the other 2 but not on the one you were late
@KoKoKen
Жыл бұрын
30 seconds or less
you know saints row is bad when this asset flip is worthy of a video
You know it's Christmas whenever Flippy uploads a new video.
@youtubecreators789
Жыл бұрын
I never expected You being here
perfectly placed video, I must say, flippy. I, as a Brazilian, am ashamed of the existence of this game that for many of us is almost a SCAM they stayed for 10 years, raising a total of more than 300 thousand R$ using crowdfunding to end up releasing just a pre-alpha with no content other than a ''gta clone freeroam'' with boring delivery activities. and all the lies and dishonesty, lack of transparency with the community that helped the devs asking money for things like ''mocap equipment'' to end up using free animation assets using assets to achieve the goals faster wouldn't be a problem, but when 95% of the game is made of cheap assets and nothing really programmed by devs. and yet with all those assets and crowd campaign they can just release some alpha, yes it becomes a problem. the problem is that Brazilians want to be proud of having something about our country so bad, that they take projects like these and hype them up, when in fact there are other Brazilian games with a lot of talent, less production budget, and that still manages to be much better than 171, with more quality and more content.
@nomoretears_
Жыл бұрын
I agree, and there ARE some great projects that come from Brazil that people should pay more attention and be proud of like Automobilista 1 and 2, made by Reiza Studios. We have the potential, we just need to be made less of a fool for scammers lol
@noisyguy4013
Жыл бұрын
@@nomoretears_ Exactly, and real good examples btw people defending this alpha project like it was some type of masterpiece meanwhile other projects with really good content and overhaul quality like Automobilista, unfortunately are very unknow...
@sirlimen333
Жыл бұрын
So there really is nothing to be proud about Brazil huh.
@noisyguy4013
Жыл бұрын
@@sirlimen333 this is not true Brazil has many good games, with real good quality and plenty of content, unfortunately most of them are just not popular enough... 171 is an exception of something bad in the brazil industry, but there are many good games that brazilians can be proud of.
@KrackBoySlim
Жыл бұрын
What are the other games?
As a brazilian, it feels good to see a video talking against this game, it's seriously stupindeous how many many YTers out there, brazilian or american, sucking off this game which sucks, our game industry has potencial but we have so many games like this that look like a asset flip scam, 171 is not even the first, you can search up for ''Rio - raised in oblivion'' and that one was even worse, cause it released in such a terrible state and now the creators even put NFTs...still, i wouldn't say we don't have good games, we have great ones like fobia st dinfna hotel, Dolmen, Dandy Ace and Toren, despite being well made they all fail to get attention simply because they aren't a cheap knock-off from AAA games like call of duty and GTA.
@Hugal.
Жыл бұрын
Verdade irmão, Pulling no Punches is also a great brazilian game made by a small company.
@goosechaser13
Жыл бұрын
Dolmen is a horrible game too lol remove it from that list
@icarommartins
Жыл бұрын
Wolfstride e Dodgeball Academia tmb
3rd world gta is actually new saints row
$30 for this? My guy you best get that refund
@Flippy
Жыл бұрын
you know it
@whoelsebutmeofcoursei
Жыл бұрын
@@Flippy as a Brazilian I command you to refund
Haven't seen Brazil be this embarrassing since 7-1.
@Kadett-rr7ry
Жыл бұрын
Haven't seen the USA be this embarrassing since 9/11
@henkjeoma8069
Жыл бұрын
Oof
@whoelsebutmeofcoursei
Жыл бұрын
Nowhere near as embarassing as electing a mob boss this election *cries in português-brasileiro*
@Mateus_Carvalho
Жыл бұрын
I think you're underestimating our criativity.
@tardwrangler1019
Жыл бұрын
@@Mateus_Carvalho youre creative with your spelling, alright
3:03 I mean, if by Brazil you mean Rio de Janeiro (or more specifically, the favelas) then you're right -- this game represents that place pretty accurately Brazil is such a diverse place that even the cartels' modes of operation are different wherever you go
@louisalex98
Жыл бұрын
It looks more like a suburban São Paulo...
@ConnorDWolves
Жыл бұрын
But the game is in São Paulo, not Rio, caralho
@FrancisBaconDoMuayThai
Жыл бұрын
@@louisalex98 WTF bro???, you two are both Brazilians, why the fuck are you talking in english?
