He's trying to transpose his modern leftwing modernist definition of ethnic identity on easten Romans to fit in with Sksopians foreign apologists the claimed them "Macedonians". They were not an "ethnic" group. Easterm Roman emperor, Leo V was an Armenian. Constantine was a mix of Illyrian and Greek. They were from different ethnic background but emphasized Roman national identity and Christianity over ethnic heritage. The western Holy Roman empire even insisted they were mostly Greeks not Roman.
@mydogsbutlerАй бұрын
Physist Alan Sokal warned about a segment of academics in the humanities are peddling their leftist politics under the veneer of scientific discourse. This describes the so-called "Greek" academic here to a tee. Speaking as a Greek, it's obvious he's a leftist by his political correct gibberish narrative. He's massaging the narrative of Hellenism using ad-hoc analogies to match current western narratives of Greeks as not "real" Greeks not the view most Greeks have of themselves and Greek history. A prime example is his claim Greeks of today have more in common with middle age Roman Greeks is plain ridiculous.. Greece during the middle ages was theocratic. And the very fact he uses the insulting western term Byzantine is further evidence of a desire to fit in with foreign colleagues rather than historic truth. The reason why the term Byzantine is used by the west isn't trivial issue. It's at the heart of identifying the primary ethnicity and culture of the people the eastern Roman empire. The reason is because after the Pope crowned Charlemagne Roman emperor in the Holy Roman empire the west claimed they were the "real" Roman empire. Despite that the east called themselves the Roman empire, until the 17th century the western Roman empire insisted the eastern Roman one was Greek. Roman was not an "ethnicity" in the eastern Roman empire as this author falsely claims. Anyone could be Roman. Post antiquity Roman was closer to a citizenship than an ethnicity. With the Renaissance, Hellenism came back into vogue in the west., The west then switching to calling the east "Byzantine" in the 17th century as way to disconnect Greece's people from both Roman imperial authority and ancient Greeks. In other words, they were motivated by hate not academic objectivity. This disconnect from the past was later used by Nazis to commit atrocities against Greeks as they justified as it as against not "real" Greeks. As a ethnic Greek with no non-Greeks as far back as I can trace my roots, I find "Greek" leftists like Kadellis appalling. This man in no shape or form speaks for me as a Greek I don't even see "Greeks' like him as Greek despite the term Greek to describe himself. We don't share the same identity. He obviously suffering an identity crisis trying so hard to fit in. He doesn't even follow his own alleged academic principles when it comes to making similar historical decoupling analogies with other ethnic groups and languages who have less in common with their claimed roots than Greeks do. Guaranteed this leftist pseudo-Greek coward has never condemned Skopje's foreign apologists for ridiculously recognizing Skopians as Macedonians.
@ss98892 ай бұрын
Great interview! Love the insights on classics
@robertomedina99273 ай бұрын
The thing that bothers me the most about all this is that I arrived 4 years late for the well-deserved hype that this book has. I finished listening to the audio book (an experience that I highly recommend. The narrator did an exceptional job) for the second time two days ago and I am still in mourning. It is a beautiful story, excellently narrated and described. The depth in Patroclus, the complexity of Achilles. The development of love and its dynamics. The passion, the faith, the dedication, the adoration, the sensations... The story changes your life, you become someone new, with a new definition of loving. It is wonderful.
@CG-up9iv3 ай бұрын
could the book have been called The Achilliad? It still means 'the song of achilles' but has the added significance of sounding like 'The Illiad' showing how bound to Troy his fate was?
don't manipulation the history The Albanians are founders of greece 100 heroes 90 heroes were Albanian and this is documeted
@Sira6287 ай бұрын
Because byzantium was an antimacedonian continuity thats why did not survived hellenistic writers
@radiushadariah901010 ай бұрын
the only mistake made by Turks was occupying half of Cyprus, turkiye had to occupy the whole island for peace in the world. but, however, Türkiye will manage the mistake in the near future.
@osmanozdemir225210 ай бұрын
He says; Turkey shows his true colors:) now time to see your true color. Gold bars from Egypt? Anywhere else? Cyprus? Greece? He barely escaped one not long ago, let's see how he ends up this time.
@acausevic111 ай бұрын
Greeks and Turks still have hostilities over an event that occurred over 6 centuries ago. Let it go already! In that case we should all be angry at the Italians because Rome ruled just about half the world it seems.
@whitepanties275111 ай бұрын
Didn't even know that 'Iliad' means 'Song of Troy'. As we only have the words and the original music is long forgotten, we must have a partial view of its original appeal. The Ancient Greeks invented an alphabet to record the words, but they never devised an adequate music notation.
