The dumbest of all dumb things is that KK actually made the decision to make a sequel trilogy without a story. Her plan to just make it up after each movie was not just dumb, it was genuinely baffling. How she kept her job after that mess is beyond me.

@thecunninlynguist

3 ай бұрын

yeah. you'd think since she's been part of some of the most beloved trilogies...she'd know to plan one out.

@megatronjenkins2473

3 ай бұрын

This. Just this. This could've been the ENTIRE LIST.

@Skute

3 ай бұрын

But that’s not really what happened. There was clearly an outline of where to go. The original script for episode 9 is more in line with following up the last Jedi. They just changed direction midstream due to the backlash

@megatronjenkins2473

3 ай бұрын

@@Skute oh? You were there in the writing room? THEN WHY DIDN'T YOU FIX THIS SĤIT?!?

@kenbrown2808

3 ай бұрын

this point is mentioned way too rarely.

Not having the big three share a scene is unforgivable

@ahlija

3 ай бұрын

I understand they wanted to go somewhere else but putting the 3 in the movies was a nobrainer. They had to share some time together. Plus the whole sequel was an absolute disaster, at least the fans would have gotten that moment.

@DavidLLambertmobile

3 ай бұрын

Part of it was KK, Lucas deal. Disney-KK had to pay license, trademark fees. $$$. 📂 Disney & ILM wanted to swing away from OT characters, ships, planets as soon as possible.

@sergiocarmona2424

3 ай бұрын

Agreed

@usernamunavailiable

3 ай бұрын

Actually it was dumb and pointless for any of them to be in these movies.

@ahlija

3 ай бұрын

@@usernamunavailiable You have a point, especially after what they did with them.

How about Rey being somehow a) a strong swimmer and b) an expert sailor despite growing up on a desert planet?

It's a good thing WhatCulture decided to list ten of the dumbest things in the Sequel Trilogy. If they had decided to list all of the dumbest things in the Sequel Trilogy, it would be a six part video with two hour run times each.

@silentxero5955

3 ай бұрын

Absolutely 💯 !!! Mauler (Longman) and The Critical Drinker have made hours of epic stupidity found in the Sequel Trilogy.

T H E E N T I R E T H I N G

Not having Luke & R2, Han, Leia, and Chewy in a scene together is definitely number 1 for me. Hell, I'd have settled for just Luke, Han, and Leia. In over seven hours of film across three movies, they never share the screen together. It's baffling. And what they did to Mark Hamill's character is just criminal. It's as if whoever wrote Luke's parts had never seen any Star Wars media and had no idea who he was. I can see him going into exile after what happens with Kylo. But once Rey finds him and asks for his help, he would be back in the fight immediately. Mark Hamill has talked about this so much. It's just awful.

@zshah3107

3 ай бұрын

What about Lando Calrissian & also Mara Jade?!

@jonathanmarkoff4469

3 ай бұрын

@@zshah3107 Mara Jade actually was considered in the earliest developments for Ep 7. But then Disney-Lucasfilm decided to excise anything good from the movie.

Good Lord, the whole trilogy was incredibly dumb.

@nickwilliams7940

3 ай бұрын

You got that right

What they did to Boyega was just criminal... So was not having Luke and Han share a SINGLE scene. For me the utter look of real disgust on Isaac's face when he's told "say the line or you don't get paid" perfectly sums up the sequels.

@Paul_McSeol

3 ай бұрын

I’ve seen screen shots of the Game of Thrones actors doing table reads for the final season. They look confused and dismayed. I imagine the actors for RoS looked much the same.

@jayl878

3 ай бұрын

Not having Han, Luke, and Leia in a single scene together was ridiculous. Yoiu haved the most iconic trio ofcharacters in cinerma history and not even oner scene. I feel Boyega was used too. They wanted to show the "New and Diverse Star Wars" in the magazines and trailers. I feel the whole fiasco about him being a black stormtrooper was staged. They knew that a lot of fans were under the impression that all stormtroopers are clones so when a black man is the VERY FIRST shot of the first trailer was his in a stormtrooper uniform (With ZERO dialogue or explanation) there would be questions and some outrage. Maybe 1% of the fans were racist but the rest just didn't understand why there was a stormtrooper that didn't look like Boba Fett. They made no attempt to exploit it and just watched the media swell as people called fans racist and others saying doesn't matter the race, he should look like BF. They loved the free exposure. They set SW fans up to be called racist and "manbabies."