@StarmenRock
Жыл бұрын
This game is about São Paulo lol you can clearly see it by the houses and the graffiti
It’s weird to think that I’ve been watching you for a decade and still get excited when you upload 😂
@Matt0482
Жыл бұрын
And I’m only 18☠️
When unknown Brazilian indie devs do a better gangster game than, well... that game we shall not name.
@InternetMouse
Жыл бұрын
Agreed. The less we talk bout THAT game. The better.
@Fabriciod_Crv
Жыл бұрын
@@InternetMouse Pão com Linguiça!
@synque7296
Жыл бұрын
what're you scared of their wholesome progressiveness?!
@SpikeRose
Жыл бұрын
Ah yes, better than 50 Cent: Blood on the sand?
@superdrinkingpepsi
Жыл бұрын
@@SpikeRose That's simply not possible Blood on the Sand is a damn masterpiece
These games are kind of a meme in the Brazil Dev community. There is always that guy who enters the dev Voice Chat just to say "What if we made (Game that already exists) *bUt iN BrAzIl*?" And most of people will defend the game just because it is labeled as "X" game but in Rio or São Paulo, even though the game is dogshit.
yea, this game mostly served to taint the name of crowd-funded games even more and poison the well for any future ambitious game made in Brazil. the devs underestimated the costs, made a patchwork of pre-made assets and after so many years it's still in this state. I also wouldn't call it a scam, but it seems they bit way more than they could chew with the project
The drifting doesn’t break the laws of physics, Brazil just has different physics.
@megaman_oficial
4 ай бұрын
😂 Os caras não perdoam nem um jogo inacabado, que nem está pronto ainda.
@SDSypher
4 ай бұрын
@@megaman_oficial what are you saying
Damn I saw the Professional play this game. I thought a lot of the game was unique stuff the devs made, didn’t know a lot of it was reused assets
This game is just two dudes in a favela trying to get out of the slums with an Intel Celeron and crowd funding campaigns.
The map looks really cool for a super early build and it has potential. I agree with what you said about the money and pre-made assets. This game understandably looks broken and buggy, but I can’t imagine how difficult making a game like this is. I can’t imagine how difficult it is to even get the game to run as much as it does in this video, especially since I have no background in game making, probably like the person who made this game.
every new flippy video gives me so much serotonin its unreal
@whoelsebutmeofcoursei
Жыл бұрын
The amount of estrogen his videos give me is fan-tas-tic 💅
@uglify1325
Жыл бұрын
....engine.
Giga chad flippy. It must be Christmas morning and no one told me
The robot at 7:42 saying 'if you dont get your receipt, your purchase is free' in spanish gets me every time
joined the flippy grind again after 4+ years since the thug pro installation video
That's it. No more electricity for Brazil
Today I was in a spelling bee and I was told to spell out Goat. As soon as I heard this, I didn’t hesitate. “F-L-I-P-P-Y" Confetti fell, I had WON! All my teachers went on their knees and begged to marry me. My money went up by $10 million! Thank you TOP F🙏
@temp1326
Жыл бұрын
haha
Thanks Flippy. Hearing this valid criticism and taking it into consideration I don't think I will go to Brazil.
@whoelsebutmeofcoursei
Жыл бұрын
Your biggest mistake was thinking you had any power in deciding whether you got to Brazil or not 🖐👹🖐
babe wake up, flippy video
It's a flippy Christmas miracle! Welcome back buddy 😄
This and Gangstar New york are honestly looking like decent timekillers till the saints row 2 pc patch happens or gta 6 comes out
"171" is the code in our law for the crime of fraud, costing 30$ and having this specific name is very ironic also make a huebro happy finish you SR1 playthrough
I missed you so much daddy, thanks for actually coming back
As an indie dev-ish, it is ok to use pre-made assets if you're testing physics, code or anything that doesn't rely on a 're-invented' asset. But this should only be for gimmicks such as "I Made GTA VI In 24 Hours", demonstration or just practice. Most dev tutorials on KZread have you installing pre-made assets just to speed up the process of learning, while also teaching you how to import assets. It seems odd to take 10 years making something that only meets this caliber, but I also do not know the story behind it. I also think "Clone" should be used for those lacking in quality for a price of.. dignity. This is most likely inspired by GTA but I would not name it a clone since the devs may be naive rather than malice -- not making a quick cash-grab, but I could be wrong. It does have a lot more potential than what you can find in the "Great Theft Crime City 3D Simulator Life 一坨屎 5 Part 2" part of the app stores. EDIT 1: 30 Trx is too much for what this 'game' is. Sorry for the bad English.
oh hey flippy nice of you to upload the brazil simulator review!