@mpouzbouris111 ай бұрын
If the United States and British gave the green light to invate Cyrus so ask Henry Kissingerand the British are occupying Cyprus too
@mortyn.8581 Жыл бұрын
Perfect explained , Bravo
@Kareena-i6t Жыл бұрын
🙏🙏🙏thanks
@philiparavanis7519 Жыл бұрын
Thank you so much for your support 🙏!!!
@antonteodor6305 Жыл бұрын
Mr. Kaldellis is such a pleasure to listen to ❤️
@spartanleo5121 Жыл бұрын
Turkey has too much blood on its hands
@mehmetsimsek736 Жыл бұрын
Korkunun ecele faydası yok!
@malekesper3959 Жыл бұрын
😂 truck doesn't need your planes they have their own they made their own😅 you need to catch up to the new news
@TADCFan0098 Жыл бұрын
Cyprus is one Internationally recognized country. Blue Homeland doctrine is a joke. It will never go anywhere. Turkey is bankrupt. And cannot afford military grade airplanes, much less F-35’s. Austerity is waiting for Turkey.
@kemalsurmeli7722 Жыл бұрын
greeks commits genocide in cyprus and then cry when the turkish army brings peace to the island greeks claim turkish waters and then cry when the turkish navy pushes them back where they belong greeks fly over turkish mainland and then cry when turkish jets fly over greek islands wich are a few meters away the blue homeland is nothing you can stop
@hany9978 Жыл бұрын
Turkey has the right to defend itself against Greece it's a joke that you think you own EastMid when it's closer to Mainland Turkey than it will ever be for Greece not to mention that Cyprus is for two countries not one
@hany9978 Жыл бұрын
@@D19DMO128D funny when you talk like that, to the oppressed as if they are the oppressor anyway Greece trying yo take lands not theirs only natural to defend their borders .. and good that you mentuoned ww2 so you should take a hint Germany had every right to start the war but not after reclaiming their land and open wars on rest of countries aside from France
@helioslegigantosaure69394 ай бұрын
Istambul is near greece that mean is for us ? Thank you very much
@michaelpenzikis1234 Жыл бұрын
Keep up the great work everybody. Stay on top of every issue. The activity is working.
@__Man__ Жыл бұрын
All Greeks will be Turkified. The Turkification of Greeks will be completed. Hellenism will be only just a history in the future. NE MUTLU TÜRKÜM DİYENE. 🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺.
@dimitrikatsimberis7690 Жыл бұрын
While I agree, its the UK and USA that set this up…..
@NickPantazis Жыл бұрын
Εξαιρετικό. Μπράβο!
@user-xj1sb9wu4x Жыл бұрын
If the US sells F-16's to Turkey, we will embolden the Turks & ensure a war between Turkey & Greece as well as destabilizing the Black Sea.
@thomasj3421 Жыл бұрын
Spot on 💯
@TheKwgeorge Жыл бұрын
I think this morning's call from Erdogan to Putin more than highlights the talking points being made in this terrific video.
@doiranimarkou4004 Жыл бұрын
Excellent summary!
@F.D.S.1 Жыл бұрын
🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱
@anastasiamoreyne9467 Жыл бұрын
Juedochristianity rewrote Greco Roman history and it still does with its people…shame…
@antonteodor6305 Жыл бұрын
Speaking as a pagan, there are some good parts in the transition to Christianity, like giving up on slavery and bloodsports
@animalcart41286 ай бұрын
What?
@mydogsbutlerАй бұрын
@@antonteodor6305 Christians continued slavery until the 19th century.
@ellz223 Жыл бұрын
Madeline Miller is a literary genius
@demetrissofroniou9466 Жыл бұрын
Thank you And God bless you?
@jimmypellas5937 Жыл бұрын
Sadly, although this is about history, it endorses the reality of the alleged pandemic of 2020 , which any discerning historian would see as a fraudulent crime of international proportion.
@Katafrakt_ Жыл бұрын
Interesting! This needs more videos!
@MrBasil312 Жыл бұрын
Yet more effects of Hellenism that has had a profound effect on society!!! Thank you Professor!!!!!
@bc7190 Жыл бұрын
This is the most racist and corrupt politician ever… He has no place in our country… But Armenian diaspora and Greek diaspora votes get him there and he is paying his dues at the expense of USA and our most loyal ally Türkiye…
@keig9385 Жыл бұрын
A Touch of Spice is one of the best movies I have ever watched. It tells us about the sensitive and artistic soul of its writer and director Mr. Boulmetis. A strong story about forced migration, very beautifully presented. Thank you for this gift you gave to us.