@amitypredator9385

3 ай бұрын

Not only did Luke and Han not share a scene, Luke and Han and Leia don't share a scene. Freaking Lando doesn't get to say goodbye to his old pal. The sequels suck.

@patrickbarnes9462

3 ай бұрын

​@@jayl878re: Luke, Han and Leia...THANK YOU.

@Azure_Fire

3 ай бұрын

I can forgive them for that at least. There's no way Harrison Ford was coming back without them killing off Han, and having Luke show up early would diminish the impact of the final scene. You gotta remember, these movies are supposed to be about the new generation, not the OT trio. Boyega did get robbed though. Imagine this: instead of the stupid Canto side mission, Rose is deadset on avenging her sister. Finn talks her down and Leia sees that Finn has the potential to be a Jedi. Then instead of spending the movie in a coma, she teaches Finn the ways of the Force in her own way, while Luke trains Rey in his own way. The Last Jedi ends with Luke still dead, but both Rey and Finn are ready to lead the charge as Jedi in Episode 9.

TFA 10: Finn is instantly given a back seat 9: Rey knows how to fix the Millennium Falcon better than Han Solo 8: Lightspeed skipping 7: Rey beats Kylo Ren in battle. Just hearing stories about the Force is enough to use it, apparently TLJ 6: Bombers in space 5: Leia flying back to the Republic ship 4:The Holdo manoeuvre 3: Luke not being there in person on Crait TROS 2: Force Dyad and all the bullplop that came with it 1: Palpatine (somehow) returns Bonus Dumb 0: "I'm Rey, Rey Skywalker."

@jaykoops9502

3 ай бұрын

In a Star Wars encyclopedia on the ships, it was explained that the bombers were able to drop their load in space because the bombs were supposedly magentized and I guess were attracted to the surface of the Dreadnaught.

@Anthyrion

3 ай бұрын

@@jaykoops9502 That still sounds like a try, to explanate that crap. I mean, the Rebels HAD Bombers. B Wings and Y Wings. And both were a lot faster, then those things and equipped with better weapons.

@charlesjohnson7458

3 ай бұрын

Number #2 Mary Poppins moment and Number #1 - Luke not knowing about Han's death when in ESB, Luke could feel his friend being hurt.

@mar.s6516

3 ай бұрын

I dont see prob. with Rey fixing Falcon, hey she was taking apart and tinkering with ship parts whole life prob almost every day and Han was never technician specialist - he was more like long time "truck driver" (pilot in SW univ.) who knows his rig and can fix minor things or coax few bugs to make things go, but most real techs/ship repairmen would know much more about that stuff than him. And force dyad could be pretty interresting concept IF they done it well(not shirtless Kylo), SW universe is huge you cant be opposed to every new thing introduced with force, plus there is plenty unique force powers in old legends, in other games - KOTOR, SWTOR - you have some very unique and COOL powers there (Battle meditation,Force bonds and more) that werent mentioned in movies at all, but i would love to see them in future. ...Agree with rest.

@johnserrano9689

3 ай бұрын

Enough talking shit about completely disappointed fans calling us racist...that's not racism you piece of shot all you and people like you do with that trashy shit is take away from actual racism. Racism is not and will not be tolerated against any race, from ANY RACE its called being an adult. Perhaps one of the biggest and more important facts of being an adult is you have to be able to deal with reality and the real world.

The second Death Star appearing almost entirely intact after being completely atomized in Return of the Jedi was one of the worst ret-cons I've ever seen.

@Swiftbow

3 ай бұрын

It was absurd... even if large pieces survived the explosion (which they clearly didn't), those pieces would then be burned up during reentry. And even if they SOMEHOW survived reentry... they would shatter even more on impact with the surface. The size of intact wreckage shown in the movie would have caused an impact crater and massive surface devastation. And, of course, it would not be intact. It's like the writers forgot that this thing was in space, and not some castle standing on a cliff.

@matthewpatrick7263

3 ай бұрын

@@SwiftbowThose same writers don't know gravity doesn't work in space.