Someone has to say things how they are. Everyone now is an “indie developer”, yeah right!
@eletgres519
Жыл бұрын
what the hell are you on about
@ldalipis
Жыл бұрын
@@eletgres519 About people that only use ready-made assets.
This looks like one of those videos games you would see in a TV show doing an episode about violent video games
Nice fursona Mr. Flipster
Lalo Salamanca
Game has potential hopefully the developers dnt give up on it
Finally that silky smooth voice is back
Thanks for the upload
The man in the last phot is henry Kissinger he made the coup stade in chile in 73 and make a eugenics program in Mexico,india,brazil,Argentina,china,Indonésia
Finally a good Saints Row game.
The ragdolls upon getting shot seem somewhat interesting. Seem somewhat close to how people are when they actually get shot instead of the GTA V dramatic injuries. Overall, it's likely a game driven by passion than it is a qualified production.
The interview uploaded in Live Leak 💀
It looks like they have a lot of potential
I doubt there was any premade assets used, however buying assets could have saved them time to put the effort where the game needs it.
CUIDADO E O FLIPPY
Great video Flippy!
Flippy trying SO HARD to avoid having someone call him "racist" for calling a trash Brazilian indy game "trash," LOL!
@whoelsebutmeofcoursei
Жыл бұрын
That's so stupid 😂 these people are dumb and are always out there ready to start an outrage... on top of that Brazil doesn't even have a race, not that they care tho, these types just want to signal-a-virtue
@Bomberman66Hell
Жыл бұрын
Braziltards will do it anyways.
Mmmmmmmmm gotta love the frame rate
Who is FLIPPY? To the blind, he is the light. To the starving, he is the bread. To the sick, he is the cure. To the lonely, he is companion. To the sad, he is joy. To the prisoner, he is freedom. To the poor, he is treasure. For me, he is my goat and arguably my god!
Well, to be fair it is Brazil. I have a friend there and it's exactly as third world as it seems in movies and games. Game development is hard there, almost mirroring how the Metro and STALKER games are made, but worse
Late ass upload but I'm here for it lol
Ive been wanting a brazilian gta for so long it would fit so well
The sheer liquidified fear that ran through my spine when I saw the notification is something I cannot express in words. It's a bit sad seeing Flippy review this when not only it is pretty much a scam, but also because some people are taking this as the best our country can do despite many well-crafted games like Horizon Chase and Momodora having been made here.
I've been following your channel for a while, but our Flippy, you should have done more research to make this video, as a Brazilian who likes the 171 game and also the mixmods mods, I have the property to explain a little more about the history of 171. To begin with, I agree with you that the price in dollars is a little expensive, but the rest of the information you said in the video is distorted because you didn't look at both sides, I questioned the developers about this price in dollars in their contact and they said that they got the price wrong and will reduce the price to about 15 dollars as soon as steam releases the possibility of changing the price again, it seems that Brazil does not have a tax agreement with the US and that is why companies here end up charging a little more because they are bi-taxed. To begin with: their first crowdfunding took place in 2019, since then it's been 4 years of development and $30,500 of investment excluding fees and costs with rewards, before 2019 the game was just an idea. The creator of the mixmods site also has a rival game of 171 that has been in development since 2015 and is more outdated, what I mean is that development time does not mean that they are fulltime in development, they are indies! If you want to look it up, the game is called IMPUNES. About the purchased assets, in fact any serious developer can say that 171 is much more than assets, they published a note on their page denying these accusations they received, they used some assets as a base, however it is visible that there is a lot of authorial work in on top of these assets, and there is a lot of programming in the game that is not for sale on the marketplace, just compare the assets on the marketplace with the mechanics present in the game, the car for example, they used purchased physics, but all the other mechanics that exist in the car are authorial: interaction with the characters, interaction with the player, interaction with the world, collision, damage, destruction, tuning, modified physics and handling, traffic artificial intelligence, police artificial intelligence, etc. The point is: if it's so easy to create an open world game, just buying ready-made assets and no additional work, why aren't there dozens of open world games like 171 in the indie market? and why is the mixmods site that has a rival game that started in the same year not better developed since it also uses assets? it seems strange to me that one competitor criticizes the other, don't you think it's strange? About the $16,000 to buy a day and night ready system for $39.99, actually this is another distorted information, the $16,000 is an extended goal of their crowdfunding, that means it is the first goal value of $11,000 + the additional value of $5,000 to complete the crowdfunding stretch goal, and that $5,000 would not only be for the day and night cycle, there are other mechanics included in the stretch goal, which require the work of several professionals In summary, the mixmods site has the habit of attacking and defaming creators in Brazil for their own promotion, and always using false information for the attack, he already did this with another well-known modder in Brazil called Julionib, he criticized him because Julionib used Patreon to make your mods. The content of your channel is of quality, I ask that you search and reconsider all the information presented in the video if you are interested in the truth.
