I wish schools in Scotland would teach this instead of Scots languages
@lornallewКүн бұрын
I am Welsh and further to the previous comment there was a period in British history when English landowners came up with the idea of "Welsh Not" people were punished for speaking Welsh.
@pablolanchares1976Күн бұрын
En Irlanda tendrían que enseñar el idioma irlandés en las escuelas 21/5
@phralvim2 күн бұрын
It is strange that although english is a germanic language, it sounds much more like a celtic language. Maybe the english language was just adopted by celts living in Britain and they added their accent to it.
@pickledpeckers77892 күн бұрын
Sounds slavic
@consubg2 күн бұрын
you are lacking Galicia, also part of the celtic league
@viharkabat35182 күн бұрын
Thank you for this video! It's very useful!
@hiketas35652 күн бұрын
I had doubts about the scientific validity of the categorisation of Hungarian among the Finno-Ugric languages... These doubts have been strengthened.
@zer-atop30322 күн бұрын
In Serbo-Croatian, I've never heard anyone say "kotka". We always use the word "maca" or "mačka"
@mancpaul012 күн бұрын
You can travel to North Wales, especially Anglesey, and hear the Welsh language alive and well in most shops, cafes etc.
@lauriehartley98083 күн бұрын
I don’t understand what they are say in but I like what I am hearing. For some reason it makes me happy.
@teveve313 күн бұрын
The -ni ending should have been omitted from Hungarian verbs and it also doesn't help that the Hungarian spelling is displayed without explaining that the 'sz' is pronounced as 's' in other languages (thus 'szem' is pronounced as 'sem' would be in English.)
@dorianosatane72443 күн бұрын
In Polish is lisica olso
@alexanderbraun65664 күн бұрын
such fantastic to hear all this well sounded languages, tho i did not get a single word
@lunabranwen4 күн бұрын
Cymru rydd
@dirkvantroyen91704 күн бұрын
Too bad the Scottish gaelic parts weren't translated. It seemed I could understand a few words here and there (I'm Flemish), since some words sounded like old Dutch or Norse. Can anyone confirm?
@user-sx6we8qy6h2 күн бұрын
Right. I thought of Danish.
@fitwolf89514 күн бұрын
Чтото на удмуртском или мордовском говорят. Не могу понять
@CarlosM.FernandezRivera-ez6vr4 күн бұрын
Was the first Manx speaker saying a prayer? It sounded like said "Lord" and "Amen" at the end.
@tinapica68ify4 күн бұрын
Very interesting comparison. To my Italian ears they all sound quite Dutch/Neerlandees.
@AndyPrice-ds2tz4 күн бұрын
Britain's we've lost our native tongue so sad in a few more generations its gone forever it should be tough in schools
@ofruoscar58005 күн бұрын
Es curioso pero irlandes y breton tienen acento gallego
@rosslambda96135 күн бұрын
my grandfather was fluent in irish gael and ive managed to relearn a few words and put them in my books novels
@ThomasMuirAudionaut5 күн бұрын
The idea that there's such a thing as no accent is an English attitude with absolutely no voracity. The people in these clips have the accent of their cultures.
@gaborjuhasz56105 күн бұрын
Hungarian is not Finn-ugor 😂 Never was... But 150 years ago suddenly we become that..... 😂😂😂
@iromba93275 күн бұрын
Teljesen igazad van. Semmi közünk a finnugorizmushoz, bár páran még próbálják erőltetni. Ráadásul miért pont így hívják a nyelvcsaládot, mikor a magyar lenne benne a legnagyobb lélekszámú. Budenzék ezt jól kifundálták ellenünk. A törökben és a mongolban sokkal több hasonló szó van.
@GoldieDawn6 күн бұрын
Us Romany Gypsies language is far older than 'Celtic' languages. x
@gregkerna74103 күн бұрын
lmao, sure, the proto-celtic languages appeared in the early iron age and modern celtic languages descend from late iron age languages. this means they're thousands of years old. The first attestation of Romani is from 1542 AD, and that likely means their language can't be that much older. also, you don't need to be bragging about other languages lol, this just reeks being insecure.
@letstry89346 күн бұрын
İts obvious Man came from europe formed those nations , kind of hollands, danish deutch not English surely ))
@letstry89346 күн бұрын
Nothing to do with English ,surely a different language kind of mixture of Fin danish deutch , sounds weird
@rickwrites26126 күн бұрын
Im amazed anyone thinks that. The Gaelic languages aren't even in the same branch as English ie Celtic vs Germanic.