1. Disney being in charge of making the sequels

All valid points. I’d also add: building THOUSANDS of star destroyers in a dark corner of the galaxy, fully manned and trained. Like…what? No liberty? No breaks? No one noticing the planets full of materials needed to make so many ships and man them in such a short time? Just sloppy and lazy…

Very pro Rian Johnson take here. How about 1: the casino scene 2: the overt reference to Jurassic Park 3: the holdo maneuver (literally no one ever thought of that before in the history of space flight? How about it accidentally happening in the history of space flight? 4: Mary Poppins Leia 5: the subtle as a brick “war profiteering is bad” 6: [some windows were crashed at a casino] “that taught the war profiteers!” 7: leaving the guy you met 10 minutes ago in the room as the Rebellion reveals its secret plan 8: the Rose/Fin/Rey love triangle 9: killing admiral Akbar as disrespectfully as possible 10: Luke dying of mental exhaustion

@dronesclubhighjinks

3 ай бұрын

Agree. What did Leia die of? Force skyping her hideous son?

@null6634

3 ай бұрын

The difficulty when making a list like this is that you cannot possibly include everything. The channel included some, you have others. The trilogy was hot garbage from start to finish, but the biggest failure was in not having a coherent plan before starting and sticking to it.

@joaopedrorosa6198

3 ай бұрын

11 - There were pointed to the only guy in the universe that could crack some kind of code, in the casino. It just so happens that a random guy starving in a cell can do just the same thing.

@iceman90734

3 ай бұрын

Top 10 dumb things in the Sequel Trilogy is literally impossible...as MOST scenes, individually, can be on the list

@oliverklosov5153

3 ай бұрын

I totally agree. The folks at Whatculture are obviously Rian defenders. He and Kathleen Kennedy are the ones who ruined the franchise with their liberal agenda.

The greatest Star Wars villain of all time is Kathlyn Kennedy for disregarding Lucas' idea for the sequel trilogy after telling him they would absolutely, 100% use his idea when they were negotiating to buy Lucasart.

@mar.s6516

3 ай бұрын

So Sith lord in next SW movie will be Mickey with KK as his new apprentice? 😆🤪

@Azure_Fire

3 ай бұрын

That's a weird way of spelling "Troy Denning"

@namikstudios

3 ай бұрын

The Ahsoka series is a lot closer to what the sequels should have been, focusing on the Imperial Remnant and Grand Admiral Thrawn and partly based on Timothy Zahn's well-liked books. Much better than inventing a totally new story involving the First Order which wasn't well thought through at all. I think Disney just got waaay too excited and waaaay too ahead of themselves. They are capable of making enjoyable Star Wars stuff: Rogue One, Mando, Obi-Wan, and Ahsoka are all quite good, certainly much better than the sequel trilogy. Solo is also pretty good once you get over Harrison Ford not being in it.

I always wondered why Palpatine would have his essence put into a knarled, and disfigured clone missing fingers instead of a younger more vigorous one.

@Azure_Fire

3 ай бұрын

There's precedent. Whether it was intentional or not, Episode 9 took ideas from the 1991 comic Dark Empire where Palpatine's spirit returned in a clone body. Clones can't handle the Force very well, and Palp's dark side energy would cause his cloned bodies to age rapidly. The transfer process was...unpleasant so he'd wait until the last possible moment to transfer. Now I am not defending the choice to put Palpatine in the movie at all, it's just there's a lot of little things that fans like stick on: things that have long since been explained away in the EU.

@matthewpatrick7263

3 ай бұрын

@@Azure_FireBut KK claimed that the EU didn't exist.

@Azure_Fire

3 ай бұрын

@@matthewpatrick7263 So? Lore is lore.

@matthewpatrick7263

3 ай бұрын

@@Azure_FireMy point is their hypocrisy. They claimed none of it is lore, and then use small bits and pieces of it.

@Azure_Fire

3 ай бұрын

@@matthewpatrick7263 Yeah? Wanna know who else didn't acknowledge Legends but still borrowed ideas from it? George Lucas. Acquaint yourself with the real-life behind the scenes story about Coruscant, and then tell me if he's a hypocrite too.

"Somehow, Palpatine returned" is the stupidest sentence ever spoken in the history of cinema.

@collinturner5307

3 ай бұрын

I don't know I think THEY FLY NOW? is still worse.

@notwithintolerance

3 ай бұрын

@@collinturner5307 It's a close call, but I think "They fly now?!" can be written off as just a poor attempt at writing punchy banter, but Palpatine is just BAD handwaving nonsense for a critical plot line that is irredeemable.

