1.JS Bach Minuet 1 suite g minor BWV 822 2.Bartok Teasing song 3.JS Bach Invention C major BWV 772 4.JS Bach Gigue from Partita B flat major 5.JS Bach French Suite no 2 C minor BWV 813 5.5.Debussy La Cathedrale Engloutie 6. JS Bach Prelude and Fugue D major BWV 850 6.5. Beethoven sonata 27 7. Mozart sonata d major K576 7.5 Liszt Un Sospiro 8. Ravel Miroirs no 3 8.5 Rachmaninoff etude Tableaux Op 39 no 3 9. Albeniz Triana from Iberia book 2 9.5 Brahms piano concerto 2 10. Alkan Grande sonata op 33

It's interesting how the level of difficulty varies for different reasons. I marvel at anyone who can go past about a 5 on this scale. Nice renditions!

Wonderful performances, such clarity even in some very difficult pieces!

I’m learning all rach 39 etudes right now, (after having done the op 33 set) the thumbnail set me back to reality lol

@ryanting1707

2 ай бұрын

Caught you

@ryzikx

Ай бұрын

@@ryanting1707are you ryans piano dumpster or is that someone else?

@ryanting1707

Ай бұрын

@@ryzikx that’s me lol

nice playing!

я был удивлен, когда увидел что видео вышло 9 дней назад, а не 10 лет назад

NoIce

Where would the following pieces fit? (These are the ones I'm currently learning): - Chopin Ballade 1 - Beethoven Waldstein - Liszt HR2

@ericbouchard3745

2 ай бұрын

I would say all of those are around level 8. I based my levels 1-9 on the Henle Verlag difficulty scale (that goes from 1 to 9), and the Waldstein originally (before they changed the system) was ranked between an 8 and a 9, but I find Beethoven easier in general (ex. I would put appassionata at 8 and tempest at 7, instead of 9 and 8).

@-.a

Ай бұрын

​@@ericbouchard3745 I personally find the henle scale to be terrible (just look at the chopin preludes - no. 24 is a LEVEL 9) I'd also say b1 is way easier than hr2 and waldstein. i've played b2 and wouldnt even consider playing hr2 until i am more prepared

@ericbouchard3745

Ай бұрын

@@-.a Yeah, the Henle scale isn't always great. I was indeed confused at the ranking of prelude no. 24 (which I would rank at most an 8), and some Grieg lyric pieces and Rachmaninoff preludes op. 32 are ranked higher than they should be.

@-.a

Ай бұрын

@@ericbouchard3745 now just wait until you see henle rankings for violin

@octopuszombie8744

Ай бұрын

Waldstein and ballade 1 around 7.5, HR2 around 9. I find the HR2 way more difficult than most other people, I'd even rank it at the same level as chopin Ballade 4 since playing it with small hands is really tiring (you are like 5 times more likely to injure your wrist compared to, let's say la campanella.)

Cool I’m at level 1.5

@katttttt

2 ай бұрын

Same 😂 long way to go..

Where does Sonata Tragica fall in your classification?

@ericbouchard3745

2 ай бұрын

Maybe 8.5? Just estimating from looking at the score.

Where would you put maple leaf rag in?

@ericbouchard3745

2 ай бұрын

Level 5.5 ish

アルカンのop33は全体が演奏会用エチュードとしての性格を持ちます。 スケルツォの序曲:1楽章はなんと言ってもBPM300超えの脅威のスピードと練習曲らしい音の配列 2楽章も速く、特に注目されるのは、えげつない左手の跳躍や中間部の幅広い対位法旋律の維持だろう。 3楽章は緩徐楽章で、対位法旋律や和音で旋律を掻き消さない様に注意する必要がある事や、何より重音の無駆動が特徴的です。 4楽章はとても遅く、エチュードとしての効果は一見無いように思えるが、音をホールドする時間が長いのが特徴で、実はそれが指を強化する事に繋がります。

Can someone say me if its good to be at level 7.5-8 at 15 years old or bad?

@met-andre6007

2 ай бұрын

Nah you're good: i know a lot of pianists older than you with "your same level". Keep going!

@-.a

Ай бұрын

If you are just playing for a hobby it is pretty average if piano is your main instrument. If you want to go pro it is alright, but you won't be selling out concert halls.

Where would you put the late scriabin sonatas?

@ericbouchard3745

2 ай бұрын

Hmm... Sonata no. 5: 9.5 Sonata no. 6: 9 Sonata no. 7: 9 Sonata no. 8: 9.5 Sonata no. 9: 8.5 Sonata no. 10: 8.5 This is just an estimation, based on some opinions I got from other people. I took a look at a few of the sonatas, but I've only ever played the Scriabin fantasy.

@leoviridis

2 ай бұрын

Ha, Vers la flamme

Why is gaspard de la nuit ranked 9.5？It should be more difficult than the Brahms concerto. In addition to this, Why is the mozart K 576 ranked higher than Beethoven sonata 27?

@ericbouchard3745

2 ай бұрын

Beethoven sonata 27 IMO really isn't that hard technically (very personal, as I know this isn't necessarily the case for most people), while the K576 is much more twisty and requires greater clarity, speed, and dynamic control. As for Brahms vs Gaspard, Gaspard may be a little harder, but I wouldn't give it level 10, in that it's still within the realm of playable and pianistic (unlike the Alkan). The Brahms is very difficult to pull off since it has to be clean and there are several parts which are absurdly difficult (like the thirds in the last movement and a few parts in the first movement, such as the L.H. leaps and the rapid-fire scales), and I personally found it harder than Scriabin Fantasy, Triana, Ondine (from Gaspard), and even the Barber sonata, which is often ranked with Gaspard as the hardest piano piece. Again, this is all personal.

@octopuszombie8744

Ай бұрын

I would straight up put gaspard (especially ondine) at 10.

How about Beethoven’s appasionata and Chopin’s heroic polonaise?

@ericbouchard3745

2 ай бұрын

Having played appassionata, I would say that it's somewhere between level 8 and 8.5. I would put it closer to 8, but some people would put it higher. Chopin's heroic polonaise is around a 7.5.

@tomyang3797

2 ай бұрын

@@ericbouchard3745 how about Beethoven op 111, Chopin ballde No. 4, Chopin op 22, Bach BWV 848, Liszt Mephisto Waltz no.1, and Debussy's reflections in the water?

@ericbouchard3745

2 ай бұрын

​@@tomyang3797 This is very subjective, but here's some of my thoughts: Beethoven op. 111: 8 or 8.5 Chopin Ballade no. 4: 8.5, but some people would say 9 Chopin op. 22: 8.5 Bach BWV 848: 5.5 or 6 (if I base myself on the Henle Verlag system, which my scale is derived from), never played or tried playing this one so don't know Liszt Mephisto Waltz: 8.5, but I found it to be harder, closer to 9 (a little easier than the Scriabin Fantasy, which would be a middle-tier level 9) Debussy reflections in the water: 7.5

I guess I am at 7.5 or 8

Please bro, I know much more difficult pieces than the ones you showed here ;)

Magari se ne la chatedrale engloutie il pianista avesse suonato il pp dove c'è scritto e non mf o f sarebbexstato keglio

@ericbouchard3745

Ай бұрын

I was 12 years old in that recording, so I wasn't at my highest level yet.

Alkan is not the most difficult and he is trash too

@octopuszombie8744

Ай бұрын

He simply said it's level 10, never said it was most difficult (And yes I agree alkan kinda sucks)