@RammusTheArmordillo6 күн бұрын
I'm French and I often see videos of people speaking Breton, supposedly "with no accent", but to me it clearly sounds like a French speaker who started learning 2 years ago and barely makes any effort with pronunciation. I didn't know how the language really sounds so I couldn't be sure but I had a strong feeling about it. Seeing this, with old people truly speaking breton with little to no accent, it's clear that it's completely different and doesn't sound like French at all. It's a little sad that the new generation seems to ignore traditional pronunciation and don't care about having a thick French accent when speaking breton.
@murraygiles31916 күн бұрын
Aberdeen northeast scotland in doric we say ma instead of mother and also mither.
@prufungvideoaufnahme38216 күн бұрын
Very nice to hear I did not expect such similarity between the countries. It was really a true language that unfortunately not only France have diminished or we can even say help to disappear
@Zaire826 күн бұрын
There were actually 2 main Scottish languages, Scottish Gaelic in the highlands, and Scots in the lowlands. Scots sounds very similar to English and a lot of Scots is just seen as a strong accent and some odd slang rather than a different language. Technically, it's still widely spoken.
@alessandroinglese42386 күн бұрын
Irish sounds so Scandinavian...
@gregkerna74103 күн бұрын
well, cities like dublin were controled by scandinavians, so there could be influence. celtic and germanic languages also appeared and evolved in close regions at similar times.
@dzmmi6 күн бұрын
1:37 кітка (kitka) 😭🇺🇦 Кішка є бридке слово 😅
@yzwariij7 күн бұрын
Wven my qife and I visited Ireland last year, we played a game while walking along the streets of Ireland: Is is Irish, or is it Dutch. 😂
@michk51497 күн бұрын
Thank you for compiling such a video!
@geraldjoyce74007 күн бұрын
My parents were both native Irish speakers from the Conamara Gaeltacht in Galway. My dad‘s oldest sister went over to the Isle of Man in the late 1940s and spoke Conamara Irish to some of the last native Manx speakers. She said they had no problems communicating with each other Back-and-forth using Manx Gaelic and Irish. At that time, it was very likely that she had little or no English.
@hamiltongoodman38367 күн бұрын
Yes to the survival of language. I'd like to see these grouped back-to-back by type, e.g. have Q-Celtic grouped with Q-Celtic and P-Celtic with P-Celtic
@radosawzakosny50137 күн бұрын
I'm very sorry for asking. What language is from 4:50?
@zeten___99087 күн бұрын
they have accents
@oliviermariebrittany4ever6507 күн бұрын
Breton was forbiden at School for my mom!!! and she refused to teach me 😢😢😢
@ataguala7 күн бұрын
Yes, very interesting. But aren't there more Saami languages than just west and East Saami? I thought that within (at least East Saami) each group there are ialects that ave been given the rank of separate languages?
@dragonfly-pg8jl9nq7z7 күн бұрын
It's the language of legends and fairy tales! Thank you, it was interesting.
@wadeoden84647 күн бұрын
Are any of these different languages closely related enough for speakers to understand one another?
@gregkerna74103 күн бұрын
depends. there are two main groups of languages, one of them is called brythonic and includes cornish, breton and welsh. they would have a hard time talking to each other, but it's feasible. however, brythonics wouldn't understand non brythonic celtic languages.
@brianwarriner88268 күн бұрын
This video brings me back to my ancestors who spoke these languages. It’s inspiring me to learn these languages .
@rw47498 күн бұрын
I love it!
@nonai78978 күн бұрын
They sound like theyre casting spells. Especially the old lady next to last. Its a shame were losing languages and dialects uear after year.
@knirps48518 күн бұрын
so sad to mostly see older people speaking these languages
Пікірлер
Sounds Scandinavian and weirdly Turkish 😅
cElTiC
I wish schools in Scotland would teach this instead of Scots languages
I am Welsh and further to the previous comment there was a period in British history when English landowners came up with the idea of "Welsh Not" people were punished for speaking Welsh.
En Irlanda tendrían que enseñar el idioma irlandés en las escuelas 21/5
It is strange that although english is a germanic language, it sounds much more like a celtic language. Maybe the english language was just adopted by celts living in Britain and they added their accent to it.
Sounds slavic
you are lacking Galicia, also part of the celtic league
Thank you for this video! It's very useful!
I had doubts about the scientific validity of the categorisation of Hungarian among the Finno-Ugric languages... These doubts have been strengthened.
In Serbo-Croatian, I've never heard anyone say "kotka". We always use the word "maca" or "mačka"
You can travel to North Wales, especially Anglesey, and hear the Welsh language alive and well in most shops, cafes etc.
I don’t understand what they are say in but I like what I am hearing. For some reason it makes me happy.
The -ni ending should have been omitted from Hungarian verbs and it also doesn't help that the Hungarian spelling is displayed without explaining that the 'sz' is pronounced as 's' in other languages (thus 'szem' is pronounced as 'sem' would be in English.)