@Doofwarrior88

3 ай бұрын

When I was in the Theater. Like 5 different people yelled "What?" When they heard that. And one person said f@#$ you

@totterdell

3 ай бұрын

Worst line in the history of film "Somehow Palpatine returned" Dumbest line in film history "They fly now!?" They have always used backpacks U idiots

@sonictemple2925

3 ай бұрын

So at first I thought this too, but if you think about it how was Poe supposed to know how he returned? The line is really not as stupid as people make it out to be. Also Palpatine returned multiple times in the EU and everyone praises the EU yet this is stupid? Now if Leia or Luke said something like that I’d find it questionable because I’d think they’d have an idea of how, but not Poe or someone that wasn’t knowledgeable of the force. Overall I enjoy the sequels, but I admit there is stuff that should have been better and stuff they seemed to just change total direction on. The shows are really leading up to showing how Palpatine came back I feel and let’s face it all 3 trilogies have done this and it’s been left to other books, comics, shows ir movies to explain.

This list is “What Culture loves Rian Johnson and blames JJ Abrams for the problems in the trilogy”

@dronesclubhighjinks

3 ай бұрын

Sure seems like it!

What are the 10 dumbest things in the Star Wars Sequel Trilogy... YES.

Want to describe the dumbest things in the Sequel Trilogy? Show all three movies and just include the caption, "This".

@dronesclubhighjinks

3 ай бұрын

🤣🤣🤣

Not having Han, Luke, Leia and Chewie in a scene together is the dumbest thing not done in the sequel trilogy.

The writers really owe these actors some apologies. They took a brunt of the punishment for their dumb decisions and direction.

I don’t think undoing Rey as a nobody was bad - the WHOLE PLOT of Rey’s parentage was stupid! It’s like why make her parentage a thing if she’s not tied to the original! It was a hook that made us invested in a plot then Rian effectively DROPS us! You don’t do that in stories!

@matthewpatrick7263

3 ай бұрын

If I wanted to undo what TLJ said, I'd just have claimed Kilo Ren was lying. I'd also point out that the Force didn't used to make people omniscient. Quigon Gin (forgive my spelling) didn't look at Anakin and know his parentage. He asked.

Rose was snubbed because she was a bad character full stop.

@Boomstick4life

3 ай бұрын

I laugh as soon as he blame everything else but lazy writing

@shamusomalley4263

3 ай бұрын

"But, muh racisms"

@pepperVenge

3 ай бұрын

I had to stop watching the video after that section. There was nothing good about this character. She was only written in to give KK something to get excited about.

@j-rod4600

3 ай бұрын

Rose's sister was a better character

@ColonelMetus

3 ай бұрын

​@@shamusomalley4263 you are a racist troll

I almost walked out of the theater when I saw Leia flying through space in The Last Jedi.

@megatronjenkins2473

3 ай бұрын

Same, but I paid IMAX price for that ticket, I don't waste IMAX money, no matter how much I hate what's onscreen.

@juanresto6756

3 ай бұрын

That was so insufferably silly.

@dav5666

3 ай бұрын

You wasted your money anyway.@@megatronjenkins2473

@j-prins61

3 ай бұрын

Honestly I wish she wouldve died there so Kylo would be more dark and conflicted after killing both parents. And it wouldve made sense with her real life passing

@reaganlpeterson

3 ай бұрын

@@j-prins61 Yes, I agree.

10 dumbest things in the star wars sequel trilogy? The whole sequel trilogy is dumb!

Hux turning into solely comedic relief in TLJ was just a weird shift from TFA where (in my opinion) was played very well as an overly serious pawn to the first order who detested Kylo Ren. Also I didn’t realize people were upset that Chewy DIDN’T die? If Chewy had died in such a moment that would’ve offered little closure would’ve really bothered me.

@Azure_Fire

3 ай бұрын

I think the issue was that his "death" was a fake out, and a poorly executed one. But of course if they had killed him there, they'd probably still be upset for the reason you described. Either way nothing would have topped his original death where it took dropping a moon on him to kill him.

@mar.s6516

3 ай бұрын

It would make for BOLD choice and it would give MC real depth and possibly more interresting and maybe darker character arc. I think ppl miss that possibility more, rather just wanting Chewie to die. 😅@@Azure_Fire

@Azure_Fire

3 ай бұрын

@@mar.s6516 Well let me put it this way. Do you think JJ has the talent to make the most out of a Chewie death?

@rigatenes338

3 ай бұрын

​@@mar.s6516Rey already got that with Leia which died because of Rey technically

Aside from Palpatine my favorite villain is Darth Maul. Hes martial arts fighting style is excellent, he can use the force and a double bladed saber. But most of all he looks intimidating and the fact that he hardly speaks and almost never blinks adds to his menacing presence

@dronesclubhighjinks

3 ай бұрын

Good points!