@Rohit.Gaikwad
Жыл бұрын
That's why BetaGamesGroup posted in community tab
@beef9785
Жыл бұрын
This comment is the reason, brazilian game industry will never go foward and instead will be stuck with the basic, too much hype and defending obvious asset-flip games just because it's a popular genre in the mainstream.
30 USD is wild. But it's a lot of taxes tho, those guys have no big lawyers to help them evade that YET. In Brazil is only 10 USD, and it was every Brazilian kid's dream to have a GTA title set here, so this could be a game changer for us gamers and for game development.
A gente sabe que é foda quando a treta vai parar até na gringa
@whoelsebutmeofcoursei
Жыл бұрын
Pqp
@meritidodiano
Жыл бұрын
Papo reto
@joaoantoniogoldneraragao577
Жыл бұрын
Treta não, ele só analisou o jogo, e como programador viu de cara que tinha algo errado. Ainda acho que os youtuber br tão recebendo dinheiro pra falar bem do jogo, tipo uns 10% do que o jogo vendeu na Steam.
@asddw4998
Жыл бұрын
@@joaoantoniogoldneraragao577 Provavelmente, a quantidade de brasileiro fazendo vista grossa pro pedaço de merda que é esse jogo é preocupante.
hey flippy Thanks for this video, people around here are a little emotional about it, but the kids from Brazil spent years playing GTA San Andreas mods in favelas, so it would finally be an option to have something real related, so they bit the bait hard, investing on crowdfunding and buying the game in this state of development, which means it will possibly never officially release, which is sad.
is this man actually going to start uploading again
ever since I first saw this game I've been thinking this game just looks like a glorified tech demo
its yandere simulator all over again
@noisyguy4013
Жыл бұрын
exactly lol
@DR3ADER1
Жыл бұрын
Hell, Yandere Sim was much more polished than this, and that was a glorified debug mode, not a game.
Oh heck yeah! A new Flippy video!
Brother, did you play this on a toaster? Every other KZreadr I've seen play this game had it on better specs and the game looked much sharper.
Good insights, I was just directed to your channel since *my last vid offered a fair critique to the game too* (which i agree is rare), however I got some backlash and victimization from what I assume our colleagues of the dev's. My conclusion was to simply Wait for them to release the "big" update which would shut down all the so called "haters", so I'll be either staying tuned for the car crash.. or who know's.. maybe they pull it off somehow.
@paperclip9558
Жыл бұрын
Lmao, dont sweat it. They will never recover, this game definitely will crash and burn, then quietly abandoned, and forgotten.
i didn't even know 171 was a game. It sounded like a random number they asked their buddies for.
@whoelsebutmeofcoursei
Жыл бұрын
Pelo menos não é 24
@agabrield
Жыл бұрын
171 is a criminal code for fraud in brazil Kinda ironic if you ask me
@vinicioprod
Жыл бұрын
171 is the criminal code in Brazil for scam, wich is funny because that's exactly what this game is
@shincaion
Жыл бұрын
@@vinicioprod 171 é pra roubos e furtos
@vinicioprod
Жыл бұрын
@@shincaion furto é 155
I believe it was Steve jobs that said something like, an idea will get you started on your work, to finish it, you’ll need to leave your idea behind as your work will have no resemblance to it. There’s a concept here but it needs to be ground up into something palatable, with a lot of concessions as they seem unable to cope otherwise.