In Polish is lisica olso
such fantastic to hear all this well sounded languages, tho i did not get a single word
Cymru rydd
Too bad the Scottish gaelic parts weren't translated. It seemed I could understand a few words here and there (I'm Flemish), since some words sounded like old Dutch or Norse. Can anyone confirm?
Right. I thought of Danish.
Чтото на удмуртском или мордовском говорят. Не могу понять
Was the first Manx speaker saying a prayer? It sounded like said "Lord" and "Amen" at the end.
Very interesting comparison. To my Italian ears they all sound quite Dutch/Neerlandees.
Britain's we've lost our native tongue so sad in a few more generations its gone forever it should be tough in schools
Es curioso pero irlandes y breton tienen acento gallego
my grandfather was fluent in irish gael and ive managed to relearn a few words and put them in my books novels
The idea that there's such a thing as no accent is an English attitude with absolutely no voracity. The people in these clips have the accent of their cultures.
Hungarian is not Finn-ugor 😂 Never was... But 150 years ago suddenly we become that..... 😂😂😂
Teljesen igazad van. Semmi közünk a finnugorizmushoz, bár páran még próbálják erőltetni. Ráadásul miért pont így hívják a nyelvcsaládot, mikor a magyar lenne benne a legnagyobb lélekszámú. Budenzék ezt jól kifundálták ellenünk. A törökben és a mongolban sokkal több hasonló szó van.
Us Romany Gypsies language is far older than 'Celtic' languages. x
lmao, sure, the proto-celtic languages appeared in the early iron age and modern celtic languages descend from late iron age languages. this means they're thousands of years old. The first attestation of Romani is from 1542 AD, and that likely means their language can't be that much older. also, you don't need to be bragging about other languages lol, this just reeks being insecure.
İts obvious Man came from europe formed those nations , kind of hollands, danish deutch not English surely ))
Nothing to do with English ,surely a different language kind of mixture of Fin danish deutch , sounds weird
Im amazed anyone thinks that. The Gaelic languages aren't even in the same branch as English ie Celtic vs Germanic.
I'm French and I often see videos of people speaking Breton, supposedly "with no accent", but to me it clearly sounds like a French speaker who started learning 2 years ago and barely makes any effort with pronunciation. I didn't know how the language really sounds so I couldn't be sure but I had a strong feeling about it. Seeing this, with old people truly speaking breton with little to no accent, it's clear that it's completely different and doesn't sound like French at all. It's a little sad that the new generation seems to ignore traditional pronunciation and don't care about having a thick French accent when speaking breton.
Aberdeen northeast scotland in doric we say ma instead of mother and also mither.
Very nice to hear I did not expect such similarity between the countries. It was really a true language that unfortunately not only France have diminished or we can even say help to disappear
There were actually 2 main Scottish languages, Scottish Gaelic in the highlands, and Scots in the lowlands. Scots sounds very similar to English and a lot of Scots is just seen as a strong accent and some odd slang rather than a different language. Technically, it's still widely spoken.
Irish sounds so Scandinavian...
well, cities like dublin were controled by scandinavians, so there could be influence. celtic and germanic languages also appeared and evolved in close regions at similar times.
1:37 кітка (kitka) 😭🇺🇦 Кішка є бридке слово 😅
Wven my qife and I visited Ireland last year, we played a game while walking along the streets of Ireland: Is is Irish, or is it Dutch. 😂
Thank you for compiling such a video!
My parents were both native Irish speakers from the Conamara Gaeltacht in Galway. My dad‘s oldest sister went over to the Isle of Man in the late 1940s and spoke Conamara Irish to some of the last native Manx speakers. She said they had no problems communicating with each other Back-and-forth using Manx Gaelic and Irish. At that time, it was very likely that she had little or no English.
Yes to the survival of language. I'd like to see these grouped back-to-back by type, e.g. have Q-Celtic grouped with Q-Celtic and P-Celtic with P-Celtic
I'm very sorry for asking. What language is from 4:50?
they have accents
Breton was forbiden at School for my mom!!! and she refused to teach me 😢😢😢
Yes, very interesting. But aren't there more Saami languages than just west and East Saami? I thought that within (at least East Saami) each group there are ialects that ave been given the rank of separate languages?
It's the language of legends and fairy tales! Thank you, it was interesting.
Are any of these different languages closely related enough for speakers to understand one another?
depends. there are two main groups of languages, one of them is called brythonic and includes cornish, breton and welsh. they would have a hard time talking to each other, but it's feasible. however, brythonics wouldn't understand non brythonic celtic languages.
This video brings me back to my ancestors who spoke these languages. It’s inspiring me to learn these languages .
I love it!
They sound like theyre casting spells. Especially the old lady next to last. Its a shame were losing languages and dialects uear after year.
so sad to mostly see older people speaking these languages