@ahetzel9054

3 ай бұрын

Yea same, I just think he looks cool AF 🤣

Alright, gotta say, killing off Chewbacca when all the other older characters woud make sense, but, if you had kept them (which, obviously, they didn't), Chewie could have been a character that shone even more then he did in the og trilogy, instead of being... the side Wookie.

I agree with video. Here are my additions. -flying space Leia -the cringe "whooo" the little slave kid does as Finn and Rose escape -blue milk sceen -holdo maneuver -flying space Leia -"permission to hop in an xwing and blow something up" "permission granted" -cringe "go team" moment and they utter "for Chewie" 🤦‍♀️ -Force ghost Luke and Leia smiling at the end -killing Han with no reunion with Luke - Reylo romance -****ing flying space Leia I'll stop. Its all unfortunate.

@Paul_McSeol

3 ай бұрын

I will say the Holdo maneuver looked really cool when I saw it in theaters. It was only later when we thought about it that we were like, “wait, nooooo.”

@sanremo112

3 ай бұрын

You know Leia was using the force to move herself, not actually _flying_ right?

@mRibbons

3 ай бұрын

@@sanremo112 Oh damn! What's up Captain Obvious? Didn't know you were in town.

@namikstudios

3 ай бұрын

Holdo's kamikaze attack was fine, and no it doesn't break any law. The often cited "hyperspace lanes" argument against it is simply irrelevant - The Raddus never enters hyperspace, it rams into the Supremacy, which is right in front of it, while it is accelerating. It doesn't matter what the trajectory of The Raddus beyond the Supremacy was as it was never intended to travel further than that - it was a kamikaze! The very definition of one.

@zshah3107

Ай бұрын

You mean Green milk screen!

The dumbest thing about the sequel it that they're don't plan the whole thing from the start

I remember getting the first of this trio of mess on blu-ray and had my parents over to watch it with me. We're all huge Star Wars fans and were excited to see this new stuff. Well, the movie ended and we were all stunned into silence and my dad turns to me and quietly asks "What was this even about?"

There was one single amazingly dumb thing in the sequel trilogy and that was the sequel trilogy.

The number 1 dumbest thing in Star Wars: Sequel Trilogy: The Star Wars: Sequel Trilogy

Richard E Grant's Pryde was severely underused. I would love to see his time during the original trilogy

@PsychotoasterProd

3 ай бұрын

Who the hell casts Max Von Sydow in a cameo? Make him the goddamned Neo Emperor!

Hux was one of the worst things in the sequel trilogy. I was so confused with him in TROS. The first two movies he wanted the resistance destroyed and was so committed to do that. In TROS, he turned out to be a spy and helped Finn and Poe escape. "I don't care if you win, I need Kylo Ren to lose."🤦‍♂

@Paul_McSeol

3 ай бұрын

Yeah, he was at least a bit more interesting when he was a devoted fanatic.

@dronesclubhighjinks

3 ай бұрын

That motivation is some thing an ex-girlfriend might think of. I’m a woman and I find it very odd that a man would have this motivation. But this just is one of the massive list of idiotic things in these sequel movies. 😄

Rise of Skywalker is so dumb, I actually forgot what it was called.

4:02 the worst part about the side characters isn’t that they’re side characters, they’re just poorly utilized by the movies. Empire Strikes Back had a several side characters who had little screen time, and yet were very compelling. Lando, Boba Fett, Bosk, IG-88, the Norwegian Red Cross, the guy running with the ice cream maker on Bespin, Lobot, etc. they were just well-executed and relatively well-written characters.

@dronesclubhighjinks

3 ай бұрын

Very true!

The trio of Dooku, Ventress, and Grievous is probably my fav villains. All pretty interesting backstories and reasons for becoming villains compared to Palpatine who is just ‘evil because evil’ and doesn’t have anything really interesting in his life story other than being a power hungry sociopath

@dronesclubhighjinks

3 ай бұрын

But which villain inspires the greatest fear? And Vader has to be the most iconic villain of all time. Even girls who have avoided Star Wars their whole lives know who he is. I don’t know of any other movie villain that is a household name. Not even Voldemort. I’m not a movie buff though so maybe you can think of another Vader-comparable villain. But you are correct about the back stories of the ones you named.