@spectrobit5554
Жыл бұрын
Hey man if you find the source of that quote I'd appreciate it. Searched it on Google but couldn't find anything.
@Journey_Awaits
Жыл бұрын
I believe I referred to this by Ive “Ideas are fragile. If they were resolved, they would not be ideas, they would be products. It takes determined effort not to be consumed by the problems of a new idea. Problems are easy to articulate and understand, and they take oxygen.”
Hello flippy, I give you a shoutout in my broken kenshin glitch vid in the description, thank you! Also upload some interesting glitches from the new SR Reboot, I know is not the best but glitches are always interesting and fun to watch.
@edward7434
Жыл бұрын
That entire game is a glitch.
@yxzl1l1l1l1l.7_ombieGlitcher
Жыл бұрын
@@edward7434 i know that already. bruhhhh
I too used to get all my developer commentaries from liveleak.
It's funny this game has legit potential.
30 dollars? my god, it is 10 bucks here in Brazil
@whoelsebutmeofcoursei
Жыл бұрын
Enough for being able to test a game , but not this one
Max Payne 3's open world DLC looks sick dude.
Good video
I'd love to make my own SR game in unreal but idk anything about this stuff
Hey Flippy. Have you ever thought of making a prequel to Saints Row? Something with Julius & King when they were teens?? Just saying you have enough love and street credit to pull something off. Great video 😊
@lisa1162
Жыл бұрын
ya, IP laws suck. Maybe a game about Julian Fries and Burger Queen?
@lovefunbeer
Жыл бұрын
@@lisa1162 bro there so much Fan stuff being made now a days that I'm sure there a work around. Look at all the DBZ comics made for example. Even hip-hop loops song parts. Fingers crossed.
Imagine Flippy playing Yakuza or No More Heroes.
More Flippy content, yes
unreal engine "developer" try to implement only-in-sight rendering challenge (impossible) with something like gamemaker unoptimized things are a little bit acceptable, but with the weight of an entire 3d rendered game with thousands of polygons on screen, you cant put off optimizing with more than unreal engines automatic backface culling
damn, thanks for pointing things out, I was really hyped for this game..
looked like pubg when u were on the bike lmao
5:40 From what I know of Brazilian developers, they are certainly qualified to develop quality games, especially because this developer is not the only one that exists, as several studios have launched successful games on different platforms.
I have a Rockstar like in mind ,but not really gonna do it this direct
OMG Brazil is a great setting for GTA like honestly imagine
Reminds me of Gangstar Rio, it was made by Gameloft but it's another GTA style game set in Brazil.
@whoelsebutmeofcoursei
Жыл бұрын
I laughed the whole time playing that game, everything is so cliche and stereotypical! It was like a Hollywood version of Brazil, I lmao'd
i've seen liveleak videos from brazil where guys wear the exact same clothes backpack and helmet as your character
@K3NSHIRODUBS
Жыл бұрын
Liveleak? Get upon on times, me and all my bros just use bestgore
is this still update?
@Rohit.Gaikwad
Жыл бұрын
Every 30 Days on Steam
Yeah, I like the game, but I want to wait until it's finished It's other people's choice if they wanna try it out early, I just wanna be patient
Brazil simulator?
I'm kind of disappointed flippy you didn't say deliver package Pizza drug combined all of them I was actually waiting for the joke
The brazilian Star Citizen.
The ragdolls are very weighty, and interesting.. that's like the only cool thing about it lmao
Ohhhh shittt
W
I mean it's literally $30 for a pre-pre-pre-alpha. They literally just have an open world, some side quests no story etc. I was assuming this was a jk game until u said it costs 30
It's so sad that, in the nine years since GTA V, there have been a grand total of zero good open world crime games that do anything better than a nine year old game thats been entirely neglected in favor of an online "experience". I hope this game can get better, but at this point, I'm starting to think it's just a cash grab to try and get some dough from people desperate for anything even remotely similar to GTA.
@onemorescout
Жыл бұрын
Watch Dogs 2’s NPC systems are the only real advancement, something entirely neglected in the next game
*Character Name is Nicolaus*
I was so not expecting to see flippy do a video on this. But i certainly welcome it. Im very happy we are getting much better gta competitors like 171. I even heard we might POSSIBLY be getting a new open world crime game from 505 games. They released a photo of their city known as rockay city. Its gonna be revealed at game awards. Cannot wait...