Galadriel is chiding Frodo for offering her the ring, not happily surprised at the idea of having it. And she “long desired” to know if she’d pass the test, if presented the opportunity, she didn’t long desire to have and use the ring. She, like Gandalf, knew it would be bad to have in their possession. Jackson et al didn’t seem to understand this.
@dynamicvoltage97656 күн бұрын
who the hell is "arrowman?"
@ExtradaemonYT10 күн бұрын
Honestly, this is much better than the Jackson version.
@daviswilderson348913 күн бұрын
Don't worry Sauron won't find us. Take a look at these cool light rays coming out of my ring
@eliteteamkiller31915 күн бұрын
_“This is the mirror of Galadriel. It shows things that were, and things that are, and things that yet may be. Do you wish to look?”_ “This is Jon Snow. He’s king in the North.”_
@eliteteamkiller31915 күн бұрын
This is the PC of EliteTeamKiller. It shows things that are on the internet.
@caseyhamm429215 күн бұрын
the idea of rotoscope fantasy is still so amazing to me. imagine the people/elves are all rotoscoped but they hand draw the orcs and ents and such to give them that other worldly feel. like something out of a story book
@EliasValadez-pu1iq23 күн бұрын
I like how in Jackson’s film she goes all crazy when Frodo offers her the ring. But here she just laughs it off like ‘ah that’s cute. But no that thing is kinda dangerous so maybe keep it away from me.’
@user-qu2ol7fz1z26 күн бұрын
Where is Eye of Sauron?
@BelindaBower29 күн бұрын
Thanks for continuing to share this method and examples. We started teaching the Seldon method a few years ago when you first published your videos and had the best English Standard results ever at our school. Due lots of disruption and staff changes, we dropped off with it and I'm trying to reintroduce again after having recently read the CESE document. Being an English teacher, I really appreciate seeing the English examples and love looking at the teacher resources/student books. Is there any chance you could share a bit more about how it works in HSIE and Science subjects?
@benjaminseldon348929 күн бұрын
Yes, I ve just traversed great romantic trauma and am back in the land of the living, stronger, more focused and more powerful than ever!!! And thanks! Xoxxoxoxooxx
@skylord2422Ай бұрын
Great video
@exxcaliburs6002Ай бұрын
Thanks!
@RiceIsGoodFoodАй бұрын
Love the content sir 👍
@tarvoc746Ай бұрын
I like her laughing at Frodo's proposal. In the Peter Jackson movie, Galadriel is still deeply shaken and tempted by the offer and its prospect. In contrast, the almost sassy laughter in this version seems to indicate that this version of Galadriel has already pondered the idea to the end and rejected it for herself. Even though it seems slightly goofy how she's so light-hearted in her dismissal of something of such gravity, it shows her as someone who has already overcome this kind of desire for power, and is thus in a way wiser than her live action counterpart.
@MagicCarpetMusicАй бұрын
Brilliant brilliant acting from Sheen, so poignant, and dare I say so much deeper and more moving than Peter Finch in the 1968 version. Sheen just makes you feel his agony.
@seandenzelrhymer760Ай бұрын
Blank slate cost 437 million... Mainly because you have nothing eles of value
@rosea23502 ай бұрын
Bathsheba was awful and Gabriel deserved better.
@elsakristina26892 ай бұрын
Anyone else think this version and Cate Blanchett's version are genius in their own ways?
@pnoon315Ай бұрын
Agree
@inannaenigma93914 ай бұрын
As much as I adore Cate Blanchett in all of her roles, I have to say the eerie calm and giddy laughter in this rendition of Galadriel is far more terrifying.
@auraguard02124 ай бұрын
I remember someone saying that Galadriel wouldn't be allowed back into the West until after she gave up power, since she was initially banished from there for trying to become a queen...