@marekstanek112

3 ай бұрын

​@@dronesclubhighjinksThe most interesting thing about Darth Vader is that he originally wanted to be good, bringing peace to the Galaxy, And f*cked up, becoming a galactic Reinhard Heydrich.

@dronesclubhighjinks

3 ай бұрын

@@marekstanek112 thank you for letting me know!

Sauron had the ring, Voldamort had his horcruxes, but SOMEHOW Palpatine returned

Shame KZread didn’t let you upload the entire sequel trilogy

My 3 favs are: Poe's mysterious and magical disapearance from the tie fighter crash scene in TFA leaving Finn behind for dead in the middle of a desert without a single footprint. (JJ must have thought we didn't notice...) The magical return of a lightsaber lost to the core of a giant gas planet. (JJ must have thought we didn't remember...) The magical return of Palpatine (JJ must have thought that we are idiots...)

could easiely be 100 Dumbest Things In Star Wars: Sequel Trilogy

@PsychotoasterProd

3 ай бұрын

Coming up with a top 10 list of "good smart things in the sequel trilogy" would be impossible.

@orbaitv5991

3 ай бұрын

Nah that's the Prequels

@marekstanek112

3 ай бұрын

Even if thé dumbest things in SW was made into a pentalogy, IT would still be a much BETTER movie series than thé SW.

@matthewpatrick7263

3 ай бұрын

There are only 3 things wrong with the Star Wars Sequel Trilogy. 1) The Force Awakens 2) The Last Jedi 3) The Rise of Skywalker That's all that's wrong. I don't know how they got a list of 10 things.

@matthewpatrick7263

3 ай бұрын

@@orbaitv5991I think the prequels had a good overarching story. Unfortunately, it was poorly executed. I view them as a bad high school play about what really happened.

That Chewie fake out was bs

@DavidLLambertmobile

3 ай бұрын

In 1 quick scene JJ shows the other First Order transport. It just appears like Rey was looking at Chewbacca's ship.

Disney forgot to buy contact lenses

I found neither Ren or Hux even vaguely credible. It takes a great deal of effort for me not to whistle the Laurel and Hardy theme tune when they appear together.

@megatronjenkins2473

3 ай бұрын

Fùck we're old 🤣🤣🤣🤣

@ma9x795

3 ай бұрын

@@megatronjenkins2473 xD

Ugghhh, this trilogy still makes me so angry. What an absolute waste.

@franchisefanatic4142

3 ай бұрын

I love it so much, its perfect!

I'm surprised this is only 12 minutes.

Fav villain will always be the cunning and sinister Emperor Palpatine. The man was quiet and unassuming when he needed to be, but savage and maniacal in the Dark Side, to the point that even Vader was shocked by his brutality in combat.

Snoke should have been the new Palpatin during Force awakening, the last Jedi, and the rise of Skywalker

The dumbest thing in the Sequel trilogy was the entire thing getting green lit.

I'm sure they're professionals. Because it took true talent to mess up as badly as they did. 🤣

We need a show set between VI and VII that explains how Luke fell and how Maz Kanat found the lightsaber, or maybe two shows if they can't be linked. Maybe another one about how Palpatine returned.

I really loved when, after Han's death, Leia and Chewie walk past each other like strangers and Leia comforts a girl she barely knew. Very believable character motivations.

The 3 dumbest things in this trilogy: The first movie The second movie The third movie

Rey being a Palpatine could've worked if if the line "Somehow Palpatine has returned" didnt exist. We just spent two movies with new villians and no signs of Palpatine to have him forced into the last movie and have it announced in a random fortnite event that no one was expecting to have key info about the last movie. Palpatine had to be in from the start. Everytime we are talking Rey's family we should be seeing something that gives a hint. They had enough there to make everything work but decided only make connections after the fact.

@dronesclubhighjinks

3 ай бұрын

Your first sentence is a brilliant idea! I’ve never heard anybody else say this.

@daviderickson8699

3 ай бұрын

They could've also thought about generational timelines: Rey was roughly the same age as Kylo Ren. Kylo Ren's parents were babies when Palpatine was already "grandfather age." Rey was Palpatine's granddaughter. She should've been at least his great-granddaughter if not even deeper.

@namikstudios

3 ай бұрын

If they were going to bring Palps back it should have been as a force ghost. He could still do everything he does in Rise as a ghost and it wouldn't have left us all wondering how he survived falling down the core of the Second Death Star and then somehow survived again when it exploded minutes later. He didn't need to come back alive for it to work.

How sad, we’ve lost the age old ability that goes back to primitive times called storytelling.