@MegaMayday16 Жыл бұрын
Culture changes constantly. I am from Germany. 50 years back nudity was considered more normal. Nude Beaches nude swimming lakes. Now the younger generation is alienated by this
@SmaroSpandonidis Жыл бұрын
Συνχαρητηρια και στους δυο σας ,καθημερινη υπευθηνη ενημερωση !
@leosword7142 Жыл бұрын
Thanos and Endy love your podcasts....from down under.🦃🔥🍗🍽 😋yummy‼️
@helendress6750 Жыл бұрын
Informative talk, thank you..
@angelazotos1945 Жыл бұрын
Happy Thanksgiving - thanks for the conversation!
@chirdaris Жыл бұрын
Good talk, you are both doing a great job!
@gregchristodoulides5368 Жыл бұрын
interesting talk🤩
@maxximusbm Жыл бұрын
Thanos and Endy, I am listening to your podcasts every day. Thoughtful insights, great analysis and commentaries. Journalism at its best but Endy please don't wear the wrong team shirt 😂, from a loyal ☘ fan
Пікірлер
He's trying to transpose his modern leftwing modernist definition of ethnic identity on easten Romans to fit in with Sksopians foreign apologists the claimed them "Macedonians". They were not an "ethnic" group. Easterm Roman emperor, Leo V was an Armenian. Constantine was a mix of Illyrian and Greek. They were from different ethnic background but emphasized Roman national identity and Christianity over ethnic heritage. The western Holy Roman empire even insisted they were mostly Greeks not Roman.
Physist Alan Sokal warned about a segment of academics in the humanities are peddling their leftist politics under the veneer of scientific discourse. This describes the so-called "Greek" academic here to a tee. Speaking as a Greek, it's obvious he's a leftist by his political correct gibberish narrative. He's massaging the narrative of Hellenism using ad-hoc analogies to match current western narratives of Greeks as not "real" Greeks not the view most Greeks have of themselves and Greek history. A prime example is his claim Greeks of today have more in common with middle age Roman Greeks is plain ridiculous.. Greece during the middle ages was theocratic. And the very fact he uses the insulting western term Byzantine is further evidence of a desire to fit in with foreign colleagues rather than historic truth. The reason why the term Byzantine is used by the west isn't trivial issue. It's at the heart of identifying the primary ethnicity and culture of the people the eastern Roman empire. The reason is because after the Pope crowned Charlemagne Roman emperor in the Holy Roman empire the west claimed they were the "real" Roman empire. Despite that the east called themselves the Roman empire, until the 17th century the western Roman empire insisted the eastern Roman one was Greek. Roman was not an "ethnicity" in the eastern Roman empire as this author falsely claims. Anyone could be Roman. Post antiquity Roman was closer to a citizenship than an ethnicity. With the Renaissance, Hellenism came back into vogue in the west., The west then switching to calling the east "Byzantine" in the 17th century as way to disconnect Greece's people from both Roman imperial authority and ancient Greeks. In other words, they were motivated by hate not academic objectivity. This disconnect from the past was later used by Nazis to commit atrocities against Greeks as they justified as it as against not "real" Greeks. As a ethnic Greek with no non-Greeks as far back as I can trace my roots, I find "Greek" leftists like Kadellis appalling. This man in no shape or form speaks for me as a Greek I don't even see "Greeks' like him as Greek despite the term Greek to describe himself. We don't share the same identity. He obviously suffering an identity crisis trying so hard to fit in. He doesn't even follow his own alleged academic principles when it comes to making similar historical decoupling analogies with other ethnic groups and languages who have less in common with their claimed roots than Greeks do. Guaranteed this leftist pseudo-Greek coward has never condemned Skopje's foreign apologists for ridiculously recognizing Skopians as Macedonians.
Great interview! Love the insights on classics
The thing that bothers me the most about all this is that I arrived 4 years late for the well-deserved hype that this book has. I finished listening to the audio book (an experience that I highly recommend. The narrator did an exceptional job) for the second time two days ago and I am still in mourning. It is a beautiful story, excellently narrated and described. The depth in Patroclus, the complexity of Achilles. The development of love and its dynamics. The passion, the faith, the dedication, the adoration, the sensations... The story changes your life, you become someone new, with a new definition of loving. It is wonderful.
could the book have been called The Achilliad? It still means 'the song of achilles' but has the added significance of sounding like 'The Illiad' showing how bound to Troy his fate was?
Prof. Strauss is great as always.
kzread.info/dash/bejne/f3dl062gcsi2dNI.htmlsi=AQlyZT-R4o127tAu
don't manipulation the history The Albanians are founders of greece 100 heroes 90 heroes were Albanian and this is documeted
Because byzantium was an antimacedonian continuity thats why did not survived hellenistic writers
the only mistake made by Turks was occupying half of Cyprus, turkiye had to occupy the whole island for peace in the world. but, however, Türkiye will manage the mistake in the near future.