@jtgd4 ай бұрын
1:16 literally waits right before he touches it
@maxbroadbean5 ай бұрын
The term "Ghirlandéina" refers to the "Ghirlandina" which is the Bell Tower of the Cathedral of Modena and which has become the symbol of the city. It owes its name to the double row of railings that adorn it as if they were garlands. The song is not in Italian but in the regional language (Emiliano) spoken in that city.
@marelicainavokado5 ай бұрын
I wish Jackson would have presented Galadriel this way instead of her dramatically walking around and talking in riddles. I found her unlikable.
@exxcaliburs60024 ай бұрын
Agree!
@John52Hughes5 ай бұрын
You understand if we don’t find a stiff out here we leave a fresh one
@Phumelela-qr5vk5 ай бұрын
" it must be Aruman " 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀.
@harryg24536 ай бұрын
World of warcraft on the desktop there 😆
@jemthompson81746 ай бұрын
Thank you for all of the resources you and the school have shared regarding bubble theory. I'm a teacher in NZ trying to get this rolled out in our English department.
@malytheson6 ай бұрын
Am i crazy or does she kinda look like young Jamie lee curtis?😂
@malytheson6 ай бұрын
I really love galadriels design, in this lighting especially, she really looks pretty
@kirby73797 ай бұрын
Michael Sheen - what skill! Amazing.
@taylenday7 ай бұрын
This Galadriel is SO much better than the movie version.
@kaitlynreynolds51927 ай бұрын
She looks so 70s I love it
@9Allien98 ай бұрын
I was so sad for him. She hurt him, on purpose, just because he ignored her. 😞
@dankbudew48308 ай бұрын
It’s not a bad adaptation, but my heart hurts when I see what they did to Sam
@perfectnight9998 ай бұрын
2:20
@anonymoushuman83448 ай бұрын
There's an important lesson here about the temptations of power, even on small scales. Also, the One Ring is like certain drugs, or rather the effects of certain drugs on certain people. Power over others is itself a kind of drug that can compromise judgement.
@DrummingWriterTrekfan848 ай бұрын
In this version i can actually understand what galadriel is saying when she was tested. lol. The animation is so lifelike and masterful , amazing and beautiful!!! todays hand drawn animation has nothing on this(Not including cgi graphics of course lol.).
@anthonyourbrother9 ай бұрын
great scene 🎬 Thanks for posting 🙏 ...thing about love is it's so broken n'self sacrificing ...n'still, the satisfaction one gets from it, whether it's between two lovers or many, or even none at all,... ...can be the most transcendent and spiritually moving things anyone can ever be a part of// In movies anyway... ha🎥
@briancooper49599 ай бұрын
While Kate did a very good job in the role of Galadriel, I have often wished that they could have found an actress as beautiful as this animated one.
@mtcampos19609 ай бұрын
Brilliant acting..Michael Sheen is amazing in this scene. So heartbreaking 💔 😢 and Matthias as Gabriel is a treat to watch.
@surfingonmars89799 ай бұрын
I worked with Mike Starr once or twice. He told me a great story about this song. He was at a customs stop in Canada and was singing the song to himself. The lady customs agent said, “YOU’RE SINGING IT ALL WRONG!” Turns out it was a song from her Italian village. She taught him the cadence, etc. I once wrote an episode of Law & Order and it had a big bad guy in it. I wrote it with Mike Star’s voice in mind. WHO shows up at casting, but MIKE STARR! I said, “um, I think he can handle it!” LOL
@hazellorena49409 ай бұрын
2:05 I feel like this is the one fleeting moment where she feels the temptation to take it, just that subtle widening of her eyes as Frodo offers her the ring. The speech that follows is where she has already realised that she has passed the test, and won’t take it after all, hence why she seems so light hearted during the delivery. Enchanting performance by the voice actress, and equally entrancing animation.
@ultramaximusreviews9 ай бұрын
I hate this version of the books... the Peter Jackson version is far superior
@rudy84099 ай бұрын
They really butchered galadriel in rings of power. Made here terribly unlikable and removed any shred of charm.
