#107
-----------------Support the channel-----------
Patreon: / thedissenter
PayPal: paypal.me/thedissenter
-----------------Follow me on--------------------
Facebook: / thedissenteryt
Twitter: / thedissenteryt
I’M SORRY FOR THE VIDEO BEING A BIT DESYNCHRONIZED. IT MUST HAVE BEEN SOME SORT OF RECORDING ISSUE. THANK YOU FOR YOUR UNDERSTANDING.
Dr. Frederick Crews is an American essayist and literary critic, and Professor Emeritus of English at the University of California, Berkeley. Also, a prominent participant in the "Freud wars" of the 1980s and 1990s, a debate over the reputation, scholarship and impact on the 20th century of the founder of psychoanalysis, Freud. He’s the author of many books, including the ones that are relevant to our conversation today, The Memory Wars: Freud’s Legacy in Dispute, and Freud: The Making of an Illusion.
In this episode, we talk about how and why Dr. Crews decided to turn against Freud’s psychological theories, and his role against the Recovered Memory Therapy movement in the 80’s and 90’s, and the idea of repressed memories. We then move on to talk about Freud’s personality, and what led him to adopt a pseudoscientific academic approach. We cover some of his medical work and his main theories, like hysteria, the Oedipus Complex, dream analysis, and his organization of the unconscious. Finally, we discuss psychoanalysis in general, and if it is today something resembling a science at least.
Time Links:
00:58 When Dr. Crews turned against Freud
02:50 The Recovered Memory Therapy movement
05:56 Freud’s personality
12:55 Freud’s theoretical approach
14:34 Freud’s work on cocaine
20:56 The origins of hysteria
25:05 Hysteria and the Oedipus Complex
30:10 About dream analysis
36:07 Did Freud really discover the unconscious?
39:39 Deleterious effects of Freud’s practice on his patients
44:05 Is psychoanalysis scientific nowadays?
49:56 Why are Freud’s theories so intellectually appealing?
52:39 Follow Dr. Crews’ work
--
Follow Dr. Crews’ work:
Books: tinyurl.com/ybyhfbjh
Freud: The Making of an Illusion: tinyurl.com/y9dwsbuw
--
A HUGE THANK YOU TO MY PATRONS: KARIN LIETZCKE, ANN BLANCHETTE, BRENDON J. BREWER, JUNOS, SCIMED, PER HELGE HAAKSTD LARSEN, LAU GUERREIRO, RUI BELEZA, MIGUEL ESTRADA, ANTÓNIO CUNHA, CHANTEL GELINAS, JIM FRANK, AND JERRY MULLER!
I also leave you with the link to a recent montage video I did with the interviews I have released until the end of June 2018:
• MY CHANNEL - THE DISSE...
And check out my playlists on:
PSYCHOLOGY: tinyurl.com/ybalf8km
PHILOSOPHY: tinyurl.com/yb6a7d3p
ANTHROPOLOGY: tinyurl.com/y8b42r7g
#TheDissenter #FrederickCrews #Freud
Пікірлер: 38
Great 👍 , well-done lads
Great interview. I would definitely like to hear more from Frederick Crews.
@AgendaFiles
3 жыл бұрын
archive.org/details/frederick-crews-freud-the-making-of-an-illusion-audio
Fascinating conversation. Thank you both!
Thank you
Ironically , using Freud s own method shows us a very disturbed individual
I remember having tuff time in school with my teacher refuting some of this issues; i personally felt he has Been molested at his younger age and want to inflict everyone with his experience as normal so that he can escape the guilt INSIDE himself...so shameful
Just discovered this channel and I am loving it
Wow. What a found. Great channel. Thank you. Are you Portuguese?
@Lisboooa
5 жыл бұрын
@@TheDissenterRL ahh mundo pequenino! Muitos parabéns. Um canal impressionante. Um orgulho para a jangada de pedra.
Finally someone who evidenced the great epistemological problem of psychoanalysis: the divided mind
Jeremiah 17:9 The heart is deceitful above all things and beyond cure. Who can understand it?
Awesome interview! It baffles me how so little people know that Freud was a fraud and that psychoanalysis is pure pseudo-science !
4:20 21:35 28:45 32:00 46:00
cocaine. Freud: hi dear.
How does someone with a hispanic name come to have a thick Slavonic accent?
@gdrdm
3 жыл бұрын
Very, very heavy (European) Portuguese accent, actually. Many people remark that Portuguese sounds Slavic.
@brunomenezes1410
3 жыл бұрын
@@gdrdm yeah, as a brazilian portuguese speaker i can notice the european portuguese accent from miles away, so heavy
@xXxmixiacorexXx
2 жыл бұрын
@@gdrdm I once was hearing a video while washing dishes and a russian mathematic started to talk, and was like wooow this guy sounds totally like Mourinho
@kemalhasan3082
Жыл бұрын
He has a great command on the language , he makes almost no mistakes tho. Good speaker
Freud is just one in a long list of figures whose influence has been both immense and almost exclusively detrimental to human welfare. A list, not exhaustive, but just a list of the most tragically influential, would certainly include Rousseau, Marx, Freud, Boas and his disciple Margaret Meade, G.E. Moore (father of emotivism), John Watson, Theodore Adorno, Stephen J. Gould, Keynes in economics, Bultmann in religion, Jacque Derrida (deconstructionism), and Michel Foucault (post-structuralism). If anyone wished to argue that other names belong on this list, I would not strenuously object. There are so many of these misguided socially destructive individuals who are nevertheless elevated by academia, publishing and the mass media to the status of sages and moral guides that it is difficult to decide when to stop adding figures to the Hall of Shame list.
@lukejones7164
Жыл бұрын
The entire Enlightenment movement can be added to the list honestly, with few exceptions.
@RubenLensvelt
Ай бұрын
it's the rainbow brigade....
Freud was a freak!
Balck magician are the psycatrists of today....
As a guy who have had through psychoanalitical therapy for my recuperated OCPD for 4.5 years, furthermore, which was being my 5th therapist, after 4 behaviorist method treatment therapies, 1 cited as a clinical one, I stopped watching after he pronounced "I haven't been analysed". Additionally, just searched and found out that he isn't even a psychology graduate. Guys. Don't... 🙄
@drexle2002
4 жыл бұрын
"Being analyzed" just means you paid enough lol, you fool - funny how you feed your denial by trying to discourage people to listen to something you have fear to hear. You'll find plenty of people "analyzed" who realized Freud was a fraud, me included. Anyway, you believe what you want, but your post is just "funny", it's denial 1O1.
@MrYuzirneym
4 жыл бұрын
@@drexle2002 okay.
@renatika
4 жыл бұрын
Personal anectodal experiences are not evidences. Statistically there is always a number of people who will get better accidently but it is not science. Plus Freud wasn't psychologist either. He created his own religion that Yr mind obviously liked...
@michaels4255
4 жыл бұрын
"isn't even a psychology graduate" -- this "not invented here" mentality is one of the biggest things that is wrong with the social sciences. Real sciences like physics, chemistry, geology, astronomy and biology don't reject challenging ideas just because they come from someone in a different field.
In his book, unfortunately Crews repeats lots of fake stuff spread by the Freudians. Ask him about Emma Eckstein nose, haha.
One word.... JEWS
@crossroads670
Жыл бұрын
That's pretty silly, many of the psychologists who refuted his junk were jewish.
@zfvr
3 ай бұрын
Jews are great people, actually.