He says; Turkey shows his true colors:) now time to see your true color. Gold bars from Egypt? Anywhere else? Cyprus? Greece? He barely escaped one not long ago, let's see how he ends up this time.
Greeks and Turks still have hostilities over an event that occurred over 6 centuries ago. Let it go already! In that case we should all be angry at the Italians because Rome ruled just about half the world it seems.
Didn't even know that 'Iliad' means 'Song of Troy'. As we only have the words and the original music is long forgotten, we must have a partial view of its original appeal. The Ancient Greeks invented an alphabet to record the words, but they never devised an adequate music notation.
If the United States and British gave the green light to invate Cyrus so ask Henry Kissingerand the British are occupying Cyprus too
Perfect explained , Bravo
🙏🙏🙏thanks
Thank you so much for your support 🙏!!!
Mr. Kaldellis is such a pleasure to listen to ❤️
Turkey has too much blood on its hands
Korkunun ecele faydası yok!
😂 truck doesn't need your planes they have their own they made their own😅 you need to catch up to the new news
Cyprus is one Internationally recognized country. Blue Homeland doctrine is a joke. It will never go anywhere. Turkey is bankrupt. And cannot afford military grade airplanes, much less F-35’s. Austerity is waiting for Turkey.
greeks commits genocide in cyprus and then cry when the turkish army brings peace to the island greeks claim turkish waters and then cry when the turkish navy pushes them back where they belong greeks fly over turkish mainland and then cry when turkish jets fly over greek islands wich are a few meters away the blue homeland is nothing you can stop
Turkey has the right to defend itself against Greece it's a joke that you think you own EastMid when it's closer to Mainland Turkey than it will ever be for Greece not to mention that Cyprus is for two countries not one
@@D19DMO128D funny when you talk like that, to the oppressed as if they are the oppressor anyway Greece trying yo take lands not theirs only natural to defend their borders .. and good that you mentuoned ww2 so you should take a hint Germany had every right to start the war but not after reclaiming their land and open wars on rest of countries aside from France
Istambul is near greece that mean is for us ? Thank you very much
Keep up the great work everybody. Stay on top of every issue. The activity is working.
All Greeks will be Turkified. The Turkification of Greeks will be completed. Hellenism will be only just a history in the future. NE MUTLU TÜRKÜM DİYENE. 🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🤘🏻🐺🐺🐺🐺🐺.
While I agree, its the UK and USA that set this up…..
Εξαιρετικό. Μπράβο!
If the US sells F-16's to Turkey, we will embolden the Turks & ensure a war between Turkey & Greece as well as destabilizing the Black Sea.
Spot on 💯
I think this morning's call from Erdogan to Putin more than highlights the talking points being made in this terrific video.
Excellent summary!
🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱🇦🇱
Juedochristianity rewrote Greco Roman history and it still does with its people…shame…
Speaking as a pagan, there are some good parts in the transition to Christianity, like giving up on slavery and bloodsports
What?
@@antonteodor6305 Christians continued slavery until the 19th century.
Madeline Miller is a literary genius
Thank you And God bless you?
Sadly, although this is about history, it endorses the reality of the alleged pandemic of 2020 , which any discerning historian would see as a fraudulent crime of international proportion.
Interesting! This needs more videos!
Yet more effects of Hellenism that has had a profound effect on society!!! Thank you Professor!!!!!
This is the most racist and corrupt politician ever… He has no place in our country… But Armenian diaspora and Greek diaspora votes get him there and he is paying his dues at the expense of USA and our most loyal ally Türkiye…
A Touch of Spice is one of the best movies I have ever watched. It tells us about the sensitive and artistic soul of its writer and director Mr. Boulmetis. A strong story about forced migration, very beautifully presented. Thank you for this gift you gave to us.
Culture changes constantly. I am from Germany. 50 years back nudity was considered more normal. Nude Beaches nude swimming lakes. Now the younger generation is alienated by this
Συνχαρητηρια και στους δυο σας ,καθημερινη υπευθηνη ενημερωση !
Thanos and Endy love your podcasts....from down under.🦃🔥🍗🍽 😋yummy‼️
Informative talk, thank you..
Happy Thanksgiving - thanks for the conversation!
Good talk, you are both doing a great job!
interesting talk🤩
Thanos and Endy, I am listening to your podcasts every day. Thoughtful insights, great analysis and commentaries. Journalism at its best but Endy please don't wear the wrong team shirt 😂, from a loyal ☘ fan