Why would killing of Chewie be a good idea? Bro was the only thing going for the sequels

@paulweston8408

3 ай бұрын

Not so much the killing him off, but the whole 'bait and switch' thing that shows in the old days used all the time for any cliffhanger. We saw him get into THAT SHIP, which then blew up. He's dead!

How did you manage to narrow it down to just 10? Serious talent, that's how. :D

Out of all 9 mainline Star Wars movies, Rise of Skywalker is the only one that left me feeling genuinely underwhelmed.

THEY FLY NOW !?!?

Narrowing this down to a top 10 must’ve been hard.

“THEY FLY NOW” yes they have, ever since the days of the clone wars.

The fact that racists hated Rose doesn't change the fact that she was a terrible character who sidelined Finn.

@ricardokojin7

10 күн бұрын

Nobody hated her because of her race.

Knights of Ren needed red lightsabers and actual screentime, followed by voice lines. Finn needed to be revealed as a jedi.

There's *far* too much stupidity in the sequel trilogy for me to have been able to condense a list down to 10 items, so good on you for managing that much, WhatCulture.

I hated, hated, hated, HATED the concept of Snoke. I'm glad Rian Johnson killed him off because it would've put up a good power struggle between Kylo Ren and Gen. Hux in the third movie. In the end, Hux is just an ancillary character.

I think they had the best character introduction ever….. then 2 seconds later absolutely destroyed it. When kylo was first introduced he froze the laser blasts. A feet never seen in a Star Wars movie. It was undeniably badass! Super intimidating and a fantastic way to show how powerful he was. Then the replacement Han Solo starts making fun of him, To his face! It didn’t show how brave and funny that guy was, it just showed that the main bad guy was a joke.

Not liking rose isn’t racist. She was just insufferable. But nice try.

@namikstudios

3 ай бұрын

Nah, there are plenty of things wrong with the sequels but Rose isn't one of them. Not even close to insufferable. The only truly insufferable character in the entire Star Wars franchise is old mate Jar Jar.

@matthewpatrick7263

3 ай бұрын

@@namikstudiosHow about when she betrayed them all by stopping Finn from saving them in his suicide run? She didn't know Luke was going to project himself and save the day. If he hadn't, then they all would've died because she didn't realize that sometimes good people have to sacrifice their lives in war.

@ricardokojin7

10 күн бұрын

@@namikstudios Stop the cap mate, there is a lot wrong with her. Calling it "racist" to not like it is outright bs at best. That word used to mean something... now no one cares.

@namikstudios

8 күн бұрын

@@matthewpatrick7263 Rose preventing Finn from pointlessly sacrificing himself is a positive not a negative. Considering how his skimmer was rapidly disintegrating as he foolishly drove it through the path of the beam, crashing into it wouldn't have achieved anything other than his own death. If anything this highlights a problem with Finn's actions, not Rose's. Besides, trying to save a hero of the Resistance (a main character) can hardly be seen as a betrayal. Rose's actions were selfless and very brave.

@namikstudios

8 күн бұрын

@@ricardokojin7 a great deal of the abuse directed at Kelly Marie Tran, the actress who played Rose, was most certainly racist in nature. I accept that some may simply dislike parts of the plot involving her, that's fine, but if that's really your issue then Rose should be the very least of your qualms with The Last Jedi, as she is a relatively small part of that wider plot.

It's actually impressive how they took one of the most beloved IPs and dropped the worlds biggest shit on it while staring us directly in the eyes... They didnt even blink...

So we’re not gonna talk about how Luke Skywalker’s Legacy was completely tarnished, seriously alien, titty milk? Or Rey not-Skywalker being automatically expertly able to handle a light saber and defeat a well-trained Sith master? Or bothering with animal cruelty side story that goes nowhere? Or all of a sudden, low fuel is a problem after never being a problem for 9 films? Or all of a sudden, ships can magically go through force fields?

Only 10? I admire your restraint.

@gandalf6700

3 ай бұрын

Video would be to long otherwise ;)

@johnnypay

3 ай бұрын

this is the 10 dumbest, there are many many MANY dumb things but this is what they consider to be the dumbest.

@Your_disappointed_Father

3 ай бұрын

W comment

Greatest Mistake was giving Star Wars to JJ Abrams. All other 7 star wars movie were stories in itself. That meant you could view them on themselves. JJ Abrams loves his mystery boxes so much. But they don't fit Star Wars Movies.