@soulcornflake19 ай бұрын
These are the kind of emotional scenes that break my heart. Not the full-on screaming performance, but the don't-let-it-slip-how-broken-you-really-are moments when the actor's voice breaks.
@sserpent219 ай бұрын
I’m surprised he can sing that well after The Dane broke so many of his teeth.
@user-fw6et6xk6f10 ай бұрын
Quote from Ben Seldon himself "like an uncircumcised and flaccid penis" 3 November 2022 10:34 AM
@user-fw6et6xk6f10 ай бұрын
aw yep sir
@trentdevlaminck992710 ай бұрын
It is really cool to watch this after all these years. My dad showed me this movie when i was 8 and i loved it, and then the peter jackson movies came out and it was cool to point out certain things Jackson took from Bakshi's version.
@amsfountain879210 ай бұрын
I will always love this movie. I watched at 14 in my english class and even if I didnt understood half of it moved me so much that i searched for the book and read it. That first time was like magic, discovering a new world and its wonders. Truly an unforgettable experience. So this movie will always have a place in my heart.
Пікірлер
Yay commercials every 2 minutes 🙄
Galadriel is chiding Frodo for offering her the ring, not happily surprised at the idea of having it. And she “long desired” to know if she’d pass the test, if presented the opportunity, she didn’t long desire to have and use the ring. She, like Gandalf, knew it would be bad to have in their possession. Jackson et al didn’t seem to understand this.
who the hell is "arrowman?"
Honestly, this is much better than the Jackson version.
Don't worry Sauron won't find us. Take a look at these cool light rays coming out of my ring
_“This is the mirror of Galadriel. It shows things that were, and things that are, and things that yet may be. Do you wish to look?”_ “This is Jon Snow. He’s king in the North.”_
This is the PC of EliteTeamKiller. It shows things that are on the internet.
the idea of rotoscope fantasy is still so amazing to me. imagine the people/elves are all rotoscoped but they hand draw the orcs and ents and such to give them that other worldly feel. like something out of a story book
I like how in Jackson’s film she goes all crazy when Frodo offers her the ring. But here she just laughs it off like ‘ah that’s cute. But no that thing is kinda dangerous so maybe keep it away from me.’
Where is Eye of Sauron?
Thanks for continuing to share this method and examples. We started teaching the Seldon method a few years ago when you first published your videos and had the best English Standard results ever at our school. Due lots of disruption and staff changes, we dropped off with it and I'm trying to reintroduce again after having recently read the CESE document. Being an English teacher, I really appreciate seeing the English examples and love looking at the teacher resources/student books. Is there any chance you could share a bit more about how it works in HSIE and Science subjects?
Yes, I ve just traversed great romantic trauma and am back in the land of the living, stronger, more focused and more powerful than ever!!! And thanks! Xoxxoxoxooxx
Great video
Thanks!
Love the content sir 👍
I like her laughing at Frodo's proposal. In the Peter Jackson movie, Galadriel is still deeply shaken and tempted by the offer and its prospect. In contrast, the almost sassy laughter in this version seems to indicate that this version of Galadriel has already pondered the idea to the end and rejected it for herself. Even though it seems slightly goofy how she's so light-hearted in her dismissal of something of such gravity, it shows her as someone who has already overcome this kind of desire for power, and is thus in a way wiser than her live action counterpart.
Brilliant brilliant acting from Sheen, so poignant, and dare I say so much deeper and more moving than Peter Finch in the 1968 version. Sheen just makes you feel his agony.
Blank slate cost 437 million... Mainly because you have nothing eles of value
Bathsheba was awful and Gabriel deserved better.
Anyone else think this version and Cate Blanchett's version are genius in their own ways?
Agree
As much as I adore Cate Blanchett in all of her roles, I have to say the eerie calm and giddy laughter in this rendition of Galadriel is far more terrifying.
I remember someone saying that Galadriel wouldn't be allowed back into the West until after she gave up power, since she was initially banished from there for trying to become a queen...
1:16 literally waits right before he touches it
The term "Ghirlandéina" refers to the "Ghirlandina" which is the Bell Tower of the Cathedral of Modena and which has become the symbol of the city. It owes its name to the double row of railings that adorn it as if they were garlands. The song is not in Italian but in the regional language (Emiliano) spoken in that city.
I wish Jackson would have presented Galadriel this way instead of her dramatically walking around and talking in riddles. I found her unlikable.
Agree!
You understand if we don’t find a stiff out here we leave a fresh one
" it must be Aruman " 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀.
World of warcraft on the desktop there 😆
Thank you for all of the resources you and the school have shared regarding bubble theory. I'm a teacher in NZ trying to get this rolled out in our English department.
Am i crazy or does she kinda look like young Jamie lee curtis?😂
I really love galadriels design, in this lighting especially, she really looks pretty
Michael Sheen - what skill! Amazing.
This Galadriel is SO much better than the movie version.
She looks so 70s I love it
I was so sad for him. She hurt him, on purpose, just because he ignored her. 😞
It’s not a bad adaptation, but my heart hurts when I see what they did to Sam
2:20
There's an important lesson here about the temptations of power, even on small scales. Also, the One Ring is like certain drugs, or rather the effects of certain drugs on certain people. Power over others is itself a kind of drug that can compromise judgement.
In this version i can actually understand what galadriel is saying when she was tested. lol. The animation is so lifelike and masterful , amazing and beautiful!!! todays hand drawn animation has nothing on this(Not including cgi graphics of course lol.).
great scene 🎬 Thanks for posting 🙏 ...thing about love is it's so broken n'self sacrificing ...n'still, the satisfaction one gets from it, whether it's between two lovers or many, or even none at all,... ...can be the most transcendent and spiritually moving things anyone can ever be a part of// In movies anyway... ha🎥
While Kate did a very good job in the role of Galadriel, I have often wished that they could have found an actress as beautiful as this animated one.
Brilliant acting..Michael Sheen is amazing in this scene. So heartbreaking 💔 😢 and Matthias as Gabriel is a treat to watch.
I worked with Mike Starr once or twice. He told me a great story about this song. He was at a customs stop in Canada and was singing the song to himself. The lady customs agent said, “YOU’RE SINGING IT ALL WRONG!” Turns out it was a song from her Italian village. She taught him the cadence, etc. I once wrote an episode of Law & Order and it had a big bad guy in it. I wrote it with Mike Star’s voice in mind. WHO shows up at casting, but MIKE STARR! I said, “um, I think he can handle it!” LOL
2:05 I feel like this is the one fleeting moment where she feels the temptation to take it, just that subtle widening of her eyes as Frodo offers her the ring. The speech that follows is where she has already realised that she has passed the test, and won’t take it after all, hence why she seems so light hearted during the delivery. Enchanting performance by the voice actress, and equally entrancing animation.
I hate this version of the books... the Peter Jackson version is far superior
They really butchered galadriel in rings of power. Made here terribly unlikable and removed any shred of charm.
These are the kind of emotional scenes that break my heart. Not the full-on screaming performance, but the don't-let-it-slip-how-broken-you-really-are moments when the actor's voice breaks.
I’m surprised he can sing that well after The Dane broke so many of his teeth.
Quote from Ben Seldon himself "like an uncircumcised and flaccid penis" 3 November 2022 10:34 AM
aw yep sir
It is really cool to watch this after all these years. My dad showed me this movie when i was 8 and i loved it, and then the peter jackson movies came out and it was cool to point out certain things Jackson took from Bakshi's version.
I will always love this movie. I watched at 14 in my english class and even if I didnt understood half of it moved me so much that i searched for the book and read it. That first time was like magic, discovering a new world and its wonders. Truly an unforgettable experience. So this movie will always have a place in my heart.