Rose was dreadful though! She single-handedly wiped out the Rebellion

The only good thing about these movies , kylo ren's ark and the return of Palpatine

In regards to Rey’s origin, making her a Palpatine, is the problem.

Maz Kanada actually appeared prior to the sequel Trilogy in a really unknown Lego SW Show called The Freemaker Adventures

Now Give Me J.J Abrams, (in Klingon) Revenge is a dish best served Cold!

It was a dumb move to include scenes of Lando and Chewie on the Falcon in the previews. Anyone who watched the trailer would know Chewie wasn’t really killed. That took away any kind of emotional impact that scene could have had.

The 3 C's to avoid when Writing = Coincidences, Conveniences, and Contrivances. And J.J. Abrams Star Wars and Star Trek drown in them

Ten... Is that all ya got? I could do a whole trilogy. And a solo one.

Yeah, the they fly now quote was DEFINITELY cringe worthy. In the Expanded Edition of The Force Awakens novel or comic, it actually shows how Maz got Anakin/Luke’s lightsaber.

Issue I had, no way Leia is going to hug Rey first, I dont care if they did know themselves in the force. The Force doesnt work that way, Leia and Chewie risked their lives during the original Star Wars movies, it would be like my grandfathers (Who both fought in WWII) how they felt about someone they didnt know and a mate in unit they served. They both fought and watched friends die. So, those that survived were normally like their brothers. They shared a bond, that many cant understand. Chewie and Leia were like family, solders, and people who watched friends die. No way is Rey going to be accepted into that group.

So Finn was actually a Force Sensitive individual also huh, Good 4 Him!

I'm taking a few liberties here but without a doubt in my favorite Star Wars character is most definitely tie-in between Director Orson Callan Krennic and Jango Fett.

#4 "Looks like we're about to die so I want to tell you I qualify to be part of your religious order?" Hours that I was supposed to make sense?

Finn and Rey felt natural. Finn and Rose felt forced. Rey and Kylo feels forced and Rey and Finn feel natural

Finally! Someone isn't afraid to spew the same tired complaints over and over again! Love fresh takes...

What a wasted opportunity these movies are. I remember when I saw the prequel trilogy. I was excited, some things didn't make sense or Jar Jar Binks was annoying .. but these movies are supreme stupid's. What a shame.

@Azure_Fire

3 ай бұрын

I remember when I got home after seeing RoSW it hit me that the last 6 years of hype over the movies had been a waste.

Minimizing the use of R2. I love BB8 but R2 was WOEFULLY pushed aside to sell a new toy. R2 is arguably one of the major heroes of the saga

@FanF1France

3 ай бұрын

Star Wars has been R2D2's story since the begin. Should have been the guideline for the sequel...

Ah yes, the most iconic Star Wars villain comes to mind, Wat Tambor.

How did you narrow it down to ten?

Favorite villain 100% Darth Vader. No competition at all.

I have recently come to the conclusion that episode 9 was in fact intended as a parody. That the writers and director had come to the conclusion that episode 8 had messed with the lore and characters enough that a serious sequel wasn't possible, and expected people to realise it wasn't meant seriously through such moments as "somehow, Palpatine returned" and "you? You're the spy?" and put things together.

Actually Kylo Ren is quite as ridiculous as other characters in this failure trilogy

@ricardokojin7

10 күн бұрын

Never once after he took off the mask he looked scary at all....the fact that random girl with zero training was kicking his ass doesn't help.

I just realized Palpatine stole his immediate essence transfer and cloning from Rick Sanchez.

Number 1.5 - Rebooting C-3PO

How hard would it be to let Daisy Ridley or John Boyega know that Rey had a message for her?

Killing Ackbar, the Holdo Maneuver, the Force ghosts being able to do things in the physical world - the list is endless

@DavidLLambertmobile

3 ай бұрын

JJ & KK never clearly explain or use the dreaded "Knights" of Ren either. Everyone was waiting for Luke to cut thru them or for them to reek havoc. Nope!

@namikstudios

3 ай бұрын

There's nothing wrong with Holdo's kamikaze. ...and why does everyone call it a "maneuver" when what she did is the textbook definition of a kamikaze attack? It's not like there isn't a specific name for this "maneuver".

George Lucas denied the EU (Expanded Universe) prior to Selling his Franchise to Disney & Allow Kathleen Kennedy/Bob Iger ruined this beloved Franchise!

The citizens fleet would have been destroyed in seconds on Exegol